Sri Ramdayal Thakur vs Sri Rameswar Thakur And 2 Ors

Court
Gauhati High Court

Page No.# 1/6
GAHC010210942015

2026:GAU-AS:17198
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : RSA/76/2015
ON THE DEATH OF SOLE APPELANT (SRI RAMDAYAL THAKUR) , HIS
LEGAL HEIRS
Represented By-
1.1: SRI BABAN THAKUR
S/O LATE RAMDAYAL THAKUR
R/O EAST MILAN NAGAR
C.R. BUILDING
P.O.DIBRUGARH
PS DIBRUGARH DIST. DIBRUGARH
ASSAM- 78600
VERSUS
SRI RAMESWAR THAKUR and 2 ORS
2:PANNALAL THAKUR
BOTH S/O RAM IQBAL THAKUR
3:SMTI DIWANTI THAKUR
W/O SRI PANNA LAL THAKUR
ALL ARE R/O HOUSING COLONY
EAST MILAN NAGAR
P.O. C.R. BUILDING
DIBRUGARH
DIST. DIBRUGARH
ASSAM
Advocate for the Petitioner : MR.H RAHMAN, MS.S SULTANA,MS.J
HUDA,MD.ASLAM,MS.B SARMA,MR.G N SAHEWALLA,MR.A CHETIA,MR.P DEKA,MS.P
BURAGOHAIN

Page No.# 2/6
Advocate for the Respondent : , MSN KALITA(R-1 to 3),MR.A BHATTACHARJEE(R-1 to
3),,MR.M NATH(R-1 to 3),,,MR.S S DEY(R-1 to 3),
Linked Case : I.A.(Civil)/4314/2017
SRI RAMDAYAL THAKUR
VERSUS
SRI RAMESWAR THAKUR and 2 ORS
------------
Advocate for : MD.ASLAM
Advocate for : MR.S S DEY appearing for SRI RAMESWAR THAKUR and 2 ORS
Linked Case : I.A./794/2015
SRI RAMDAYAL THAKUR
VERSUS
SRI RAMESWAR THAKUR and 2 ORS
------------
Advocate for : MS.J HUDA
Advocate for : appearing for SRI RAMESWAR THAKUR and 2 ORS

Page No.# 3/6
:: BEFORE ::
(HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE PARTHIVJYOTI SAIKIA)

Senior Advocate(s) for the Appellants : Mr. G.N. Sahewalla.
Advocate(s) for the Appellants : Ms. K. Bhattacharyya.

Senior Advocate(s) for the Respondents: Mr. M. Nath.
Advocate(s) for the Respondents : Mr. Mausam Nth.


Date on which judgment is reserved: 10.11.2026.
Date of pronouncement of judgment: 20.11.2026.
Whether the pronouncement is of the
operative part of the judgment? : YES.
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced? : YES.

JUDGMENT AND ORDER (CAV)
Heard Mr. G.N. Sahewalla, learned senior counsel assisted by Ms. K. Bhattacharyya, the
learned counsel appearing for the appellants. Also heard Mr. M. Nath, learned senior counsel assisted
by Mr. Mausam Nath, the learned counsel representing the respondents.

2. This is a Regular Second Appeal under Section 100 of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC) whereby
the judgment dated 12.09.2014 passed by the learned Civil Judge, Dibrugarh in Title Appeal
No.47/2011 affirming the judgment and decree dated 29.09.2011 passed by the learned Munsiff No.1,
Dibrugarh in Title Suit No.45/2006 is under challenge.
3. Late Ramdayal Thakur was the owner and occupier of a plot of land measuring 1 Katha –
296/144 under Dag No.154(Old) and 286(New) covered by T.P.P. No.1(Old) and 2(New) situated at
Mancotta Khanikar, Dibrugarh. He had purchased the land on execution of Sale Deed No.1000 and Sl.
No.146 of 1978.
4. After taking over possession of the land, late Ramdayal Thakur had constructed a kutcha house
over the land and started to live there with his family.
5. The respondents Rameswar Thakur and Pannalal Thakur are the sons of a brother of late

Page No.# 4/6
Ramdayal Thakur. Similarly, respondents Smti. Diwanti Thakur is the wife of Pannalal Thakur.
6. Originally, the respondents used to stay outside the State of Assam and in search of livelihood,
they came to Dibrugarh. They did not have any place to stay at Dibrugarh. Late Ramdayal Thakur
allowed them to live in his houses.
7. The house where the respondents started to live had three kutcha rooms. The house was given to
the respondents on a condition that whenever they will arrange a suitable accommodation for
themselves, they will have to vacate the house.
8. When late Ramdayal Thakur had filed the suit, the respondents had already spent four years in the
house given to them.
9. Late Ramdayal Thakur had alleged that the respondents had tried to alter the structure of the
house without his consent.
10. Narrating the aforesaid facts, late Ramdayal Thakur had filed the suit praying for declaration of
his right, title and interest over the said land and for evicting the respondents therefrom.
11. The respondents contested the case by filing the written statement and counter claim. They have
claimed that late Ramdayal Thakur and their father Ram Ekbal Thakur came to Dibrugarh from Bihar
at the same time. They have claimed that the house they reside was constructed by their father.
12. The respondents further claimed that taking advantage of the Sale Deed No.1000, late Ramdayal
Thakur wanted to sale the entire plot of land and at that time, Pannalal Thakur agreed to purchase the
land and paid a sum of ₹1,80,000/- to late Ramdayal Thakur. Late Ramdayal Thakur also agreed to
execute the sale deed in favour of Pannalal Thakur. But he did not.
13. The respondents prayed for a decree of specific performance of contract and for execution of a
sale deed in favour of Pannalal Thakur. They also prayed for decree evicting late Ramdayal Thakur
from the said land.
14. Late Ramdayal Thakur filed his written statement against the counter-claim. He denied all the
claims of the respondents.
15. On the basis of the pleadings, the trial court framed the following issues:
i. Whether there is any cause of action in the suit?
ii. Whether the plaintiff and the father of the defendants belong to Hindu Joint Family?
iii. Whether the suit premises was/is a part of the joint family property in between the
plaintiff and the father of the defendants?
iv. Whether the plaintiff has any right, title and interest over the suit premise?
v. Whether the defendants were/are tenants under the plaintiff?
vi. Whether the plaintiff and the defendant no.2 entered into any agreement to sell and
to purchase the suit land mentioned in the counter claim?
vii. Whether the defendant no.2 is entitled to get a decree for specific performance of
contract in respect of the suit land mentioned in the counter-claim?
viii. Whether the parties are entitled to any other relief/s as prayed for?
16. During the hearing, late Ramdayal Thakur examined three witnesses and the respondents also
examined three witnesses.

Page No.# 5/6
17. On the basis of the evidence on record, the trial court decreed the suit of late Ramdayal Thakur.
The trial court held that late Ramdayal Thakur had right, title and interest over the suit land and till he
executes a registered sale deed in favour of respondent Pannalal Thakur. The trial court further held that
after registration of the said sale deed, late Ramdayal Thakur shall have to be evicted from the said
land. Late Ramdayal Thakur was directed by the trial court to execute the sale deed in favour of
respondent Pannalal Thakur.
18. The respondents preferred an appeal and the appellate court, after hearing both sides, dismissed
the appeal.
19. Aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment, the present regular second has been filed by the legal heirs
of late Ramdayal Thakur for hearing the substantial question of law– whether the findings and
conclusions recorded by the learned court below as regards Issue Nos.1 and 6 as perverse in the eye of
law?
20. I have given my anxious considerations made by the learned counsels of both sides.
21. Whether there is a cause of action in the suit and whether the plaintiff and the defendant no.2
entered into any agreement to sale and purchase the suit land mentioned in the counter claim, are both
issues of facts.
22. So far as concurrent findings are concerned, inn G. Mahalingappa v. G.M. Savitha , (2005) 6 SCC
441, the Supreme Court has held as under:
“25. Let us now consider whether the concurrent findings of fact could be set aside by the High
Court in the second appeal. It is well settled by diverse decisions of this Court that the High
Court in the second appeal is entitled to interfere with the concurrent findings of fact if the said
concurrent findings of fact are based on non-consideration of an important piece of evidence in
the nature of admission of one of the party to the suit, which is overlooked by the two courts
below. (See Deva v. Sajjan Kumar [(2003) 7 SCC 481] .) It is equally well settled that under
Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the High Court cannot interfere with the concurrent
findings of facts of the courts below without insufficient and just reasons. (See Sayeda
Akhtar v. Abdul Ahad [(2003) 7 SCC 52] .) In the second appeal, the High Court is also not
entitled to set aside the concurrent findings of fact by giving its own findings contrary to the
evidence on record. (See Saraswathi v. S. Ganapathy [(2001) 4 SCC 694] .).”

23. It is a settled position of law that the High Court in the second appeal is entitled to interfere with
the concurrent findings of fact if the said concurrent findings of fact are based on non-consideration of
an important piece of evidence in the nature of admission of one of the party to the suit, which is
overlooked by the two courts below. The High Court is also not entitled to set aside the concurrent
findings of fact by giving its own findings contrary to the evidence on record.
24. This Court is of the opinion that the so-called substantial question of law is a question of fact
only. Being a second appellate court, this court is not entitled to reappreciate the evidence on record.
25. Under the aforesaid circumstances, this Court is of the opinion that this appeal is devoid of merit
and is accordingly dismissed. The connected Interlocutory Applications are also disposed of.

Page No.# 6/6
The trial court records shall be returned.

JUDGE
Comparing Assistant