Sushma And Anr vs Devender And Ors.

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

CM-3934-CII-2026 in/and
FAO-1007-2026 (O&M) -1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
133 CM-3934-CII-2026 in/and
FAO-1007-2026 (O&M)
Date of decision: 12.11.2026
Sushma and another ....Appellants
Vs.
Devender and others ....Respondents
CORAM : HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE HARSH BUNGER
Present: Mr. Rajesh Duhan, Advocate
for the applicants/appellants.
HARSH BUNGER J. (Oral)
CM-3934-CII-2026:
Present application is filed seeking condonation of delay of 20
days in filing the main case i.e. FAO-1007-2026.
For the reasons mentioned in the application, delay of 20 days
in filing the main case i.e. FAO-1007-2026 is condoned.
Application is accordingly disposed of.
FAO-1007-2026 (O&M):
1. The present appeal has been filed by the claimants challenging
the award dated 10.11.2025 passed by the learned Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, Jind (hereinafter referred to as 'the Tribunal'), seeking
enhancement of compensation of Rs.21,69,190/- awarded by the learned
Tribunal in MACP-239-2024 on account of death of Sh. Rakesh in a motor
vehicular accident.
2. Briefly, the present appellants/claimants filed a petition under
Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (in short '1988 Act') seeking
ANKIT
2026.11.18 11:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

CM-3934-CII-2026 in/and
FAO-1007-2026 (O&M) -2-
compensation on account of accidental death of Sh. Rakesh, on the plea that
on 22.07.2024, Rakesh, along with his friends Parveen son of Kuldeep, and
Ruchin son of Jasbir, residents of Village Farmana, District Rohtak, had
gone to Julana for some personal work on a motorcycle bearing registration
No.HR-15E-3626. Rakesh is stated to be driving the motorcycle and at about
8:30/9:00 PM, when they were returning and reached near the canal bridge
in the area of Village Desh Khera, a motorcycle bearing registration
No.HR-16AA-3289 (hereinafter referred to as 'the offending vehicle'), which
was being driven by Devender (respondent No. 1), came from the opposite
side in a rash and negligent manner and at a high speed and directly hit the
motorcycle of Rakesh, as a result of which Rakesh and Parveen suffered
multiple serious injuries and they were taken to the CHC, Julana, however,
due to serious condition of Rakesh, the doctors referred him to PGIMS,
Rohtak, where Rakesh disclosed the registration number of the offending
motorcycle to his brother Ashok.
2.1 Thereafter, on the advice of the Medical Officer, PGIMS,
Rohtak; Rakesh (who was having Ayushman Card) was taken to Malik
Hospital, Hansi, but when his condition could not be improved, then on
23.07.2024, he was taken to Kesri Hospital, Hisar for better treatment where
he remained admitted up to 24.07.2024. Since there was no improvement in
his health, he was taken to Jindal Institute of Medical Sciences, Hisar,
however, he succumbed to his injuries on 25.07.2024. A case FIR No. 212
dated 25.07.2024 was registered at Police Station Julana under Sections 106,
125(a) and 281 BNS regarding the accident in question on the statement of
Ashok (brother of deceased - Rakesh).
ANKIT
2026.11.18 11:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

CM-3934-CII-2026 in/and
FAO-1007-2026 (O&M) -3-
3. Upon issuance of notice by the learned Tribunal, a joint written
statement was filed on behalf of the driver and owner of the offending
vehicle namely Devender and Sandeep respectively, wherein they raised
various preliminary objections. They stated that the accident took place due
to the sole negligence of the deceased himself. On merits, they stated that a
false FIR has been lodged against Devender in collusion with the police to
get false compensation. The other averments of the claim petition were
denied and it was also stated that in case the learned Tribunal comes to the
conclusion that accident took place on account of rash and negligent driving
of Devender, then in that eventuality, respondent No. 3-Insurance Company
is liable to indemnify the insured.
4. On the other hand, respondent No. 3-Insurance Company filed
its separate written statement thereby denying the factum of accident and
stating that the offending vehicle has been falsely involved only to get false
amount of compensation from the Insurance Company. It was also stated that
there was a delay of three days in lodging the FIR and that there is no
eye-witness to the accident. It was also stated that the owner and driver of
the offending vehicle have not complied with the mandatory provisions of
Section 134(c) and 158 of the 1988 Act, and even the FIR has been falsely
registered.
4.1 It was also the plea of the Insurance Company that the driver of
the offending vehicle was not having a valid and effective driving license,
therefore, the insured had violated the terms and conditions of the insurance
policy; accordingly, the Insurance Company was not liable to indemnify the
insured.
ANKIT
2026.11.18 11:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

CM-3934-CII-2026 in/and
FAO-1007-2026 (O&M) -4-
5. From the pleadings of the parties, the learned Tribunal framed
the following issues:-
“1. Whether the accident in question resulting into death of
Rakesh son of Sube Singh took place on account of rash
and negligent driving on the part of respondent No1. While
driving offending vehicle?OPP
2. If issue No.1 is proved, whether the claimants are entitled
to any compensation, if so, how much and from whom?OPP
3. Whether respondent No.2 has violated terms and conditions
of the insurance policy? OPR(insurance company)
4. Relief.”
6. Thereafter, the parties led their respective evidence on the
aforesaid issues.
7. The learned Tribunal, upon consideration of the matter, returned
a finding under issue No. 1 that the accident resulting in death of Rakesh
took place on account of rash and negligent driving on the part of Devender
(respondent No. 1) while driving the offending vehicle.
7.1 Under issues No. 2 and 3, the learned Tribunal concluded that
deceased - Rakesh was 35 years of age at the time of accident, and further,
since no concrete and reliable evidence had been led on record to prove the
occupation and income of the deceased - Rakesh, accordingly, the learned
Tribunal, while placing reliance upon a judgment rendered by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court of India in the case of “Smt. Neeta vs. Divisional Manager,
MSRTC, Kolhapur”, 2015(1) Law Herald (SC) 105 , assessed the income of
deceased - Rakesh as Rs.11,000/- per month on the basis of minimum wages
(applicable on the date of accident) as fixed by Labour Commissioner,
Haryana.
ANKIT
2026.11.18 11:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

CM-3934-CII-2026 in/and
FAO-1007-2026 (O&M) -5-
7.2 The learned Tribunal further awarded 40% towards future
prospects and considering that deceased - Rakesh had left two dependents,
accordingly 1/3rd amount was deducted towards personal expenses of the
deceased. The learned Tribunal, considering the age of the deceased, applied
a multiplier of 16, and assessed the compensation amount as Rs.19,71,200/-.
The learned Tribunal further awarded compensation under the conventional
heads i.e. Rs.18,000/- towards funeral expenses; Rs.18,000/- towards loss of
estate; Rs.48,000/- (each) to both the claimants on account of loss of
consortium. The learned Tribunal also awarded Rs.65,990/- towards medical
bills. In this manner, the learned Tribunal awarded total compensation of
Rs.21,69,190/- to be paid to the claimants along with interest @ 7.5% per
annum from the date of filing of the claim petition till its realization.
7.3 The learned Tribunal further held the driver and owner of the
offending vehicle as well as respondent No. 3 - Insurance Company as
jointly and severally liable to pay the compensation, however, since the
offending vehicle was insured with respondent No. 3 - Insurance Company,
accordingly, Insurance Company was directed to discharge the liability for
payment of compensation.
8. Feeling dissatisfied, the appellants/claimants have preferred the
present appeal seeking enhancement of compensation on the following
grounds:
(a) that the learned Tribunal has erred in assessing the income
of the deceased - Rakesh;
(b) that the learned Tribunal has not awarded any amount
towards future prospects;
ANKIT
2026.11.18 11:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

CM-3934-CII-2026 in/and
FAO-1007-2026 (O&M) -6-
(c) that the learned Tribunal has not considered the loss of
consortium to the minor son of the deceased – Rakesh; and
(d) that the learned Tribunal has erred in awarding interest on
the compensation amount at 7.5%, rather should have
granted 12% interest on the compensation amount.
9. No other submission has been made.
10. I have heard learned counsel for the appellants and perused the
paperbook with his able assistance.
11. Perusal of the record of the case shows that although it was
pleaded case of the appellants/claimants that the deceased - Rakesh was
working as a partner in Preeti DM and RO Water Solution Plant and also he
was having 3 acres of agricultural land and used to take another 6 acres of
agricultural land on lease from one Amit, to claim that he was earning
Rs.50,000/- per month, however, the learned Tribunal, upon appraisal of the
evidence, came to the conclusion that no convincing evidence had been
placed on record to prove that deceased - Rakesh was a partner in the RO
plant or was owning any agricultural land, and also that there was no
evidence to show that deceased - Rakesh had taken land on lease from Amit.
Accordingly, since there was no concrete and reliable evidence as regards
the income of the deceased - Rakesh, therefore, the learned Tribunal
assessed the income of the deceased as Rs.11,000/- per month based upon
the minimum wages notified by the Labour Commissioner, Haryana (as
applicable on the date of accident).
12. Before this Court as well, learned counsel for the appellants has
not shown any bank account statement of the deceased - Rakesh or any other
document which may indicate that the deceased was having income of
ANKIT
2026.11.18 11:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

CM-3934-CII-2026 in/and
FAO-1007-2026 (O&M) -7-
Rs.50,000/- per month. That apart, no copy of the lease deed or even J-Form
has been produced on record to prima facie indicate that the
deceased - Rakesh was doing agricultural work on some land.
12.1 Once there is no documentary evidence as regards the
salary/income of the deceased - Rakesh, accordingly I see no error in the
approach of the learned Tribunal in assessing the income of the deceased as
Rs.11,000/- per month on the basis of the minimum wage notification issued
by the Labour Commissioner, Haryana.
13. As regards the plea of the appellants that the learned Tribunal
has not granted future prospects as well as consortium to the minor son, it is
observed that the learned Tribunal has duly granted 40% future prospects,
and even the loss of parental consortium has also been awarded to the minor
son, therefore, there is no substance in the said aforesaid pleas of the
appellants and the same are rejected.
14. Further, learned counsel for the appellants has contended that
the learned Tribunal has erred in awarding interest @ 7.5% per annum and
that the same deserves to be enhanced to 12% per annum. In this regard, it is
apposite to refer to the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
“Puttamma v. K.L. Narayana Reddy”, 2014 (1) RCR (Civil) 443, wherein it
was observed as under:
“57. Secti on  171 of the Act, 1988 deals with the award of
interest where any claim is allowed, it reads as follows :
"171.  Award of interest where any claim is allowed.  - Where
any Claims Tribunal allows a claim for compensation made
under this Act, such Tribunal may direct that in addition to the
amount of compensation simple interest shall also be paid at
ANKIT
2026.11.18 11:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

CM-3934-CII-2026 in/and
FAO-1007-2026 (O&M) -8-
such rate and from such date not earlier than the date of
making the claim as it may specify in this behalf."
Under the said provision no rate of interest has been fixed and
its duty is bestowed upon the Tribunal to fix the rate of interest.
58. The rate of interest provided and granted under different
Acts is as under :
(a) The Section 4A (3) of the Workmen's Compensation Act,
1923 provides payment of interest @12% per annum or at such
higher rate not exceeding the maximum of the lending rate of
the scheduled banks for the delayed payment of compensation.
(b) The Consumer Protection Act even though provides no
provision for grant of interest, this Court has granted interest
by invoking Section  3  of the Interest Act and Section  34  of the
CPC and has awarded interest @ 12% to 18% for delayed
payment.
(c) The Land Acquisition Act provides for the interest for
delayed payment @ 9% for the first year and 15% for the rest
of the years.
(d) The Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 provides for
interest @ 18% per annum under Section 31(7) of the Act.”
14.1 In view of the aforesaid authoritative pronouncement, the rate
of interest is a matter of judicial discretion to be exercised on the facts and
circumstances of each case. The learned Tribunal has awarded interest @
7.5% per annum from the date of filing of the claim petition till its
realization, which cannot be said to be either arbitrary or inadequate so as to
warrant interference by this Court.
15. From the above facts, it is clear that a just and fair
compensation has been awarded to the appellants. Nothing whatsoever has
been shown to this Court that would merit enhancement of the compensation
granted to the appellants. No doubt, Chapter-12 of the Act is a beneficial
ANKIT
2026.11.18 11:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

CM-3934-CII-2026 in/and
FAO-1007-2026 (O&M) -9-
legislation yet, as cautioned by the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the same cannot
be allowed to be treated as a windfall or a source of profit. The Hon'ble
Supreme Court in 'State of Haryana & Another v. Jasbir Kaur & Others'
2007(7) SCC 484 and ‘Divisional Controller K.S.R.T.C. v. Mahadeva
Shetty’, (2003) 7 SCC 197, has held that the amount of compensation should
be just and reasonable, it should neither be a bonanza nor a source of profit
but at the same time it should not be a pittance.
16. In view of the above, the present appeal stands dismissed .
17. All the pending application(s), if any, shall also stand closed.
(HARSH BUNGER)
12.11.2026 JUDGE
Ankit
Whether speaking/reasoned: Yes/No
Whether reportable: Yes/No
ANKIT
2026.11.18 11:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh