MOHAMMAD JUNAID vs SHIV KUMAR

Court
Rajasthan High Court

[2026:RJ-JD:56390]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
AT JODHPUR
S.B. Criminal Revision Petition No. 1490/2019
CNR: RJHC010740682019 | URN: CRLR / 3889U / 2019
1. Mohammad Junaid S/o Abdul Jabbar, Aged About 28
Years, I.a.s. (On Probation) Currently Posted At Tehsildar
(Revenue), Anoopgarh, District Shri Ganganagar, Raj.
2. Rampal Meena S/o Dhira Ram, Aged About 58 Years, Was
Posted At Tehsildar (Revenue) Anoopgarh, Dist. Shri
Ganganagar, Raj.
----Petitioners
Versus
Shiv Kumar, Additional District And Session Judge, Anoopgarh,
District Shri Ganganagar, Raj.
----Respondent
For Petitioner(s) : Ms. Manisha Phophaliya
For Respondent(s) : None Present
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE FARJAND ALI
Order
REPORTABLE
DATE OF CONCLUSION OF ARGUMENTS : 13/10/2026
DATE ON WHICH ORDER IS RESERVED : 13/10/2026
FULL ORDER OR OPERATIVE PART : Full Order
DATE OF PRONOUNCEMENT : 19/11/2026
BY THE COURT:-
1. The instant revision petition under Section 397 and 401 of
the CrPC has been preferred on behalf of the petitioners against
the order dated 17.10.2019 passed by learned Additional Chief
Judicial Magistrate, Anoopgarh whereby he took cognizance of the
offence and issued process against the accused-petitioners on the
complaint moved by the respondent in Criminal Case No.493/2019
under Sections 166 and 120-B of IPC.
(Uploaded on 21/11/2026 at 02:10:23 PM)
(Downloaded on 21/11/2026 at 02:55:03 PM)

(2 of 7)
[2026:RJ-JD:56390] [CRLR-1490/2019]
2. The brief facts of the case are that, vide order dated
17.10.2019 passed in Execution Application No. 15/2019, the
learned Additional District and Sessions Judge, Anoopgarh,
directed registration of a complaint against the petitioners under
Sections 166 and 120-B IPC for alleged non-compliance of the
order dated 18.02.2019 passed in Civil Suit No. 06/2008. Pursuant
thereto, a complaint was lodged and, on the very same day, the
learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Anoopgarh, took
cognizance against the petitioners and issued process under the
aforesaid provisions. Aggrieved by the said order, the petitioners
have preferred the present criminal revision petition challenging
its legality, correctness and propriety.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the
learned Magistrate erred in taking cognizance under Sections 166
and 120-B IPC without obtaining the requisite sanction under
Section 197 Cr.P.C., as the acts alleged were intrinsically
connected with the discharge of their official duties. It was further
contended that the essential ingredients of Section 166 IPC are
conspicuously absent, as the petitioners had merely submitted
their reply explaining the legal and factual impediments in
compliance with the directions issued by the executing court.
Learned counsel argued that no wilful disobedience or deliberate
violation of any lawful direction could be attributed to the
petitioners and that the complaint does not disclose a prima facie
case against them. Accordingly, it was prayed that the impugned
order of cognizance be quashed and set aside.
(Uploaded on 21/11/2026 at 02:10:23 PM)
(Downloaded on 21/11/2026 at 02:55:03 PM)

(3 of 7)
[2026:RJ-JD:56390] [CRLR-1490/2019]
4. Heard learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner
and perused the material available on record.
5. Upon consideration of the submissions advanced by learned
counsel for the petitioners and upon perusal of the material
available on record, this Court finds that the prosecution, as
instituted against the petitioners, does not prima facie disclose the
essential ingredients of the offences alleged. It is borne out from
the record that Petitioner No. 1 is an IAS officer who had been
deputed to Sri Ganganagar for a period of fifteen days as part of
his training and was assigned the charge of Tehsildar during the
said period, alongside the regular Tehsildar. The learned Additional
District Judge, vide judgment and decree dated 18.02.2019, had
decreed the civil suit for declaration and issued certain
consequential directions, including directions to the Sub-Registrar
to append appropriate remarks on the concerned document, to the
Tehsildar to effect mutation of the land in favour of the plaintiff
and to submit a compliance report before the decreeing Court.
Directions were also issued in relation to the possession of the suit
property.
5.1 The execution proceedings came to be instituted on
28.02.2019, wherein the Tehsildar was directed to furnish a report
before the executing Court. Subsequently, vide notice dated
04.10.2019, an explanation was sought from the then Tehsildar,
Shri Rampal Meena (Petitioner No. 2). In the interregnum,
Petitioner No. 1, being a trainee IAS officer temporarily holding
the charge of Tehsildar, forwarded a response on the
(Uploaded on 21/11/2026 at 02:10:23 PM)
(Downloaded on 21/11/2026 at 02:55:03 PM)

(4 of 7)
[2026:RJ-JD:56390] [CRLR-1490/2019]
administrative side, explaining the circumstances and expressing
his lack of awareness of the relevant factual position. His specific
stand was that he had not been afforded an opportunity of hearing
before any stringent direction was contemplated against him.
6. In the aforesaid factual backdrop, the most conspicuous
omission in the prosecution case is the absence of the requisite
mens rea. Section 166 IPC does not criminalise every act of non-
compliance or every perceived lapse on the part of a public
servant. Its invocation necessarily requires a conscious
disobedience of a direction of law, coupled with the intention to
cause injury to a person or knowledge that such injury is likely to
ensue. The mere forwarding of a response explaining the
administrative and factual position, without anything more, cannot
be elevated to the level of wilful disobedience with the requisite
criminal intent. No material has been brought to the fore to
indicate that either of the petitioners deliberately acted in defiance
of the decree with an intention to cause injury to the decree-
holder.
6.1 This Court is also unable to discern from the allegations any
foundational material constituting a criminal conspiracy within the
meaning of Section 120-B IPC. The allegation of conspiracy
appears to be an inference without any discernible factual
foundation. Criminal liability cannot be fastened merely because
the directions contained in a civil decree have not been complied
with to the satisfaction of the executing Court. A civil obligation,
(Uploaded on 21/11/2026 at 02:10:23 PM)
(Downloaded on 21/11/2026 at 02:55:03 PM)

(5 of 7)
[2026:RJ-JD:56390] [CRLR-1490/2019]
even if allegedly breached, does not automatically metamorphose
into a criminal offence.
6.2 So far as the protection envisaged under Section 197 Cr.P.C.
is concerned, the question whether the acts complained of bear a
reasonable nexus with the discharge of official duties would have
to be examined in the light of the principles enunciated by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Devinder Singh & Others v. State of
Punjab reported in (2016) 12 SCC 87. The protection is neither
an absolute immunity nor a licence to commit an offence;
however, where the alleged act has a reasonable connection with
the discharge of official functions, the statutory safeguard cannot
be lightly disregarded. In the present matter, the issue of sanction
also assumes significance, particularly in view of the official
capacity in which the petitioners were acting. Nevertheless, this
Court finds that the prosecution fails to cross the more
fundamental threshold of disclosing the ingredients of the offences
alleged.
6.3 In the case of Prakash Rajpurohit v. Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal , decided in S.B. Criminal Misc. Petition No.
663/2020, the Coordinate Bench of this Court has held that the
prosecution of a public servant for an offence under Section 166
IPC, without obtaining the requisite sanction under Section 197
Cr.P.C., is impermissible in law. For ready reference, the relevant
paragraph of the judgment is reproduced hereinbelow:
"I am of the firm opinion that the Presiding Officer
should have remained cognizant of this mandatory
legal requirement before directing filing of complaints
(Uploaded on 21/11/2026 at 02:10:23 PM)
(Downloaded on 21/11/2026 at 02:55:03 PM)

(6 of 7)
[2026:RJ-JD:56390] [CRLR-1490/2019]
against the District Collector. It cannot be disputed that
before taking cognizance on a complaint filed against a
public servant for the offence under Section 166 IPC,
requirement of prosecution sanction under Section 197
Cr.P.C. is sine-qua-non and without such sanction,
prosecution of the public servant concerned is
impressible. Admittedly, in the cases at hand, no
sanction was sought for before directing prosecution of
the present petitioner. Thus, the impugned orders
taking cognizance against the petitioner are absolutely
illegal and amount to a sheer abuse of process of law
and cannot be sustained."
7. The criminal process cannot be permitted to become an
instrument for converting every administrative omission,
disagreement or alleged non-compliance with a judicial direction
into a penal proceeding. The majesty of a civil decree is
undoubtedly required to be respected and its execution must
proceed in accordance with law; nevertheless, the coercive
machinery of criminal law must be invoked only where the
necessary statutory ingredients are demonstrably present.
8. In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court is of the
considered opinion that the order dated 17.10.2019, taking
cognizance against the petitioners under Sections 166 and 120-B
IPC, cannot be sustained in the eyes of law. The same suffers
from a fundamental infirmity and warrants interference by this
Court in exercise of its revisional jurisdiction.
9. Accordingly, the criminal revision petition is allowed. The
impugned order dated 17.10.2019, to the extent it relates to the
present petitioners, is hereby quashed and set aside. It is,
however, clarified that the proceedings in the execution application
(Uploaded on 21/11/2026 at 02:10:23 PM)
(Downloaded on 21/11/2026 at 02:55:03 PM)

(7 of 7)
[2026:RJ-JD:56390] [CRLR-1490/2019]
shall remain undisturbed and shall continue in accordance with
law.
10. Stay petition and all pending applications, if any, stands
disposed of.
(FARJAND ALI),J
Crt_20 (1763)
D-A/33
Mamta Tak
(Uploaded on 21/11/2026 at 02:10:23 PM)
(Downloaded on 21/11/2026 at 02:55:03 PM)
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)