GOVIND KUMAR GUPTA vs STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ANR
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
PRESENT:
THE HON’BLE DR. JUSTICE AJOY KUMAR MUKHERJEE
CRR 1870 of 2024
Govind Kumar Gupta
Vs.
State of west Bengal & Anr.
For the Petitioner : Mr. Saswata Gopal Mukherjee
Mr. Arkadeb Bhattacharya
For the Opposite Party no.2 : Mr. Saurabh Guhathakurata
Mr. Abhratanu Sarkar
For the State : Mr. Gouranga Kumar Das
Mr. Imran Siddiqui
Heard on : 28.07.2026
Judgment on : 20.11.2026
Dr. Ajoy Kumar Mukherjee, J.
1. The present application has been preferred seeking quashment of the
proceeding being GR(S) Case no. 45 of 2024 under section 120B/420/
406/465/467/468/471 of the IPC presently pending before the court of
learned Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Calcutta.
2. In the FIR it is stated that the complainant company namely
Cholamandalam Investment & Finance Co. Ltd. (in short CIFCL) engaged
inter alia in the business of extending home loan to prospective customers.
1
It is alleged that one co-accused Biswajit Sinha (who is not the petitioner
rd
herein) intended to purchase the entire 3 floor measuring 1600 sq. ft super
build area together with a car parking space on the ground floor of the
building at a locality under Haridevpur P.S for a sum of Rs. 86,000,00/- and
applied for the home loan with all the relevant documents vide application
no. 10036116 on 09.06.2023. A sanction letter was issued for the said loan
application in favour of Co-accused Biswajit Sinha for a some of Rs.
62,000,00/- on 30.06.2023 for a term of 216 months and said Biswajit
Sinha with all the co-applicant and guarantor signed the loan agreement
with CIFCL along with his wife Sangita Sinha, mother Reba Sinha with both
as co-applicants and Indranil Chakraborty as the guarantor for the loan
account. Said Biswajit Sinha registered the property in his name vide sale
deed no. 10462 of 2023 on 28.07.2023 and issued the cheque amount of Rs.
58,68,225/- in favour of Ganapati Construction vide cheque no. 637241 on
the same day.
3. Said Biswajit Sinha started paying EMIs for the said loan account
with the complainant company since July 2023 but suddenly he defaulted
payment of the monthly instalment during October 2023. Owing to
continuous default in payment of the monthly instalment in time, the
company visited the property once again for cross-verification. The builder
namely Petitioner herein Gavind Kumar Gupta denied about the fact that
CIFCL has extended loan for purchase of the said flat. When countered with
the facts, said Biswajit Sinha immediately committed to pay a sum of Rs.
st
5,00,000/- and also to close the loan account on or before 31 March, 2024.
Out of committed amount of Rs. 5,00,000/- Biswajit paid a sum of
2
Rs.1,00,000/- apart from the monthly EMI to CIFCL and denied to meet in
person or cooperate with the company. On account of the suspicious
conduct of Biswajit’s company, Complainant started to make enquiry and it
was found that total four conveyance deeds were executed in respect of
same property, out of which three are forged. It is alleged in the FIR that co-
accused Biswajit Sinha, Sangita Sinha, Reba Sinha, Indranil Chakraborty
and the present petitioner Govind Kumar Gupta and their associates are
jointly involved and made criminal conspiracy in preparing the forged deeds.
4. On the basis of the above complain, Shakespeare Sarani Police Station
Case no. 6 of 2024 dated 10.01.2024 was registered for investigation
alleging commission of aforesaid offences by the petitioner and five others,
under section 120B/420/406/465/467/468/471 of the IPC.
5. It is alleged that the complainant upon enquiry came to know that co-
accused Biswajit Sinha had registered four different deeds being first deed
no. 9663 of 2023 on 07.07.2023, second deed no. 8899 of 2023 on
01.07.2023, third deed no 9015 of 2023 on 03.07.2023 and fourth deed no.
10462 of 2023 on 28.07.2023 in respect of the same property and thereby
availed multiple loan form different banks/financial institutions.
6. Being aggrieved, learned Senior counsel for the
developer/accused/petitioner herein Govind Kumar Gupta submits that the
petitioner is the proprietor of construction firm under the name and style
M/s Ganapati Constriction, having office at 18 Vidyasagar Sarni, Natun
Pally Kolkata-700008. The petitioner had been carrying on the said business
for last several years and has requisite trade licence to carry on the
businesses of construction of real estate projects. One Subrata Chakraborty
3
and other, being the owner of the property, entered into a registered
development agreement with the petitioner in the year 2019 and by virtue of
said development agreement, the owner had executed a registered power of
attorney in favour of petitioner by virtue of which the petitioner was
empowered to develop and construct a building on the said property as per
sanction plan under the name “Ganapati Enclave”. Sometime in the month
of May, 2023 one local broker introduced to the petitioner one prospective
purchaser namely Sulata Sarder and her son Kunal Sardar. They showed
their keen interest in purchasing a flat and being satisfied with the
documentation and construction of the property they expressed their
rd
interest to purchase the entire 3 floor of “Ganapati Enclave” admeasuring
an area of about 1600 sq. ft and for which they made payment of Rs.
11,000/- in cash as a token money against issuance of money receipt.
Subsequently said Sulata Sardar informed that aforesaid co-accused
rd
Biswajit Sinha would purchase the said 3 floor at Ganpati Enclave and
accordingly on 07.07.2023 the proprietorship firm of the petitioner M/s
Ganpati Construction as the developer and aforesaid Subrata Chakraborty
and others, being the land owner of the said plot of land, executed a deed of
conveyance with co-accused Biswajit Sinha by virtue of which Biswajit
rd
Sinha purchased the said 3 floor along with a car parking space against
rd
payment of Rs. 59,000,00/- comprising of Rs. 56,000,000/- towards 3
floor and additional Rs. 3,00,000/- for car parking space. It is submitted by
petitioner that said deed of conveyance was registered being deed no.
160209663 and that was the only deed executed by the petitioner with the
application of the petitioner’s biometric. On the request of aforesaid Sulata
4
Sardar, the petitioner introduced them with the LIC Finance Ltd. for availing
the requisite loan amount and the petitioner in due course had duly
received the entire consideration amount of Rs. 58,25,000/- by way of
cheque issued by Biswajit Sinha and rest of the amount from LIC Housing
Ltd, though one cheque amounting Rs. 75,000/- issued by Biswajit Sinha in
favour of Ganpati Constriction was dishonoured on account of insufficient
fund. Thereafter the petitioner was informed by Sulata Sardar and Biswajit
Sinha that they will not require the car parking space and accordingly
demanded the petitioner to pay the balance sum of Rs. 3,000,00/- which
was paid toward car parking space. Accordingly, after adjudging the
dishonoured cheque amount of Rs. 75,000/- and Rs. 35,000/- paid by
petitioner towards income tax for the car parking space, the balance sum of
Rs. 1,90,000/- was refunded to Biswajit Sinha’s bank account.
7. Petitioner’s further case is that sometime in the middle of December,
2023, the bank officials of complainant company came to the office of the
rd
petitioner and disclosed that the said flat at the 3 floor of “Ganpati
Enclave” which was purchased by Biswajit Sinha from him, is being
financed by them to Biswajit Sinha. However, since their phone no was
switched off, the bank official could not contact them. On 09.01.2024 bank
officials of another financial institution, Canara Bank visited the office of the
petitioner and made similar assertion that Biswajit Sinha have availed loan
form Canara Bank and they have financed Biswajit for purchasing the said
rd
flat at 3 floor.
8. The petitioner upon gaining such information made enquiry with
Registrar of Assurances, Kolkata through online platform and came to know
5
that Biswajit Sinha in collusion with some other miscreants and officials of
Registrar of Assurances, by way of 3 deeds being deed no. 190210462 of
2023, deed no. 190208899 of 2023, deed no. 190209015 of 2023 executed
the same property which was already executed and registered by deed of
conveyance between Ganpati Construction and Biswajit Sinha on
07.07.2023 by way of deed no. 160209663 of 2023. The fake three deeds
were executed on 28.07.2023, 03.07.2023, 01.07.2023.
9. Petitioner’s counsel submits his client herein immediately applied for
the certified copy of three deeds and upon perusing the same it was found
that said forged deeds were created to extract loan from different financial
institutions. Petitioner immediately after coming to know that his signature
has been forged and a fake photo and false thumb impression is used to
impersonate him as a party to the fake execution of three deeds of
conveyance in respect of the said property by Biswajit Sinha and other
miscreants, he lodged complain before Haridevpur police station, but the
officer-in-charge of the said P.S refused to register the complaint and he
treated the said written complaint dated 10.01.2024 as general diary. The
petitioner did not stop there but lodged another complaint on 11.01.2024
before the Hare Street Police Station stating in detail how he has been
impersonated by the miscreants. The Here Street police station also refused
to register the FIR although patently a cognizable offence is clearly made
out. Thereafter on 02.3.2024, the petitioner submitted another complaint
before Haridevpur police station, Here Street police station, detective
department Lal bazar P.S, stating in detail how accused person had opened
bank account in the name of counterfeit Govind Kumar Gupta and issued
6
demand draft in the name of Govinda Kumar Gupta for the purpose of
syphoning off funds from bank.
10. Mr. Mukherjee on behalf of Petitioner argued that that prior to the
institution of impugned proceeding the petitioner had made several
complaints before multiple competent public authorities narrating in detail
how Biswajit Sinha, Sulata Sardar and other accused persons have
impersonated the petitioner in different fake deeds, to attend their ulterior
motive.
11. Learned counsel for the petitioner further argued that such complaint
evidently goes to show that petitioner had no nexus whatsoever in the
commission of alleged offence. Even in the forwarding report dated
03.04.2024 the investigating officer has categorically stated that during
investigation of the instant case and upon scrutinising the seized deed of
conveyance, it revealed that some other person had posed as petitioner and
represented Ganpati Construction during the registration process.
Therefore, petitioner prays for quashing the said proceeding qua the
Petitioner Govind Kumar Gupta.
12. In reply learned counsel appearing on behalf of opposite party no. 2
submits that the petitioner’s argument is solely based on the initial remand
report which has no probative value in quashing the FIR against the
petitioner. The initial remand report is based on the materials collected by
the investigating agency at the threshold of the investigation. Investigation is
at nascent stage and investigation is still in progress, so at this stage it
would not be proper to quash the FIR. He further submits that FIR cannot
be considered as encyclopaedia of the entire incident. The fourcorner of the
7
FIR and materials collected by the investigating agency, so far clearly
established participation and involvement of the petitioner in the entire
conspiracy of the offence committed by all the accused persons.
13. He further pointed out that there is a difference between quashing of
an FIR and quashing of charge sheet. In case of quashing of an FIR High
Court cannot consider any evidence nor can examine the truthfulness of any
document, while in case of quashing of charge sheet, the High Court can
consider all the materials collected after completion of the investigation. He
further argued that all the points raised by petitioner are triable issues
which can be decided at the stage of trial after adducing evidence by the
parties and the High Court cannot quash the proceeding in such cases
invoking its jurisdiction under section 528 of BNSS by conducting mini trial.
14. Learned counsel appearing for the State placed one report of the
Investigating Officer dated 10.07.2026 by way of memo of evidence dated
29.06.2026 in support of further continuance of proceeding against the
petitioner.
15. Having considered submission made on behalf of the parties it
appears that only in the last paragraph of the FIR, it has been alleged that
the present petitioner along with other co-accused persons are jointly
involved. In the affidavit of opposition going beyond the contents of FIR, it
has been stated that in all the aforesaid deeds petitioner is party and has
received financial assistance from different financial organisations.
16. During the course of arguments, the learned counsel appearing for the
opposite party no.2 has made the following arguments in support of alleged
conspiracy made by the petitioner in creating the forged deed:
8
(A) The employees of the complainant company went to the office of the
petitioner before the registration of the said deed of conveyance in favour of
Biswajit Sinha but petitioner did not disclose to the finance company that
the subject property has already been sold to Biswajit Sinha financed by
LIC. This amounts to false representation and involvement of the petitioner
in the conspiracy.
(B) After discussion with the petitioner, he assured the finance company to
provide KYC and accordingly he has provided all documents to the employee
of the finance company knowing fully well that the subject property already
been sold to Biswajit Sinha financed by LIC. This constitutes mens rea and
involvement of the petitioner in the conspiracy, who has actually played a
pivotal role in the entire scam.
C) Before sanctioning the loan and at the time of the inspection of the
subject property, technical manager of the complainant/company and the
petitioner were present, who elaborated all the technical details of the said
property to the technical manager of the complainant/company. Even at
that stage also, the petitioner did not disclose that the subject property has
already been sold to Biswajit Sinha financed by LIC. This proves active
participation of the petitioner in the entire scam and the petitioner has very
much conspired the criminal acts behind the curtain and he is the master
mind of the entire conspiracy hatched by all other accused persons.
17. From the prosecution report dated 10.07.2026, it appears that the
arrested accused Kunal Sardar had made a statement wherefrom it reveals
that the developer, being the petitioner Govind Kumar Gupta was all along
aware of the offence and allowed the fraudsters to get access in his property
9
multiple times to get the loan sanctioned from different financial
institutions. Petitioner took financial benefit for the same in cash from the
fraudster as appearing from the statement of co-accused Kunal Sardar.
Further during investigation, the technical security report along with
relevant photographs were seized. The photo confirms the petitioner’s
presence at the disputed property during the site visit by the complainant
company before sanction of the loan is confirmed. The statement of officer
Sujoy Kumar Das, area manager who conducted the site visit was also
examined and it reveals therefrom that Govind Kumar Gupta had
introduced himself as developer of the property and introduced accordingly
during the site visit that was conducted before the loan was sanctioned. He
also stated that Govind Kumar Gupta told him that accused Kunal Sardar
and Chandan Naskar were his representatives. It also appears from the said
report that the investigation of the case is complete.
18. Now in order to constitute an offence under section 120B of the IPC
essential ingredients are as follows:-
(1) An agreement between two or more persons to commit an offence;
(2) In doing so the accused either did or caused to be done:
(i) An illegal act, or
(ii) An act, which is not in itself illegal, by illegal means.
(3) Such an act done or caused to be done was an offence punishable under
the Indian Penal Code:
(4) If the act so done was not an offence, then an overt act had been done by
one or more parties to such agreement in pursuance thereof.
19. Petitioner’s specific case is that immediately after coming to know of
the criminal offence, petitioner lodged as many as three complaints, the first
one was made before Haridevpur police station on 10.01.2024 even before
lodging of impugned FIR, petitioner made second complaint at Hare Street
10
P.S. on 11.01.2024 and on 02.03.2024 petitioner lodged third complaint
before Haridevpur P.S., Commissioner of police Lal Bazar anti-fraud section,
detective department. On 10.01.2024 based on the complaint lodged by
Officer, Asis Saha of the complainant company, the present impugned
investigation was started where it is alleged that the petitioner Govinda
Kumar Gupta and his associates are jointly involved. During investigation
though the other accused person were arrested but the petitioner was
neither arrested nor his bank account or his firm’s bank account was frozen
by the investigating agency. The investigation is completed as appearing
from Prosecution report dated 29.06.2026.
20. In the present case neither there is any allegation nor any material
that petitioner has ever made any kind of representation to the complainant.
There is no material that petitioner had induced any bank official to part
with money or property. On the contrary the document on record shows that
the petitioner was himself the victim of an elaborate fraud perpetrated by
the co-accused persons. The I.O’s report states that Debasis @ Babai
Mazumdar impersonated Govind Kumar Gupta before the registering
authority and Kunal Sarder is the kingpin who organized the offence and
syphoned of the defrauded money. Fictitious bank account was opened in
the name of Ganpati Constriction which did not belong to the petitioner or
his firm. The defrauded amount was received and misappropriated by the
co-accused persons and their associates and IO’s report further revealed
that forged documents were prepared by the other accused persons. Infact
at the closure of investigation it does not attribute any overtact of the
petitioner in relation to either the impersonation, preparation of forged
11
document, opening of fictitious bank account or receipt of any part of the
alleged cheated amount. No pecuniary benefit has also appeared to be
accrued to the petitioner. Neither his bank account nor that of his firm
appears to have received any portion of the defrauded money. There is no
specific allegation that any of the financial institutions were induced by any
representation made by the petitioner to sanction loan or deliver any
property and therefore the foundational fact required to constitute dishonest
inducement has not been found during the investigation. On the contrary
the documents demonstrate that the petitioner is victim of identity theft and
impersonation. The investigation also reveal that the petitioner lawfully
constructed the residential project “Ganapati Enclave” and executed a
genuine registered deed of conveyance in favour of Biswajit Sinha upon
receipt of lawful consideration. The deed was registered by using the
petitioner’s biometrics before the competent registering authority. It further
appears that immediately upon discovering the fraud petitioner lodged
complaints one after another before the police authorities, which conduct is
wholly inconsistent with that of a person harbouring dishonest or
fraudulent intention.
21. There is no allegation or any material collected during investigation
that any property, money or document or valuable security was ever
entrusted to the petitioner by the complainant or financial institution to
attract offence under Section 406 IPC against the petitioner. The amount
allegedly defrauded were credited to the bank account, which was opened
and operated by the co-accused persons and were subsequently syphoned
off by them. The I.O.’s report specifically attributes the acts of
12
impersonation, preparation of forged documents and receipt of the
defrauded amount to the co-accused person and not to the petitioner. There
is also nothing to show that the petitioner either prepared any forged
document or participated in its preparation of any forged document as
genuine and derive any pecuniary benefit from the alleged transaction. On
the contrary the prosecution material established that the petitioner’s
identity, signature was forged by the co-accused persons for perpetrating the
fraud.
22. In the present case it appears from the prosecution report that in
order to level the charge of criminal conspiracy against the petitioner the
prosecution relied upon following grounds namely:-
(a) Photograph of the petitioner with the co-accused person at the
construction site.
(b) Statement of the bank official recorded under section 161 Cr.P.C.
stating that he allegedly seen petitioner at the construction site along
with co-accused person.
(c) From the statements of accused no. 2, 4 it reveals that petitioner had
allowed access to the fraudster and showed the same to loan
sanctioning authorities and allegedly, he took financial benefits from
the fraudsters in cash.
23. In this context it appears that the petitioner is admittedly developer of
the residential project ‘‘Ganapati Enclave’’ and the co-accused persons had
approached the petitioner as prospective purchaser of a residential unit and
had visited the construction site in connection therewith. Therefore, merely
because the petitioner was photographed with the co-accused person at the
13
construction site hardly led to the conclusion that he had entered into a
criminal conspiracy with them. None of the photographs relied by the
prosecution discloses the commission of any illegal act or any conduct
suggestive of a conspiratorial agreement. At best the photographs merely
establish acquaintance or physical presence of the petitioner at the
construction site, which is insufficient to attract offence under section 120B.
24. So far as the statement of an official of the complainant bank made
under section 161 Cr.PC is concerned which states that the petitioner was
present at the construction site along with co-accused person, even if taken
at face value does not advance the prosecution case of conspiracy against
the petitioner. The bank official is not an eye witness to any alleged
agreement or meeting of minds between the petitioner and the co-accused
persons to commit crime. His statement merely speaks about the petitioner’s
physical presence at the construction site. The said witness has not alleged
that the petitioner made any false representation or furnished any forged
document or impersonated any person or received any loan proceeds or
induced any financial institution to part with any money. The statement
infact does not speak any overt act attributable to the petitioner in
furtherance of the alleged conspiracy. It is merely a suspicion that since the
petitioner was present with the co-accused person at the site, he must have
been involved with the criminal conspiracy.
25. Criminal conspiracy cannot be based on mere presumption or from
mere association. There must be independent material evidencing an
unlawful agreement which is absent in the present case. The prosecution
has also failed to explain as to how the petitioner could be a conspirator
14
when the investigation reveals that Debasis @ Babai Mazumder
impersonated the petitioner before the registering authorities. According to
investigation Subrata Debnath and Sunit Mondal prepared the forged
documents. Tamal Mukherjee opened the fictitious bank account in the
name of Ganpati Construction and the defrauded loan amount was credited
into accounts which did not belong to the petitioner or his firm. Moreover,
there is nothing to show that the petitioner received any pecuniary benefit or
had participated in the fraudulent loan transaction.
26. Though the opposite party no. 2/ de facto complainant has stated in
his affidavit-in-opposition that in all the aforesaid forged deeds petitioner is
a party and had received financial assistance from different financial
organizations/fraudsters but it appears that such allegation does not form
part of the written complaint and opposite party no. 2 for the first time had
made such allegation before this High Court after receipt of criminal revision
application. Opposite party no. 2 has failed to disclose as to how he derives
the knowledge that the forged deeds were prepared in connivance with the
petitioner or petitioner received financial assistance from different financial
organization, when during investigation nothing revealed to substantiate the
same. So far as the flow of money is concerned, the report dated 03.04.2024
submitted by the investigating officer would make it clear that petitioner is
not involved with the misappropriated money nor there is anything to show
that any amount of misappropriated money was transferred to the account
of petitioner or his firm. Therefore, from the prosecution documents it has
not been established that the petitioner was involved in the purported scam.
It has also not been established during investigation that the petitioner was
15
the mastermind or even a conspirator to the illegal transaction. Therefore, at
the end of investigation no prima facie case has been made out against the
petitioner in respect of any of the alleged offences under section
120B/420/406/465/467/468/471 of IPC.
27. It is settled law that conspiracy can’t be inferred merely on the basis
of suspicion or association but there must be cogent material indicating
meeting of minds between the accused persons to establish a charge of
conspiracy knowledge about indulgence in either an illegal act or a legal act
by illegal means is necessary. In the present case except the allegation of the
petitioner’s presence at the sight during the alleged visit of officer of the
complainant company, the prosecution has failed to show any substantive
evidence, indicating prior agreement or concert between the petitioner and
the principal accused persons. Mere acquaintance with the principal
accused person if any, does not bring about even a prima facie element of
conspiracy. FIR also does not speak of any overtact of the petitioner to
constitute any cognizable offence against him. Even the statement made by
the officer of the company under section 161 of the Cr.P.C does not help the
prosecution case as it does not speak of foundational fact of conspiracy
against the petitioner. Conspiracy has to be proved by conduct and
surrounding circumstances but in the present case, the FIR and available
materials prima facie failed to point out any conduct or circumstances that
can reasonably led one to believe the existence of the conspiracy. Conspiracy
must be founded on some facts either from the FIR or form the statement
form witness or documents seized during investigation. Mere association
with the accused person owing to business connection, in my opinion,
16
cannot give rise to an inference of meeting of mind between the petitioner on
the one hand and other principal accused persons on the other hand to
commit the act of forgery. The statement of the witness made during
investigation even if taken to be true is not sufficient to come to a
conclusive finding that the petitioner entered into an agreement with the
principal accused persons. The principal accused persons may have good
acquaintance with the petitioner but that is not sufficient to say that there
was a meeting of mind between the petitioner and other accused person to
plan the said act of forgery or misappropriation. The substantive evidence
collected during investigation is unconvincing for allowing the criminal
proceeding to continue against the present petitioner. Mere evidence of
association is not sufficient for inferring an act of conspiracy.
28. Therefore clause (e) of paragraph 102 of Bhajan Lal’s case reported in
1992 Supp (1) SCC 335 clearly attracts in the present context which says
that-
“(e) Where the allegations made in the FIR or
complaint are so absurd and inherently improbable
on the basis of which no prudent person can ever
reach a just conclusion that there is sufficient ground
for proceeding against the accused ”.
29. Therefore, I do not find any justification for continuance of the present
impugned proceeding against the petitioner in the absence of any prima
facie case of committing cognizable offence against him even after
completion of investigation.
30. CRR 1870 of 2024 is allowed.
17
31. The proceeding being GR(S) Case no. 45 of 2024 presently pending
before the court of learned Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Calcutta arising
out of Shakespear Sarani P.S Case no. 6 of 2024 dated 10.01.2024 is hereby
quashed, qua the petitioner Govind Kumar Gupta .
Urgent Xerox certified photocopies of this Judgment, if applied for, be given
to the parties upon compliance of the requisite formalities.
(DR. AJOY KUMAR MUKHERJEE, J.)
18