V S Lehra vs Delhi Jal Board, Govt. Of Nctd
- Court
- Central Administrative Tribunal
1
Item No. 36 - Court 3
Central Administrative Tribunal
Principal Bench
New Delhi
OA No. 3320/2016
th
This the 05 day of November, 2026
Hon’ble Mrs. Harvinder Kaur Oberoi, Member (J)
Hon’ble Dr. Sumeet Jerath, Member(A)
Sh. V.S.Lehra,
S/o Late Sh.Sohan Lal,
Aged 60 years,
R/o Type III, Quarter no;9, Jal Vihar Colony,
Lajpat Nagar, New Delhi and working as Head Clerk
in the Office of Executive Engineer (Central)-I, Delhi
Jal Board, near UGR & BPS, Ramila Ground, JLN,
Marg, New Delhi.
..Applicant(s)
(By Advocates: None)
Versus
1. Delhi Jal Board
through its Chief Executive Officer,
Govt. of N.C.T. ofDelhi,
Varunlaya, Phase-II,
Karol Bagh, New Delhi.
2. Assistant Commissioner (D)
Delhi Jal Board, Govt. ofN.C.T. of Delhi
Varunlaya ,Phase-II,
Karol Bagh ,New Delhi.
...Respondent(s)
(By Advocate: Mr. Kunal Anand, Ms. Aditi Rathore)
SOURJYA
SOBHANIYA
2
Item No. 36 - Court 3
O R D E R(Oral)
Hon’ble Mrs. Harvinder Kaur Oberoi, Member(J)
There is no representation on behalf of the applicant
today. On the last several occasions, the matter has
either been adjourned on the request of the applicant
or due to paucity of time.
2. In the circumstances, this matter is proceeded
with in accordance with Rule 16 of the CAT (Procedure)
Rules, 1987.
3. Learned counsel for the respondents submits that
the applicant is aggrieved of the order dated
26.02.2016 issued by the respondents rejecting his
request for antedating his promotion as Head Clerk
from 14.07.2010 to 13.11.2001.
4. The applicant has stated in the pleadings that he
had joined service on 07.07.1980 and was promoted as
LDC by order dated 23.10.1984 under the PH quota.
Thereafter, he was promoted as UDC on 28.02.1996.
His claim is that his junior, who was promoted as Head
Clerk under the PH quota by order dated 13.11.2001,
was given the benefit of such promotion, whereas he
was overlooked. He was subsequently promoted as
Head Clerk w.e.f. 14.07.2010. His case is that he ought
to have been considered for promotion under the PH
quota and promoted w.e.f. 13.11.2001 itself. He
submitted his representation on 28.12.2015 and the
same was rejected by the impugned order dated
26.02.2016.
5. The respondents, in their counter reply, have
disputed the very basis of the applicant's claim. It is
SOURJYA
SOBHANIYA
3
Item No. 36 - Court 3
submitted that the promotion order dated 23.10.1984
nowhere indicates that the applicant was promoted
against a PH category post. It is further submitted that
the applicant had not submitted any disability
certificate issued by the competent medical authority to
establish that he fulfilled the prescribed disability
criteria. The respondents have also clarified that the
applicant was promoted as UDC on 28.02.1996 under
the SC quota and was subsequently promoted as Head
Clerk on 14.07.2010, also against the SC quota. The
respondents have, therefore, denied that the applicant
was entitled to promotion under the PH quota.
6. The applicant's claim, as is evident from the
pleadings, emanates from the order dated 13.11.2001.
He submitted his representation only on 28.12.2015,
which was rejected by the respondents on 26.02.2016.
If the applicant was aggrieved that he should have been
promoted as Head Clerk in 2001, he could have
approached the Tribunal at that stage itself. Even
otherwise, when he was promoted in 2010, that was
the time to approach the respondents or the Tribunal.
However, he chose to remain silent for several years. A
representation submitted after such an inordinate
delay cannot revive a stale claim or give rise to a fresh
cause of action. The limitation prescribed under
Section 21(1) of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985
cannot be circumvented in this manner. The applicant
has also not made out any case for condonation of
delay under Section 21(3) of the said Act. We, therefore,
find that the claim is hopelessly barred by limitation.
SOURJYA
SOBHANIYA
4
Item No. 36 - Court 3
7. We also note that the present OA itself has been
filed after the applicant had retired on attaining the age
of 60 years. The applicant retired on 30.09.2016. As
such, this case seems nothing more than a luxury
litigation and an afterthought.
8. Even otherwise, the applicant has not been able to
establish, on the basis of the material placed before us,
that his promotion in 1984 was against a PH category
post or that he was entitled to the promotion claimed
w.e.f. 13.11.2001. The OA, therefore, does not merit
consideration.
9. Devoid of merit, this OA is dismissed. No costs.
(Dr. Sumeet Jerath) (Harvinder Kaur Oberoi)
Member(A) Member(J)
/ss/
SOURJYA
SOBHANIYA