Moshers vs Shri Mittal Agritech Pvt. Ltd.
- Court
- Madhya Pradesh High Court
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:23867
1 AC-56-2024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VINAY SARAF
ARBITRATION CASE No. 56 of 2024
MOSHERS
Versus
SHRI MITTAL AGRITECH PVT. LTD.
Appearance:
Mr. Shivansh Soni with Mr. Kanishka Gupta - Advocates for
petitioner.
Mr. Veer Kumar Jain - Senior Advocate with Mr. Sanjay P. Joshi -
Advocate for respondent.
Reserved on : 11/08/2026
Delivered on : 21/08/2026
ORDER
The subject application has been preferred by the petitioner under
Section 44 to 49 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereinafter
referred to as, 'Act of 1996') for enforcement of the foreign award dated
26/08/2022 passed by the sole Arbitrator J. Hawkins in Arbitration Case No.
18-634 of GAFTA.
2) The parties were directed by order dated 15/09/2025 to advance
their arguments on the question of enforceability of the award in question.
The parties advanced their arguments and thereafter, by order dated
08/05/2026 this Court decided the enforceability of the award and held that
the objection raised by the respondent against the enforcement of the arbitral
award are not acceptable and the award passed by the sole Arbitrator dated
26/08/2022 is enforceable as the decree of this Court. The Court fixed the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TEJPRAKASH
VYAS
Signing time: 2026-08-21
5:20:40 PM
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:23867
2 AC-56-2024
case for further consideration and proceedings for execution of the award.
3) The respondent raised an oral objection in respect of the execution
of the award that after deciding the enforceability of the award by an order
dated 08/05/2026 now by virtue of Section 49 of the Act of 1996 the award
has attained the status of deemed decree of this Court and is executable like
any other decree under the provisions of Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
(hereinafter for short referred to as, 'CPC'). The respondent raised the issue
that this Court is not having ordinary original civil jurisdiction, the decree is
required to be sent to the sub-ordinate Court for further execution. It is also
stated by the respondent that there is no machinery such
a s Nazarat Department for execution of the decree with this Court and
therefore, it is practically not possible for this Court to execute the decree.
4) The respondent submits that Section 38 of CPC provides that the
decree may be executed either by the Court which passed it, or by the Court
to which it is sent for execution. The learned Senior Counsel Mr. Veer
Kumar Jain appearing on behalf of the respondent submits that
the enforceability of the award has been decided by this Court by the order
dated 08/05/2026 and as per the provisions of Section 49 of the Act of 1996,
the award is executable as decree of this Court, therefore, this Court can sent
it for execution to the District Court or Commercial Court.
5) Learned Senior Counsel further relied on the provisions of Section
39(1)(d) and 39(2) of CPC and submits that these provisions empower this
Court to transfer the decree to any Court and it is not necessary that the
decree has to be executed by this Court itself, especially when this Court is
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TEJPRAKASH
VYAS
Signing time: 2026-08-21
5:20:40 PM
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:23867
3 AC-56-2024
not having any machinery required for execution under Order XXI of the
CPC. The learned Senior Counsel submits that once the foreign award is
declared enforceable, the provisions of CPC will be applicable for its
enforcement and the same may be sent to the competent District Court for
further execution.
6) Mr. Shivansh Soni, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioner submits that this Court while deciding the enforceability of the
foreign award dated 26/08/2022 vide order dated 08/05/2026 has also
considered the maintainability of composite application for enforcement and
execution of foreign award and after relying upon the judgments delivered
by the Supreme Court in the matter of Fuerst Day Lawson Ltd. vs. Jindal
Exports Ltd. reported in (2001) 6 SCC 356 and LMJ International Limited
vs. Sleepwell Industries Company Limited reported in (2019) 5 SCC 302 has
held that there is no need to take two separate proceedings, one for deciding
the enforceability of the foreign award and another for its execution and the
composite proceeding can be filed, but also makes it axiomatic that it is for
this Court to execute the foreign awards. The relevant portions of the order
dated 08/05/2026 are reproduced hereunder for the sake of convenience:
"16. The issue that whether a composite application for
enforceability of foreign arbitral award and its execution can be
filed and whether this Court can execute the award, once it is held
to be enforceable, despite not exercising ordinary original civil
jurisdiction.
.......................
16.4 In view of the above, it is clear that there is no need to
take separate proceedings : one for deciding the enforceability of
the foreign award another for its execution thereafter. These
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TEJPRAKASH
VYAS
Signing time: 2026-08-21
5:20:40 PM
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:23867
4 AC-56-2024
judgments of the Hon'ble Apex Court not only clarify the
composite proceeding can be filed but also makes it axiomatic
that it is for this Court to execute the foreign award.
16.5 Apart from above, Section 49 of the Act of 1996
provides that where the Court is satisfied that the foreign award is
enforceable, the award shall be deemed to be decree of that Court.
Further, as per Section 2(1)(e)(ii) of the Act in the case of
International Commercial Arbitration, the "Court" means the High
Court having jurisdiction to hear appeals from decrees of court
subordinate to it. As such, when Section 49 provides that the
award shall be deemed to be decree of 'that Court', the expression
'that Court' means the High Court. Thus, it is decree of the High
Court itself which is to be executed by the High Court in
accordance with the scheme of Sections 47, 48, and 49 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996."
7) The counsel further submits that under Part II of the Act of 1996,
which deals with enforcement of foreign award, pursuant to the amendment
in Section 47 the definition of "Court" means the "High Court" as set out in
the Explanation below Section 47 of the Act of 1996, which reads as under:
"Explanation.— In this section and all the following sections of
this Chapter, ‘‘Court’’ means the principal Civil Court of original
jurisdiction in a district, and includes the High Court in exercise of
its ordinary original civil jurisdiction, having jurisdiction over the
subject-matter of the award if the same had been the subject-
matter of a suit, but does not include any civil court of a grade
inferior to such principal Civil Court, or any Court of Small
Causes."
He further submits that the High Court is the competent Court to
enforce the foreign award irrespective to the fact that the High Court is not
having original civil jurisdiction.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TEJPRAKASH
VYAS
Signing time: 2026-08-21
5:20:40 PM
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:23867
5 AC-56-2024
8) The counsel for the petitioner relied on the judgment delivered by
the Supreme Court in the matter of Government of India v. Vedanta Ltd.
reported in 2020 10 SCC 1, wherein the Supreme Court has held that the
issue of enforceability and execution of the award should be decided in one
proceeding and once the enforceability of the award is decided, the same
Court may proceed to take further steps for execution of the award. Relevant
portion of the aforesaid judgment reads as under:
"82. A foreign award is not a decree by itself, which is
executable as such under Section 49 of the Act. The enforcement
of the foreign award takes place only after the court is satisfied
that the foreign award is enforceable under Chapter 1 in Part II of
the 1996 Act. After the stages of Sections 47 and 48 are
completed, the award becomes enforceable as a deemed decree, as
provided by Section 49. The phrase “that court” refers to the
Indian court which has adjudicated on the petition filed under
Section 47, and the application under Section 48. In contrast, the
procedure for enforcement of a foreign decree is not covered by
the 1996 Act, but is governed by the provisions of Section 44A
read with Section 13 of the CPC.
83.7 The award holder is entitled to apply for recognition and
enforcement of the foreign award by way of a common petition. In
Fuerst Day Lawson Ltd. v Jindal Exports Ltd.,[(2019) 11 SCC
620] this Court held that a proceeding seeking recognition and
enforcement of a foreign award has different stages : in the first
stage, the Court would decide about the enforceability of the
award having regard to the requirements of Sections 47 and 48 of
the 1996 Act. Once the enforceability of the foreign award is
decided, it would proceed to take further effective steps for the
execution of the award. The relevant extract from the judgment
reads as: (SCC pp. 371-72, para 31)
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TEJPRAKASH
VYAS
Signing time: 2026-08-21
5:20:40 PM
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:23867
6 AC-56-2024
“31. Prior to the enforcement of the Act, the Law of
Arbitration in this country was substantially contained in
three enactments namely (1) The Arbitration Act, 1940, (2)
The Arbitration (Protocol and Convention) Act, 1937 and (3)
The Foreign Awards (Recognition and Enforcement) Act,
1961. A party holding a foreign award was required to take
recourse to these enactments. Preamble of the Act makes it
abundantly clear that it aims at to consolidate and amend
Indian laws relating to domestic arbitration, international
commercial arbitration and enforcement of foreign arbitral
awards. The object of the Act is to minimize supervisory role
of court and to give speedy justice. In this view, the stage of
approaching court for making award a rule of court as
required in Arbitration Act, 1940 is dispensed with in the
present Act. If the argument of the respondent is accepted,
one of the objects of the Act will be frustrated and defeated.
Under the old Act, after making award and prior to
execution, there was a procedure for filing and making an
award a rule of court i.e. a decree. Since the object of the act
is to provide speedy and alternative solution of the dispute,
the same procedure cannot be insisted under the new Act
when it is advisedly eliminated. If separate proceedings are to
be taken, one for deciding the enforceability of a foreign
award and the other thereafter for execution, it would only
contribute to protracting the litigation and adding to the
sufferings of a litigant in terms of money, time and energy.
Avoiding such difficulties is one of the objects of the Act as
can be gathered from the scheme of the Act and particularly
looking to the provisions contained in Sections 46 to 49 in
relation to enforcement of foreign award. In para 40 of the
Thyssen Stahlunion GmbH Vs. SAIL [(1999) 9 SCC 334]
judgment already extracted above, it is stated that as a matter
of fact, there is not much difference between the provisions
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TEJPRAKASH
VYAS
Signing time: 2026-08-21
5:20:40 PM
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:23867
7 AC-56-2024
of the 1961 Act and the Act in the matter of enforcement of
foreign award. The only difference as found is that while
under the Foreign Award Act a decree follows, under the new
Act the foreign award is already stamped as the decree. Thus,
in our view, a party holding foreign award can apply for
enforcement of it but the court before taking further effective
steps for the execution of the award has to proceed in
accordance with Sections 47 to 49. In one proceeding there
may be different stages. In the first stage the Court may have
to decide about the enforceability of the award having regard
to the requirement of the said provisions. Once the court
decides that foreign award is enforceable, it can proceed to
take further effective steps for execution of the same. There
arises no question of making foreign award as a rule of
court/decree again. If the object and purpose can be served in
the same proceedings, in our view, there is no need to take
two separate proceedings resulting in multiplicity of
litigation. It is also clear from objectives contained in para 4
of the Statement of Objects and Reasons, Sections 47 to 49
and Scheme of the Act that every final arbitral award is to be
enforced as if it were a decree of the court. The submission
that the execution petition could not be permitted to convert
as an application under Section 47 is technical and is of no
consequence in the view we have taken. In our opinion, for
enforcement of foreign award there is no need to take
separate proceedings, one for deciding the enforceability of
the award to make rule of the court or decree and the other to
take up execution thereafter. In one proceeding, as already
stated above, the court enforcing a foreign award can deal
with the entire matter. Even otherwise, this procedure does
not prejudice a party in the light of what is stated in para 40
of the Thyssen [(1999) 9 SCC 334] judgment."
(emphasis supplied)
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TEJPRAKASH
VYAS
Signing time: 2026-08-21
5:20:40 PM
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:23867
8 AC-56-2024
83.9 The enforcement / execution petition is required to be
filed before the concerned High Court, as per the amendment to
Section 47 by Act 3 of 2016 (which came into force on
23.10.2015). The Explanation to Section 47 has been amended,
which now reads as:
“47. Evidence – (1)… (2)…
[Explanation.- In this section and in the sections following in
this Chapter, “Court” means the High Court having original
jurisdiction to decide the questions forming the subject
matter of the arbitral award if the same had been the subject-
matter of a suit on its original civil jurisdiction and in other
cases, in the High Court having jurisdiction to hear appeals
from decrees of courts subordinate to such High Court.”
(emphasis supplied)
83.15 If the Court is satisfied that the application under
Section 48 is without merit, and the foreign award is found to be
enforceable, then under Section 49, the award shall be deemed to
be a decree of “that Court”. The limited purpose of the legal
fiction is for the purpose of the enforcement of the foreign
award. The concerned High Court would then enforce the award
by taking recourse to the provisions of Order 21 of the CPC."
9) The counsel further relied upon the judgment delivered by the
Division Bench of the Gujarat High Court in the matter of M/s. OCI
Corporation Vs. Kandla Export Corporation & Others neutral citation 2016 :
GujHC : 44379 - DB, wherein the Division Bench of Gujarat High Court
dealing with a matter that whether the execution petitions filed before the
District Court could continue after the amendment to Section 47, considered
the legal provisions and directed that all the execution petitions pending
before the Courts / District Courts for enforcement of the foreign award are
required to be considered and dealt with by the "Court" mentioned in Section
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TEJPRAKASH
VYAS
Signing time: 2026-08-21
5:20:40 PM
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:23867
9 AC-56-2024
47 of the Act of 1996.
10) Pressing to the similar situation that Gujarat High Court has also
not having original civil jurisdiction, the Division Bench of Gujarat High
Court has held that the execution petitions for enforcement of the foreign
award are required to be considered, dealt with and disposed of by the
Commercial Division of the High Court or the concerned High Court, as the
case may be.
11) The counsel further relied on the judgment delivered by the
Telangana High Court in the matter of Keytrade AG Vs. Nagarjuna
Fertilizers & Chemicals Ltd. in Execution Petition No. 3/2017 and the
judgment of Rajasthan High Court in the matter of Emeraldstone
Management SIA Vs. Mamta Hygiene Products Pvt. Ltd. in Arbitration
Application No. 40/2020, wherein the Telangana High Court and Rajasthan
High Court have proceeded for enforcement of the foreign award as decree
of that Court.
12) The counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner further relied on
the order passed by the co-ordinate Bench in the matter of Cereales Y.
Servicios Agricolas de Burgs S.L. Vs. Sethi Agritech Pvt. Ltd. passed in
MCC No. 1834/2023, whereby the co-ordinate Bench has proceeded for
execution of the award by order dated 05/05/2025. He submits that as per the
provisions of Section 47 to 49, the Court in a case of foreign award is High
Court and therefore, only the High Court is empowered to enforce the award
as decree of this Court. He prays for overruling the objections raised by
counsel for the respondent.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TEJPRAKASH
VYAS
Signing time: 2026-08-21
5:20:40 PM
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:23867
10 AC-56-2024
13) Arguments raised by the counsel for the parties are considered and
perused the record.
14) The award in question was passed by the sole Arbitrator in
Arbitration Case No. 18-634 of GAFTA on 26/08/2022, which is a foreign
award, therefore, as per the provisions of Section 47 to 49 of the Act of
1996, whenever a foreign award is placed for enforcement, firstly, the Court
has to decide the enforceability of the foreign award as per the provisions of
Section 47 and 48 of the Act of 1996 and once the award is declared
enforceable by the competent Court, the award is enforceable as deemed
decree of that Court under Section 49 of the Act of 1996.
15) The petitioner / award holder has filed this petition under Section
44 to 49 of the Act of 1996 for enforcement of the award and the respondent
filed objection to the enforceability of the award, those were decided by this
Court vide order dated 08/05/2026 and award has been declared enforceable.
16) Part II of the Act of 1996 relates to enforcement of the foreign
award and Chapter I of Part II deals with New York Convention Awards.
The subject award is an award covered under the New York Convention
Awards and the award holder has applied to this Court for enforcement of
the award. Enforceability has already been decided and now this court has to
proceed further to execute the foreign award as a decree of this Court.
17) The Supreme Court in the matter of Fuerst Day Lawson Ltd.
(Supra) has held that a party holding a foreign award can apply for
enforcement of it, but the Court before taking further effective steps in the
execution of the award has to proceed in accordance with Section 47 to 49 of
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TEJPRAKASH
VYAS
Signing time: 2026-08-21
5:20:40 PM
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:23867
11 AC-56-2024
the Act of 1996. In one proceeding there may be different stages. In the first
stage, the Court may have to decide about the enforceability of the award
having regard to the requirement of the said provisions. Once the Court
decides that the foreign award is enforceable, it can proceed to take further
effective steps for execution of the same. There arises no question of making
foreign award a rule of Court / degree again and if the object and purpose can
be served in the same proceeding, in view of the Supreme Court, there is no
need to take two separate proceedings resulting in multiplicity of the
litigation.
18) The Supreme Court further observed that it is also clear from the
objectives contained in para 4 of the statement of the objects and reasons,
Section 47 to 49 and the scheme of the Act that every foreign arbitral award
is to be enforced as it if were a decree of Court.
19) The mere submission of the execution petition can be permitted to
convert as an application under Section 47 of the Act of 1996 for
enforcement of the foreign award and there is no need to take separate
proceedings, one for deciding the enforceability of the foreign award and
another to take execution thereafter. The foreign award is executable in one
proceeding.
20) Considering the law laid down in the matter of Fuerst Day Lawson
Ltd. (Supra), there cannot be other view except that the enforceability and
execution of the foreign award will be proceeded in one and same
proceeding. As the definition of "Court" in explanation to Section 47
provides that the High Court will be the competent Court for deciding the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TEJPRAKASH
VYAS
Signing time: 2026-08-21
5:20:40 PM
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-IND:23867
12 AC-56-2024
enforceability, the award is required to be executed by the High Court as the
decree passed by the High Court. Therefore, the oral objections raised by the
respondent are not tenable and are hereby rejected.
21) As the co-ordinate Bench of this Court has already proceeded to
execute the foreign award in the matter of Cereales Y. Servicios Agricolas de
Burgs S.L. (Supra), the subject award can also be executed by this Court in
the same manner.
22) So far as unavailability of the machinery is concerned, in case any
practical difficulty is faced by this Court in execution of the award, the
option of transfer the award / decree to any competent Court for further
execution will always available, but at this stage, this Court does not deem it
appropriate to issue transfer certificate under Section 39 of CPC.
23) Now award is required to execute under the provisions of Order
XXI of CPC, consequently office is directed to register this case as Misc.
Civil Case for the purpose of execution of award and list the matter for
further consideration before the roster bench. With the aforesaid proceedings
of Arbitration Case are closed.
(VINAY SARAF)
JUDGE
Tej
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TEJPRAKASH
VYAS
Signing time: 2026-08-21
5:20:40 PM