State Of Haryana And Others vs Tek Chand And Others

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
Item No.106+107 (66 cases) RFA-670-2026 (O&M)
Reserved on : 11.11.2026
Pronounced on : 16.11.2026
STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS …Appellants
Versus
TEK CHAND AND OTHERS …Respondents
With
Sr.
No.
Case No. Appellant(s) Respondent(s)

2. RFA-1592-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Barhamanand

3. RFA-1594-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Bhoop Singh & Ors.

4. RFA-1595-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Ami Chand & Anr.

5. RFA-1596-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Lal Chand & Ors.

6. RFA-1597-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Mahender

7. RFA-1598-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Bimla Devi

8. RFA-1599-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Smt. Santosh & Ors.

9. RFA-1600-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Rohtash & Ors.

10. RFA-1601-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Smt. Ramkala & Ors.

11. RFA-1602-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Ramchander & Ors.

12. RFA-1605-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Lal Singh & Ors.

13. RFA-1606-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Jaswant Singh & Ors.

14. RFA-1607-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Gajender & Ors.

15. RFA-1609-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Tek Chand & Ors.

16. RFA-1610-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Bhure Lal & Ors.

17. RFA-1611-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Jagdish & Ors.

18. RFA-1612-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Pyare Lal & Ors.

19. RFA-1613-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Deepak & Anr.

20. RFA-1614-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Bishamber

21. RFA-1615-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Raj Pal & Ors.

22. RFA-1616-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Nand Lal & Ors.

23. RFA-1617-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Arjun Singh & Ors.

24. RFA-1593-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Dharampal & Ors.

25. RFA-1642-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Bhure Lal & Ors.

26. RFA-1643-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Satish Kumar & Ors.

27. RFA-1644-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana Mahabir & Ors.

28. RFA-1645-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Nand Lal & Ors.

29. RFA-1647-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Layak Ram & Ors.

30. RFA-1648-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Mahipal & Ors.

31. RFA-821-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Sardar Singh (deceased)
through LRs & Ors.

32. RFA-1705-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Rajaram

33. RFA-215-2020 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Braham Prakash & Ors.

34. RFA-216-2020 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Ramkanwar & Anr.

35. RFA-217-2020 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Sarjeet Singh & Ors.

36. RFA-218-2020 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Hukum Singh & Ors.

37. RFA-219-2020 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Rajinder & Ors.

38. RFA-220-2020 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Sultan Singh & Ors.

39. RFA-222-2020 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Puran Singh & Ors.

40. RFA-223-2020 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Ishwar & Ors.
DEEPAK BISSYAN
2026.11.17 15:54
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment



RFA-670-2026 (O&M) & connected cases -2-
Sr.
No.
Case No. Appellant(s) Respondent(s)

41. RFA-265-2020 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Ram Singh & Ors.

42. RFA-266-2020 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Rampat & Ors.

43. RFA-324-2020 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Om Parkash & Ors.

44. RFA-325-2020 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Kanshi Ram & Ors.

45. RFA-329-2020 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Rajender Singh & Ors.

46. RFA-332-2020 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Ram Kanwar & Ors.

47. RFA-232-2020 (O&M) Raj Singh & Ors. State of Haryana & Ors.

48. RFA-2436-2021 (O&M) Rampat & Ors. State of Haryana & Ors.

49. RFA-2495-2021 (O&M) Hukum Singh & Ors. State of Haryana & Ors.

50. RFA-534-2020 (O&M) Sarjeet Singh & Ors. State of Haryana & Ors.

51. RFA-536-2020 (O&M) Ramkanwar & Anr. State of Haryana & Ors.

52. RFA-537-2020 (O&M) Rajinder & Ors. State of Haryana & Ors.

53. RFA-1640-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Mahabir & Ors.

54. RFA-1604-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Balram & Ors.

55. RFA-221-2020 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Mahender Singh & Ors.

56. RFA-1666-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Amar Singh & Anr.

57. RFA-480-2026 (O&M) Deepak & Anr. State of Haryana & Ors.

58. RFA-160-2022 (O&M) Rajender Singh & Ors. State of Haryana & Ors.

59. RFA-1652-2026 (O&M) State of Haryana & Ors. Shriram & Anr.

60. XOBJR-110-2026 (O&M)
in RFA-1614-2026 (O&M)
State of Haryana & Ors. Bishamber

61. XOBJR-107-2026 (O&M)
in RFA-1593-2026 (O&M)
State of Haryana & Ors. Dharampal

62. XOBJR-96-2026 (O&M)
in RFA-821-2026 (O&M)
State of Haryana & Ors. Sardar Singh (deceased)
through LRs & Ors.

63. XOBJR-109-2026 (O&M)
in RFA-1640-2026
State of Haryana & Ors. Mahabir & Ors.

64. XOBJR-113-2026 (O&M)
in RFA-1605-2026
State of Haryana & Ors. Balram (deceased)
through LRs & Ors.

65. XOBJR-108-2026 (O&M)
in RFA-1652-2026 (O&M)
State of Haryana & Ors. Shriram & Anr.

CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE JAGMOHAN BANSAL
Present: - Mr. Abhinash Jain, Additional Advocate General, Haryana

Mr. Shailendra Jain, Senior Advocate with
Mr. Shubham Verma, Advocate,
Ms. Ruchi Jain, Advocate,
Ms. Samkiti Jain, Advocate
Mr. Munish Sharma, Advocate and
Mr. Bharat Bhushan, Advocate
for appellants (in RFA-480-2026 )
for respondents (in RFAs No.1593, 1652, 1640, 1614, 1605 &
1613 of 2026 ) and
for cross-objector (in XOBJR No.113, 110, 107, 109 of 2026)

Mr. Chanderhas Yadav, Advocate
for respondent(s) (in RFAs No.670, 1604, 1609, 1612, 1606,
1615, 1596, 1598, 1600, 1617, 1607, 1647, 1648, 1616 &
1643 of 2026 )


DEEPAK BISSYAN
2026.11.17 15:54
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment



RFA-670-2026 (O&M) & connected cases -3-
Mr. Jai Singh Yadav, Advocate
For appellants (In RFA-534-2020, RFA-536-2020,
RFA-537-2020, RFA-2436-2021 & RFA-2495-2021 );
for respondent No.2 (In RFA-216-2020 );
for respondents No.1 to 3, 5 to 7 & 20 to 22 (in RFA-217-2020 );
for respondents No.1 to 4 (in RFA-218-2020 );
for respondents No.4 & 5 (in RFA-324-2020 ); and
for respondents No.1 to 5 & 11 (in RFA-332-2020 )

Mr. Ram Darshan Yadav, Advocate for respondent(s)
(in RFA Nos.1592, 1597 & 1611 of 2026 )
for respondents No.1(A), 1(C), 1(E), 1(F) and 5
(in RFA-821-2026 ) and
for cross-objector No.1 (i)(iii)(v)(vi) & 5 (in XOBJR-96-2026)

Mr. L.K. Gollen, Advocate
for respondent Nos.1B(i)(ii)(iii), 1D, 2, 3 & 4(in RFA-821-2026 )

Mr. Mohit Jaggi, Advocate (through V.C.)
for LRs of respondents No.2 & 12 ( in RFA-1602-2026 )

Mr. Akash Sharma, Advocate (through V.C.)
for the landowners ( in RFAs No.215, 265, 221, 222 of 2020)

*

JAGMOHAN BANSAL, J.

1.
These appeals under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act,
1894 (for short ‘1894 Act’) are directed against awards dated 20.03.2025,
14.02.2025 and 19.08.2019 passed, with respect to land of Villages
Gokalgarh, Kaluwas, Rewari and Chandawas by learned Additional District
Judge, Rewari (hereinafter called as ‘Reference Court’). The landowners are
seeking enhancement of the amount of compensation whereas the State is
claiming otherwise.

2. As common issues are involved in the captioned appeals, with
the consent of both sides, the same are hereby disposed of by this common
order. For the sake of brevity and convenience, facts are borrowed from
RFA-670- 2026 .

3. Tabulated details of the assessment made till date read as: -
DEEPAK BISSYAN
2026.11.17 15:54
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment



RFA-670-2026 (O&M) & connected cases -4-
Date of notification under Section 4 01.07.2008
Date of notification under Section 6 20.02.2009
Purpose of acquisition Construction of Road from Rewari-Jhajjar road
to Narnaul Road via Rewari-Dadri Road
Location Villages: Gokalgarh, Kaluwas, Rewari,
Chandawas, Kan Majra and Qutabpur Mola
Tehsil & District –Rewari
Area (Total in acres) 59.57
Date of Collector’s Award (LAC) 09.09.2009- Village Gokalgarh
14.07.2009- Kaluwas
30.07.2009- Rewari
24.12.2010- Village Chandawas
Market value of the land in question 16,00,000/-
as per LAC (₹ per acre)
Date of Reference Court (RC) Awards 20.03.2025- Gokalgarh, Kaluwas
14.02.2025- Rewari
19.08.2019- Chandawas

Market value as per RC (₹ per sq. (i) 1,95,72,960/- for Gokalgarh, Kaluwas and
yards) Rewari

(ii) 48,93,240/- for Chandawas



4. The State Government issued notification dated 01.07.2008
under Section 4 of the 1894 Act for the acquisition of 59.57 Acres land
situated in six Villages i.e. Gokalgarh, Kaluwas, Rewari, Chandawas, Kan
Majra and Qutabpur Mola District Rewari, with intent to construct Road from
Rewari-Jhajjar road to Narnaul Road via Rewari-Dadri Road in District
Rewari. The said notification was followed by notification dated 20.02.2009
issued under Section 6 of 1894 Act. Present appeals are confined to land
situated in four villages i.e. Gokalgarh, Kaluwas, Rewari and Chandawas.

Matter of remaining two villages is still pending before the Reference Court.

5. The Land Acquisition Collector (for short ‘Collector’) under
Section 11 vide Awards dated 09.09.2009, 14.07.2009, 30.07.2009 and
24.12.2010, determined compensation payable to the landowners, for the
Villages Gokalgarh, Kaluwas, Rewari and Chandawas respectively. Market
value of the acquired land was determined @ ₹16,00,000/- per acre.
Landowners were held entitled to solatium and other statutory benefits.
Feeling dis-satisfied from the aforesaid award, landowners preferred petitions
DEEPAK BISSYAN
2026.11.17 15:54
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment



RFA-670-2026 (O&M) & connected cases -5-
before the Collector which were referred to the Court under Section 18 of the
1894 Act.

6. The Reference Court while appreciating evidence led by both
sides, by impugned award adjudicated reference petitions. The Reference
Court by impugned awards dated 20.03.2025 and 14.02.2025 has assessed
market value of the acquired land @ ₹1,95,72,960 /- per acre for the villages
Gokalgarh, Kaluwas, Rewari. Market value for the Village Chandawas has
been assessed @ ₹48,93,240/- per acre vide award dated 19.08.2019.

7. Learned counsel for the landowners submit that the Reference
Court has rightly relied upon order dated 29.01.2016 passed by this Court in
RFA-3341-2011 titled as ‘ Lala Ram Vs. State of Haryana & Ors. ’ and order
dated 19.02.2016 passed in RFA-48-2012 titled as ‘Harphool Singh Vs. State
of Haryana & Ors.’ . Rewari is an urban fully developed area. This Court
while passing order in Harphool Singh (supra) relied upon order dated
05.05.2008 passed in RFA-3353-2001 titled as ‘Bhawani Sahai & Anr. Vs.
State of Haryana & Ors.’ wherein market value was determined @ ₹990/-
per sq. yard. Order in Bhawani Sahai (supra) related to notification dated
15.02.1990 issued under Section 4 of 1894 Act. While relying upon order
passed in Bhawani Sahai (supra), market value of the land comprising
Sectors 6 & 7, District Rewari was determined. Sectors 6 & 7 of District
Rewari comprised revenue estates Gokalgrah and Rewari. Land comprised
in Harphool Singh (supra) is situated close to the land of few landowners.
There is distance of less than 400 feet between the land comprised in
Harphool Singh (supra) order and land in question. As Harphool Singh
(supra) was passed relying upon order passed in Bhawani Sahai (supra) ,
market value of the land in question can also be assessed on the basis of order
DEEPAK BISSYAN
2026.11.17 15:54
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment



RFA-670-2026 (O&M) & connected cases -6-
passed in Bhawani Sahai (supra) . There may be little more or little less
distance between two pieces of land, however, market value is required to be
assessed in a holistic and pragmatic manner. The Court cannot adopt pedantic
approach because valuation under 1894 Act is not a mathematical or algebraic
exercise. The Court must consider entire area especially when there is
development across the area. Sale deed dated 19.06.2007 (Ex.P-11) was
executed prior to notification in question. As per sale deed dated 19.06.2007
(Ex.P-11), market value comes to ₹2,59,50,000/- per acre (₹5362/- per sq.
yard). The sale deeds Ex.P-9 & P-10 may not be relied upon because it is
settled law that sale deed disclosing highest price must be relied upon. Land
comprised in Ex.P-9 & P-10 is abutting Rewari-Jhajjar Road. As per Master
Plan, land abutting road cannot be utilized, thus, possibility of distress sales
qua Ex.P-9 & P-10 cannot be ruled out.

8. Per contra , learned State counsel submits that market value of
the land in question cannot be determined as per orders passed in RFA-3341-
2011 ( Lala Ram ) and RFA-48-2012 ( Harphool Singh ) . Both the aforesaid
orders are based upon order passed in Bhawani Sahai (supra) . As per
judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in ‘Manoj Kumar & Ors. Vs. State of
Haryana & Anr.’ , 2018 (13) SCC 96 , market value cannot be mechanically
determined as per previous awards. The Courts are bound to consider
foundation of previous award. Land in question is situated at far away from
the land situated in Bhawani Sahai (supra) . The landowners before the
Reference Court relied upon sale deed No.8881 dated 18.03.2008 (Ex.P-9)
and sale deed No.245 dated 15.04.2008 (Ex.P-10). The market value as per
Ex.P-9 & P-10 comes to ₹62,97,579/- and ₹75,00,870/- per acre, respectively.
Land comprised in Ex.P-9 & P-10 is situated abutting the road as well as very
DEEPAK BISSYAN
2026.11.17 15:54
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment



RFA-670-2026 (O&M) & connected cases -7-
close to the starting point of the acquired land. Land comprised in Ex.P-11
dated 19.06.2007 is located at far away and that too abutting Rewari-Delhi
Highway. Land comprised in Ex.RW-1/C (Village Kaluwas) i.e. sale deed
No.377 dated 22.04.2008 forms part of the acquired land. Market value as
per aforesaid sale deed comes to ₹7,00,243/- per acre. The State vide
notification dated 04.04.2007 acquired land for constructing Kaluwas Minor
which comprised land situated in Village Aaspur, Gokalgarh and Kaluwas.
Land in question is situated in six Villages and Village Gokalgarh and
Kaluwas are two of them. This Court with respect to land acquired for
Kaluwas Minor vide order dated 19.02.2016 passed in RFA-7398-2011 titled
as ‘State of Haryana & Ors. Vs. Ghisa Ram’ has determined market value
@ ₹48,93,240/- per acre. This Court while passing aforesaid order has relied
upon order passed in RFA-48-2012 ( Harphool ). The Court has imposed 75%
cut over the value assessed in Harphool (supra) . This Court vide order dated
29.07.2025 passed in RFA-7146-2012 tilted as ‘Rajinder Singh & Ors. Vs.
State of Haryana & Ors.’ , with respect to notification dated 06.11.2006
whereby land situated in Gokalgarh and Gindogarh for construction of
Kishangarh Minor was acquired, has determined market value @
₹47,70,909/- per acre.

9. Learned counsel for the State does not oppose condonation of
delay in filing appeal by the landowners. The landowners are opposing
condonation of delay in filing appeal by the State. Separate order with respect
to State’s application seeking condonation of delay has been passed.
Landowners’ application(s) seeking condonation of delay is hereby allowed.
It is clarified that appellant(s) shall not be entitled to interest for the delayed
period.
DEEPAK BISSYAN
2026.11.17 15:54
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment



RFA-670-2026 (O&M) & connected cases -8-

10. All the arguments raised by both sides have been recorded in the
presence of counsel for the parties. They have not raised any other argument.

11. Heard the arguments and perused the record.

12. The Collector vide awards dated 09.09.2009, 14.07.2009,
30.07.2009 and 24.12.2010 determined market price @ ₹16,00,000/- per acre.
All the awards emanated from notification dated 01.07.2008 issued under
Section 4 of the 1894 Act. The landowners preferred petitions under Section
18 which came to be adjudicated by the Reference Court vide awards dated
19.08.2019, 20.03.2025 and 14.02.2025. By notification dated 01.07.2008
land of six villages was acquired and till date the Reference Court has passed
award with respect to four villages i.e. Gokalgarh, Kaluwas, Rewari and
Chandawas. By award dated 19.08.2019 market value of the land of Village
Chandawas has been determined @ ₹48,93,240/- per acre. By award dated
14.02.2025 market value of land of Village Rewari (Sardar Singh) has been
determined @ ₹1,95,72,960/- per acre. By award dated 20.03.2025 market
value of land situated in Village Gokalgarh and Kaluwas has been determined
@ ₹1,95,72,960/- per acre. The Reference Court while passing award dated
19.08.2019 has relied upon order passed in Ghisa Ram (supra) . The
Reference Court while passing other awards has banked upon order dated
29.01.2016 and 19.02.2016 passed by this Court in Lala Ram (supra) and
Harphool (supra), respectively.

13. Learned counsel for the landowners are supporting assessment
made vide awards dated 20.03.2025 and 14.02.2025. They are also claiming
that they deserve to be granted escalation @ 12% p.a. because notification in
Harphool (supra) was issued on 14.11.2006 whereas notification in question
was issued on 01.07.2008. The State is claiming that in view of orders of this
DEEPAK BISSYAN
2026.11.17 15:54
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment



RFA-670-2026 (O&M) & connected cases -9-
Court in Ghisa Ram (supra) and Rajinder Singh (supra) as well as sale deeds
Ex.P-9 & P-10 cited by landowners, there is no occasion to rely upon orders
dated 29.01.2016 and 19.02.2016 passed by this Court.

14. In the wake of arguments raised by both sides, this Court has to
consider whether market value for the land in question should be determined
as per orders dated 29.01.2016 and 19.02.2016 passed by this Court or as per
orders dated 19.02.2016 and 29.07.2025 read with sale deeds Ex.P-9 & P-10.
The Court has to further consider whether sale deed Ex.P-11 dated 19.06.2007
can be made basis to determine market value for the land in question.

15. Before delving into the issues involved, it would be appropriate
to have bird’s eye view of afore-cited orders of this Court. By order dated
05.05.2008, this Court determined market value of the land which was
acquired vide notification dated 15.02.1990. By notification dated
06.01.2006 and 14.11.2006, the State Government acquired land situated in
revenue estates Gokalgarh and Rewari. By order dated 29.01.2016 and
19.02.2016, this Court determined market value of the acquired land as per
order dated 05.05.2008 whereby market value of the land acquired in 1990
was determined. This Court formed an opinion that cumulative escalation @
12% p.a. may be granted. Market value qua notification dated 15.02.1990
was determined @ ₹990/- per sq. yard. This Court applying cumulative
16
escalation doctrine [990(1+12/100) ] found market value @ ₹6,065/- per sq.
rd
yard. The Court further applied cut of 1/3 and determined market value @
₹4,044/- per sq. yard. The Reference Court in two awards i.e. award dated
20.03.2025 and 14.02.2025 has followed orders dated 29.01.2016 &
19.02.2016 of this Court and assessed market value @ ₹1,95,72,960/- per acre
whereas the Collector had determined @ ₹16,00,000/- per acre. The
DEEPAK BISSYAN
2026.11.17 15:54
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment



RFA-670-2026 (O&M) & connected cases -10-
Reference Court with respect to same acquisition vide award dated
19.08.2019 has determined market value @ ₹48,93,240/- per acre.

16. In Lala Ram (supra) and Harphool (supra) , this Court has
rejected contention of the State that escalation cannot be counted beyond five
years. The Court has calculated escalation for 16 years and that too
cumulative.

17. Hon’ble Supreme Court in Lal Chand Vs. Union of India ,
2009(15) SCC 769 while noticing its judgment in The General Manager, Oil
& Natural Gas Corporation Ltd. Vs. Rameshbhai Jivanbhai Patel 2008(4)
RCR (Civil) 487 has held that escalation should not be calculated beyond five
years. Award made with regard to acquisition of 1961 will not be of any use
for determining the market value for a 1981 acquisition. The Court has held:
“19. This Court had occasion to examine this issue recently.
In The General Manager, Oil & Natural Gas Corporation
Ltd. v. Rameshbhai Jivanbhai Patel 2008(4) RCR (Civil)
487 : 2008(5) R.A.J. 538 : [2008 (11) SCALE 637 ] , this court
held :
“Normally, recourse is taken to the mode of
determining the market value by providing appropriate
escalation over the proved market value of nearby
lands in previous years (as evidenced by sale
transactions or acquisition), where there is no evidence
of any contemporaneous sale transactions or
acquisitions of comparable lands in the neighbourhood.
The said method is reasonably safe where the relied-
on-sale transactions/acquisitions precedes the subject
acquisition by only a few years, that is upto four to five
years. Beyond that it may be unsafe, even if it relates to
a neighbouring land. What may be a reliable standard
if the gap is only a few years, may become unsafe and
unreliable standard where the gap is larger. For
example, for determining the market value of a land
DEEPAK BISSYAN
2026.11.17 15:54
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment



RFA-670-2026 (O&M) & connected cases -11-
acquired in 1992, adopting the annual increase method
with reference to a sale or acquisition in 1970 or 1980
may have many pitfalls. This is because, over the course
of years, the 'rate' of annual increase may itself undergo
drastic change apart from the likelihood of occurrence
of varying periods of stagnation in prices or sudden
spurts in prices affecting the very standard of
increase.”
Even if the relied upon transaction is only two to three
years prior to the acquisition, court should, before adopting a
standard escalation, satisfy that there were no adverse
circumstances. For example, if the acquisition is of this year
2009, it may not be possible to determine the market value,
based on the 2007 or 2008 prices, by providing an increase of
12% or 15% per year, as the newspaper reports disclose that
the price of immovable properties in most areas of the country
came down by more than 40% to 50% from the 2007 rates.
Caution is therefore necessary before increasing the price with
reference to the old transactions. Be that as it may. It is clear
that the award made in regard to a 1961 acquisition will not
be of any use for determining the market value for a 1981
acquisition.”
As per afore-cited judgment, escalation should not be counted
for more than five years. In the case in hand, there was gap of 18 years
between the previous acquisition and acquisition in question. The Reference
Court has calculated escalation @ 12% and that too cumulative. In view of
above-cited judgement, there is no occasion to calculate escalation for 16
years. There was gap of 18 years so question arises as to why escalation was
not calculated for 18 years. Actually, the Reference Court has mechanically
followed orders of this Court in Lala Ram (supra) and Harphool (supra).
The Reference Court with respect to same acquisition has determined market
value @ ₹48,93,240/- per acre.
DEEPAK BISSYAN
2026.11.17 15:54
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment



RFA-670-2026 (O&M) & connected cases -12-

18. The Supreme Court in Manoj Kumar & Ors. Vs. State of
Haryana & Anr., 2018 (13) SCC 96 has held that market value cannot be
mechanically determined as per previous award. As per judgment of
Supreme Court in Ram Krishan (Since Deceased) Vs. State of Haryana,
2025 SCC OnLine SC 715 previous award may be considered. It need not be
outrightly ignored. The Apex Court has made aforesaid observation after
noticing its earlier judgment in Manoj Kumar (supra) . The Apex Court in
Ram Kishan (supra) has held:
“29. In Manoj Kumar (Supra) , this Court in Para 11,12,13,14
and 16 held as under.
"11. In our opinion, the High Court could not have
placed an outright reliance on Swaran Singh v. State
of Haryana, 2012 SCC Online P&H 19044 , without
considering the nature of transaction relied upon in the
said decision. The decision could not have been applied
ipso facto to the facts of the instant case. In such cases,
where such judgments/awards are relied on as
evidence, though they are relevant, but cannot be said
to be binding with respect to the determination of the
price, that has to depend on the evidence adduced in the
case. However, in the instant case, it appears that the
land in Swaran Singh case was situated just across the
road as observed by the High Court as such it is
relevant evidence but not binding. As such it could have
been taken into consideration due to the nearness of the
area, but at the same time what was the nature of the
transaction relied upon in the said case was also
required to be looked into in an objective manner. Such
decisions in other cases cannot be adopted without
examining the basis for determining compensation
whether sale transaction referred to therein can be
relied upon or not and what was the distance, size and
also bona fide nature of transaction before such
judgments/awards are relied on for deciding the
DEEPAK BISSYAN
2026.11.17 15:54
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment



RFA-670-2026 (O&M) & connected cases -13-
subsequent cases. It is not open to accepting
determination in a mechanical manner without
considering the merit. Such determination cannot be
said to be binding.
12. We have come across several decisions where the
High Court is adopting the previous decisions as
binding. The determination of compensation in each
case depends upon the nature of land and what is the
evidence adduced in each case, may be that better
evidence has been adduced in later case regarding the
actual value of property and subsequent sale deeds
after the award and before preliminary notification
under Section 4 are also to be considered, if filed. It is
not proper to ignore the evidence adduced in the case
at hand. The compensation cannot be determined by
blindly following the previous award/judgment. It has
to be considered only a piece of evidence, not beyond
that. The court has to apply the judicial mind and is
supposed not to follow the previous awards without due
consideration of the facts and circumstances and
evidence adduced in the case in question. The current
value reflected by comparable sale deeds is more
reliable and binding for determination of compensation
in such cases award/judgment relating to an acquisition
made before 5 to 10 years cannot form the safe basis
for determining compensation.
13. The awards and judgment in the cases of others not
being inter partes are not binding as precedents.
Recently, we have seen the trend of the courts to follow
them blindly probably under the misconception of the
concept of equality and fair treatment. The courts are
being swayed away and this approach in the absence of
and similar nature and situation of land is causing more
injustice and tantamount to giving equal treatment in
the case of unequals. As per situation of a village,
nature of land, its value differ from distance to distance,
even two to three kilometre distance may also make the
material difference in value. Land abutting highway
DEEPAK BISSYAN
2026.11.17 15:54
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment



RFA-670-2026 (O&M) & connected cases -14-
may fetch higher value but not land situated in interior
villages.
14. The previous awards/judgments are the only piece
of evidence on a par with comparative sale
transactions. The similarity of the land covered by
previous judgment/award is required to be proved like
any other comparative exemplar. In case previous
award/judgment is based on exemplar, which is not
similar or acceptable, previous award/judgment of
court cannot be said to be binding. Such determination
has to be outrightly rejected. In case some mistake has
been done in awarding compensation, it cannot be
followed; on the ground of parity an illegality cannot
be perpetuated. Such award/judgment would be wholly
irrelevant.
16. To base determination of compensation on a
previous award/judgment, the evidence considered in
the previous judgment/award and its acceptability on
judicial parameters has to be necessarily gone into,
otherwise, gross injustice may be caused to any of the
parties. In case some gross mistake or illegality has
been committed in previous award/judgment of not
making deduction, etc. and/or sufficient evidence had
not been adduced and better evidence is adduced in
case at hand, previous award/judgment being not inter
parties cannot be followed and if land is not similar in
nature in all aspects it has to be outrightly rejected as
done in the case of comparative exemplars. Sale deeds
are on a par for evidentiary value with such awards of
the court as court bases its conclusions on such
transaction only, to ultimately determine the value of
the property."
30. Even in Manoj Kumar (Supra) , this Court did not hold
that awards in other cases which are relevant cannot be relied
upon at all. What is held was such awards will be relevant as
a piece of evidence and not be conclusive in nature.”
[Emphasis supplied]
DEEPAK BISSYAN
2026.11.17 15:54
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment



RFA-670-2026 (O&M) & connected cases -15-

19. In view of above-cited judgments, the previous award cannot be
mechanically relied upon. The Reference Court, in the case in hand, has
mechanically relied upon previous awards. The landowners had cited
exemplar sale deeds. The State had also produced exemplar sale deeds.
Previous award could be considered, in the absence of exemplar sale deeds.
It is apt to notice that foundation of impugned award dated 20.03.2025 and
award dated 19.08.2019 is orders passed by this Court in Lala Ram (supra)
and Harphool (supra). In Ghisa Ram (supra) and Rajinder (supra), this
Court imposed cut of 75% over value assessed in Lala Ram (supra) and
Harphool (supra). The Reference Court as per its suitability has relied upon
orders passed in Ghisa Ram (supra) while passing award qua village
Chandawas and relied upon orders passed in Lala Ram (supra) and
Harphool (supra) while passing awards qua villages Gokalgarh, Kaluwas
and Rewari. It is apt to notice here that by one notification and for the same
purpose, mere 0.66 acre land of Village Rewari was acquired whereas 10.62
acres land of Village Gokalgarh, 14.71 acres land of Village Kaluwas and
17.97 acres land of Village Chandawas was acquired. The Reference Court
was supposed to consider sale deeds rather than previous awards.
19.1 In the previous awards, escalation @ 12% p.a. was calculated on
cumulative basis (compounded). The Supreme Court has evolved doctrine of
escalation. Except in exceptional circumstances, the Court has granted simple
escalation @ 8 to 12% p.a. The Courts have not granted cumulative
escalation. If this formula is applied despite availability of contemporaneous
sale deeds, value of every piece of land may be determined applying
cumulative escalation @ 12% p.a. The Reference Court has applied
cumulative escalation despite gap of 18 years between the previous
DEEPAK BISSYAN
2026.11.17 15:54
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment



RFA-670-2026 (O&M) & connected cases -16-
acquisition and acquisition in question. If market value determined 16 or 18
years back can be made basis, there is no hitch to determine market value as
per value determined 40-50 years back. This Court finds itself unable to
subscribe aforesaid view. It is even otherwise contrary to judgments of the
Apex Court in The General Manager, Oil & Natural Gas Corporation Ltd
(supra) and Lal Chand (supra) .

20. The landowners cited sale deeds Ex.P-9, P-10 & P-11 before the
Reference Court. Both sides during the course of hearing cited site plan. The
landowners have placed on record their site plan as additional evidence. The
State too during hearing produced site plan. There is no difference between
the site plan produced by both sides. As per site plan, land comprised in Ex.P-
9 & P-10 dated 18.03.2008 and 15.04.2008 is close to starting point of the
acquired land. Market price as per Ex.P-9 & P-10 comes to ₹62,97,579/- and
₹75,00,870/- per acre respectively. The Reference Court has rejected
aforesaid sale deeds on the ground that it pertained to small parcels of land.
The Reference Court has further rejected Ex.P-11 on the ground that it
pertains to Village Khalilpuri and not Villages Gokalgarh and Kaluwas. Land
comprised in Ex.P-9 is 347 sq. yard and Ex.P-10 is 1391 sq. yards. Both
parcels of land are situated abutting the road and very close to the starting
point of the acquired land. The landowners are claiming that starting point of
the acquired land is just 400 feet away from previously acquired land. This
Court, in view of afore-cited judgments especially in view of the fact that
foundation of afore-cited judgments is acquisition of 1990 i.e. 18 years prior
to the acquisition in question, does not find it appropriate to rely upon
previous awards/orders passed by this Court in Lala Ram (supra) and
.
Harphool (supra)
DEEPAK BISSYAN
2026.11.17 15:54
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment



RFA-670-2026 (O&M) & connected cases -17-

21. Ld. State Counsel has vehemently pleaded that sale deed No.377
dated 22.04.2008 (Ex.RW1/C) formed part of the acquired land. It is situated
within revenue estate Kaluwas. Area comprised in aforesaid sale deed is 12K-
3M and market value is ₹7,00,243/- per acre.

22. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in ‘ Spl. Tehsildar, Land
Acquisition, Vishakapatnam Vs. Smt. A. Mangala Gowri’ , 1991(4) SCC
218 has held that when bona fide or genuine sale transaction relating to the
self-same land is available, there is no justification to rely upon another
award. The Apex Court in the said case has noticed that one acre land was
sold @ ₹5 per sq. yard and it cannot be expected that within a short span of 9
months, it would fetch ₹10 per sq. yard. The Reference Court and High Court
had determined value @ ₹10 per sq. yard while relying upon another award
wherein market value @ ₹10 per sq. yard was determined. A part of the
acquired land itself was sold @ ₹5 per sq. yard. The Apex Court held that
High Court has committed error while ignoring sale consideration of the land
under acquisition. The relevant extracts of the judgment read as:
“In a span of one year and four months, they sold @ Rs.5
per sq. yard. It is common knowledge that proposal for
acquisition would be known to everyone in the
neighbourhood, in particular, to the owners of the property
and it is not uncommon that sale transactions would be
brought into existence before the publication of Section
4(1) notification so as to form the basis to lay higher claim
for compensation. We do assume that Ex. B.10 is a genuine
and bona fide sale transaction. In respect of one acre of
the land in the self-same land when sold at Rs.5 per sq.
yard, would it fetch in a short period of nine months,
double the market value, namely, @ Rs.10 per sq. yard. We
have no doubt that it would not get that price for 5 acres
and odd area. It is undoubted that in respect of a
DEEPAK BISSYAN
2026.11.17 15:54
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment



RFA-670-2026 (O&M) & connected cases -18-
notification of 1961 in which another T.S. number in the
locality, namely, T. S. No. 1008, (sic) ultimately, the High
Court awarded @ Rs.10 per sq. yard. Perhaps had there
been no bona fide or genuine sale transaction relating to
the self-same land, the reliance placed on that judgment
may be justified but exclusion of bona fide and genuine
sale transactions in respect of the same land under
acquisition and to place reliance on the award of some
other land is obviously illegal. When the claimants
themselves sold as a willing seller of an acre of land @
Rs.5 per sq. yard large extent of five acres and odd under
acquisition, if it is offered to be sold as a block, it would
not fetch higher rate but surely be negotiated for a lesser
rate if not the same market value @ Rs.5 due to time lag
of nine months. No attempt was made by the respondent to
explain under what circumstances they came to sell their
lands @ Rs.5 per sq. yard when they expect higher value
@ Rs.10 per sq. yard. May be the payment of Rs.10 per sq.
yard, be windfall to the owner of the land:- T 1008. Taking
the totality of the facts and circumstances, we hold that the
High Court committed grave error to completely ignore
the sale transactions of the lands under acquisition. In
view of the time lag we have no hesitation to conclude that
the prevailing market value of the land as on the date of
the notification would be Rs. 6 per sq. yard.”
[Emphasis supplied]

23. In view of afore-cited judgment, sale deed No.377 dated
22.04.2008 (Ex.RW1/C) comprising 1 Acre 4 Kanal 3 Marla land cannot be
ignored. Market price as per aforesaid sale deed was ₹7,00,243/- per acre.

24. There are many sale deeds like Ex.RW1/A (Gokalgarh), RW2/D
(Rewari), R1 (Chandawas), R2 (Chandawas), RW1/C (Kaluwas) which are
comprising land in the close vicinity of the acquired land. Value declared in
these sale deeds is not more than ₹16,00,000/- per acre i.e. equal to market
DEEPAK BISSYAN
2026.11.17 15:54
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment



RFA-670-2026 (O&M) & connected cases -19-
value assessed by the Collector. Area comprised in sale deeds Ex.R-1, R-2,
RW1/C is more than one acre, thus, these deeds cannot be ignored. In Lal
Chand (supra), the Apex Court has held while relying upon Section 25 sale
deeds produced by State cannot be ignored. The Court has held:
“The High Court also rejected Ex.R3 to R7 relied upon by the
respondents, solely on the ground that the prices therein were
lower than the market value offered by Land Acquisition
Collector and therefore, they had to be excluded under section
25 of the LA Act. Section 25 provides that the amount of
compensation awarded by a reference court shall not be less
than the amount awarded by the Collector under section 11. We
fail to see how the said section has any relevance in regard to
determination of market value as contrasted from award of
compensation. If the sale deeds relied on by the respondents
showed a particular market value, they cannot be ignored
merely because the Collector had awarded compensation at a
higher rate in regard to the acquired land. All that section 25
requires is that courts should not award an amount which is
less than what is awarded by the Land Acquisition Collector,
even if the evidence may show a lesser market value. So, the
bar under section 25 of the LA Act is not in regard to
determination of a market value, which is less than what was
awarded by the LAO. The bar is only upon the reference court
(or any higher court) reducing the compensation awarded by
the Land Acquisition Collector. The fact that the Land
Acquisition Collector has awarded compensation at a
particular rate does not mean that the sale deeds which are
otherwise reliable, cannot be relied upon to find out what was
the real market value. Further the very assumption that all
awards made by the Collector were at a rate higher than what
was disclosed by the sale deeds (Ex.R3 to R7) is also not
correct. The Land Acquisition Collector awarded a sum of
Rs.2600 to Rs. 3800 per bigha in regard to acquisitions under
notifications dated 13.2.1981 and 20.2.1981, Rs. 6500 in
regard to acquisition under notification dated 13.3.1981. These
amounts were certainly lower than the market value shown by
DEEPAK BISSYAN
2026.11.17 15:54
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment



RFA-670-2026 (O&M) & connected cases -20-
Ex.R3 to R7. Even in regard to the acquisition under
notification dated 13.12.1981, the award by the Collector at
Rs. 7,000/- and Rs. 9000/- were lower than the value disclosed
by Ex.R3 to R7. As noticed above, these sale deeds show that
the market value was around Rs. 9000 per bigha in February
to June 1981 and 10,000 to 11,000 per bigha between July,
1981 and November, 1981. The Land Acquisition Officer
awarded Rs. 10,840 (which is more than the price shown by
Ex.R3 to R7) in regard to only some lands acquired under the
December, 1981 acquisition. Be that as it may. As the sale
deeds (Ex.R3 to R7) relate to sales of lands in Rithala Village,
they cannot be excluded from consideration merely on the
ground that what has been awarded by the Land Acquisition
Collector was higher in regard to some of the acquired lands.
We accordingly find that the ground on which the High Court
excluded the sale deeds Ex.R3 to R7 is not sound. The question
whether these deeds (Ex.R3 to R7) should be excluded on any
other relevant ground will be considered later.”

25. In the light of above discussions and findings, this Court is of the
considered opinion that reliance upon previous awards either related to
notification dated 06.01.2006 (Lala Ram) or 14.11.2006 (Harphool) or
04.04.2007 (Ghisa Ram) is misconceived and cannot be appreciated. Market
price of the land in question needs to be determined as per available exemplar
sale deeds. The landowners have cited sale deeds Ex.P-7, P-8, P-9, P-10 and
P-11. Tabulated details thereof read as:
Sr.
No.
Ex. Vasika
No./date
Consideration
(₹)
Area Sold (K-M) Rate (₹/acres)

1. P-7 4480/
26.10.2005
1,50,00,000/- 9-12 (1.2 acres) 1,25,000/-
(2,583/- sq. yards)

2. P-8 5020/
25.11.2005
21,92,500/- 1-9 (875 sq. yards) 1,21,27,657/-
(2,506/- sq. yards)

3. P-9 8881/
18.03.2008
4,51,500/- 11.5 M (347 sq.
yard)
62,97,579/-
(1,301/- sq. yards)

4. P-10 245/
21,56,500/- 2-6 (1,391.5 sq.
yard)
75,00,870/-
(1,550/- sq. yards)

5. P-11 2445/ 7,81,74,375/- 24-2 (14,580.5 sq.
19.06.2007 yard about 3.01
acres)
15.04.2008
2,59,50,000/-
(5,362/- sq. yards)

DEEPAK BISSYAN
2026.11.17 15:54
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment



RFA-670-2026 (O&M) & connected cases -21-

26. Sale deeds Ex.P-7 & P-8 were executed in 2005 whereas
notification in question was issued in 2008, thus, it is not appropriate to rely
upon aforesaid sale deeds especially when sale deeds executed during March-
April’ 2008 are available. Ex.P-11 was executed on 19.06.2007. It comprises
24K-2M land. It could be best evidence, however, in the present case cannot
be relied upon because land comprised therein is situated at far away place
from the acquired land. The Reference Court has rightly rejected aforesaid
deed on the ground that land comprised therein is situated in Village
Khalilpuri and not Villages in question. During hearing, learned State
Counsel pointed out location of the aforesaid sale deed. This Court finds that
reliance cannot be placed upon Ex.P-11 because it is situated abutting the
highway and is far away from the acquired land.

27. Sale deeds Ex.P-9 & P-10 represent land very close to the
starting point of the acquired land. It is apt to mention here that acquisition
in question is a linear acquisition. Market value as per sale deed No.8881
dated 18.03.2008 (Ex.P-9) comes to ₹62,97,579/- per acre whereas as per sale
deed No.245 dated 15.04.2008 (Ex.P-10) comes to ₹75,00,870/- per acre.
Area as well as market value disclosed in Ex.P-10 is more than area and
market value disclosed in Ex.P-9, thus, it is appropriate to rely upon Ex.P-10.
Land comprised in aforesaid sale deed is small in comparison to total land
acquired. Further it is situated abutting the road. In such circumstances, it
would be just and fair to impose 15% cut. Applying 15% cut, the market

value of the acquired land would come to ₹ 63,75,739/- per acre. For the sake
of convenience, it is rounded off as ₹63,75,800/- per acre. It is apt to mention
here that this Court in Ghisa Ram (supra) and Rajinder Singh (supra) with
respect to land of Villages Gokalgarh and Kaluwas which are two of villages
DEEPAK BISSYAN
2026.11.17 15:54
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment



RFA-670-2026 (O&M) & connected cases -22-
in question has determined market value @ ₹48,93,240/- per acre. In Ghisa
Ram (supra) , Section 4 notification was issued in 2006 and in the present case
Section 4 notification was issued in 2008. If two years gap is considered,
market price would come almost close to ₹63,00,000/- per acre.

28. Present is a case of linear acquisition. Time and again, Courts
have held that uniform rate ought to be granted where there is linear
acquisition. The Reference Court has determined market value qua land of
village Chandawas @ ₹48,93,240/-. Village Gokalgarh is at one point of the
acquired land and Chandawas is at another point. Uniform market value of
the land in question @ ₹63,75,800/- per acre is hereby determined. Awards
passed by the Reference Court are hereby modified to the extent that uniform
market value for the land of villages in question is determined @ ₹63,75,800/-
per acre. The landowners shall be entitled to statutory benefits on the
enhanced value as per provisions of 1894 Act.
RFA-160-2022, RFA-537-2020, RFA-536-2020, RFA-534-2020, RFA-
2495-2021 and RFA-2436-2021

29. In afore-stated appeals, issue of severance charges has been
raised. In RFA-480-2026 the Reference Court has awarded severance charges
@ 20% of the market value of the acquired land. No severance charges have
been awarded in other cases.

30. The Reference Court has not recorded findings with respect to
severance charges in aforesaid appeals except RFA-480-2026 . The
landowners are claiming that acquisition bifurcated their land into two parts.
This Court is of the considered opinion that every landowner cannot claim
same amount of charges/damages. The landowners are claiming severance
charges. There is possibility that area bifurcated from the unacquired area is
so small that 30% of the amount of compensation or total compensation may
DEEPAK BISSYAN
2026.11.17 15:54
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment



RFA-670-2026 (O&M) & connected cases -23-
be more than total value of the bifurcated area. This may be understood with
an example. Landowner ‘X’ is having five acres land each and his four acres
land is acquired. Value of one acre land may be less than 30% of the enhanced
compensation or total compensation. If 30% of the compensation or enhanced
compensation is awarded, it would be apparently bad because it would be in
the public interest if bifurcated/unacquired one acre land is also acquired. The
Reference Court is further supposed to ascertain area owned and possessed
by the claimants, area vivisected from the unacquired area and area vivisected
from the acquired land, utilization of the land prior to the acquisition and post-
acquisition, change in the value of unacquired land on account of construction
of road because value of land many times increases on account of construction
of State/National Highway/bypass road.

31. It is not possible for this Court to examine each reference
application as well as evidence led by landowners in support of their claim
qua severance charges/damages. Therefore, matter is remanded to the
Reference Court with respect to severance charges. The Court shall consider
claim of only those landowners who had claimed severance charges in their
reference application and led evidence. No fresh evidence would be taken on
record and amount of severance charges/damages would be determined in the
light of observations made hereinabove.

32. Appeals/cross-objections of both sides are disposed of in above
terms.

33. Pending application(s), if any, stands disposed of.
(JAGMOHAN BANSAL)
November 16, 2026 JUDGE
Deepak DPA

Whether Speaking/reasoned Yes/No
Whether Reportable Yes/No
Date of Uploading:- 17.11.2026.
DEEPAK BISSYAN
2026.11.17 15:54
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment