Dunar Foods Limited vs Ankit Vats Trading As Avjk Foods Llp & Anr.
- Court
- Delhi High Court
$- J1 & J2
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
BEFORE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV
# CNR No. DLHC010492622024
+ C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 158/2024 and I.A. 36142/2024, I.A.
36143/2024, I.A. 10268/2026, I.A. 18994/2026 & I.A. 21408/2026
DUNAR FOODS LIMITED
NEAR C.W.C., VILLAGE, BAZIDA JATTAN ROAD,
KARNAL, HARYANA -132001 .....PETITIONER
Through: Ms. Swathi Sukumar, Sr. Advocate
with Mr. Junaid Alam, Mr. S. Nithin,
Ms. Rishika Aggarwal and Mr.
Nishant Mattha, Advocates.
versus
ANKIT VATS TRADING AS AVJK FOODS LLP
B-2/308, SECTOR-6, ROHINI, DELHI-110085
ALSO AT
5583, SECOND FLOOR, NAYA BAZAR, DELHI-11006
.....RESPONDENT NO.1
THE REGISTRAR OF TRADEMARKS
BAUDHIK SAMPADA BHAWAN,
PLOT NO.32, SECTOR 14,
DWARKA, NEW DELHI-110078
.....RESPONDENT NO.2
Through: Mr. Utsav Jain, Mr. Hemant Singh,
Ms. Urvashi Jain, Mr. Aman Bidhuri,
Mr. Attrey Gupta, Advocates.
Signature Not Verified
Signature Not Verified
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:19:37
1
# CNR No. DLHC010704862024
+ C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 203/2024, I.A. 42370/2024 & I.A.
42371/2024
ANKIT VATS TRADING AS AVJK FOODS LLP
B-2/308, SECTOR-6, ROHINI, DELHI-110085
.....PETITIONER
Through: Mr. Utsav Jain, Mr. Hemant Singh,
Ms. Urvashi Jain, Mr. Aman Bidhuri,
Mr. Attrey Gupta, Advocates.
versus
DUNAR FOODS LIMITED
NEAR C. W.C., VILLAGE, BAZIDA JATTAN ROAD,
KARNAL. HARYANA- 132001
.....RESPONDENT NO.1
UNION OF INDIA
THE REGISTRAR OF TRADEMARK
DEPARTMENT FOR PROMOTION OF
INDUSTRY AND INTERNAL TRADE
MINISTRY OF COMMERCE AND INDUSTRY
BOUDHIK SAMPADA BHAWAN,
PLOT NO. 32, SECTOR 14, DWARKA,
NEW DELHI - 110078
.....RESPONDENT NO.2
Through: Ms. Swathi Sukumar, Sr. Advocate
with Mr. Junaid Alam, Mr. S. Nithin,
Ms. Rishika Aggarwal and Mr.
Nishant Mattha, Advocates.
Ms. Nidhi Raman, CGSC with Ms.
Nikita Singh and Mr. Rishay Raj,
Advocates for R-2.
Signature Not Verified
Signature Not Verified
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:19:37
2
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% Reserved on: 27.10.2026
Pronounced on: 17.11.2026
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
(The matter was listed for pronouncement on 16.11.2026. However, in view
of 16.11.2026 having been declared a holiday on account of Chhath Puja,
the matter is being pronounced today, i.e., 17.11.2026.)
INDEX
I. FACTS ........................................................................................................ 4
II. SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES ..................................................... 4
III. ANALYSIS ............................................................................................. 5
A. THE OBJECTION OF NON-MAINTAINABILITY ............................ 6
B. THE SCOPE OF APPEAL ..................................................................... 6
C. COMPARISON OF THE RIVAL MARKS AND TRADE DRESS ...... 8
D. THE EVIDENCE OF PRIOR USE ........................................................ 9
E. THE RIGHTS OF PRIOR USER ......................................................... 11
IV. CONCLUSION ..................................................................................... 11
There are two petitions under Section 57 of the Trade Marks Act,
1999 (“the Act”) for cancellation of the registration of each others‟ trade
mark. The petition filed by Dunar Foods Ltd. [ Dunar Foods ] is first in
order. The other petition filed by Ankit Vats Trading as AVJK Foods LLP
[ Ankit Vats ] is subsequent and hence the primary facts are extracted from
Signature Not Verified
Signature Not Verified
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:19:37
3
the petition filed by Dunar Foods.
I. FACTS
2. Dunar Foods claimed to have coined and adopted the distinctive
trademark NAWAJISH/NAWAZISH in the year 2017 for rice and allied
products under Class 30. It had obtained registration for NAWAJISH for
the stylized and device representation of the mark with user claimed from
13.10.2007. There was some clerical oversight in spelling and instead of the
word “J” it was typed as “G” which was later rectified.
3. The petitioner found in the year 2024 that Ankit Vats was marketing
identical goods in the form of basmati rice under packaging bearing a
deceptively similar mark and artistic trade. On enquiry, it was discovered
that Ankit Vats had obtained the registration for the impugned mark
NAWAJISH with the device mark “N” in the year 2017 under Class 30.
The same was obtained on a proposed to be used basis. The petitioner
Dunar Food had issued legal cease and desist notice. Non-compliance
thereto had constrained the petitioner to file the instant petition.
4. It appears that as a counter-blast Ankit Vats filed a subsequent
petition seeking cancellation of the petitioner‟s trademark.
5. The pleadings were completed. The parties were allowed to file
written submissions and the relevant decisions.
II. SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES
6. Ms. Swathi Sukumar, learned senior counsel appearing for the Dunar
Food Ltd. made various submissions inter alia that Dunar Food is the prior
Signature Not Verified
Signature Not Verified
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:19:37
4
adopter, continuous user and registered proprietor of the mark since April,
2007, almost one decade before filing of the application by Ankit Vats.
Various decisions have been cited to establish that registration of the similar
mark for identical goods i.e. rice under Class 30 by the Ankit Vats is
impermissible in law and violates Dunar Food‟s pioneering presence
violating Sections 9(1)(a), 9(2)(a), 11(1), 11(3), 11(10) and 18(4) of the Act.
It is contended that alleged non-use by Dunar Food is an argument of
afterthought and is not substantiated, same had been sufficiently rebutted on
the strength of the record.
7. Mr. Utsav Jain, learned counsel appearing for the Ankit Vats raises an
objection regarding maintainability in view of the provisions of Sections 4
and 5 of the Maharashtra Protection of Interest of Depositors (in Financial
Establishment) Act, 1999. It has been contended that owing to notice by the
Economic Offence Wing on 01.02.2016 and the action of Directorate of
Enforcement under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 without
the express permission from the designated MPID Special Court under
Section 10 of the MPID Act, the petitioner lacks locus standi to maintain the
rectification proceedings.
8. On merits, it is contended that Ankit Vats enjoys honest concurrent
user‟s right under a specially crafted device mark featuring the letter “N”.
The reliance is also placed on various decisions.
9. I have heard the learned counsels appearing for the parties and have
perused the record.
III. ANALYSIS
Signature Not Verified
Signature Not Verified
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:19:37
5
A. THE OBJECTION OF NON-MAINTAINABILITY
10. The intellectual property rights are sought to be protected by way of
instant petition. Dunar Foods has been discharged from all its liabilities.
The company underwent corporate resolution proceedings, alongside which
provisional attachment orders were issued by the Enforcement Directorate
(ED) and what was directed was not to create any third-party interest
regarding the intellectual property without permission of the designated
Court. During these proceedings, there is no such allegation of creating any
third-party rights etc. and which otherwise is also borne out by the scope of
Section 57. As held by this Court in Rajiv Chakraborty Resolution
1
Professional of EEIL v. Directorate of Enforcement , that attachment is
not liable to be viewed as an effacement of all rights that may exist or be
claimed by an individual. It is essentially a fetter placed upon the possessor
of that property to deal with the same till such time as proceedings under the
aforesaid enactment come to a definitive conclusion. Therefore, protection
of intellectual property rights by invoking legal proceedings neither has been
interdicted nor restricted.
B. THE SCOPE OF APPEAL
11. The scope of Section 57 of the Act empowers this Court to expunge
or vary an entry where it was made in the Register without sufficient cause,
or where it is wrongly remaining on the Register. This Court in Blue
2
Heaven Cosmetics Pvt. Ltd. v. Deepak Arora and Ors. , held that Section
57 serves as a vital statutory mechanism to maintain the purity of the
1
2022 SCC OnLine Del 3703
2
2022 SCC OnLine Del 1001
Signature Not Verified
Signature Not Verified
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:19:37
6
Register by ensuring that entries obtained contrary to the statutory
framework or without lawful justification do not encumber public records.
Expanding upon this, this Court held that where a mark is registered in
violation of the absolute or relative grounds for refusal, it stands 'wrongly
entered and wrongly remaining' on the Register, thereby warranting direct
cancellation.
12. This Court in Russell Corp Australia Pty. Ltd. v. Ashok Mahajan
3
and Anr. further elaborated on the threshold for wrong entries, it held that
an entry in the Register is wrongly made or remaining if any ground for
refusal under Section 9 or Section 11 of the Act is established at the time of
registration or subsequently. It was further underscored that the adoption of
an identical or deceptively similar mark for identical goods by a subsequent
trader without any plausible explanation or bona fide justification constitutes
a dishonest attempt to usurp the reputation and goodwill of the prior
proprietor, rendering the registration legally unsustainable and liable to be
expunged under Section 57.
13. It is, thus, well established that this Court is fully empowered to direct
for cancellation or barring of the registration on the ground of contravention
or failure to observe a condition entered on the Registrar in relation thereto.
The parties have already been granted sufficient opportunity to establish
their case. The Court, thus, has to undertake an enquiry and if is convinced
that there is a contravention of the provisions of the Trade Marks Act and
the mark in question is deceptively adopted/registered, the necessary
directions for cancellation would follow.
Signature Not Verified
Signature Not Verified
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:19:37
7
C. COMPARISON OF THE RIVAL MARKS AND TRADE DRESS
Mark of the petitioner, i.e.,
Mark of the respondent no. 1, i.e.,
DUNAR FOODS LIMITED
ANKIT VATS TRADING AS
AVJK FOODS LLP
14. A side-by-side comparison of the competing marks and their
respective product packaging demonstrates that they are phonetically and
visually identical. Both the marks are registered in respect of identical
goods, i.e., rice falling under Class 30. The device mark “N” in the Ankit
3
(2023) 4 HCC (Del) 301
Signature Not Verified
Signature Not Verified
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:19:37
8
Vats packaging fails to create any meaningful difference bearing in mind the
registration under same class. In the marketplace, consumers rarely have the
opportunity for a thorough comparison; consequently, a minor device
feature of this nature is entirely insufficient to avert consumer confusion.
15. Furthermore, the difference of the word “Z” instead of “J” will also be
of no assistance. Phonetically, both words are pronounced similarly and the
same seems to have been done calculatively with a view to pass off the
plaintiff‟s goods. Such minor tweaks and design variations do not appear to
be done honestly, rather when compared against the petitioner‟s long
standing prior use, the adoption of an identical sounding term seems to have
been done deliberately.
D. THE EVIDENCE OF PRIOR USE
16. Dunar Food has placed on record the material to indicate that it is
using the same mark since 2007. Tracing its corporate lineage back to an
enterprise established in the year 1956 by Late Shri Lala Duli Chand Ji, the
business was subsequently formalized under the company name Dulichand
Narender Kumar Exports Private Limited in 1997, which later changed its
name to Dunar Foods Limited on 29.12.2010. The petitioner claims to be
amongst India's largest manufacturers, millers, and exporters of premium
Basmati rice, boasting massive paddy processing capacities, global
accreditations and phenomenal global sales volumes running into thousands
of lakhs.
17. Dunar Food obtained registration for the mark „NAWAJISH‟ under
Application No. 1550388 on 17.04.2007, which proceeded to registration on
Signature Not Verified
Signature Not Verified
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:19:37
9
31.03.2009. Furthermore, its predecessor company filed Application No.
2055689 on 19.11.2010 for the stylized and device representation of the
mark with a user claim dating from 13.10.2007, which was registered on
29.05.2015 wherein due to a clerical oversight the spelling was initially put
in as „NAWAGISH‟ instead of „NAWAJISH‟, which was subsequently
rectified. This conclusively establishes Dunar Food‟s long-standing presence
and prior commercial adoption in the market well over a decade before the
respondent no. 1 filed its application on 26.06.2017 on a “proposed to be
used basis”.
18. Conversely, Ankit Vats applied for an identical mark for goods in the
very field in which the petitioner trades, strictly on a “proposed to be used”
basis. It deals in food products and Basmati rice under Class 30.
“NAWAJISH” is not a common dictionary word; it is a distinctive and
arbitrary term that forms an integral part of the petitioner‟s established brand
identity and corporate goodwill. There is nothing on record to explain how
respondent no. 1 came to adopt this exact mark. When a trader in the same
field adopts an identical coined word for identical goods without any
plausible explanation or bona fide justification, the only reasonable
inference is that the adoption was not honest and was designed to ride upon
the prior user's established reputation.
4
19. As held in Dorco Co. Ltd. v. Durga Enterprises and Anr., , a
respondent cannot claim to be the proprietor of an impugned trademark
where there is an absence of any explanation regarding its adoption,
rendering such an application in contravention of Section 18(1) of the Act.
Signature Not Verified
Signature Not Verified
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:19:37
10
Similarly, as observed in Russell Corp (supra) the adoption of an identical
mark for identical goods under such circumstances constitutes a dishonest
attempt to usurp the reputation of the prior proprietor.
E. THE RIGHTS OF PRIOR USER
20. The law is well-settled that the rights of a prior user are superior to
5
those of a later registrant. In S. Syed Mohideen vs. P. Sulochana Bai, the
Supreme Court held as follows, after reading Sections 27, 28 and 34 of the
Act together:
“30.4. … Thus, the scheme of the Act is such where rights of
prior user are recognised superior than that of the registration
and even the registered proprietor cannot disturb/interfere with
the rights of prior user. …”
21. In view of the petitioner‟s prior use and goodwill, use of the identical
mark by the respondent no. 1 for identical goods is likely to deceive the
public and cause confusion as to the source of the goods. Such use would be
liable to be restrained under the law of passing off. The registration was
therefore barred by Sections 9(2)(a) and 11(3)(a) of the Act. As held in Amit
6
Sood vs. Union of India and Ors , under Section 11 of the Act, any mark
that would result in passing off of a business of the applicant of the mark
would not be liable to be registered.
IV. CONCLUSION
22. In view of the aforesaid, the adoption of the impugned mark by the
respondent no. 1 is found to be dishonest and violative of statutory
4
2023 SCC OnLine Del 1484
5
2016 2 SCC 683
6
2024SCCOnLine Del 3226.
Signature Not Verified
Signature Not Verified
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:19:37
11
provisions, and, therefore, the same is set aside. Consequently, the petition
[C.O.(COMM.IPD -TM) 158/2024] is allowed, and the registration of the
impugned mark „NAWAZISH‟ bearing Application No. 3578464 in Class
30 along with the Registration Certificate No. 1741844 in the Register of
Trade Marks is hereby cancelled and set aside. All pending applications also
stand disposed of.
C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 203/2024, I.A. 42370/2024 & I.A. 42371/2024
23. For the same reasons assigned above, the petitioner herein has failed
to make out any case for interference, and accordingly, the petition filed by
Ankit Vats stands dismissed. All pending applications also stand disposed
of.
24. The date already fixed in both matters before the Joint Registrar i.e.,
22.01.2027, stands cancelled.
(PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV)
JUDGE
NOVEMBER 17, 2026
AB/Tr
Signature Not Verified
Signature Not Verified
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:19:37
12