Virinder Pal Singh vs Punjab And Sind Bank

Court
Supreme Court

REPORTABLE
2026 INSC 266

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 3571 OF 2026
(Arising out of SLP (C) No. 10742/2026)
(Arising out of Diary No. 603/2024)


VIRINDER PAL SINGH …APPELLANT

VERSUS
PUNJAB AND SIND
BANK & ORS. …RESPONDENT(S)


J U D G M E N T
MANOJ MISRA, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. This appeal impugns judgment and order of the
1
High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh
dated 23.02.2023 in LPA No. 370 of 2018 which
arose out of CWP No. 12865 of 2014.
FACTS
3. In brief, facts relevant for deciding this appeal are
as follows:
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
CHETAN ARORA
Date: 2026.03.23
10:17:52 IST
Reason:

1
High Court
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 1 of 33

(i) The appellant while in service of Punjab
2
& Sind Bank i.e., the first respondent
was served a charge sheet on
30.09.2011, inter alia , on allegation of
irregularities in disbursement of loans.
(ii) On 30.09.2011 itself, the appellant
superannuated from service. However,
the disciplinary proceedings continued
and one of the charges, namely, Charge
No. 2, that is the appellant had failed to
ensure the end use of the loan, was found
partly proved. Consequently, vide order
dated 15.06.2013, punishment of
reduction by three stages in the time
scale of pay, on permanent basis, was
imposed upon the appellant.
(iii) Aggrieved therewith, the appellant
preferred an appeal before the Appellate
Authority which was dismissed by order
dated 19.04.2014. Thereafter, the

2
Bank
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 2 of 33

appellant preferred a writ petition i.e.,
CWP No. 12865/2014 before the High
Court, which was heard by a Single
Judge Bench of the High Court.
(iv) Before the learned Single Judge, the
appellant, inter alia , urged that the
penalty imposed upon him was not
permissible as he had superannuated.
Post retirement, penalties specified in the
Punjab and Sind Bank Employees’
3
Pension Regulations, 1995 alone could
be imposed.
(v) The aforesaid argument was accepted by
the learned Single Judge. In
consequence, the punishment order was
set aside while reserving the right of the
Bank to issue a fresh show cause notice
for action under the Pension Regulations.

3
Pension Regulations.
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 3 of 33

(vi) Aggrieved therewith, the Bank preferred
an intra court appeal before the Division
Bench of the High Court.
(vii) The Division Bench by relying upon a
three-Judge Bench decision of this Court
in Chairman-Cum-Managing Director,
Mahanadi Coalfields Limited v.
4
Rabindranath Choubey and
Regulation 20(3)(iii) of the Punjab and
Sind Bank Officers’ Service Regulations,
5
1982 held that the extant Service
Regulations permitted continuance of
disciplinary proceedings post attainment
of the age of superannuation, therefore
the disciplinary proceedings could
continue and brought to its logical
conclusion as per those Regulations. As
a result, the order of the learned Single
Judge was set aside, and the writ petition
of the appellant was dismissed.

4
(2020) 18 SCC 71
5
Service Regulations.
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 4 of 33

(viii) Aggrieved by the order of the Division
Bench, the appellant is before us.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT
4. On behalf of the appellant, it was submitted that
once the appellant had attained the age of
superannuation, the master-servant relationship
between the Bank and the appellant ceased to exist,
therefore, the punishment of reduction of pay could
not have been imposed. Though the Bank could
have either reduced the pension, otherwise payable,
or recover the loss, if any, caused to the Bank,
under the Pension Regulations.
5. Reliance was placed on a decision of this Court in
Ramesh Chandra Sharma v. Punjab National
6
Bank and another to contend that for the
purposes of proceeding with disciplinary action
post-retirement, punishment of dismissal from
service stands on a different footing than reduction
of pay, as by dismissal the liability to pay pension
also ceases. Reliance was also placed on UCO Bank

6
(2007) 9 SCC 15
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 5 of 33

7
and others vs. Prabhakar Sadashiv Karvade to
contend that Service Regulations apply to serving
employees only.
6. It was next contended that the appellant had taken
multiple other grounds (i.e., (a) the concerned
charge was not proved; (b) the concerned charge
was not relatable to any specified misconduct; and
(c) the punishment as well as the appellate order
was a non-speaking one), which the High Court
failed to address. To buttress the submission that
disciplinary /Appellate Authority’s order must carry
reasons, reliance was placed on decisions of this
Court in A.L. Kalra v. Project and Equipment
8
Corporation of India Limited and Allahabad
9
Bank and others v. Krishna Narayan Tewari .
7. It was also contended that even if the merits of the
finding(s) returned by the Inquiry Officer,
Disciplinary Authority and Appellate Authority was
not specifically questioned before the High Court, it
being a pure question of law can be raised at any

7
(2018) 14 SCC 98
8
(1984) 3 SCC 316
9
(2017) 2 SCC 308
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 6 of 33

stage. In this regard, reliance was placed on
decisions of this Court in Securities and
Exchange Board of India through its Chairman
10
v. Roofit Industries Limited and Chittoori
11
Subbanna v. Kudappa Subbanna and others .

SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE BANK

8. Per contra , the learned counsel for the Bank
submitted that the general principle that there
could be no disciplinary action post termination of
master-servant relationship, consequent to
attaining the age of superannuation, has an
exception, which is, that if the extant Service
Rules/Regulations permit continuance of
disciplinary proceedings post attainment of the age
of superannuation, the proceedings can continue
and brought to its logical conclusion. Regulation
20(3)(iii) of the Service Regulations permits
continuance of disciplinary proceedings against the
charged-officer even post-superannuation, if those

10
(2016) 12 SCC 125
11
AIR 1965 SC 1325 : 1964 SCC OnLine SC 322
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 7 of 33

were initiated prior to incumbent’s superannuation,
as is the case here. It was contended that in
Ramesh Chandra Sharma (supra), this Court
held that in view of the provisions of Regulation
20(3)(iii) it is permissible to continue with the
disciplinary proceedings post-retirement. Same
view has been taken by a three-Judge Bench of this
12
Court in Canara Bank v. D.R.P. Sundharam .
On the other hand, Pension Regulations become
applicable when proceedings are initiated under the
Pension Regulations.
9. It was next contended that the decision in
Prabhakar Sadashiv Karvade (supra) relied by
the appellant is distinguishable on facts inasmuch
as in that case the charged-officer had retired before
service of charge-sheet. In that context, it was held
that extant Regulations would apply to only serving
employees.
10. On merits of the charge and the orders passed by
the Disciplinary/Appellate Authority, it was

12. (2016) 12 SCC 724
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 8 of 33

submitted that the Inquiry Officer in his report
dated 20.12.2012 found Charge No. 2 partly proved
because the borrower had made cash withdrawals
of several lacs of rupees without supporting bills. In
that context, the Inquiry Officer concluded that the
charged officer had failed to ensure end-use of the
loan amount. The said conclusion is logical and
cannot be held perverse. More so, when the loan
account had turned Non-Performing Asset (for
short, NPA). It was submitted that diversion of loan
is best prevented by ensuring that it is used for the
purpose intended. Withdrawal by cash, without
supporting bills, is a clear indication of misuse of
loan amount. Moreover, the appellant had never
questioned the finding qua cash withdrawals
without supporting bills.
11. Besides, the punishment imposed on the appellant
had resulted in reduction of pension by a meagre
sum of Rs. 302 per month. Thus, the punishment
is not shockingly disproportionate to the gravity of
the proven misconduct. Further, as to what
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 9 of 33

punishment is to be imposed, the discretion vests
with the disciplinary authority. In this regard
decision of this Court in Union of India And
13
Others v. Ram Karan was relied upon. Based on
the aforesaid submissions, it was prayed on behalf
of the Bank that the appeal be dismissed.
ANALYSIS
12. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties
and have perused the materials on record.
13. On consideration of the rival submissions, in our
view, following issues arise for our determination:
(i) Whether post-retirement of the
appellant, punishment of reduction of
three stages in the scale of pay, as
imposed by the respondent, was
permissible under the extant Service
Regulations, or action under the Pension
Regulations was the only way forward?
(ii) Whether there is any perversity/infirmity
in the enquiry report and the order(s)

13
(2022) 1 SCC 373
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 10 of 33

passed by the Disciplinary/Appellate
Authority? If yes, whether it could be
raised as a ground when it was not
pressed before the High Court?
14. Before proceeding to address Issue No. (i), we would
address Issue No. (ii) as it turns on facts. Issue No.
(ii) relates to the merits of the Inquiry Report and
the order(s) of the Disciplinary/Appellate Authority.
It also relates to the consequence of High Court not
addressing the same. In this regard, it be noted that
the charge which stood proved was in respect of
appellant’s failure to ensure end use of the loan
disbursed by the Bank. The Inquiry Officer held the
charge as partly proved because Bills in respect of
cash payments of up to Rs. 27.25 lacs were not on
record, and it was reported that the account had
turned NPA.
14
15.
The enquiry report takes note of the evidence
produced and the submissions made by both sides.
After analyzing the same, it holds Charge No. 2

14
Which is contained in Annexure P-6
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 11 of 33

partly proved. The enquiry report is in respect of two
charges. Charge No. 1 is held not proved whereas
Charge No. 2 is held partly proved because there
existed no Bills on record to demonstrate as to how
the cash was spent. Based on that, the Inquiry
Officer concluded that there was failure on part of
the appellant to ensure end-use of the loan amount.
16. The appellant was given opportunity to submit his
comments on the Inquiry Report. In his comments
to the Inquiry Report, the appellant did not claim
that he was not given due opportunity of hearing or
that a faulty procedure was adopted by the Inquiry
Officer. In fact, he did not even challenge the
finding of the Inquiry Officer that no Bills were there
on record. Rather his stand was that his
predecessor-in-office had also not taken Bills, but
no objection was taken to his predecessor’s
conduct. In that backdrop, the disciplinary
authority, while accepting the finding of the Inquiry
Officer, imposed the punishment in question.
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 12 of 33

17. Ensuring end-use of loan disbursals serves multiple
purposes. First, it ensures that loan is not diverted
for purposes other than the one for which it is
sanctioned/ disbursed. Often loans are prioritized
for a particular purpose. Ensuring end use
safeguards that purpose. Second, it secures
recovery. For example, if loan is for purchase of a
machine to run a business, if the machine is
purchased, possibility of business yielding profits is
greater than where the loan is diverted for purposes
other than to serve the business. Besides, it is a
matter of common knowledge that loan is
sanctioned after appraisal of the project or the
business in respect of which the loan is sought.
Appraisal is often to ascertain the feasibility and
viability of the project / business for which the loan
is sought. Failure to ensure end use would render
the appraisal meaningless. In such circumstances,
if end use of the loan is not ensured, the Bank
would be exposed to financial risk.
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 13 of 33

18. In the instant case, as there was no challenge to the
indictment that huge amount of cash withdrawals
was allowed without taking supporting
bills/receipts, the charge that the appellant had
failed to ensure end use of the loan stood proved. It
was in this context, probably, the learned counsel
for appellant while assailing the disciplinary action
pressed only one ground i.e., that the extant
Discipline and Appeal Regulations/Service
Regulations under which the punishment was
imposed, applied to serving employees only. Even
before the Division Bench of the High Court, it
appears, no argument was raised on the merit of the
finding that Charge No. 2 was partly proved.
19. Besides, a bank officer holds a position of trust as
he deals with public funds. Sanction of loan beyond
one’s power, or not ensuring end-use of the loan,
amounts to financial irregularity which exposes the
Bank to financial risk. Therefore, penal action on
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 14 of 33

proof of such a charge cannot be questioned merely
15
because no loss is suffered by the Bank .
20. Moreover, where an employee of a Bank handles
money of depositors /customers/investors, it is
most essential for him to be cautious and not
reckless in discharge of his duties because he deals
with the money for and on behalf of his employer.
Every such employee/officer is, therefore, required
to take all possible steps to protect the interests of
his employer. He must, therefore, discharge his
duties with utmost sense of integrity, honesty,
devotion and diligence and must ensure that he
does nothing, which is unbecoming of an
employee/officer. Although good conduct and
discipline is expected from every employee/officer of
an institution, but it is required more when the
institution deals with money of customers/
depositors/investors. Any dereliction in discharge
of duties by such an employee or officer, whether by

15
Disciplinary Authority-Cum-Regional Manager and others v. Nikunja Bihari Patnaik, (1996) 9 SCC 69
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 15 of 33

way of negligence/casualness, or with deliberate
16
intention, constitutes misconduct .
21. In that backdrop, we find neither any perversity in
the finding(s) returned by the Inquiry Officer nor do
we deem it appropriate to permit the appellant to
question the merit of the finding(s) that Charge No.
2 was partly proved, particularly when no such plea
was pressed before the High Court.

22. For the aforesaid reasons, we decline to accept
appellant’s submissions that the Writ Court and the
Division Bench of the High Court failed in their
obligation to examine the merits of the disciplinary
action. Moreover, upon consideration of the
enquiry report and the comments of the appellant
to the same, we do not find any good ground to hold
that Charge No. 2, as discussed above, was not
partly proved, or that the punishment awarded was
shockingly disproportionate to the gravity of proven
misconduct. Issue No. (ii) is decided in the above
terms.

16
Mihir Kumar Hazara Choudhury v. Life Insurance Corporation and another, (2017) 9 SCC 404; Chairman and
Managing Director, United Commercial Bank and others v. P.C. Kakkar, (2003) 4 SCC 364.
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 16 of 33

23. Now, we shall address Issue No. (i) i.e., whether,
post-retirement, the punishment as imposed upon
the appellant is permissible in law.
24. In support of his contention on the issue, the
learned counsel for the appellant had placed
reliance on Regulation 2 of the Service Regulations
which reads as under:
“ 2. OFFICERS TO WHOM THE REGULATIONS
APPLY
2. (1) These Regulations shall apply to all
officers of the Bank and to such other employees of
the Bank to whom they may be made applicable by
the Competent Authority to the extent and subject to
such conditions as such authority may decide.
(2) They shall also apply to officers transferred/
posted/deputed outside India except to such extent
as may be specifically or generally prescribed by the
Competent Authority.
(3) They shall, however, not apply to employees
appointed/engaged in any country outside India and
permanently serving there.”

25. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the Bank
relied on Regulation 20 (3), more particularly
Clause (iii) of Sub-regulation (3) of Regulation 20, of
the Service Regulations. Sub-regulation (3) of
Regulation 20 reads as under:
“20. TERMINATION OF SERVICE
(3) (i) An officer against whom disciplinary
proceedings are pending shall not leave/discontinue
or resign from his service in the bank without the
prior approval in writing of Competent Authority and
any notice or resignation given by such an officer
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 17 of 33

before or during the disciplinary proceedings shall
not take effect unless it is accepted by the Competent
Authority.

(ii) Disciplinary proceedings shall be deemed to
be pending against any employee for the purpose of
this regulation if he has been placed under
suspension or any notice has been issued to him to
show cause why disciplinary proceedings shall not be
instituted against him and will be deemed to be
pending until final orders are passed by the
Competent Authority.

(iii) The officers against whom disciplinary
proceedings have been initiated will cease to be in
service on the date of superannuation, but the
disciplinary proceedings will continue as if he was in
service until the proceedings are concluded and final
order is passed in respect thereof. The concerned
officer will not receive any pay and/or allowance after
the date of superannuation. He will also not be
entitled for the payments of retirement benefits till
the proceedings are completed and final order is
passed thereon except his own contribution to CPF.”

26. The contention on behalf of the appellant is that the
Service Regulations, of which Regulation 20 (3) (iii)
is a part, would apply to all officers of the Bank.
However, once an officer superannuates, he is no
longer an officer of the Bank therefore, Regulation
20 (3) (iii) cannot rescue disciplinary proceedings
post-retirement. Thus, it is contended, post-
retirement, action can be taken only under the
Pension Regulations.
27. At this stage, it would be useful to refer to two
decisions placed on behalf of the appellant, namely,
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 18 of 33

“UCO Bank and Others vs. Prabhakar Sadashiv
Karvade” (supra) (for short, Prabhakar Sadashiv
Karvade ) and “Ramesh Chandra Sharma vs.
Punjab National Bank and Another” (supra) (for
short, Ramesh Chander Sharma).
28. In Prabhakar Sadashiv Karvade , based on a
charge sheet served on 09.09.2000, the incumbent
was dismissed from service on 12.10.2004 while he
had retired from service on 13.12.1993. In that
context, this Court considered various service
Rules/ Regulations which were extracted in
Paragraph 8 of the judgment. Relevant portion of
which is reproduced below:
8.
“ …..

Discipline and Appeal Regulations

4. Penalties — The following are the penalties which
may be imposed on an officer employee, for acts of
misconduct or for any other good and sufficient
reasons—

Minor penalties —

(a) censure;

(b) withholding of increments of pay with or without
cumulative effect;

(c) withholding of promotion;

SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 19 of 33

(d) recovery from pay or such other amount as may
be due to him of the whole or part of any pecuniary
loss caused to the Bank by negligence or breach of
orders.

(e) reduction to a lower stage in the timescale of pay
for a period not exceeding 3 years, without
cumulative effect and not adversely affecting the
officer's pension.


Major penalties —

(f) save as provided for in (e) above, reduction to a
lower stage in the timescale of pay for a specified
period, with further directions as to whether or not
the officer will earn increments of pay during the
period of such reduction and whether on the expiry
of such period the reduction will or will not have the
effect of postponing the future increments of his pay.

(g) reduction to a lower grade or post,

(h) compulsory retirement;

(i) removal from service which shall not be a
disqualification for future employment;

(j) dismissal which shall ordinarily be a
disqualification for future employment.”

“ 1979 Regulations

20 (3) (iii) The officer against whom disciplinary
proceedings have been initiated will cease to be in
service on the date of superannuation but the
disciplinary proceedings will continue as if he was in
service until the proceedings are concluded and final
order is passed in respect thereof. The concerned
officer will not receive any pay and/or allowance after
the date of superannuation. He will also not be
entitled for the payment of retirement benefits till the
proceedings are completed and final order is passed
thereon except his own contributions to CPF.”

“ The Pension Regulations

46. Provisional Pension —(1) An employee who has
retired on attaining the age of superannuation or
otherwise and against whom any departmental or
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 20 of 33

judicial proceedings are instituted or departmental
proceedings are continued, a provisional pension,
equal to the maximum pension which would have
been admissible to him, would be allowed subject to
adjustment against final retirement benefits
sanctioned to him, upon conclusion of the
proceedings but no recovery shall be made where the
pension finally sanctioned is less than the provisional
pension or the pension is reduced or withheld, etc.
either permanently or for a specified period.

(2) In such cases the gratuity shall not be paid to
such an employee until the conclusion of the
proceedings against him. The gratuity shall be paid
to him on conclusion of the proceedings subject to
the decision of the proceedings. Any recoveries to be
made from an employee shall be adjusted against the
amount of gratuity payable.

Explanation. — in this Chapter—(a) to (e)
*

48. Recovery of pecuniary loss caused to the
Bank —(1) The competent authority may withhold or
withdraw a pension or a part thereof, whether
permanently or for a specified period, and order
recovery from pension of the whole or part of any
pecuniary loss caused to the bank if in any
departmental or judicial proceedings the pensioner is
found guilty of grave misconduct or negligence or
criminal breach of trust or forgery or acts done
fraudulently during the period of his service;

Provided that the Board shall be consulted before any
final orders are passed.

Provided further that departmental proceedings, if
instituted while the employee was in service, shall,
after the retirement of the employee, be deemed to be
proceedings under these Regulations and shall be
continued and concluded by the authority by which
they were commenced in the same manner as if the
employee had continued in service.

Provided also that no departmental or judicial
proceedings, if not initiated while the employee was
in service, shall be instituted in respect of a cause of
action which arose or in respect of an event which
took place more than four years before such
institution.
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 21 of 33

(2) Where the competent authority orders recovery of
pecuniary loss from the pension, the recovery shall
ordinarily be made at a rate exceeding one-third of
the pension admissible on the date of retirement of
the employee.

Provided that where a part of pension is withheld or
withdrawn, the amount of pension drawn by a
pensioner shall not be less than the minimum
pension payable under these Regulations.”

After considering the aforesaid Regulations, this
Court held as under:
“9. A reading of the plain language of Regulation 4 of
the Discipline and Appeal Regulations and
Regulation 20(3)( iii ) of the 1979 Regulations makes it
clear that any of the penalties, whether major or
minor can be imposed only on a serving officer
employee of the Bank. This necessarily implies that
none of the penalties specified in Regulation 4 of the
Discipline and Appeal Regulations can be imposed on
an officer employee after his retirement from service,
though in terms of Regulation 20(3)( iii ) of the 1979
Regulations, the disciplinary proceedings initiated
against an officer employee before his retirement can
be continued and final order is passed and further
that such officer employee is not entitled to retiral
benefits till the conclusion of disciplinary
proceedings and passing of final order. The only
exception to this is that the officer is entitled to
receive his own contribution to CPF. However, there
is nothing in the language of these Regulations from
which it can be inferred that the disciplinary
authority has the power to impose a substantive
punishment on retired officer employee. This
becomes more explicit from a conjoint reading of
Regulation 48 of the Pension Regulations which
empowers the competent authority to withhold or
withdraw a pension or a part thereof and order
recovery from pension of the whole or part of any
pecuniary loss caused to the bank if in a
departmental or judicial proceedings, the pensioner
is found guilty of grave misconduct or negligence or
criminal breach of trust or forgery or acts done
fraudulently during the period of his service. Second
proviso to Regulation 48 contains a fiction and lays
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 22 of 33

down that if the departmental proceedings are
instituted while the employee was in service, the
same shall be deemed to be proceedings under the
Regulations and continued and concluded as if the
employee had continued in service. The third proviso
imposes a bar on the initiation of departmental or
judicial proceedings against an employee after his
retirement in respect of an event which took place
more than 4 years before such institution. The sum
and substance of these Regulations is that even
though a departmental inquiry instituted against an
officer employee before his retirement can continue
even after his retirement, none of the substantive
penalties specified in Regulation 4 of 1979
Regulations, which include dismissal from service,
can be imposed on an officer employee after his
retirement on attaining the age of superannuation.
Therefore, we have no hesitation to hold that order
dated 12-10-2004 passed by the disciplinary
authority dismissing the respondent from service,
who had superannuated on 31-12-1993 was ex facie
illegal and without jurisdiction and the High Court
did not commit any error by setting aside the same.

10. We may also observe that master and servant
relationship between the respondent and the
employer i.e. Appellant 1 Bank had come to an end
for all practical purposes on 31-12-1993 i.e. the date
of superannuation. The departmental inquiry
initiated against the respondent before his retirement
could be continued for a limited purpose for
determining whether or not he is entitled for full
pensionary benefits and gratuity.”
(Emphasis supplied)

29. In Ramesh Chandra Sharma (supra), the issue
was whether punishment of dismissal could be
inflicted on an employee who has already retired on
attaining the age of superannuation. In that
context, this Court considered Regulation 20(3)(iii)
of the Service Regulations (which is in same terms
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 23 of 33

as Regulation 20(3) (iii) of 1979 Regulations
extracted in the preceding paragraph) and
Regulations 22, 43 and 48 of the Pension
Regulations, which are reproduced below:
“22 . (i) Resignation or dismissal or removal or
termination of an employee from the services of the
Bank shall entail forfeiture of his entire past service
and consequently shall not qualify for pensionary
benefits.

43 . Withholding or withdrawal of pension .—The
competent authority may, by order in writing,
withhold or withdraw a pension or a part thereof,
whether permanently or for a specified period, if the
pensioner is convicted of a serious crime or criminal
breach of trust or forgery of ( sic or) acting
fraudulently or is found guilty of grave misconduct.

Provided that where a part of pension is withheld or
withdrawn, the amount of such pension shall not be
reduced below the minimum pension per mensem
payable under these Regulations.

48
. Recovery of pecuniary loss caused to the Bank .—
(1) The competent authority may withhold or
withdraw a pension or a part thereof, whether
permanently or for a specified period and order
recovery from pension of the whole or part of any
pecuniary loss caused to the Bank if in any
departmental or judicial proceedings the pensioner is
found guilty of grave misconduct or negligence or
criminal breach of trust or forgery or acts done
fraudulently during the period of his service:

Provided that the Board shall be consulted before any
final orders are passed;

Provided further that departmental proceedings, if
instituted while the employee was in service, shall,
after the retirement of the employee, be deemed to be
proceedings under these Regulations and shall be
continued and concluded by the authority by which
they were commenced in the same manner as if the
employee had continued in service;
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 24 of 33

(2) No departmental proceedings, if not instituted
while the employee was in service, shall be instituted
in respect of an event which took place more than
four years before such institution:

Provided that the disciplinary proceedings so
instituted shall be in accordance with the procedure
applicable to disciplinary proceedings in relation to
the employee during the period of his service.

(3) Where the competent authority orders recovery of
pecuniary loss from the pension, the recovery shall
not ordinarily be made at a rate exceeding one-third
of the pension admissible on the date of retirement of
the employee:

Provided that where a part of pension is withheld or
withdrawn, the amount of pension drawn by a
pensioner shall not be less than the minimum
pension payable under these Regulations.”

Construing the object of Regulation 20(3)(iii)
(supra), this Court observed:
“ 17. ……
The said Regulation clearly envisages continuation of
a disciplinary proceeding despite the officer ceasing
to be in service on the date of superannuation. For
the said purpose a legal fiction has been created
providing that the delinquent officer would be
deemed to be in service until the proceedings are
concluded and final order is passed thereon. The said
Regulation being statutory in nature should be given
full effect.”

Thereafter, upon considering Regulations 22, 43
and 48 of the Pension Regulations, it was held:
“25. Indisputably as a consequence of the order
imposing the punishment of dismissal from service
the appellant would not have qualified for the
pensionary benefits.
… …………

SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 25 of 33

26. Where a proceeding is initiated for withholding
or withdrawal of pension, Regulation 43 of the
Pension Regulations would be attracted. But
provisions of the said Regulation if read in its entirety
clearly go to show that an officer would not qualify for
pensionary benefits, if, inter alia , he is dismissed
from service.

27. Regulation 48 empowers the Bank to recover
pecuniary loss caused to it from the pensionary
benefits. Regulation 20(3)( iii ) of the (Discipline and
Appeal) Regulations must be read in conjunction with
the Pension Regulations. Where the employees are
pension optees, Regulation 48(1) shall apply. In any
event, if an officer is removed or dismissed from
service under Regulation 4 of the (Discipline and
Appeal) Regulations, the Bank need not take recourse
to Regulation 48 of the Pension Regulations as
Regulation 22 thereof would be attracted.”

30. In Chairman-cum-Managing Director, Mahanadi
Coalfields Ltd. vs. Rabindranath Choubey
(supra) (for short, Mahanadi Coalfields Ltd. ), the
issue, inter alia , under consideration was, ‘whether,
in view of Rule 34.2 of the 1978 Rules, the
punishment of dismissal can be imposed upon
finding one guilty of misconduct, where
departmental enquiry is instituted while the
employee is in service and continued after he
attains the age of superannuation?’

SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 26 of 33

31. Rule 34.2 and 34.3 of CDA Rules, which were
considered by this Court in Mahanadi Coalfields
Ltd. , read as under:
“ 34.2. Disciplinary proceeding, if instituted while
the employee was in service whether before his
retirement or during his re-employment shall, after
the final retirement of the employee, be deemed to be
proceeding and shall be continued and concluded by
the authority by which it was commenced in the same
manner as if the employee had continued in service.

34.3. During the pendency of the disciplinary
proceedings, the Disciplinary Authority may withhold
payment of gratuity, for ordering the recovery from
gratuity of the whole or part of any pecuniary loss
caused to the Company if have been guilty of offences
/misconduct as mentioned in sub-section (6) of
Section 4 of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 or to
have caused pecuniary loss to the Company by
misconduct or negligence, during his service
including service rendered on deputation or on re-
employment after retirement. However, the
provisions of Sections 7(3) and 7(3-A) of the Payment
of Gratuity Act, 1972 should be kept in view in the
event of delayed payment, in the case the employee is
fully exonerated.”

32. In that context, in Mahanadi Coalfields Ltd. , this
Court held:
“7.
Indisputably, the respondent was governed by
the CDA Rules. Therefore, Rules 34.2 and 34.3 of the
CDA Rules shall be applicable and the respondent
employee shall be governed by the said provisions.
Rule 34 permits the management to withhold the
gratuity during the pendency of the disciplinary
proceedings. Rule 34.2 permits the disciplinary
proceedings to be continued and concluded even
after the employee has attained the age of
superannuation, provided the disciplinary
proceedings are instituted while the employee was in
service. It also further provides that such disciplinary
proceedings shall be deemed to be the proceedings
and shall be continued and concluded by the
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 27 of 33

authority by which it was commenced in the same
manner as if the employee had continued in service.
Therefore, as such, on a fair reading of Rule 34.2 of
the CDA Rules, an employee shall be deemed to be
continued in service, after he attains the age of
superannuation/retired, for the limited purpose of
continuing and concluding the disciplinary
proceedings which were instituted while the
employee was in service. Therefore, at the conclusion
of such disciplinary proceedings any of the penalty
provided under Rule 27 of the CDA Rules can be
imposed by the authority including the order of
dismissal. If the submission on behalf of the
employee that after the employee has attained the age
of superannuation and/or he has retired from
service, despite Rule 34.2, no order of penalty of
dismissal can be passed is accepted, in that case, it
will be frustrating permitting the authority to
continue and conclude the disciplinary proceedings
after retirement. If the order of dismissal cannot be
passed after the employee has retired and/or has
attained the age of superannuation in the
disciplinary proceedings which were instituted while
the employee was in service, in that case, there shall
not be any fruitful purpose to continue and conclude
the disciplinary proceedings in the same manner as
if the employee had continued in service.

8. It is true that while considering the very
provisions of the CDA Rules, namely, Rule 34.2 and
Rule 34.3 of the CDA Rules, this Court in Jaswant
Singh Gill [ Jaswant Singh Gill v. Bharat Coking Coal
Ltd. , (2007) 1 SCC 663 : (2007) 1 SCC (L&S) 584] has
observed and held that once the employee is
permitted to retire on attaining the age of
superannuation, thereafter no order of dismissal can
be passed. However, for the reasons stated
hereinabove, we are not in agreement with the view
taken by this Court in Jaswant Singh Gill [ Jaswant
Singh Gill v. Bharat Coking Coal Ltd. , (2007) 1 SCC
663: (2007) 1 SCC (L&S) 584]. As observed
hereinabove, if no major penalty is permissible after
retirement, even in a case where the disciplinary
proceedings were instituted while the employee was
in service, in that case, Rule 34.2 would become
otiose and shall be meaningless.

9. On the contrary, there is a decision of three-
Judge Bench of this Court in Ram Lal
Bhaskar [ SBI v. Ram Lal Bhaskar , (2011) 10 SCC
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 28 of 33

249: (2012) 1 SCC (L&S) 402] taking just a contrary
view. In Ram Lal Bhaskar [ SBI v. Ram Lal Bhaskar ,
(2011) 10 SCC 249: (2012) 1 SCC (L&S) 402], Rule
19(3) of the State Bank of India Officers Service
Rules, 1992 came up for consideration which was
pari materia with Rule 34.2 of the CDA Rules. The
said Rule 19(3) of the State Bank of India Officers
Service Rules, 1992 also permits the disciplinary
proceedings to continue even after the retirement of
an employee if those were instituted when the
delinquent employee was in service. In that case,
charge-sheet was served upon the respondent before
his retirement. The proceedings continued after his
retirement and were conducted in accordance with
the relevant Rules where charges were proved.
Punishment of dismissal was imposed. The High
Court allowed [ Ramlal Bhaskar v. SBI , Writ-A No.
8415 of 2003, order dated 12-4-2006 (All)] the
petition and quashed the order of dismissal. This
Court reversed the said decision of the High Court. In
the said decision, it was specifically observed by this
Court while considering the pari materia provisions
that in case disciplinary proceedings under the
relevant Rules of service have been initiated against
an officer before he ceased to be in the bank's service
by the operation of, or by virtue of, any of the Rules
or the provisions of the Rules, the disciplinary
proceedings may, at the discretion of the Managing
Director, be continued and concluded by the
authority by whom the proceedings were initiated in
the manner provided for in the Rules as if the officer
continues to be in service, so however, that he shall
be deemed to be in service only for the purpose of the
continuance and conclusion of such proceedings. In
the said decision, this Court also took note of another
decision of this Court in Rajinder Lal Capoor [ UCO
Bank v. Rajinder Lal Capoor , (2007) 6 SCC 694 :
(2007) 2 SCC (L&S) 550] and it is observed even in
the said decision that the UCO Bank Officer
Employees' Service Regulations, 1979 which were
also pari materia to the SBI Rules as well as the CDA
Rules, could be invoked only when the disciplinary
proceedings had been initiated prior to the
delinquent officer ceased to be in service.”

33. What is important to note is that in Mahanadi
Coalfields Ltd. , this Court had the occasion to
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 29 of 33

consider its earlier decision in Ramesh Chandra
Sharma, and the same was approved.

34. The ratio of Mahanadi Coalfields Ltd. is found in
paragraphs 47 and 48 of the judgment, which are
reproduced below:
“ 47. Thus considering the provisions of Rules 34.2
and 34.3 of the CDA Rules, the inquiry can be
continued given the deeming fiction in the same
manner as if the employee had continued in service
and appropriate punishment, including that of
dismissal can be imposed apart from the forfeiture of
the gratuity wholly or partially including the recovery
of the pecuniary loss as the case may be.

48. In view of the above and for the reasons stated
above and in view of the decision of the three-Judge
Bench of this Court in Ram Lal Bhaskar [ SBI v. Ram
Lal Bhaskar , (2011) 10 SCC 249 : (2012) 1 SCC (L&S)
402] and our conclusions as above, it is observed and
held that ( 1 ) the appellant employer has a right to
withhold the gratuity during the pendency of the
disciplinary proceedings, and ( 2 ) the disciplinary
authority has powers to impose the penalty of
dismissal/major penalty upon the respondent even
after his attaining the age of superannuation, as the
disciplinary proceedings were initiated while the
employee was in service.”

35. In Mahanadi Coalfields Ltd. , Ajay Rastogi, J.
wrote a separate opinion partly concurring and
partly dissenting with the majority view. In respect
of the first question, Ajay Rastogi, J. concurred with
the majority view whereas in respect of the second
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 30 of 33

question, that is, whether the penalty of dismissal
could be imposed after the employee had retired
from service, Ajay Rastogi, J. opined thus:
“ 78.2. Que. 2—Whether the penalty of dismissal
could be imposed after the employee stood retired
from service?

Ans. In my considered view, after conclusion of the
disciplinary inquiry, if held guilty, indeed a penalty
can be inflicted upon an employee/delinquent who
stood retired from service and what should be the
nature of penalty will always depend on the relevant
scheme of the Rules and on the facts and
circumstances of each case, but either of the
substantive penalties specified under Rule 27 of the
1978 Rules including dismissal from service are not
open to be inflicted on conclusion of the disciplinary
proceedings and the punishment of forfeiture of
gratuity commensurate with the nature of guilt may
be inflicted upon a delinquent employee provided
under Rule 34.3 of the 1978 Rules read with sub-
section (6) of Section 4 of the 1972 Act.”

36. On a survey of the decisions cited and discussed
above, in our view, what is settled is that if the
extant service Rules/Regulations permit
continuance of the disciplinary proceedings,
initiated against an officer/ employee before he had
attained the age of superannuation, those can be
continued and brought to its logical conclusion even
after he had attained the age of superannuation.
And where, pursuant to such proceedings, the
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 31 of 33

ultimate penalty imposed is of dismissal, there may
be no technical difficulty in its implementation as it
may result in forfeiture of pension and other retiral
dues. Therefore, in such an event, the question of
entitlement to pensionary benefits may not arise.
However, where the punishment imposed is such
which may, instead of forfeiture of pension in its
entirety, result in mere reduction or adjustment of
pension, or recovery from post retiral dues, the
Court may have to consider whether such
punishment is implementable or not, post-
retirement.


37. In the instant case, the punishment awarded is of
reducing the pay scale by three stages on
permanent basis. Such reduction in the pay scale
would relate back to the date the incumbent
superannuated from service. Ordinarily, pension is
computed based on salary last drawn/payable.
Therefore, in our view, it would not be difficult to
implement such a punishment as pension can be
computed accordingly.
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 32 of 33

38. For the foregoing reasons, in our view, the Division
Bench of the High Court was justified in allowing
the writ appeal by properly construing Regulation
20(3)(iii) of the Service Regulations.

39. The appeal therefore lacks merit and is accordingly
dismissed. Pending applications, if any, shall stand
disposed of. There shall be no order as to costs.


…............................................. J.
(Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha)


................................................ J.
(Manoj Misra)

New Delhi;
March 19, 2026
SLP (C) D. No. 603/2024 Page 33 of 33