(O&M) Sheela And Ors. vs Bijender & Ors.
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
245 FAO-2430-2002 (O&M)
Date of decision :16.11.2026
SHEELA AND OTHERS …APPELLANTS
VERSUS
BIJENDER AND OTHERS ...RESPONDENTS
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PARMOD GOYAL
Present: Mr. Adarsh Jain, Senior Advocate with
Ms. Kamaldeep kaur, Advocate and
Ms. Amandeep Kaur, Advocate
for appellants.
Mr. Paramjeet Singh, D.A.G., Haryana.
Mr. D.K. Dogra, Advocate
for respondent No.3.
*
PARMOD GOYAL, J. (ORAL)
Present appeal has been preferred by appellants-claimants [wife,
three children and mother] seeking enhancement in compensation awarded
vide award dated 10.12.2001 passed by learned Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, Faridabad (hereinafter referred to as ‘ Tribunal ’), whereby
appellants-claimants were awarded total compensation of Rs.1,15,200/- on
account of death of Sher Singh (hereinafter referred to as ‘ deceased ’) in
motor vehicular accident dated 16.08.1999 allegedly caused due to rash and
negligent driving of respondent-driver while driving bus bearing registration
No.HR-26A-1322 (hereinafter referred to as ‘ offending vehicle ’) after
deduction of 50% towards contributory negligence.
2. In the present case, learned Tribunal had awarded the following
compensation to appellant-claimants:
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.17 16:59
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO No.2430 of 2002 -2-
Income Rs.1,800/- per month
Deduction 1/3rd
Multiplier 16
Loss of dependency Rs.2,30,400/-
(Rs.1,200/-X12X16)
50% deduction towards
Rs.1,15,200/-
contributory negligence
Total compensation awarded Rs.1,15,200/-
3. Learned counsel for the appellants-claimants has sought
enhancement of compensation on the following grounds:
●
That the learned Tribunal has erred in not assessing the
income of the deceased as pleaded and proved by the
claimants.
●
That the learned Tribunal has failed to apply the correct
multiplier, as per age of deceased.
●
That the deduction towards the personal and living
expenses of the deceased is excessive and contrary to the
settled principles of law.
●
That no addition towards future prospects has been made
while calculating the loss of dependency. Future prospects
ought to have been added, as per age of deceased.
●
That the learned Tribunal has also failed to award just and
appropriate compensation under the conventional heads,
namely funeral expenses, loss of estate, and loss of spousal,
parental, and filial consortium, in accordance with the law
laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court.
4. Appellants-claimants have challenged the finding of the learned
Tribunal on issue No.1 with regards to rash and negligent driving on the part
of the responder-driver as well as the quantum of compensation under issue
No.2. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondents have supported
the award and argued that the findings of the learned Tribunal are based on
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.17 16:59
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO No.2430 of 2002 -3-
record and the compensation of Rs.2,30,400/- was rightly awarded and
deduction of 50% on account of contributory negligence was rightly made.
5. It is the case of the appellants-claimants that on 16.08.1999,
deceased was going on his scooter at normal speed on the right side of the
road. However, the scooter of the deceased struck against the offending
vehicle driven by the respondent-driver, which was negligently parked in the
middle of the road. It was asserted that respondent-driver of the offending
vehicle, had parked the offending vehicle without any indication in the
middle of the road. Therefore, during night hours the offending vehicle
could not be seen by the deceased and resultantly, his scooter struck against
the stationary offending vehicle from behind on account of which deceased
had suffered head injuries. After the accident the deceased was taken to the
hospital but succumbed to his injuries. FIR No.274 dated 17.07.1999 under
Sections 279, 304A of IPC (Ex.P1) was registered against the offending
vehicle on the statement of PW1-Lal Chand.
6. In order to prove the accident to be result of rash and negligent
driving on the part of the respondent-driver of offending vehicle, appellants-
claimants had examined Lal Chand as PW-1 and Bhoop Singh as PW-2.
Both the witnesses i.e. PW-1 and PW-2, had reiterated the manner of
occurrence as was stated by the appellants-claimants in their claim petition
and as was stated in FIR (Ex.P1). The author of FIR namely Lal Chand, in
his statement while appearing as PW-1, had clearly stated that the offending
vehicle driven by the respondent-driver was parked in the middle of the road
during night hours without any indicator or blinkers. These assertions were
reiterated by PW-2.
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.17 16:59
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO No.2430 of 2002 -4-
7. On the other hand, respondent-driver-Bijender had also
appeared as RW-1 and claimed that on account of sudden breakdown of the
bus, the bus was parked and accident had taken place due to negligence of
the deceased who, despite the light and indicator, had failed to notice the bus
and struck against the same from behind.
8. Learned Tribunal accepted the evidence of PW-1 and PW-2 to
the extent that the offending vehicle was parked in the middle of the road.
However, it had skipped issue whether parking lights or indicators of the
offending vehicle were turned on or not. Learned Tribunal, by taking note of
the fact that the offending vehicle was parked on the road and accident had
taken place at 08:30 p.m., concluded that as the accident occurred in the
month of July and it was not very dark at that time. Therefore, the deceased,
who had hit the bus from behind was also negligent in not taking note of the
bus which was standing on the road. Accordingly, learned Tribunal had held
that deceased also contributed in causing the accident.
9. In the present case, admittedly, the accident had taken place at
08:30 p.m. in the month of July. 08:30 p.m. is the time when it gets dark in
absence of any street lights. No evidence was adduced to show availability
of street lights at the place of accident. Therefore, learned Tribunal ought to
have given a definite finding by appreciating the evidence as to whether
parking lights of the offending vehicle were turned on or not, so as to give
sufficient notice to the deceased regarding parking of bus on the road.
10. It is pertinent to note that FIR (Ex.P1) was promptly lodged by
PW1-Lal Chand on 17.07.1999 on the next day of occurrence of the accident
i.e. on 16.07.1999. On the statement of Lal Chand PW-1 statement before
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.17 16:59
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO No.2430 of 2002 -5-
the police, FIR (Ex.P1) was lodged, wherein, he had specifically stated that
the scooter had hit the offending vehicle from behind and the offending
vehicle was parked in the middle of the road. He had clearly asserted that no
light or indication of the offending vehicle was on at that time. Respondent-
driver was put to face trial in FIR No.279 dated 17.07.1999 under Sections
279, 304A of IPC. The manner of occurrence as stated by appellants-
claimants in their claim petition as well as both by PW1 and PW2 before the
Court, had come in public domain immediately after the occurrence on
17.07.1999, whereas the manner of occurrence as is being asserted by the
respondent-driver had come before the notice of Court for the first time
when he appeared as RW1. No complaint or protest was ever made by the
respondent-driver to the police authorities or civil authorities against lodging
of FIR for causing the accident by parking the offending vehicle without
lights in the middle of the road. While appearing as RW1, in fact, the
respondent-driver had even tried to deny that his vehicle was parked in the
middle of the road, however, this was not even accepted by the learned
Tribunal.
11. Therefore, on appreciation of evidence, I find that it is the
evidence of PW1 and PW2 which is trustworthy and reliable than the
evidence of RW1. From the evidence of PW1 and PW2, it is clearly made
out that the accident had taken place at 08:30 p.m. when it was dark and the
offending bus was standing in the middle of the road without there being any
indicator or lights on. In these circumstances, deceased who was coming and
expecting road to be clear from any traffic cannot be expected to presume
the presence of a stationary bus in the middle of the road. Therefore, no act
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.17 16:59
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO No.2430 of 2002 -6-
of omission or commission on the part of the deceased can be shown or
presumed in order to hold him liable for causing the accident. Accordingly,
finding of the learned Tribunal on issue No.1 that the deceased had also
contributed in causing the accident cannot be sustained and same is set
aside. It is held that the accident had occurred on account of sole rash and
negligent driving on the part of the respondent-driver of offending vehicle.
12. The appellants-claimants have claimed that the deceased was
aged around 31 to 35 years old and was earning Rs.4,000/- by working as an
auto mechanic. However, except for oral assertions, no documentary
evidence to show existence of workshop or qualification or justification that
deceased was a motor mechanic or a skilled person has been placed on
record.
13. Faced with lack of evidence on the part of the appellants-
claimants, learned Tribunal had taken monthly income of the deceased to be
Rs.1,800/- per month. Learned counsel for the appellants-claimants submits
that minimum wages payable to an unskilled worker in year 1999 were
Rs.1901/- and the Tribunal ought to have taken at least minimum wages
payable to an unskilled worker.
14. I find merit in the contention raised by learned counsel for
appellants-claimants that the Tribunal ought to have taken minimum wages
payable to an unskilled worker in absence of any cogent and reliable
evidence regarding pleaded vocation and income of deceased. Therefore,
income of the deceased is taken as Rs.1,900/- per month. Since deceased
was between 31 to 35 years old at the time of the accident, learned Tribunal
had rightly applied multiplier of ‘16’ in view of judgment passed by Hon’ble
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.17 16:59
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO No.2430 of 2002 -7-
Supreme Court in Smt. Sarla Verma & Ors. Vs. Delhi Transport
Corporation & Anr. , 2009(6) SCC 121. For calculating loss of dependency,
future prospects to the extent of 40% needs to be added as per age of the
deceased in view of judgment passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court in
National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi and Ors. , 2017 (16)
SCC 680. Similarly, deduction towards personal expenses has to be made on
the basis of number of dependents which are five in present case i.e. wife,
three children and mother. Accordingly, deduction to the extent of 1/4th
shall be applicable.
15. The loss of dependency, therefore, has to be determined by
taking monthly income of deceased to be Rs.1,900/- per month by applying
future prospects to the extent of 40% , multiplier of ‘16’ and by making
deduction of 1/4th towards personal expenses.
16. Apart from compensation for loss of dependency, appellants-
claimants shall also be entitled to Rs . 15,000 /- towards funeral expenses and
Rs . 15,000 /- towards loss of estate . Appellant-claimant No.1 shall be entitled
to compensation of Rs . 40,000 /- towards loss of spousal consortium .
Appellants-claimants No.2 to 4 shall be entitled to compensation of
Rs . 40,000 /- each towards loss of parental consortium . Appellant-claimant
No.5 shall be entitled to compensation of Rs . 40,000 /- towards loss of filial
consortium . It is however made clear that in case Hon’ble Supreme Court
answer the reference regarding quantum of compensation under
conventional head made in Hasina Yasmin & Ors. Vs. National Insurance
Co. Ltd. , 2025 SCC Online SC 2919 in favour of appellants-claimants,
appellant-claimants shall be free to seek said amount by moving appropriate
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.17 16:59
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO No.2430 of 2002 -8-
application in this regard.
17. Reworked compensation payable to appellants-claimants is as
under:-
Income Rs.1,900/- Rs.1,900/-
per month per month
Future prospects 40% Rs.2,660/-
(1,900+760)
Deduction 1/4th Rs.1,995/-
(2,660 - 665)
Multiplier 16 16
Total loss of Rs.1,995/-X12X 16 Rs.3,83,040/-
dependency
Loss of estate Rs.15,000/-
Funeral expenses Rs.15,000/-
Loss of spousal
consortium to
appellant-claimant
No.1
Rs.40,000/-
Loss of parental
consortium to
appellants-claimants
No.2 to 4
Rs.40,000/-X 3 Rs.1,20,000/-
Loss of filial
consortium to
appellant-claimant
No.5
Rs.40,000/-
Rs.1,15,200/-
(after 50%
deduction towards
contributory
negligence)
Total compensation Rs.6,13,040/-
awarded in appeal
Total compensation
awarded by the
Tribunal
Enhanced Rs.6,13,040/-
compensation (as awarded in
appeal)
–
Rs.1,15,200/-
(as awarded by
Tribunal)
Rs.4,97,840/-
18. Appellants-claimants shall be entitled to enhanced
compensation (except for conventional heads i.e. loss of consortium, funeral
expenses, loss of estate) along with 7.5% interest from the date of filing of
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.17 16:59
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO No.2430 of 2002 -9-
claim petition till realization of entire amount. Interest on enhanced
compensation under conventional heads shall be payable from August 2017
onwards till realization. Apportionment and liability to pay compensation
shall be as per award.
19. Appeal is allowed in above terms.
20. Pending application(s), if any, stand disposed of.
(PARMOD GOYAL)
JUDGE
16.11.2026
Sunil Chander
Whether speaking/reasoned : Yes/No
Whether reportable : Yes/No
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.17 16:59
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document