KAL CABLES PVT. LTD vs WORLD VIEW (M.D. SHANMUGA SUNDARAM )
- Court
- Telecom Disputes Settlement and Appellate Tribunal
1
TELECOM DISPUTES SETTLEMENT & APPELLATE TRIBUNAL
NEW DELHI
rd
Dated 23 September 2026
Broadcasting Petition No. 251 of 2017
M/s Kal Cables Pvt. Ltd. …Petitioner
Vs.
Mr. M.D. Shanmuga Sundaram,
Proprietor
M/s World View …Respondent
BEFORE:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAM KRISHNA GAUTAM, MEMBER
For Petitioner : Mr. Ajay Kumar, Advocate
For Respondent : Mr. Sharath Sampath, Advocate
Ms. Kavya Singh, Advocate
Ms. Anushri Joshi, Advocate
JUDGMENT
1. The present Petition, under Section 14, read with Section 14A, of
the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997, (hereinafter
2
referred to as “TRAI Act”), has been filed, by Kal Cables Pvt. Ltd.-
Petitioner, against Mr. M.D. Shanmuga Sundaram, Proprietor, M/s.
World View, Chennai, Respondent, with a prayer for a decree, in the
tune of Rs. 14,05,392/- (Rupees Fourteen Lakhs Five Thousand
Three Hundred Ninety Two Only), on account of premature
delinking of the signals of the Petitioner Network with the
Respondent, within the period of 7 years, from the date of
Interconnect Agreement, dated 28.10.2015, along with interest
@18% per annum, with effect from 08.02.2017, till actual date of
payment, with a further prayer of a decree, directing the
Respondent to return the Set Top Boxes (STBs) 419 SD set top boxes,
and 12 HD set top boxes, to the Petitioner, along with their paired
viewing cards, remote control and AV cords, in good and working
condition, or alternatively to pay a sum of Rs. 6,64,500/- (Rupees Six
Lakhs Sixty-Four Thousand Five Hundred Only), against the cost of
those set top boxes, along with interest, @18% per annum, with
effect from 08.02.2017, till actual date of payment.
3
2. In brief, the Petition contends that the Petitioner is a Multi System
Operator (MSO), having its Office at No. 229, Kutchery Road,
Mylapore, Chennai-600004. It is a Company, incorporated under the
provisions of “The Companies Act, 1956”, and is a Multi System
Operator (MSO), as per definitions, envisaged in Regulation 2(s) of
The Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services)
Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems)
Regulations, 2012. Shri J. Rajesh is the authorised representative, as
being General Manager of the Petitioner Company, duly authorized
to file the present Petition, for and on behalf of Petitioner Company,
vide its Board Resolution, dated 31/03/2015, which is Annexure P-
2 to the Petition. The Respondent, Mr. M.D. Shanmuga Sundaram,
is a sole Proprietor of the proprietorship firm, M/s. World View,
situated at No. 34, Tamilnadu Housing Board Colony, Tambaram
Sanatorium, Chennai - 600047, who is a cable operator, LCO
involved in cable operator business, within the meaning and
definition, provided under Regulation 2(k) of the said
Interconnection Regulations of 2012, and distributing its signals to
4
the end consumers, within the parts of Chennai, specified in Para
4(b) of the Petition.
3. The Petitioner, MSO, is engaged in the business of distribution of
television channels in digital mode. The Petitioner and Respondent
entered into an Agreement, dated 28.10.2015, with two options
namely, (1) revenue sharing in accordance with the proportion
stipulated by the Tariff Order of the Authority (TRAI), or (2) special
revenue sharing arrangement, on mutually agreed basis, on an
assurance of a minimum lock-in period of 7 years, and this
Respondent adopted the second option. An addendum, was also
entered, in between, the parties on 28.10.2015, wherein
Respondent had agreed to pay a sum of Rs. 18,400/- per month, as
minimum guarantee fee, as fixed subscription amount for Set Top
Boxes up to 199 numbers. These monthly subscription charges were
fixed, on the date of entering into agreement for 199 STBs. As per
this Interconnection Agreement, the Petitioner is the absolute
owner and right holder for the Set Top Boxes and viewing cards
along with other accessories, and in case of termination of the
5
agreement, in between the parties, the Petitioner shall be entitled
to recover the Set Top Boxes, Viewing Cards, Remote controls and
accessories or to claim damages for the same, under agreement.
Besides this, the Petitioner was also entitled to recover charges/
damages for pre mature delinking or termination of agreement by
the Respondent, before the expiry of Lock-in period of 7 years’
terms, as per clauses 13.6 and 13.7 of the Interconnect Agreement,
executed, in between the parties.
4. The Respondent was using, 419 number of Standard Definition (SD)
Set Top Boxes and 12 number of High Definition (HD) Set Top Boxes,
along with its accessories, absolutely on free to use and “use and
return basis”. As per Interconnection Agreement, the Petitioner,
continuously and without any interruption, had provided the signals
to the Respondent, on the payment of agreed subscription charges
on the agreed terms, till June 2016, when Respondent without any
intimation to the Petitioner switched over to some other MSO,
without clearing the outstanding subscription charges and returning
6
the Set Top Boxes to the Petitioner, which he was bound to return
as per clause 13.6 of the Interconnect Agreement.
5. The Petitioner is entitled to recover the charges/compensations,
for premature delinking of services by Respondent, before the
expiry of 7 years lock-in term. Respondent migrated to other MSO,
without giving notice to that effect to the Petitioner, or making
clearance of dues, till the month of June 2016, for which a legal
notice, dated 08.02.2017, was given, with a direction to return all
the Set Top Boxes (419 SD Set Top Boxes and 12 HD Set Top Boxes),
or alternatively to make payment in the tune of Rs. 6,64,500/- in lieu
thereof, and also to pay a sum of Rs. 14,05,392/- towards
charges/compensations for premature delinking of the signals of
Petitioner MSO, within the Lock-in period of 7 years, from the date
of delinking, till the end of the term of Interconnect Agreement, as
per clause 13.7 of the Interconnect Agreement. This legal notice is
Annexure P-3 Colly to the Petition.
7
6. The legal notice, dated 08.02.2017, of the Petitioner, was replied by
Respondent, vide its reply dated, 15.02.2017, wherein the
Respondent denied the contents of the notice, dated 08.02.2017,
with a claim for the Set Top Boxes, to have been issued by the
Petitioner to the Respondent on outright purchase basis. The
number of Set Top Boxes were also disputed. The Respondent
further claimed that the copy of Interconnect Agreement was not
provided to the Respondent by the Petitioner. This reply of the
Respondent is Annexure P-4 (Colly) to the Petition .
7. The Respondent deliberately chosen not to return the Set Top Boxes
of the Petitioner, which otherwise was the property of the
Petitioner as per clause 13.6 of the Interconnect Agreement. Hence,
a cause of action, within the territorial jurisdiction of this Tribunal,
had arisen within the limitation period, and this Petition with above
prayer, was got filed by Petitioner.
8. The reply was with this contention, that the Respondent is with no
outstanding towards subscription amount of the Petitioner, nor has
8
the Petitioner claimed any amount towards subscription amount, in
the present Petition. Relationship between the parties was on the
basis of oral understanding, for the past many years, and as is the
practice in the DAS areas of Chennai, all Cable operators including,
Respondent herein, takes signals from the MSOs operating in that
area, hence, contention to move to other competitive MSO is
misconceived. It is the Petitioner, who had disconnected the signals
to the network of the Respondent, because Respondent started
demanding the copy of agreement, which had been signed by the
parties in year 2015, with a detailed Statement of Account of the
payments, made by Respondent to the Petitioner, as well as
invoices, which have till date, not been issued by the Petitioner on
Respondent, either on the basis of oral understanding, or the
written agreement, a copy of which had not been provided to the
Respondent, by the Petitioner. A continuous threat by Petitioner to
Respondent with regard to disconnection of signals, in case of non-
stopping of taking signals from other MSO, operating in the area was
given. Meaning thereby, for confining exclusively to the signals of
Petitioner only, was being pressed, and in case of failure, to face
9
discontinuation, was being repeatedly extended by Petitioner. The
alleged claim for lock-in period of 7 years in Interconnect
Agreement, dated 28.10.2015, is not maintainable because of being
against the mandate of competent authority, by virtue of
Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services)
Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems)
(Seventh Amendment) Regulations, 2016 (3 of 2016), dated
15.03.2016, which came in operation, with effect from 15.03.2016,
whereby it was made mandatory for all the MSOs and LCOs to enter
into a fresh agreement, on the basis of Model Interconnect
Agreement (MIA) or Standard Interconnect Agreement (SIA) and the
MSO was to bring the existing agreement, in line with the MIA or
the SIA, under Clause 13(B), or in the alternative, provide an option
to the LCOs, such as the Respondent herein, in writing to amend the
existing agreement in light of same, under Clause 13(A). But, no such
information/ option, as contemplated in the Interconnect
Regulations, in writing, has been received by the Respondent, till
date.
10
9. As per above Regulation, the period of Agreement can never be for
more than one year. The claim with regard to lock-in period of 7
years, is not maintainable at all. As per Interconnect Regulations,
said as above, the mandatory MIA or SIA provides the time to be of
one year for each agreement, as against alleged 7 years lock-in
period. Thus, the claim for cost or compensation or damages with
regard to lock-in period of 7 years, is not maintainable. Though no
basis for claiming an amount of Rs. 14,05,392/-, towards alleged
compensation charges, for pre-matured de-linking of signals, was
given in the pleading, nor there was any actual loss of damage to
Petitioner. A statutory period of 3 weeks is available to either side,
for getting the relationship terminated, by way of a written notice.
Hence, for remaining locking period, even for remaining of 1 year,
that can never be a claim for any damages or compensation, for
remaining period. Moreso, in present case, neither specific damages
has been pleaded, nor proved by Petitioner, which is contrary to
proposition of law, given under Indian Contract Act, 1872. Most of
the STBs were purchased outright by the Respondent, much prior to
the signing of the agreement, relied upon by the Petitioner, and the
11
remaining, were purchased thereafter, for which Respondent had
paid an amount of Rs. 600/- to Rs. 900/- per STB, towards outright
purchase of the same. There is no report of the activation of the
STBs, which may clearly prove, when the same were purchased by
the Respondent. The STBs issued more than three years back, as per
schedule provided by TRAI in its Telecommunication (Broadcasting
and Cable) Services (Fifth) (Digital Addressable Cable Television
System) Tariff Order, dated 27.05.2013, became the property of
subscribers and no claim for them can be made by Petitioner.
Hence, the prayer is for dismissing this Petition.
10. Replication cum Rejoinder, denying the contention of reply, and
reiterating Petition, has been filed with the same prayer of Petition.
11. On the basis of pleadings, following issues were framed by Court of
Registrar on 08.03.2018, in a bunch of cases, which were now de-
clubbed and taken up separately:
(1) Whether the petitioner is entitled for relief as claimed in
the petitions?
12
(2) Whether the Agreement between the parties is a valid
one?
(3) Whether the Agreement is in violation of the Interconnect
Regulations? If so, to what effect?
(4) Whether the petitioner is entitled to receive from the
respondents amounts and/or STBs as set out in the
petitions?
(5) Whether the petitioner is entitled to receive from the
respondents any amounts as compensation charges as set
out in the petitions?
(6) Whether the Petitioner is entitled to any interest on the
amounts so claimed or any other amount and if so, at
what rate?
12. Learned Counsel for Petitioner filed affidavit, by way of evidence of
Petitioner as of M. Natesan, and for Respondent affidavit of M. D.
Shanmuga Sundaram was on record.
13
13. Heard Learned Counsel for both side and gone through the material
placed on record.
14. Hon’ble Apex Court in Anil Rishi Vs. Gurbaksh Singh – AIR 2006 SC
1971 has propounded that onus to prove a fact is on the person who
asserts it. Under Section 102 of The Indian Evidence Act, initial onus
is always on the plaintiff to prove his case and if he discharges, the
onus shifts to defendant. It has further been propounded in
Premlata Vs. Arhant Kumar Jain- AIR 1976 SC 626 that where both
parties have already produced whatever evidence they had, the
question of burden of proof ceases to have any importance. But
while appreciating the question of burden of proof and misplacing
the burden of proof on a particular party and recording of findings
in a particular way will definitely vitiate the judgment. The old
principle propounded by Privy Council in Lakshman Vs.
Venkateswarloo – AIR 1949 PC 278 still holds good that burden of
proof on the pleadings never shifts, it always remains constant.
Factually proving of a case in his favour is cost upon plaintiff when
he fulfils, onus shifts over defendants to adduce rebutting evidence
14
to meet the case made out by plaintiff. Onus may again shift to
plaintiff. Hon’ble Apex Court in State of J & K Vs Hindustan Forest
Co. (2006) 12 SCC 198 has propounded that the plaintiff cannot
obviously take advantage of the weakness of defendant. The
plaintiff must stand upon evidence adduced by him. Though unlike
a criminal case, in civil cases there is no mandate for proving fact
beyond reasonable doubt, but even preponderance of probabilities
may serve as a good basis of decision, as was propounded in M
Krishnan Vs Vijay Singh- 2001 CrLJ 4705. Hon’ble Apex Court in
Raghvamma Vs. A Cherry Chamma – AIR 1964 SC 136 has
propounded that burden and onus of proof are two different things.
Burden of proof lies upon a person who has to prove the facts and
it never shifts. Onus of proof shifts. Such shifting of onus is a
continuous process in evaluation of evidence.
15. This Petition, before this Tribunal, is a civil proceeding and in civil
proceeding, the preponderance of probabilities, is the touchstone
for making a decision, as against strict burden of proof, required in
criminal proceeding.
15
16. Issue Nos. 2 and 3:
Both of these issues have been framed on the basis of reply filed by
Respondent, and in brief, the dispute is with regard to validity of
interconnect agreement, owing to legislative mandate of legislation,
which came in effect from 15.03.2016 i.e., the Telecommunication
(Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital
Addressable Cable Television Systems) (Seventh Amendment)
Regulations, 2016 (3 of 2016), dated 15.03.2016, wherein, a
mandate was for all MSOs and LCOs, to enter into a fresh
agreement, on the basis of the Model Interconnect Agreement
(MIA) or Standard Interconnect Agreement (SIA) under Clause 13 (B)
or in the alternative, provide an option to the LCO, in writing, to
amend the existing agreement in light of the same, under Clause 13
(A), and as per mandate of this legislation, the tenure and term of
interconnect agreement, was renewable after one year each.
Hence, the very contention of lock-in period of 07 years, is being
challenged on this basis. The pleadings of both side, specifically
admits the Interconnect Agreement, dated 28.10.2015 i.e.,
16
Annexure P-1 to Petition, entered, in between parties, on
28.10.2015. The terms and conditions are elaborated in it. The
Annexures are there. The only dispute in written submission, as well
as in reply, by Respondent, is that he admits signature over this
agreement. Contents are not being admitted. But, as per law laid
down repeatedly, that in a case of written document, if the
signatures are being admitted, execution is being admitted, then the
interpretation of this Agreement, will be in accordance with the
words written in it, in between, the lines. Hence, this agreement,
Annexure P-1 to Petition has been proved by Affidavit filed in
Evidence of PW-1 and it is with a very clear and unequivocal terms
and conditions written in it. Hence, this agreement is to be
interpreted as is written in it. The only challenge is with regard to
lock-in period of 07 years, whereas, this agreement was prior to
above date of operation of legislation on 15.03.2016. It was of
28.10.2015 wherein, the terms and conditions were enclosed,
signed and acted upon by the parties, entering into agreement.
17
th
17. The Black’s Law Dictionary, in its 9 Edition at Page No. 78,
categorically gives the meaning of ‘agreement’, that a mutual
understanding between two or more persons, about their related
rights and duties, regarding past or future performances; a
manifestation of mutual essence by two or more persons. Hence,
acknowledging the past performances and assuring for the future,
by mutual understanding, between two or more persons, are
‘agreement’. Even in the definition of ‘consideration’, given under
Indian Contract Act, it is very well there, that it may be a past
consideration too. Hence, in present undertaking i.e., agreement
Exhibit P-1, nothing illegal is there. Rather, it is a valid one
agreement.
18. By the operation of law, the period of one year has been prescribed
for Interconnect Agreement as per Standard Interconnect
Agreement or Model Interconnect Agreement. Hence, from the
operation of this law, the next renovation of any existing agreement
will be for that period of one year, and there is an option given for
re-entering into an Interconnect Agreement, in between, MSO and
18
LCO, by way of a notice in writing for executing the same. Hence,
merely by giving this provision, this agreement already executed, in
between, and acted upon, will not become invalid. Hence, this
agreement in question, Exhibit P-1, is a valid one and Issue No. 2 is
being decided, accordingly.
19. With regard to Issue No. 3 , the lock-in-period of 07 years, will cease
to come in effect, from the date of operation of above legislation
i.e., 15.03.2016, or the renewal or re-adjustment of agreement, on
the basis of mutual understanding, as per Model Interconnect
Agreement (MIA) or Standard Interconnect Agreement (SIA), by the
parties entered subsequently to date of this agreement, dated
28.10.2015. Hence, for one year i.e., upto period of 28.10.2016, this
agreement is a valid one. This Issue No. 3 is being decided in favour
of Petitioner.
20. Issue No. 4:
Specific pleading in Petition is of 419 SD set top boxes and 12 HD set
top boxes i.e., in all 431 set top boxes, alongwith its accessories said
19
to have been given to Respondent, in connection with the
Interconnect Agreement, proved and exhibited as Annexure P-1 to
Petition. Whereas, this factum has been disputed in reply. But, the
acknowledgement, having signature of both side, filed as at Page
No. 32 of the Petition, is with specific mention of 199 STBs in it. The
number of STBs elaborated at Page No. 29, 30 with
acknowledgment at Page No. 32, with specific heading ‘World View’
199 Active SMC Details (CC-0000941) dated 08.03.2015, are with
fact of issuance of 199 STBs with their acknowledgement by
Respondent. Hence, as against claimed 431 STBs, the proof is only
of 199 STBs. The other evidence is oath against oath, affidavit of
Petitioner, countered by affidavit of Respondent. But, the
Interconnect Agreement, claimed to be the basis of the Petition, is
with specific contention of those 199 STBs only, and the specific
provision under clause 7.5 (i) of this agreement), is of the ownership
of Petitioner over the Set Top Boxes and accessories, which were
bailed out to Respondent for installing at subscribers’ end. Sub-
Clause 7.5 (iii) specifically provides that these Set Top Boxes are
returnable property of the Petitioner and in case of any damage or
20
loss thereof, the Respondent will compensate the Petitioner, as and
when demanded by the Petitioner. The purchase was pleaded by
Respondent. But, no documentary proof regarding this is there on
record, and it was a burden casted upon Respondent to prove this
fact of purchase of those STBs. As these Set Top Boxes are
admittedly of more than 10 years back, having no worth at present,
and may not be returned in good and working condition to
Petitioner. Hence, the Petitioner is to be compensated for cost of
same. The admission with regard to purchase of same for a cost
ranging from Rs. 600 to Rs. 900 in the year 2012, has been made by
the Respondent in its reply filed in the Petition, and this is the best
piece of evidence. Meaning thereby, these STBs were of costing at
about Rs.1000/- each, on alleged execution of document
agreement, on 28.10.2015. Considering this admission and notional
depreciation, regarding the general wear and tear of STBs, till it is
not returned, till date of demand i.e., 08.02.2017, the cost per STB,
appeared to be of Rs. 1200/- per STB, alongwith all accessories
including Viewing Cards, Remote Controls and AV cord, as a proper
and genuine one. Hence, on the date of non-return of these 199
21
STBs, along with their accessories, the property worth Rs. 1200*199
= Rs. 2,38,800/-, (Rupees Two lakhs thirty eight thousand and eight
hundred only), was suffered by Petitioner, which are to be
compensated by Respondent. This issue is being decided
accordingly, in favour of Petitioner.
21. Issue No 5:
The lock-in period of seven years and de-linking before it, has been
made basis for claiming compensation in tune of Rs. 14,05,392/-
(Rupees Fourteen Lakhs Five Thousand Three Hundred Ninety Two
Only) , but as per admitted legal proposition, the Interconnection
Agreement came in existence on 28.10.2015. Whereas,
Interconnect Regulations propounded by a competent authority,
came in effect from 15.03.2016 mandating parties to enter into
standard MIA and SIA, form of agreement, for a period of one year,
with subsequent renewal option. The Learned Counsel for
Petitioner, while making arguments, clearly and fairly admitted this
proposition, and said that for one year, the renewal ought to be
made from 15.03.2016, the day when this new Regulation came in
22
effect, and this migration to another competitive MSO, by
Respondent was said to be in the month of June, 2016. Hence, this
new regulation, came in operation from 15.03.2016, and the
migration said to be there was from June, 2016 i.e., this was
apparently in view of non-compliance and non-entering of MIA or
SIA agreement. Hence, there is no loss or compensation or damage
to Petitioner, nor it got proved. Hence, this Issue No. 5 is being
decided against the Petitioner.
22. Issue Nos. 1 and 6:
These issues are one and common. The interest rate claimed is of
18% per annum. Whereas, this Tribunal in repeated judgments,
considering the fiscal scenario and the hard period of cable workers,
had awarded simple interest @ 9 % per annum, in previously
decided petitions, and the same seems to be reasonable and just
rate of interest over above amount. But the same is to be given from
the date of notice, when cause of action had arisen till the actual
date of payment, over above amount. Accordingly, these issues are
being decided in favour of Petitioner.
23
ORDER
Petition is being allowed. Respondent is being ordered to
make deposit in the Tribunal, within two months of judgment, Rs.
2,38,800/- (Rs. 1200*199) (Rupees Two Lakhs Thirty Eight Thousand
Eight Hundred Only) towards cost of 199 STBs, alongwith all
accessories, including Viewing Cards, Remote Controls and AV cord,
etc., till 08.02.2017, the date of demand notice, with a Simple
Interest @ 9% p.a, over above amount from 08.02.2017 to actual
date of payment, for making payment to the Petitioner, failing
which, the same shall be realized by due process.
Formal order / decree be got prepared by office, accordingly.
….......………………
(Justice Ram Krishna Gautam)
Member
23.09.2026
/NC/