SHRI. K M NARENDRA KUMAR vs THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
WP No. 19477 of 2025


IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

TH
DATED THIS THE 12 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026


BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH RAI K

WRIT PETITION NO. 19477 OF 2025 (GM-RES)


BETWEEN:

SHRI. K.M NARENDRA KUMAR
S/O MUNIYAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS
WORKING AS SURVEYOR SUPERVISOR,
SLAO-1, KIADB, BENGALURU

R./AT NO.177
TH
8 MAIN, CQAL LAYOUT,
SAHAKARANAGAR
BENGALURU - 560 092
…PETITIONER

(BY SRI. ARUN SHYAM, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR
SRI. D.M. MANJUNATH, ADVOCATE)

AND:

1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
REPRESENTED BY
THE SPECIAL PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
BY LOKAYUKTHA POLICE STATION,
BENGALURU - 560 001.

2. SRI. V. RAVI
SON OF LATE VENKATESHAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS,
RESIDING AT NO.297,
ND TH
2 MAIN ROAD, 10 CROSS,
VIJAYA BANK LAYOUT,
BILEKAHALLI,
BANNERGHATTA ROAD













Digitally signed
by PANKAJA S
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA

- 2 -
WP No. 19477 of 2025


BENGALURU - 560 076
…RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI. VENKATESH S ARABATTI, SPL.PP FOR R1,
SRI. KUSHAL GOWDA, ADVOCATE FOR
SRI. ABHINAY Y.T, ADVOCATE FOR R2)

THIS WP IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227 OF
THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE
COMPLAINT, DATED 21.04.2025 FILED BY THE SECOND
RESPONDENT I.E. ANNEXURE- B AND CONSEQUENTLY ALL
PROCEEDINGS IN LOKAYUKTHA CRIME NO.18/2024 PENDING
BEFORE THE HON'BLE 23 ADDITIONAL CITY CIVIL AND
SESSIONS JUDGE CUM SPECIAL COURT (PREVENTION OF
CORRUPTION ACT), BANGALORE, AS AGAINST THE
PETITIONER ANNX-G.

THIS PETITION HAVING BEEN RESERVED FOR ORDERS
ON 05.11.2026 COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT THIS DAY,
THE COURT MADE THE FOLLOWING:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH RAI K

CAV ORDER

This writ petition is filed seeking following reliefs:
"a) To Quash the complaint, Dated: 21.04.2025
filed by the Second Respondent i.e, ANNEXURE-
B and consequently all proceedings in
Lokayuktha Crime No.18/2024 pending before
the Hon'ble 23rd Additional City Civil & Sessions
Judge Cum Special Court (Prevention of
Corruption Act), Bangalore, as against the
Petitioner. ANNEXUAE.G.
b) To Quash the First Information Report
registered as Lokayuktha Crime No.18/2025 in
pursuance to the complaint, Dated: 21.04.2025

- 3 -
WP No. 19477 of 2025


filed by the Second Respondent i.e, ANNEXURE-
A and consequently all proceedings in
Lokayuktha Crime No.18/2024 pending before
the Hon'ble 23rd Additional City Civil & Sessions
Judge Cum Special Court (Prevention of
Corruption Act), Bangalore, as against the
Petitioner.
c) Order to call for Records in Lokayuktha Crime
No.18/2025 pending Hon'ble 23rd Additional
city Civil & Sessions Judge Cum Special Court
(Prevention of Corruption Act), Bangalore.
d) To pass such other orders as may be deemed
expedient in the circumstance of the case and
in the interest of justice."
2. The brief facts of the case which are necessary for
the disposal of this petition are that the petitioner is working as
a Surveyor Supervisor in the office of the Special Land
Acquisition Officer-I, Karnataka Industrial Areas Development
Board (for short, "the KIADB"), Bengaluru.
3. The allegations against the petitioner arise out of a
complaint lodged by respondent No.2 on 21.04.2025 before
respondent No.1, alleging demand of illegal gratification for
furnishing a survey sketch in respect of the lands belonging to
one Smt.Shakuntalamma i.e., the mother-in-law of respondent
No.2, situated at Bilekahalli Village, Bengaluru South Taluk. It

- 4 -
WP No. 19477 of 2025


is alleged that, pursuant to an application submitted by
respondent No.2 on behalf of Smt.Shakuntalamma for fixation
of boundaries, one Nethravathi, acting on the directions of the
SLAO, had visited the property, conducted a mahazar and
prepared a sketch. However, the said sketch was not handed
over to respondent No.2 as it required the approval and
signature of the superior authority. Respondent No.2 was
allegedly informed by Smt.Nethravathi that the petitioner would
hand over the copy of the survey sketch. Accordingly, she
furnished the petitioner's mobile number 9845154426 to
respondent No.2 and advised him to meet the petitioner in that
regard.
4. It is further alleged that respondent No.2 contacted
the petitioner on several occasions, during which the petitioner
demanded different sums of money, initially Rs.50,000/-,
subsequently Rs.1,50,000/-, which was later reduced to
Rs.1,00,000/-, and again demanded Rs.1,50,000/- for handing
over the survey sketch. Respondent No.2 claims to have
recorded the conversations relating to the alleged demands and
lodged a complaint before respondent No.1. On the basis of the
said complaint, a case came to be registered in Crime

- 5 -
WP No. 19477 of 2025


No.18/2025 for the offence punishable under Section 7(a) of
Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (for short, "the PC Act").
5. Pursuant to the said complaint, on 05.06.2025,
respondent No.1 laid a trap and apprehended the petitioner-
accused on the allegation that he had received the tainted
money from respondent No.2. Thereafter, the petitioner was
produced before the jurisdictional Court and remanded to
judicial custody. Being aggrieved by the initiation of criminal
proceedings against him, the petitioner has approached this
Court by filing the present writ petition.
6. Heard the learned Senior counsel Sri. Arun Shyam,
for the petitioner, the learned Spl.PP Sri. Venkatesh S Arabatti
for respondent No.1-Lokayuktha and the learned counsel Sri.
Kushal Gowda for respondent No.2.
7. Apart from raising various other contentions,
learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner primarily
contended that respondent No.2 was set up by the petitioner's
brother-in-law, who is allegedly harbouring vengeance against
the petitioner on account of a property dispute between them.
He further submitted that the petitioner has been working as a
Surveyor Supervisor under the surveyors of the KIADB
,

- 6 -
WP No. 19477 of 2025


Bengaluru since 2021. Drawing the attention of this Court to
the complaint averments, learned Senior Counsel contended
that respondent No.2 had approached the office of the Special
Land Acquisition Officer at V.V. Towers, Bengaluru, in
connection with the survey and phodi work of his mother-in-
law's property situated at Bilekahalli Village, where he met one
Nethravathi, a surveyor, who allegedly furnished the
petitioner's mobile number and informed him to contact the
petitioner. However, the petitioner had no connection with the
survey work of respondent No.2 or the work entrusted to said
Nethravathi. Further, neither the complaint nor the FIR
discloses any material indicating a conspiracy between the
petitioner and said surveyor.
8. Learned Senior Counsel further contended that,
when the petitioner was working at Kolar, there was no
occasion for respondent No.2 to approach him in connection
with the survey work at Bengaluru, much less any occasion for
him to demand illegal gratification. He also submitted that no
work pertaining to respondent No.2 was pending before the
petitioner and that the alleged telephone conversations do not
prima facie disclose any demand for illegal gratification.
Further, immediately after the alleged trap, the petitioner had

- 7 -
WP No. 19477 of 2025


explained that the tainted currency notes were thrown into his
car and that he had not voluntarily received the same. It is also
contended that the trap mahazar was drawn at the police
station instead of the alleged place of incident, without any
satisfactory explanation. Hence, learned Senior Counsel
submitted that the petitioner has been falsely implicated and
that the essential ingredients of Section 7(a) of the PC Act,
particularly the demand and acceptance of illegal gratification in
connection with any official work, are not prima facie made out.
Accordingly, he prays to allow the petition.
9. Per contra , learned Spl.PP appearing for respondent
No.1-Lokayukta contended that, as could be gathered from the
complaint averments, respondent No.2, on the advice of one
Nethravathi, a surveyor at V.V. Tower, Bengaluru contacted the
petitioner and met him near Maharani's College canteen on
20.08.2024, where the petitioner allegedly demanded
Rs.50,000/- for furnishing the survey sketch. Subsequently, on
24.09.2024, the petitioner allegedly demanded Rs.1,50,000/-,
which was later reduced to Rs.1,00,000/-. Again, on
19.04.2025, the petitioner allegedly demanded Rs.1,50,000/-,
which compelled respondent No.2 to lodge the complaint. He

- 8 -
WP No. 19477 of 2025


further contended that the alleged demand is clearly reflected
in the mobile phone recordings of respondent No.2.
10. Learned Spl.PP further submitted that the pre-trap
and trap mahazars prima facie disclose that the tainted
currency notes were handed over by respondent No.2 to the
petitioner pursuant to his demand and that the petitioner
received the same. Further, the right-hand wash of the
petitioner, when tested with sodium carbonate solution, turned
pink, thereby prima facie establishing the demand and
acceptance of illegal gratification. As regards the contention
relating to the absence of pending official work, learned Spl.PP
submitted that the alleged act of the petitioner would fall within
the ambit of Explanation 2(i) to Section 7 of the PC Act, as the
illegal gratification was allegedly obtained for another person.
11. He further contended that the investigation is still at

a nascent stage and respondent No.1-Lokayukta are required to
investigate the matter to ascertain the involvement of other
persons named in the complaint and any other persons
connected with the alleged offence. Accordingly, he prays to
dismiss the petition.

- 9 -
WP No. 19477 of 2025


12. The learned counsel for respondent No.2 also
opposed the petition by adopting the contentions urged by the
learned Spl.PP for respondent No.1-Lokayuktha.
13. I have given my anxious consideration to the
submissions made by the learned counsel for the respective
parties and also perused the entire materials on record.
14. Before adverting to the merits of the case, it is
appropriate to refer to the findings of the Hon'ble Apex Court in
the case of STATE BY LOKAYUKTHA POLICE V. K. RANGAYYA
AND ANOTHER - 2026 SCC OnLine SC 963 , wherein, at
paragraphs 18 to 22, the Hon'ble Apex Court has held as
follows:
"18 . In order to appreciate the contention of the
Appellant, it is necessary to advert to the relevant
provisions of the PC Act. Section 7(a) of the PC Act
reads as follows:
‘‘7. Offence relating to public servant
being bribed .—Any public servant
who,— (a) obtains or accepts or attempts
to obtain from any person, an undue
advantage, with the intention to perform
or cause performance of public duty
improperly or dishonestly or to forbear or

- 10 -
WP No. 19477 of 2025


cause forbearance to perform such duty
either by himself or by another public
servant’’
Section 7 is further clarified by Explanation 2, which
provides that,
“ Explanation 2 .—For the purpose of this
section,—
(i) the expressions “obtains” or “accepts”
or “attempts to obtain” shall cover cases
where a person being a public servant,
obtains or “accepts” or attempts to
obtain, any undue advantage for himself
or for another person, by abusing his
position as a public servant or by using
his personal influence over another public
servant; or by any other corrupt or illegal
means; (ii) it shall be immaterial whether
such person being a public servant
obtains or accepts, or attempts to obtain
the undue advantage directly or through
a third party.
19 . As we proceed to examine the issue at
hand, it would be necessary ascertain the
ingredients of Section 7(a) of the PC Act under
which the Respondent No.1 has been charged.
When we split Section 7(a) of the PC Act,
it consists of the following parts:

- 11 -
WP No. 19477 of 2025


(i) The charged person must be a public
servant;
(ii) Such a public servant should be
charged of obtaining or accepting or
attempting to obtain an undue advantage;
(iii) from any person;
(iv) with the intention to
(a) perform or cause performance of
public duty;
(b) improperly or dishonestly or to
forbear or cause forbearance to perform
such duty;
(v) such act of performance or forbearance
is to be done either
(a) by himself; or
(b) by another public servant.
If the aforesaid parts or ingredients are
disclosed, such a public servant can be charged
of committing offence contemplated under
Section 7(a) of the PC Act.
20 . Reading of Section 7(a) of the PC Act,
however, would indicate that it will apply when
the public servant himself obtains or accepts or
attempts to obtain the undue advantage, by
doing such acts with the intention as
mentioned in the aforesaid Clause (a).

- 12 -
WP No. 19477 of 2025


However, it appears that the Explanation
2(i) to Section 7 has enlarged the scope of the
offence by not restricting the beneficiaries to
the public servant himself only but to “another
person” also. Explanation 2 (i) to Section 7
expands the scope of the beneficiaries by not
confining only to the public servant who
obtains, accepts or attempts to obtain an
undue advantage, but also in favour of
“another person” who may or may not be a
“public servant” as there is no qualification to
the words “another person”. Thus, Explanation
2(i) clearly mentions that for the purpose of
Section 7, the expressions “obtains” or
“accepts” or “attempts to obtain” shall cover
cases where a person being a public servant,
obtains or accepts or attempts to obtain, any
undue advantage for himself or for another
person, by abusing his position as a public

servant or by using his personal influence over
another public servant; or by any other corrupt
or illegal means.
Further, Explanation 2(ii) provides that it
shall be immaterial whether such person being
a public servant obtains or accepts, or attempts
to obtain the undue advantage directly or
through a third party.

- 13 -
WP No. 19477 of 2025


21 . Therefore, it is clear from Section 7(a) read
with Explanation 2(i) that it is not necessary
that the public servant himself has to obtain or
accept or attempt to obtain undue advantage
for himself only, but such undue advantage can
be obtained or accepted or attempted to be
obtained for “another person” also.
Further, as per Explanation 2(i) such
obtaining/accepting/attempting to obtain undue
advantages can be by way of abusing the
position of public servant himself but also by
using the personal influence over “another
public servant”. Therefore, Explanation 2
clearly provides that the aforesaid act of
performing the public duty
improperly/dishonestly or refraining to perform
the public duty can be by himself or by another
public servant by using influence by the
concerned public servant.
22 . Thus, such an offending act can be done by
“another public servant” also under the
personal influence of the concerned public
servant. What we, therefore, understand from
the reading of Section 7 (a) of the PC Act read
with Explanation 2, is that, it is not necessary
that the public servant who has been charged
of the offence under Section 7 of the PC Act
has to obtain the undue benefit for himself, but

- 14 -
WP No. 19477 of 2025


it also covers cases where he does the
offensive act for obtaining undue advantages
for “another person”, and this act may be done
by himself by abusing his position, or may be
executed through another public servant by
using his personal influence over the other
public servant.
Therefore, in the light of the above
provision, a public servant may not be directly
a recipient or the executor of the offensive act
and thus, may not be in the limelight and
remain in the background. Nevertheless, he
can be instrumental in ensuring obtaining,
accepting or attempting to obtain from another
person the undue advantage for “another
person” by taking the help of “another public
servant”. Such public servant who has been
charged of offence under Section 7(a) may be
the main instrumentality, through whom undue
advantage is obtained and/or arranged through
other public servant.
Keeping the aforesaid broad scope of
Section 7(a) read with Explanation 2, we must
consider the issue on hand. ”
15. Applying the aforesaid findings of the Hon'ble Apex
Court to the facts and circumstances of the present case, the
contention urged by learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner

- 15 -
WP No. 19477 of 2025


does not merit acceptance. No doubt, the petitioner was not
working in the office where the survey work of respondent No.2
was pending, nor had respondent No.2 initially approached the
petitioner directly. It is also the contention of the petitioner that
his office was situated far away from the office of the Special
Land Acquisition Officer at V.V. Towers, Bengaluru. However,
the fact remains that the petitioner was working as a Surveyor
Supervisor in KIADB, Bengaluru in connection with the work of
Kolar division and the complaint averments disclose that
respondent No.2 had approached one Nethravathi, a Surveyor,
at V.V. Towers, Bengaluru, in connection with the survey and
phodi work of his land and that said Smt.Nethravathi informed
him to approach the petitioner by furnishing his mobile
number.
16. Further, the complaint averments disclose
successive demands of illegal gratification allegedly made by
the petitioner, initially for a sum of Rs.50,000/-, thereafter
Rs.1,50,000/-, which was subsequently reduced to
Rs.1,00,000/-, and finally again for Rs.1,50,000/-. In this
background, the enlarged scope of Explanation 2(i) to Section 7
of the PC Act, as explained by the Hon'ble Apex Court at
paragraph No.20 of the aforesaid judgment, makes it clear that

- 16 -
WP No. 19477 of 2025


the act of a public servant demanding or accepting illegal
gratification, either for himself or for another person, by
abusing his position as a public servant, exercising personal
influence over another public servant or by any other corrupt or
illegal means, attracts the provisions of Section 7(a) of the PC

Act.
( emphasis supplied )
17. In the instant case, the complaint, pre-trap
mahazar and trap mahazar, prima facie disclose the demand
and acceptance of illegal gratification by the petitioner to the
tune of Rs.50,000/-. The said circumstance also finds support
from the chemical analysis report. Further, in his explanation,
the petitioner has admitted that the tainted currency notes
were seized from his car. Whether the said currency notes were
deliberately thrown into the petitioner's car by respondent
No.2, as contended by the petitioner, or were received by the
petitioner pursuant to the alleged demand, is a matter of
evidence to be established during trial. The said disputed
question of fact cannot be examined by this Court at this stage
while exercising its jurisdiction under Section 482 of Cr.P.C.

- 17 -
WP No. 19477 of 2025


18. The other contention urged by the learned Senior
Counsel for the petitioner that, if the petitioner had demanded
or accepted illegal gratification on behalf of the officers before
whom the work of respondent No.2 was pending, there ought
to have been an allegation of conspiracy between the petitioner
and the said officers, and that no such allegation is forthcoming
in the complaint, is concerned, the complaint averments
disclose that respondent No.2 had initially approached one
Nethravathi, a Surveyor at V.V. Towers, Bengaluru, in
connection with his work. However, except informing
respondent No.2 to approach the petitioner and furnishing his
mobile number, no specific allegation of demand of illegal
gratification is forthcoming against said Nethravathi. Further,
the investigation is still at the nascent stage, and respondent
No.1-Lokayukta are yet to collect the necessary material to
ascertain the involvement, if any, of said Nethravathi or other
persons in the alleged offence. Learned Spl.PP appearing for
respondent No.1 has also fairly submitted in this regard. Hence,
the absence of specific allegations of conspiracy at this stage,
by itself, cannot be a ground to quash the proceedings against
the petitioner.

- 18 -
WP No. 19477 of 2025



19. The entire matter is at pre-mature stage and the
investigation has not proceeded with, except some preliminary
effort taken on the date of registration of the case. The
evidence has to be gathered after a thorough investigation and
placed before the Court on the basis of which alone, Court can
come to a conclusion one way or other. If the allegations are
bereft of truth and are malicious, the investigation will reveal
the same. At this stage, when there are only allegations and
recriminations but no evidence, this Court cannot anticipate the
result of the investigation and render a finding on the materials
available at present. Even assuming that the complaint has
filed on account of personal animosity, that by itself will not be
a ground to discard the complaint containing serious
allegations, which have to be tested and weighed after the
evidence is collected.
ANIL
20. The Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of
BHAVARLAL JAIN AND ANOTHER VS. STATE OF
MAHARASHTRA AND OTHERS in SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION
(CRL.)NO.10078/2023 AND 12776/2023 held that, in a case
registered under the special statute i.e., P.C Act, a quashing of
the offences under the said act would have a grave and

- 19 -
WP No. 19477 of 2025


substantial impact not just on the parties involved, but also on
the society at large.
21. Further, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in case of STATE
OF ORISSA AND ANOTHER VS. SAROJ KUMAR SAHOO , reported
in (2005) 13 SCC 540 , held in paragraph Nos.8 and 9 as
follows:
“8. Exercise of power under Section 482
of the Cr.P.C. in a case of this nature is the
exception and not the rule. The Section does
not confer any new powers on the High Court.
It only saves the inherent power which the
Court possessed before the enactment of the
Cr.P.C. I envisages three circumstances
under which the inherent jurisdiction may be
exercised, namely, (i) to give effect to an
order under the Cr.P.C., (ii) to prevent abuse
of the process of court, and (iii) to otherwise
secure the ends of justice. It is neither
possible nor desirable to lay down any
inflexible rule which would govern the
exercise of inherent jurisdiction. No legislative
enactment dealing with procedure can
provide for all cases that may possibly arise.
Courts, therefore, have inherent powers apart
from express provisions of law which are
necessary for proper discharge of functions

- 20 -
WP No. 19477 of 2025


and duties imposed upon them by law. That is
the doctrine which finds expression in the
section which merely recognizes and
preserves inherent powers of the High Courts.
All courts, whether civil or criminal possess,
in the absence of any express provision, as
inherent in their constitution, all such powers
as are necessary to do the right and to undo
a wrong in course of administration of justice
on the principle "quando lex aliquid alicui
concedit, concedere videtur et id sine quo res
ipsae esse non potest" (when the law gives a
person anything it gives him that without
which it cannot exist). While exercising
powers under the section, the court does not
function as a court of appeal or revision.
Inherent jurisdiction under the section though
wide has to be exercised sparingly, carefully
and with caution and only when such exercise
is justified by the tests specifically laid down
in the section itself. It is to be exercised ex
debito justitiae to do real and substantial
justice for the administration of which alone
courts exist. Authority of the court exists for
advancement of justice and if any attempt is
made to abuse that authority so as to
produce injustice, the court has power to
prevent abuse. It would be an abuse of
process of the court to allow any action which

- 21 -
WP No. 19477 of 2025


would result in injustice and prevent
promotion of justice. In exercise of the
powers court would be justified to quash any
proceeding if it finds that
initiation/continuance of it amounts to abuse
of the process of court or quashing of these
proceedings would otherwise serve the ends
of justice. When no offence is disclosed by
the report, the court may examine the
question of fact. When a report is sought to
be quashed, it is permissible to look into the
materials to assess what the report has
alleged and whether any offence is made out
even if the allegations are accepted in toto.
11. As noted above, the
powers possessed by the High
Court under Section 482 of the
Cr.P.C. are very wide and the very
plenitude of the power requires
great caution in its exercise. Court
must be careful to see that its
decision in exercise of this power is
based on sound principles. The
inherent power should not be
exercised to stifle a legitimate
prosecution. The High Court being
the highest court of a State should
normally refrain from giving a
prima facie decision in a case

- 22 -
WP No. 19477 of 2025


where the entire facts are
incomplete and hazy, more so
when the evidence has not been
collected and produced before the
Court and the issues involved,
whether factual or legal, are of
magnitude and cannot be seen in
their true perspective without
sufficient material. Of course, no
hard and fast rule can be laid down
in regard to cases in which the
High Court will exercise its
extraordinary jurisdiction of
quashing the proceeding at any
stage. (See: Janata Dal v. H. S.
Chowdhary, [1992] 4 SCC 305,
and Raghubir Saran (Dr.) v. State
of Bihar, AIR (1964) SC 1). It
would not be proper for the High
Court to analyse the case of the
complainant in the light of all
probabilities in order to determine
whether a conviction would be
sustainable and on such premises
arrive at a conclusion that the
proceedings are to be quashed. It
would be erroneous to assess the
material before it and conclude
that the complaint cannot be

- 23 -
WP No. 19477 of 2025


proceeded with. When an
information is lodged at the police
station and an offence is
registered, then the mala fides of
the informant would be of
secondary importance. It is the
material collected during the
investigation and evidence led in
court which decides the fate of the
accused person. The allegations of
mala fides against the informant
are of no consequence and cannot
by themselves be the basis for
quashing the proceedings. (See:
Dhanalakshmi v. R. Prasanna
Kumar, [1990] Supp SCC 686,
State of Bihar v. P. P. Sharma, AIR
(1996) SC 309, Rupan Deol Bajaj
v. Kanwar Pal Singh Gill, [1995] 6
SCC 194, State of Kerala v. O.C.
Kuttan, AIR (1999) SC 1044, State
of U.P. v. O.P. Sharma, [1996] 7
SCC 705, Rashmi Kumar v. Mahesh
Kumar Bhada, [1997] 2 SCC 397,
Satvinder Kaur v. State (Govt. of
NCT of Delhi, AIR (1996) SC 2983
and Rajesh Bajaj v. State NCT of
Delhil, [1999] 3 SCC 259). 14. It is
to be noted that the investigation

- 24 -
WP No. 19477 of 2025


was not complete and at that stage
it was impermissible for the High
Court to look into materials, the
acceptability of which is essentially
a matter for trial. While exercising
jurisdiction under Section 482 of
the Cr.P.C., it is not permissible for
the Court to act as if it was a trial
Court. Even when charge is framed
at that stage, the Court has to only
prima facie be satisfied about
existence of sufficient ground for
proceeding against the accused.
For that limited purpose, the Court
can evaluate material and
documents on records but it
cannot appreciate evidence. The
Court is not required to appreciate
evidence to conclude whether the
materials produced are sufficient
or not for convicting the accused.
In Chand Dhawan (Smt.) v.
Jawahar Lal and Ors., [1992] 3
SCC 317, it was observed that
when the materials relied upon by
a party are required to be proved,
no inference can be drawn on the
basis of those materials to
conclude the complaint to be

- 25 -
WP No. 19477 of 2025


unacceptable. The Court should not
act on annexures to the petitions
under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C.,
which cannot be termed as
evidence without being tested and
proved." (Emphasis supplied)
9. The above decisions of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court make it abundantly clear that
the Courts should be slow in exercising the
power under Section 482 of Cr.P.C. especially
where serious allegations of Corruption by
public servants are made.”
22. In the instant case, as discussed supra, the primary
ingredients of the offences punishable under Sections 7(a) of
P.C. Act are made out by the prosecution against the petitioner.
The question as to whether the complaint is motivated by mala
fides is itself a matter of evidence and trial and this Court
cannot conduct a mini trial, at this stage. On an entire perusal
of charge sheet materials especially in light of the presence of
recordings of conversation between the petitioner and
respondent No.2 and in view of the ratio laid down in the
aforesaid judgments, which observed that the Courts should be
slow in exercising the power under Section 482 of Cr.P.C.
especially where serious allegations of corruption by public

- 26 -
WP No. 19477 of 2025


servants are made, I am of the view that, continuation of
criminal proceedings against the petitioner will not amount to
abuse of process of Court. Hence, without expressing any
opinion on the merits of the case, the petition is dismissed .





SD/-
(RAJESH RAI K)
JUDGE













PKS/K