Amu S Makwana vs M/o Railways

Court
Central Administrative Tribunal

:: 1 :: O.A.No.583/2017

CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
AHMEDABAD BENCH

O.A. No. 583/2017

th
Dated this the 26 Day of October, 2026

CORAM:
Hon’ble Shri Jayesh V Bhairavia, Member (J)
Hon’ble, Shri Sanjiv Kumar, Member (A)

1. Shri AMU S. Makwana
S/o. Shakerbhi Makwana
Aged 61 years,
Retd. Points man from operating Department
Under DRM (E), RJT.
R/O.: Vill: Valana, Tal: Viramgam
Dist- Ahmedabad – 363001.
……………………. Applicant.
(By Advocate: Ms. S.S. Chaturvedi)

VERSUS

1. Union of India,
Notice to be served through,
General Manager,
Western Railway,
Churchgate, Mumbai – 400020.

2. Divisional Railway Manager (E)
Rajkot Division
Kothi Compound, Rajkot – 360001.

3. Assistant Divisional Finance Manager,
Rajkot Division,
Kothi Compound, Rajkot – 360001.
Pratapnagar, Baroda – 390004.
………………….. Respondents.
(By Advocate: Ms. R.R. Patel)

2026.11.04
PRATIK VYAS
15:00:54+05'30'

:: 2 :: O.A.No.583/2017

O R D E R (ORAL)
Per : Hon’ble Shri Jayesh V. Bhairavia, Member (Judicial)
In the instant OA, the applicant being aggrieved with impugned
memorandum dated 28.02.2017 (Annexure A/1) whereby a pay
fixation was done retrospectively after his retirement on
31.05.2016 and accordingly an amount of Rs. 63,736/- is
recovered for alleged excess payment from his retirement
benefits and subsequent deductions from his pension, PPO No.
20167081800105 dated 26.05.2017 (Annexure A/2) and also for
issuance of direction upon the respondents to decide the time
period from 18.05.2000 to 12.03.2004 as per the para 1343 to
1345 of IREC, has filed the present OA under Section 19 of the
Administrative Tribunal‟s Act 1985.
2. Brief facts of the case are as under:-
2.1 That the applicant retired from the service on 31.05.2016
from the post of Pointsman (Group-C) in the Operating
Department of the Western Railway under the Rajkot Division.
2.2 It is stated that at the time of the applicant‟s retirement,
the respondents prepared a statement of his retirement dues and
deducted an amount of Rs.63,736/- towards alleged excess
payment of salary.
In this regard, learned counsel for the applicant
argued that the said deduction was made without
communicating the precise basis of the alleged overpayment
and without affording an opportunity to the applicant to explain
his position.
2026.11.04
PRATIK VYAS
15:00:54+05'30'

:: 3 :: O.A.No.583/2017

2.3 It is submitted that the applicant‟s pension was initially
processed through Pension Payment Order No.
20167081800105 dated 13.05.2016. The applicant states that his
last pay drawn was recorded as Rs.10,860/- in the applicable
pay structure and that his basic pension was initially fixed at
Rs.5,430/-.
2.4 Subsequently, by impugned memorandum No. ET/ZA/81
dated 28.02.2017, the respondents illegally revised the
applicant‟s pay fixation retrospectively whereby his pay was
reduced from 01.07.2006 from Rs. 7860/- to Rs. 7210/- without
any show cause notice that too after the retirement of the
applicant. The revision was stated to have been necessitated as
the respondents have inadvertently granted the benefit of
MACP to the applicant from the date to which he was not
entitled.
2.5 The respondents thereafter issued a revised Pension
Payment Order dated 26.05.2017 and fixed his pension to Rs.
13000/- w.e.f. 01.06.2016, however, the applicant credit in the
bank account of the applicant from June 2017 is Rs. 5764/-
instead of Rs. 13000/-.
2.6 Being aggrieved, the applicant submitted
representations dated 08.06.2017 and 10.06.2017 through the
recognised railway union, objecting to the retrospective revision
of pay and recovery from his retiral benefits. However, the
same has not been considered, hence, the applicant has filed the
present OA challenging the legality of the impugned
2026.11.04
PRATIK VYAS
15:00:54+05'30'

:: 4 :: O.A.No.583/2017

memorandum dated 28.02.2017, the consequential revision of
his pension and the recovery of the alleged excess payment.
3. In support of the prayer sought in this OA, Ms. S.S.
Chaturvedi learned counsel for the applicant mainly submitted
that the principal grievance of the applicant is that, having
retired from service on 31.05.2016, he was subjected to a
retrospective revision of pay by memorandum dated 28.02.2017
(Annexure A/1), whereby his pay was reduced with effect from
01.07.2006 and accordingly a revised PPO No.
20167081800105 has been issued whereby his pension and
other retiral benefits have been reduced and a recovery of an
amount of Rs. 63,736/- is done his pension and other retiral
benefits have been reduced.
3.1 That the applicant herein retired from the service on
31.05.2016 from the post of Pointsman (Group-C) and the
respondents after his retirement has done a pay fixation
(revised) retrospectively and without issuing any show-cause
notice or affording any opportunity to the applicant recovered
an amount of Rs. 63,736/- from the retiral dues of the applicant,
the said conduct/action of the respondents is contrary to the law
laid down by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in case of State of
Punjab & Ors. Vs. Rafiq Masih (White Washer) & Ors.,
(2015) 4 SCC 334.
3.2 Learned counsel for the applicant further argued that as per
settled law recovery from an employee‟s salary must be
preceded by a specific show-cause and opportunity of hearing.
2026.11.04
PRATIK VYAS
15:00:54+05'30'

:: 5 :: O.A.No.583/2017

Therefore, the action of the respondents to effect such a huge
recovery that too without issuing show cause is not tenable and
in violation of principle of natural justice, hence, the impugned
orders are bad in law and requires to be quashed and set aside.
3.3 Further, it is submitted that there was absolutely no
misrepresentation, suppression of facts, fraud or deceit on the
part of the Applicant at any point of time. The Applicant neither
induced the Respondents to grant the benefit of MACP from the
date to which he was not entitled nor obtained any pecuniary
benefit by making any false declaration or by practicing any
fraud. The the benefit of MACP was granted by the
Respondents themselves in the ordinary course of
administration after due scrutiny of the Applicant‟s service
records. The Applicant merely received the salary lawfully
disbursed by the competent authority and had no role
whatsoever in the decision-making process relating grant of
MACP, therefore, now after the retirement of the applicant, it is
not open for the respondents to revise the pay of the applicant
and effect a recovery as the said action of the respondent is in
utter violation of judgment passed by the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court in case of Rafiq Masih (White Washer) (supra). Hence,
the impugned orders are bad in law and requires to be quashed
and set aside.
4. Per contra, the respondents have filed the reply and denied
the claim of the applicant. Ms. R.R. Patel learned counsel for
the respondents by referring the reply mainly submitted as
under:-
2026.11.04
PRATIK VYAS
15:00:54+05'30'

:: 6 :: O.A.No.583/2017

4.1 That the recovery sought from the applicant's retirement
dues is legal and as per the extent Rule viz. Rule 15 of Pension
Manual, 1993 (Annexure R/1). Further, it is stated that the
recovery made is as per the statement given by pay bill section
on the basis of which Memo dated 28-02-2017 is issued by ET
section and therefore also, recovery is legal and the pay fixation
(revised) is correct.
4.2 Learned counsel by referring the Note No.
ESB/774/SDD/2017 dated 14-04-2017 (Annexure R/2) submits
that the recovery is also based on the said note and in
compliance of it, the settlement section has obeyed the Rule in
deducting over payment and which is sought to be effected vide
the said Memo dated 28-02-2017.
4.3 Further, it is stated that the applicant had retired on 31-05-
2016 and therefore no question would arise to issue show cause
notice before issuance of any Memorandum/Corrigendum in
connection with the revision of pay.
4.4 Learned counsel submits that the change in MACP grant
date i.e. instead of 01-09-2008, the same has to be effected from
06-06-2012 due to penalty imposed upon the applicant of
removal from service and which remain in operation from 25-
04-2002 to 12-03-2004. It is stated that the applicant had
preferred departmental Appeal, wherein, penalty was reduced
from removal to reinstatement in scale of Rs.2610-3540 with
effect from 12-03-2004 with a penalty of “reduction at the
2026.11.04
PRATIK VYAS
15:00:54+05'30'

:: 7 :: O.A.No.583/2017

lowest stage at the same time of scale for three years with future
effect.” This penalty had achieved finality
4.5 It is submitted that, change in basic pension had to be
effected because of revision of pay due to revised MACP with
effect from 06-06-2012 instead of 01-01-2008 which was based
on observation of Associate Account. Recovery was made as
per Note No. RJT/EP/E/773/7"CPC dated 29-11-2016 of senior
DFM. Therefore, mistake which was committed by the
administration was rectified by way of impugned order.
4.6 It is also submitted that the applicant had furnished an
undertaking permitting recovery of excess payments from his
retirement benefits if any mistake in the calculation of his
entitlement was subsequently detected. Hence, the OA lacks
merit and accordingly, the same may be dismissed.

5. In rejoinder, the applicant submits that that he retired from
service on 31.05.2016, whereas the respondents issued the
impugned memorandum dated 28.02.2017 revising his pay
fixation retrospectively from the year 2006. The respondents
sought to correct an alleged administrative mistake after a
substantial lapse of time and after his retirement, thereby
adversely affecting the benefits already determined or paid to
him.
Further, it is stated that the respondents‟ own in
their reply admitted that a mistake had been committed by the
2026.11.04
PRATIK VYAS
15:00:54+05'30'

:: 8 :: O.A.No.583/2017

administration and was subsequently rectified. In this regard,
learned counsel for the applicant argued that this admission
demonstrates that the alleged excess payment arose from an
administrative error rather than any deliberate misrepresentation
or fraud on his part. Consequently, the financial consequences
of such an error should not be imposed upon him by recovering
amounts from his retiral dues and monthly pension.
5.1 Learned counsel for the applicant also relied on the
judgment passed by the Hon‟ble High Court of Madhya Pradesh
in Rajendra Prasad Pandey v. State of Madhya Pradesh and
Others and Mohd. Shahid v. State of Madhya Pradesh and
Others , Writ Petition Nos. 5937/2016 and 13828/2016 wherein,
the High Court considered the recovery of alleged excess
payments from retired Group C employees and observed that a
general undertaking in a proforma concerning refund of
overpayments could not automatically be equated with the
specific undertaking. Further, it is observed that the undertaking
said to be given is in a proforma that simply mentions for
refund of over payments, if any made, on account of incorrect
fixation. The undertaking is a part of proforma and it is well
known that the persons belonging to lower posts put signatures
on such undertaking without application of mind and directed
the respondents therein to consider the case of the appellants
therein in light of the law laid down by the Apex Court in the
case of Rafiq Masih (supra).
Therefore, by referring the aforesaid judgment, learned counsel
for the applicant submits that the undertaking relied upon by the
2026.11.04
PRATIK VYAS
15:00:54+05'30'

:: 9 :: O.A.No.583/2017

respondents cannot override the legal protections available to a
retired Group „C‟ & „D‟ employees.
6. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material available on record.
7. Considering the aforesaid submissions, we are of the view
that the core issue which requires adjudication by this Tribunal
are as under:-
(i) Whether Rule 15 of the Pension Manual, 1993, by itself
justifies the recovery in the manner adopted by the respondents
in the present case.
(ii) Whether the undertaking relied upon by the respondents
conclusively validates the impugned recovery.
(iii) Whether recovery of the alleged excess payment from the
retiral benefits and pension of the applicant, a retired Group „C‟
employee, is sustainable in view of the principles laid down by
the Hon‟ble Supreme Court.
8. As noted herein above, the respondents have relied upon
Rule 15 of the Pension Manual, 1993, for justifying the
recovery and adjustment of Government or railway dues from
pensionary benefits of the applicant.
8.1 The extract of Rule 15 placed on record recognises that
certain outstanding Government or railway dues, including
overpayments of pay and allowances, may be adjusted against
retirement gratuity, subject to the applicable provisions and
conditions. The rule also contains provisions concerning the
2026.11.04
PRATIK VYAS
15:00:54+05'30'

:: 10 :: O.A.No.583/2017

assessment of dues, the treatment of unassessed or unrealised
dues at the time of retirement, and the need to ensure that
amounts withheld are not disproportionately large. It
contemplates appropriate steps for determining and adjusting
the dues within the prescribed period.
However, the existence of a provision permitting
recovery of certain dues does not mean that every amount
described by the administration as an overpayment becomes
recoverable automatically. The respondents must first establish
the employee‟s actual entitlement, identify the precise amount
alleged to have been paid in excess, explain the legal basis for
its recovery and demonstrate compliance with the applicable
procedural requirements.
8.2 In the present case, the respondents have referred to the
statement prepared by the pay bill section, a note dated
14.04.2017 and an earlier financial note dated 29.11.2016.
These documents may form part of the administrative record
supporting the respondents‟ calculation. They do not, by
themselves, answer the applicant‟s objection that the adverse
revision and recovery were effected without a prior opportunity
of hearing/show cause.
8.3 Hence, the respondents‟ reliance upon Rule 15 must,
therefore, be considered along with the principles of natural
justice and the judicial safeguards applicable to recovery of
excess payments from retired employees. The rule cannot be
read as authorising an arbitrary or procedurally unfair recovery
2026.11.04
PRATIK VYAS
15:00:54+05'30'

:: 11 :: O.A.No.583/2017

merely because the administration has subsequently identified a
possible error in the calculation of pay.
8.4 We accordingly hold that Rule 15 does not, by itself,
validate the impugned recovery in the circumstances of the
present case.
9. The respondents have also relied upon an undertaking
allegedly furnished by the applicant, agreeing to refund or
permit recovery of any excess payment subsequently detected.
9.1 An undertaking is a relevant document and cannot be
ignored. Nevertheless, it cannot be treated as a complete answer
to every objection concerning the legality of a recovery. The
existence of an undertaking does not relieve the administration
of its obligation to establish the amount actually recoverable,
the legal authority for recovery and compliance with the
applicable rules. Nor can an undertaking, by itself, dispense
with the principles laid down by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court
governing inequitable recovery from retired employees. Its
effect must be assessed in the context of the governing service
rules, the circumstances in which it was furnished and the
nature of the proposed recovery.
9.2 In this regard, learned counsel for the applicant has rightly
relied upon the judgment passed by the Hon‟ble High Court of
Madhya Pradesh in Rajendra Prasad Pandey v. State of
Madhya Pradesh and Others and Mohd. Shahid v. State of
Madhya Pradesh and Others , Writ Petition Nos. 5937/2016 and
13828/2016 (Supra) wherein the Hon‟ble High Court observed
2026.11.04
PRATIK VYAS
15:00:54+05'30'

:: 12 :: O.A.No.583/2017

that the undertaking is a part of proforma and it is well known
that the persons belonging to lower posts put signatures on such
undertaking without application of mind and directed the
respondents therein to consider the case of the appellants
therein in light of the law laid down by the Apex Court in the
case of Rafiq Masih (supra).
9.3 We, therefore, hold that the undertaking relied upon by the
respondents does not independently validates the impugned
recovery.
10. As noted above, undisputedly, the applicant herein retired
from the service on 31.05.2016 from the post of Pointsman
(Group-C) and the respondents after his retirement has done a
pay fixation (revised) retrospectively and without issuing any
show-cause notice or affording any opportunity to the applicant
recovered an amount of Rs. 63,736/- from the retiral dues
payable to the applicant and recovery from his pension for
overpayment of Rs. 1,66,454/- as stated by the applicant in the
rejoinder. The said conduct/action of the respondents in our
considered view is contrary to the law laid down by the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court in case of Rafiq Masih (White Washer)
(supra).
10.1 At this stage it is apt to refer the judgment passed by
the Hon‟ble Apex Court in case of State of Punjab & Ors. Vs.
Rafiq Masih (White Washer) & Ors., dated 18.12.2014,
reported in (2015) 4 SCC 334 which covers the issues
regarding monetary recoveries from employees (Class-III and
2026.11.04
PRATIK VYAS
15:00:54+05'30'

:: 13 :: O.A.No.583/2017

Class-IV service (or Group 'C' and Group 'D' ) due to mistaken
excess payments by employers, wherein in paragraph 12, the
Apex Court summarized specific situations where recoveries
are ex-facie impermissible in law:
“12. It is not possible to postulate all situations of
hardship, which would govern employees on the
issue of recovery, where payments have mistakenly
been made by the employer, in excess of their
entitlement. Be that as it may, based on the
decisions referred to herein above, we may, as a
ready reference, summarize the following few
situations, wherein recoveries by the employers,
would be impermissible in law:
(i) Recovery from employees belonging to Class-III
and Class-IV service (or Group 'C' and Group 'D'
service).
(ii) Recovery from retired employees, or employees
who are due to retire within one year, of the order
of recovery.
(iii) Recovery from employees, when the excess
payment has been made for a period in excess of
five years, before the order of recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has
wrongfully been required to discharge duties of a
higher post, and has been paid accordingly, even
2026.11.04
PRATIK VYAS
15:00:54+05'30'

:: 14 :: O.A.No.583/2017

though he should have rightfully been required to
work against an inferior post.
(v) In any other case, where the Court arrives at
the conclusion, that recovery if made from the
employee, would be iniquitous or harsh or
arbitrary to such an extent, as would far outweigh
the equitable balance of the employer's right to
recover.”
10.2 In the present case, it can be seen that the applicant
retired as a Pointsman (Group-C) on 31.05.2016 and the the
impugned revision of pay was made on 28.02.2017 for the
fixation done in the year 2006 i.e. more than ten years before
his retirement that too without affording any opportunity of
hearing to the applicant, which is not tenable in light of the
judgment passed by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in case of
Rafiq Masih (supra).
11. In the facts and circumstances of the present case, we are of
the considered view that the impugned recovery cannot be
sustained and that the consequential deductions from the
applicant‟s pension must cease. The applicant is, therefore,
entitled to relief in respect of the recovery and the consequential
adverse financial action challenged in this Original Application.
12. For the reasons recorded above, the Original Application is
allowed, in the following terms:
2026.11.04
PRATIK VYAS
15:00:54+05'30'

:: 15 :: O.A.No.583/2017

(i) The impugned memorandum No. ET/ZA/81 dated
28.02.2017 (Annexure A/1) and the consequential revised
Pension Payment Order dated 26.05.2017 (Annexure A/2)
are set aside to the extent that they form the basis of the
impugned recovery and consequential deductions from the
applicant‟s retiral benefits and pension.
(ii) The respondents are directed to refund the amount of
recovered from the retiral dues and pension of the applicant
and stop further recovery, if any.
(iii) The respondents shall restore the applicant‟s pensionary
payments without deductions attributable to the recovery
set aside by this order and shall release any consequential
pension arrears arising from the cessation of such
deductions.
(iv) The aforesaid exercise shall be completed within 90 days
from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.
13. In view of what is stated herein above, the OA is allowed.
Pending Miscellaneous Applications, if any, shall stand disposed
of accordingly. No order as to costs.



(Sanjiv Kumar) (Jayesh V Bhairavia)
Member (A) Member (J)



/pv/
2026.11.04
PRATIK VYAS
15:00:54+05'30'