K.Baskaran vs The Inspector of Police

Court
Madras High Court

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT
Reserved On: 15.09.2026
Delivered On: 13.11.2026
CORAM:
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE A.D.JAGADISH CHANDIRA
and
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE B.MURUGESAN
CRL A(MD) No. 747 of 2023
CNR:{HCMD010904452023}
K.Baskaran ... Appellant
Vs.
The Inspector of Police
All Women Police Station,
Samayanallur,
Madurai District.
Crime No.24/2019. ... Respondent
PRAYER: Criminal Appeal filed under Section 374(2) Cr.P.C., to call for
the records and set aside the judgment and conviction dated 13.02.2023
by the learned Sessions Judge, Principal Special Court for Exclusive Trial
of Cases under POCSO Act, Madurai in Spl.S.C.No.11 of 2020 and
acquit the appellant.
For Appellant : Mr.S.Mahendrapathy
For Respondent : Mr.D.Venkatesh,
Additional Public Prosecutor.
__________
Page  1  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
JUDGMENT
[Judgment of the Court was made by B.MURUGESAN, J. ]
Assailing the judgment dated 13.02.2023 of the learned Sessions
Judge, Special Court for Exclusive Trial of Cases under POCSO Act,
Madurai, hereinafter referred to as ‘the trial court’, in Spl SC No.11/2020,
convicting the appellant/sole accused and sentencing him to undergo
imprisonment for life and to pay a fine of Rs.5,000/-, in default, to
undergo simple imprisonment for one year, for the offences punishable
under S.5(m) and S.5(n) r/w S.6 POCSO Act,2012, the appellant/sole
accused has preferred this criminal appeal.
02. Victim is 6 years old girl child, hereafter referred to as ‘the
child victim’, and her father is ‘the accused’.
03. Case of the prosecution would run as under:
(1) Accused married the mother of the child victim as his second
wife and the child victim is their second child studying in II standard.
(2) One day in July, 2019, when the child victim returned to the
house from the school, the accused who was alone in the house took the
child victim to a room, hugged her, sucked her breasts, kissed on her head
and cheeks, made her lay on the floor, inserted his finger into her vagina
and penetrated his penis into her vagina. Owing to such insertion and
__________
Page  2  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
penetration, the child victim got sores in her private parts and the accused
applied oil on such sores.
(3) On knowing such sores, the mother of the child victim, through
her elder sister, Mariammal, sent the child victim to Sathiyamoorthy
Nagar Govt Hospital where a doctor treated the child victim for such
sores.
(4) On 12.07.2019, the said doctor, in a medical camp at the school
where the child victim was studying, saw such sores in the private part of
the child victim and made an enquiry with the child victim who then
disclosed the occurrence to the said doctor. In turn, the doctor informed
the occurrence to the mother of the child victim and on enquiry with the
child victim, her mother also knew of the occurrence. Feeling scared of
the future of the child victim, her mother was silent.
(5) On 18.07.2019, Child Help Line, Madurai, received a call
informing of such occurrence and the counselors thereof made enquires
with the headmaster, the mother of the child victim, the elder maternal
aunt of the child victim, the child victim and BMO of Primary Health
Centre and knew of the occurrence.
(6) On 21.08.2018, the mother of the child victim lodged a
complaint with AWPS, Samayanallur, and accordingly, FIR in Cr No.
24/2019 on the file of AWPS, Samayanallur, was registered.
__________
Page  3  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
(7) Pursuant thereto, IO, Alagupandi, took the case for
investigation on 21.08.2019, inspected the house of the accused being the
place of occurrence and prepared the observation mahazar and rough
sketch in the presence of the witnesses, Kathiravan and Balamurugan,
and she examined the mother of the child victim, the child victim,
Mariammal, Kathiravan and Balamurugan and recorded their statements.
At about 20.40 hrs, IO, Alagupandi, arrested the accused near Sevuga
Bakery, Samayanallur, and caused the accused remanded to judicial
custody. On 22.08.2019, IO, Alagupandi, through Head Constable Sudha
Selvi, and Constable Madhavi, caused the child victim examined at
Madurai Govt Rajaji Hospital.
(8) On 26.08.2019, IO/PW22 took the case for investigation. On
27.08.2019, IO/PW22 examined the child victim and her mother and
recorded their further statements. On 29.08.2019, IO/PW22 caused the
statement of the child victim recorded under S.164 CrPC. On 29.08.2019,
IO/PW22, through Head Constables Sudha Selvi, and Murugan, caused
the accused examined at Madurai Govt Rajaji Hospital. IO/PW22
examined Teacher Deicy who issued a certificate as to the date of birth of
the child victim, and recorded her statement. IO/PW22 examined
Ponnuthai, Muthurani, Indra, Malarvizhi and Renuka Devi. On
__________
Page  4  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
30.08.2019, IO/PW22 examined Head Constables, Sudha Selvi, and
Murugan, and recorded their statements. On 30.09.2019, IO/PW22
examined Dr.Sorubarani and Dr.Muniappan, and recorded their
statements. On 15.10.2019, IO/PW22 examined Dr.Saravanan and nurses,
Hemalatha and Murugeswari, and recorded their statements. On
13.11.2019, IO/PW22 sent the accused to Dr.Vijayakumar for urology
test. On 20.12.2019, IO/PW22 examined Dr.Vijayakumar and
Dr.Navaneethakrishnan, and recorded their statements. After such
investigation, IO/PW22 filed a final report against the accused for the
offences punishable under S.5(l), S.5(m) and S.5(n) r/w S.6 POCSO Act,
2012.
04. On appearance of the accused before the trial court, he was
furnished free of cost with the copies of the records relied on by the
prosecution, as required under S.207 CrPC.
05. Thereupon, the learned Public Prosecutor opened the case
before the trial court, as under S.226 CrPC, and the learned counsel for
the accused was also heard. On due consideration thereof, charges were
framed by the trial court against the accused under S.5(l), S.5(m) and
S.5(n) r/w S.6 POCSO Act, 2012, and the same were read over and
explained to him by trial court, as under S.228 CrPC.
__________
Page  5  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
06. Accordingly, the accused was questioned by the trial court as to
the charges framed against him, and he denied the charges as not true,
pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
07. Pursuant thereto, trial was ordered, and the prosecution
produced evidence in support of its case, and therefore, the prosecution,
before the trial court, examined PW1 to PW22, and marked Ex.P1 to
Ex.P20 through the competent witnesses. Ex.C1 was also marked.
08. Details of the witnesses and the exhibits on the side of the
prosecution before the trial court are as under:
(1) PW1 is mother of the child victim who was declared hostile.
Ex.P1 is her signature in the complaint. PW2 is the child victim who was
also declared hostile. PW6 is Mariammal, the elder maternal aunt of the
child victim, who was also declared hostile.
(2) PW3, Muthurani, PW4, Indhira, and PW5, Malarvizhi, are
office bearers and members of All India Democratic Women's
Association (AIDWA) who came into the picture after the registration of
FIR.
__________
Page  6  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
(3) PW7, Renuga Devi, and PW11, Sobana Kumar, are counselors
in Child Help Line who would speak about their enquiry with the
headmaster, the mother of the child victim, the child victim and BMO of
Primary Health Centre.
(4) PW8 is Kathiravan who would speak of the preparation of
observation mahazar, Ex.P2, and rough sketch, Ex.P4.
(5) PW9 is Head Constable Sudha Selvi, and PW10 is Head
Constable Murugan, who would speak of the medical examination of the
child victim and the accused. Ex.P4 to Ex.P6 are the related passports.
(6) PW12 is Dr.Saravanan, BMO, PHC, Samayanallur, who would
speak of the medical camp held at the school where the child victim was
studying and the related events. Ex.P7 is his report/answers in response to
the questionnaire issued by IO/PW22. PW13 is Dr.Poorima, PHC,
Samayanallur, who would speak of the examination of the child victim at
the medical camp. PW14 is Hemalatha and PW15 is Murugeswari, the
medical staff at PHC, Samayanallur, who would speak of the examination
of the child victim at the medical camp.
(7) PW16 is Dr.Soruparani who conducted medical examination on
the child victim. Ex.P8 is her report.
(8) PW17 is Deicy, the teacher in Govt School where the child
victim was studying, who would speak of the medical camp at the school
__________
Page  7  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
and the related events. Ex.P9 is the school certificate showing the date of
birth of the child victim.
(9) PW18 is Navaneethakrishnan who issued biological report,
Ex.P10. PW19 is Dr.Vijayakumar who examined the accused, and
Ex.P11 is the requisition for such medical examination and Ex.P12 is his
report. PW20 is Dr.Muniappan who examined the accused, and Ex.P13 is
the requisition for such medical examination and Ex.P14 is his report.
(10) PW21 is Jeyamani, SI, AWPS, Samayanallur, who would
speak of the registration of FIR, Ex.P16, on the complaint, Ex.P15. PW22
is Grace Sophia Bai, IO, who would speak about the investigation in
detail and the consequent final report. Ex.P17 is the requisition for
recording the statement of the child victim under S.164 CrPC. Ex.P18 is
the statement of the child victim under S.164 CrPC and its proceedings is
Ex.C1. Ex.P19 is the requisition to RFSL, Madurai. Ex.P20 is the birth
certificate of the child victim.
09. While questioning under S.313 CrPC in respect of the
incriminating materials appearing against him in the evidence of the
prosecution, the accused answered before the trial court that all such
evidence is false and that this is a false case.
__________
Page  8  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
10. On the other hand, there is no evidence, either oral or
documentary, on the side of the accused.
11. Finding him guilty, the trial court has convicted the accused for
the offences under S.5(m) and S.5(n) r/w S.6 POCSO Act, 2012, and
sentenced him as aforesaid.
12. Assailing such conviction and sentence of the trial court, the
accused has preferred this criminal appeal before us.
13. We have heard the learned counsel for the appellant/accused
and the learned counsel for the State (Criminal Side), and we have also
perused the records carefully.
14. Learned counsel appearing for the appellant/accused would
submit that PW1, PW2 and PW6, the material witnesses, have turned
hostile, that PW1, the defacto complainant, has disowned the contents of
the complaint, Ex.P15, that PW2, the child victim, has not supported the
case of the prosecution both in her statement recorded under S.164(5)
CrPC and in her evidence before the court, that PW2, the child victim,
has given evidence to the effect that her cousin poked a wooden stick into
__________
Page  9  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
her private part, that PW2, the child victim, has also mentioned the name
of her such cousin and his mother in her statement recorded under
S.164(5) CrPC, that the evidence of PW3, PW4 and PW5 is hearsay, that
PW7 and PW11 are Child Help Line counselors whose evidence is also
hearsay, that even though the medical camp is said to have been
conducted at the school on 12.07.2019, the complaint is said to have been
given by the mother of the child victim only on 21.08.2019, that
therefore, the evidence of PW12 and PW13, the doctors, of PW14, and
PW15, the medical team, and of PW7 and PW11, the Child Help Line
counselors, are obviously shrouded in mystery, that the medical evidence
would also not support the case of the prosecution, that since the
foundational facts for the offence are not proved, the statutory
presumption under S.29 POCSO Act, 2012, would not arise driving the
accused to prove the contrary and that therefore, a judgment reversing the
finding and sentences of the trial court, and acquitting the accused of all
the charges leveled against him needs to be passed.
15. Per contra , the learned counsel for the State (Criminal Side)
would submit that even though PW1, PW2 and PW6, the material
witnesses, have turned hostile, the medical evidence would bring home
the offence, that the delay in lodging the complaint under POCSO Act,
__________
Page  10  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
2012, would not absolve the accused of the crime, that the evidence of
PW12 and PW13, the doctors, of PW14, and PW15, the medical team,
and of PW7 and PW11, the Child Help Line counselors, would obviously
support the case of the prosecution, that the evidence of PW12, PW13,
PW14, PW15, PW7 and PW11 would corroborate each other in all
material particulars, that since the accused is the father of the child victim
having committed penetrative sexual assault on the child victim aged
about 6 years, the offence committed by the accused is nothing but the
offence of aggravated penetrative sexual assault as under S.5(m) and
S.5(n) POCSO Act, 2012, punishable under S.6 POCSO Act, 2012, as
amended, that since the prosecution has established the foundational facts
for the offence of aggravated penetrative sexual assault, the prosecution
would enjoy the presumption as under S.29 POCSO Act, 2012, that there
is nothing on the side of the accused to rebut such presumption and that
therefore, the criminal appeal filed by the accused deserves for dismissal.
16. Point for determination in this appeal is whether the trial court
is right in finding the appellant/accused guilty and thereby convicting and
sentencing him under S.5(m) and S.5(n) r/w S.6 POCSO Act, 2012?
17. 09.03.2013 is the date of birth of the child victim, as evidenced
__________
Page  11  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
by her birth certificate, Ex.P20, and 12.07.2019 is the date of the medical
camp where the occurrence is said to have surfaced. It is therefore clear
that the victim, during the alleged occurrence, had been a child below the
age of 18 years as under S.2(1)(d) POCSO Act, 2012.
18. Of course, it is true that PW1, the mother of the child victim,
PW2, the child victim, and PW6, the elder maternal aunt of the child
victim, who is said to have taken the child victim to Sathiyamoorthy
Nagar Govt Hospital, have turned hostile and accordingly, they have been
declared hostile.
19. Two cardinal principles, with which we would like to fumigate
our mind, are (1) that the evidence of a hostile witness need not
necessarily be discarded in toto and any dependable portion thereof can
be relied on either by the prosecution or by the defense (vide
C.Muniappan and others V State of Tamil Nadu (2010) 9 SCC 567 ),
and (2) that even though the victim and her parents turn hostile in cases
under POCSO Act, 2012, the prosecution can still succeed if there is/are
other evidence proving the guilt of the accused.
20. Therefore, the questions before us are (a) whether there is any
__________
Page  12  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
dependable portion in the evidence of PW1, PW2 and/or PW6,
supporting the case of the prosecution, and (b) whether there is/are any
other evidence proving the guilt of the accused?
21. Coming to the first question referable to the dependable portion
in the evidence of PW1, PW2 and/or PW6,
(1) PW1, the mother of the child victim, would state in her chief
examination inter alia that she did not lodge any complaint, that her
signatures were obtained in several blank white papers, that she did not
send her daughter/PW2 to the hospital and that the police did not examine
her. During her cross examination by the prosecution, nothing contrary
has been elicited to disbelieve her evidence in the chief examination.
During her cross examination by the defense, she would state she
informed to the police that one xxx (a male child) caused such injury to
her daughter/PW2 but the police did not accept.
(2) PW2, the child victim, would state in her chief examination
inter alia that when she studied in II standard, her cousin xxx poked a
wooden stick into her private part, that she informed to the doctor that her
cousin xxx poked a wooden stick into her private part, that she informed
to the police that her cousin xxx poked a wooden stick into her private
__________
Page  13  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
part, that the police did not believe, that the police tortured her to tell the
name of her father (as the perpetrator) and that the police took her to a
court where too the police tortured her to tell the name of her father (as
the perpetrator), as under (in her vernacular language):
“ ehd ; J}q;fpl;L ,Uf;fg;g jz;zpa bjspr;R
vGg;gp mg;ght brhy;YD lhh;r;rh ; gz;zhq;f.
mg;gwk; Crp nghl;lhq;f. ehd ; v];.I. fpl;l ruz;
jhd; Fr;rpa tr;R Fj;jpdhd;D brhd;ndd;. mtq;f
ek;gy. nghyp];fhuq;f mg;ght brhy;YD lhh;r;rh;
bfhLj;jhq;f. ,d;bdhU nfhh;l;Lf;F Tl;ol;L
nghdq;f. mq;ifa[k ; mg;ght brhy;YD lhh;r;rh;
gz;zhq;f. ehd; ruz; ngu jhd; brhd;ndd;. ”
Even during her cross examination by the prosecution, she would
reiterate that her cousin xxx poked a wooden stick into her private part,
that she informed to the doctor that her cousin xxx poked a wooden stick
into her private part, that she informed to the police that her cousin xxx
poked a wooden stick into her private part and that the police tortured her
to tell the name of her father (as the perpetrator).
(3) PW6, the elder maternal aunt of the child victim, who is said to
have taken the child victim to Sathiyamoorthy Nagar Govt Hospital,
would state in her chief examination that she did not know anything
about the occurrence and that the police did not examine her. During her
cross examination by the prosecution, nothing contrary has been elicited
__________
Page  14  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
to disbelieve her evidence in the chief examination.
22. It is therefore clear that the evidence of PW1, PW2 and/or PW6
is absolutely bereft of any dependable portion which the prosecution can
rely on against the accused.
23. Coming to the next question relating to ‘any other evidence
proving the guilt of the accused’,
(1) PW3, PW4 and PW5 are office bearers and members of All
India Democratic Women's Association (AIDWA) who came into the
picture after the registration of FIR.
(2) PW7 and PW11 are counselors in Child Help Line who came
into the picture only on 18.07.2019 whereas the medical camp is said to
have been conducted on 12.07.2019. Be that as it may, PW7 would state
as if the mother of the child victim/PW1 and the elder maternal aunt of
the child victim/PW6, during enquiry by such counselors, narrated the
occurrence pointing out the accused as the perpetrator but the child victim
did not say anything. On the contrary, PW11 would state as if the child
victim/PW1, during enquiry by such counselors, narrated the occurrence
pointing out the accused as the perpetrator. Therefore, the evidence of
PW7 and PW11, in our considered view, is neither credible nor reliable.
__________
Page  15  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
(3) PW12 to PW15 is the medical team which is said to have
conducted the medical camp at the school. PW12, Dr.Saravanan, BMO,
would admit both in his chief examination and his cross examination to
the effect that PW13, Dr. Poornima, examined the child victim and as
such, his evidence and his report, Ex.P7, are purely hearsay. PW14, the
medical staff, would also admit in her cross examination that she had no
personal knowledge about the injuries spoken to by the child victim.
(4) PW13, Dr. Poornima, and PW15, the other medical staff, would
state that during the medical examination of the child victim, the child
victim said her father/accused caused such injuries in her private part by
inserting his finger. Firstly, there is nothing on record to show the alleged
medical camp at the school or to show the child victim was examined at
the medical camp. Secondly, PW12, Dr.Saravanan, BMO, would speak of
a first aid given to the child victim whereas PW13, Dr. Poornima, and
PW15, the other medical staff, would state that the child victim was
referred to Madurai without any treatment at the medical camp.
Therefore, we are of the firm view that it would be unsafe to sustain the
conviction of the accused only on the evidence of PW13, Dr. Poornima,
and PW15, the other medical staff.
(5) What remains is Ex.P8, the medical report of the child victim
issued by PW16, Dr.Soruparani. Of course, Ex.P8 would say that the
__________
Page  16  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
hymen of the child victim was not intact. But, PW16, Dr.Soruparani,
would explain that cycling or other games/sports might cause the hymen
ruptured/damaged.
(6) Other witnesses, as indicated above, are usual and official
witnesses whose evidence would not assume much importance.
24. Resultantly, we answer the second question in such a way that
there is/are no other evidence proving the guilt of the accused.
25. Technically speaking with reference to the statutory
presumption under S.29 POCSO Act, 2012, the prosecution has
miserably failed to establish the foundational facts for the offence under
POCSO Act, 2012. As the result thereof, the prosecution cannot take aid
of such statutory presumption as under S.29 POCSO Act, 2012. Because,
only when the foundational facts are proved by unimpeachable evidence,
the statutory presumption under S.29 POCSO Act, 2012, would rule the
field, as recently held by the Apex Court in Debraj Dutta V State of
West Bengal and another (2026 LiveLaw (SC) 401) .
26. Assuming arguendo that the prosecution has established in this
__________
Page  17  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
case such foundational facts for the offences under POCSO Act, 2012, as
claimed by the prosecution, the statutory presumption under S.29 POCSO
Act, 2012, is not static or not irrebuttable. S.29 POCSO Act, 2012,
would read as under:
29. Presumption as to certain offences.—Where a
person is prosecuted for committing or abetting or
attempting to commit any offence under sections 3, 5, 7 and
section 9 of this Act, the Special Court shall presume, that
such person has committed or abetted or attempted to
commit the offence, as the case may be unless the contrary
is proved . (italics supplied by this court)
It is therefore clear from the phrase ‘unless the contrary is proved’ that
the statutory presumption under S.29 POCSO Act, 2012, is, of course,
rebuttable and that the accused is at liberty to rebut such presumption
even by the preponderance of probabilities.
27. Deepak in JC V State Govt of NCT Delhi (2026 INSC 1008)
is a very recent case where Hon’ble Apex Court has elaborately explained
the role of such statutory presumption in the appreciation of evidence and
the relevant excerpts would read as under:
‘7.4 The statutory presumptions cannot be read to
mean that the prosecution version is liable to be treated as
gospel truth in every case. It has to be additionally observed
by this Court the presumptive provisions notwithstanding,
__________
Page  18  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
the courts are not absolved from discharging their essential
duty to analyse the evidence on record in light of the
features emerging in a particular case. The court should not
mechanically accept the ipse dixit of the prosecution riding
on the provisions regarding presumption of guilt to give a
stamp of approval to every prosecution even if they are
absurd or improbable in its story. At the end of the trial, the
accused should not stand at a discount or at disadvantage
only for the reason that the particular statute under which he
is tried for the offence contains presumptive provisions
about the guilt of the accused.
7.5 The reverse burden contemplated in presumptive
provisions could be said to be an additional weapon in the
armoury of prosecution. However, this arm could be
thwarted by the accused by leading evidence to the
contrary. Differently stated, the presumption of commission
of offence, or the presumption of culpability mental state,
are rebuttable presumptions. The truthfulness of the factum
raised by way of statutory presumptions can be countered
by the accused by leading evidence. Although the
prosecution may have established the primary facts relating
to commission of offence, once the accused discharges his
burden of shifting onus to be able to show that the state of
things are otherwise or that the accused raises a valid
defence, the presumption of guilt and culpability would
start disappearing.
__________
Page  19  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
7.5.1 The rebuttal of presumption by the accused
could be in several ways as may be permissible in law. The
accused may demolish the prosecution version by
discrediting the prosecution witnesses or falsify them in the
cross-examination. The presumption could be kept at bay
by showing inherent inconsistencies and contradictions in
the evidence of the prosecution. The rebuttal may be
achieved by pointing out the absurdities and the gaps in the
prosecution story and by bringing out the loopholes therein.
The absence of proof of relevant facts, mismatch of ocular
and medical evidence and non-corroboration of the
evidence in different walks may also be good tools for
rebuttal. The accused may also raise available statutory
defence or factual defence to counter the allegations of the
prosecution. He may by his version in defence show the
improbability of the prosecution case.
7.5.2 The presumption of commission of offence and
that of guilty mental state which has been applied at the
beginning of the trial in view of the presumptive provisions
in that regard, may at the stage of the conclusion of
evidence, vanish if the reverse burden is successfully
discharged by the accused to rebut the prosecution case. In
ultimate analysis, it will be the total canvass of evidence
which would play a decisive role. The presumptive
provisions do not operate to oust the evidence standing in
favour of the accused.
……………
__________
Page  20  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
……………
9. In the case of conviction or acquittal of the accused
facing trial for any criminal offence, what is necessarily
involved is the issue of his personal liberty. When an issue
concerning the liberty of an individual is involved to be
dealt with in law, the court has to be extra careful and
cautious. The court should always undertake objective
assessment and appreciation of evidence. Therefore, in
addressing the entitlement of the accused to the acquittal,
the court should not overweigh itself with the provisions
like that of Section 29 or Section 30 of the POCSO Act.’
28. In a bid to prove the contrary, the learned counsel for the
accused would bring to our notice the following points affecting the case
of the prosecution.
(1) PW2, the child victim, in her statement, Ex.P18, recorded under
S.164(5) CrPC, does not even whisper anything about much less against
her father/accused, instead, she implicates her cousin xxx and his mother.
(2) Despite such implications/imputations in Ex.P18, recorded
under S.164(5) CrPC, the prosecution did not choose make any
investigation with respect to such imputations against such cousin xxx or
his mother.
(3) As discussed earlier, PW2, the child victim, would state in her
chief examination that her cousin xxx poked a wooden stick into her
__________
Page  21  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
private part, that she informed to the doctor that her cousin xxx poked a
wooden stick into her private part and that she informed to the police that
her cousin xxx poked a wooden stick into her private part.
(4) As discussed earlier, PW2, the child victim, would state in her
chief examination that the police tortured her to tell the name of her
father (as the perpetrator) and that the police took her to a court where too
the police tortured her to tell the name of her father (as the perpetrator).
(5) 12.07.2019 is the date of the medical camp where the
occurrence is said to have surfaced and the complaint is said to have been
given only on 21.08.2019, that too, by her mother, not by the medical
team, not by the headmistress or not by the Child Help Line personnel.
(6) Despite such an occurrence is said to have been brought to their
knowledge, such stakeholders are portrayed to have been silent.
(7) PW1 disowns the complaint, Ex.P15, saying that she did not
lodge any complaint and that her signatures were obtained in several
blank white papers.
(8) Notably, PW7, the Child Help Line counselor, would bring a
different picture/story in her chief examination that on 22.07.2015, they
took the child victim to Sathiyamoorthy Nagar Govt Hospital where the
doctor described that she had already treated the child victim for the burn
injuries on her lower abdomen and that such injuries were caused to her
__________
Page  22  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
by the flames during Karthigai Deepam, as under (in her vernacular
language):
ehq;fs; 22Mk; njjp rj;jpaK:h;j;jp efh; M];gj;jphpf;F
Tl;ol;L nghndhk;. mq;f lhf;lh ; tphpthf brhd;dhh;.
me;j FHe;ijf;F nyhah ; mg;lkdpy;
jPf;fhaq;fs ; ,Ug;gjhf brhd;dhh;. mJ fhh;j;jpif
jPgk; mg;ngh jP gpoj;jjhf brhd;dhh;. mog;gFjpapy;
kl;Lk; jhd; gl;Ls;sJ vd;W brhd;dhh;. ,e;j mog;gl;l
fhaj;jpw;Fk;> nkw;go rk;gtj;jpd ; nghJ xnu
kUj;Jthplk; jhd; brd;Ws;shh;fs;. mjhdy; jhd; me;j
kUj;Jth ; tphpthf brhd;dhh;. ghjpf;fg;gl;l rpWkpapd;
bgz;Zwg;gpy; g[z;zhf ,Ue;jjhf brhd;dhh;.
(9) It is not known who treated the child victim for the burn
injuries and who treated the child victim, prior to the medical camp, for
the sores in her private part.
(10) PW1, PW2 and PW6 who are portrayed to be the material
witnesses have turned hostile.
29. In the light of the foregoing discussions and reasons, we are of
the firm view that even if we take for a moment that the prosecution has
established in this case the foundational facts for the offences under
POCSO Act, 2012, the accused has successfully proved such contraries
as aforesaid and thereby rebutted the statutory presumption under S.29
__________
Page  23  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
POCSO Act, 2012, leaving the prosecution desolated.
30. Before parting with, we would like to point out that giving
much emphasis on Illustration (j) to S.8 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872,
the trial court has found the accused guilty under S.5(m) and S.5(n) r/w
S.6 POCSO Act,2012, and sentenced him accordingly. S.8 of the Indian
Evidence Act, 1872, would read as under:
S.8. Motive, preparation and previous or subsequent conduct.
Any fact is relevant which shows or constitutes a
motive or preparation for any fact in issue or relevant
fact.
The conduct of any party, or of any agent to any party, to
any suit or proceeding, in reference to such suit or
proceeding, or in reference to any fact in issue or
relevant thereto, and the conduct of any person an
offence against whom is the subject of any proceeding is
relevant, if such conduct influences or is influenced by
any fact in issue or relevant fact, and whether it was
previous or subsequent thereto.
Explanation 1. - The word "conduct" in this
section does not include statements; unless those
statements accompany and explain acts other than
statements; but this explanation is not to affect the
relevancy of statements under any other section of this
Act.
Explanation 2. - When the conduct of any person
__________
Page  24  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
is relevant, any statement made to him or in his presence
and hearing, which affects such conduct, is relevant.
Illustrations
……….
……….
(j) The question is, whether A was ravished. The facts
that, shortly after the alleged rape, she made a complaint
relating to the crime, the circumstances under which, and
terms in which, the complaint was made, are relevant.
The fact that, without making a complaint, she said that
she had been ravished is not relevant as conduct under
this section, though it may be relevant, as a dying
declaration under section 32, clause (1), or as
corroborative evidence under section 157. (italics
supplied by this court)
Even a cursory look on the illustration (j), with reference to the
explanations, would make it clear that it deals with the conduct of the
victim shortly after the crime committed on her.
31. Here is a case where PW1, the mother of the child victim, is
said to have given the complaint, that too, 40 days after the occurrence is
said to have surfaced at a medical camp. Further, PW1 disowns the
complaint, Ex.P15, saying that she did not lodge any complaint and that
her signatures were obtained in several blank white papers. Furthermore,
PW2, the child victim, would state in her chief examination that the
__________
Page  25  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
police tortured her to tell the name of her father (as the perpetrator) and
that the police took her to a court where too the police tortured her to tell
the name of her father (as the perpetrator). In such circumstances,
Illustration (j) to S.8 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, would not come
into play.
32. Ex consequenti , we hold that the trial court is not right in
finding the appellant/accused guilty and thereby convicting and
sentencing him under S.5(m) and S.5(n) r/w S.6 POCSO Act, 2012.
33. In fine,
(a) that this criminal appeal shall stand allowed,
(b) that the finding and sentence of the trial court in
Spl.SC.No.11/2020 is hereby reversed,
(c) that the appellant/accused is hereby acquitted of the charge
under S.5(m) and S.5(n) r/w S.6 POCSO Act, 2012,
(d) that the appellant/accused is hereby set at liberty,
(e) that the appellant/accused, unless his detention is required in
any other case, shall be released forthwith,
(f) that the fine amount, if paid by the appellant/accused, shall be
refunded, and
__________
Page  26  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
(g) that the bail bond executed by the appellant/accused shall stand
cancelled.
[A.D.J.C., J.] [B.M., J.]
13.11.2026
gns
To
1.The Inspector of Police
All Women Police Station,
Samayanallur,
Madurai District.
2.The Sessions Judge,
Principal Special Court for Exclusive Trial of Cases under POCSO Act,
Madurai
3.The Additional Public Prosecutor,
Madurai Bench of Madras High Court,
Madurai.
__________
Page  27  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )

Crl.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
A.D.JAGADISH CHANDIRA, J.
AND
B.MURUGESAN, J.
gns
Pre-Delivery Judgment made in
CRL.A.(MD)No.747 of 2023
13.11.2026
__________
Page  28  of  28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:07:25 pm )