DR P PADMANABAN vs UT OF PUDICHERRY

Court
Central Administrative Tribunal

1 of 11
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
CHENNAI BENCH
OA No. 310/00814 of 2021
.
th
DATED WEDNESDAY, THE 18 DAY OF NOVEMBER, TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
CORAM :
HON'BLE MS. VEENA KOTHAVALE, MEMBER (J)
BETWEEN
Dr. P. Padmanaban, S/o. Perumal,
Hindu, aged 60 years, working as
Joint Director (presently Director
Current Duties) now working as
Secretary, PANCARE,
Puducherry. 605001. .....Applicant.
(Advocate: M/s. V. Ajayakumar)
Versus
1. The Union of India represented
by the Secretary, Ministry of Home Affairs,
Government of India, New Delhi. 110011;
2. The Secretary, Department of
Personnel and Training Govt. of India,
New Delhi. - 110011;
3. The Secretary, Department of Animal
Husbandry, Dairying and Fisheries,
Ministry of Animal Husbandry,
Dairying and Fisheries,
Government of India, New Delhi-110011;
4. The Chief Secretary to Government of
Puducherry, Chief Secretariat,
Puducherry- 605001. …....Respondents
.
(Advocate: Mr. K. Rajendran, Sr. CGSC (R1-R3)
Mr. R. Syed Mustafa, R4)
CAV ON : 06.10.2026

2 of 11
O R D E R
(Hon'ble Ms. Veena Kothavale, Member(J)
This Original Application is filed by the applicant under Section 19 of the
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 seeking the following relief:-
th
“
To call for the records of the 4 respondent with No.
390/CS(AH)/2021 dated 20.09.2021 the order rejecting the claim of
the applicant and to quash the same and consequently to direct the
respondents to extend the benefit of the enhanced age of retirement to
the applicant and to pass such other or further orders in the interest of
justice and thus render justice.”
2. The brief facts are that the applicant is working as Joint Director in the Animal
Husbandry Department and by office order dated 17/02/2011, he was ordered to look
after the current duties of the post of Director of Animal Husbandry and Animal
Welfare, Puducherry. He joined the service as Veterinary Assistant Surgeon on ad
hoc basis on 13.8.1987 which was subsequently regularised through UPSC on
11.2.1991. He was promoted on regular basis to the post of Joint Director on
31.12.2002 and is currently holding the charge of Director of Animal Husbandry and
Animal Welfare, Puducherry.
3. The parity of the Veterinary Doctors with that of the General Duty Medical
th
Officers and Dental Doctors is established through the recommendations of the 5
th
Pay Commission and 6 Pay Commission and the same was accepted by the

3 of 11
Government of India as per order dated 29.8.2008 and also by the Union Territory of
Puducherry. The Veterinary Doctors are given the benefit of pay scale treating them
on par with the other category of doctors.
4. On the basis of the order passed by the Hon'ble Delhi High Court in W.P.
No.2780 of 2011 which was upheld by the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the Government
of India issued specific order extending the benefits of Dynamic Assured Career
Progression Scheme (DACP) to the Veterinary Doctors as well and consequently the
Government of Puducherry also has issued orders implementing the said benefit to
the Veterinary Doctors in the Union Territory of Puduchery.
5. The Government of India has enhanced the age of retirement of General Duty
Medical Officers and Dental Doctors upto 65 years whereas the same was not
extended to AYUSH doctors and Veterinary Doctors. When the same was challenged
by the AYUSH doctors, the Principal Bench, Central Administrative Tribunal
declared that the doctors covered under AYUSH are also entitled to the benefit of
enhanced superannuation of 65 years. The same was upheld by the Hon'ble Delhi
High Court and the Hon'ble Supreme Court. The Veterinary Doctors are also entitled
to the same benefit of enhanced age of superannuation as extended to the General
Duty Medical Officers, Dental Doctors and the Veterinary Assistant Surgeon. There
is no reason or rationale for denying the same to the Veterinary Doctors. In the
absence of any valid and legal rationale, discriminating the Veterinary Doctors and

4 of 11
denying the said benefit will amount to a clear case of arbitrariness and
discrimination.
6. Aggrieved by the arbitrary and discriminatory approach of the Government, a
case was filed before the Central Administrative Tribunal, Principle Bench, New
Delhi for extending the benefit of enhanced age of superannuation whereas the same
was dismissed by the Tribunal stating that the petitioner has already retired from
service. As it was not at a ground to deny the benefit, the same has been challenged
before the Hon'ble High Court and the Writ Petition is pending.
7. As the applicant was to retire by superannuation on 30/09/2021, he submitted a
representation for extending the benefit of enhanced age of superannuation, but the
Government of Puducherry has rejected the same stating that there is no specific
orders for extending the said benefit and in the absence of such orders the
Government of Puducherry cannot grant the benefit. Hence, this OA is filed seeking
the aforesaid relief.
8. In the reply statement filed by the Respondents 1 to 3, it is contended that this
application seeks to intrude into the domain which is exclusive prerogative of the
Government. There are many judgments of the Courts, including the Apex Court,
which exclusively establishes the prerogative of the government to decide on the
service matters including age of superannuation of the Government employees. The

5 of 11
issue of parity with other categories of doctors raised by the petitioner is out of
context and without regard to the fact that decision on service matters like
enhancement of age limit for a particular set of government employees is taken
keeping in view the availability, need, public interest, etc. The comparison drawn
with medical and other doctors to substantiate claim of parity by relying on
recommendations of V and VI Pay Commission as also judgement dated 14.10.2014
of this Hon'ble Court in WP (C) No.2780/2011 is also misunderstood as the parity
conceived therein was in terms of career progression and neither the Pay
Commission's reports nor this Hon'ble Court's Order dated 14.10.2014 in WP (C)
No.2780/2011, directed/ recommended for enhancement of age of superannuation
even in an implied manner.
9. The applicant had submitted a representation dated 27.08.2021 (Annexure A-
17 to the instant OA) to the Chief Secretary, Government of Puducherry, for
enhancement of age of superannuation of Veterinary Doctors from 60 years to 65
years on par with the GDMOs/Dental doctors in terms of V and VI CPC
recommendations and Judgement of Hon'ble High Court of Delhi vide Order dated
14.10.2014 in WP (C) No.2780/2011. The said request was not acceded to by the
Government of Puducherry, as no specific orders had been issued by the Government
of India.
10. Many Judgments of Hon'ble CAT, High Court as well as Hon'ble Supreme

6 of 11
Court establish the exclusive right of the Government to decide on service matters of
its employees. The age of superannuation of Medical Doctors was raised through a
conscious decision of the Government on account of shortage of the doctors available
for treatment of patients and teaching in medical colleges, and not based on any court
order. However, this enhancement of age of superannuation was with the stipulation
that beyond the age of 62 years, they shall not be entitled to hold any administrative
positions and the enhancement is only to enable them to render service of treatment
of patients and of teaching. It is the prerogative of the Government to decide on
service matters of its employees including age of retirement.
11. A meeting was convened by the Government of India on 17.07.2017 to review
the status of proposals for enhancement of superannuation age of Doctors and
Medical Officers in organizations/Medical services and based on the review, it was
decided by the Government to enhance the age of superannuation of CHS doctors
w.e.f. 31.05.2016 and Non-CHS doctors working in AYUSH, Ministry of Defence,
Railways, etc. with effect from 30.09.2017 respectively. However, the age of
superannuation of Veterinary Doctors was not enhanced to 65 years. Based on the
representation of one Dr. R.S. Sharma, President, Indian Veterinary Association, the
matter relating to enhancement of age of superannuation of Veterinary Doctors from
60 years to 65 years was considered by the Government of India and it was decided
and communicated vide DOP&T's OM dated 01.12.2016 that Veterinary Doctors had
no case for raising their retirement age at par with CHS Doctors. The decision on

7 of 11
service matter like enhancement of age limit for a particular set of government
employees is taken keeping in view various factors, i.e. the availability, need, public
interest etc.
12. In the reply statement filed by the Respondent No.4, it is stated that the request
made by the applicant in his representation dated 27/08/2021 for enhancement of the
retirement age on par with general duty medical officers and dental doctors, was not
acceded to by the Government of Puducherry as there were no specific orders issued
by either the Ministry of Home Affairs or by the Department of Animal Husbandry
and Dairing, New Delhi.
13. Learned counsel for the respondents submitted that a number of cases on the
issue of enhancing the age of superannuation filed before CAT, PB, New Delhi have
been considered and dismissed by it including -
(i) Order dated 12.03.2020 in O.A. No.3940/2017 in the case of Dr Ak
Singla vs Union of India & Ors.;
(ii) Order dated 27/09/2018 in O.A. No. 3571/2018 in the case of Dr.
Chandra Shekhar Sahukar vs UOI & ors;
(iii) Order dated 22/12/2020 in O.A. No. 883/2019 in the case of Dr.
M.L. Sharma Vs UOI & ors;

8 of 11
(iv) OAs No.1269/2020, No. 1660/2020, and No.3978/2018, etc.
However, some of the orders so passed are under challenge before
Hon'ble Delhi High Court.
14. Heard the learned counsels on both sides, considered the citations relied upon
and perused the material on record.
15. It is observed that in a catena of cases, the Hon'ble Apex Court has held that the
age of superannuation is a matter of policy and falls exclusively within the domain of
executive. In the case of P.U. Joshi & Others Vs. Accountant General, Ahmadabad
and Others, [2003 (2) SCC 632], the Hon'ble Supreme Court has made the following
observations: -
"10. We have carefully considered the submissions made on behalf
of both parties. Questions relating to the Constitution, Pattern,
Nomenclature of post, Cadres, Categories, their creation/abolition,
prescription of qualifications, and other conditions of service
including avenues of promotions and criteria to be fulfilled for such
promotions pertain to the field of policy is within the exclusive
discretion and jurisdiction of the State, subject, of course, to the
limitations or restrictions, envisaged in the Constitution of India, and
it is not for the statutory tribunals, at any rate, to direct the
government to have a particular method of recruitment, eligibility
criteria, or avenues of promotion or impose itself by substituting its
views for that of the State.".

9 of 11
16. In New Okhla Industrial Development Authority (NOIDA) vs. B.D. Singhal
(AIR 2021 SC 3457), the Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed as under: -
"Whether the age of superannuation should be enhanced is a matter of
policy. If a decision has been taken to enhance the age of
superannuation, the date with effect from which the enhancement
should be made falls within the realm of policy. The High Court in
ordering that the decision of the State government to accept the
proposal to enhance the age of superannuation must date back to 29
June 2002 has evidently lost sight of the above factual background,
more specifically (i) the rejection of the original proposal on 22
September 2009; and (ii) the judgment of the Division Bench dated 17
January 2012 refusing to set aside the order rejecting the proposal on
22 September 2009 which has attained finality. But there is a more
fundamental objection to the basis of the decision of the High Court.
The infirmity in the judgment lies in the fact that the High Court has
trenched upon the realm of policy making and has assumed to itself,
jurisdiction over a matter which lies in the domain of the executive.
Whether the age of superannuation should be increased and if so, the
date from which this should be effected is a matter of policy into
which the High Court ought not to have entered.".

17. In the case of Prakasan M.P.. vs State of Kerala, the Hon'ble Supreme Court
vide its order dated 25/08/2023 in C.A. No.7580 of 2012 observed as under: -
"The idea behind extension of retirement age of doctors was to take
care of the emergency situation caused by shortage of doctors, which
was resulting in affecting the studies or patient care. It was not merely

10 of 11
to grant benefits to a particular class. The Doctrine of Legitimate
Expectation does not have any role to play in matters that are strictly
governed by the service regulations. This is an exercise that is
undertaken by the State in discharge of its public duties and should
not brook undue interference by the Court."
18. From the foregoing decisions, it is established that the Government has the
exclusive right and privilege to decide on service matters including extension of the
age of superannuation and the courts cannot assume such jurisdiction over matters
which lie exclusively in the domain of the executive.

19. It is noted that this OA is filed by the applicant on 27/09/2021 just three days
prior to his superannuation on 30/09/2021 and no interim relief was granted to him.
The applicant has since superannuated on 30/09/2021 and issued with Pension
Payment Order dated 16/12/2021. As mirrored in the above referred decisions of the
Hon'ble Apex Court, any decision in respect of enhancement of age of
superannuation lies exclusively in the domain of the Government and it is clearly
stated by the respondents that no specific order regarding enhancement of the age of
superannuation of Veterinary Doctors has been issued by the Government. Though
the Government has taken a decision to enhance the age of superannuation in respect
of General Duty Medical Officers, Dental Doctors, CHS doctors and certain other
categories of doctors as it would help better patient care, proper academic activities in
medical colleges, effective implementation of the national health program, delivery of

11 of 11
healthcare services, etc., however, in the case of Veterinary Doctors, it is conveyed by
the DoP&T to the Department of Animal Husbandry, Dairying and Fisheries in the
Ministry of Agriculture vide OM dated 01/12/2016 (Annexure R-2) that Veterinary
Doctors have no case for raising their retirement age at par with CHS doctors.
Hence, the Government of Puducherry has stated that it is not in a position to accede
to the request for enhancement of the age of superannuation of the Veterinary
Doctors.
20. In view of the above, I do not find any merit in this OA. Accordingly, OA is
dismissed with no order as to costs.

(Veena Kothavale)
Member(J)
18.11.2026
asvs
Digitally signed by
ASAPU SRINIVASA
VIDYASAGAR
Date: 2026.11.20
17:10:02 +05'30'
A.S.V. Sagar
P.S., CAT,
Chennai Bench.