SMT. MANJULA W/O LAXMAN HALINGALI vs SHANKARAYYA S/O SAVALAGAYYA NISHANI

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18483
MFA No. 104967 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020176962023



IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT DHARWAD


TH
DATED THIS THE 12 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026


BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE K.G.SHANTHI

MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 104967 OF 2023 (MV-D)



BETWEEN:


1. SMT. MANJULA
W/O. LAXMAN HALINGALI
AGE: 39 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O: BUDIHAL,
RAIBAG TALUKA,
BELAGAVI DISTRICT.
PIN: 591302.

2. SANTOSH
S/O. LAXMAN HALINGALI
AGE: 21 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: BUDIHAL
RAIBAG TALUKA,
BELAGAVI DISTRICT.
PIN: 591302.

3. SMT. SIDDAVVA
W/O. BHIMAPPA HALINGALI
AGE: 65 YEARS, OCC: NIL,
RAIBAG TALUKA,
BELAGAVI DISTRICT.
PIN: 591302.

…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI. HANAMANT R. LATUR, ADVOCATE)





- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18483
MFA No. 104967 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020176962023



AND:

1. SHANKARAYYA
S/O. SAVALAGAYYA NISHANI,
AGE: 50 YEARS,
OCC: BUSINESS,
R/O: SAVALAGI, NANDAON,
GOKAK TALUKA,
BELAGAVI DISTRICT
PIN: 591307.

2. NATIONAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.,
BY ITS BRANCH MANAGER,
OPP: RANGE FOREST OFFICE,
BUS STAND ROAD,
GOKAK, PIN. 591307
GOKAK TALUKA,
BELAGAVI DISTRICT.

…RESPONDENTS
(NOTICE TO R1 IS DISPENSED WITH;
BY SRI. V.P. VADAVI, ADVOCATE)

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.173(1) OF MV ACT, 1988, PRAYING TO
ENHANCE THE COMPENSATION BY MODIFYING THE JUDGMENT AND
AWARD PASSED BY XII ADDL. DISTRICT JUDGE AND M.A.C.T.,
BELAGAVI SITTING AT GOKAK, IN MVC NO.1488/2021 DATED
06.07.2023 IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.

THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR ADMISSION, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18483
MFA No. 104967 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020176962023


CORAM: HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE K.G.SHANTHI

ORAL JUDGMENT

Aggrieved by the judgment and award dated 06.07.2023
in MVC No.1488/2021 passed by the XII Additional District
1
Judge and MACT, Belagavi Sitting at Gokak , the appellants
being the petitioners before the Tribunal filed this appeal
seeking enhancement of the compensation.
2. Parties are hereinafter referred to as per their ranks
before the Tribunal for the sake of convenience.
3. Brief facts of the case of the petitioner are that on
04.07.2021 at about 4.00 p.m. on Gokak-Ghataprabha road
within the limits of Shindikurbet village ,one Laxman S/o.
Bhimappa Halingali was returning from Bailhongal towards
Budihal village on his motorcycle bearing registration No.KA-
2
23/E-9475 in a moderate speed by observing all traffic rules
and regulations. At that time, the driver of the car bearing
3
registration No.KA-22/Z-8684 came from opposite side in a
rash and negligent manner so as to endanger human life and

1
For short, ‘the Tribunal’
2
For short, ‘the motorcycle’
3
For short, ‘the car’
Digitally Signed by KADAMBADI
GANESH SHANTHI on 19-11-2026

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18483
MFA No. 104967 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020176962023


suddenly attempted to overtake another vehicle. In the
process, he came on the wrong side and dashed against the
motorcycle ridden by Laxman. Due to the said impact, the
Laxman sustained grievous injuries and immediately shifted to
the hospital for treatment. However, during the course of
treatment, he succumbed to the injuries sustained in the
accident.
4. The petitioners being the legal representatives of
the deceased stated that, prior to the accident, the deceased
was hale and healthy and earning Rs.25,000/- per month by
doing coolie work. Due to sudden death of the deceased, the
petitioners lost their only bread earner and suffered mentally,
physically and financially. The petitioners further stated that,
they have spent huge amount towards medical, transportation
of dead body, funeral and other expenses. Accordingly, they
filed a claim petition claiming compensation before the
Tribunal.
5. Upon filing of the petition, notices were issued to

the respondents. They appeared through their counsel and filed
their objections.
Digitally Signed by KADAMBADI
GANESH SHANTHI on 19-11-2026

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18483
MFA No. 104967 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020176962023


6. Respondent No.1 denied the averments of the
petition in total and contended that the car was duly insured
with respondent No.2 and the vehicle documents including
driving license were valid and effective as on the date of
accident. Accordingly, prayed to dismiss the claim petition.
7. Respondent No.2 denied entire petition averments
and contended that the alleged accident had not occur and the
car was not involved in the accident. It was further contended
that the deceased was under the influence of alcohol and not
having any knowledge of riding the motorcycle and therefore,
the accident alleged was occurred due to sole or self negligence
on the part of the rider of the motorcycle. It was further
contended that the owner of the insured vehicle had violated
the policy conditions by entrusting the insured vehicle to the
driver without driving license and therefore, there is a statutory
breach of policy condition. Accordingly, prayed for dismissal of
the petition.
8. Before the Tribunal, the petitioner No.2 examined

as PW1 and one witness examined as PW2 and got marked the
documents as Exs.P.1 to P.27. On behalf of respondents, one
Digitally Signed by KADAMBADI
GANESH SHANTHI on 19-11-2026

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18483
MFA No. 104967 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020176962023


witness has been examined as RW1 and got marked Ex.R1 to
R3.
9. On hearing the arguments, the Tribunal allowed the
claim petition in part and awarded compensation under the
following heads with interest at the rate of 6% per annum from
the date of petition till realization:
Sl.
Heads Amount in Rs.
No.
1 Loss of dependency 16,94,112/-
2 Medical expenses 1,77,078/-
3 Transportation expenses 15,000/-
4 Funeral expenses 16,500/-
5 Loss of consortium 88,000/-
6 Loss of estate 50,000/-
Total 20,41,000/-

The Tribunal attributed 25% negligence on the rider of the
motorcycle i.e., deceased, and 75% negligence on respondents
No.1 and 2 and further directed the respondent No.2/Insurance
Company to deposit the amount to the extent of its liability i.e.,
75% along with interest within a period of two months from the
date of award.
10. Dissatisfied with the quantum of compensation, the
petitioners preferred this appeal.
Digitally Signed by KADAMBADI
GANESH SHANTHI on 19-11-2026

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18483
MFA No. 104967 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020176962023


11. Learned counsel for the petitioners argued that the
Tribunal erred in attributing the negligence to the extent of
25% on the rider of the motorcycle. Further it is argued that
the Tribunal assessed the income of the deceased on the lower
side. Accordingly, prays for attributing entire negligence to the
driver of the car and for enhancement of the compensation.
12. Learned counsel for the Insurance Company argued
that the award passed by the Tribunal is reasonable and that
there is no need to interfere. Accordingly, prays for dismissal of
the appeal.
13. Heard the arguments. Perused the materials
available on record. The points that would arise for
consideration by this Court are as follows:
(i) Whether the Tribunal is justified in
attributing negligence to the extent of 25%
on the deceased?
(ii) Whether the petitioners prove that the
compensation awarded by the Tribunal is
inadequate and it deserves to be modified?
(iii) What order?
Digitally Signed by KADAMBADI
GANESH SHANTHI on 19-11-2026

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18483
MFA No. 104967 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020176962023


14. Points framed by this Court for consideration are
answered as follows:
Point No.(i) : In the negative
Point No.(ii) : Partly in the affirmative.
Point No.(iii): As per the final order, for the
following:
15. Regarding Point No.(i): The deceased was

proceeding in his motorcycle on 04.07.2021 at about 04:00
p.m. on Gokak-Ghataprabha road, at that time, the car driven
by its driver in a rash and negligent manner came from
opposite side in a wrong direction and dashed to the
motorcycle. As a result, the motorcycle rider sustained grievous
injuries and he died during the course of treatment. The police
have filed a charge sheet against the driver of the car for the
offence punishable under Section 279 of the Indian Penal Code,
1860 and also filed a charge sheet against the rider of the
motorcycle for the offence punishable under Sections 3 and 185
of the Motor Vehicles Act, stating that the rider of the
motorcycle has no driving license to ride the motorcycle.
Digitally Signed by KADAMBADI
GANESH SHANTHI on 19-11-2026

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18483
MFA No. 104967 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020176962023


16. The Tribunal, on ascertaining the evidence, held
that the motorcycle rider was not having driving license to ride
the motorcycle at the time of accident and thereby has
contributed his negligence to the accident.
17. In Dinesh Kumar J. @ Dinesh J. v. National
4
Insurance Company Limited and Others , the Hon'ble Apex
Court observed as under:
“9.If a person drives a vehicle without a
license, he commits an offence. The same, by itself,
in our opinion, may not lead to a finding of
negligence as regards the accident. It has been held
by the courts below that it was the driver of the mini
truck who was driving rashly and negligently. It is
one thing to say that the appellant was not
possessing any license but no finding of fact has
been arrived at that he was driving the two-wheeler
rashly which contributed to the accident, we fail to
see as to how, only because he was not having a
license, he would be held to be guilty of contributory
negligence….
10. The matter might have been different if by
reason of his rash and negligent driving, the
accident had taken place.”

4
2017 INSC 1247
Digitally Signed by KADAMBADI
GANESH SHANTHI on 19-11-2026

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18483
MFA No. 104967 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020176962023


18. In this case, the police have not filed any charge
sheet against the deceased that he is riding the motorcycle in a
rash and negligent manner. However, after investigating the
matter they have filed a charge sheet stating that the rider of
the motorcycle was not having effective driving license to ride
the motorcycle at the time of accident. Merely because the
rider was not having driving license, it does not mean that he
has rode the motorcycle in a rash and negligent manner.
19. On looking into the material available on record,

this Court is of the opinion that the finding of the Tribunal that
the rider has no valid driving license and thereby contributed
his negligence to the accident is not sustainable. The Tribunal is
not justified in attributing the negligence to the extent of 25%
on the rider of the motorcycle.
20. Accordingly, point No.(i) is answered in the
negative .
21. Regarding point No.(ii): Learned counsel for the
petitioners contended that the Tribunal assessed the income of
the deceased at Rs.11,500/-. The petitioners have not
produced any documents to prove the income of the deceased.
Digitally Signed by KADAMBADI
GANESH SHANTHI on 19-11-2026

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18483
MFA No. 104967 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020176962023


Such being the circumstances, it is up to the Tribunal to assess
the notional income of the deceased based on the guidelines
issued by the Karnataka Legal Services Authority. The accident
occurred in the year 2021. So as per the chart, the notional
income of the deceased to be taken at Rs.14,250/- per
month.
22. The deceased died at the age of 41 years. So, the
applied multiplier would be “14”.
23. As per the law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court
5
in National Insurance Company Limited v. Pranay Sethi ,
towards future prospects 25% of the notional income of the
deceased has to be added, and as the deceased died leaving
rd
behind him three dependants, 1/3 of the notional income of
the deceased has to be deducted towards personal living
expenses. Hence, the petitioners are entitled for compensation
under the head of “loss of dependency” as under:
Rs.14,250/- + 25% (Rs.3,563/-) = Rs.17,813/-
rd
Rs.17,813/- - 1/3 (Rs.5,937/-) = Rs.11,876/-
Rs.11,876/- X 12 X 14 = Rs.19,95,168/-


5
(2017) 16 SCC 680
Digitally Signed by KADAMBADI
GANESH SHANTHI on 19-11-2026

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18483
MFA No. 104967 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020176962023


24. By considering the documents available before the
Court, the Tribunal has awarded compensation of
Rs.1,77,078/- under the head of “medical expenses” and also
awarded compensation of Rs.15,000/- under the head of
“transportation expenses” which does not call for any
interference by this Court.
25. The petitioner No.1 is the wife of the deceased,
petitioner No.2 is the son of the deceased and petitioner No.3 is
the mother of the deceased. The Hon’ble Apex Court in case of
Magma General Insurance Company Limited v. Nanu Ram
6
@ Chuhru Ram , has held that consortium is compendious
term which includes spousal consortium, parental consortium
and filial consortium. Hence, the petitioners No.1 to 3 are
entitled for compensation of Rs.40,000/- each under the head
of “loss of consortium”. Further, in Pranay Sethi’s case the
Hon’ble Apex Court has held that the amount awarded under
the head of loss of consortium, is liable to be enhanced by 10%
escalation. Thus, the petitioners No.1 to 3 are entitled for

6
(2018) 18 SCC 130
Digitally Signed by KADAMBADI
GANESH SHANTHI on 19-11-2026

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18483
MFA No. 104967 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020176962023


compensation of Rs.44,000/- each i.e., to Rs.1,32,000/-
under the head of “loss of consortium”.
26. The Tribunal has awarded compensation of
Rs.16,500/- under the head of “funeral expenses”, which does
not call for any interference.
27. Further, the Tribunal has awarded compensation of
Rs.50,000/- under the head of “loss of estate”, which deserves
to be modified. As per the law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex
Court in Pranay Sethi’s case, a sum of Rs.15,000/- is required
to be awarded under the said head, with an enhancement of
10% escalation. Accordingly, the petitioners are entitled for
compensation of Rs.16,500/- under the head of “loss of
estate”. In all, the petitioners are entitled for compensation
under the following heads:

Sl. Amount in
Heads
No. Rs.
1 Loss of dependency 19,95,168/-
2 Medical expenses 1,77,078/-
3 Transportation expenses 15,000/-
4 Funeral expenses 16,500/-
5 Loss of consortium 1,32,000/-
6 Loss of estate 16,500/-
Total 23,52,246/-
Digitally Signed by KADAMBADI
GANESH SHANTHI on 19-11-2026

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18483
MFA No. 104967 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020176962023



28. Thus, the petitioners are entitled to receive
compensation of Rs.23,52,246/- as against Rs.20,41,000/- as
awarded by the Tribunal.
29. Accordingly, point No.(ii) is answered partly in the
affirmative .
30. Regarding point No.(ii) : In view of the findings
on points No.(i) and (ii), this Court proceeds to pass the
following:
ORDER
(i) The appeal filed by the petitioners is

allowed in part.
(ii) The impugned judgment and award passed
by the Tribunal is modified. The petitioners
are entitled to receive compensation of
Rs.23,52,246/- as against Rs.20,41,000/-
awarded by the Tribunal.
(iii) The enhanced compensation amount shall
carry interest at the rate of 6% per annum
from the date of petition till the date of
payment.
Digitally Signed by KADAMBADI
GANESH SHANTHI on 19-11-2026

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18483
MFA No. 104967 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020176962023


(iv) Respondent No.2/Insurance Company shall
deposit the entire compensation amount
with accrued interest before the Tribunal
within a period of six weeks from the date
of receipt of certified copy of this judgment.
(v) Draw modified award accordingly.
(vi) Registry to transmit the Trial Court Records
forthwith.

(vii) In view of disposal of this appeal, pending
applications, if any, do not survive for
consideration and the same are accordingly
disposed of.

Digitally Signed by KADAMBADI
GANESH SHANTHI on 19-11-2026

(K.G.SHANTHI)
JUDGE


SMM
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 21