C. ANAND vs STATE OF KARNATAKA

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62385-DB
CRL.A No. 1504 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010365572023




IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

TH
DATED THIS THE 11 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026


PRESENT

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ

AND

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B.PRAMOD

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1504 OF 2023 (C)

BETWEEN:

C. ANAND
S/O CHIKKA MUNIYAPPA
AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS,
R/AT KEMPUDOMMASANDRA VILLAGE,
ANEKAL TALUK,
BENGALURU DISTRICT
PIN.562106.
…APPELLANT







(BY SRI. RAJASHEKARA R V., ADVOCATE)

AND:

STATE OF KARNATAKA
BY ANEKAL POLICE STATION,
REPRESENTED BY
THE STATE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
HIGH COURT BUILDING
BANGLAORE-560001.
…RESPONDENT

Digitally signed
by
SHARADAVANI
B
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA

(BY SRI. VIJAYA KUMAR MAJAGE, SPP-II A/W;
SRI. SUDHINDRA B.S., HCGP)

THIS CRL.A IS FILED U/S.374(2) CR.P.C PRAYING TO SET
ASIDE THE JUDGMENT OF CONVICT AND ORDER SENTENCE

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62385-DB
CRL.A No. 1504 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010365572023


DATED 02.09.2021 PASSED BY THE III ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
AND SESSIONS JUDGE, BENGALURU RURAL DISTRICT, SIT AT
ANEKAL IN S.C.NO.5021/2017, FOR THE OFFENCE P/U/S 302
OF IPC AND ETC.,
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR FURTHER HEARING, THIS
DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ
and
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B.PRAMOD

ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ)

This appeal is preferred challenging the judgment
and order of conviction and sentence passed against the
accused/appellant for the offence punishable under
Section 302 IPC.

2. The trial Court vide its judgment of conviction
and order on sentence dated 02.09.2021 convicted the
accused for the offence punishable under Section 302 of
IPC and sentenced him to undergo rigorous imprisonment
for life and to pay a fine of Rs.50,000/-, in default to pay

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62385-DB
CRL.A No. 1504 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010365572023


the fine amount, to undergo further imprisonment for 6
months.

3. It is the case of the prosecution that about 4-5
years prior, deceased Prakash had stolen a mobile phone
from the house of the accused. He had refused to admit
that he had committed the theft of the mobile phone.
Once under the influence of alcohol, the deceased had told
the accused that he had taken his mobile phone and also
assaulted him and his mother. On 02.08.2016, accused
and the deceased had been to one Shubha Bar situated at
Anekal, to consume alcohol. A quarrel took place between
them and in the said quarrel, the deceased had threatened
the accused with dire consequences. Hence, the accused
was grinding an axe against the deceased. On that day,
i.e., on 02.08.2016 at about 11.00 p.m., when the
deceased had arrived near his house, the accused
assaulted him on his hand with a chopper. PW.5 and PW.6
pacified the quarrel and snatched the chopper from the
hands of the accused. On 03.08.2016, the accused left to

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62385-DB
CRL.A No. 1504 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010365572023


Mathura Nagara situated at Varthur Village to the house of
CW.23, apprehending danger from the deceased and
stayed there till 06.08.2016. On 07.08.2016, he returned
to Kempudommasandra Village and at about 07.00 p.m.,
with an intention to commit the murder, sprinkled chili
powder on the face of the deceased and assaulted on his
head, hands, etc., with a long. When the deceased
attempted to snatch the weapon from his hands, the
accused sustained injuries to his left hand. The accused by
assaulting the deceased on his head, hands, face, etc.,
committed his murder.

4. Ex.P1 is the complaint lodged by the brother of
the deceased, Kumara examined as PW.1. The contents of
Ex.P1 would reveal that the complainant-PW.1 is not an
eyewitness to the incident. As per the complaint
averments, on 07.08.2016 at about 07.15 p.m., when the
complainant was in his house, his grandmother by name
Munithayamma came weeping and informed him that the
accused-Anand, living in the opposite house, as well as 4

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62385-DB
CRL.A No. 1504 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010365572023


others barged into the house and assaulted the deceased
with the chopper. Immediately, the complainant went to
the spot and saw his brother lying dead and the accused
standing beside him. The accused abused and threatened
him and tried to assault the complainant with the chopper,
however, he escaped and went to the house of his
brother-in-law by name Ashwath. After some time, he
returned to the spot and enquired with his grandmother,
who informed him that when the deceased Prakash
returned to the house and, while he was entering the
house, after parking his vehicle, the accused Anand and
four others came inside the house and assaulted him.

5. In Ex.P1, the complainant has narrated the
motive for the incident. He has stated that on 02.08.2016
at about 11.20 p.m., he heard some quarrelling noise and
therefore he came near the house of his brother Prakash.
At that time, his brother was abusing the accused. When
he enquired with his brother, he told him about the quarrel
which had taken place in the evening in one Shubha Bar,

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62385-DB
CRL.A No. 1504 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010365572023


wherein the accused had taken away his bike key and
thereafter when he returned to the house, the accused
tried to assault him with a chopper on his head and in the
process, he sustained injuries to his right hand and left
index finger.

6. As per the complaint averments, the immediate
motive for the accused to commit the murder was an
incident which took place on 02.08.2016 at one Shubha
Bar and the subsequent incident, where in the accused
had assaulted the deceased and caused injuries to his
right hand and left forefinger.

7. As already noted, PW.1- the complainant, the
brother of the deceased is not an eyewitness to the
incident. In his evidence, he has deposed that, by the
time he reached the spot, his brother was already dead.
He has stated that prior to lodging of the complaint; the
police had already visited the spot. Further stated that

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62385-DB
CRL.A No. 1504 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010365572023


even the accused had sustained injuries but he was not
aware as to how he suffered those injuries.

8. As per prosecution, the grandmother of the
deceased is an eyewitness to the incident. In Ex.P1 it is
stated that she informed the complainant that the
accused- Anand along with 4 others entered the house and
assaulted the deceased with a chopper. She is examined
as PW.2, before the trial court.

9. PW.2 in her evidence has deposed that their
house is situated opposite to the house of the accused.
She has deposed regarding the incident of quarrel which
took place in the bar wherein, the accused had assaulted
Prakash with a chopper on his head and hands. Regarding
the incident in question, she has stated that at about
07.00 p.m., the deceased came near the house and at that
time, the accused held him and assaulted on his head with
a chopper and as she was scared, could not do anything.
She has further stated that the accused sustained injuries

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62385-DB
CRL.A No. 1504 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010365572023


to his hand while the deceased tried to snatch away the
chopper from him.

10. The evidence of PW.3 reveals that he came to
the spot, along with CW.3 (PW.4), on hearing the hue and
cry of the people. By the time he reached the spot, the
incident was already over. However, he has stated that
when they went to the spot, they saw the accused holding
a knife in his hand. PW.4 has also testified in his chief-
examination that by the time he went to the spot, Prakash
was dead. He has stated that the accused was present at
the spot and he had sustained injuries. He has further
stated that he saw 4 other boys running away from the
spot. However, he has stated that the accused was not
holding any weapon, contrary to the evidence of PW.3. He
has further stated that when he tried to lift the deceased,
his clothes were stained with blood and the said clothes
were seized by the police under a panchanama-Ex.P2.
PW.4 was treated hostile by the prosecution. He denied

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62385-DB
CRL.A No. 1504 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010365572023


the suggestion that he had seen the accused assaulting
the deceased with a chopper.

11. Another witness examined by the prosecution to
establish the charge is PW.7-Smt. Venkatalakshmamma.
She has been treated hostile by the prosecution. According
to the prosecution, she had seen the accused armed with a
blood-stained weapon. She is not an eyewitness to the
incident.

12. The cause of death is not seriously disputed. As
per the PM report-Ex.P13, the cause of death is
haemorrhage and shock as a result of injuries sustained.
The deceased had sustained several injuries and the
doctor-PW.16, who conducted the post mortem
examination has testified to the effect that the injuries
sustained by the deceased were the cause for his death.
He has also given his opinion regarding the weapon- MO.1
as per Ex.P15 that, the injuries noticed in the PM report

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62385-DB
CRL.A No. 1504 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010365572023


could be possible if the person is assaulted with the said
weapon.

13. Insofar as the opinion furnished by the doctor
as per Ex.P14 is concerned, it is contended by the learned
counsel for the appellant that in the deposition of PW.16,
he has stated that an iron rod was sent to him for
examination, whereas the weapon is an iron long. He
further contended that PW.3 has referred the weapon as a
knife and the said discrepancies with regard to the weapon
casts a serious doubt on the credibility of the prosecution
case.

14. The trial Court while appreciating the above
discrepancies pointed out by the defence, has observed
that ‘on perusal of Ex.P15, it is found that PW.16 has
examined a long and therefore it can be said that by
oversight, PW.16 might have deposed the weapon as an
iron rod in place of iron long’ and further opined that
‘there is a possibility that while dictating the’

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62385-DB
CRL.A No. 1504 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010365572023


order/judgment, there must be a typographical error. It
has further observed that ‘common people would refer to
the weapons with different names and to his
understanding, PW.3, during the course of his
examination-in-chief has identified the weapon. Therefore
merely because PW.3 called the weapon as knife, his
otherwise reliable evidence cannot be discarded’.

15. We have perused Ex.P15, the opinion furnished
by the doctor (PW.16) regarding the weapon. The said
document clearly shows that PW.16 had examined an iron
long and furnished his opinion stating that the injuries
sustained by the deceased are possible if assaulted with
the said weapon.

16. It is nobody's case that the accused assaulted
the deceased with an iron rod. The descrepancy pointed
out by the defense will not dent the prosecution case, in
so far as use of weapon.

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62385-DB
CRL.A No. 1504 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010365572023



17. In the case on hand, admittedly, the accused
has also sustained injuries in the very same incident. The
eyewitness i.e. PW.2 in her deposition has tried to explain
those injuries, stating that the while the deceased tried to
snatch the weapon, accused sustained those injuries.
Even the evidence of PW.3 and PW.4 reveal that the
accused had sustained injuries to his hand. In the
complaint-Ex.P1, it is stated that at the time of incident,
accused sustained injuries. However, it is not stated as to
how he sustained those injuries. It is not stated that the
accused sustained the injuries to his hand when the
deceased attempted to snatch the weapon from his hands.

18. PW15 is the Police Constable, who immediately
visited the spot, on receiving the information regarding the
incident. He has deposed that when he went to the spot,
the public had nabbed the accused and at that time he
noticed that the accused had sustained injuries to his hand
and he was holding a long. He has stated that from the
people who had gathered, he came to know that when the

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62385-DB
CRL.A No. 1504 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010365572023


deceased tried to snatch the chopper from the hands of
the accused, he sustained injuries.

19. As already noted, in Ex.P1 it is not stated as to
how the accused sustained injuries to his hand. According
to PW15, who went to the spot immediately upon receiving
the information about the incident, he came to know from
the public that the accused had sustained injuries, when
the deceased tried to snatch the chopper from his hand.
However, he has not stated as to who informed the same
to him. PW1 in his deposition has stated as to how the
accused sustained injuries to him. According to him, when
the deceased tried to snatch the weapon, the accused
sustained the injuries.

20. The prosecution has examined PW17, the
doctor who treated the accused. She has deposed that on
07.08.2016, the accused was brought to the hospital by
one Suresh, Head Constable of Anekal Police Station. The
accused gave the history that he was assaulted by Prakash

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62385-DB
CRL.A No. 1504 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010365572023


(deceased) with a chopper. Copy of the MLC register is
marked as Ex.P16. The same goes to show that the
accused was brought to the hospital for treatment, by the
Head Constable, Suresh of Anekal Police Station with a
history of assault by Prakash (known person) i.e., the
deceased, with sickle (Machu) at 7.00 p.m. on 07.08.2016
near his residence, following which the patient was
Ⓛ
bleeding from hand. The following injuries were noticed:
"Ⓛ
Palm - deep lacerated wound seen between
thumb and index finger exposing and injuries blood
vessels, bones tendons, muscles."


21. Ex.P16, further shows that the accused was
shifted to Victoria Hospital for further management. The
injuries mentioned in Ex.P16 has been spoken to by PW17.
In her evidence, she has testified that those injuries
sustained by the accused were grievous in nature.

22. The learned counsel for the appellant contended
that the statements of the witnesses are recorded

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62385-DB
CRL.A No. 1504 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010365572023


belatedly. The witnesses have not referred to the cause of
injuries sustained by the accused and only at the time of
recording of the evidence, PW2 has deposed that the
accused sustained the injuries while the deceased tried to
snatch the weapon from his hand. He, further contended
that the deceased was a rowdy sheeter and he had
several enemies and previously he was in prison in
connection with a murder case. He contended that the
prosecution has suppressed the genesis of the incident and
the facts on record will weigh in favour of the accused and
the false implication of the accused is not ruled out in view
of the previous enmity and therefore, the accused is
entitled to benefit of doubt. The learned counsel has relied
on a decision of the Apex Court in Aslam alias Imran v.
The State of Madhya Pradesh ( SLP (Criminal)
No.15254/2024 ).

23. In the above decision, the Apex Court noticing
several factors in favour of the accused including recording
of the statement of the witnesses after a long gap after

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62385-DB
CRL.A No. 1504 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010365572023


the incident and noticing that there was enmity between
the accused and the deceased, held that 'the enmity is a
double-edged weapon. On one hand, it provides motive,
and on the other hand it also does not rule out the
possibility of false implication. From the nature of the
evidence placed on record by the prosecution, the
possibility of the appellant being falsely implicated on
account of previous enmity cannot be ruled out’. Hence,
opined that the accused is entitled to benefit of doubt.

24. In the case on hand, the prosecution is placing
much reliance on the evidence of PWs.1 to 4. PWs.1, 3
and 4 are not the eyewitnesses to the incident. PW4 has
been treated hostile by the prosecution. PW2 is the sole
eyewitness to speak about the incident. The incident took
place on 07.08.2016. The evidence of the Investigation
Officer-PW21 goes to show that the statements of PWs.3,
4 and 5 were recorded on 16.08.2016 and the statement
of PW2-Smt.Munithayamma, was recorded on 17.08.2016.
Their statements were not recorded when the inquest

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62385-DB
CRL.A No. 1504 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010365572023


proceedings were conducted. No reasons are forthcoming
as to why their statements were recorded belatedly. In
view of the document at Ex.P16, wherein, the history was
furnished regarding the injuries sustained by the accused
that he was assaulted by the deceased with a chopper,
coupled with the delay in recording the statements of the
witnesses, a reasonable doubt arises regarding the genesis
of the incident.

25. Insofar as the motive aspect is concerned, it is
the case of the prosecution that on 02.08.2016 there was
a quarrel between the deceased and the accused in one
Shuba bar. Following the said quarrel, the accused had
assaulted the deceased with a chopper. When it is the
specific case of the prosecution that in the previous
incident it was the accused who had assaulted the
deceased, there was motive for the deceased to attack the
accused. As per the case of prosecution, after the said
incident, it was the accused who went to Mathura Nagara
to the house of his aunt, apprehending danger from the

- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62385-DB
CRL.A No. 1504 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010365572023


deceased. The incident took place only after he returned to
Kempudommasandra village. Hence, the possibility of
deceased attacking the accused at the first instance is not
ruled out. The witnesses have also admitted about the
previous cases registered against the deceased including a
murder case in which, the deceased and another had
committed the murder of one Chinna Reddy. Ex.D1, is the
document pertaining to the rowdy sheet opened against
the deceased, marked by the defence through PW18-PSI
of Anekal Police Station. He has admitted in his cross
examination that a rowdy sheet register was opened
against the deceased. As per Ex.D1, the deceased was
involved in the murder of one Chinna Reddy. PW1 has
admitted in his cross examination that the deceased was
involved in a murder case in the year 2012. PW2 has also
admitted in her cross examination that the deceased was
in prison for about 2 years in a murder case.

26. Another important aspect to be seen is that, in
Ex.P1, it is stated that the accused and 4 others had

- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62385-DB
CRL.A No. 1504 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010365572023


barged into the house of the deceased and assaulted him.
However in their chief examination, neither PW1 nor PW2
have mentioned about the presence of 4 persons. They
have conveniently suppressed the said fact. In the cross
examination of PW2, she has stated that along with the
accused, there were 4 more persons. It is not known as to
who are those 4 persons who were along with the accused
at the time of incident. The Investigatin Officer-PW21 has
only stated that he had conducted investigation with
regard to those 4 persons, but during investigation he
came to know that it was the accused who had committed
the offence. The said explanation is unsatisfactory. The
accused had taken a defense that, the deceased was a
rowdy sheeter and had many enemies. He was attacked
by the enemies and while trying to rescue, he had
sustained injuries to his hand.

27. On an overall appreciation of the entire
evidence and material on record, we find that the evidence
of PW2, an eyewitness to the incident, is not trustworthy

- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62385-DB
CRL.A No. 1504 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010365572023


so as to hold that the charges established against the
accused is proved beyond all reasonable doubt. There is
an inordinate delay in recording the statements of the
witnesses including that of PW2. The injuries sustained by
the accused, which are grievous in nature has not been
explained properly. There was previous enmity between
the deceased and the accused, which provides motive.
The said enmity is a double edged weapon and the
possibility of the appellant being falsely implicated on
account of the previous enmity cannot be ruled out.
Hence, the appellant is entitled to the benefit of doubt. For
the aforesaid reasons, we proceed to pass the following:
ORDER
i) The appeal is allowed .
ii) The Judgment and Order dated 02.09.2021
passed by the Court of III Additional District and Sessions
Judge, Bengaluru Rural District, (sitting at Anekal) in
SC No.5021/2017, convicting and sentencing the accused/

- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62385-DB
CRL.A No. 1504 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010365572023


appellant for the offence punishable under Section 302 of
IPC is set aside .
iii) The accused is acquitted of the offence
punishable under Section 302 IPC.
iv) He shall be released from the prison, if not
required in any other case.
The Registry shall communicate this order to the trial
Court and the concerned Prison authority.

Sd/-
(MOHAMMAD NAWAZ)
JUDGE

Sd/-
(B.PRAMOD)
JUDGE

BSV/TL
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 12