Mahendra Ram vs The State of Bihar,
- Court
- Patna High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.15451 of 2024
======================================================
Mahendra Ram Son of Late Ganauri Ram Resident of Village- Pipra Makhra,
P.O.- Jai Govind Nagar, P.S.- Jamhor, District- Aurangabad, State Bihar, Pin
Code- 824124, Correspondence Address Mohalla- Kamranganj, Ward No. 39,
Land No. 03, P.O.- Manikpur, P.S.- Dehri-on-Sone, District- Rohtas, State-
Bihar, Pin Code- 821305.
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1. The State of Bihar, through the Additional Chief Secretary, Department of
Cabinet Secretariat, Government of Bihar, Patna.
2. The Chief Secretary, Department of Cabinet Secretariat, Government of
Bihar, Patna.
3. The Additional Chief Secretary cum Principal Secretary, Department of
Water Resources, Government of Bihar, Patna.
4. The Principal Secretary, Department of Finance, Government of Bihar,
Patna.
5. The Additional Secretary, Department of Water Resources, Government of
Bihar, Patna.
6. The District Magistrate, Rohtas.
7. The District Magistrate, Lakhisarai.
8. The Joint Secretary, Department of Water Resources, Government of Bihar,
Patna.
9. The Joint Secretary (Engineering) cum Conducting Officer, Department of
Water Resources, Government of Bihar, Patna.
10. The Deputy Secretary, Management-1, Department of Water Resources,
Government of Bihar, Patna.
11. The Engineer-in-Chief, Irrigation Creation, Department of Water Resources,
Government of Bihar, Patna.
12. The Director (Chief Engineer), Institute of Water and Land Management,
Walmi, Patna.
13. The Superintending Engineer, Command Area, Development Circle, Sone
Bhawan, Patna.
Patna High Court CWJC No.15451 of 2024 dt.24-09-2026
2/16
14. The Executive Engineer, Command Area, Development Division, Lakhisarai
at present Shifted- The Executive Engineer, Command Area Development
Division, Khagaul, Patna.
15. The Under Secretary of Government, Water Resources Department, Bihar,
Patna.
16. The District Treasury Officer, Rohtas.
17. The District Treasury Officer, Lakhisarai.
18. The Accountant General, Bihar, Patna, Mahalekhakar Bhawan, Veerchand
Patel Path, Patna-800001.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Petitioner/s : Mr. Deepak Kishore, Advocate
For the Respondent/s : Mr. Shiv Pratap, Advocate
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PURNENDU SINGH
ORAL JUDGMENT
Date : 24-09-2026
Heard learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioner and learned counsel for the respondents.
2. The petitioner in paragraph no. 1 of the present writ
petition has sought, inter alia, the following relief(s), which is
reproduced hereinafter:-
"(I) Issuance of an appropriate writ/writs,
order/orders, direction/directions to provide Gratuity,
pension, commutation, leave encashment of 300 days, 10%
deducted pension amount/full pension (100%) under the
Head of Retirement Benefits as well as other consequential
financial benefits of service period for which the petitioner
is entitled after the retirement from the service worked as
Sub-Divisional Officer (Assistant Engineer) Command Area
Development Sub-Division-01, Lakhisarai, Department of
Water Resources, Government of Bihar in favour of
plaintiff.
(II) For a further direction on the respondents
due to the negligence of the respondents, Gratuity, Pension,
commutation, leave encashment of 300 days and 10%
deducted pension amount under the head of retirement
benefits as well as other concerning benefits of retirement,
Patna High Court CWJC No.15451 of 2024 dt.24-09-2026
3/16
even after more than 04 years, of petitioner's retirement has
not been paid/ consider till the date in favour of petitioner.
So gratuity, leave encashment of 300 days, pension
commutation as well as other consequential benefits of
retirement should be paid along with interest.
(III) And other relief or reliefs be also granted
to the petitioner for which they may be found entitled too."
3. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioner submitted that in garb of allegation that the petitioner,
who had retired on 30.04.2020 from the post of Assistant
Engineer, Department of Water Resources, had illegally
withdrawn a sum of Rs. 48,000/-, the respondents have not paid
the retirement benefits to the petitioner under different heads.
The petitioner has been acquitted from the charge of illegal
withdrawal of government money so retirement benefits should
not be held up under the Rule 43(c) and 43(d) of Bihar Pension
Rules., but due to negligence of the respondents, retirement
benefits of the petitioner has been held up without any further
departmental proceeding or any departmental order, whereas, it
has been five years since the petitioner had retired from the
service. Since the petitioner has been acquitted from the charge
of illegal withdrawal of government money, full pension should
be sanctioned in favour of petitioner, but due to negligence of
the respondents, only 90% provisional pension was sanctioned
in favour of petitioner and rest retirement benefits are pending
Patna High Court CWJC No.15451 of 2024 dt.24-09-2026
4/16
till date. He further submitted that the General Administration
Department has issued a circular contained in Letter No. 3/M-
09/2018 G.A. 894/Patna dated 17.01.2020 and as per the
circular, a decision on the Enquiry Report will be taken as soon
as possible or within the prescribed period by the competent
authority under Rule- 18 of Bihar CCA Rules 2005, however, in
spite of said statutory circular, due to negligence on the part of
the respondents, after lapse of more than five years of the
Enquiry Report and the petitioner's retirement, the competent
authority has not passed a final order under Rule 18 of Bihar
C.C.A. Rule 2005, so consequently, the Retirement Benefits
(10% pension, full gratuity, full leave encashment) are still
pending. Learned counsel further submitted that the disciplinary
proceeding, which was initiated against the petitioner on
15.04.2019 is pending for nearly seven years and the same will
not come in way once the enquiry officer, based on the
evidences, in respect of charge no. 1 regarding illegal
withdrawal of Rs. 48,000/- from the Bank of India, Lakhisarai
Branch, has concluded that the said amount was illegally
withdrawn by one Dhananjay Kumar, Account Clerk, who was
dismissed from service for the said charge.
4. Per contra , learned counsel appearing on behalf of
Patna High Court CWJC No.15451 of 2024 dt.24-09-2026
5/16
the State submitted that the respondents are justified in
withholding the gratuity in view of the mandate of law
contained in Rule 43(d) of the Bihar Pension Rules. Learned
counsel referring to the counter affidavit, submitted that the
petitioner was initially appointed as Junior Engineer in the
Water Resources Department on 20.01.1987 and was thereafter
promoted to the post of Assistant Engineer in the year 1997. He
ultimately superannuated from service on 30.04.2020 and prior
to his retirement, a departmental proceeding was initiated
against him vide Resolution contained in Memo No.770 dated
15.04.2019 in relation to the allegation of illegal withdrawal of
Government money and non-compliance with the provisions of
the Bihar Financial Rules. Since the departmental proceeding
was pending on the date of his retirement, the petitioner was
sanctioned 90% provisional pension vide Letter No.2972 dated
29.09.2020 in terms of Rule 43(C) of the Bihar Pension Rules,
although the allegation of illegal withdrawal of Government
money has not been substantiated against the petitioner, the
Conducting Officer found that the petitioner had failed to
comply with the relevant provisions of the Bihar Financial
Rules during his tenure and, to that extent, the allegation was
held to be proved. He further submitted that the departmental
Patna High Court CWJC No.15451 of 2024 dt.24-09-2026
6/16
proceeding has not attained finality and a proposal for
imposition of punishment under Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension
Rules, namely, reduction of pension by 5% for a period of one
year, has been forwarded to the Bihar Public Service
Commission for consultation vide Memo No.648 dated
24.04.2026 and the petitioner cannot be treated as having been
completely exonerated from the departmental proceeding and
that, upon receipt of the opinion of the Bihar Public Service
Commission and final conclusion of the departmental
proceeding, the admissible retiral benefits shall be released to
the petitioner in accordance with law.
5. Heard the parties.
6. Short question, which arises for consideration is
whether the petitioner is entitled for reitral dues, which have not
been paid due to pendency of a Departmental Proceeding for
nearly 7 years?
7. The issue regarding prolonged pendency of
departmental proceedings came up for consideration before the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of P.V. Mahadevan v.
Managing Director, T.N. Housing Board , reported in (2005) 6
SCC 636 , wherein the Apex Court, taking into consideration its
earlier judgment passed in the case of State of A.P. v. N.
Patna High Court CWJC No.15451 of 2024 dt.24-09-2026
7/16
Radhakishan , reported in (1998) 4 SCC 154 , has observed that
it is settled that there cannot be any predetermined principle
applicable to every case of delay in concluding disciplinary
proceedings, and each case has to be examined on its own facts
and circumstances. However, where the delay is abnormal and
remains unexplained, the Court is required to consider the
prejudice caused to the delinquent employee and whether the
delay is attributable to him. Though disciplinary proceedings
should ordinarily be allowed to take their course in accordance
with law, an unexplained and prolonged delay may cause
serious prejudice to the delinquent employee. The Court,
therefore, has to balance the competing considerations while
determining whether the disciplinary proceeding should be
permitted to continue. The relevant paragraph of the P.V.
Mahadevan (Supra) is inter alia reproduced as under:
"5. In the second case of N. Radhakishan
[(1998) 4 SCC 154 : 1998 SCC (L&S) 1044] the respondent
was appointed as Assistant Director of Town Planning in
the year 1976. A report dated 7-11-1987 was sent by the
Director General, Anti-Corruption Bureau, Andhra
Pradesh, Hyderabad to the Secretary to the Government,
Housing, Municipal Administration and Urban
Development Department, Andhra Pradesh, Hyderabad
about the irregularities in deviations and unauthorised
constructions in multi-storeyed complexes in the twin cities
of Hyderabad and Secunderabad in collusion with
Municipal Authorities. On the basis of the report, the State
issued two memos both dated 12-12-1987 in respect of three
officials including the respondent Radhakishan, the then
Assistant City Planner. In this case, till 31-7-1995 the
articles of charges had not been served on the respondent.
The Tribunal, however, held that the memo dated 31-7-1995
Patna High Court CWJC No.15451 of 2024 dt.24-09-2026
8/16
related to incidents that happened ten years or more prior
to the date of the memo and that there was absolutely no
explanation by the Government for this inordinate delay in
framing the charges and conducting the enquiry against the
respondent and that there was no justification on the part of
the State now conducting the enquiry against the
respondent in respect of the incidents at this late stage. This
Court, in para 19, has observed as follows: (SCC p. 165)
“19. It is not possible to lay down any
predetermined principles applicable to all cases and in all
situations where there is delay in concluding the
disciplinary proceedings. Whether on that ground the
disciplinary proceedings are to be terminated each case has
to be examined on the facts and circumstances in that case.
The essence of the matter is that the court has to take into
consideration all the relevant factors and to balance and
weigh them to determine if it is in the interest of clean and
honest administration that the disciplinary proceedings
should be allowed to terminate after delay particularly
when the delay is abnormal and there is no explanation for
the delay. The delinquent employee has a right that
disciplinary proceedings against him are concluded
expeditiously and he is not made to undergo mental agony
and also monetary loss when these are unnecessarily
prolonged without any fault on his part in delaying the
proceedings. In considering whether the delay has vitiated
the disciplinary proceedings the court has to consider the
nature of charge, its complexity and on what account the
delay has occurred. If the delay is unexplained prejudice
to the delinquent employee is writ large on the face of it. It
could also be seen as to how much the disciplinary
authority is serious in pursuing the charges against its
employee. It is the basic principle of administrative justice
that an officer entrusted with a particular job has to
perform his duties honestly, efficiently and in accordance
with the rules . If he deviates from this path he is to suffer a
penalty prescribed. Normally, disciplinary proceedings
should be allowed to take their course as per relevant rules
but then delay defeats justice. Delay causes prejudice to the
charged officer unless it can be shown that he is to blame
for the delay or when there is proper explanation for the
delay in conducting the disciplinary proceedings.
Ultimately, the court is to balance these two diverse
considerations.”
This Court held that there was hardly any
explanation worth consideration as to why the delay
occurred. In the circumstances, this Court held that the
Tribunal was justified in quashing the charge memo dated
31-7-1995 and directing the State to promote the
respondent as per recommendation of the DPC ignoring
memos dated 27-10-1995 and 1-6-1996. Accordingly, the
appeal filed by the State of Andhra Pradesh was dismissed."
Patna High Court CWJC No.15451 of 2024 dt.24-09-2026
9/16
8. Based on above consideration, the Apex Court held
in Para-11 as under:
“ 11. Under the circumstances, we are of the
opinion that allowing the respondent to proceed further
with the departmental proceedings at this distance of time
will be very prejudicial to the appellant. Keeping a higher
government official under charges of corruption and
disputed integrity would cause unbearable mental agony
and distress to the officer concerned. The protracted
disciplinary enquiry against a government employee
should, therefore, be avoided not only in the interests of the
government employee but in public interest and also in the
interests of inspiring confidence in the minds of the
government employees. At this stage, it is necessary to draw
the curtain and to put an end to the enquiry. The appellant
had already suffered enough and more on account of the
disciplinary proceedings. As a matter of fact, the mental
agony and sufferings of the appellant due to the protracted
disciplinary proceedings would be much more than the
punishment. For the mistakes committed by the department
in the procedure for initiating the disciplinary proceedings,
the appellant should not be made to suffer”
9. In the present case, the departmental proceeding
was initiated against the petitioner on 15.04.2019, whereas the
petitioner superannuated on 30.04.2020. The enquiry report was
submitted, but admittedly no final order has yet been passed by
the competent disciplinary authority. The respondents have
stated that a proposal for imposition of punishment under Rule
43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules has been forwarded to the
Bihar Public Service Commission for consultation vide Memo
No.648 dated 24.04.2026. Thus, the departmental proceeding
has remained inconclusive for nearly seven years from the date
Patna High Court CWJC No.15451 of 2024 dt.24-09-2026
10/16
of its initiation. The petitioner has, during this entire period,
been paid only 90% provisional pension and the other retiral
dues have remained withheld.
10 . The Apex Court , while examining the scope of
Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules, 1950 in the case of Dr.
Hira Lal v. State of Bihar & Ors. , reported in AIR 2020 SC
1027 held that the said provision empowers the State
Government to withhold or withdraw pension when the
pensioner is found guilty of grave misconduct or is found to
have caused pecuniary loss to the Government by misconduct or
negligence, but Rule 43(b) by itself does not authorise
withholding of pension merely because a departmental or
judicial proceeding is pending. The Apex Court further held that
pension and gratuity constitute rights protected under Article
300-A of the Constitution and cannot be withheld on the basis of
executive instructions in the absence of statutory authority. The
relevant paragraph of the aforesaid judgment is inter alia as
under
22. It is well settled that the right to
pension cannot be taken away by a mere executive
fiat or administrative instruction. Pension and
gratuity are not mere bounties, or given out of
generosity by the employer. An employee earns these
benefits by virtue of his long, continuous, faithful
and unblemished service. [State of Jharkhand v.
Jitendra Kumar Srivastava, (2013) 12 SCC 210 :
(2014) 1 SCC (Civ) 315 : (2014) 2 SCC (L&S) 570]
The right to receive pension of a public servant has
Patna High Court CWJC No.15451 of 2024 dt.24-09-2026
11/16
been held to be covered under the “right to
property” under Article 31(1) of the Constitution by
a Constitution Bench of this Court in Deokinandan
Prasad v. State of Bihar [Deokinandan Prasad v.
State of Bihar, (1971) 2 SCC 330 : 1971 Supp SCR
634] , which ruled that : (Deokinandan Prasad case
[Deokinandan Prasad v. State of Bihar, (1971) 2
SCC 330 : 1971 Supp SCR 634] , SCC pp. 343-44,
paras 30-31 & 33)
“30. The question whether the pension
granted to a public servant is property attracting
Article 31(1) came up for consideration before the
Punjab High Court in Bhagwant Singh v. Union of
India [Bhagwant Singh v. Union of India, 1962 SCC
OnLine P&H 27 : AIR 1962 P&H 503] . It was held
that such a right constitutes “property” and any
interference will be a breach of Article 31(1) of the
Constitution. It was further held that the State
cannot by an executive order curtail or abolish
altogether the right of the public servant to receive
pension. This decision was given by a learned
Single Judge. This decision was taken up in letters
patent appeal by the Union of India. Letters Patent
Bench in its decision in Union of India v. Bhagwant
Singh [Union of India v. Bhagwant Singh, 1964 SCC
OnLine P&H 275 : ILR (1965) 2 P&H 1] approved
the decision of the learned Single Judge. The Letters
Patent Bench held that the pension granted to a
public servant on his retirement is “property”
within the meaning of Article 31(1) of the
Constitution and he could be deprived of the same
only by an authority of law and that pension does
not cease to be property on the mere denial or
cancellation of it. It was further held that the
character of pension as “property” cannot possibly
undergo such mutation at the whim of a particular
person or authority.
31. The matter again came up before a
Full Bench of the Punjab and Haryana High Court
in K.R. Erry v. State of Punjab [K.R. Erry v. State of
Punjab, 1966 SCC OnLine P&H 255 : ILR (1967) 1
P&H 278] . The High Court had to consider the
nature of the right of an officer to get pension. The
majority quoted with approval the principles laid
down in the two earlier decisions [Bhagwant Singh
v. Union of India, 1962 SCC OnLine P&H 27 : AIR
,
1962 P&H 503] [Union of India v. Bhagwant
Singh, 1964 SCC OnLine P&H 275 : ILR (1965) 2
P&H 1] of the same High Court, referred to above,
and held that the pension is not to be treated as a
bounty payable on the sweet will and pleasure of the
Government and that the right to superannuation
Patna High Court CWJC No.15451 of 2024 dt.24-09-2026
12/16
pension including its amount is a valuable right
vesting in a government servant. It was further held
by the majority that even though an opportunity had
already been afforded to the officer on an earlier
occasion for showing cause against the imposition
of penalty for lapse or misconduct on his part and
he has been found guilty, nevertheless, when a cut is
sought to be imposed in the quantum of pension
payable to an officer on the basis of misconduct
already proved against him, a further opportunity to
show cause in that regard must be given to the
officer. This view regarding the giving of further
opportunity was expressed by the learned Judges on
the basis of the relevant Punjab Civil Service Rules.
But the learned Chief Justice in his dissenting
judgment was not prepared to agree with the
majority that under such circumstances a further
opportunity should be given to an officer when a
reduction in the amount of pension payable is made
by the State. It is not necessary for us in the case on
hand to consider the question whether before taking
action by way of reducing or denying the pension on
the basis of disciplinary action already taken, a
further notice to show cause should be given to an
officer. That question does not arise for
consideration before us. Nor are we concerned with
the further question regarding the procedure, if any,
to be adopted by the authorities before reducing or
withholding the pension for the first time after the
retirement of an officer. Hence, we express no
opinion regarding the views expressed by the
majority and the minority Judges in the above
Punjab High Court decision on this aspect. But we
agree with the view of the majority when it has
approved its earlier decision that pension is not a
bounty payable on the sweet will and pleasure of the
Government and that, on the other hand, the right to
pension is a valuable right vesting in a government
servant.
33. Having due regard to the above
decisions, we are of the opinion that the right of the
petitioner to receive pension is property under
Article 31(1) and by a mere executive order the
State had no power to withhold the same. Similarly,
the said claim is also property under Article 19(1)(f)
and it is not saved by clause (5) of Article 19.
Therefore, it follows that the order, dated 12-6-1968,
denying the petitioner right to receive pension
affects the fundamental right of the petitioner under
Articles 19(1)(f) and 31(1) of the Constitution, and
as such the writ petition under Article 32 is
maintainable.”
Patna High Court CWJC No.15451 of 2024 dt.24-09-2026
13/16
(emphasis supplied)
11. The Apex Court in the case of D. S. Nakara &
Ors. Vs. Union of India, reported in (1983) 1 SCC 305 has held
that pension is not a bounty rather property as defined under
Article 300A of the Constitution and the same is required to be
paid, expeditiously.
31. From the discussion three things emerge: (i)
that pension is neither a bounty nor a matter of grace
depending upon the sweet will of the employer and that it
creates a vested right subject to 1972 Rules which are
statutory in character because they are enacted in exercise
of powers conferred by the proviso to Article 309 and
clause (5) of Article 148 of the Constitution; (ii) that the
pension is not an ex gratia payment but it is a payment for
the past service rendered; and (iii) it is a social welfare
measure rendering socio-economic justice to those who in
the hey-day of their life ceaselessly toiled for the employer
on an assurance that in their old age they would not be left
in lurch. It must also be noticed that the quantum of pension
is a certain percentage correlated to the average
emoluments drawn during last three years of service
reduced to 10 months under liberalised pension scheme. Its
payment is dependent upon an additional condition of
impeccable behaviour even subsequent to retirement, that
is, since the cessation of the contract of service and that it
can be reduced or withdrawn as a disciplinary measure.
12. This Court in case of Akhilesh Prasad v. State of
Bihar & Ors. , CWJC No.9957 of 2023, while considering the
withholding of pension, gratuity and leave encashment, has held
that the power under Rule 43(a) and 43(b) of the Bihar Pension
Rules, 1950 has to be exercised in accordance with the statutory
conditions contained therein. This Court further relying upon
Bajrang Deo Narain Sinha v. State of Bihar , L.P.A. No.124 of
Patna High Court CWJC No.15451 of 2024 dt.24-09-2026
14/16
1999, further observed that pensionary dues including gratuity
cannot be withheld merely on account of pendency of a
proceeding until an order is passed in accordance with Rule
43(b), and that leave encashment also cannot be withheld
merely by invoking the said provision.
13. It the facts of the present case, it is admitted that
the enquiry officer has already returned his findings in respect
of the charge relating to illegal withdrawal of Rs.48,000/-. As
the enquiry officer found that the said amount had been illegally
withdrawn by Dhananjay Kumar, Account Clerk, who was
subsequently dismissed from service. At the same time, the
State submits that the petitioner was found to have failed to
comply with certain provisions of the Bihar Financial Rules and,
on that basis, a proposal for punishment has been forwarded for
consultation. Thus, the enquiry report cannot, by itself, be
treated as a final adjudication of guilt or as a final order
imposing punishment under Rule 43(b) of Bihar pension Rules,
1950.
14. In view of the conclusion arrived at by the
Enquiry Officer, on the basis of the evidence on record, whereby
he has found charge no.1 relating to the alleged illegal
withdrawal of Rs.48,000/- having not been proved against the
Patna High Court CWJC No.15451 of 2024 dt.24-09-2026
15/16
petitioner, he cannot be deprived of the benefit of his retiral dues
in light of the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the case of D.S. Nakara (Supra) that pension is not a bounty,
rather a property as enshrined under Article 300 (A) of the
Constitution of India. The prolonged pendency of the
Departmental Proceeding has an indirect penal effect, the
respondents are under obligation to conclude the Departmental
Proceeding in shortest possible time as has been held by the
Apex Court in cases of P.V. Mahadevan (supra) and Dr. Hira
Lal (supra) , otherwise, on the basis of information contained in
the counter affidavit, the delay remains unexplained, which is
not attributable to the petitioner, has caused serious prejudice to
him, to balance the competing consequences, the equity lies in
favour of the petitioner due to arbitrary action of the
Disciplinary Authority, who have delayed the Departmental
Proceeding without authority of law beyond statutory period,
which requires interference of this Court.
15. Accordingly, in view of the above mentioned facts
and circumstances and the settled law by the Apex Court, the
respondents are directed to take a final decision in the
Departmental Proceeding within a further period of six weeks,
failing which, the proceeding shall stand closed and the
Patna High Court CWJC No.15451 of 2024 dt.24-09-2026
16/16
respondents will be under obligation to make payment of retiral
dues under different heads to the petitioner including pension
within further period of two weeks.
16. The present writ petition stands disposed of.
(Purnendu Singh, J)
Niraj/-
AFR/NAFR A.F.R.
CAV DATE N/A
Uploading Date 28.09.2026
Transmission Date N/A