Rajasthan Prime Steel Processing Center Pvt. Ltd. vs Deputy Commissioner Of Income Tax & Anr.
- Court
- Delhi High Court
$~8
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
th
Date of decision: 05 NOVEMBER, 2026
IN THE MATTER OF:
# CNR No. DLHC010098662023
+ ITA 175/2023
RAJASTHAN PRIME STEEL PROCESSING CENTER PVT.
LTD. .....Appellant
Through: Mr. Nageswar Rao, /Mr.
Ravilochan Daliparthi, /Mr.
Pratik Rath, Advocates
versus
DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Ruchir Bhatia, SSC, Mr.
Anant Mann, JSC, Mr.
Pratyaksh Gupta JSC
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBRAMONIUM PRASAD
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE RENU BHATNAGAR
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
1. The present appeal arises out of the order dated 11.11.2021
passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Delhi Bench in
ITA No. 488/Del/2021 for the Assessment Year 2016–17 („ Impugned
Order’ ) as well as the Order dated 30.09.2022 in MA
No.91/Del/2022..
2. The present challenge primarily concerns the action of the
Transfer Pricing Officer (TPO), affirmed by the Dispute Resolution
Panel (DRP) as well as the ITAT in bifurcating the Appellant‟s
Signature Not Verified
ITA 175/2023 Page 1 of 19
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
16:14:51
business into separate manufacturing and trading segments for transfer
pricing benchmarking, instead of considering its business as one
consolidated segment. The Appellant also disputes the manner of
computation of the working capital adjustment and alleges that certain
grounds raised by it before the ITAT were not adjudicated.
3. Shorn of unnecessary details, the facts, in brief, leading to the
present Appeal, are as under:
a. The Appellant, Rajasthan Prime Steel Processing Center
Private Limited was incorporated on 05.10.2007 as a
subsidiary of Honda Trading Corporation, Japan, which
is, in turn, a subsidiary of Honda Motor Co. Ltd., Japan.
It is stated that as on 31.03.2016, Honda Trading
Corporation, Japan holds 49% of the equity share capital
while 30% shares are held by Steel Centre Co. Ltd.,
13.53% by Honda Cars India Limited, 6.04% by Honda
Trading Asia Co. Ltd., Thailand, and 1.42% shares are
held by Honda Trading Corporation India Private
Limited.
b. During the relevant assessment year, i.e. AY 2016–17,
the Appellant was engaged in the business of trading and
processing of steel coils and supplied steel products to
companies of the Honda Group operating in the
automobile, motorcycle and power equipment sectors.
c. On 28.11.2016, the Appellant filed its return of income
declaring a total income of Rs.5,98,50,610/-. During the
Signature Not Verified
ITA 175/2023 Page 2 of 19
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
16:14:51
relevant financial year, the Appellant had entered into
various international transactions with its Associated
Enterprises (AEs), which were duly reported in Form
3CEB. It is stated that as per section 92C under chapter X
of the Income Tax Act, 1961 ( hereinafter referred to as
‘the IT Act’ ), international transactions entered into with
AEs are required to be at arm‟s length price of
international transactions. It is stated that the Appellant
maintained the prescribed transfer pricing documentation
containing details of the functions performed, assets
employed and risks assumed in connection with the
international transactions. It is stated that in its Transfer
Pricing Study, the Appellant adopted the Transactional
Net Margin Method (TNMM) as the most appropriate
method and undertook benchmarking at the entity level,
treating its activities as one consolidated business
segment. According to the Appellant, the same
methodology had been accepted by the Department in the
scrutiny assessments for AYs 2012–13, 2013–14 and
2014–15.
d. It is stated that during the scrutiny assessment
proceedings, the matter was referred to the TPO under
Section 92CA of the IT Act, for determination of the
arm‟s length price of the international transactions. It is
stated that vide order dated 22.10.2019, the TPO rejected
Signature Not Verified
ITA 175/2023 Page 3 of 19
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
16:14:51
the economic analysis undertaken by the Appellant at the
entity level and held that the Appellant was carrying out
two distinct activities, namely, trading and
manufacturing. The TPO accordingly bifurcated the
Appellant‟s business into separate trading and
manufacturing segments, observing that the functional
profile of companies engaged in manufacturing was
different from that of companies engaged in trading and,
therefore, the two segments were required to be
benchmarked separately. It is stated that the TPO
proposed an aggregate upward adjustment of
Rs.41,33,47,300/-, i.e., Rs.17,87,67,833/- in the trading
segment and Rs.23,45,79,467/- in the manufacturing
segment and also denied the benefit of working capital
adjustment to the Appellant.
e. Thereafter, the Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax
passed a draft assessment order dated 04.12.2019,
incorporating the adjustment proposed by the TPO and
proposing to assess the total income of the Appellant at
Rs.47,31,97,910/-.
f. Subsequently, pursuant to an application for rectification
filed by the Appellant under Section 154 of the IT Act
seeking restriction of the transfer pricing adjustment to
international transactions undertaken with AEs, the TPO,
vide order dated 17.12.2019, reduced the adjustment from
Signature Not Verified
ITA 175/2023 Page 4 of 19
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
16:14:51
Rs.41,33,47,300/- to Rs.7,30,07,162/- (i.e.,
Rs.3,14,63,139/- in trading segment and Rs.4,15,44,024/-
in manufacturing segment).
g. Thereafter, the Appellant filed objections before the
Dispute Resolution Panel (DRP) on 03.01.2020, which
passed certain directions on 20.01.2021 upholding the
TPO‟s action of bifurcating the Appellant‟s business into
separate trading and manufacturing segments. However,
the DRP granted the benefit of working capital
adjustment to the Appellant. Insofar as the manufacturing
segment was concerned, the DRP directed certain
changes in the comparable companies, resulting in the
entire adjustment in that segment being deleted.
Consequently, the adjustment in the trading segment was
reduced to Rs.2,50,85,515/-.
h. Pursuant to the directions of the DRP, the National e-
Assessment Centre passed the final assessment order
dated 31.03.2021 under Section 143(3) read with Section
144C(13) of the IT Act, assessing the total income of the
Appellant at Rs.8,49,36,125/- and raising a demand of
Rs.1,45,30,620/-.
i. Aggrieved by the aforesaid assessment order, the
Appellant filed an appeal before the ITAT on 05.05.2021,
being ITA No.488/Del/2021, challenging the rejection of
its entity-level benchmarking and the alleged artificial
Signature Not Verified
ITA 175/2023 Page 5 of 19
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
16:14:51
bifurcation of its business into manufacturing and trading
segments. The Appellant also raised grounds concerning
the principle of consistency, the computation of
segmental margins and the working capital adjustment.
j. Vide the impugned order dated 11.11.2021, the ITAT
partly allowed the appeal of the Appellant. While
upholding the TPO‟s action of separately benchmarking
the manufacturing and trading segments, the ITAT
granted relief to the Appellant by directing the exclusion
of one comparable company, namely SK Pipe Fittings
Pvt. Ltd., from the trading segment and directing that the
SBI Base Rate, instead of SBI Prime Lending Rate
(PLR), be applied for computing the working capital
adjustment. Aggrieved by the findings of the ITAT, the
Appellant filed a Miscellaneous Application dated
18.05.2022 under Section 254(2) of the IT Act, being
M.A. No.91/Del/2022, alleging that the ITAT had failed
to adjudicate Ground No.5 relating to the principle of
consistency, Grounds No.7 and 7.1 concerning the correct
computation of segmental margins and the plea regarding
consideration of all components of working capital while
computing the working capital adjustment. Vide order
dated 30.09.2022, the ITAT dismissed the Miscellaneous
Application filed by the Appellant.
k. The Appellant has therefore filed the present Appeal
Signature Not Verified
ITA 175/2023 Page 6 of 19
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
16:14:51
under Section 260A of the IT Act challenging the orders
dated 11.11.2021 and 30.09.2022, passed by the ITAT.
4. A perusal of the impugned order indicates that while dismissing
the Appeal of the Appellant, the ITAT has noted that the principal
controversy before it concerned the characterisation of the Appellant‟s
business and whether its activities were required to be benchmarked as
a single consolidated business segment or as two distinct segments,
namely, manufacturing and trading. The ITAT recorded that the TPO
had sought segmental data from the Appellant and, upon finding that
the requisite segmental data had not been furnished, the TPO rejected
the entity-wide margins and bifurcated the business into
manufacturing and trading segments. The ITAT had also noted the
Appellant‟s submission that it was essentially engaged in procuring
steel coils from its overseas AEs and supplying them to customers in
India or to its AEs outside India. The ITAT also considered the
submission of the Appellant that in the processing operations, the
Appellant merely undertook limited activities such as slitting,
blanking and welding before reselling the steel products, without
making any substantial value addition and that the Appellant was
principally a distributor of steel products performing minimum value-
added functions and could not be characterised as a manufacturer.
However, the ITAT examined the nature of the processing activities
undertaken by the Appellant and observed that slitting involved
cutting steel coils into strips of specified lengths and widths through
automated machinery equipped with sharp rotary blades and noted that
Signature Not Verified
ITA 175/2023 Page 7 of 19
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
16:14:51
the process required substantial mechanisation, automated machines
and technological infrastructure. The ITAT observed that although
conventional steel manufacturing machinery might not be required for
processing steel coils into sheets, the installation of large automated
machines and other technological requirements for cutting and slitting
the coils into sheets of specified sizes rendered the activity a
manufacturing activity.
5. The ITAT further examined the financial statements of the
Appellant, particularly the details of revenue from operations and the
cost of material consumed. It noted that the Appellant‟s sales
comprised both finished goods and traded goods, with the traded
goods being identified as steel coils. The ITAT also took note of the
revenue of Rs.23.51 crores from the sale of scrap, work-in-progress in
respect of goods under manufacturing, inventories of finished goods at
the beginning and end of the year, excise duty payment of Rs.69.94
crores, consumption of fuel and power amounting to Rs.1.60 crores
and plant and machinery comprising equipment on which depreciation
had been claimed. It further noted that the sale of finished goods
amounted to Rs.548 crores, as against receipts from traded goods
amounting to Rs.117 crores. On the basis of the aforesaid financial
particulars, the ITAT concluded that the Appellant had clearly
identifiable and divisible manufacturing as well as trading segments.
Accordingly, the ITAT affirmed the action of the TPO in undertaking
separate economic analyses of the manufacturing and trading
segments and rejected the Appellant‟s contention that its entire
Signature Not Verified
ITA 175/2023 Page 8 of 19
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
16:14:51
business ought to be benchmarked as one consolidated segment.
6. In the present Appeal, the following substantial question of law
arises for consideration:
A. Whether the ITAT erred in upholding the reclassification
of the Appellant‟s business into manufacturing and
trading segments, disregarding the principle of
consistency and upholding segmentation of the audited
financial statements on an invalid and subjective basis?
7. The principal contention of the Appellant is that the ITAT erred
in upholding the TPO‟s action of bifurcating its business into
manufacturing and trading segments. Learned Counsel for the
Appellant submits that the Appellant is essentially engaged in the
business of trading/value-added distribution of steel coils and that its
processing activities, involving cutting, slitting and blanking, do not
constitute full-fledged manufacturing operations. According to the
Appellant, these activities involve only limited processing without
substantial value addition and, therefore, do not warrant the
characterisation of the Appellant as a manufacturer for transfer pricing
benchmarking. The Appellant contends that the ITAT failed to
appreciate that the raw material procured for both trading and
processing activities is the same, being steel coils purchased from the
AEs. It is further contended that the resources employed in carrying
out the business activities are common, and sales are made to both
related and unrelated parties in respect of both traded and processed
goods. It is, therefore, contended that the two activities are closely
Signature Not Verified
ITA 175/2023 Page 9 of 19
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
16:14:51
linked and cannot be artificially segregated for the purpose of transfer
pricing analysis.
8. Learned Counsel for the Appellant further contends that the
ITAT proceeded merely on the basis of the use of plant and
machinery, payment of excise duty and disclosure of finished goods in
the financial statements, without undertaking the requisite functional,
asset and risk analysis. It is submitted that the nature and complexity
of its processing activities are materially different from those of full-
fledged manufacturing companies selected by the TPO as
comparables. He also submits that the ITAT erroneously relied upon
the payment of excise duty amounting to Rs.69.94 crores,
consumption of fuel and power and the disclosure of finished goods in
the audited financial statements to conclude that the Appellant was
engaged in manufacturing activities. It is contended that the definition
of „manufacture‟ under the Central Excise Act, 1944 cannot be
mechanically imported into the transfer pricing provisions contained
in Chapter X of the IT Act. In this regard, Appellant has placed
reliance on the Judgment rendered by a Co-ordinate Bench of this
Court in Faridabad Iron & Steel Traders Association v. Union of
India, 2004 (178) E.L.T. 1099 (Del.) , wherein it has been held that
cutting and slitting of steel coils into sheets does not amount to
manufacturing.
9. The Appellant further contends that the ITAT failed to consider
that the Department had consistently accepted its entity-level
benchmarking approach in the scrutiny assessments for AYs 2012–13,
Signature Not Verified
ITA 175/2023 Page 10 of 19
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
16:14:51
2013–14 and 2014–15, despite the nature of its business and the
relevant facts remaining unchanged. It is submitted that there was no
change in the functions performed, assets employed, risks assumed or
the applicable legal provisions which could justify a departure from
the approach consistently adopted in the earlier years. It is, therefore,
submitted that the ITAT erred in upholding the segmented
benchmarking approach without assigning any cogent reasons for
departing from the principle of consistency.
10. On the basis of the above submissions of the learned Counsel
for the Appellant, notice in the present Appeal was issued on
24.03.2023 and the Appellant, on 18.09.2023 was directed by this
Court to file an affidavit stating as to whether any excise duty was
paid by the Appellant for the period in issue in its capacity as a
manufacturer, in order to ascertain as to whether the matter can be
remanded back to the Assessing Authority by this Court or not.
11. In compliance with the Order dated 18.09.2023, Appellant has
filed an affidavit. Relevant portions of the said affidavit read as under:
“ 6) I understand that dispute involved in present
appeal ITA is confined to determination of arm’s-
length price as per chapter X (transfer pricing
provisions) of Income Tax Act, in relation to steel
coils imported from associated enterprises during
financial year 2015-2016 (Assessment year 16-
17). In this context, it may be stated that in
addition to import of coils from AE substantial
purchases are made and sold from/to unrelated
parties results of which are reflected in audited
Profit & loss account. Para 9 of Impugned order
Signature Not Verified
ITA 175/2023 Page 11 of 19
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
16:14:51
of Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT or
Tribunal) at pages 47/48 of Appeal set refers to
excise duty, finished goods stock, finished goods
sales etc.,. It may be stated that for first time in
context of assessment/appellate process relating
to Ay 16-17, Tribunal relied on select numbers
from P&L in its order but has grossly
misunderstood the facts. Perhaps lower
authorities (reference is invited to paras 4.8 to
4.11 of DRP order at page 337 and 338 of appeal
set & case set up by transfer pricing officer (TPO)
is at page 214 of appeal set) appreciated the
irrelevance of these numbers in context of
evaluation of arm's length price (ALP) of coils
imported from overseas AE, hence did not feel
necessity to refer to or rely on same.
7) Adjustment to arm’s length price (TP
adjustment) impugned before ITAT i.e., post DRP
directions can be found at page 379 and page 380
of appeal set – Manufacturing segment NIL and
Trading segment INR 2.50 crores. Accordingly,
subject matter of appeal before Tribunal is
confined to this.
8) By reference to records, I state that Transfer
pricing officer's case against appellant vide order
dated 22nd October 2019 (Annexure C to appeal
set at page 211) shows margins of Trading and
manufacturing segments are determined by
bifurcating Profit & loss account on adhoc basis,
de hors records. Ld. TPO carried out fresh
searches for identifying comparable companies.
Reference to pages 216 and 232 shows TPO had
chosen companies which had related party
transactions less than 25%. Rationale stated by
Ld.TPO is 'companies below 25% RPT
Signature Not Verified
ITA 175/2023 Page 12 of 19
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
16:14:51
transaction business .....can be construed to be
market determined" (page 217, 232 of appeal set).
Market determined price is arm’s length price. At
page 376 TPO notes Related party transactions in
petitioner’s case in trading segment is 17.6 %.
Therefore, it should follow from TPO's own logic
that transactions in present case are market
determined / at arm’s length and require no TP
adjustment. Artificial bifurcation of Profit & Loss
on adhoc basis can be noticed at page 214. No
reference is made to Excise duty, finished stock,
etc., as is relied on in impugned ITAT order. For
the first time, ITAT at para 9 of impugned order
refers to these details and without any assistance/
verification draws invalid inference. These
aspects are also elaborated in para 6.14 of appeal
memorandum at pages 24 and 25 of present
appeal.
9) On the basis of inputs that I received from
concerned officials of company, I state that
perhaps due to the line of reasoning adopted by
TPO and DRP, at no stage of Transfer pricing
assessment relating to Ay 16-17, details of Excise
duty, finished goods stock etc., were called for
(or) examined or relied upon by authorities .
Para 9 of impugned ITAT order neither called for
supporting documentation nor made any effort to
appreciate underlying facts. Contemporaneous
Central Excise records and returns evidence that
bulk of imported coils purchased from Associate
enterprise (AE) are only slit, which activity did
not attract central excise duty. Small portion of
very same imported coils purchased from AE are
used for further manufacturing together with
huge quantities of local unrelated party
purchases. This portion suffered Excise duty (23
Signature Not Verified
ITA 175/2023 Page 13 of 19
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
16:14:51
%) reflected in the Profit & loss account. These
details are evident from copies of
contemporaneous Central excise registers etc.,
verified and accepted. These details were never
called for or considered at any stage of
proceedings in relation to this Assessment year.
Understanding of these details is essential to
decide on necessity and scope of segmentation,
most appropriate method and then to determine
ALP . Impugned ITAT order concluded on
presumptions/speculation. In case Tribunal felt
excise duty was to be examined, it could have
called for details. ” (emphasis supplied)
12. The Order sheets indicate that after the filing of the above
affidavit, the Revenue has sought repeated adjournments to obtain
instructions. It is also stated by the learned Counsel appearing for the
Revenue that reply to the affidavit filed by the Appellant has been
filed. However, the same is not on record.
13. Before proceeding ahead, it is necessary to reproduce the
relevant portions of the Order passed by the DRP and the same reads
as under:
“ 4.7 We have considered the submission of the
assessee. We observe that the assessee is not
engaged in the manufacturing of steel by means
of a vertically integrated manufacturing process
from mining of metals/ procuring iron ore as
raw material, converting ore into steel ingots
through Blast Furnace and Steel melting shop.
However, we are also of the view that the
assessee cannot be said to be a low value added
distributor company only .
Signature Not Verified
ITA 175/2023 Page 14 of 19
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
16:14:51
4.8 On perusal of all the details submitted during
the proceedings and as it is available on the
website of the company, we are of the view that
the assessee is not merely a distribution company
but engaged in the processing of imported steel
coils into steel sheets of different sizes/quality by
the process of cutting and slitting which is nothing
but a manufacturing activity with deployment of
plant and machinery, technology and automation
require in manufacturing activity.
4.9 Slitting is a metal manufacturing process
wherein a coil of material, such as aluminum or
steel, is slit into the lengths and widths specified
by the end application. As the material runs
through the machine, the steel rolls are moved
through extremely sharp circular blades, making
the cuts. In order to make the slice, substantial
compressive forces must be applied - and when
the forces exceed the tensile strength of the
material, it slices. The end product is long strips
of material cut to the buyer's specifications.
Slitting steel is, essentially, a manufacturing
process in which coils of steel are cut lengthwise
to create strips of metal that are narrower than
the original in width. This is an automated
process where the master coil is run through a
machine that has very sharp rotary blades, one
upper and one lower, often called "knives." All
such activities need lot of mechanization and
involve automated machines which is akin to
manufacturing activities. Plant and machinery
and other infrastructure required in steel
manufacturing will not be required in the
processing of steel coils into sheets but the
overall installation of large automated machines
and other related technological requirements to
Signature Not Verified
ITA 175/2023 Page 15 of 19
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
16:14:51
cut and slit the large coils into sheets of required
sizes make the whole process a manufacturing
activity. Hence, we held that the assessee is
engaged in the manufacturing activity of
processing steel coils into sheets .
4.10 In view of the above discussion, DRP is also
of the view that assessee is not completely
engaged in the trading activity but dealing in
trading and manufacturing segment both. The
action of the TPO to benchmark the
manufacturing segment and trading segment
separately is therefore upheld.
4.11 Once it is considered that the assessee is
engaged in the manufacturing segment and
trading segment both, comparables selected by
the assessee and TPO and rejected by the TPO in
both segments are required to be seen here. ”
(emphasis supplied)
14. The DRP observed that although the Appellant was not engaged
in the manufacture of steel through a vertically integrated process, it
could not be characterised as merely a low-value-added distributor. It
held that the Appellant‟s activity of processing imported steel coils
into sheets of different sizes and specifications through cutting and
slitting, involving the use of plant and machinery, technology and
automation, constituted a manufacturing activity. Accordingly, the
DRP concluded that the Appellant was engaged in both trading and
manufacturing activities and upheld the TPO‟s decision to benchmark
the two segments separately. Consequently, it proceeded to examine
the comparables selected by the Appellant and the TPO for the
Signature Not Verified
ITA 175/2023 Page 16 of 19
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
16:14:51
respective segments.
15. In the opinion of this Court, the findings in paragraphs No.4.7
& 4.9 of the Order passed by the DRP are contrary to each other. The
DRP has failed to appreciate that the Assessee is purchasing bulk of
imported coils from AE, which is being slit. This activity did not
attract central excise duty, as is evident from the Affidavit filed by the
Assessee/Appellant before this Court, to which Revenue has failed to
file their Reply. It is also stated in the Affidavit that a small portion of
very same imported coils purchased from AE are used for further
manufacturing, together with huge quantities of local unrelated party
purchases. This portion suffered an Excise duty of 23 % reflected in
the Profit & loss account mentioned in the copies of contemporaneous
Central excise registers, etc.. It is pertinent to note that at no stage of
Transfer pricing assessment relating to Assessment Year in question,
details of Excise duty, finished goods stock etc., were called for or
examined or relied upon by the authorities. The DRP also did not take
into account the Judgment passed by the co-ordinate Bench of this
Court in Faridabad Iron & Steel Traders Association (supra).
16. Having considered the submissions advanced on behalf of the
Appellant and the material placed on record, this Court is of the view
that the segregation of the Appellant‟s business into separate
manufacturing and trading segments has not been supported by an
adequate functional analysis. The Appellant‟s business model
remained unchanged and its entity-level benchmarking approach
under the TNMM had been accepted by the Revenue in the scrutiny
Signature Not Verified
ITA 175/2023 Page 17 of 19
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
16:14:51
assessments for AYs 2012–13, 2013–14 and 2014–15. No change in
the facts or circumstances warranting a departure from the consistent
approach has been demonstrated. Further, the mere deployment of
plant and machinery, technology and automation for carrying out
activities such as cutting, slitting and blanking of steel coils cannot, by
itself, justify treating the Appellant as a manufacturer for the purposes
of transfer pricing benchmarking. The decision of the Co-ordinate
Bench of this Court in Faridabad Iron & Steel Traders Association
(supra), also recognises that cutting or slitting of steel sheets does not
amount to manufacture where no new and distinct article emerges
from the process. The impugned findings, therefore, could not have
been sustained without examining the actual functions performed,
assets employed and risks assumed by the Appellant.
17. Further, the ITAT has relied upon certain entries in the profit
and loss account, including excise duty, finished goods stock, power
and fuel consumption and depreciation on plant and machinery,
without undertaking the necessary verification of the underlying
transactions or examining whether such entries were attributable to
manufacturing activity or merely reflected the Appellant‟s processing
and trading operations. The Appellant‟s functional analysis and the
audited segmental data furnished by it were not properly dealt with,
and the ITAT also failed to adjudicate material grounds relating to the
principle of consistency and the arbitrary allocation of income and
expenses between the two segments. In these circumstances, the
Impugned Orders suffer from material infirmities in the determination
Signature Not Verified
ITA 175/2023 Page 18 of 19
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
16:14:51
of the arm‟s-length price.
18. Accordingly, the impugned orders dated 11.11.2021 and
30.09.2022, to the extent challenged in the present appeals, are set
aside and the matter is remanded to the Assessing Officer for fresh
consideration in accordance with law. The Assessing Officer/TPO
shall examine the transfer pricing study furnished by the Assessee, the
objections raised thereto, the nature of its business activities, the
appropriate segmentation, selection of comparables and the
adjustments claimed, after affording the Assessee an effective
opportunity of hearing.
19. All the contentions of the parties are left open to be urged
before the Assessing Officer/TPO, who shall pass a reasoned order
uninfluenced by the observations made hereinabove.
20. The appeals are, accordingly, allowed in the aforesaid terms.
Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
SUBRAMONIUM PRASAD, J
RENU BHATNAGAR, J
NOVEMBER 5, 2026
Rahul
Signature Not Verified
ITA 175/2023 Page 19 of 19
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
Signing Date:19.11.2026
16:14:51