Public Work Department Through Executive Engineer vs Lalita
- Court
- Madhya Pradesh High Court
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34568
1 WP-4900-2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT GWALIOR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE MILIND RAMESH PHADKE
WRIT PETITION No. 4900 of 2025
CNR No.: MPHC030036462025
PUBLIC WORK DEPARTMENT THROUGH EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
Versus
LALITA
and
WRIT PETITION No. 4463 of 2025
CNR No.: MPHC030032932025
PUBLIC WORK DEPARTMENT THROUGH EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
Versus
RAJU
and
WRIT PETITION No. 4466 of 2025
CNR No.: MPHC030032952025
PUBLIC WORK DEPARTMENT THROUGH EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
Versus
RAMKISHAN PRAJAPATI
and
WRIT PETITION No. 4894 of 2025
CNR No.: MPHC030036412025
PUBLIC WORK DEPARTMENT
Versus
SHUSHIL PRATAP SINGH SIKARWAR
Appearance:
Shri Rajendra Singh Dhakar - Advocate for the petitioners.
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34568
2 WP-4900-2025
Shri Jitendra Kumar Sharma, Senior Advocate with Shri Krati
Sachdev, Advocate for the respondent.
Reserved on : 26.10.2026
Pronounced on : 18/11/2026
These petitions having been heard and reserved for orders, Hon’ble Shri
Justice Milind Ramesh Phadke, Judge pronounced the following:
ORDER
This order shall also govern the disposal of the connected batch of
petitions. For the sake of convenience, the facts of W.P. No.4900/2025 are
being taken into consideration.
The petitioner, Public Works Department, through its Executive
Engineer, has filed the present petition under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India, calling in question the order dated 25.07.2024 (Annexure P/1)
passed by the Competent Authority under the Minimum Wages Act, 1948, in
Case No. 24/2020, whereby the petitioner has been directed to pay an
amount of Rs.8,55,487/- towards the difference in minimum wages along
with compensation of Rs.42,77,435/-, equivalent to five times the amount of
the wage difference.
2. The facts of the case, in brief, are that the respondent was initially
engaged as a daily-wage employee on muster roll in the Public Works
Department on 15.01.1991. Subsequently, she was classified as a daily-wage
employee with effect from 24.12.2004. According to the petitioner, the
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34568
3 WP-4900-2025
respondent was being paid wages in accordance with the circulars and
notifications issued by the Labour Commissioner from time to time. It is the
case of the petitioner that the wages payable to the respondent were duly
calculated and paid in accordance with the applicable rates of minimum
wages.
3. The respondent, however, filed an application under Section 20 of
the Minimum Wages Act, 1948, before the Competent Authority, claiming
the difference in wages payable to her under the applicable provisions of
law. The petitioner entered appearance and filed its reply, denying the claim
and contending that all payments had already been made in accordance with
the applicable notifications. The petitioner also relied upon a tabulation chart
and the relevant circulars issued by the Labour Commissioner in support of
its defence.
4. The Competent Authority, after considering the rival submissions
and the material available on record, passed the impugned order dated
25.07.2024, directing the petitioner to pay Rs.8,55,487/- towards the
difference in minimum wages and further awarded compensation of
Rs.42,77,435/- under Section 20(3) of the Act, which is five times the
amount of the wage difference. The petitioner thereafter preferred a review
application, which was returned on 05.11.2024 on the ground that there is no
provision for review under the Minimum Wages Act, 1948. Being aggrieved
by the order passed by the Competent Authority, the petitioner has
approached this Court.
5. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the impugned order
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34568
4 WP-4900-2025
is illegal, arbitrary and contrary to the provisions of the Minimum Wages
Act, 1948. The Competent Authority has failed to appreciate that the
petitioner department has regularly paid wages to the respondent in
accordance with the circulars and notifications issued by the Labour
Commissioner from time to time. It is submitted that the respondent was
initially engaged on 15.01.1991 and was subsequently classified on
24.12.2004. The classification of the respondent was never challenged by her
before any competent Court or authority. Therefore, the Competent
Authority could not have ignored the nature and status of her engagement
while determining the alleged difference in wages. It is further submitted by
learned counsel for the petitioner that the department had prepared a detailed
calculation chart showing the payments made to the respondent for the
period from 1991 to 2016. The said chart was also placed before the
Competent Authority. However, the authority failed to properly examine the
calculation furnished by the department and proceeded to determine the
alleged difference in wages without properly verifying the actual payments
made to the respondent. The authority has also failed to appreciate that the
petitioner had been following the rates prescribed by the Labour
Commissioner and had not deliberately withheld any amount payable to the
respondent. Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that the
Competent Authority has committed an error in extending the benefit of the
revised pay structure and other consequential benefits to the respondent
without properly considering the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Ram Naresh Rawat v. Ashwini Rai, (2017) 3 SCC 436. It is argued that the
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34568
5 WP-4900-2025
said judgment deals with the rights and entitlements of daily-wage
employees and classified employees in the context of their classification and
applicable service conditions. The respondent was admittedly a classified
daily-wage employee and, therefore, her entitlement was required to be
examined in accordance with the relevant classification orders and applicable
pay-scale provisions.
6. It is also contended that the Competent Authority has failed to
appreciate that the petitioner had already paid the regular amount payable to
the respondent in accordance with the applicable orders and the principles
laid down in Ram Naresh Rawat (supra). Despite this, the authority has
calculated the alleged difference in minimum wages by including the period
subsequent to the classification of the respondent and by extending benefits
which were not legally payable in the manner claimed. It is further argued
that the authority has included the period from 1993 to 2005 even though,
according to the petitioner, there was no dispute regarding payment of
minimum wages during the said period. Learned counsel for the petitioner
lastly submits that the award of compensation amounting to five times the
alleged difference in wages is wholly unjustified. The petitioner has neither
committed any deliberate violation of the statutory provisions nor withheld
the wages payable to the respondent. When the department had made
payments on the basis of the rates prescribed by the Labour Commissioner,
there was no justification for imposing such a heavy financial liability by
way of compensation. The Competent Authority has failed to consider the
bona fide conduct of the petitioner and the documentary material produced
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34568
6 WP-4900-2025
by it. On these grounds, it is prayed that the impugned order be set aside.
7. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondent opposes
the petition and submits that the impugned order has been passed by the
Competent Authority after considering the relevant material, the rival
submissions and the applicable provisions of the Minimum Wages Act,
1948. The petitioner has approached this Court without establishing any
jurisdictional error, perversity or illegality in the findings recorded by the
Competent Authority. The petition is essentially an attempt to reopen the
factual determination and wage calculations already undertaken by the
statutory authority. Learned counsel for the respondent submits that the
petitioner has itself admitted that the respondent was initially engaged as a
daily-wage employee and was subsequently classified with effect from
24.12.2004. The petitioner has also admitted before the Competent Authority
that the respondent was its employee and that the provisions of the Minimum
Wages Act, 1948, were applicable. Once the relationship of employer and
employee and the applicability of the Act were not in dispute, it was
incumbent upon the petitioner to establish that the respondent had actually
been paid the minimum wages prescribed under the applicable notifications
throughout the relevant period.
8. It is further submitted that the petitioner, being a government
department and the custodian of the service records, wage registers, payment
records and other relevant documents, was required to establish its defence
by producing reliable documentary evidence. Mere production of a
calculation chart prepared by the department does not establish that the
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34568
7 WP-4900-2025
statutory liability has been fully discharged. The petitioner was required to
demonstrate, month by month, the minimum wages payable to the
respondent and the actual amount paid to her. However, the petitioner failed
to establish through cogent documentary evidence that the respondent had
received the prescribed minimum wages for the entire claim period. Learned
counsel for the respondent further submits that the calculation furnished by
the petitioner suffers from a fundamental error inasmuch as it does not take
into account the revised pay structure and the consequential benefits claimed
by the respondent pursuant to the recommendations of the Seventh Pay
Commission, stated to have become applicable from January, 2016. The
petitioner has continued to rely upon the earlier pay structure without
properly considering the revised minimum pay scale and the applicable
orders. The calculation of wages on the basis of the pre-revised minimum
pay scale after the revised structure became applicable is wholly untenable.
The Competent Authority has duly considered this aspect in paragraphs 5
and 6 of the impugned order.
9. It is also submitted that the reliance placed by the petitioner upon
Ram Naresh Rawat v. Ashwini Rai (supra) is misplaced. The said judgment
has to be considered in the context of the classification of employees, the
applicable service rules and the relevant pay-scale orders. The petitioner
cannot rely upon the said judgment in isolation to defeat the respondent's
statutory entitlement to minimum wages. The issue before the Competent
Authority was whether the respondent had been paid the minimum wages
legally payable to her during the relevant period. The petitioner's reliance
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34568
8 WP-4900-2025
upon the aforesaid judgment does not absolve it of its statutory obligation
under the Minimum Wages Act, 1948. Learned counsel for the respondent
further submits that the petitioner has attempted to adjust the amount paid
under the head of Vishesh Bhatta against the difference in minimum wages.
Such an adjustment is not permissible merely because the employer has
described a particular payment as an allowance. Section 4(1) of the
Minimum Wages Act, 1948, specifies the permissible components of
minimum wages, which may consist of a basic rate of wages together with a
special allowance adjusted in accordance with variations in the cost-of-living
index, a basic rate of wages together with the cash value of authorised
concessions in respect of essential commodities, or an all-inclusive rate
comprising the recognised components.
10. It is argued that the Vishesh Bhatta paid by the petitioner is a
separate departmental allowance and cannot automatically be treated as the
statutory special allowance or cost-of-living allowance contemplated under
Section 4(1) of the Act. Unless the petitioner establishes that such allowance
forms part of the minimum wage components prescribed or authorised under
the applicable statutory notification, the same cannot be adjusted against the
statutory shortfall. The employer cannot unilaterally alter the components of
minimum wages by assigning a particular nomenclature to a payment. In
support of the aforesaid contention, learned counsel for the respondent places
reliance upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Manganese Ore
(India) Ltd. v. Chandi Lal Saha, 1991 Supp (2) SCC 465, wherein the
distinction between statutory minimum wages and additional payments such
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34568
9 WP-4900-2025
as attendance bonus was considered. It is submitted that payments or
amenities which are not recognised as components of the prescribed
minimum wages cannot automatically be counted towards the statutory
obligation of the employer. Therefore, in the absence of any material
establishing that Vishesh Bhatta forms part of the statutory minimum wages
under the applicable notification, the petitioner cannot claim adjustment of
the said amount against the difference determined by the Competent
Authority.
11. Learned counsel for the respondent also disputes the method
adopted by the petitioner for adjustment of alleged surplus amounts against
the wage shortfall of earlier months. It is submitted that the petitioner's own
wage chart reflects negative differences for certain subsequent months,
which have been adjusted against the shortfall of earlier months. Such a
method of calculation is not legally sustainable unless the petitioner
establishes the factual and legal basis for such adjustment. The statutory
obligation to pay minimum wages has to be examined with reference to the
applicable rates and the wages actually paid for the relevant wage periods.
An alleged surplus in a particular month cannot automatically extinguish a
statutory shortfall in another month. With regard to the compensation
awarded under Section 20(3) of the Minimum Wages Act, 1948, learned
counsel for the respondent submits that the determination of the difference in
wages and the award of compensation are separate aspects of the statutory
adjudication. The petitioner has failed to demonstrate that the compensation
awarded by the Competent Authority suffers from any legal infirmity or that
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34568
10 WP-4900-2025
the authority has exercised its discretion in an arbitrary manner. Merely
because the petitioner disputes the calculation of wages or the amount of
compensation, the same cannot constitute a ground for interference under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
12. It is lastly submitted that the impugned order has been passed after
consideration of the material available on record and the petitioner has failed
to establish any perversity, jurisdictional error or violation of the principles
of natural justice. The present petition seeks nothing but re-appreciation of
the factual findings and recalculation of the amounts determined by the
Competent Authority. Therefore, the petition deserves to be dismissed.
13. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
14. The controversy involved in the present case is whether the
Competent Authority under the Minimum Wages Act, 1948, committed any
illegality in determining the difference in minimum wages payable to the
respondent and awarding compensation under Section 20(3) of the Act. The
principal contention of the petitioner is that the respondent was paid wages in
accordance with the circulars issued by the Labour Commissioner from time
to time and, therefore, no further amount was payable. On the other hand, the
respondent has disputed the correctness of the petitioner's calculation and has
contended that the department failed to establish payment of the statutory
minimum wages in accordance with the applicable rates and wage
components.
15. At the outset, it is not in dispute that the respondent was initially
engaged as a daily-wage employee on 15.01.1991 and was subsequently
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34568
11 WP-4900-2025
classified with effect from 24.12.2004. The petitioner has not disputed the
relationship of employer and employee. Rather, its entire defence before the
Competent Authority was that the wages had been paid in accordance with
the applicable circulars and notifications. Thus, the applicability of the
Minimum Wages Act, 1948, was not seriously in dispute. Once the
applicability of the Act is accepted, the petitioner was under a statutory
obligation to ensure payment of minimum wages at the rates prescribed
under the relevant notifications. The mere fact that the petitioner department
had issued or followed certain administrative circulars does not, by itself,
establish that the statutory obligation under the Minimum Wages Act, 1948,
has been fully discharged. The relevant consideration is whether the amount
actually paid to the respondent was in conformity with the minimum rates of
wages legally payable during the respective wage periods. The employer
cannot claim immunity from statutory liability merely by demonstrating that
payments were made in accordance with its internal calculation or
departmental practice. What is required is compliance with the statutory
minimum wage rates.
16. This Court finds substance in the submission advanced on behalf
of the respondent that the calculation of minimum wages has to be
undertaken with reference to the applicable statutory notifications and the
relevant wage components. The petitioner's calculation chart, merely
showing the amounts allegedly paid, cannot be accepted as conclusive proof
of discharge of its statutory obligation unless the same is supported by the
relevant wage records and is consistent with the rates legally payable during
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34568
12 WP-4900-2025
the corresponding period. So far as the reliance placed by the petitioner
upon Ram Naresh Rawat (supra), is concerned, the said judgment has to be
appreciated in the context of the legal status of the employee, the nature of
classification and the applicable service rules and pay-scale orders. The said
decision cannot be construed as laying down that an employer is exempted
from complying with the statutory provisions governing payment of
minimum wages. The question of entitlement to a particular pay scale or
service benefit is distinct from the statutory obligation to pay minimum
wages. The petitioner cannot avoid its obligation under the Minimum Wages
Act, 1948, merely by referring to the classification of the respondent or the
principles laid down in the aforesaid judgment.
17. It is also relevant to observe that the respondent's classification
with effect from 24.12.2004 is not a matter which has been challenged in the
present proceedings. Therefore, the petitioner cannot now rely upon the
classification order as a ground to defeat the respondent's claim without
demonstrating the actual legal effect of such classification upon the wages
payable to her. The question before the Competent Authority was not merely
the nature of engagement of the respondent but whether the wages paid to
her were in conformity with the applicable statutory rates. The contention
relating to the revised pay structure pursuant to the recommendations of the
Seventh Pay Commission also requires consideration. The respondent has
specifically contended that the petitioner's calculation does not take into
account the revised pay structure and the applicable benefits with effect from
January, 2016. The petitioner, on the other hand, has relied upon the earlier
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34568
13 WP-4900-2025
wage structure and its own calculation chart. In this regard, it is necessary to
emphasise that the determination of minimum wages must be based upon the
applicable statutory notifications and legally operative pay-scale or wage-
revision orders. The employer cannot continue to calculate wages on the
basis of an earlier structure if a revised structure has become legally
applicable to the employee concerned.
18. In the present case, the petitioner has failed to demonstrate that the
Competent Authority adopted an impermissible basis while considering the
revised wage structure. The authority has considered the relevant aspect in
paragraphs 5 and 6 of the impugned order. The petitioner has not been able
to establish that the findings recorded therein are contrary to any binding
statutory notification or applicable order. A mere assertion that the
department had already paid the requisite amount is not sufficient to displace
the findings of the statutory authority.
19. The next contention relates to the inclusion of Vishesh Bhatta in
the computation of minimum wages. Section 4(1) of the Minimum Wages
Act, 1948, recognises the permissible components which may constitute the
minimum rate of wages. The statutory scheme does not permit an employer
to treat every payment made under a separate head as a component of
minimum wages. Whether a particular allowance can be included in the
computation has to be determined with reference to the applicable statutory
notification and the nature of the payment. In this regard, the judgment
relied upon by the respondent in Manganese Ore (India) Ltd. (supra),
supports the proposition that additional payments or benefits which are not
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34568
14 WP-4900-2025
recognised as components of prescribed minimum wages cannot
automatically be adjusted against the statutory wage liability. The distinction
between a statutory special allowance and an independent departmental
allowance cannot be ignored. The petitioner was required to establish that
Vishesh Bhatta was a recognised component of the minimum wages
prescribed under the applicable notification. In the absence of such material,
the petitioner cannot claim an automatic adjustment of the said amount. This
Court is also unable to accept the petitioner's method of adjusting alleged
surplus amounts of subsequent months against the shortfall of earlier months
without establishing the legal basis for such adjustment. The statutory
requirement is to ensure payment of minimum wages for the relevant wage
period. The calculation must, therefore, be transparent and based upon the
applicable rates and the actual payments made. An alleged excess payment
under a particular wage period cannot automatically be utilised to wipe out
an earlier statutory deficiency without demonstrating that such adjustment is
permissible under the applicable law and wage notification.
20. The petitioner was in possession of the relevant service records,
wage registers and payment particulars. It was, therefore, incumbent upon
the petitioner to place reliable documentary evidence before the Competent
Authority to establish that the respondent had been paid the minimum wages
in accordance with the applicable rates throughout the claim period. The
department cannot discharge its burden merely by relying upon a self-
prepared tabulation chart, particularly when the respondent has specifically
disputed the correctness of the calculations and the inclusion of certain
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34568
15 WP-4900-2025
allowances. The contention that there was no dispute regarding the payment
of minimum wages for the period from 1993 to 2005 also does not, by itself,
establish that the determination made by the Competent Authority is illegal.
The relevant question is whether the authority had jurisdiction to examine the
claim for the period in question and whether its determination is supported
by the material available on record. The petitioner has not demonstrated any
specific jurisdictional bar or any error of law which would warrant
interference with the impugned order on this ground.
21. The next question concerns the award of compensation under
Section 20(3) of the Minimum Wages Act, 1948. The aforesaid provision
empowers the Competent Authority, while allowing a claim arising out of
payment of less than the minimum rates of wages, to direct payment of the
amount due and such compensation as it considers appropriate, subject to the
statutory limit prescribed therein. The award of compensation is intended to
provide an appropriate remedy to the employee against the failure of the
employer to discharge its statutory obligation. In the present case, the
Competent Authority has determined the wage difference at Rs.8,55,487/-
and awarded compensation of Rs.42,77,435/-, equivalent to five times the
amount of the wage difference. The petitioner has challenged the award of
compensation primarily on the ground that there was no deliberate default on
its part and that payments had been made in accordance with the
departmental circulars. However, the mere assertion that the employer acted
bona fide or followed its own calculation does not, by itself, establish that the
statutory obligation was fulfilled.
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34568
16 WP-4900-2025
22. The petitioner has also failed to demonstrate that the compensation
awarded exceeds the statutory limit or that the Competent Authority
exercised its discretion beyond the powers conferred upon it by Section
20(3) of the Act. The fact that the compensation has been quantified at five
times the amount of the wage difference, by itself, does not render the award
illegal. The petitioner was required to establish that the exercise of discretion
by the Competent Authority was arbitrary, unreasonable or contrary to the
statutory provisions. No such ground has been satisfactorily established in
the present proceedings. It is further relevant that the petitioner is a
government department and is expected to maintain proper service records
and ensure timely compliance with statutory obligations concerning payment
of wages to its employees. The obligation to pay minimum wages is not a
matter of discretion or administrative convenience. It is a statutory obligation
which has to be strictly complied with. The respondent cannot be deprived of
the benefit of the minimum wages prescribed by law merely because the
department claims to have followed its own administrative instructions.
23. This Court is conscious of the fact that the petitioner has attempted
to challenge the impugned order by raising several grounds relating to the
classification of the respondent, the applicability of the revised pay structure,
the treatment of Vishesh Bhatta and the method of calculation adopted by the
Competent Authority. However, none of these grounds establishes that the
authority acted beyond its jurisdiction or committed any patent error of law.
The objections raised by the petitioner essentially relate to the correctness of
the factual and financial calculations already examined by the statutory
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34568
17 WP-4900-2025
authority. The jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India is not intended to provide another forum for a complete
re-examination of the factual calculations undertaken by a competent
statutory authority. Interference is warranted where the impugned order
suffers from a jurisdictional error, patent illegality, perversity, violation of
the principles of natural justice or an error apparent on the face of the record.
A mere possibility of taking another view on the calculation or interpretation
of the material does not justify interference in the exercise of extraordinary
writ jurisdiction.
24. In the present case, the petitioner has failed to demonstrate that the
Competent Authority ignored any mandatory statutory provision or relied
upon irrelevant material while determining the amount payable to the
respondent. On the contrary, the objections raised by the petitioner were
substantially directed towards disputing the method of calculation and
seeking acceptance of its own version of the wage payments. Such an
exercise would require re-appreciation of the factual material, which cannot
be undertaken merely on the basis of the assertions made in the writ
petition. The fact that the petitioner's application for review was returned on
05.11.2024 on the ground that the Minimum Wages Act, 1948, does not
provide for review also does not confer any additional right upon the
petitioner to seek reconsideration of the entire factual determination under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The absence of a review provision
cannot, by itself, be treated as a ground to set aside an otherwise lawful order
passed by the Competent Authority.
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34568
18 WP-4900-2025
25. Having considered the rival submissions, this Court finds that the
petitioner has failed to establish any illegality, perversity or jurisdictional
error in the order dated 25.07.2024 passed by the Competent Authority under
the Minimum Wages Act, 1948. The petitioner has also failed to establish
that the respondent was paid the minimum wages in accordance with the
applicable statutory notifications for the entire claim period or that the
calculation adopted by the Competent Authority is contrary to law. The
grounds raised in the writ petition do not warrant interference with the
impugned order in exercise of the extraordinary jurisdiction under Article
226 of the Constitution of India. Consequently, this Court does not find any
ground to interfere with the impugned order dated 25.07.2024 passed by the
Competent Authority in Case No. 24/2020. The writ petitions, being devoid
of merit, deserves to be and are hereby dismissed.
26. The interim relief, if any, stands vacated. The impugned order
passed by the Competent Authority is hereby affirmed.
27. The writ petitions stand dismissed.
28. No order as to costs.
(MILIND RAMESH PHADKE)
JUDGE
(aspr)