M/S VISHNU PRAKASH R. PUNGLIA LIMITED vs UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
(Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction)
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Krishna Rao
W.P.A. No. 19401 of 2026
M/s Vishnu Prakash R. Punglia Limited.
Vs.
Union of India & Ors.
Mr. Jishnu Choudhury, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Joyjeev Medhi
Mr. Deep Basak
Mr. Subodh Asthana
....For the petitioner.
Mr. Rajarshi Dutta
Mr. Prasun Mukherjee
Mr. Deepak Agarwal
....For the respondent nos. 2 to 9.
Hearing Concluded On : 28.09.2026
Judgment Delivered On : 07.10.2026
Judgment Uploaded On : 07.10.2026
2
Krishna Rao, J.:
1. The petitioner has filed the present writ petition challenging the
th th th
impugned letters dated 7 March, 2026; 28 April, 2026 and 26
June, 2026 as well as any other decision taken or order passed by the
respondents pursuant to the impugned letters including the
rd
consequential email dated 23 July, 2026, seeking recovery of Rs.
6,95,147/-.
2. The Central Procurement Cell of the Bharat Heavy Electricals Limited,
being the respondent no. 3 has issued the Notice Inviting Bids
th
(hereinafter referred to as “NIB”) on 16 December, 2024 in respect of
Civil, Structural & Architectural works of entire Power Block Area (T-
Yard to FGD up to Chimney Raft) Power House, Boiler, ESP, Mill &
Bunker, TG, BFP, Fan Foundations, FGD, TG, CEP, CW pit, ESP
Control Room, Chimney Raft, ID Ducts, Paving Works, Transformer
Yard, CST Pump House, Compressor, DG, MRS, AC & Ventilation
Ducting Labour Hutment for 1000 workers including land leasing,
Rooftop Solar System foundation (Within power block area), Sewage
water line (Within BTG area), Civil work for LP piping & Fire Fighting
(Within BTG area), Pipe rack/cable rack (Within BTG area), CW Duct
Buried (Civil work within powerhouse area), Worker's Rest Room etc.
at 1X800 MW NTPC Sipat Project..
th
3. The petitioner has participated in the bid process and on 5 February,
2025, the respondent no. 2, Bharat Heavy Electricals Limited
3
(hereinafter referred to as “BHEL”) has issued Letter of Award
(hereinafter referred to as “LOA”) in favour of the petitioner for
execution of Civil, Structural & Architectural works of entire Power
Block Area (T-Yard to FGD up to Chimney Raft) Power House, Boiler,
ESP, Mill & Bunker, TG, BFP, Fan Foundations, FGD, TG, CEP, CW
pit, ESP Control Room, Chimney Raft, ID Ducts, Paving Works,
Transformer Yard, CST Pump House, Compressor, DG, MRS, AC &
Ventilation Ducting, Labour Hutment for 1000 workers including land
leasing, Rooftop Solar System foundation, Sewage water line, Civil
work for LP piping & Fire Fighting, Pipe rack/cable rack, CW Duct
Buried, Worker's Rest Room etc. at the 1x800 MW NTPC Sipat Project
(hereinafter referred to as "Project").
After issuance of Letter of Award in favour of the petitioner, a
th
Contract Agreement was also executed between the parties on 18
March, 2025.
th
4. The respondent no. 6 has issued a Contractual Notice dated 29 June,
2026 to the petitioner informing the petitioner that the petitioner failed
to comply with the contractual obligations and directed the petitioner to
rectify/improve the job execution and to complete the relevant targets
within 14 days from the issuance of letter failing which the BHEL may
exercise its right to terminate the contract on the ground of breach of
th
contract. The petitioner has submitted a detailed reply dated 11
February, 2026, explaining that the delays alleged therein were
substantially and directly attributable to the respondents default,
4
including non–availability of work fronts, piecemeal release of drawings,
delayed engineering approvals, pendency of blasting permission and
hard rock conditions and non-release RA Bills.
5. Mr. Jishnu Choudhury, Learned Senior Advocate, representing the
petitioner submits that without considering reply submitted by the
petitioner, without affording any opportunity of hearing and any prior
notice, the respondent no. 6 has issued the first impugned order dated
th
7 March, 2026, invoking Clause 2.7.1 of the GCC proceeded ahead for
descoping the works like Excavation of works at CCR–MPH and balance
civil works of PA, FD Fan and ID Duct Foundation and get it done
through suitable alternatives in the line of the contractual provisions. It
was also informed that all obligations towards payments and other
statutory compliances related to manpower deployment through
alternative sources shall be the responsibility of the petitioner and the
petitioner shall not be entitled for any compensation due to descope of
work.
6. Mr. Choudhury submits that the impugned letter was issued barely six
(6) weeks into the scheduled excavation period and ten (10) months
before the contractual completion milestone when no delay or default
arose. The petitioner has submitted detailed reply to the notice dated
th
7 March, 2026 but inspite of considering reply, the respondents have
th
issued second notice dated 28 April, 2026, informing the petitioner
that the Civil Architectural Works of the Transformer Yard valued of Rs.
1,40,53,229/- was withdrawn under Clause 2.7.2 of the GCC with the
5
reservation of right to recover differential cost plus 5% overheads
through alternative agencies and Civil and Architectural Works of
underground CW Pipe Encasing along A-Row, valued at approximately
Rs. 1,41,43,284/- was withdrawn under Clause 2.7.1 of the GCC,
without recovery, but reserving execution through alternative agencies.
th
7. The respondent no.7 has issued a notice dated 8 June, 2026 to the
petitioner on the allegation of poor progress of work and the respondent
th
no. 6 has issued notice dated 17 June, 2026 by granting 7 days’ time
to improve the work failing which the respondents threatened the
petitioner to terminate the contract on the ground of breach of contract.
th
On 26 June, 2026, the respondents have withdrawn further scope of
work of the petitioner under Clause 2.7.2 of the GCC with respect to TG
Deck and its associated works, Foundation of MPH and CCR building
and final lift of all balance 8 no. Mills and all Fan Foundations valued
at approximately Rs. 9,97,59,037/- with the reservation of the right to
recover differential cost plus an additional 5% overheads through
engagement of alternate agencies.
8. Mr. Choudhury submits that the petitioner again submitted detailed
th
reply to the respondents on 27 June, 2026 but the respondent
authorities have not considered the same. He submits that the contract
includes liquidated damages and other remedies in case of breach of
contract outlined in Clauses 2.7.2.1 to 2.7.2.2 of the GCC but the
respondent no.3 proceeded with cancelling the work order without
adhering to the required 14 days’ notice period, which is deemed
6
rd
violation of the GCC. He submits that by an email dated 23 July,
2026, the respondents sought to recover an amount of Rs. 6,95,147/-
towards the alleged differential cost of the partially withdrawn work at
the petitioner’s risk and cost.
9. Mr. Choudhury submits that despite having initiated a re-tendering
process of the said works, the respondents abandoned the same and
instead awarded the work to a third party agency on a rate contract
basis without any contractual or legal justification.
10. Mr. Rajarshi Dutta, Learned Advocate, representing the respondents
th
submits that on 5 February, 2025, Letter of Award (LOA) was issued
to the petitioner. The contract price for the subject work is
247,55,00,000/-. Time to complete the said work is 28 months from
the date of start of the work.
11. Mr. Dutta submits that as per Clause 2.9 of the General Conditions of
Contract, execution plan, progress monitoring, monthly review and
performance evaluation in Form-14 is to be maintained to ascertain the
monthly progress of work awarded to the petitioner. He submits that
after considering the monthly progress of the work of the petitioner, the
respondents have time to time directed the petitioner to expedite the
work but inspite of direction of the respondents, the petitioner has not
expedited the works awarded which appears in the performance
evaluation form.
7
12. Mr. Dutta submits that the respondents have issued notices to the
petitioner intimating that if the petitioner will expedite the work as per
time provided by the respondents, the respondent will take appropriate
steps in accordance with Clause 2.7.1 but the petitioner failed to do so
and accordingly, the respondents have descope the part work order
awarded to the petitioner.
13. Mr. Dutta has relied upon Section 20A of the Specific Relief Act, 1963
(hereinafter referred to as “Act of 1963”) and submits that the work
awarded to the petitioner is infrastructure project and there is a bar
under the said provision for grant of interim order. He further relied
upon Sub–Section (ha) of Section 41 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 and
submits that as per Schedule Entry-2 of the Act, the work order is of
Power House which is coming under “Energy”.
14. In support of his submissions, Mr. Dutta has relied upon the judgment
in the case of N.G. Projects Limited Vs. Vinod Kumar Jain and
Others reported in (2022) 6 SCC 127 and submits that the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held that the construction of road is an infrastructure
project and keeping in view the intent of the legislature that
infrastructure projects should not be stayed, the High Court would
have been well advised to hold its hand to stay the construction of the
infrastructure project.
15. Mr. Dutta has relied upon the judgment in the case of State of Uttar
Pradesh and Others Vs. Sandeep Kumar Balmiki and Others
8
reported in (2009) 17 SCC 555 and submits that staying the order of
termination could not be passed at the interim stage and if such relief
is granted, it amounts to allow the writ petition without permitting the
parties to place their respective cases at the time of final hearing of the
writ petition.
16. Mr. Dutta has relied upon the judgment in the case of State of Kerala
Vs. M.K. Jose reported in (2015) 9 SCC 433 and submits that the writ
court should ordinarily not entrained a writ petition, if there is a breach
of contract involving disputed questions of fact.
17. Mr. Dutta has handed over the communication made by the petitioner
th
to the respondents dated 9 July, 2026 wherein the petitioner
requested the respondents for exit permission for scaffolding materials
inside the plant premises as the said materials were mobilized for the
execution of the TG Deck and its associated works but the said work
has been withdrawn.
th
18. Mr. Dutta further relied upon the email dated 25 July, 2026 wherein
the petitioner has informed the respondents that substantial portion of
the contract work has been withdrawn due to which construction
materials, equipment and temporary works has become surplus to the
requirements of remaining scope of work and repeatedly requested for
permission for removal of such materials and now after the period of
two months, the petitioner has filed the present writ petition. He
further submits that once the petitioner has admitted the descoping
9
work, the petitioner cannot be permitted to challenge the said
descoping work.
19. Mr. Dutta has filed documents and submits that the work in question
is an infrastructure project and the authority cannot wait such long
th
time and thus the respondents have published a tender notice on 20
January, 2026 with the broad scope of job of framework agreement
(Rate Contract) for execution of balance civil, structure and architecture
works at various project sites of BHEL across India. The said tender
was awarded to one M/s Anand Kumar Singhania. The descoping of
works of the petitioner was also awarded to the M/s Anand Kumar
th th
Singhania by way of Letter of Award dated 4 May, 2026 and 26
June, 2026. The petitioner had the knowledge of the Letter of Award
issued to third party but the petitioner has not made the said firm as
party to the present writ petition, thus the writ petition suffers from
non-joinder of parties. In support of his submission, the petitioner has
relied upon the judgment in the case of U.P. Jal Nigam and Another
Vs. Jaswant Singh and Another reported in (2006) 11 SCC 464 and
submits that the petitioner has admitted the descoping order and
requested to exit its materials which was brought for execution of the
said work and the petitioner also has the knowledge about the
awarding of contract to the third party but the said LOA is not
challenged and the said firm has not made party to the present writ
petition.
20. Scope of the tender work is as follows:
10
“ 1. SCOPE OF WORK :
Civil, Structural & Architectural works of entire
Power Block Area (T-Yard to FGD up to Chimney
Raft) Power House, Boiler, ESP, Mill & Bunker, TG,
BFP, Fan Foundations, FGD, TG, CEP, CW pit, ESP
Control Room, Chimney Raft, ID Ducts, Paving
Works, Transformer Yard, CST Pump House,
Compressor, DG, MRS, AC & Ventilation Ducting,
Labour Hutment for 1000 workers including land
leasing, Rooftop Solar System foundation (Within
power block area), Sewage water line (Within BTG
area), Civil work for LP piping & Fire Fighting
(Within BTG area), Pipe rack/cable rack (Within
BTG area), CW Duct Buried (Civil work within
powerhouse area), Worker's Rest Room etc. at
1x800 MW NTPC Sipat Project, as detailed in
Chapter-II of Technical Conditions of Contract (TCC)
of tender and associated corrigenda.”
21. The petitioner has disclosed the reply submitted by the petitioner to the
th th
respondents dated 7 July, 2025 and 10 July, 2025 with reference to
several letters of the respondents but the petitioner has not disclosed
the letters received by the petitioner from the respondents. The reply
submitted by the petitioner reveals that the petitioner tried to satisfy
the respondents that the petitioner is putting its best efforts to achieve
the progress to complete the project in given time.
th
22. The respondents have issued a letter dated 12 July, 2025 to the
petitioner by referring several reference numbers of the letters issued
by BHEL to the petitioner and in the said letter, the BHEL has given
actual status of the project work awarded to the petitioner. By the said
letter, the respondents have categorically informed the petitioner that if
the petitioner fails to meet the contractual commitments despite giving
11
repeated timelines, the respondents will take appropriate action against
the petitioner in terms of the General Conditions of Contract.
23. Clause 2.7 provides the Rights of BHEL which reads as follows:
“2.7 RIGHTS OF BHEL
BHEL reserves the following rights in respect of this
contract during the original contract period or its
extensions if any, as per the provisions of the
contract, without entitling the contractor for any
compensation.
27.1 To withdraw any portion of work and/or to
restrict/alter quantum of work as indicated in the
contract during the progress of work and get it
done through other agencies to fulfill BHEL's
commitment to its customer or the date of
completion is advance due to other emergent
reasons/ BHEL'S obligation to its customer.
Where the contractor fails to deploy adequate
manpower to meet the contractual target, BHEL
reserves the right to deploy manpower to meet such
shortfall, through any other agency for expediting
activities in the interest of the project. Supplied
manpower shall be put on job by the contractor.
Fulfilling of all obligations towards payments and
other statutory compliances related to manpower
shall be the contractor's responsibility. In case of
contractor's failure to fulfill his obligations in
respect of such manpower, BHEL shall be entitled
to take action as provided herein.”
24. Breach of Contract, Remedies and Termination provided under Clause
2.7.2 which reads as follows:
“ 2.7.2 Breach of Contract, Remedies and
Termination
2.7.2.1 The following shall amount to breach of
contract:
I. Non-supply of material/ non-completion of
work by the Supplier/Vendor within scheduled
12
delivery/ completion period as per contract or as
extended from time to time.
II. The Supplier/Vendor fails to perform as per
the activity schedule and there are sufficient
reasons even before expiry of the delivery/
completion period to justify that supplies shall be
inordinately delayed beyond contractual
delivery/ completion period.
III. The Supplier/Vendor delivers equipment/
material not of the contracted quality.
IV. The Supplier/Vendor fails to replace the
defective equipment/ material/ component as
per guarantee clause.
V. Withdrawal from or abandonment of the work
by the Supplier/Vendor before completion as per
contract
VI. Assignment, transfer, subletting of Contract
by the Supplier/Vendor without BHEL's written
permission resulting in termination of Contract or
part thereof by BHEL.
VII. Non-compliance to any contractual condition
or any other default attributable to Supplier/
Vendor.
VIII. Any other reason(s) attributable to Vendor
towards failure of performance of contract. In
case of breach of contract, BHEL shall have the
right to terminate the Purchase Order/ Contract
either in whole or in part thereof without any
compensation to the Supplier/Vendor.
IX. Any of the declarations furnished by the
contractor at the time of bidding and/or entering
into the contract for supply are found untruthful
and such declarations were of a nature that
could have resulted in non-award contract to the
contractor or could expose BHEL and/or Owner
to adverse consequences, financial or otherwise.
X. Supplier/Vendor is convicted of any offence
involving corrupt business practices, antinational
activities or any such offence that compromises
the business ethics of BHEL, in violation of the
13
Integrity Pact entered into with BHEL has the
potential to harm the overall business of BHEL/
Owner.
Note
i. Once BHEL considers that a breach of
contract has occurred on the part of
Supplier/Vendor, BHEL shall notify the
Supplier/Vendor by way of notice in this
regard. Contractor shall be given an
opportunity to rectify the reasons causing
the breach of contract within a period of 14
days.
ii. In case the contractor fails to remedy the
breach, as mentioned in the notice, to the
satisfaction of BHEL, BHEL shall have the
right to take recourse to any of the remedial
actions available to it under the relevant
provisions of contract.
LD against delay in executed work in case of
Termination of Contract:
LD against delay in executed work shall be
calculated in line with LD clause no. 2.7.9 of GCC,
for the delay attributable to contractor. For limiting
the maximum value of LD, contract value shall be
taken as Executed Value of work till termination of
contract.
Method for calculation of "LD against delay in
executed work in case of termination of contract" is
given below.
i). Let the time period from scheduled date of
start of work till termination of contract
excluding the period of Hold (if any) not
attributable to contractor = T1
ii). Let the value of executed work till the time
of termination of contract= X
iii). Let the Total Executable Value of work for
which inputs/fronts were made available to
contractor and were planned for execution till
termination of contract = Y
14
iv). Delay in executed work attributable to
contractor i.e. T2=[1-(X/Y)] x T1
v). LD shall be calculated in line with LD
clause (clause 2.7.9) of the Contract for the
delay attributable to contractor taking "X" as
Contract Value and "T2" as period of delay
attributable to contractor.
2.7.2.2. []. ” *
th
25. On 29 January, 2026, the respondents have issued notice to the
petitioner informing the petitioner that the petitioner failed to comply
with the contractual obligations and has committed breach of contract.
The respondents have given an opportunity to the petitioner to rectify
and improve the job execution and complete/ achieve the relevant
target within 14 days from the date of receipt of the notice failing which
the BHEL will exercise its rights to terminate the contract on the
ground of breach of contract. In the notice, the BHEL has also annexed
the details of the work which the petitioner was required to complete
but the petitioner failed to comply with the same and accordingly, the
th
respondents have issued the impugned order dated 7 March, 2026 by
descoping the critical works like Excavation works at CCR-MPH and
balance work of PA, FD Fan and ID duct foundation and decided to get
the said work done through the suitable alternatives in terms of the
th
contractual provisions. Similarly by an order dated 28 April, 2026 and
th
on 26 June, 2026, further part works have been descoped.
15
26. Clause 2.9 of the GCC provides for Execution Plan, Progress
Monitoring, Monthly Review and Performance Evaluation, which reads
as follows:
“2.9 EXECUTION PLAN, PROGRESS
MONITORING, MONTHLY REVIEW AND
PERFORMANCE EVALUATION
2.9.1 A tentative plan/ programme for completion
of the contractual scope of work as per the time
schedule given in the contract shall be made jointly
by BHEL and Contractor, before commencement of
work. The above programme shall be supported by
month wise deployment of resources viz Manpower,
T&P, Consumables, etc. Progress will be reviewed
periodically (Daily/Weekly/Monthly) vis-à-vis this
jointly agreed programme.
Subsequently, every month, quarterly rolling plan
will be made by BHEL based on budgeted targets.
Monthly plan in F-14 format shall be drawn from
this Quarterly plan. Monthly plan shall necessarily
include activities required for achieving targets/
milestones unless inputs/ fronts are not available.
While planning and arriving on asking rate all
available inputs shall be taken into consideration.
Vendor will be required to execute the monthly plan
in that month in addition to make full efforts to
minimize the cumulative shortfall attributable to
him up to the month.
BHEL may require monthly work plan up to one
and half times of average monthly value and
demand matching manpower.
Where, Average Monthly Value Total Contract
Value (as per latest revision)/ Period of Contract (in
months)
Provided, this requirement is reflected in the rolling
quarterly plan two months in advance.
If the Contractor refuses to sign the F-14 format,
those F-14 formats requiring Contractor's signature
shall be deemed to have been signed and accepted
16
by the Contractor, if communicated to the
Contractor through email or any other mode as
stated in clause 2.3.1.
The Contractor shall submit periodical progress
reports (Daily/Weekly/Monthly) and other reports/
information including manpower, consumables,
T&P mobilization etc. as desired by BHEL.
2.9.2 Monthly progress review between BHEL and
Contractor shall be based on the agreed
programme as above, availability of inputs/fronts
etc., and constraints if any, as per prescribed
formats (i.e. Form F-14). Manpower, T&P and
consumable reports as per prescribed formats shall
be submitted by contractor every month. Release of
RA Bills shall be contingent upon certification by
BHEL Site Engineer of the availability of the above
prescribed formats duly filled in and signed
2.9.3 The burden of proof that the causes leading
to any shortfall is not due to any reasons
attributable to the contractor is on the contractor
himself. The monthly progress review shall record
shortfalls attributable to (i) Contractor, (ii) Force
Majeure Conditions, and (iii) BHEL
2.9.4 Performance of the Contractor shall be
assessed as per prescribed formats and shall form
the basis for Assessment of Capacity of Bidder for
Tenders where the Contractor is a bidder. BHEL
reserves the right to revise the evaluation formats
during the course of execution of the works.”
27. The petitioner has disclosed charts / table with respect to monthly plan
and review in compliance with Clause 2.9 of the GCC wherein it reveals
that cumulative shortfall attributable to the contractor and the
petitioner has not raised any objection to the said monthly plan. On
th
receipt of the impugned orders, the petitioner by a letter dated 9 July,
2026, requested the respondents for permission for scaffolding
materials inside plant premises. In the said letter, the petitioner has
17
categorically stated that as the partial scope of work has been
withdrawn, the scaffolding materials are no longer required at the site
and the petitioner requested to grant exit permission to take out its
th
materials out from the work site. Subsequent to the letter date 9 July,
2026, the petitioner has again sent an email to the respondents
requesting for necessary approval, gate passes and all requisite
clearances for immediate removal of surplus materials and equipment
from the project site.
28. The petitioner in one hand accepted the descoping order and is ready
and willing to take out its materials out from the work site and on the
other hand, the petitioner has filed the present writ petition. The
petitioner has also admitted in the writ petition that the respondents
have awarded the work to a third party on a rate contract basis without
any contractual or legal justification but the petitioner has neither
made the third party as respondent in the present writ petition nor the
said work order issued to the third party is challenged. The
respondents during hearing of the case, have produced two work orders
issued in favour of the third party with respect to the work which is
descoped from the work awarded to the petitioner but even after receipt
of the work order issued in favour of the third party, the petitioner has
not taken any steps to challenge the same.
29. This Court finds that after issuance of orders of descoping, the
petitioner has accepted the said orders and requested the respondents
to grant permission to take out its materials from the project site. The
18
respondents have also issued work orders of descoping work to M/s
Anand Kumar Singhania. The petitioner has not challenged the said
orders and also not made M/s Anand Kumar Singhania as party to the
present writ petition inspite of having knowledge that the descoping
work of the petitioner is awarded to the third party.
30. Considering the above, this Court did not find any illegality in the
impugned orders and the order does not require any interference. WPA
No. 19401 of 2026 is thus dismissed .
Parties shall be entitled to act on the basis of a server copy of the
Judgment placed on the official website of the Court.
Urgent Xerox certified photocopies of this judgment, if applied for,
be given to the parties upon compliance of the requisite formalities.
(Krishna Rao, J.)