LAL HUSSAIN TH HIS SON LIQUAT ALI vs UT OF J AND K TH INCHARGE STATE INVESTIGATION AGENCY, JAMMU
- Court
- Jammu and Kashmir High Court
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU &KASHMIR AND LADAKH AT
JAMMU
Reserved on: 30.10.2026
Pronounced on: 13.11.2026
Uploaded on: 13.11.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced: Full
CrlA(D) No.52/2025
c/w
CrlA(D) No.49/2025
ASHIQ ALI @AKHI & ANR.
...APPELLANT(S)
Through: - Mr. Nadeem Bhat, Advocate (in CrlA(D) No.52/2025)
Mr. Asheesh Singh Kotwal, Advocate (in CrlA(D) No.49/2025)
Vs.
UT OF J&K & ANR. …RESPONDENT(S)
Through: - Ms. Monika Kohli, Sr. AAG, with
Ms. Malvika Gupta, Advocate.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SHAHZAD AZEEM, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
Sanjay Dhar ‘J’:
1) The appellants, through the medium of present appeals,
have called in question two separate orders dated 15.09.2025
rd
passed by learned 3 Additional Sessions Judge (Designated
under TADA/POTA u/s 22 of NIA Act), Jammu (for short “the
Trial Court”), whereby bail applications of the appellants have
been dismissed. It is pertinent to mention here that both the
appellants are facing trial before the learned Trial Court in a
case arising out of FIR No.101/2024 for offences under
CrlA(D) No.52/2025 c/w
CrlA(D) No.49/2025 Page 1 of 13
Sections 13, 16, 18, 23 of UA(P) Act, 1967, 302, 307, 120-B,
121, 121-A, 122 of IPC, 4/5 Explosive Substances Act and
Section 7/27 of Arms Act.
2) Briefly stated, case of the respondent-prosecution is that
on 11.06.2024 at about 2000 hours, an information was
received by Police Station, Hiranagar, through reliable
sources that some unknown terrorists equipped with illegal
automatic weapons, acting on the instigation of Pakistan-
based terrorist outfits with the intention to spread terror and
disrupt peace and tranquility of the State, after illegally
crossing the international border, have entered Village Saida
Sohal, Tehsil Hiranagar, and started indiscriminate firing
upon the civilians, in which one person, namely Omkar, son
of Dina Nath, sustained injuries. On the basis of this
information, FIR No.101/2024 came to be registered at Police
Station, Hiranagar, and investigation of the case was started.
The Investigating Officer proceeded to the spot along with
paramilitary forces and SOG and the area was cordoned off.
During search, the hidden terrorists fired upon the police
parties with automatic weapons and hurled hand grenades
towards search parties. The police party also fired in self-
defence. In the ensuing gun battle between the terrorists and
security forces, two unidentified terrorists were killed,
whereas the third terrorist managed to escape from the spot.
CrlA(D) No.52/2025 c/w
CrlA(D) No.49/2025 Page 2 of 13
During the gun battle, one Constable of CRPF also sustained
injuries and he later on succumbed to the injuries. Thus,
offence under Section 302 of IPC was incorporated in the FIR.
The injured civilian, Omkar Sharma, survived the injuries.
The police recovered automatic weapons and huge quantity of
warlike stores, hand grenades, Indian currency notes and
large number of medicines and eatable items from the
possession of slain terrorists.
3) At this stage, the investigation of the case was
transferred to SIA, Jammu. During investigation of the case
by the said agency, it surfaced that during the intervening
th
night of 07/08 June, 2024, accused Ashiq Ali (the appellant
herein) and Ashraf Ali, along with other bovine smugglers,
were engaged in the illegal trade of bovine smuggling. While
they were carrying the bovine animals from Mathra Chak,
District Kathua, to Basantar in Samba via Sanyal, Sherpur,
Kattal Gujran, via Bein Nallah, along with their associates,
they were chased by the activists of Gau Raksha Samiti.
These accused persons fled away from the spot leaving behind
the cattle. It was established that accused Ashiq Ali (the
appellant herein) and Ashraf Ali, along with four other bovine
smugglers, had met three unidentified armed terrorists at
Village Lala Chak, near the western bank of Bein Nallah. It
was also established that the three unidentified terrorists
CrlA(D) No.52/2025 c/w
CrlA(D) No.49/2025 Page 3 of 13
took away the mobile phones of Liaqat Ali alias Shummu and
another mobile phone belonging to Farooq Din along with one
mobile phone belonging to accused Ashraf Ali. It was also
established that appellant Ashiq Ali along with co-accused
Ashraf Ali took all the three terrorists for their safe stay to the
house of appellant/accused Lal Hussain, where the terrorists
were voluntarily provided food and shelter for about
seventeen hours without informing the police or security
forces. The three armed terrorists were thereafter shown the
safe passage towards NH-44. The investigation also revealed
that prior to leaving, the terrorists had given three mobile
phones to accused Ashraf Ali, who handed over two mobile
phones to appellant/accused Ashiq Ali. Instead of handing
over the third phone to accused Farooq Din to whom the said
cell phone belonged, he deliberately got it formatted. After
analysis of the recovered cell phones, it was established that
the phone had been formatted to erase the activities carried
out from the said phone. Analysis of the phone belonging to
accused Ashraf Ali confirmed his presence at the relevant
location during the intervening night of 07/08the June, 2024.
4) The investigation also revealed that on 07.06.2024, the
terrorists had killed one person, namely Basudev, who was
working as cook in ANT Construction Company located at
Village Regal, by shooting him dead prior to meeting the
CrlA(D) No.52/2025 c/w
CrlA(D) No.49/2025 Page 4 of 13
appellants. The killed terrorists were found to be associated
with Jaish-e-Mohammed and it was found that the appellants
had come in contact with the terrorists during the intervening
th
night of 07/08 June, 2024.
5) After completion of investigation, charge sheet was laid
against the appellants, co-accused Ashraf Ali as well as
against killed and escaped terrorists, including the Chief of
Jaish-e-Mohammed, Maulana Masood Azhar, before the
learned Trial Court. As per the charge sheet, offences under
Section 19 UA(P) Act and Section 201 of IPC were found
established against both appellants Ashiq Ali and Lal
Hussain.
6) Vide order dated 06.02.2025, the learned Trial Court
framed charges for aforesaid offences against both the
appellants. In the charge sheet, as many as 83 prosecution
witnesses have been cited, out of whom five witnesses have
been examined so far.
7) The appellants have challenged the impugned orders
passed by the learned Trial Court on the grounds that the
Court below has not properly appreciated the fact that the
witnesses examined so far, have not supported the
prosecution case. It has been contended that examination of
83 prosecution witnesses is going to take a lot of time,
CrlA(D) No.52/2025 c/w
CrlA(D) No.49/2025 Page 5 of 13
therefore, prolonged incarceration of the appellants would
amount to pre-trial punishment. It has been contended that
there is no admissible evidence on record to implicate the
appellants in the alleged crime, therefore, the learned Trial
Court has wrongly applied the rigour of Section 43-D(5) of
UA(P) Act.
8) During the course of arguments, learned counsels for
the appellants have raised the contention that the grounds of
arrest were not provided to the appellants at the time of their
arrest, therefore, arrest and subsequent remand of the
appellants is rendered illegal, as a result whereof they are
entitled to be set at liberty.
9) We have heard learned counsel for the parties and
perused the grounds of appeal, the impugned orders passed
by the learned Trial Court and record of the Trial Court.
10) Although in the memo of appeal, the appellants have
sought bail on merits by contending that statements of the
prosecution witnesses examined so far and the material
collected by the investigating agency during the investigation
of the case does not show the involvement of the appellants
in the alleged crime, therefore, rigour of Section 43-D(5) of
UA(P) Act is not attracted to their case, yet, during the course
of arguments, learned counsels for the appellants have given
CrlA(D) No.52/2025 c/w
CrlA(D) No.49/2025 Page 6 of 13
up the said contention and have laid emphasis on the
contention that the appellants have not been provided the
grounds of arrest at the time of their arrest, as such, their
arrest is illegal, entitling them to grant of bail. Reliance in this
regard has been placed on the judgments of the Supreme
Court in the cases of Prabir Purkayastha vs. State (NCT of
Delhi) , (2024) 8 SCC 254, and Mihir Rajesh Shah vs. State
of Maharashtra and others , (2026) 1 SCC 500.
11) In Mihir Rajesh Shah's case (supra), the Supreme Court
has, after analyzing the legal position in the light of mandate
of Article 22(1) of the Constitution of India, concluded as
under:
i) The constitutional mandate of informing the
arrestee the grounds of arrest is mandatory in all
offences under all statutes including offences
under IPC 1860 (now BNS 2023);
ii) The grounds of arrest must be communicated in
writing to the arrestee in the language he/she
understands;
iii) In case(s) where, the arresting officer/person is
unable to communicate the grounds of arrest in
writing on or soon after arrest, it be so done
orally. The said grounds be communicated in
writing within a reasonable time and in any case
at least two hours prior to production of the
arrestee for remand proceedings before the
magistrate.
iv) In case of non-compliance of the above, the
arrest and subsequent remand would be
rendered illegal and the person will be at liberty
to be set free.
12) From the foregoing analysis of the legal position, it is
clear that at the time of arrest of an accused, the grounds of
CrlA(D) No.52/2025 c/w
CrlA(D) No.49/2025 Page 7 of 13
arrest must be communicated in writing to him in the
language he or she understands, and in case of default or
non-compliance, the arrest and subsequent remand would be
rendered illegal and the person would be entitled to be set at
liberty.
13)
As to what is distinction between the “reasons for arrest”
and “grounds of arrest” the Supreme Court has, in Prabir
Purkayastha's case (supra), emphasized that there is a
significant difference in the phrase 'reasons for arrest' and
'grounds of arrest'. It has been observed that reasons for
arrest are purely formal parameters, namely to prevent the
accused person from committing any further offence, for
proper investigation of the offence, to prevent accused person
from causing the evidence of the offence to disappear or
tampering with such evidence in any manner, to prevent the
arrested person from making inducement, threat or promise
to any person acquainted with the facts of the case so as to
dissuade him from disclosing such facts to the Court or to the
Investigating Officer. While explaining the meaning of
“grounds of arrest”, the Supreme Court observed that the
same would require to contain all such details in hand of the
Investigating Officer which necessitated the arrest of the
accused. After making a distinction between reasons for
arrest and the grounds of arrest, the Supreme Court held that
CrlA(D) No.52/2025 c/w
CrlA(D) No.49/2025 Page 8 of 13
grounds of arrest informed in writing must convey to the
arrested accused all basic facts on which he was being
arrested so as to provide him an opportunity of defending
himself against custodial remand and to seek bail. In the said
case, the Supreme Court , after concluding that the grounds
of arrest in writing were not provided to the
accused/appellant therein before passing the order of
remand, held that the arrest and subsequent remand of the
appellant stood vitiated.
14) Turning to the facts of the present case, a perusal of the
Trial Court record would reveal that the appellants have been
provided with grounds of arrest in writing in English
language. In the grounds of arrest, it has been mentioned that
the appellants had met the terrorists who were equipped with
automatic weapons and carry bags and the appellants had
arranged and provided shelter, logistics, and arranged food,
water for these terrorists during the intervening night of
07/08the June, 2024. It is further recorded in the grounds of
arrest that the same have been read over to the appellants in
the language they fully understand, whereupon the
appellants have also put their signatures/thumb
impressions.
15) Learned counsels for the appellants have contended that
the contents of the grounds of arrest would show that the
CrlA(D) No.52/2025 c/w
CrlA(D) No.49/2025 Page 9 of 13
same do not constitute the grounds of arrest, but the same
constitute only reasons for arrest.
16) We are afraid, the aforesaid contention of the learned
counsels for the appellants is wholly misconceived. As has
been clearly distinguished by the Supreme Court in Prabir
Purkayastha's case (supra), the reasons for arrest would be
purely formal parameters which would include the
justification for arresting the accused to prevent him from,
committing any further offences, tampering with the evidence
or threatening the witnesses, or not cooperating with the
Investigating Officer. None of these reasons is mentioned in
the grounds of arrest communicated to the appellants herein.
The grounds of arrest in the instant case give a gist of the
activities in which the appellants have indulged, which
prompted the investigating agency to effect their arrest. This
gist of facts contained in the writing communicated to the
appellants falls within the category of “grounds of arrest” as
explained by the Supreme Court in Prabir Purkayastha's
case (supra). Therefore, it cannot be stated that the grounds
of arrest were not furnished to the appellants at the time of
their arrest.
17)
As already stated, it has been clearly mentioned in the
grounds of arrest that the same were explained to the
appellants in the language they understand. At this stage,
CrlA(D) No.52/2025 c/w
CrlA(D) No.49/2025 Page 10 of 13
there is no reason for us to disbelieve the same, though it will
be open to the appellants to cross-examine the arresting
officer on this aspect of the matter at the appropriate stage
during the trial of the case.
18) Apart from the above, even if it is assumed that there is
some minor procedural irregularity in drafting/providing the
grounds of arrest to the appellants, the same may not vitiate
their arrest and subsequent remand orders in the facts and
circumstances of the case unless it is shown that a prejudice
was caused to the appellants. In this regard, reliance is being
placed on the ratio laid down by the Supreme Court in the
case of State of Meghalaya vs. Sonam Raghuvanshi , 2026
SCC OnLine SC 1392. In the said case, it has been held that
there is a fundamental difference between non-service of
grounds of arrest and non-furnishing of adequate reasons
thereunder. While the first category might vitiate the arrest,
in the second category, one has to see the prejudice caused
to the accused.
19) Again, in the case of State of Karnataka vs. Sri
Darshan and others , (2026) 8 SCC 223, the Supreme Court
has held that the constitutional and statutory framework
mandates that the arrested person must be informed of the
grounds of arrest, but no specific form has been prescribed
for communication of the grounds of arrest. It has been held
CrlA(D) No.52/2025 c/w
CrlA(D) No.49/2025 Page 11 of 13
that substantial compliance with the constitutional and
statutory requirements in this regard is sufficient unless
demonstrable prejudice is shown. The Supreme Court further
held that Article 22(1) is satisfied if the accused is made aware
of arrest grounds in substance, even if not conveyed in
writing. The Court further went on to hold that written,
individualized grounds are not an inflexible requirement in all
circumstances.
20) In the present case, as already stated, the allegations in
brief against the appellants were conveyed to them in writing
and the same were explained to them in the language they
understood. Therefore, even if the grounds of arrest are
deficient in details about the allegations against the
appellants, it can still be safely stated that there has been
substantial compliance to the mandate of Article 22(1) of the
Constitution and Section 50 of Cr. P. C, corresponding to
Section 47 of BNSS, in the present case.
21) The appellants have not demonstrated that any
prejudice has been caused to them on account of non-supply
of detailed grounds of arrest to them. The appellants have not
raised the said plea either at the time of remand or when their
bail applications were rejected by the learned Trial Court on
as many as two occasions. Even in the present appeals, the
appellants have not urged the said ground. It is only during
CrlA(D) No.52/2025 c/w
CrlA(D) No.49/2025 Page 12 of 13
the course of arguments that learned counsel for the
appellants have come up with the ground of non-furnishing
of grounds of arrest. From these circumstances, it is clear
that the appellants have not suffered any prejudice because
of non-supply of detailed grounds of arrest.
22)
For what has been discussed hereinbefore, we do not
find any ground to interfere in the impugned orders passed
by the learned Trial Court and we do not find any ground to
enlarge the appellants on bail at this stage. Accordingly, both
the appeals are dismissed.
(Shahzad Azeem) (Sanjay Dhar)
Judge Judge
SRINAGAR
13.11.2026
“Bhat Altaf-Secretary”
Whether the judgment is reportable: YES/NO
CrlA(D) No.52/2025 c/w
CrlA(D) No.49/2025 Page 13 of 13