Sunisha Anand vs State Of Haryana

Court
Supreme Court

Non-Reportable
2026 INSC 494


IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.2457 OF 2026


Sunisha Anand
...Appellant

Versus

State of Haryana & Anr.

...Respondents

O R D E R

The above appeal is filed by one of the applicants before the
High Court seeking interference to FIR No.588 dated 02.06.2018,
registered at the Police Station, Faridabad Central. The impugned
common order in two petitions declined relief holding that though
the dispute primarily pertains to land and a civil suit has already
been filed there are criminal elements, which cannot be ignored
since the accused persons are alleged to have knowingly
prepared and executed forged General Power of Attorneys
(GPAs), despite being aware that a portion of the land in question
have been transferred to the State of Uttar Pradesh.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
Deepak Guglani
Date: 2026.05.15
17:54:57 IST
Reason:
Page 1 of 4
Crl. A. No.2457 of 2026

2. Sri Siddharth Luthra, learned Senior Counsel pointed out
that in the First FIR though the name of the appellant herein is
mentioned she was no arrayed as an accused. By a
supplementary FIR, the appellant has been arrayed, though there
is no material seen to have been unearthed on the further
investigation after the first FIR. The decision in Mariam
1
Fasihuddin & Anr. v. State by Adugodi Police Station & Anr. is
relied on, wherein submission of supplementary report in the
absence of new evidence was frowned upon.
3. Sri Abhinav Bajaj, learned Additional Attorney General for
the respondent-State argues that there is no reason to quash the
FIR and the appellant has been arrayed subsequently by reason
of the details revealed on investigation. The first FIR was
registered and in the course of the investigation, the appellant’s
role was also disclosed and hence she was arrayed as an accused.
4. The allegation as seen from the first FIR is that the appellant
is the daughter of one Onkar Singh and Mohinder Kaur, who are
title holders to certain properties. Onkar Singh having died, the
appellant also obtained right over the said property by way of

1
(2024) 11 SCC 733
Page 2 of 4
Crl. A. No.2457 of 2026

succession. It is the allegation that the mother of the appellant got
fake GPAs executed and registered on the strength of which lands
were transferred to the accused Pratap Singh and Prem Pal, who
entered into further conveyances with respect to the same
properties. It was also alleged that the appellant and her mother
did not have title over the entire properties, the title to a portion
of which having been divested by transfer to the Government. In
the first FIR, the first information statement refers to the appellant,
but the appellant was not made one of the accused. In the second
FIR produced as Annexure P10 the very same allegations are
levelled and there is nothing unearthed to find the culpability of
the appellant herein but for a reference to a jamabandi having
been referred to in the document, which in fact does not exist.
5. As we see from the records, the de-facto complainant, the
second respondent is said to be in possession of certain lands,
which was the subject matter of the transaction alleged. The
appellant along with her mother is said to have executed a GPA
on the strength of which and by a separate sale deed having
conveyed certain properties to the accused. We are unable to
comprehend how the GPA can be termed as fake or fraudulent,
when the very contention is that the GPAs were executed by the
Page 3 of 4
Crl. A. No.2457 of 2026

mother and daughter. Further the jamabandi having been noticed
in the sale deed or the vendors having conveyed more property
than they had title over cannot lead to any criminal liability as
such; which if at all alleged, should be by the purchasers. Here,
a person alleged to be in occupation of a land has filed the
complaint and we are unable to find any reason on facts as
disclosed from the FIR to even allege any criminality on the
appellant herein. Admittedly, there is a civil suit pending as
initiated by the de-facto complainant. Criminal law cannot be
used to further the cause in a purely civil dispute.

6. We, hence, quash FIR No.588 dated 02.06.2018, Annexure
P10, registered at Faridabad Central Police Station, insofar, the
appellant herein is concerned.
7. The above appeal is allowed.
8. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.


……...…….……………………. J.
(SANJAY KUMAR)


...………….……………………. J.
(K. VINOD CHANDRAN)
NEW DELHI;
May 11, 2026.
Page 4 of 4
Crl. A. No.2457 of 2026