NANDLAL RATHI vs KAMALALAYA CENTRE SHOP AND OFFICE OWNERS ASSOCIATION AND ORS

Court
Calcutta High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
AN APPEAL FROM JUDGMENT AND ORDER PASSED IN ITS
ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
ORIGINAL SIDE


APD/4/2026

NANDLAL RATHI
Versus
KAMALALAYA CENTRE SHOP AND OFFICE OWNERS
ASSOCIATION AND ORS.


Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Debangsu Basak
-And-
The Hon’ble Justice Ajay Kumar Gupta



For the Appellant : Mr. Sakabda Roy, Adv.
Mr. S. R. Saha, Adv.

For the Respondent : Mr. Swarup Banerjee, Adv.
Mr. Arindam Chatterjee, Adv.
Ms. Amrita Pandey, Adv.
Ms. Ayushi Mishra, Adv.


HEARING CONCLUDED ON : 16.11.2026
JUDGMENT DELIVERED ON : 16.11.2026


AJAY KUMAR GUPTA, J.:-

1. The instant appeal arises out of a judgment and order dated October
1, 2024 passed by the learned Single Judge in CS/174/2002.
2. By the said judgment, the learned Single Judge has rejected the
prayer for decree for damages for defamation, declaration and
permanent injunction made by the appellant in its entirety.

2
3. The brief facts leading to filing of this instant appeal may be
adumbrated as follows:

a) The defendant no.1 is a society registered under the West Bengal
Societies Registration Act, 1961; defendant nos.2 and 3 are the
Secretary and President of the defendant no.1, respectively.
b) The appellant herein was a founder member and executive
member of the defendant no. 1, who was duly elected in the
election held in the year 2000-2001 from the ground floor of
Kamalalaya Centre. The new office bearers were at loggerheads
with the appellant over the issues of car parking, use of common
space, and maintenance of the building.
c) The appellant was allegedlycollecting some fees for car parking
within the premiseswithout legal authority. These proved to be
detrimental to the existence of the defendant no.1. There was also
litigation between the defendant no.1 and the promoter,
Kamalalaya Centre Shop and Office Owners’ Association, where a
suit was instituted in the City Civil Court at Kolkata against
Kamalalaya Centre Pvt. Ltd., which was registered as Title Suit
No.1620 of 2000.
4. Having heard the submissions and arguments advanced by the
learned counsels for the respective parties and having gone through
the materials made available on the record, it is revealed that the

3
st
appellant has challenged the order dated 1 October, 2024 passed in
connection with C.S. no. 174 of 2002, alleging, inter alia , that the
learned judge erred in not considering that the suit filed by the
appellant/plaintiff has been filed claiming damages for defamation,
declaration and permanent mandatory injunction against the
defendants, when the defendants published a notice dated February
3, 2001, which was hung in a conspicuous place to inform all the
members of the defendant no.1 including the appellant indicating
certain actions of the appellant considered to be prejudicial to the
interest of the Association.
5. The appellant herein, through learned counsel, demanded Rs.10
lakhs as damages in terms of the letter dated February 15, 2001. It
was also alleged that the appellant faced financial loss to the tune of
Rs.5 lakhs for disturbances created by the defendant no.1 as
regards several allegations including collection of car parking fees.
Accordingly, the appellant instituted the suit for damages claiming
Rs.15 lakhs for defamation, declaration that the letter dated
February 3, 2001 is illegal, along with other reliefs.
6. The suit was contested by the defendant filing a written statement.
After adducing evidence from the side of the appellant, the Trial
Court framed eight issues.

4
7. In the course of evidence, the plaintiff adduced oral testimony as
well as presented documentary evidence, whereas the defendant did
not adduce any evidence;however, the defendant exclusively cross-
examined the appellant’s witness.
8. Issue nos. 1, 2 and 3, relating to maintainability, bar of limitation,
and non-joinder or mis-joinder of parties, were taken up together by
the learned Trial Court and decided, holding therein that the prayer
for compensation on account of libel is barred by limitation, as such
a prayer could be made only within one year from the date when
libel was published as per Article 75 of the Limitation Act, 1963.
Therefore, the suit was declared barred by limitationrelating to
publication of alleged libel and defamation.The suit was accordingly
held barred by limitation so far as it related to the publication of the
alleged libel and defamation. As regards the other prayers, it was
held that they were not barred by limitation, the period being three
years for a declaratory decree or permanent injunction. On the
question of non-joinder or mis-joinder of parties, the Trial Court
noted that no specific plea had been taken by the respondent, and
that the point therefore stood decided in favour of the appellant,
although it held that the matter need not be considered any further.
9. The learned Trial Court took up the remaining issues together, for
convenience and to avoid repetition, which are : (i) whether the

5
plaintiff’s membership was illegally terminated by defendant no. 1
without any show cause notice; (ii) whether defendant nos. 1, 2 and
3 defamed the plaintiff and, if so, who is liable for the defamation;
and (iii) whether the plaintiff is entitled to the reliefs prayed for and,
if so, whether the defendants are liable to pay damages and
compensation to the plaintiff together with others.
10. The appellant contends that he was illegally terminated by the
defendant no.1 without show cause notice, as the notice dated
February 3, 2001,which he alleges to be defamatory, demeans the
esteem of the appellant in the eyes of other members. Furthermore,
plaintiff’s membership and membership of the Executive Committee
of the defendant No.1 ceased to exist without assigning any sound or
valid reasons and same was done without giving any opportunity to
the plaintifftherefore, the same should not be given effect.
11. Learned Judge has referred to a letter dated December 15, 2000
which contains a draft Minutes of the Executive Committee meeting
held on November 10, 2000,which was circulated amongst the
members of the executive committee. The contents of the said letter
read as follows:
“Most of the members put on record some activities done by
Sri N. L. Rathi which are detrimental to the interest of the
Association. The house discussed the matter regarding his
activities and decided to issue show cause notice to Sri N. L.

6
Rathi mentioning his attempt to hamper the image and
function of the Association which is undesired and uncalled
for. Further to this his behavior makes him liable for
explanation to the committee as per provisions of the Article
of Associations. The members took a serious view of the
matter and it was decided that the secretary shall call for an
explanation from him about the matter.”
12. Considering the impugned letter, the Trial Court has held the
said notice was based on a resolution and the decision taken by
the committee member was also justified and published. The
appellant objected to the same by producing evidence as Exbt.-D,
i.e., letter dated December 20, 2000. The Trial Court further held
that the notice, which was published by affixation at a
conspicuous place, had come to the appellant’s knowledge, yet he
neither replied to it nor refuted it. It ,therefore, could not be said
that the appellant was denied any opportunity to present his case
before the respondent.The Trial Court also held that the
appellant’sallegation that he was denied the opportunity to
represent his case was demolished by his own contention and
documents presented before the learned court. The learned
Judge also held that the notice dated February 3, 2001 is the
product of a resolution taken in the meeting of the constituted
body and that was the decision made by the members of the
committee based on majority.

7
13. It was further held by the Trial Court that, in terms of the
decision, the committee communicated the decision to the
plaintiff by registered post as well as affixation. So, it was neither
unfair nor opposed to the principle of natural justice.
Communication by affixing the notice dated February 3, 2001
itself is not defamatory and cannot be said to be defamatory. The
contents of the said notice did not specify any defamatory word
against the appellant, which wouldlower his image. Such notice
is an official declaration and comes within the purview of
qualified privilege and communication, made in the course of
legal duty for common interest and purpose.
14. The Trial Court also relied upon a judgment while deciding the
said case, i.e. Hunt v. Great Northern Rly Co. reportedin (1891)
2 QB 189, wherein it was held that a person in performance of
duty is entitled to make defamatory statements against another
person. Further reliance was placed on Pandey Surendra Nath
Sinha v. Bageshwari Pd. reported in AIR 1961 Patna 164 ,
where it was held that a person who makes the statement has
aninterest or duty legal, social or moral interest or duty to pass
such a statement againsta person and such person has a
corresponding interest or duty to receive such statement; itis
privileged and cannot be made the basis of an action for

8
defamation. Trial Court finally relied upon judgments in the case
of Stuart v. Bell , reported in (1891) 2 Q.B. 354 and Smythson v.
Cramp , reported in (1943) 1 All E. R. 326 (C.A.), wherein it was
also held that the occasion is privileged where the defendant has
an interest in communicating to the third person, and the third
person has a corresponding interest in receiving it. Reciprocity of
interest is essential.
15. Learned Advocate appearing for the appellant has drawn the
attention of the Court to the draft Minutes dated November 20,
2000 as well as the covering letter dated December 15, 2000. He
has submitted that, the Minutes of the Executive Committee
claimed to be held on November 20, 2000 was a draft Minutes
and was yet to be finalized.
16. Drawing the attention of the Court to the letter dated February 3,
2001, learned Advocate appearing for the appellant has
submitted that, the decision to cease the membership of the
appellant in the Executive Committee was communicated. He has
contended that, the appellant was not heard prior to such letter
being issued. In any event, according to him, such letter contains
defamatory statements as against the appellant.
17. Learned Advocate appearing for the appellant has contended
that, the appellant made representation through the advocate. He

9
has submitted that, the appellant was entitled to be heard prior
to any decision with regard to the Membership of the appellant
being taken.
18. The appellant has claimed himself to be the Executive Committee
Member of the Association. Life of an Executive Committee is
limited.
19. The Association for which, the appellant has claimed himself to
be a Member of the Executive Committee had held a meeting on
November 20, 2000. In such meeting, the Association had taken
resolution on several agendas including one relating to the
appellant. In such meeting, the Members of the Association had
taken a serious view of the activities of the appellant and resolved
that the Secretary of the Association shall call for an explanation
from the appellant about his activities of collecting parking fees.
The draft Minutes for such meeting had been circulated under
the letter dated December 15, 2000. Thereafter, a letter dated
February 3, 2001 was issued to the appellant informing that the
activities of the appellant were considered to be prejudicial to the
interest of the association and that, the appellant was debarred
from representing the ground floor members in the Executive
Committee in terms of the provisions of the Memorandum and
Articles of Association of the Association.

10
20. We have considered the contents of the letter dated February 3,
2001 and have not found any material which is offending or
defamatory to the appellant. The letter has informed the
appellant that the association considered certain actions of the
appellant to be prejudicial to the interest of the association. It
has thereafter gone on to say that the appellant was debarred to
represent the ground floor members in the Executive Committee.
The decision of the Members of the Association taken on
November 20, 2000 is communicated by the letter dated
December 15, 2000 apparently had formed the basis of the
contents of the letter dated February 3, 2001.
21. Having considered the reasoning of the learned Trial Court, this
Court is in agreement with the conclusions reached. The notice
dated 3rd February, 2001 was issued pursuant to a resolution of
the constituted body of defendant no. 1 and communicated to the
appellant and the members in discharge of the Association’s
duty, on an occasion of qualified privilege. Neither the notice nor
the draft minutes contain any specific imputation capable of
lowering the appellant’s esteem in the eyes of right-thinking
members, and no express malice has been pleaded or proved.
The contention that the appellant was denied a show cause

11
notice or an opportunity of being heard is contradicted by his
own documents.

22. This Court therefore finds that since the appellant has failed to
prove his case, the observation made by the Trial Court is correct
and neither warrants any illegality or perversity nor calls for any
interference.
23. With the above observation, APD/4/2026 is dismissed .
24. Connected application, if any, is also thus disposed of.
25. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
26. Urgent certified copy of this order, if applied for be supplied to
the parties upon usual undertakings.




(AJAY KUMAR GUPTA , J.)


27. I agree .

(DEBANGSU BASAK, J.)



A/s.