THE DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER vs PRABHAYYA S/O. PANCHAYYA CHOUKIMATH
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17889
WP No. 107903 of 2016
CNR: KAHC020022402016
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT DHARWAD
TH
DATED THIS THE 30 DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA
WRIT PETITION NO.107903 OF 2016 (L-KSRTC)
BETWEEN:
THE DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER,
NWKRTC, BAGALKOT DIVISION,
BAGALKOT,
THE PETITIONER IS REPRESENTED BY
ITS CHIEF LAW OFFICER,
NWKRTC CENTRAL OFFICE, HUBBALLI.
…PETITIONER
(BY SMT. RENUKA A/W
SRI. M.M. KHANNUR, ADVOCATE)
AND:
PRABHAYYA S/O. PANCHAYYA CHOUKIMATH,
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS, OCC: NIL,
R/O: C/O: V.P. CHOUKIMATH, KALLIKPETHY,
BADAMI, TQ: BADAMI, DIST: BAGALKOT.
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. S.K. HEGDE, ADVOCATE)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF
THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, 1950, PRAYING TO, ISSUE A
WRIT IN THE NATURE OF CERTIORARI THEREBY QUASH THE
AWARD DATED 14.11.2014 PASSED BY THE PRESIDING
OFFICER LABOUR COURT VIJAYAPUR IN APL.NO.28/2014 AND
CONSEQUENTLY BE PLEASED TO DISMISS THE APL.NO.28/2014
FILED BY THE RESPONDENT AND THE COPY OF THE SAME IS
PRODUCED IS AT ANNEXURE-C TO THE WRIT PETITION IN THE
INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
Digitally signed
by RAKESH S
HARIHAR
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka,
Dharwad Bench
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17889
WP No. 107903 of 2016
CNR: KAHC020022402016
THIS WRIT PETITION, COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY
HEARING B GROUP THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS
UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA
ORAL ORDER
The petitioner-North-West Karnataka Road Transport
Corporation (hereinafter referred to as ‘Corporation’ for
short) stands before the Court calling in question the award
dated 14.11.2014 passed by the Presiding Officer, Labour
Court, Bijapur (hereinafter referred to as ‘Labour Court’ for
short) in Application No.28/2014, by which the Labour
Court allowed the application filed under Section 33C(2) of
the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (hereinafter referred to as
‘ID Act’ for short) directing the petitioner/Corporation to
pay Rs.6,51,057/- to the workman within three months.
2. Heard the learned counsel Smt. H.R. Renuka
along with learned counsel Sri. S.K. Hegde for the
respondent/workman.
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17889
WP No. 107903 of 2016
CNR: KAHC020022402016
3. Facts, in brief, germane are as follows:
The respondent was working as a driver in the
petitioner/Corporation at the relevant point in time. The
respondent was dismissed from service on 23.07.2011 for
misconduct. The respondent thereafter moves an
application before the Labour Court under Section 33-C(2)
of the ID Act claiming back wages from the date of
dismissal. The award of the Labour Court is as follows:
“8. Point No.1:- The applicant (PW.1) has
reiterated the averments of the application in his
affidavit evidence. By entering into witness box, he
has spoken to the documents at Ex.P.1 and 2. During
the cross-examination he has admitted that he has
not challenged the order of dismissal. Further he has
denied the suggestion that he has claimed more
Basic and HRA and not entitled for `6,51,057/-.
9. Ex.P.1 is the copy of order of dismissal
dated 23.07.2011. The applicant has been dismissed
from service on the misconduct of remaining
unauthorizedly absent to duty for the period from
28.06.2010 to 22.09.2010. Ex.P.2 is the copy of
Note dated 12.08.2011, issued by the Director (P&E)
of KSRTC, Central Office, Bangalore. This Note has
been issued on the basis of the Judgment of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Jaipur Zila Sahakari
Bhoomi Vikas Bank Ltd. Vs. Ram Gopal Sharma.
Through this Note the Disciplinary Authorities have
been advised to file approval application in
I.D.No.148/2005 on the file of Industrial Tribunal in
case of dismissal /discharge /termination
/retrenchment of an employee and to comply with
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17889
WP No. 107903 of 2016
CNR: KAHC020022402016
Sec.33(2)(b) of I.D.Act. As per Ex.P.2, all the
Disciplinary Authorities were advised to file an
approval application U/Sec.33(2)(b) of I.D.Act in
I.D.No.148/2005 pending on the file of Industrial
Tribunal, Bangalore. In the present case no such
application is filed.
10. On the other hand RW.1 has filed an
affidavit in lieu of oral evidence, the contents of
which are bereft of pleadings. However, he has
stated that the claim of Rs.6,51,057/- is exorbitant
and baseless. It is also stated that the basic shown in
the calculation memo is excessive. At the same time
the respondent has not produced any calculation
statement, which according to him is correct.
Therefore, I am unable to appreciate the conduct of
the respondent. By entering into witness box, RW.1
has deposed to the documents at Ex.R.1 to 40.
Ex.R.40 is the authorization letter issued by the
respondent in favour of RW.1 to give evidence.
Ex.R.1 to 39 are the various records pertaining to the
domestic enquiry and pasing of order of dismissal
dated 23.07.2011. The applicant has not disputed his
dismissal from service. His only contention is that the
respondent has not complied with the provisions of
Sec.33 (2) (b) of I.D.Act and hence, the order of
dismissal is non-est and ineffective. Therefore, I am
of the considered opinion that the documents at
Ex.R.1 to 39 are of no help to the respondent.
11. Sec.33(2)(b) of I.D.Act provides that no
workman shall be discharged or dismissed unless he
has been paid wages for one month and application
has been made by the employer to the authority
before whom the proceeding is pending, for approval
of the action taken by the employer. It is an
undisputed fact that I.D.No.148/2005 is pending
before the Industrial Tribunal, Bangalore which is
raised by the KSRTC Staff and Workers Federation
with regard to wage revision and other benefits. The
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17889
WP No. 107903 of 2016
CNR: KAHC020022402016
respondent has not disputed that the applicant is
interested in that matter.
12. The learned counsel for the applicant has
relied upon the decision reported in AIR 2012 SC 643
(Jaipur Zila Sahakari Bhoomi Vikas Bank Ltd. Vs. Sri.
Ram Gopal Sharma & others) the Hon’ble Supreme
Court has clearly held that non-approval of order of
dismissal or failure to make application U/Sec.33
(2)(b) seeking approval renders dismissal in-
operative-dismissal becomes ineffective from the
date it was passed- employee becomes entitled to
the wages from the date of dismissal to the date of
disapproval of application. The Hon’ble Supreme
Court has discussed various provisions of the I.D.Act,
1947 and upheld the order of the Tribunal, which has
dismissed the application U/Sec.33(2)(b) as the
employer had not paid the salary for one month at
the time of passing the order of dismissal. This
decision makes it clear that if a workman is
dismissed by the employer, he has to be paid the
salary for one month and an approval application
U/Sec.33 (2)(b) of the Act has to be filed before the
Authority where the matter is pending. Therefore,
non-compliance of Sec.33 (2)(b) of the Act renders
the order of dismissal ineffective from inception
itself.
13. Further reliance is also placed on the
decision of the Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka
reported in 2013(3) KAR. L.J. 415. In that case as
many as 10 Writ Petitions were clubbed based on the
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Jaipur Zila
Sahakari Bhoomi Vikas Bank Ltd. Vs. Sri. Ram Gopal
Sharma & others, the Hon’ble High Court has held
that the dismissal or discharge of workman would be
of no effect and such workman would continue to be
in service as if there never was any dismissal or
discharge, if the mandatory provision of Sec.33
(2)(b) is not complied with. Accordingly the workman
is entitled for 100% back wages, continuity of
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17889
WP No. 107903 of 2016
CNR: KAHC020022402016
service and all other benefits. In those cases the
Labour Court had set aside the orders of dismissal
for non-compliance of Sec.33 (2)(b) of I.D.Act and
directed the respondent to reinstate the petitioners
therein with 50% back wages. But the Hon’ble High
Court has modified the award and granted 100%
back wages instead of 50%. This decision is aptly
applicable to the case on hand and it helps the
applicant fully.
14. Further reliance is also placed on the
unreported decision of the Hon’ble High Court of
Karnataka rendered in W.P.No.14465/2010 (L-
KSRTC) (BMTC Vs. S.B.Lakshman, since deceased by
L.Rs.) In that case said Lakshman was also
dismissed from service but the respondent had not
filed approval application U/Sec.33 (2) (b) of I.D.Act.
Hence, said Lakshman had filed application U/Sec.33
C (2) of I.D.Act seeking arrears of wages and said
application came to be allowed by the Labour Court.
In the Writ Petition the Hon’ble High Court by relying
upon the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Jaipur Zila Sahakari Bhoomi Vikas Bank Ltd. Vs. Ram
Gopal Sharma & others, has upheld the order of
Labour Court and held that said workman was
entitled for arrears of wages. This decision also
makes it amply clear that non-filing of approval
application U/Sec.33 (2) (b) of I.D.Act in pending
I.D.No.148/2005 on the file of Industrial Tribunal,
Bangalore, makes the order of dismissal of present
applicant ineffective and null and void. Consequently,
the applicant is deemed to have continued in service.
Therefore, he is entitled for arrears of wages from
the date of order of dismissal i.e., 23.07.2011 to
30.04.2014. Since the applicant is deemed to have
continued in service, the respondent has got right to
extract work from the applicant. For that purpose the
respondent can issue notice and call upon the
applicant to join duty. If the applicant does not turn
up, then he commits default. Therefore, he forfeits
his right to claim wages for the default period.
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17889
WP No. 107903 of 2016
CNR: KAHC020022402016
15. The learned counsel for the respondent
has argued that the applicant had remained
unauthorizedly absent to duty and hence enquiry
was held and on the basis of report of enquiry, the
order of dismissal is passed. Since, the order of
dismissal is not challenged by the applicant, the
present application is not maintainable. This
submission cannot be accepted, in view of the above
noted decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court and
Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka. The respondent has
vaguely denied the correctness of the calculation of
arrears made by the applicant. The respondent has
not furnished any calculation of arrears, which is
correct according to him. Under these circumstances,
I have no other go except to accept the calculation of
arrears of wages made by the application at
annexure-1. Therefore, I am of the considered
opinion that the applicant is entitled for arrears of
wages of `6,51,057/- for the application period. At
the same time the applicant is not entitled for the
interest as claimed, since he has not worked for the
said period. With these observations, I answer Point
No.1 partly in the affirmative and proceed to pass
the following:
O R D E R
The application filed U/Sec.33 C (2) of
Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, is hereby partly
allowed.
The respondent is hereby directed to pay a
sum of `6,51,057/-, to the applicant, as
arrears of wages for the period from
23.07.2011 to 30.04.2014, within 3 months
from today. In default thereof, the respondent
shall pay the said amount together with
interest @ 9% p.a. from the date of this
application till the date of realisation.”
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17889
WP No. 107903 of 2016
CNR: KAHC020022402016
4. Learned counsel Smt. H.R. Renuka, appearing
for the petitioner/Corporation would submit that the order
of dismissal has not been challenged before any Court of
law and has attained finality. Learned counsel would submit
that the award of the Labour Court is without jurisdiction as
there is no challenge to the order of dismissal.
5. Learned counsel Sri. S.K. Hegde, appearing for
the respondent/workman would submit that the order of
dismissal is non-est and that the award passed by the
Labour Court cannot be found fault with. Learned counsel
would seek dismissal of the petition.
6. I have given my anxious consideration to the
submissions made by the respective learned counsel and
have perused the material available on record.
7. The afore-narrated facts and link in the chain of
events are a matter of record and would require no
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17889
WP No. 107903 of 2016
CNR: KAHC020022402016
reiteration. The issue in the lis lies in a narrow compass.
The issue is, whether the Labour Court could entertain the
application under Section 33-C(2) of the ID Act without
there being any challenge to the order of dismissal by the
respondent/workman before any forum. The issue is no
longer res-integra in the light of judgment of the co-
ordinate Bench of this Court in the case of KARNATAKA
STATE ROAD TRANSPORT CORPORATION v. C.V.
1
VENKATARAVANA , wherein it is held as follows:
“…. …. ….
13. In view of the above factual aspects of the
matter the question for consideration is, "Whether
respondent-workman could resort for filing application
under Section 33C(2) of the I.D.Act in the absence of
challenge to the order of dismissal dated 08.03.2008 by
the petitioner-Corporation or not?
14. The moment respondent-workman was
dismissed from service on 08.03.2008, he ceased to
be a workman of the petitioner-Corporation. The
respondent's contention is that dismissal order dated
08.03.2008 was not approved in terms of Section
33(2)(b) of the I.D.Act, therefore, order of dismissal
is void. Consequently, respondent-workman has
resorted to invoke Section 33C(2) of the I.D.Act in
submitting application. However, the ingredients of
Section 33C(2) of the I.D.Act is required to be taken
into consideration in deciding whether
respondentworkman's application is maintainable or
1
Writ Petition No.24649 of 2016, decided on 16.04.2021
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17889
WP No. 107903 of 2016
CNR: KAHC020022402016
not. Undisputed facts are that respondent-workman
was dismissed from service on 08.03.2008 before
submission of application filed under Section 33C(2)
of the I.D.Act. There was no relationship between
employee and employer as on the date of submission
of application. For invoking Section 33C(2) of the
I.D.Act, one of the ingredient is that there must be a
relationship between the employee and employer.
Therefore, in the absence of challenge to the order of
dismissal dated 08.03.2008 before the appropriate
forum, application filed under Section 33C(2) of
I.D.Act by the respondent-workman and entertaining
such application by the Labour Court are contrary to
Section 33C(2) of the I.D.Act read with the order of
dismissal dated 08.03.2008. In other words,
ingredients of Section 33C(2) of the I.D.Act was not
compiled before presentation of Application
No.9/2014 by the respondent. On this ground alone,
petitioner-Corporation has made out case so as to
interfere with the impugned order dated 24.11.2015
passed by the III Additional Labour Court, Bengaluru
in Application No.9/2014. That apart, delay and
laches for the period from i.e. 8.3.2008 to 24.3.2014
i.e. from the date of dismissal till the date of filing
App.No.9/2014 has not been explained. Respondent-
workman availed all terminal benefits without any
protest. Thereafter, he cannot claim any benefits
beyond the date of dismissal.
…. …. ….
18. Scope of application under Section 33C(2) of
the I.D.Act is to invoke the jurisdiction of the Labour Court
under Section 33C(2) two ingredients must be present.
The first is that a workman must be entitled to receive
from the employer any money or benefit which is capable
of being computed in terms of money and the other one is
that a question must have arisen as to the amount of
money due, or as to the amount of such benefit has to be
computed. Reading to the Section reveals that the Labour
Court has jurisdiction to decide both these ingredients.
Therefore, in a case where one or both of these ingredients
are satisfied, the Labour Court will have jurisdiction to
determine the question. The Legislature has empowered
the Labour Court to decide a dispute as to the right of
workman to receive from the employer any money or any
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17889
WP No. 107903 of 2016
CNR: KAHC020022402016
benefit which is capable of being computed in terms of
money and also has authorised it to decide the question as
to the amount of money due or to the amount at which
such benefit has to be computed.
19. The Labour Court has no jurisdiction to
first decide the workmen's entitlement and then
proceed to compute the benefit so adjudicated on
that basis in exercise of its power under Section
33C(2) of the I.D.Act. It is only when the entitlement
has been earlier adjudicated has been recognised by
the employer thereafter, for the purpose of
implementation or enforcement thereof, some
ambiguity requires interpretation that the
interpretation is treated as incidental to the Labour
Court's power as held by the Apex Court in the case
of MCD VS Ganesh Razak and another reported in
1995 - 1 L.L.N. S.C. 402.
20. In the case of State of U.P. VS Brijpal
Singh reported in 2005 VIII AD(SC) 250. Paragraph 15
held as under:-
"15. Thus it is clear from the principle
enunciated in the above decisions that appropriate
forum where question of back wages could be decided
is only in a proceeding to whom a reference under
Section 10 of Act is made. Thereafter, the Labour
Court, in the instant case, cannot arrogate to itself
functions of an Industrial Tribunal and entertain the
claim made by the respondent herein which is not
based on an existing right but which may
appropriately be made the subject matter of an
industrial dispute in reference under Section 10 of the
I.D. Act. Therefore, the Labour Court has no
jurisdiction to them adjudicate the claim made
by the respondent herein under Section 33C(2)
of the I.D. Act in an undetermined claim and
until such adjudication is made by the
appropriate forum, the respondent-workman
cannot ask the Labour Court in an application
under Section 33C(2) of the I.D. Act disregard
his dismissal as wrongful and on that basis to
compute his wages. It is therefore, impossible for us
to accept the arguments of Mrs. Shymala Pappu that
the respondent-workman can file application under
Section 33C(2) for determination and payment of
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17889
WP No. 107903 of 2016
CNR: KAHC020022402016
wages on the basis that he continues to be in service
pursuant to the said order passed by the High Court in
Writ Petition No. 15172 of 1987 dated 28.10.1987.
The LCA 18/2006/2003 argument by the learned
counsel for the workman has no force and is
unacceptable . The Labour Court, in our opinion,
has erred in allowing the application filed under
Section 33C(2) of the I.D. Act and ordering
payment of not only the salary but also bonus to
the workman although he has not attended the
office of the appellants after the stay order
obtained by him. The Labour Court has
committed a manifest error of law in passing the
order in question which was rightly impugned
before the High Court and erroneously dismissed
by the High Court. The High Court has also equally
committed a manifest error in not considering the
scope of Section 33C(2) of the I.D. Act. We, therefore,
have no hesitation in setting aside the order passed by
the Labour Court in Misc. Cases No. 11 of 1993 dated
23.8.1995 and the order dated 9.1.2002 passed by
the High Court in C.M.W.P. No. 36406 of 1995 as
illegal and incalled for. We do so accordingly."
21. In the case of Jeet Lal Sharma Vs. Presiding
Officer, Labour Court IVTH and Another reported in 2000
(85) FLR 268, Ganesh Razak's Case (Supra) has been
quoted, wherein it is held as under:-
" It is clear from the above legal position
that without prior adjudication or settlement on
the point of entitlement (it is entitlement in
general, period of entitlement and rate of
entitlement) application under Section 33-C(2)
of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 is not
maintainable. In the present LCA, there is no claim
of LCA 18/2006/2003 applicant/petitioner that there is
any prior adjudication or settlement as regards
entitlement of leave encashment for 188 days as
claimed. I am of the considered view that present LCA
is not maintainable under Section 33-C(2) of Industrial
Disputes Act 1947 and the same is dismissed. File be
consigned to record room."
22. In the case of Rai Bahadur Narain Singh
Sugar Mills Ltd., Vs. Mangey Ram reported in (2019) 9
SCC 365.
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17889
WP No. 107903 of 2016
CNR: KAHC020022402016
(8) When the matter of payment of wages
from 1995 to 2005 was left to the decision of the
employer, the wages as ordered by the Labour
Court in the proceedings under Section 33-C(2)
of the I.D. Act would not be justified. Since the
High Court had directed that the appellant herein shall
consider the representation of the respondent for
wages for intervening period, the consideration in that
regard was necessary to be made by the appellant and
the order of the Labour Court dated 06.08.2011 is
unsustainable. In Municipal Corporation of Delhi v.
Ganesh Razak and Anr., (1995) 1 SCC 235, it was
held by this Court as under:
“12. The High Court has referred to some of
these decisions but missed the true import thereof.
The ratio of these decisions clearly indicates that
where the very basis of the claim or the
entitlement of the workmen to a certain benefit
is disputed, there being no earlier adjudication
or recognition thereof by the employer, the
dispute relating to entitlement is not incidental
to the benefit claimed and is, therefore, clearly
outside the scope of the proceeding under
Section 33-C(2) of the Act. The Labour Court has
no jurisdiction to first decide the workmen’s
entitlement and then proceed to compute the
benefit so adjudicated on that basis in exercise
of its power under Section 33-C(2) of the Act. It
is only when the entitlement has been earlier
adjudicated or recognised by the employer and
thereafter for the purpose of implementation or
enforcement thereof some ambiguity requires
interpretation that the interpretation is treated
as incidental to the Labour Court’s power under
Section 33-C(2) like that of the Executing Court’s
power to interpret the decree for the purpose of
its execution .” Likewise the scope of Section 6(H)(2)
of the U.P. Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 is also limited
to calculation of monetary benefits where right has
already been adjudicated.”
23. Analysis of the factual aspects of the case
that respondent-workman was dismissed from
service and the management in not invoking Section
33(2)(b) of the I.D. Act does not give any right to
the respondent-workman to submit application
under Section 33C(2) of the I.D.Act. Without
compliance to the ingredients of the said provision,
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17889
WP No. 107903 of 2016
CNR: KAHC020022402016
application under Section 33C(2) of the I.D.Act is not
maintainable as held by various Courts cited supra.
In order to entertain application under Section
33C(2) of the I.D.Act, the ingredients under the said
provision were required to be examined. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Ganesh Razak (supra)
concluded that ratio of decision clearly indicates that
where the very basis of the claim or entitlement of
the workmen to a certain benefit is disputed, there
being no earlier adjudication or recognition thereof
by the employer, the dispute relating to entitlement
is not incidental to the benefit claimed and is,
therefore, clearly outside the scope of a proceeding
under Section 33C(2) of the I.D. Act and the Labour
Court has no jurisdiction to first decide the
workmen’s entitlement and then proceed to compute
the benefit so adjudicated on that basis in exercise
of its power under Section 33C(2) of the I.D. Act. It
is only when the entitlement has been earlier
adjudicated or recognised by the employer and
thereafter for the purpose of implementation or
enforcement thereof some ambiguity requires
interpretation that the interpretation is treated as
incidental to the Labour Court’s power under Section
33C(2) of the I.D. Act like that of Executing Court’s
power to interpret the decree for the purpose of its
execution which is evident from para.12 of the
Judgment in Ganesh Razak’s case (supra). As on the
date of submission of application under Section
33C(2) of the I.D.Act by the respondent-workman,
he ceased to be an employee/workman.
Consequently, application filed under Section 33C(2)
of the I.D.Act is not maintainable before the Labour
Court and it has no vested jurisdiction. Hence, the
following:
ORDER
The Labour Court has committed manifest error in
entertaining application filed by the respondent-workman
under Section 33C(2) of the I.D.Act. Therefore, order
dated 24.11.2015 passed by the III Additional Labour
Court, Bengaluru in Application No.9/2014 vide Annexure-F
stands set aside. Accordingly, writ petition stands allowed.”
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17889
WP No. 107903 of 2016
CNR: KAHC020022402016
The afore-quoted judgment of the learned Single Judge was
challenged before the Division Bench in the case of C.V.
2
VENKATARAMANA v. K.S.R.T.C , wherein the Division
Bench confirmed the order of the learned Single Judge
quoted supra . The Division Bench has held as follows:
“…. …. ….
6. We have considered the submissions made on
both sides and have perused the record. The scope and
ambit of Section 33C(2) of the Act is well defined by
catena of decisions. The Supreme Court in
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION OF DELHI Vs. GANESH
RAZAK AND ANOTHER [(1995) 1 SCC 235] has held
that a workman can proceed under Section 33C(2) of
the Act only after the Tribunal has adjudicated a
complaint under Section 33(a) of the Act or on a
reference under Section 10 of the Act that the order
of discharge or dismissal was not justified and has
set aside the order and has reinstated the workman.
It has further been held that the nature of
proceeding under Section 33C(2) of the Act is in the
nature of an executive proceeding which pre-
supposes adjudication of the liability in respect of a
right which has to be enforced. Similar view has been
taken by the Supreme Court in CENTRAL INLAND
WATER TRANSPORT CORPORATION LIMITED Vs.
WORKMEN AND ANOTHER [(1974) 4 SCC 696].
7. In the instant case, admittedly there is no
adjudication in respect of the order of dismissal, that
the same has been passed in violation of Section
33(2)(b) of the Act. Similarly, it is also not in dispute
that the claim made by the appellant in respect of his
wages for a period from 08.03.2008 till 22.03.2014,
there has been no adjudication. The Corporation has
disputed the entitlement of the appellant to claim
wages for the aforesaid period by filing statement of
2
Writ Appeal No.541 of 2021, decided on 01.03.2023
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17889
WP No. 107903 of 2016
CNR: KAHC020022402016
objections. Therefore, in the absence of any
adjudication of the right of the appellant to recover
the amount in question from the Corporation, the
Labour Court could not have adjudicated the liability
in a proceeding under Section 33C(2) of the Act and
could not have passed the impugned order.
8. Sofar as reference made by the learned counsel
for the appellant on the decisions relied upon by him is
concerned, the same are an authority for a proposition that
in case an order of dismissal is passed in violation of
Section 33(2)(b) of the Act, the same is void. However, it
is trite law that even a void order is required to be
challenged, otherwise it binds the parties.
The learned Single Judge has therefore rightly
quashed the order passed by the Labour Court dated
24.11.2015.
For the aforementioned reasons, we do not find any
ground to differ with the view taken by the learned Single
Judge.
In the result, the appeal fails and is hereby
dismissed.”
(Emphasis supplied at each instance)
8. In the light of the judgment of the co-ordinate
Bench, which was affirmed by the Division Bench, both
quoted supra and for the reasons mentioned therein, the
application filed under Section 33C(2) of the ID Act is not
maintainable before the Labour Court. Therefore, impugned
award of the Labour Court requires interference at the
hands of this Court.
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17889
WP No. 107903 of 2016
CNR: KAHC020022402016
9. For the aforesaid reasons, the following:
ORDER
a) The writ petition stands allowed ;
b) The impugned award dated 14.11.2014
passed in Application No.28 of 2014 by the
Labour Court is set-aside.
Sd/-
(M.NAGAPRASANNA)
JUDGE
VNP/CT: ASC
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 42