Gurdeep Singh vs P.O. & Anr

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

CWP No.16879 of 2013
- 1 -
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
(222) CWP No.16879 of 2013 (O&M)
Date of Decision: 16.11.2026
Gurdeep Singh
....Petitioner
Versus
Presiding Officer, Central Government Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour Court-
II, Chandigarh and another
....Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE KIRTI SINGH
Present: Mr. Sharwan Sehgal, Advocate
for the petitioner (through V.C.).
Mr. R. Kartikeya, Advocate,
Mr. Kartik Patial, Advocate and
Mr. Ashok Goyal, Advocate
for respondent No.2.

KIRTI SINGH, J. (ORAL)
1. This petition assails the award dated 28.12.2012 passed by the
learned Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour Court-II,
Chandigarh, in I.D. No.715 of 2005, referred for adjudication under Section
10(1)(c) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (for short, 'the Act of 1947'),
whereby the reference was answered against the petitioner-workman.
2. Briefly stated, as per the pleaded case of the petitioner, he was
appointed as a Peon in Punjab and Sind Bank, Branch at VPO Jaspal Bangarh,
with effect from 06.08.1997 on daily wages. Thereafter, he claims to have been
transferred to another branch of the Bank situated at Gill Road, Ludhiana, in
June 2002. His services were allegedly terminated with effect from 24.08.2002
ITHLESH KUMAR
without any notice or payment of retrenchment compensation, in violation of
2026.11.21 13:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment

CWP No.16879 of 2013
- 2 -
the provisions of Sections 25-F, 25-G and 25-H of the Act of 1947. Aggrieved
thereby, the petitioner raised an industrial dispute by serving a demand notice
dated 17.03.2003, seeking reinstatement with continuity of service and full back
wages. Pursuant thereto, the Government made a reference under Section 10(1)
(c) of the Act of 1947, registered as I.D. No.715 of 2005, to the learned
Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour Court, Chandigarh, for adjudication of the
following question: "Whether the action of the management of Punjab and Sind
Bank in terminating the services of Shri Gurdeep Singh son of Dayal Singh, Ex-
Peon/Daily Wages basis w.e.f. 24.8.2002 without any notice and without any
payment of retrenchment compensation is legal and justified? If not, what relief
the concerned workman is entitled to and from which date?"
3. Notice of the reference was issued to both the parties. The
petitioner filed his claim statement on 27.01.2004. The respondent-Bank
contested the reference by filing a written statement on 28.03.2005, wherein it
was pleaded that the engagement of the petitioner was neither in accordance
with the prescribed procedure nor made by the competent authority and,
therefore, he was not entitled to protection under Section 25 of the Act of 1947.
It was further pleaded that his engagement was purely need-based, to meet
exigencies of service, and that he had not been appointed against any permanent
or sanctioned post. It was also asserted that no post of Peon was available in the
Bank.
4. Upon appraisal of the evidence, the learned Tribunal held that, to
claim protection under Section 25-F of the Act of 1947, the petitioner was
required to establish that he had completed 240 days of actual work during the
twelve calendar months preceding the date of his alleged termination, as
ITHLESH KUMAR
contemplated under Section 25-B of the Act of 1947. However, the petitioner
2026.11.21 13:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment

CWP No.16879 of 2013
- 3 -
had neither pleaded the requisite continuous service nor established the same
through evidence. The learned Tribunal also noticed the deposition of the
management witness that the petitioner had been engaged intermittently at
different branches of the Bank to meet exigencies of service and had not
rendered 240 days of continuous service. Accordingly, holding that the
petitioner had failed to establish the foundational requirement for attracting
Section 25-F of the Act of 1947, the learned Tribunal answered the reference
against him vide the impugned award dated 28.12.2012.
5. Learned counsel for the petitioner contends that the findings
recorded by the learned Tribunal are contrary to the evidence on record. It is
submitted that the management itself admitted that the petitioner had been
engaged on a temporary basis to meet exigencies of service. It is further
contended that even if the stand of the respondents that the petitioner had
worked temporarily from 06.08.1997 to 24.08.2002 at different branches is
taken into consideration, without admitting the same, he had completed more
than 240 days of continuous service and, therefore, his services could not have
been discontinued without complying with the provisions of Sections 25-F and
25-G of the Act of 1947. It is, accordingly, prayed that the impugned award be
set aside and the petitioner be reinstated in service with continuity of service
and full back wages.
6. Per contra, learned counsel for respondent No.2 submits that the
findings recorded by the learned Tribunal are based upon a proper appreciation
of the evidence on record. It is contended that the petitioner failed to plead or
produce cogent evidence establishing that he had actually worked for 240 days
during the twelve calendar months preceding the alleged termination. It is
ITHLESH KUMAR
further submitted that the petitioner failed to discharge the burden resting upon
2026.11.21 13:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment

CWP No.16879 of 2013
- 4 -
him under Section 25-B of the Act of 1947. Dismissal of the petition is,
accordingly, prayed for.
7. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material available on record.
8. Before proceeding further, it would be apposite to refer to the
judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Surendranagar District Panchayat
v. Dahyabhai Amarsinh, (2005) 8 SCC 750, wherein, while considering the
applicability of Section 25-F of the Act of 1947, the Hon'ble Supreme Court
held that the burden of proving that a workman had actually worked for 240
days during the twelve months immediately preceding the date of termination
rests upon the workman. The Court further held that such burden has to be
discharged by leading cogent evidence and that a mere self-serving statement
would not suffice. It was also held that non-production of muster rolls or other
records, by itself, would not necessarily warrant drawing an adverse inference
against the employer. Whether such an inference is warranted would depend
upon the facts and circumstances of each case.
9. It is equally well settled that, while exercising supervisory
jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India over an
award passed by a Labour Court or Industrial Tribunal, this Court does not
ordinarily interfere with findings of fact merely because another view of the
evidence may be possible. Interference is warranted where the findings are
perverse, based on no evidence, or suffer from a patent error of law or
jurisdictional infirmity. The question, therefore, is whether the findings
recorded by the learned Tribunal in the present case suffer from any such
infirmity warranting interference in exercise of the supervisory jurisdiction of
ITHLESH KUMAR
this Court.
2026.11.21 13:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment

CWP No.16879 of 2013
- 5 -
10. Reverting to the facts of the present case, the petitioner asserted
that he had been engaged as a Peon on daily wages with effect from 06.08.1997
and had thereafter worked at the Gill Road Branch till 24.08.2002. However, the
mere assertion that he had been engaged over a period spanning several years
would not, by itself, establish that he had actually worked for 240 days during
the twelve calendar months immediately preceding the alleged date of
termination, i.e. 24.08.2002.
11. The cross-examination of the petitioner also reveals that he was
being paid daily wages after working for periods of two to five days and that he
had worked at the Jaspal Bangar Branch up to 2001, whereafter he was sent to
the Gill Road Branch. On the other hand, the management witness, while
acknowledging that the petitioner had joined the Jaspal Bangar Branch on
06.08.1997 and that his services at the Gill Road Branch were discharged on
24.08.2002, maintained that the engagement at the latter branch was a fresh
engagement and not a transfer. The petitioner had also moved an application
seeking production of the attendance and payment records of his engagement.
However, the management stated that the old records were not readily available
and that efforts were being made to trace the same. It also placed tabulated
statements of the particulars of service rendered by the petitioner on record
along with its evidence.
12. In these circumstances, the mere fact that the petitioner had sought
production of the service records, or that the entire record was not produced,
would not, by itself, dispense with his initial burden of establishing that he had
actually worked for the requisite number of days during the relevant twelve-
month period. His oral assertion, without cogent supporting material
ITHLESH KUMAR
establishing the requisite number of days of actual work during the relevant
2026.11.21 13:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment

CWP No.16879 of 2013
- 6 -
period, cannot be treated as sufficient proof of the statutory requirement under
Section 25-B of the Act of 1947.
13. The relevant consideration was not merely the overall period
during which the petitioner claimed to have been associated with the Bank, but
whether he had completed 240 days of actual work during the twelve calendar
months immediately preceding the alleged termination. The learned Tribunal,
upon appreciation of the evidence, found that this essential requirement had
neither been specifically pleaded nor established by the petitioner. The said
finding cannot be said to be perverse or contrary to the material on record.
14. Once the petitioner failed to establish the requisite continuous
service contemplated under Section 25-B of the Act of 1947, he could not claim
the protection of Section 25-F of the Act of 1947. Consequently, the challenge
on the ground of non-compliance with the mandatory requirements of Section
25-F does not merit acceptance.
15. As regards the alleged violation of Section 25-G of the Act of
1947, the learned Tribunal specifically noticed that there was no evidence to
establish that any person junior to the petitioner had been retained in service at
the time of his disengagement. In the absence of such evidence, the finding
recorded by the learned Tribunal that no violation of Section 25-G had been
established does not warrant interference.
16. The learned Tribunal also noticed the allegation regarding
subsequent engagement of other persons and considered the same in the context
of Section 25-H of the Act of 1947. However, it held that the question of re-
employment under the said provision was beyond the scope of the reference,
which was confined to the legality and justification of the termination without
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.21 13:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment

CWP No.16879 of 2013
- 7 -
notice and retrenchment compensation. No infirmity in the approach adopted by
the learned Tribunal in this regard has been demonstrated.
17. In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court finds no perversity,
illegality or jurisdictional infirmity in the findings recorded by the learned
Tribunal warranting interference in exercise of its supervisory jurisdiction. The
impugned award dated 28.12.2012, therefore, calls for no interference.
18. Consequently, the present writ petition is dismissed.
19. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall also stand
disposed of.
(KIRTI SINGH)
JUDGE
November 16, 2026
Ithlesh
Whether speaking/reasoned: Yes
Whether reportable: No
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.21 13:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment