Mohit Kumar vs State Of U.P. And 4 Others
- Court
- Allahabad High Court
A.F.R.
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
WRIT - A No. - 18348 of 2026
Mohit Kumar
.....Petitioner(s)
Versus
State Of U.P. And 4 Others
.....Respondent(s)
Counsel for Petitioner(s) : Siddharth Khare, Sr. Advocate
Counsel for Respondent(s) : C.S.C., Mahendra Narain Singh
Court No. - 52
HON'BLE MRS. MANJU RANI CHAUHAN, J.
1. Heard Mr. Ashok Khare, learned Senior Advocate assisted by Mohd.
Yasin, learned counsel for the petitioner, learned Standing Counsel for the
State-respondent nos.1 and 2 as well as Mr. Nishith Yadav, learned
counsel for respondent-Commission.
2. The present writ petition has been filed seeking quashing of the
notification dated 16.10.2026 issued by the Secretary, Uttar Pradesh
Public Service Commission, Prayagraj, whereby the petitioner's
candidature has been rejected, along with a further prayer for a direction
to the Commission to recommend his name for appointment to the post of
Lecturer in Textile Technology pursuant to the notification dated
25.06.2026.
3. The brief facts of the case, as advanced by learned counsel for the
petitioner, are that pursuant to the advertisement dated 15.09.2021 issued
by the Uttar Pradesh Public Service Commission, the petitioner submitted
his application within the prescribed time for consideration of his
candidature for the post of Lecturer in Textile Technology. The last date
for submission of the application form was 15.10.2021. While filling up
the online application form, the petitioner had mentioned his category as
Economically Weaker Section (EWS). He thereafter participated in the
written examination conducted on 26.11.2025 and was declared
successful in the EWS category. Consequently, vide interview letter dated
27.04.2026, he was called upon to participate in the interview scheduled
WRIA No. 18348 of 2026
2
to be held on 05.05.2026.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that while filling up
the online application form, the petitioner had inadvertently mentioned his
category as Economically Weaker Section (EWS), although he did not
belong to the said category and was not in possession of an EWS
certificate. Upon realising the aforesaid mistake, the petitioner, on
02.05.2026, prior to the scheduled interview, voluntarily submitted an
affidavit before the Commission, categorically declaring that the mention
of the EWS category in his application form was an inadvertent
clerical/technical error. He accordingly requested the Commission to
consider his candidature under the Unreserved category.
5. Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that, vide interview
letter dated 27.04.2026, the petitioner was called upon to participate in the
interview scheduled to be held on 05.05.2026. It is further submitted that,
in compliance with the interview letter, the petitioner appeared before the
Commission and produced the requisite original certificates and other
relevant documents. At the time of verification and production of
documents, he also submitted a covering application, duly enumerating
the documents produced by him, along with the aforesaid affidavit dated
02.05.2026, thereby placing the correct factual position before the
Commission well before the scheduled interview.
6. Learned counsel for the petitioner, therefore, contends that the
petitioner had neither concealed any material fact nor sought to secure
any undue advantage by claiming reservation under the EWS category.
On the contrary, prior to participating in the interview, he had voluntarily
brought the inadvertent error to the notice of the Commission and
expressly sought consideration of his candidature under the Unreserved
category. It is, thus, argued that the mere incorrect mention of the EWS
category in the online application form, particularly when the petitioner
had voluntarily disclosed and rectified the mistake before the interview
and had not availed any benefit of the said category, could not, by itself,
constitute misrepresentation or misconduct warranting cancellation of his
candidature. The impugned action of the Commission is, therefore,
assailed as arbitrary, unjustified and legally unsustainable.
WRIA No. 18348 of 2026
3
7. Despite the aforesaid, on 05.05.2026, an undertaking was obtained
from the petitioner to the effect that he had not yet produced the EWS
certificate and that the same would be furnished on or before 20.05.2026.
The furnishing of the aforesaid undertaking was made a pre-condition for
permitting the petitioner to participate in the interview. Accordingly, upon
submission of the undertaking, the petitioner was permitted to participate
in the interview held on 05.05.2026.
8. Thereafter, on 25.06.2026, the respondent Commission issued a
notification publishing the select list for the posts of Lecturer in
Pharmacy, Textile Technology and Architecture. In the select list so
published, the petitioner was placed at Serial No. 4 in order of merit and
was shown as selected under the UR/EWS category. However, his
selection was indicated to be provisional.
9. Aggrieved by the provisional nature of his selection, the petitioner
submitted a representation dated 29.06.2026 before the Secretary of the
respondent Commission, requesting that the provisional status of his
selection be removed and that his candidature be recommended for
appointment as a duly selected candidate under the Unreserved (UR)
category.
10. Without taking any decision on the aforesaid representation, the
Commission proceeded to recommend the names of 34 selected
candidates, out of the 35 candidates included in the select list, to the
Technical Education Department for appointment. However, no
recommendation was made in respect of the petitioner.
11. Subsequently, on 16.10.2026, the Secretary of the respondent
Commission issued the impugned notification, recording therein that the
candidature of one selected candidate had been cancelled and
recommending the name of Suraj Singh, bearing Roll No. 0900854, as a
selected candidate. Notably, no separate order cancelling the petitioner's
candidature has ever been served upon him, nor was any decision
communicated to him regarding the representation submitted on
29.06.2026. In the aforesaid circumstances, the petitioner has approached
this Court by means of the present writ petition, assailing the notification
dated 16.10.2026 issued by the Secretary of the respondent Commission.
WRIA No. 18348 of 2026
4
12. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that, owing to an
inadvertent mistake while filling up the online application form, the
petitioner had mentioned his category as EWS, whereas he actually
belongs to the Unreserved (UR) category. It is further submitted that the
petitioner has neither claimed nor availed any benefit or concession
admissible to a candidate belonging to the EWS category. In fact, the
petitioner deposited the application fee applicable to a General Category
candidate and participated in the selection process on his own merit. It is
contended that the petitioner was ultimately selected in the Unreserved
Category and, therefore, the mere inadvertent mention of EWS category
in the application form, without availing any corresponding benefit, could
not have furnished a valid ground for cancellation of his candidature.
13. Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that, although the
petitioner had inadvertently mentioned his category as EWS while
submitting the online application form, prior to appearing in the
interview, on 02.05.2026, he had furnished an affidavit categorically
stating that the EWS category had been mentioned due to a bona fide
mistake and that he had neither claimed nor availed any benefit or
concession whatsoever admissible to a candidate belonging to the said
category. It is further pointed out that the petitioner had deposited the
application fee applicable to a General Category candidate, thereby
demonstrating that he had not sought to derive any advantage on the basis
of his erroneous declaration. Despite the petitioner having disclosed the
mistake and clarified his actual category before participating in the
interview, the respondent Commission proceeded to cancel his
candidature. It is, therefore, contended that the impugned action is
arbitrary, unjustified and contrary to the settled principles governing
public employment and the application of reservation rules, particularly
when the petitioner had competed on his own merit and had not availed
any preferential treatment or concession under the EWS category.
14. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the mere mentioning of
the EWS category in the application form, owing to an inadvertent
mistake, cannot, in the facts and circumstances of the present case, be
construed as an act of misconduct or misrepresentation, particularly when
the petitioner had, even prior to appearing in the interview, furnished an
WRIA No. 18348 of 2026
5
affidavit dated 02.05.2026 categorically clarifying that the aforesaid
declaration had been made inadvertently and that he actually belonged to
the Unreserved Category. It is contended that such voluntary disclosure,
made before the culmination of the selection process, sufficiently
demonstrates the bona fide nature of the mistake and negates any
intention on the part of the petitioner to secure an undue advantage by
claiming reservation. In the absence of any benefit or concession having
been claimed or availed under the EWS category, the subsequent
cancellation of his candidature on the ground of the aforesaid erroneous
declaration is wholly unjustified and unsustainable in law.
15. Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that the petitioner
has secured selection on the basis of his own merit in the Unreserved
Category, without seeking or availing any benefit, concession or
preferential treatment admissible to a candidate belonging to the EWS
category. It is, therefore, contended that once the petitioner is found
eligible for consideration against an Unreserved Category vacancy on the
basis of his merit, his candidature cannot be invalidated merely on
account of an inadvertent and erroneous declaration of his category as
EWS in the application form, particularly when such error was voluntarily
disclosed and duly clarified by way of an affidavit furnished prior to his
participation in the interview. The mere mis-description of his category,
in the absence of any corresponding claim to reservation or any attempt to
secure an undue advantage, cannot constitute a legitimate ground for
denying him consideration in the Unreserved Category. The respondent
Commission, therefore, could not have rejected or cancelled his
candidature without examining his claim for selection against the
Unreserved Category on the basis of his merit and eligibility.
16. It is, thus, contended that the action of the respondent Commission is
wholly arbitrary, discriminatory and unsustainable in law, being contrary
to the settled principles governing public employment and the application
of reservation rules. The petitioner, having secured the requisite merit for
selection against an Unreserved Category vacancy and having neither
claimed nor availed any benefit or concession under the EWS category,
could not have been deprived of his legitimate claim to selection merely
on account of an inadvertent error in the declaration of his category,
WRIA No. 18348 of 2026
6
particularly when the same had been duly disclosed and rectified before
his participation in the interview. Learned counsel, therefore, submits that
the notification dated 16.10.2026 is liable to be quashed and the petitioner
is entitled to consequential relief, including a direction to the respondent
Commission to recommend his candidature for appointment to the post of
Lecturer in Textile Technology, pursuant to the select list notified on
25.06.2026.
17. Learned counsel for the petitioner, placing reliance upon the judgment
rendered by the Division Bench of this Court in Writ-A No. 8882 of 2023
(Pankhudi Agarwal v. State of U.P. and 2 Others), decided on 17.07.2023,
submits that a clear distinction is required to be drawn between an
incorrect or unsubstantiated disclosure and a deliberate false or
misleading representation made with the intention of securing an undue
advantage. He further submits that this Court has observed that a mere
failure on the part of a candidate to substantiate a claim for reservation
would not, by itself, amount to furnishing false or misleading information
so as to warrant cancellation of the entire candidature. Although such a
candidate may be dis-entitled to the benefit of the particular reservation
claimed, the deficiency cannot automatically result in exclusion from the
selection process in the absence of any finding of dishonest or deceitful
conduct. It is further contended that where the recruitment advertisement
prescribes distinct consequences for different deficiencies, the recruiting
authority cannot impose the extreme penalty of cancellation of
candidature for an eventuality for which such consequence has not been
contemplated. Learned counsel, therefore, submits that the impugned
decision fails to maintain proportionality between the nature of the
alleged default and the consequence imposed and that an innocent or
unsubstantiated claim cannot be equated with deliberate
misrepresentation. On the aforesaid premise, it is contended that the
impugned notification is arbitrary, illegal and unsustainable in law and is,
therefore, liable to be quashed. Consequently, a direction deserves to be
issued to the respondents to consider the candidature of the petitioner for
the post of Lecturer in Textile Technology in accordance with law.
18. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondent Commission,
Mr. Nishith Yadav, on the basis of instructions received, which have been
WRIA No. 18348 of 2026
7
placed on record, submits that the action of the Commission is in
conformity with the terms and conditions stipulated in the advertisement
dated 15.09.2021. Referring to Condition No. 1 under the heading
“Important Instructions” of the said advertisement, he submits that the
condition expressly stipulates as follows:
“If, at any stage, it is found that the candidate has concealed or misrepresented any
desired/required information, his candidature may be cancelled and other appropriate
action, including debarment may be initiated against him.”
19. On the strength of the aforesaid condition, learned counsel for the
respondent Commission seeks to justify the action taken against the
petitioner on the ground that the petitioner had declared himself to be
belonging to the EWS category in his application form, whereas he did
not fulfil the requirements of the said category.
20. Learned counsel for the respondent Commission has further drawn the
attention of the Court to the instructions furnished to applicants for
submission of online applications, wherein Clause 4, under the heading
“Modify Submitted Application”, provides as follows:
“If a candidate comes to know of any error/errors in the submitted application form,
except in the name of the examination and type of recruitment, registered mobile
number, E-mail ID, Aadhaar number and such cases where the prescribed fee for the
modified category is higher (in case of errors in these entries, the candidate may
submit a fresh online application along with the prescribed fee, as the fee previously
deposited shall neither be adjusted nor refunded), he/she will be given only one
opportunity to modify it/them according to the following procedure before the last
date of submission of the application form.”
21. Learned counsel for the respondent Commission has further invited
the attention of the Court to Clause 13 of the advertisement, which deals
with the important instructions for candidates. In particular, he has placed
reliance upon Clause 13.2, which stipulates as follows:
“The claim of category, sub-category, domicile, gender, date of birth, name and
address shall remain valid only up to the last date of submission of the online
application. In this regard no application for error correction/modification shall be
WRIA No. 18348 of 2026
8
acceptable. Incomplete application forms shall be summarily rejected and no
correspondence in this regard shall be entertained. In the event of submission of
false/misleading information, the candidature shall be cancelled.”
22. He has also placed reliance upon Clause 13.10 of the advertisement,
which provides as follows:
“The Commission may admit the candidates provisional after summarily checking of
the application but if it is found at any stage that applicant was not eligible or that
his/her application should have been rejected or was not entertainable initially, his/her
candidature will be rejected and if the candidate is selected, the recommendation of
the Commission for appointment will be withdrawn.”
23. On the basis of the aforesaid stipulations, learned counsel for the
respondent Commission submits that the declaration made by the
petitioner in the online application form was binding upon him and that
the Commission was empowered under the express terms of the
advertisement to reject his candidature even at a subsequent stage of the
selection process.
" / - /
मैं यह भी घोषणा करता करती हूँ कि इस आवेदन पत्र में सारे विवरण सूचनायें सत्य एवं सही हैं और मैंने इन
/
विवरणों/सूचनाओं में कोई तथ्य नहीं छिपाया है। यदि कोई विवरण सूचना असत्य या गलत पायी जाये या कोई
तथ्य मेरे द्वारा छिपाया जाना पाया जाए तो मेरा अभ्यर्थन निरस्त कर दिया जाये। यदि नियुक्त किये जाने के
"
उपरान्त ऐसी स्थिति प्रकाश में आये तो मेरी सेवायें समाप्त कर दी जाए।
24. Drawing the attention of the Court to page 50 of the writ petition,
learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that the petitioner was
issued an interview letter dated 27.04.2026, wherein Clauses 4 and 8
specifically stipulate as follows:
“
उक्त अभिलेखों के अभाव में आपका साक्षात्कार करना संभव नहीं होगा और आपका अभ्यर्थन निरस्त समझा
जाएगा।”
2
बिन्दु संख्या
“ , , (
साक्षात्कार के समय समस्त प्रमाण पत्रों उपाधियों अंकतालिकाओं एवं अनुभव प्रमाण पत्र की मूल
Original) (Original)
प्रतियां अपने साथ अवश्य लाएं। यदि पद के लिए निर्धारित अर्हता से संबंधित मूल
(Provision
डिग्री तथा प्रमाण पत्र उपलब्ध न हो तो संबंधित संस्था के सक्षम प्राधिकारी द्वारा प्रदत्त अस्थायी
WRIA No. 18348 of 2026
9
al)
प्रमाण पत्र अपने साथ अवश्य लाएं अन्यथा आपका साक्षात्कार नहीं किया जाएगा।”
4
बिन्दु संख्या
“ , (
यदि आपने किसी आरक्षित श्रेणी के अभ्यर्थी होने का दावा किया है तो शाशन द्वारा निर्धारित प्रारूप पर जो
)
वेबसाइट पर उपलब्ध है वांछित प्रमाण पत्र की मूल प्रति साक्षात्कार के समय प्रस्तुत करें एवं उसकी एक
अभिप्रमाणित अथवा फोटोस्टेट कॉपी भी प्रस्तुत करें।”
25. Drawing the attention of the Court to page 56 of the writ petition,
learned counsel for the respondent Commission, Mr. Nishith Tyagi,
submits that the petitioner had furnished an Abhivachan Patra
(undertaking) dated 05.05.2026, requesting permission to participate
provisionally in the interview on the assurance that he would submit the
EWS category certificate within fifteen days, i.e., by 20.05.2026. Learned
counsel, therefore, seeks to contend that the petitioner had himself
undertaken to furnish the requisite EWS certificate within the stipulated
period.
26. Learned counsel for the respondent Commission further submits that
the conduct of the petitioner cannot be regarded as bona fide or a mere
inadvertent error. It is contended that, despite being fully aware that he
did not belong to the EWS category, the petitioner furnished an
undertaking dated 05.05.2026, falsely assuring the Commission that he
would produce the requisite EWS certificate within fifteen days, solely
with a view to securing permission to participate in the interview. Learned
counsel further submits that the petitioner, having received the interview
letter, submitted an application dated 02.05.2026, (in case given before
Commission)yet proceeded to furnish the aforesaid undertaking. Such
conduct, according to learned counsel, was neither fair nor transparent
and amounted to deliberate misrepresentation of material particulars for
the purpose of gaining entry into the interview process. It is, therefore,
urged that the petitioner's conduct cannot be condoned as an innocent or
inadvertent mistake, particularly when the undertaking was furnished as a
condition precedent to his participation in the interview.
27. The select list pursuant to the Uttar Pradesh Technical Education
(Teaching) Service Examination, 2021, conducted in respect of 21 posts
of Lecturer in Pharmacy and 9 posts of Lecturer in Textile Technology,
WRIA No. 18348 of 2026
10
was declared by the Commission. The list contains the particulars of 36
candidates, with their respective positions determined after taking into
consideration the applicable vertical and horizontal reservation
provisions. The selection and placement of candidates in the respective
categories have been reflected in the said list in accordance with the
relevant reservation criteria.
28. In the said select list, the petitioner finds mention at Serial No. 4
under the UR/EWS category, with his selection status specifically
indicated as “Provisional”. It is further pointed out that, in paragraph
no.38 of the writ petition, which has been verified on the basis of personal
knowledge, the petitioner has averred that he secured marks higher than
those obtained by the last candidate selected under the General Category.
However, no specific factual foundation has been laid in the writ petition,
nor has any authentic material been placed on record to establish whether
the petitioner was actually selected against an Unreserved Category
vacancy on the basis of his merit or was selected under the EWS category,
as declared by him in his online application form. Thus, the petitioner's
assertion regarding his entitlement to selection under the Unreserved
Category remains unsupported by any specific particulars or cogent
documentary evidence.
29. In view of the express terms and conditions stipulated in the
advertisement, particularly Clauses 13.2 and 13.10, and having regard to
the declaration and undertaking furnished by the petitioner himself,
learned counsel for the respondent Commission submits that the
impugned notification dated 16.10.2026 suffers from no illegality,
infirmity or procedural impropriety warranting interference by this Court
in exercise of its writ jurisdiction.
30. On the basis of the instructions received, learned counsel for the
respondent Commission further submits that the written examination of
all candidates who had submitted online applications pursuant to the
advertisement was conducted on 26.11.2025, which was an objective-type
examination. The result thereof was declared on 22.04.2026, wherein 88
candidates were declared successful and shortlisted for interview.
Accordingly, interviews were conducted on 04, 05 and 06 May, 2026.
WRIA No. 18348 of 2026
11
The petitioner appeared for the interview on 05.05.2026. However, owing
to his failure to produce the original EWS certificate along with its
photocopy, he was provisionally permitted to participate in the interview.
The final result for the post in question was declared on 25.06.2026,
wherein the petitioner was placed at Serial No. 4 in the select list, albeit
with his selection being kept provisional.
31. It is further submitted that, on the date of interview, i.e., 05.05.2026,
the petitioner had furnished an affidavit dated 02.05.2026, wherein he
categorically stated as follows:
"While filling up the online application form, owing to a clerical/technical error, I
inadvertently marked 'Yes' in the column relating to the Economically Weaker Section
(EWS) category. I do not possess any valid certificate belonging to the EWS category
in accordance with the conditions stipulated in the advertisement, nor do I intend to
claim reservation under the said category. It is, therefore, respectfully requested that
my candidature may kindly be considered under the General (Unreserved) Category."
32. In this regard, learned counsel for the respondent Commission submits
that Clause 2 under the heading 'Important Instructions for Candidates' in
Clause 13 of the advertisement dated 15.09.2021 expressly stipulates that
only claims relating to category, sub-category, domicile, gender, date of
birth, EWS, creamy layer, name and address, as furnished up to the last
date of submission of the online application, shall be treated as valid. It
further provides that no subsequent alteration in the aforesaid particulars
shall be permissible and that no representation seeking correction or
modification of any error in this regard shall be entertained.
33. Learned counsel for the respondent Commission further submits that,
pursuant to a decision taken by the Commission on 02.08.2024, it was
expressly stipulated that, in all examinations/selections, the particulars
relating to category, sub-category, domicile, gender, date of birth, EWS,
creamy layer, name and address, as declared by a candidate while
submitting the online application, would remain valid only up to the last
date or the last date of modification of the online application, as the case
may be. No alteration in the aforesaid particulars would be permissible
after the expiry of the stipulated date, nor would any representation
seeking correction of an error in this regard be entertained. It was further
WRIA No. 18348 of 2026
12
stipulated that, in the event of submission of incorrect information by a
candidate, his/her candidature would be liable to cancellation. Learned
counsel further submits that the EWS category certificate furnished by a
candidate must be valid for the year immediately preceding the year in
which the application is submitted, in accordance with the Office
Memorandum dated 18.02.2019 issued by the Department of Personnel,
Government of Uttar Pradesh, under Personnel Section-1.
34. Learned counsel for the respondent Commission further submits that,
in view of the categorical declaration made by the petitioner in his
affidavit dated 02.05.2026, wherein he admitted that he did not possess
any valid certificate belonging to the EWS category in accordance with
the conditions stipulated in the advertisement, and having regard to
Clause 2 under the heading “Important Instructions for Candidates”
contained in Clause 13 of the advertisement dated 15.09.2021, as well as
the decision of the Commission dated 02.08.2024, any subsequent
alteration of the petitioner's declared category was impermissible.
Consequently, the Commission proceeded to cancel the candidature of the
petitioner, Mohit Kumar. Upon cancellation of his candidature, the
Commission declared the result vide notification dated 16.10.2026,
whereby candidate Suraj Singh was selected against the resultant vacancy.
It is further submitted that the recommendation of the said selected
candidate has already been forwarded to the State Government on
22.10.2026.
35. Learned counsel for the respondent Commission has also drawn the
attention of the Court to the instructions received, according to which the
petitioner had submitted two representations dated 29.06.2026 and
03.08.2026 before the office of the Commission. However, in view of the
express stipulations contained in the advertisement and the decision of the
Commission, which prohibited any alteration in the category declared by
a candidate after the prescribed date, and since the petitioner's candidature
had already been cancelled on that basis, the Commission did not consider
it necessary to take any further action on the aforesaid representations.
Accordingly, the same were consigned to the records.
36. Learned counsel further submits that, in response to the information
sought by the petitioner under the Right to Information Act, 2005, vide
WRIA No. 18348 of 2026
13
application dated 10.08.2026, an Office Memorandum dated 02.09.2026
was dispatched through Speed Post to the address furnished by the
petitioner in his application. However, the postal article was returned to
the Commission's office on account of the address being found incorrect
or unavailable. Thereafter, the said Office Memorandum was once again
dispatched through Speed Post, along with the representation submitted
by the petitioner, to the address mentioned in his Aadhaar Card. However,
on the second occasion as well, the postal article was returned to the
Commission's office on account of the address being found incorrect or
unavailable.
37. In conclusion, learned counsel for the respondent Commission
submits that, in view of the categorical declaration made by the petitioner
in his affidavit dated 02.05.2026 regarding non-possession of a valid
EWS category certificate, coupled with the express conditions stipulated
in the advertisement and the subsequent decision of the Commission
dated 02.08.2024, the petitioner could not have been permitted to alter his
declared category from EWS to Unreserved. The Commission, therefore,
cancelled his candidature and proceeded to fill the resultant vacancy by
selecting the next eligible candidate, namely, Suraj Singh. It is
accordingly contended that the impugned action of the Commission
suffers from no illegality or infirmity warranting interference by this
Court in exercise of its writ jurisdiction.
38. Learned counsel for the respondent Commission submits that the
category declared by a candidate in the online application form cannot be
altered after the expiry of the last date prescribed for submission or
modification of the application. It is further contended that, since the
petitioner himself admitted in his affidavit dated 02.05.2026 that he did
not possess a valid EWS category certificate, the Commission was
justified in treating his candidature as liable to cancellation in terms of the
conditions stipulated in the advertisement and the decision of the
Commission dated 02.08.2024. Accordingly, upon cancellation of the
petitioner's candidature, the resultant vacancy was filled by
recommending the next eligible candidate, namely, Suraj Singh. Learned
counsel, therefore, submits that the impugned notification dated
16.10.2026 suffers from no illegality or infirmity and does not warrant
interference by this Court in exercise of its writ jurisdiction.
WRIA No. 18348 of 2026
14
39. Learned counsel appearing for the respondents submits that the
judgment rendered by the Division Bench of this Court in Pankhudi
Agarwal (supra) , is clearly distinguishable on facts and has no
application to the controversy involved in the present case. He submits
that in the aforesaid case, the factual position was materially different,
inasmuch as the candidate therein had disclosed her claim under the
relevant reservation categories at the stage of submission of the
application, and the issue with regard to the unsubstantiated claim under
one of the reservation categories arose while the selection process was
still at the stage preceding the Main Examination. In contrast, in the
present case, the petitioner disclosed the correct factual position only after
having participated in the selection process and upon being declared
successful and called for interview. Learned counsel further submits that
the specific stipulations contained in the advertisement, governing the
declaration of category and the consequences of furnishing incorrect
information, read with the affidavit furnished by the petitioner, are of
considerable significance and cannot be overlooked. The subsequent
disclosure, made at such an advanced stage of the selection process,
cannot be equated with a timely and bona fide correction of the
declaration furnished at the initial stage of recruitment. It is, therefore,
contended that the controversy in the present case is not merely whether
the petitioner ultimately secured sufficient marks for consideration under
the unreserved category, but whether the initial declaration made by him,
in the face of the specific conditions of the advertisement and the affidavit
furnished, amounted to material misrepresentation. Learned counsel thus
submits that the ratio laid down in Pankhudi Agarwal (supra) is
distinguishable and cannot be invoked to invalidate the impugned action
taken by the respondents in accordance with the conditions of
recruitment.
40. Learned counsel appearing for the respondents further places reliance
upon the judgment rendered by this Court in Writ-A No. 17824 of 2019 (
Prabhakar Mani Tripathi v. State of U.P. and 3 Others), decided on
21.11.2019, wherein the writ petition was dismissed , considering the
objection raised on behalf of the respondents, the Court took note of the
specific stipulation contained in the recruitment advertisement to the
effect that no change in category, sub-category or date of birth would be
WRIA No. 18348 of 2026
15
permissible after receipt of the application form in the office of the
Commission and that no application seeking correction or modification in
that regard would be entertained. Learned counsel submits that, in view of
the aforesaid express condition in the advertisement, the candidate's
subsequent claim for alteration of the category could not have been
entertained by the Commission. It is, therefore, contended that once a
candidate submits an application declaring a particular category, he
cannot, at a subsequent stage of the selection process, seek to alter or
withdraw such declaration contrary to the express conditions of the
advertisement. The respondents, accordingly, contend that the petitioner's
claim for consideration under a different category was rightly not
entertained and that the impugned action of the Commission calls for no
interference.
41. Placing further reliance upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme
Court passed in the case of The State of Tamil Nadu and others v G.
, reported in , learned
Hemalathaa and another (2020)19 SCC 430
counsel appearing for the respondent Commission submits that the
conditions and instructions stipulated in the recruitment advertisement are
mandatory in nature and are binding upon all candidates participating in
the selection process. It is contended that neither a candidate can claim
any relaxation contrary to the express terms of the advertisement nor can
the recruiting authority permit deviation therefrom at an advanced stage
of the selection process. Learned counsel further submits that adherence
to the prescribed conditions is essential to maintain uniformity,
transparency and fairness in the recruitment process and that the
Commission is equally bound by the terms of the advertisement and
cannot selectively relax them in favour of an individual candidate. In this
regard, learned counsel has invited the attention of the Court to the
following observations made by the Hon'ble Supreme Court:
"8. We have given our anxious consideration to the submissions made by the learned
Senior Counsel for the respondent. The Instructions issued by the Commission are
mandatory, having the force of law and they have to be strictly complied with. Strict
adherence to the terms and conditions of the Instructions is of paramount importance.
The High Court in exercise of powers under Article 226 of the Constitution cannot
modify/relax the Instructions issued by the Commission."
WRIA No. 18348 of 2026
16
42. Learned counsel appearing for the respondent Commission further
submits that a challenge to the rejection of candidature ought not
ordinarily to be entertained in a manner that may impede or stall the
expeditious completion of the recruitment process, thereby causing
prejudice to thousands and lakhs of other aspirants awaiting the outcome
of the selection. In support of his contention, learned counsel for
respondent-Commission has placed reliance upon the judgment of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court passed in the case of Poonam Dwivedi and
Others v. State of U.P. and Others , reported in (2026 SCC Online SC
577) , wherein the candidature of the petitioner therein had been rejected
on account of an error in the application form. It is submitted that the
Hon'ble Supreme Court, while considering the challenge to such rejection,
emphasised the need to ensure that recruitment proceedings are not
unnecessarily delayed or derailed by individual claims, particularly when
the interests and expectations of a large number of candidates are
involved. Learned counsel, therefore, submits that the present challenge
deserves to be considered keeping in view the larger public interest in the
timely conclusion of the recruitment process. In this regard, he has placed
reliance upon the following observations of the Hon'ble Supreme Court:
"28. Before parting, we would like to observe that in matters of public recruitment,
where large number of candidates participate, application forms are submitted online
along with the scanned eligibility documents, certificates, etc. Such applications are
processed through computer applications/software and therefore, any error in the
application is bound to result in rejection of the candidature. Challenge to such a
rejection must not ordinarily be entertained as it could stall expeditious completion of
the recruitment process thereby frustrating thousands and lacs of aspirants."
43. Having considered the rival submissions advanced by learned counsel
for the parties, the material available on record, the conditions stipulated
in the advertisement and the judicial precedents relied upon, this Court
finds that the controversy essentially turns upon the nature of the
declaration made by the petitioner at the time of submitting his
application and the consequences flowing from his subsequent conduct in
the course of the selection process.
44. It is not in dispute that the petitioner, while submitting his online
WRIA No. 18348 of 2026
17
application for the post of Lecturer, consciously indicated his category as
Economically Weaker Section (EWS) and thereby sought consideration of
his candidature under the said category. Subsequently, when he failed to
furnish the requisite EWS certificate, he submitted an affidavit
acknowledging that the EWS category had been erroneously indicated in
his application. However, instead of maintaining the aforesaid position
consistently and seeking consideration of his candidature exclusively in
the Unreserved category, the petitioner, prior to appearing in the
interview, furnished a further undertaking before the Commission,
assuring it that he would produce the requisite EWS certificate within
fifteen days. The said undertaking cannot be viewed as an isolated
procedural formality, divorced from the declaration contained in the
original application and the subsequent affidavit. The petitioner, having
made successive declarations at different stages of the same selection
process, was expected to maintain consistency and candour in his
representations before the recruiting authority.
45. The submission that the undertaking was furnished merely to secure
permission to participate in the interview does not, by itself, absolve him
of the consequences flowing from the representation so made. A
candidate cannot be permitted to treat a solemn undertaking as a mere
instrumentality for securing an opportunity to participate in the next stage
of selection and subsequently disown the obligation voluntarily
undertaken by him. The contention advanced on behalf of the petitioner
that he has ultimately secured sufficient merit for consideration in the
Unreserved category and has not actually availed any reservation benefit
also requires examination in the context of the governing conditions of
recruitment. Undoubtedly, a reserved-category candidate who secures
selection on the basis of his own merit, without availing any concession
or relaxation, may be entitled to consideration against an Unreserved
vacancy. However, such a principle cannot be divorced from the
prescribed procedure or construed as conferring an unfettered right upon a
candidate to alter the category declared by him at any stage of the
selection process, irrespective of the express stipulations of the
advertisement. The Unreserved category is not a residual avenue which
may be invoked at the convenience of a candidate after his original
declaration has been acted upon by the Commission.
WRIA No. 18348 of 2026
18
46. The terms and conditions of the advertisement constitute the
governing framework of recruitment and are equally binding upon the
candidates as well as the recruiting authority. The Commission cannot be
compelled to depart from the notified conditions merely to accommodate
an individual candidate, nor can this Court, in exercise of its extraordinary
jurisdiction, sanction a course of action which is contrary to the
prescribed recruitment procedure. The principle enunciated by the
Supreme Court in Bedanga Talukdar v. Saifudaullah Khan, (2011) 12
SCC 85, that the conditions of an advertisement cannot be relaxed except
in accordance with an express enabling provision, reinforces the aforesaid
position.
47. In response to the contention advanced on behalf of the petitioner that
he had ultimately secured sufficient merit to warrant consideration under
the Unreserved Category and had not, in fact, availed himself of any
benefit of reservation and, therefore, his candidature could not validly be
cancelled, this Court considers it appropriate to examine the decision of
the Division Bench of this Court in Writ-A No.36163 of 2013 (Pankaj
Singh v. State of U.P. and Others), decided on 12.08.2013.
48. In the aforesaid case, the petitioner had applied for selection to the
post of Lecturer under the OBC category and was subsequently unable to
furnish a certificate in the prescribed form within the period stipulated by
the Commission. The Division Bench, while examining General
Instruction No. 11 of the advertisement applicable therein, found that the
said instruction specifically contemplated that a candidate who failed to
establish his entitlement to reservation would be treated as a General
category candidate. It was in the backdrop of that express stipulation, and
in the absence of any material demonstrating that the petitioner's
declaration regarding his OBC status was false, that the Division Bench
held that the Commission could not cancel his candidature altogether and
was required to consider him in the Unreserved category, subject to his
merit. The Division Bench further observed that an undertaking furnished
by a candidate could not enable the Commission to act contrary to the
express terms and conditions of its own advertisement. The ratio of the
aforesaid judgment, therefore, is that where the advertisement itself
provides for consideration of an unsuccessful reserved-category claimant
WRIA No. 18348 of 2026
19
in the General category, the Commission is bound to give effect to such
stipulation, and mere inability to furnish a proper category certificate,
without anything further demonstrating falsity of the declaration, would
not justify cancellation of the entire candidature. However, the aforesaid
decision cannot be construed as laying down an inflexible proposition that
every candidate who initially declares himself to belong to a reserved
category is invariably entitled to seek consideration in the Unreserved
category, irrespective of the specific conditions of the advertisement and
the circumstances attending his declaration. The material distinction
sought to be drawn in the present case lies in the petitioner's own
successive declarations and the specific stipulations governing the present
recruitment. Unlike a case resting merely upon the inability to furnish a
valid category certificate, the petitioner herein initially acknowledged
through an affidavit that the EWS category had been incorrectly indicated
and, thereafter, furnished a further undertaking to produce the EWS
certificate within fifteen days. The Commission was, therefore, required
to examine his candidature in the light of the original declaration, the
subsequent affidavit and the undertaking furnished before the interview,
read together with the relevant conditions of the advertisement. More
importantly, the protection afforded in Pankaj Singh was founded upon
the existence of an express provision in General Instruction No. 11
permitting consideration in the Unreserved category, a corresponding
stipulation being required to be established in the present advertisement
before the petitioner can claim an identical consequence. The petitioner
cannot claim the benefit of a condition which is not contained in the
governing advertisement, nor can the ratio of a judgment be extended
beyond the factual and statutory setting in which it was rendered. The
submission that the petitioner had secured sufficient marks in the
Unreserved category cannot, in itself, cure a material violation of the
conditions governing his candidature, if such violation is established from
the record. At the same time, it is clarified that the mere furnishing of an
inconsistent affidavit or failure to produce an EWS certificate cannot,
without more, be elevated to a finding of fraud or deliberate
misrepresentation; such a conclusion must necessarily rest upon the
precise language of the advertisement and cogent material establishing the
nature and effect of the petitioner's declaration. In the present case, if, as
WRIA No. 18348 of 2026
20
borne out from the relevant stipulations of the advertisement, a candidate
furnishing an incorrect or false category declaration is liable to the
consequences prescribed therein, and no corresponding provision exists
permitting automatic conversion of such candidature into the Unreserved
category, the Commission cannot be faulted for enforcing those
conditions.
49. The Court cannot substitute an individualized standard of indulgence
for the uniform criteria governing all candidates, as that would be
antithetical to the principles of fairness, transparency and equality in
public employment embodied in Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution.
Consequently, upon the aforesaid considerations, and subject to the
advertisement containing the stipulated consequence of cancellation and
the Commission having established a material and deliberate
misrepresentation on the petitioner's part, this Court finds no ground
warranting interference with the impugned action.
50. Even otherwise, this Court finds no ground warranting interference
with the impugned order, particularly in view of the fact that the
petitioner's candidature has been validly cancelled in accordance with the
terms and conditions stipulated in the advertisement and the applicable
recruitment framework. Consequent thereto, the Commission has already
recommended the candidature of Suraj Singh against the resultant
vacancy. In the considered opinion of this Court, once the cancellation of
the petitioner's candidature is found to be legally sustainable, the
consequential recommendation made by the Commission cannot be
faulted with. No illegality, arbitrariness or procedural impropriety is,
therefore, discernible in the impugned action so as to warrant interference
by this Court in exercise of its writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.
51. The writ petition is , accordingly. There shall be no order as
dismissed
to costs.
(Mrs. Manju Rani Chauhan,J.)
November 16, 2026
K.N.
Digitally signed by :-
KALP NATH SINGH
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad