K.ASHOKAN vs THE STATE REP BY

Court
Madras High Court

CRL RC.No.131 of 2022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE OF MADRAS
Reserved on : 15.09.2026
Pronounced on : 13.11.2026
CORAM:
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE M.NIRMAL KUMAR
CRL.RC.No.131 of 2022
K.Ashokan ... Petitioner / Sole Accused
Vs.
State Represented by its
The Inspector of Police,
H-1 Washermanpet
Traffic Investigation Wing,
Crime No.264/III/2014 ... Respondent / Complainant

Prayer: Criminal Revision Case filed under Section 397 r/w 401 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure, to set-aside the Judgement and
conviction passed in C.A.No.7 of 2016 by the learned IV Additional
City Civil and Sessions Court, Chennai by an order dated 08.10.2021
confirming the conviction and modifying the sentence as 6 months
R.I for the offence under section 304-A IPC and rest of the sentence
and fine imposed on the accused shall remain unmodified filed
against the judgement and Conviction imposed by the learned III
Metropolitan Magistrate, George Town, Chennai in C.C.No.3690/2014
by an order dated 09.12.2015 sentencing the petitioner to undergo 1
years R.I and to pay a fine of Rs.5000/- under section 304-A IPC i/d to
undergo 1 month S.I and sentenced to pay a fine of Rs.1000/- under
Section 184 of Motor Vehicle Act i/d undergo S.I for two weeks


1
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )

CRL RC.No.131 of 2022
For Appellant : Mr.Prabhakar
For Mr.Arockiasami
For Respondent : Mr.S.Udayakumar
Government Advocate (crl.side)
O R D E R

This Criminal Revision Case is filed by the Petitioner / sole
accused challenging the Judgment of the learned III Metropolitan
Magistrate, George Town, Chennai, in C.C.No.3690 of 2014, dated
09.12.2015, by which the petitioner convicted for the offences under
Section 304-A IPC and Section 184 of the Motor Vehicles Act and
sentenced to undergo Rigorous Imprisonment for one year and to pay
a fine of Rs.5,000/-, in default, to undergo Simple Imprisonment for
one month, under Section 304-A IPC, and to pay a fine of Rs.1,000/-,
in default, to undergo Simple Imprisonment for two weeks, under
Section 184 of the Motor Vehicles Act. The conviction confirmed in
C.A.No.7 of 2016, by the IV Additional City Civil and Sessions Court,
Chennai, by judgment dated 08.10.2021, with the sentence under
Section 304-A IPC reduced to six months Rigorous Imprisonment, the
remaining sentence and the fines being left unaltered.
2
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )

CRL RC.No.131 of 2022
2. The case of the prosecution is that on 28.10.2014, at about
12.45 p.m., the petitioner, then a driver of the Metropolitan Transport
Corporation, driving the bus bearing Registration No.TN-01-N-8362
(route 32A) from south to north near the Mint Clock Tower Junction,
T.H.Road, Washermanpet. He drove the bus in a rash and negligent
manner and dashed against an elderly woman, one Gunabooshanam,
aged about 80 years, who standing to cross the road, the bus ran
over her and she died on the spot. P.W.1 (Mani), an auto-rickshaw
driver, gave a complaint (Ex.P1) at 14.00 hours, on which the First
Information Report in Crime No.264/H1/2014 (Ex.P7) was registered
for the offences under Section 304-A IPC and Section 184 of the
Motor Vehicles Act. After investigation by P.W.8, the Inspector of
Police, filed the final report.
3. On the petitioner's appearance and compliance with Section
207 Cr.P.C., he pleaded not guilty. The prosecution examined P.W.1 to
P.W.8 and marked Exs.P1 to P10. When questioned under Section
313(1)(b) Cr.P.C., the petitioner denied the incriminating
circumstances as false. No witness examined and no document
marked on the side of the defence. The trial Court found the
petitioner guilty and convicted and sentenced him as stated above.
The Criminal Appeal in C.A.No.7 of 2016 preferred by the petitioner
3
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )

CRL RC.No.131 of 2022
was dismissed on 08.10.2021 with the modification of sentence alone.
Aggrieved, the petitioner is before this Court.
4. Mr.Prabhakar, learned counsel for the petitioner, submitted
that the three alleged eyewitnesses are unreliable and contradict one
another. P.W.1 is a chance witness whose version of the occurrence is
ambiguous. P.W.2, Traffic Sub-Inspector, not shown to have been on
duty at the spot. P.W.3, flower vendor, is contradicted by the
Observation Mahazar (Ex.P2) and the Rough Sketch (Ex.P8). The
place of occurrence is a busy junction, about 20 feet wide, at a curve
where a person ahead cannot be seen. The deceased, an aged
woman, not used any pedestrian crossing and came suddenly into the
path of a turning vehicle in the midst of heavy traffic. In these
circumstances, neither rashness nor negligence, nor dangerous
driving, is made out. Even P.W.1 to P.W.3 and the Investigating
Officer (P.W.8) admit that the place is a busy road with heavy traffic,
and the trial Court itself recorded that it is a narrow area. A bus
cannot be driven at a dangerous speed there. The conviction was
rested only on the inference that the bus not stopped immediately
after the impact, which is not evidence of rash or negligent driving,
and the prosecution failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt.
5. Per contra, Mr.S.Udayakumar, the learned Government
Advocate (Crl.Side) submitted that the occurrence, identity of the
deceased, identity of the petitioner as driver and cause of death are
4
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )

CRL RC.No.131 of 2022
not in dispute. Both the Courts below, on a concurrent appreciation of
the evidence of three eyewitnesses, corroborated by the complaint,
First Information Report, inquest report and post-mortem certificate,
held that the bus driven rashly and negligently. He submitted that the
revisional jurisdiction is a limited one and this Court ought not to re-
appreciate evidence to interfere with the concurrent findings,
particularly, when the sentence already reduced by the lower
appellate Court, and prayed that the Revision be dismissed.
6. I have heard the learned counsel on either side and perused
the records, including the depositions of the witnesses.
7. It is settled that in exercise of the revisional power under
Sections 397 and 401 Cr.P.C. this Court does not sit as a Statutory
Court of appeal and does not ordinarily re-appreciate evidence. But
the power is not to be exercised in a mechanical manner. Where the
finding recorded is perverse, is based on no evidence or on a
misreading of material evidence, or where the Courts below have
drawn an inference which the evidence does not permit, the High
Court is not only entitled but bound to interfere to prevent a
miscarriage of justice (State of Kerala v. Puttumana Illath Jathavedan
Namboodiri, (1999) 2 SCC 452; Amit Kapoor v. Ramesh Chander,
(2012) 9 SCC 460. The question here is whether the finding of rash
and negligent driving survives this test.
5
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )

CRL RC.No.131 of 2022
8. Section 304-A IPC penalises the causing of death by a rash or
negligent act not amounting to culpable homicide. The mere fact that
a death has resulted from an accident involving a motor vehicle is not
sufficient to attract the provision. The prosecution must establish,
beyond reasonable doubt, that the accused was driving the vehicle in
a rash or negligent manner and that such rashness or negligence was
the direct, proximate and efficient cause of the death. Criminal
rashness consists in hazarding a dangerous or wanton act with the
knowledge that it is so, whereas criminal negligence denotes a gross
and culpable failure to exercise reasonable and proper care
(Bhalchandra v. State of Maharashtra, AIR 1968 SC 1319; Jacob
Mathew v. State of Punjab, (2005) 6 SCC 1). The maxim res ipsa
loquitur has no application in a criminal trial so as to dispense with
the prosecution's burden of proof. The mere fact that a person has
been run over by a vehicle does not, by itself, give rise to a
presumption of guilt against its driver. Likewise, speed, by itself, is
not conclusive of rashness. Whether the speed of a vehicle amounts
to rash driving must be determined with reference to the nature of
the road, prevailing traffic conditions and surrounding
circumstances. (Ravi Kapur v. State of Rajasthan, (2012) 9 SCC 284).
Section 184 of the Motor Vehicles Act requires an assessment of
whether the vehicle driven at a speed or in a manner dangerous to
the public, having regard to all the circumstances, including the
6
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )

CRL RC.No.131 of 2022
nature, condition and use of the place and the traffic actually present
or reasonably expected to be present there.
9. The undisputed facts are that the identity of the deceased,
her death at the scene of occurrence on 28.10.2014 after coming
under the wheels of the MTC bus, and the medical cause of her death
are not in controversy. P.W.5, Dr.Balasubramanian, who conducted the
post-mortem examination, spoken to the injuries sustained by the
deceased. Ex.P3 records multiple crush injuries over the left leg,
right thigh, gluteal regions, left forearm, abdomen and pelvis, besides
fractures and a laceration on the forehead. He opined that the
deceased died of shock and haemorrhage consequent upon the
multiple injuries sustained by her. This evidence establishes the
nature of the injuries and the cause of death. However, it does not, by
itself, establish the manner in which the accident occurred or
demonstrate that the bus being driven rashly or negligently. That is
the crucial issue which the prosecution is required to establish
beyond reasonable doubt.
10. The evidence on the manner of occurrence. The prosecution
rests its case on P.W.1 to P.W.3. Their evidence needs to be examined
in some detail. P.W.1 (Mani), the complainant, is an auto-rickshaw
driver who parked his auto at the Mint round-turner. He deposed that
an elderly woman standing at the side to cross the road, the bus
(MTC 32A) turned "speedily", front wheel struck her while she stood
on the right side, wheel went over her and the bus did not stop. In
7
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )

CRL RC.No.131 of 2022
cross-examination he admitted that the spot is a narrow curve, that
he cannot say who would come from the front, that elderly persons
generally find it difficult to cross a road, and he does not know
whether her eyesight was good. He did not see the driver and, as per
his own evidence, knew of the bus only as number 32A. P.W.2
(Anandaraj), Traffic Sub-Inspector, deposed that while on duty at the
junction he saw the bus, coming from the Stanley side towards
Moolakothalam, strike the woman who standing to cross, with its
right side hitting her, right-side rear wheel running over her hand
and leg. According to him, he regulated the traffic, bus parked on the
side and informed his control room. He says nothing about the speed
of the bus. When recalled at the instance of the accused, he admitted
that he filed no document to show that he was on duty at the spot at
the time of the occurrence, and admitted that the place is a curve.
11. P.W.3 (Lakshmi), a flower vendor, deposed that the
occurrence took place at about "11 a.m." (as against 12.45 p.m.
alleged by the prosecution), that a bus hit an elderly woman standing
to cross the road, and that the wheel ran over the woman who fell,
and the driver not stopped despite their shouting. She too says
nothing about the speed of the bus. In cross-examination she
admitted that she did not see the driver, she knew only that the bus
number was "32" and not known the registration number, the
deceased was around 80 years old and could not cross the road
quickly, and the Mint circle is a curve where it cannot be known who
8
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )

CRL RC.No.131 of 2022
is coming from the front. She added that the deceased used to stay at
that very place and come and go. P.W.4 (Mohideen), an attesting
witness to Ex.P2 and Ex.P8, did not see the occurrence, the bus or
the driver. He reached the spot after the incident, when the deceased
already injured and died before the ambulance arrived.
12. P.W.6 (Sathasivam), the MTC Traffic Invigilator, has no
personal knowledge of the occurrence. He stated that he went to the
spot at about 2.20 p.m., that the bus was not there and taken to the
H-1 police station, and he produced the petitioner and the vehicle
documents before the police. P.W.7 (Kumara), the Motor Vehicle
Inspector, who inspected the bus on the next day, found no damage
and no mechanical defect, with foot-brake efficiency of 72%, and
opined that the accident not due to mechanical failure (Ex.P6). It
does not follow from this that the driver was negligent. P.W.8
(Selvakumar), the Investigating Officer, in cross-examination admit
that the place of occurrence is a main road where vehicles pass in
large numbers on both sides, that it is a place of heavy pedestrian
movement, a bus depot is situated a little distance away, and,
importantly, the deceased crossing the road when the occurrence
took place.
13. The prosecution version is internally inconsistent on
material aspects. The first difficulty is the manner of the occurrence.
The charge, as framed in the final report and the evidence of P.W.1 to
P.W.3, is that the deceased standing at the side of the road to cross
9
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )

CRL RC.No.131 of 2022
when the bus hit her. The Investigating Officer, on the other hand,
admitted that the deceased was crossing the road when she was
struck, and Ex.P2 records, she was crossing the road from east to
west when the bus, coming from south to north, hit her. Whether a
pedestrian stood still at the side or was in motion in the carriageway
is a fact on which the manner of driving, and the possibility of
avoiding the impact, necessarily turn.
14. The second inconsistency concerns what the bus did after
the impact. P.W.1 and P.W.3 deposed that the bus not stopped and
went away. P.W.2 deposed he got it parked on the side. P.W.8 states
that the vehicle was at the spot when he reached there, whereas
P.W.6 says that at about 2.20 p.m. the bus was not at the spot and
taken to the police station, and the petitioner formally arrested at
about 7 p.m. on the same day. These versions cannot all be true, and
the prosecution not explained them. The Court below chosen to rely
on the one version, that the bus did not stop, to prove the offence,
without noticing that the prosecution's own evidence contradicts it.
15. Other circumstances weaken the reliability of the
eyewitness account. P.W.1 is a chance witness who stopped his auto
at the spot. P.W.1 and P.W.3 could say that the bus bore the number
"32", although Ex.P1 and Ex.P7 carry the full registration number of
the bus, and the source of that information is not explained. P.W.3
places the occurrence nearly two hours before the time alleged.
P.W.2, a police officer said to have witnessed the very occurrence and
10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )

CRL RC.No.131 of 2022
to have stopped the bus, not the person who set the law in motion.
The First Information Report registered at 14.00 hours on a
complaint of an auto driver, and the petitioner brought to the police
station through the MTC invigilator. As regards Ex.P2, it records that
it was prepared at 15.00 hours, whereas P.W.4 deposed that the
rough sketch drawn while he was present at the spot, and he left at
about 1.30 p.m. He also vacillated on whether his signature on the
mahazar was obtained at the spot or at the police station. The
conductor of the bus, the person best placed to speak about the
speed and manner of driving, and the occupants of the bus, not
examined, and the other attesting witness to Ex.P2 not examined.
These omissions are not fatal by themselves, but they leave
unresolved a case that already rests on shaky evidence.
16. Even if the evidence of P.W.1 to P.W.3 is accepted in full, the
only material on the manner of driving is the bare word "speedily"
used by P.W.1 for a bus that was turning at a curve of a junction. No
witness gives any indication of the actual or approximate speed of the
bus, the distance from which the driver could see the deceased, the
point of impact on the road, whether the horn was sounded, or
whether any effort was made to avoid the impact. P.W.2 and P.W.3 do
not speak of speed at all. Ex.P2 does not record any skid mark, or any
other physical circumstance from which speed can be inferred. The
witnesses themselves have admitted that the place is a narrow blind
curve, with an obstructed view, on a busy road with heavy pedestrian
11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )

CRL RC.No.131 of 2022
and vehicular movement and a bus depot nearby. In such a place, a
bus driver turning around the blind curve cannot be expected to
travel at a high speed, and the evidence does not show that he did.
The prosecution has thus not proved that the petitioner was driving
at a dangerous speed.
17. The Courts below, in effect, persuaded by the circumstance
that the bus did not stop immediately after striking the deceased. The
trial Court reasoned that if the bus driven slowly and carefully, it
could have stopped immediately after the impact, and the failure to
do so shows that the bus driven rashly or negligently. With respect,
this is a non sequitur, and amounts to applying the principle of res
ipsa loquitur which the Supreme Court has held to be inapplicable in
criminal cases. The question under Section 304-A IPC is the manner
of driving which caused the impact, and not what happened after it. A
heavy vehicle such as a bus cannot be stopped at once after an
impact. If, as stated by P.W.1 and P.W.3, the driver left the scene
without stopping, that might be a separate matter under the Motor
Vehicles Act, but the petitioner not charged on that count, and it does
not establish that the impact itself caused by rash or negligent
driving. Moreover, as noted above, the prosecution's own evidence is
divided on whether the bus stopped at all.
18. The trial Court further held that a driver manoeuvring a
junction must expect people to cross the road and drive with utmost
care. That is a correct statement of the general duty of a driver, but it
12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )

CRL RC.No.131 of 2022
does not relieve the prosecution of the burden of proving a breach of
that duty. The prosecution has led no evidence of how the deceased,
an aged woman of about 80 years who, by the evidence of P.W.1 and
P.W.3, could not cross the road quickly, came to be on the
carriageway at the curve of a busy junction in the path of a turning
bus, or whether the driver had any real opportunity to see her and
avoid the impact. A death in a road accident does not by itself prove
criminal negligence on the part of the driver, and the doubt in this
regard must go to the accused. The Court below, however, treated the
death itself as proof of the offence, and the cross-examination
admissions regarding the nature of the place were not considered at
all.
19. Section 184 of the Motor Vehicles Act. The conviction under
this section not separately reasoned by the trial Court and rests
entirely on the same inference. As the prosecution failed to establish
that the bus driven at a speed or in a manner dangerous to the
public, having regard to the nature of the place and the traffic
present, the conviction under Section 184 of the Motor Vehicles Act
also cannot stand.
20. On a careful scrutiny, the evidence on record does not
establish beyond reasonable doubt that the death of the deceased
caused by a rash or negligent act of the petitioner. The finding of the
trial Court, confirmed by the lower appellate Court, is based on an
inference not warranted by the evidence, ignores the admissions of
13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )

CRL RC.No.131 of 2022
the prosecution witnesses regarding the nature of the place, and
overlooks the material inconsistencies in the prosecution case. It is
perverse, and calls for interference in exercise of the revisional
jurisdiction. The petitioner is entitled to the benefit of doubt.
21. In the result, the Criminal Revision Case is allowed, and:
(i) the judgment dated 08.10.2021 in C.A.No.7 of 2016 on the
file of the IV Additional City Civil and Sessions Court, Chennai, and
the judgment dated 09.12.2015 in C.C.No.3690 of 2014 on the file of
the III Metropolitan Magistrate, George Town, Chennai, are set aside;
(ii) the petitioner/accused is acquitted of the charges under
Section 304-A IPC and Section 184 of the Motor Vehicles Act;
(iii) the fine amount, if any, paid by the petitioner, shall be
refunded to him; and
(iv) the bail bond, if any, executed by the petitioner shall stand
cancelled.
13.11.2026
Index : Yes/No
Internet : Yes/No
Neutral Citation : Yes/No
mpk
14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )

CRL RC.No.131 of 2022
To
1. The IV Additional City Civil and Sessions Court,
Chennai.
2. The III Metropolitan Magistrate,
George Town,
Chennai – 600 015.
3. The Inspector of Police,
H-1 Washermanpet Traffic Investigation Wing,
Chennai – 600 021.
4. The Public Prosecutor,
High Court,
Madras.


15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )

CRL RC.No.131 of 2022
M.NIRMAL KUMAR, J.
mpk
Pre-Delivery order made in
CRL.RC.No.131 of 2022
13.11.2026
16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )