Bakhtawar Singh vs State Of Punjab And Others
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
CM-2066-CI-2019 IN/AND RFA-863-2019 (O&M) & connected cases -1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
Item Nos.216+231+246+252+254 (22 cases)
CM-2066-CI-2019
IN/AND RFA-863-2019 (O&M)
Decided on: 16.11.2026
Bakhtawar Singh …Appellant
Versus
State of Punjab and others …Respondents
With
Sr. Case No. Appellant(s) Respondent(s)
No.
2. RFA-864-2019 Ram Singh and another State of Punjab and others
(O&M)
3. RFA-865-2019 Jaswant Singh and others State of Punjab and others
(O&M)
4. RFA-866-2019 Shankar Singh (deceased) State of Punjab and others
(O&M) through LR(s)
5. RFA-867-2019 Bhullo (deceased) through State of Punjab and others
(O&M) LR(s)
6. RFA-868-2019 Bimla Devi and others State of Punjab and others
(O&M)
7. RFA-869-2019 Gurandita (deceased) State of Punjab and others
(O&M) through LR(s)
8. RFA-870-2019 Gardhari Lal (deceased) State of Punjab and others
(O&M) through LR(s)
9. RFA-871-2019 Govind Singh and others State of Punjab and others
(O&M)
10. RFA-872-2019 Gollu (deceased) through State of Punjab and others
(O&M) LR(s)
11. RFA-4352-2019 Bhindi (deceased) through State of Punjab and others
(O&M) LR(s) and others
12. RFA-110-2020 Dhian Singh (deceased) Union of India and others
(O&M) through LR(s) and others
13. RFA-113-2020 Wadhiko @ Vadhiko
(O&M) (deceased) through LR(s) and
others
State of Punjab and others
14. RFA-433-2020 Bishan Singh (deceased) Union of India and others
(O&M) through LR(s)
15. RFA-449-2020 Bishno Devi (deceased) State of Punjab and others
(O&M) through LR(s)
16. RFA-1230-2022 Puran and another Union of India and others
(O&M)
17. RFA-1133-2025 Tejo @ Tej Ram (deceased) Union of India and others
(O&M) through LR(s)
18. RFA-1135-2025 Ratno (deceased) through Union of India and others
(O&M) LR(s)
19. RFA-753-2026 Parkash Chand (deceased) Union of India and others
(O&M) through LR(s)
20. RFA-754-2026 Ram Chand (deceased) Union of India and others
(O&M) through LR(s) and another
21. RFA-755-2026 Badri Nath (deceased) Union of India and others
(O&M) through LR(s) and another
MOHIT KUMAR
2026.11.17 15:21
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this order/judgment.
CM-2066-CI-2019 IN/AND RFA-863-2019 (O&M) & connected cases -2-
Sr. Case No. Appellant(s) Respondent(s)
No.
22. RFA-1376-2026 Bishno Devi (deceased) Union of India and others
(O&M) through LR(s)
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE JAGMOHAN BANSAL
Present: - Mr. Vishal Aggarwal, Advocate,
Mr. Gopal Krishnan, Advocate,
Ms. Aastha Sharma, Advocate and
Mr. G.S. Sarao, Advocate for the appellants
(in RFA-863-2019, RFA-864-2019, RFA-865-2019,
RFA-866-2019, RFA-867-2019, RFA-868-2019,
RFA-869-2019, RFA-870-2019, RFA-871-2019
RFA-872-2019, RFA-4352-2019, RFA-110-2020,
RFA-113-2020, RFA-433-2020 & RFA-449-2020)
Mr. Sukhdev Singh, Advocate and
Mr. Vikram Singh, Advocate for the appellants
(in RFA-1230-2022, RFA-1135-2025, RFA-1133-2025,
RFA-753-2026, RFA-754-2026, RFA-755-2026)
Mr. Munish Puri, Advocate for the appellant(s)
(in RFA-1376-2026)
Mr. Puru Jarewal, Deputy Advocate General, Punjab
Mr. Vikram Bajaj, Senior Panel Counsel
for Union of India-respondent Nos.2 to 4
(in RFA-863-2019, RFA-864-2019, RFA-865-2019,
RFA-866-2019, RFA-867-2019, RFA-868-2019,
RFA-869-2019, RFA-870-2019, RFA-871-2019
RFA-872-2019)
Mr. Ashish Chaudhary, Senior Panel Counsel
for Union of India-respondents
(in RFA-4352-2019, RFA-110-2020, RFA-113-2020,
RFA-433-2020, RFA-449-2020)
Mr. Sunil Kumar Sharma, Senior Panel Counsel
for Union of India-respondents
*
JAGMOHAN BANSAL, J . (Oral)
1. These appeals under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act,
1894 (for short ‘ 1894 Act ’) are directed against award dated 01.06.1981
whereby learned District Judge, Gurdaspur (hereinafter referred to as
‘ Reference Court ’) has not granted compensation as claimed by
appellants/landowners.
MOHIT KUMAR
2026.11.17 15:21
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this order/judgment.
CM-2066-CI-2019 IN/AND RFA-863-2019 (O&M) & connected cases -3-
2. As common issues are involved in the captioned appeals, with
the consent of both sides, the same are hereby disposed of by this common
order. For the sake of brevity and convenience, facts are borrowed from
CM-2066-CI-2019 in/and RFA-863-2019.
3. The appellant through CM-2066-CI-2019 is seeking condonation
of delay of 37 years in filing the appeal. It is apt to mention here that in all the
appeals in question, there is delay of more than 35 years in filing appeal before
this Court. The appellant (Bakhtawar Singh) is claiming that he had handed
over papers to clerk of the counsel who did not file his appeal along with
appeals of other villagers of other villages. He came to know about this fact
when compensation was paid to other villagers, however, he was denied on
the ground that there is no order in his favour. Delay is unintentional and needs
to be condoned. Hon’ble Supreme Court in New Okhla Industrial
Development Authority v. Rameshwar @ Ramesh Chandra Sharma (Dead)
through Legal Heir and another , 2022 SCC OnLine SC 1599; Suresh
Kumar v. State of Haryana, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 896 and Urban
Improvement Trust v. Vidhya Devi and others, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3725
has held that holistic and pragmatic approach while entertaining application
seeking condonation of delay especially in land acquisition matters should be
adopted. Courts should avoid adopting pedantic approach. In case of
inordinate delay, landowners may be denied interest or interest & statutory
benefits, however, appeal should not be rejected on the ground of delay.
4. Per contra , learned counsel for respondents submit that in land
acquisition matters liberal approach should be adopted while adjudicating
applications seeking condonation of delay, however, inordinate delay cannot
be condoned unless and until there is a sufficient cause. In the present case,
MOHIT KUMAR the appellants/landowners have raised lame excuse which is raised in every
2026.11.17 15:21
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this order/judgment.
CM-2066-CI-2019 IN/AND RFA-863-2019 (O&M) & connected cases -4-
second case. The appellants are relying upon judgment of Supreme Court in
Dilawar Singh and others v. Union of India and others, Law Finder Doc Id
# 349732 which was delivered on 26.10.2010. There is delay of 9 years even
from the date of aforesaid judgment.
5. All the arguments raised by both sides have been recorded in the
presence of counsel for the parties. They have not raised any other argument.
6. Heard the arguments and perused the record.
7. Hon’ble Supreme Court in New Okhla Industrial Development
Authority (supra) while adverting to the inordinate delay in filing the appeals
before the High Court has held that delay may be condoned and enhanced
compensation may be granted, however, the beneficiary/acquiring body
cannot be saddled with the liability of statutory benefits and interest. Relevant
extracts of the judgment read as:
“5.2 Even otherwise as rightly observed by the High Court,
the land owners are not entitled to the compensation at
Rs.297/- per sq.yard considering the decision of this Court in
the case of Nanak (Deceased) through LRS. (supra). Nothing
was pointed out that how the case of the land owners was
comparable with that of the case of Nanak (Deceased) through
LRS. (supra). On the contrary with respect to the acquisition
of the year 1982, this Hon'ble Court determined the
compensation at Rs.149/- per sq.yard in the case of Deo Karan
& Ors.(supra).
5.3 However, at the same time the acquiring body and the
beneficiary of acquisition shall not be saddled with the liability
of statutory benefits and the interest which may be available
under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 for the delayed period.
In the present case the delay of 22 years can be said to be a
substantial delay. However, as the claimants are held to be
entitled the enhanced amount of compensation, in the facts and
circumstances of the case, the High Court can be said to be
MOHIT KUMAR
2026.11.17 15:21
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this order/judgment.
CM-2066-CI-2019 IN/AND RFA-863-2019 (O&M) & connected cases -5-
justified in condoning the delay. However, at the same time, the
High Court has erred in awarding other statutory benefits and
interest for the delayed period. To saddle with the liability to
pay statutory benefits and interest for the delayed period upon
the beneficiary/acquiring body would be a financial burden
upon the public body and it may increase the project cost which
shall be against the public interests. It cannot be disputed that
the liability towards the statutory benefits and the interest
under the Act, 1984 would be a huge liability considering the
interest at the rate of 15% per annum, solatium, price rise etc.
Therefore, while condoning the delay and enhancing the
amount of compensation at par with other landowners, the
High Court ought not to have saddled the liability upon the
appellant to pay statutory benefits and the interest payable
under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 for the delayed period.
To the aforesaid extent the impugned common judgment and
order passed by the High Court is required to be modified and
the present appeals are required to be partly allowed to the
aforesaid extent.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
8. The Supreme Court vide judgment dated 23.04.2025 passed in
Suresh Kumar (supra) has reiterated that applications seeking condonation
of delay ought to be considered by adopting a justice-oriented and liberal
approach. It has been observed that the discretion vested in the Courts under
the law of limitation should be exercised to advance substantial justice, and
that a technical or pedantic approach should not defeat the adjudication of
disputes on their merits. Relevant extracts of the judgement read as:-
“9. Implementing in letter and spirit, the observations made
as above, i.e. a liberal approach in condonation of delay, we
notice that this Court in quite a few judgments has condoned
substantial delay. We may refer to some of them. In Dhiraj
Singh v. State of Haryana The Court observed that even though
there was long delay in filing the appeals, it was a case of
compulsory acquisition and there had been a difference in the
MOHIT KUMAR amount of compensation granted to some land losers vis-a-vis
2026.11.17 15:21
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this order/judgment.
CM-2066-CI-2019 IN/AND RFA-863-2019 (O&M) & connected cases -6-
others. References were also made to Market Committee Hodal
v. Krishan Murari wherein delay of 3240 days arising from the
same acquisition has been condoned. In Huchanagouda v.
Assistant Commissioner and Land Acquisition Officer., this
Court, taking into account the poverty and illiteracy of the land
loser, condoned the delay of more than 2000 days. It was
observed that equities had to be balanced by ensuring that the
determination of market value relates back to the preliminary
notification - making sure that there is no prejudice to the
acquiring authorities, as also no undue advantage to the land
loser. In other words, the appellants who approached the
Court with delay, would not be granted interest for such
period.
10. In Executive Engineer, Nimna Dudhna Project Selu,
District Parbhani, Maharashtra v. State of Maharashtra, this
Court held that the Body acquiring land cannot be saddled with
the liability of paying interest for the period of delay in
preferring the appeals. The order of the High Court, which
granted interest also for five and half years' delay, was
modified to such an extent that interest shall not be payable for
delay. [See also Ningappa Thotappa Angadi v. Special Land
Acquisition Officer.]
11. In all judgments referred supra, the common thread that
can be observed is that delay is not a reason to deny the land
losers their compensation, which is just, fair and reasonable
for the land they have lost.
12. This Court has noticed that in Delhi Air Tech Services Pvt.
Ltd. v. State of U.P., with reference to Coffee Board,
Karnataka, Bangalore v. Commission of Commercial Tax,
Karnataka that while the State has the power of eminent
domain, the owner of a land can only be divested thereof in
accordance with the procedure established by law after
appropriately compensating them. This is in view of Article 300
A and 31A of the Constitution of India.”
9. The Supreme Court in Urban Improvement Trust (supra) while
adopting a liberal approach in condoning the delay in appeals preferred by
MOHIT KUMAR
2026.11.17 15:21
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this order/judgment.
CM-2066-CI-2019 IN/AND RFA-863-2019 (O&M) & connected cases -7-
landowners in land acquisition matters, has deprecated a hyper-technical
approach. It has been observed that having regard to the beneficial nature of
land acquisition jurisprudence and the rights involved the matters ought to be
adjudicated on their merits rather than being rejected on technical ground of
delay. The parameters laid down by the Court are reproduced below: -
“47. It is pertinent for us to consider the judgment of this
Court in Vidya Devi v. State of Himachal Pradesh, (2020) 2
SCC 569, wherein it was held, inter alia, as follows:
“12.12. The contention advanced by the state of delay
and laches of the appellant in moving the court is also
liable to be rejected. Delay and laches cannot be raised
in a case of a continuing cause of action, or if the
circumstances shock the judicial conscience of the
court. Condonation of delay is a matter of judicial
discretion, which must be exercised judiciously and
reasonably in the facts and circumstances of a case. It
will depend upon the breach of fundamental rights, and
the remedy claimed, and when and how the delay arose.
There is no period of limitation prescribed for the courts
to exercise their constitutional jurisdiction to do
substantial justice.
12.13. In a case where the demand for justice is so
compelling, a constitutional court would exercise its
jurisdiction with a view to promote justice, and not
defeat it. [P.S. Sadasivaswamy v. State of T.N., (1975) 1
SCC 152 : 1975 SCC (L&S) 22]”
[Emphasis supplied]
XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX
49. Similarly, this Court in its decision in Maharashtra
State Road Transport Corporation v. Balwant Regular Motor
Service, (1969) 1 SCR 808 held that:
“Now the doctrine of laches in Courts of Equity is not
an arbitrary or a technical doctrine. Where it would be
practically unjust to give a remedy, either because the
MOHIT KUMAR
2026.11.17 15:21
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this order/judgment.
CM-2066-CI-2019 IN/AND RFA-863-2019 (O&M) & connected cases -8-
party has, by his conduct, done that which might fairly
be regarded as equivalent to a waiver of it, or where by
his conduct and neglect he has, though perhaps not
waiving that remedy, yet put the other party in a
situation in which it would not be reasonable to place
him if the remedy were afterwards to be asserted in
either of these cases, lapse of time and delay are most
material. But in every case, if an argument against
relief, which otherwise would be just, is founded upon
mere delay, that delay of course not amounting to a bar
by any statute of limitations, the validity of that defence
must be tried upon principles substantially equitable.
Two circumstances, always important in such cases,
are, the length of the delay and the nature of the acts
done during the interval, which might affect either party
and cause a balance of justice or injustice in taking the
one course or the other, so far as relates to the remedy.”
[Emphasis supplied]
XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX
51. The decisions of this Court have consistently held that
the right to property is enshrined in the Constitution and
requires that procedural safeguards be followed to ensure
fairness and non-arbitrariness in decision-making especially
in cases of acquisition by the State. Therefore, the delay in
approaching the court, while a significant factor, cannot
override the necessity to address illegalities and protect right
to property enshrined in Article 300A. The court must balance
the need for finality in legal proceedings with the need to
rectify injustice. The right of an individual to vindicate and
protect private property cannot be brushed away merely on the
grounds of delay and laches.”
10. The Supreme Court in Shivamma (Dead) v. Karnataka Housing
Board & others, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1969 while taking a stringent view
has held that ‘ sufficient cause ’ must be shown for the delay throughout the
entire period, administrative lethargy or negligence by State authorities cannot
MOHIT KUMAR
2026.11.17 15:21
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this order/judgment.
CM-2066-CI-2019 IN/AND RFA-863-2019 (O&M) & connected cases -9-
be treated as sufficient cause. In cases of inordinate delay by State
instrumentalities, Courts must not condone delay mechanically. Public
interest is better served by enforcing limitation strictly to promote
accountability and timely action. Relevant extracts are reproduced as below:-
“258. The length of the delay is a relevant matter which the
court must take into consideration while considering whether
the delay should be condoned or not. From the tenor of the
approach of the respondents, it appears that they want to fix
their own period of limitation for instituting the proceedings
for which law has prescribed a period of limitation. Once it is
held that a party has lost his right to have the matter
considered on merits because of his own inaction for a long, it
cannot be presumed to be non-deliberate delay and in such
circumstances of the case, it cannot be heard to plead that the
substantial justice deserves to be preferred as against the
technical considerations. While considering the plea for
condonation of delay, the court must not start with the merits
of the main matter. The court owes a duty to first ascertain the
bona fides of the explanation offered by the party seeking
condonation. It is only if the sufficient cause assigned by the
litigant and the opposition of the other side is equally balanced
that the court may bring into aid the merits of the matter for
the purpose of condoning the delay.
259. We are of the view that the question of limitation is not
merely a technical consideration. The rules of limitation are
based on the principles of sound public policy and principles
of equity. We should not keep the 'Sword of Damocles' hanging
over the head of the respondent for indefinite period of time to
be determined at the whims and fancies of the appellants.
260. From the above exposition of law, it is abundantly clear
that the High Court has erroneously condoned a massive delay
of 3966 days on account of certain lapses at the administrative
levels and of there being no follow-ups in the proceedings,
along with finding certain merits in the case of the respondent
no. 1 against the maintainability of the suit of the appellant and
that of the relief molded by the First Appellate Court. We have
MOHIT KUMAR
2026.11.17 15:21
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this order/judgment.
CM-2066-CI-2019 IN/AND RFA-863-2019 (O&M) & connected cases -10-
no hesitation in stating that such grounds are nowhere near to
being "sufficient cause" as per Section 5 of the 1963 Act. The
High Court lost sight of the fact that the precedents and
authorities it relied upon by it had delays of two-digits, or even
that of single-digit, more particularly the delay in those cases
was supported by sufficient cause. The present case, however,
stands on a very different footing, owing to such an enormous
delay. Hence, we are not inclined to accept the condonation of
the delay by the High Court.”
11. A conspectus of the aforesaid judgments of Hon'ble Supreme
Court reveals that liberal approach in case of application of a landowner
seeking condonation of delay in land acquisition matter should be adopted.
Cases of landowners must not be treated at par with other cases.
12. In the case in hand, there is delay of more than 35 years. The
appellants/landowners are claiming higher amount of compensation on the
basis of judgment of Supreme Court in Dilawar Singh (supra) . The aforesaid
judgment was delivered on 26.10.2010. Appeals in hand were filed after 9
years even from the date of aforesaid judgment. This Court in a bunch of
appeals including RFA No.883 of 2020, Karam Singh (since deceased)
through LRs and others v. Union of India and others, decided on 04.07.2022
with respect to acquisition of land of District Pathankot where land in question
is situated has dismissed appeals where there was delay of 12 years. In
Pathapati Subba Reddy (Died) by LRs & others v. The Special Deputy
Collector , 2024(12) SCC 336 , the Supreme Court has held that delay subject
to denial of interest cannot be mechanically condoned. Denial of interest is
condition to condone delay, however, there should be sufficient cause for
delay. In the absence of sufficient cause, delay cannot be condoned. Delay
cannot be condoned merely because some persons have been granted relief.
MOHIT KUMAR
2026.11.17 15:21
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this order/judgment.
CM-2066-CI-2019 IN/AND RFA-863-2019 (O&M) & connected cases -11-
Condonation of delay in such circumstances is in violation of legislative intent
or the express provision of the statute.
13. In the present appeals, the appellants have not advanced any
plausible explanation for aforesaid inordinate delay of 35-37 years, therefore,
it is difficult for this Court to hold that there is a sufficient cause for delay and
it should be condoned and appellants should be granted enhanced
compensation as granted to villagers of adjoining villages.
14. In the wake of above discussion and findings, applications
seeking condonation of delay in filing the main appeal and consequential
appeals are hereby dismissed.
15. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
(JAGMOHAN BANSAL)
JUDGE
16.11.2026
Mohit Kumar
Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No
Whether reportable Yes/No
MOHIT KUMAR
2026.11.17 15:21
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this order/judgment.