SANJAY KUMAR ALIAS SANJU TH. TARO DEVI vs UT OF J AND K TH. S.H.O. POLICE STATION REHMBAL AND ANOTHER

Court
Jammu and Kashmir High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU


CrlA(D) No. 16/2024

Reserved on: 30.10.2026
Pronounced on: 13.11.2026
Uploaded on: 13.11.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced? FULL

Sanjay Kumar alias Sanju,
Aged:- 38 years,
S/o Sh. Amar Nath,
R/o Jib, Tehsil & District Udhampur.
A/P lodged in District Jail, Udhampur
Through mother Taro Devi,
Age:- 75 years,
W/o Amar Nath,
R/o Jib, Tehsil & District Udhampur.



…Petitioner(s)/Appellant(s)
Through: Ms Surinder Kour, Sr. Adv. with Ms Manpreet Kour, Adv.
Vs.
1. Union Territory of J&K
Through SHO Police Station Rehmbal
District Udhampur.
2. Jail Superintendent,
District Jail, Udhampur.


...Respondent(s)
Mr. Raman Sharma, Sr. Adv. with
Through:
Mr. Kartikay Sharma, Adv. & Ms Saliqa Sheikh, Adv.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SHAHZAD AZEEM, JUDGE

J U D G M E N T


SHAHZAD AZEEM-J
1. This appeal is directed against the judgment of conviction and order of
sentence dated 16.04.2024 and 25.04.2024 passed by the learned Additional
Sessions Judge, Udhampur (the trial court) in the Challan titled State vs.
Sanjay Kumar arising out of FIR No. 50/2017 registered at Police Station
Rehmbal for commission of offences under Section 376 and 342 of the

CrlA(D) No. 16/2024 Page 1 of 19
Mohd Altaf Nima
I attest to the accuracy
and authenticity of this
document
13.11.2026

Ranbir Penal Code (RPC), whereby the appellant was held guilty and
convicted for the said offences and sentenced to undergo rigorous
imprisonment for a period of 14 years and a fine of ₹ 1.00 lac for the offence
under Section 376 RPC, and further imprisonment of one year for the
offence under Section 342 RPC.
Brief case of the prosecution:
2. On 23.04.2017 at about 4:25 pm, PW-3, Ramesh Kumar, (father of the
prosecutrix) along with the prosecutrix approached the Police Station
Rehmbal, District Udhampur and lodged a written complaint, upon which
FIR No. 50/2017 was registered for offences under Section 376 and 342 of
the RPC.
3. The Prosecution story is that the prosecutrix, (PW-1) then aged 8
years, had gone to the house of Sanjay Kumar alias Sanju (the Appellant),
who is the Uncle/Chachu of the prosecutrix and resides in the
neighbourhood, to play hide-and-seek with the children of the house, namely
Sonu alias Himanshu and Sania. While playing, the accused took the
prosecutrix into a Kacha room (Tin-shed store) of the house, closed the door,
made her lie on the floor, removed her lower garments, and committed rape
upon her, causing severe pain and bleeding. The prosecutrix came out of the
room crying, with her clothes stained with blood, and returned home. the
accused followed her and poured 2-3 jugs of water over her, stating that she
was feeling hot. Upon enquiry by PW-2 Neelam Devi, (mother of the
prosecutrix), the prosecutrix narrated the entire occurrence of forcible sexual
assault by the accused, who in turn informed PW-3. Neighbours were called,
and the prosecutrix was driven to the Police Station in a vehicle by PW-4
Ajay Kumar, where the FIR was registered, and thereafter she was taken to

CrlA(D) No. 16/2024 Page 2 of 19
Mohd Altaf Nima
I attest to the accuracy
and authenticity of this
document
13.11.2026

District Hospital, Udhampur for medical examination and treatment. Two
stitches were put by the doctor. Blood-stained clothes, blood samples, hair
samples, blood stained soil and plain soil were seized. Upon presentation of
the Challan, the accused pleaded innocence and was committed for trial on
the charges of offences punishable under Section 376 and 342 of the RPC.
Trial Court Findings:
4. The trial court held that the statement of the prosecutrix was
consistent, reliable and inspired confidence. It remained unrebutted even
after the detailed cross-examination and was in conformity with her
statement recorded under Section 164-A of Criminal Procedure Code (the
Code).
5. The trial court also relied upon the medical evidence of PW-14 Dr.
Sanjay Verma, (Gynecologist), and found that the allegations of sexual
assault were fully corroborated. The statements of PW-2 Neelam Devi and
PW-3 Ramesh Kumar corroborated the immediate disclosure, the condition
of the prosecutrix who at the relevant time was found bleeding and crying,
and subsequent steps taken.
6. The trial court also dealt with the discrepancies and treated the same
as insignificant. Finally, the trial court vide impugned order dated
25.04.2024 sentenced the convict to rigorous imprisonment for 14 years and
a fine of ₹ 1.00 lakh for the offence under Section 376 RPC and
imprisonment for one year for the offence under Section 342 RPC.
Grounds of Challenge and Submissions:
7. The appellant has challenged the judgment of conviction and order of
sentence on the following grounds as set out in the memo of appeal, in
addition to the submissions made by learned counsel for the appellant:

CrlA(D) No. 16/2024 Page 3 of 19
Mohd Altaf Nima
I attest to the accuracy
and authenticity of this
document
13.11.2026

(i) The trial court has failed to appreciate the evidence in
accordance with the requirement that the prosecution must
prove the guilt beyond reasonable doubt; on a proper and legal
appraisal, the appellant could not have been held guilty for
commission of offences under Section 376 and 342 RPC.
(ii) The trial court acted on a superficial reading of the evidence,
misappreciated the same, and failed to appreciate the facts and
circumstances, thereby committed grave error.
(iii) The prosecution story is ridden with material contradictions and
discrepancies, indicating false implication of the appellant on
account of a land dispute between the families.
(iv) The judgment proceeds on the presumption and preconceived
mind; there is no proper individual appraisal of the statements
of the witnesses or construction of approved facts leading to the
conclusion of guilt. In absence of motive and in the face of
inherent contradictions, the conviction is illegal; even the
offence under Section 342 RPC is not made out from the
prosecution evidence.
(v) The medical evidence has not been properly appreciated; the
conviction rests on conjuncture and is not based on legal
evidence; important witnesses have not supported the
prosecution case, reflecting false implication of the appellant.
8. In addition to the grounds set out in the Memorandum of Appeal, the
learned counsel for the appellant has questioned the legality of the impugned
judgment and sentence on the following specific aspects: -
(i) The statement of the prosecutrix under Section
164-A of Code was recorded after about 14 days of
the occurrence, and those of the parents, even later,
i.e., after 23-24 days of the alleged occurrence.
However, no satisfactory explanation for this delay
was offered by the prosecution; such delay casts
serious doubt on the reliability of the prosecution
version.

CrlA(D) No. 16/2024 Page 4 of 19
Mohd Altaf Nima
I attest to the accuracy
and authenticity of this
document
13.11.2026

(ii) There are inconsistencies regarding the persons
who first arrived or were present at the house of
the victim immediately after the occurrence.
Different witnesses have given varying accounts of
who was present when the prosecutrix returned
home crying and bleeding.
(iii) The accounts of who accompanied the prosecutrix
to the police station and thereafter to the hospital
are not uniform. While some witnesses speak of
the parents (PW-2 and PW-3) and Ajay Kumar,
(PW-4), the precise composition of the party and
the sequence vary.
(iv) Though the prosecutrix stated to have raised a hue
and cry, yet no hue and cry raised by the
prosecutrix was heard by anyone, including the
children with whom she was playing, or the family
members of the accused’s household or the mother
of the prosecutrix.
(v) The probative value of the medical examination is
questioned, and it is submitted that the medical
evidence itself does not conclusively establish
commission of the offence of rape by the appellant.
The doctor admitted that the hymen can be torn by
playing or cycling, and that a vaginal tear could
possibly result from accidental sitting on a wooden
log or a metal rod. At the same time, no
spermatozoa were found, and there were no
external injuries or marks of violence, which
would be expected in a case of forcible rape of a
child of eight years.
9. While concluding, the learned counsel also submitted that the entire
case is based on the solitary, belated, and uncorroborated version of the
prosecutrix, which is unreliable in the face of the above circumstances.

CrlA(D) No. 16/2024 Page 5 of 19
Mohd Altaf Nima
I attest to the accuracy
and authenticity of this
document
13.11.2026

10 . Ex-adverso, while defending the impugned judgment and sentence,
Mr. Raman Sharma, learned senior counsel contended that once it is found
that the testimony of the prosecutrix is of sterling quality, which is duly
corroborated by the medical evidence, minor discrepancies here and there,
including delayed recording of the statements of witnesses by the
Investigating Officer, do not shake the credibility of the prosecution story,
and thus no fault much less illegality, can be found in the reasoning given by
the trial court while passing the judgment under challenge.
Analysis:
11. The prosecution case rests primarily on the testimony of the child
prosecutrix, her immediate disclosure to the mother, the condition in which
she was found, i.e., bleeding, blood-stained cloth, prompt lodging of the FIR
on the same day, and the medical opinion of recent sexual intercourse. The
trial court has accepted this version after holding that the prosecutrix
withstood cross-examination and that the medical evidence corroborates the
fact of sexual assault.
12. It is well settled that the solitary testimony of a prosecutrix, if found
reliable and trustworthy, can form the basis of conviction in a rape case, and
corroboration is not a rule of law but a matter of prudence. The testimony of
a victim of sexual assault is entitled to great weight, and refusal to act upon
it in the absence of corroboration would amount to adding insult to injury.
Where the statement of the prosecutrix is consistent, inspires confidence, and
is corroborated by medical evidence of recent sexual intercourse, conviction
can be sustained without corroboration.

CrlA(D) No. 16/2024 Page 6 of 19
Mohd Altaf Nima
I attest to the accuracy
and authenticity of this
document
13.11.2026

13. PW-1 (prosecutrix) was consistent in deposing that she was taken into
the Kacha room, door was closed, the penis was inserted into her private part
causing pain and bleeding, white liquid falling on her, water thrown by the
accused, narration of the occurrence to the mother. She remained firm in
cross-examination, and despite her tender age, she denied the suggestions of
land dispute or being tutored.
14. PW-2, deposed that she saw prosecutrix crying with blood-stained
clothes, while the accused was following and throwing water on her on the
pretext that she is feeling hot. It has specifically come in her testimony that
the prosecutrix narrated the occurrence to her, and she accordingly shared
with her husband.
15. PW-3 deposed that regarding occurrence, he was informed by his
wife, found blood on clothes of prosecutrix; FIR was lodged; medical
treatment was got done; seizures of clothes and blood sample were made and
this witness also denied the suggestion regarding the land dispute.
16. PW-4 (Ajay Kumar) was consistent in deposing that he took his
uncle, aunt and the prosecutrix in his vehicle, first to police station,
Rehmbal, and thereafter to the District Hospital, Udhampur.
17. PW-14 (Dr. Sanjay Verma, Gynecologist) who conducted the medical
examination of the prosecutrix, deposed that in view of the histopathological
examination of the vaginal smear and clinical findings, he was of the opinion
that the prosecutrix had sexual intercourse within 12 hours of the
examination. On local examination, the findings recorded by the doctor are
as under: -
1. Posterior Fourchette and Hymen torn
2. Ist degree vaginal wall tear which was stitched.

CrlA(D) No. 16/2024 Page 7 of 19
Mohd Altaf Nima
I attest to the accuracy
and authenticity of this
document
13.11.2026

3. Bleeding per vaginum +++.
4. Vaginal smear taken and sent for Histopathological
examination.
5. No other visible injury noticed on the person.

18. During the trial, the witnesses identified inter alia the blood-stained
clothes of the prosecutrix, and testified the seizure memo of blood samples
of the prosecutrix.
19. The consistent prosecution version is that the prosecutrix was first
taken to the Police Station for registration of the FIR and thereafter to the
District Hospital, Udhampur for medical treatment.
20. PW-3 Ramesh Kumar categorically stated that they did not go to the
hospital before going to the Police Station, where they reached around 3.30
to 4.00 p.m, the application was written, FIR was registered and only
thereafter they proceeded to the hospital in the evening.
21. PW-4 Ajay Kumar, who drove the vehicle, confirmed that he took his
family first to the police station and thereafter to the hospital.
22. PW-8 , ASI-Angrez Singh, who took the prosecutrix from her home
for medical examination stated that they reached the hospital around 5:00 to
6:00 p.m. The initial written complaint itself was moved at the police station,
upon which the FIR was registered.
23. The trial court, while dealing with the defence challenge to this
sequence, held the conduct of the parents to be natural in the given
circumstances. Aligning with the core of the prosecution case, immediately
after occurrence, the child returned home crying and bleeding with stained
clothes; the parents were in a state of shock, who called neighbours, and first
approached the police station before taking her to hospital for treatment.
24. Since this aspect has been considered by us in the wake of an
argument that there is a discrepancy as to the sequence, whether, after the

CrlA(D) No. 16/2024 Page 8 of 19
Mohd Altaf Nima
I attest to the accuracy
and authenticity of this
document
13.11.2026

occurrence, the prosecutrix was taken first to the police station or to the
hospital. Therefore, the sequence of the evidence recorded during the trial
aligns with the prosecution story that the prosecutrix was first taken to the
police station for registration of the FIR and thereafter to the hospital for
medical examination. As such, the trial court rightly rejected the defence
version that there is any material discrepancy in the sequence of events on
this aspect of the matter.
25. Statements of the prosecutrix and her parents were recorded during
investigation with some delay; the statement of the prosecutrix was recorded
after 14 days and that of her parents after 23-24 days. However, the
Investigating Officers tendered the following explanations:
(i) PW-18 (Inspector Vishal Manhas, I.O) deposed that he
was busy in arresting the accused and, due to this reason,
could not get the statement of the prosecutrix and her
parents recorded before the Magistrate. Thus, the I.O.
explained the omission on account of being occupied
with the arrest and other investigation steps.
(ii) PW-19 (Sanjay Raina, I.O) deposed that he was busy in
other works and, for this reason, could not get the
statements of the victim and her parents recorded. Thus,
he confirmed that recording the statement was important
but cited his pre-occupation with other duties.
(iii) PW-20 (Sohan Singh, I.O) got the statements of the
prosecutrix, her mother and other witnesses recorded. He
stated that earlier I.O’s had not recorded the statement sof
the prosecutrix and her mother and that the file indicated

CrlA(D) No. 16/2024 Page 9 of 19
Mohd Altaf Nima
I attest to the accuracy
and authenticity of this
document
13.11.2026

that the prosecutrix was not fit for statement at the
relevant time, though this was not specifically recorded
by the earlier Investigating Officers.
26. Thus, the Investigating Officers have properly explained the delay in
recording the statement of the victim and her parents during investigation.
The explanations offered are plausible and consistent with the ordinary
course of investigation, particularly in a case involving arrest of the
accused and other urgent steps. The delay, therefore, does not by itself, cast
any doubt on the credibility of the prosecution version.
27. It is worth noting that the quality of the testimony of the prosecutrix
can be gauged from the fact that through cross-examination, the credibility
of her testimony was sought to be impeached by putting the suggestion that
the occurrence is the outcome of a land dispute, and further that she has been
tutored by her parents to give false statements. Despite her tender age, she
withstood the cross-examination and specifically denied the suggestions.
Therefore, the statement of the prosecutrix inspires confidence and satisfies
the test of sterling quality.
28. The age of the prosecutrix is a material circumstance. A child of
tender age is ordinarily incapable of fabricating a detailed and consistent
account of sexual assault unless an incident has in fact occurred. The very
nature of the disclosure, when made by a minor, carries inherent reliability if
it is free from contradictions on essential points.
29. The medical report further fortifies the prosecution version. The
findings of the medical examination are consistent with the allegations made
by the prosecutrix. Where the medical evidence supports the occurrence of
sexual assault and does not contradict the version of the victim, it constitutes

CrlA(D) No. 16/2024 Page 10 of 19
Mohd Altaf Nima
I attest to the accuracy
and authenticity of this
document
13.11.2026

strong corroborative material. The combination of a sterling statement by a
child victim and supporting medical evidence leaves little room for doubt
regarding the occurrence of the incident.
30. Since the trial court primarily had taken into consideration the
testimony of the prosecutrix and the doctor who examined her, which is
further supported from the immediate acts forming part of the same
transaction in the shape of testimonies of PW-1, PW-2, PW-3 and PW-4, it is
deemed necessary to have another closer look at the testimonies of these
witnesses, because if same is found of sterling quality, then we need not to
look into any other evidence.
31. The core of the prosecutrix’s statement in the court, when she entered
the witness box, was that on 23-04-2017, she was playing hide-and-seek
with Sania and Sonu at their house. The accused present in the court is her
uncle (Chachu), whom she called Sanju Chachu. Sanju Chachu held her
hand and took her to one Kachi Kothi and he closed the door. He opened his
urinal part (penis) and inserted it into her urinal part. She came home while
crying. Sanju Chachu also came after her and he threw 2-3 jugs of water
from the drum over her, saying that she was feeling hot. Blood was oozing
out from her urinal part. She sat on the bed but blood continued to ooz out.
When her mother inquired from her about the cause of bleeding, she narrated
everything regarding the occurrence to her mother.
32. In cross-examination, she further particularized the sequence without
deviation and deposed that when taken inside the Kaccha room, Sonu and
Sania were searching for her. There was no bed and the floor was of soil.
She was laid on the floor. The accused removed her yellow-coloured
Pajama. Penetration continued for sometime, after which a white coloured

CrlA(D) No. 16/2024 Page 11 of 19
Mohd Altaf Nima
I attest to the accuracy
and authenticity of this
document
13.11.2026

liquid emanated from the accused and fell upon her. There is no land dispute
with her father. The prosecutrix specifically denied the defence suggestions
that she fell on a trunk while playing and was asked by her parents to give a
false statement, or that any land dispute existed.
33. A striking feature of the prosecutrix’s evidence is the manner in which
she identified the accused. Though in her deposition she referred to him as
“Sanju Chachu”, this is not the language of a tutored or hostile child
harbouring personal ill will. A child of tender age, when describing a
neighbour whom she knows as an uncle with whose children she was
playing, would naturally use the familial appellation. The absence of any
venom, exaggeration or attempt to blacken the accused beyond specific act,
and her categorical denial of any land dispute or tutoring, reinforces that her
testimony is not the product of personal animus or parental coaching. The
trial court rightly observed that even after detailed examination, nothing
emerged to cast doubt upon the testimony of the prosecutrix on this aspect.
34. The quality of her recollection is that of photographic memory. She
remembered:
(i) The exact game i.e., hide-and-seek and the names
of the children that is Sania and Sonu;
(ii) The nature of the room, i.e., Kachi Kothi/Kacha
Room, soil floor, absence of bed, and adjacent
rooms;
(iii) The precise sequence i.e., holding of hand, closing
of door, removal of yellow Pajama, insertion, pain,
bleeding, white liquid;
(iv) The subsequent conduct of the accused i.e.,
following her and throwing two jugs of water while
saying she was feeling hot;

CrlA(D) No. 16/2024 Page 12 of 19
Mohd Altaf Nima
I attest to the accuracy
and authenticity of this
document
13.11.2026

(v) Her own clothing i.e., Yellow Pajama and pink
frock, and the fact that clothes were not torn.
35. These minute, consistent details given by a child witness after a
considerable time from the occurrence demonstrate that the occurrence was
firmly imprinted in her memory and was not reconstructed or improved
upon. The trial court held that her statement inspired confidence precisely
because of this consistency and the absence of any material contradiction.
36. The testimony of the prosecutrix is further corroborated in all material
particulars by PW-2, PW-3, PW-4 and the doctor who examined the
prosecutrix.
37. PW-2, Neelam Devi corroborated the immediate aftermath in full
particulars. The statement of PW-2 was in conformity with her earlier
statement recorded under Section 164-A of the Code.
38. PW-3, Ramesh Kumar corroborated that he was informed by his wife
of the rape and further deposed that he saw blood-stained clothes; took the
child first to the police station and then to the hospital; identified seized
clothes and blood samples. PW-3 also specifically denied the defence
suggestion regarding the land dispute with the accused.
39. PW-4 (Ajay Kumar) further corroborated the post occurrence conduct
and deposed in tune with the prosecution story of taking the family to the
police station and thereafter to the hospital, and the seizures made at the spot
and at the hospital.
40. PW-14 Dr Sanjay Verma, (Gynecologist) also provided strong
medical corroboration. He examined the prosecutrix at 6:00 p.m on the same
st
day and found that the posterior Fourchette and hymen were torn; 1 degree
vaginal wall tear which was stitched; bleeding per vaginum.

CrlA(D) No. 16/2024 Page 13 of 19
Mohd Altaf Nima
I attest to the accuracy
and authenticity of this
document
13.11.2026

41. In view of histopathological examination of the vaginal smear and
clinical findings, the doctor opined that the prosecutrix had sexual
intercourse within 12 hours of the examination. The injuries were consistent
with penetration. This medical evidence independently confirms the core of
the prosecutrix’s account of penetration and resulting trauma. Thus, the
prosecutrix’s testimony is not solitary, rather it is reinforced by the
immediate narration to the mother, the parents’ consistent accounts, the
independent witness on the sequence of events and the contemporaneous
medical findings.
42. The statement of the prosecutrix is the foundation of the prosecution
case in offences of sexual assault. It is well settled that testimony of a
prosecutrix, if of sterling quality, can form the sole basis of conviction and
does not require independent corroboration in every case. A prosecutrix is
not an accomplice, but she is a victim of a crime. Her evidence stands on a
higher pedestal than that of an ordinary witness, particularly when the victim
is a child.
43. Earlier the law regarding the weight to be given to the testimony of
the prosecutrix was that she cannot be put on par with an accomplice, but her
evidence has to be received with the same weight as is attached to an injured
witness in cases of physical violence. In this regard, a reference can be made
to a judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in State of Maharashtra vs.
Chandraprakash Kewalchand Jain (1990) 1 SCC 550. However, over the
period of time, the law regarding the weightage to be given to the testimony
of the prosecutrix has undergone a sea-change and now the consistent
approach of the Courts is that conviction can be founded on the testimony of
the prosecutrix alone unless there are compelling reasons for seeking

CrlA(D) No. 16/2024 Page 14 of 19
Mohd Altaf Nima
I attest to the accuracy
and authenticity of this
document
13.11.2026

corroboration. The evidence of a prosecutrix is more reliable than that of an
injured witness. A reference in this regard can be made to the judgment of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Rai Sandeep alias Deepu vs. State (NCT of
Delhi) (2012) 8 SCC 21 . In paragraph 27 of the judgment held as follows: -
27. In the decision reported as State of H.P. v. Asha
Ram [(2005) 13 SCC 766 : (2006) 2 SCC (Cri) 296 :
AIR 2006 SC 381] this Court highlighted the
importance to be given to the testimony of the
prosecutrix as under in para 5: (SCC p. 770)
“ 5 . … It is now a well-settled principle of law that
conviction can be founded on the testimony of the
prosecutrix alone unless there are compelling reasons
for seeking corroboration. The evidence of a
prosecutrix is more reliable than that of an injured
witness. The testimony of the victim of sexual assault
is vital, unless there are compelling reasons which
necessitate looking for corroboration of her statement,
the courts should find no difficulty in acting on the
testimony of a victim of sexual assault alone to
convict an accused where her testimony inspires
confidence and is found to be reliable . It is also a
well-settled principle of law that corroboration as a
condition for judicial reliance on the testimony of the
prosecutrix is not a requirement of law but a guidance
of prudence under the given circumstances. The
evidence of the prosecutrix is more reliable than that
of an injured witness. Even minor contradictions or
insignificant discrepancies in the statement of the
prosecutrix should not be a ground for throwing out
an otherwise reliable prosecution case .”
44. At the same time, minor and immaterial inconsistencies and
discrepancies shall not harm the case of the prosecution, if the core of the

CrlA(D) No. 16/2024 Page 15 of 19
Mohd Altaf Nima
I attest to the accuracy
and authenticity of this
document
13.11.2026

prosecution story remains consistent, particularly when it finds support from
the medical evidence. This is the consistent approach adopted while
appreciating the evidence, and if it is found that there is no contradiction and
the core of the prosecution story is proved, then minor consistencies here
and there are irrelevant. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in this regard in Firoz
Khan Akbarkhan vs. State of Maharashtra 2025 SCC Online SC 627
dealt with the minor inconsistencies and delay in recording the statement of
the witnesses during investigation and held that parrot-like statements are
dis-favoured by the courts. In the said judgment, the Hon'ble Supreme Court
held that the delay of over two years in recording witness statements was
deemed not fatal, when explained properly. It is further held that, stricto
sinsu, delay in recording witness statement, when the said delay is explained,
will not aid an accused. Therefore, we are of the opinion that the delay was
properly explained by the Investigating Officer and thus, the plea raised by
the appellant on this account is turned down.
45. In the case in hand, the core of prosecution story regarding ingredients
of offences under Section 376 and 342 of the RPC is proved beyond doubt,
and further the Investigating Officers have also explained the delay in
recording the statements of the witnesses during investigation. Therefore, if
at all there is any discrepancy, it is, of course, always there in the natural
course of human conduct, and the case of the prosecution thus cannot be
thrown out.
46. We are also fortified in our view by the judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in State of Himachal Pradesh vs. Sanjay Kumar alias
Sunny (2017) 2 SCC 51, which was a case of a victim of rape aged 9 years
by none other than her uncle, accused of such a horrendous act. It was held

CrlA(D) No. 16/2024 Page 16 of 19
Mohd Altaf Nima
I attest to the accuracy
and authenticity of this
document
13.11.2026

that the evidence of a child victim of tender age, such as 9 years in a sexual
offence case, is entitled to full weight if it inspires confidence after careful
scrutiny. Corroboration is not necessary as a rule. Courts should not view the
testimony of the victim with suspicion or require corroboration except where
there are compelling reasons. Sensitivity must be shown in dealing with such
cases, particularly those involving acquaintance or incestuous abuse, where
delayed disclosure is common due to social stigma, fear and threats. It is
further specifically made clear that the prosecutrix stands at a higher
pedestal than an injured witness, and it was observed that:
“Why should the evidence of the girl or the woman
who complains of rape or sexual molestation be
viewed with the aid of spectacles fitted with lenses
tinged with doubt, disbelief or suspicion? The plea
about the lack of corroboration has no substance.”
47. In the given facts and circumstances, we are guided by the
observations of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the locus classicus judgment
of State of Madhya Pradesh Vs. Balveer Singh (2025) 8 SCC 545
particularly at paragraph 67.11, which are relevant and need to be taken note
of. The said paragraph reads thus:
67.11. Merely because a child witness is found to be
repeating certain parts of what somebody asked her to say
is no reason to discard her testimony as tutored, if it is
found that what is in substance being deposed by the child
witness is something that he or she had actually
witnessed. It added that a child witness who has
withstood his or her cross-examination at length and able
to describe the scenario implicating the accused in detail
as the author of crime, then minor discrepancies or parts

CrlA(D) No. 16/2024 Page 17 of 19
Mohd Altaf Nima
I attest to the accuracy
and authenticity of this
document
13.11.2026

of coached deposition that have crept in will not by itself
affect the credibility of such child witness.
Findings and conclusion:
48. On a careful and cumulative appraisal of the entire evidence on
record, read in the light of the settled principles governing appreciation of
the testimony of a child victim of sexual assault, we find that the prosecution
has established the guilt of the appellant beyond reasonable doubt. The
statement of the prosecutrix, a child of tender age, is of sterling quality. She
has given a coherent, natural and consistent account of the occurrence, free
from material embellishment or tutoring, and has withstood the test of cross-
examination. Her version regarding the identity of the accused, the place and
manner of the assault, the immediate aftermath, and the subsequent
disclosure stands corroborated by the consistent testimonies of her parents
i.e. PW-2 and PW-3, the independent witness who accompanied them i.e.
PW-4, and most importantly, by the contemporaneous medical evidence
st
which records a torn hymen, 1 degree vaginal tear, and bleeding per
vaginum, with a clear opinion of recent sexual intercourse. The minor
discrepancies and the delay in formal recordings of statements have been
satisfactorily explained and do not touch the core of the prosecution case.
The defence of false implications on account of a land remains unsupported
and has been rightly rejected.
49. In view of the settled proposition of law, the testimony of a child
prosecutrix, when found reliable and trustworthy and supported by medical
evidence, is sufficient to sustain conviction. Applying these principles, we
hold that the conviction of the appellant under section 376 and 342 RPC is
fully justified when it is tested on the anvil of law governing the subject.

CrlA(D) No. 16/2024 Page 18 of 19
Mohd Altaf Nima
I attest to the accuracy
and authenticity of this
document
13.11.2026

Under such circumstances, we find no reason to interfere with the impugned
judgment.
50. Accordingly, the appeal is found to be without merit and is dismissed.
Judgement of conviction and order of sentence passed by the trial court are
affirmed.
51. Let a copy of this order along with the record be sent to the trial court
forthwith for information and further follow-up.



(SHAHZAD AZEEM) (SANJAY DHAR)
JUDGE JUDGE
SRINAGAR:
13.11.2026
Altaf

Whether the judgment is speaking? Yes
Whether the judgment is reportable? Yes

CrlA(D) No. 16/2024 Page 19 of 19
Mohd Altaf Nima
I attest to the accuracy
and authenticity of this
document
13.11.2026