P.M RAJAN vs STATE OF KERALA
- Court
- Kerala High Court
CNR : KLHC010846132026
2026:KER:87764
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A. BADHARUDEEN
TH
FRIDAY, THE 13 DAY OF NOVEMBER 2026 / 22ND KARTHIKA, 1948
CRL.REV.PET NO. 1169 OF 2026
CRIME NO.1/2017 OF VACB, PATHANAMTHITTA,
REVISION PETITIONER/PETITIONER/2ND ACCUSED:
P.M RAJAN, AGED 76 YEARS, S/O. LATE. VARGHEESE MATHAI,
RESIDING AT PUTHUPARAMBIL VEEDU, KUNNAM MURI, MANNADISALA,
KOLLAMULA VILLAGE, NOW RESIDING AT PUTHUPARAMBIL VEEDU,
KULAMAMKUZHI, CHETHAKAL VILLAGE, RANNI TALUK, PATHANAMTHITTA
DISTRICT, PIN - 689677
BY ADVS.
SRI.R.NIKHIL
SMT.K.K.NESNA
SMT.HASEENA A.A.
SHRI.ABDUL RASHEED P.
RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT/STATE & COMPLAINANT:
STATE OF KERALA, REPRESENTED BY THE DEPUTY SUPERINTENDENT OF
POLICE, VIGILANCE AND ANTI CORRUPTION BUREAU, PATHANAMTHITTA,
THROUGH PUBLIC PROSECUTOR, HIGH COURT OF KERALA, ERNAKULAM,
PIN - 682031
OTHER PRESENT:
SR PP ROY THOMAS MUVATTUPUZHA
THIS CRIMINAL REVISION PETITION HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
06.11.2026, THE COURT ON 13.11.2026 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
Crl. Rev. Pet No.1169/2026 2
A. BADHARUDEEN, J.
—--------------------------------------------
Crl. Rev. Pet. No. 1169 of 2026
—---------------------------------------------------
Dated this the 13th day of November, 2026
‘CR’
ORDER
The second accused in C.C.No.59/2025, arising out of
V.C.01/2017/PTA of Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau,
Pathanamthitta unit has filed this revision petition under
Sections 438 and 442 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita,
2023, assailing the order dated 14.10.2026 in Crl.M.P.No.141/2026,
by which, the plea of discharge raised by the revision petitioner
was dismissed by the Enquiry Commissioner and Special Judge
(Vigilance), Kollam.
2. Heard the learned counsel for the revision
petitioner/second accused and the learned Special Public
Prosecutor in detail. Perused the order under challenge and the
relevant records.
3. The prosecution case is that, the first accused while
working as the Tribal Development Officer, Pathanamthitta,
during the period from 24-08-2015 to 05-08-2016, and the third
Crl. Rev. Pet No.1169/2026 3
accused while working as the Office Assistant at the Tribal
Development Office, Ranny from 13-02-2012 to 31-01-2016 and as
"public servants" abused their official positions with dishonest
intention to confer undue pecuniary advantage to the second
accused, who is the petitioner herein and accused Nos.4 to 7. The
specific allegation is that the accused persons hatched criminal
conspiracy and pursuant to the said conspiracy, accused Nos.4 to
7 had manipulated the land purchase process under a
Government scheme by name "Ashikkum Bhoomi Adivasikku
Swantham" implemented during the year 2015. Accordingly, the
first accused being the Implementing Officer sanctioned and
disbursed an amount of ₹77,00,000/- to the second
accused/petitioner towards the purchase of 200 cents of lands in
survey No.780/1-2-3170 of Kollamula Village at the rate of
₹38,500/- per cent intended to be distributed among 8 Scheduled
Tribe beneficiaries, each entitled to not less than 25 cents of
property. However, in deliberate violation of the scheme norms
and with fraudulent intention, the second accused who actually
possessed only 183.50 cents of land improperly set apart 13.33
cents of land for a pathway. This non-distributable extent of land
Crl. Rev. Pet No.1169/2026 4
was also dishonestly included in the total consideration.
Consequently, only an extent of 170.17 cents was available for
actual distribution and this was arbitrarily and unequally
divided among the beneficiaries. As a result, one beneficiary
received 26.44 cents and the remaining seven beneficiaries were
allotted substantially lesser extents of 18.33 cents, 20.01cents,
20.21 cents, 19.39 cents, 21.13 cents, 24.19 cents and 21.37 cents.
Hence the very object of the welfare scheme was defeated.
Further, by adopting this fraudulent method, an excess amount
of ₹11,48,555/- was dishonestly paid to the second accused with
the active assistance of the third accused who functioned as a
broker in the entire transaction.
4. It is on this premise, the prosecution alleges
commission of offences punishable under Section 13(1)(d) r/w
13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (hereinafter
referred as ‘the PC Act’) as well as under Sections 420, 120B and
34 of the Indian Penal Code (hereinafter referred as ‘the IPC’) by
accused Nos.1 to 7.
5. The revision petitioner, who is the second accused,
had approached the learned Special Judge seeking discharge,
Crl. Rev. Pet No.1169/2026 5
mainly urging that, going through the prosecution materials,
prime facie, commission of offences punishable under Section
13(1)(d) r/w 13(2) of the PC Act and Sections 420, 120B and 34 of
IPC by the second accused, could not be found and in such view
of the matter, the revision petitioner could not be proceeded
further.
6. The prosecution side strongly opposed the
contention, pointing out the materials showing his involvement
in this case.
7. The learned Special Judge, after extracting the rival
contentions urged by both sides, considered the question
whether the charges levelled against the revision petitioner
could be considered to be “groundless”?. After discussing the
prosecution materials in paragraph No.10 with reference to the
precedents referred to in paragraph Nos.11 and 12, the learned
Special Judge found that there were ample prima facie materials
for a trial against the petitioner and the veracity of the
prosecution case regarding ‘criminal conspiracy’ alleged against
the petitioner/second accused could only be considered, after a
full-fledged trial, on evidence.
Crl. Rev. Pet No.1169/2026 6
8. In this connection, the learned Special Judge given
attention to the statement of witness No.14 to the effect that the
petitioner and the other accused persons came together and
discussed matters on the date of survey measurement at the site,
inspite of referring the statements of witness Nos.15 to 17,
showing his involvement in this case. Thus, as stated in
paragraph Nos.10 to 13, the learned Special Judge dismissed the
discharge petition. The relevant paragraphs are extracted
hereunder:
“ 10. On a careful scrutiny of the entire evidence
collected by investigating agency and in particular the
evidence of the crucial surveyors i.e., witness Nos. 14 to 17 it is
evident that the petitioner was physically present at the time
of original survey. The version of the petitioner that he was not
aware about the pathway cannot be believed even for a
moment since admittedly property was conveyed for a noble
scheme of the Government meant for the "upliftment of the
Adivasis" whereby Adivasis would be provided 25 cents each of
property with access. It cannot be believed even for a moment
that plots would be assigned to such beneficiaries without
provision for access to the plots. That apart even keeping aside
the extent of 13.33 cents earmarked for the way there was still
a deficit of extent as the actual extent found in possession was
only 183.50 cents. It has also come out through the evidence
collected by the investigating agency that none of the eight
beneficiaries could be allotted 25 cents except one beneficiary
who received 26.44 cents. In fact, the other beneficiaries
received only 18.43 cents and two of the beneficiaries received
only 20.01 cents and 20.21 cents each. The others obtained
19.39 cents, 20.13 cents, 24.19 cents and 21.37 cents. Hence the
land acquired could not be equitably divided among the
Crl. Rev. Pet No.1169/2026 7
beneficiaries as contemplated by the scheme. The version of
the petitioner/2nd accused that he was totally kept the dark
regarding the provision of a pathway for access cannot be
believed prima facie. So also, his case that he had conspired
with other accused is established prima facie by the statement
of witness No.14. The version of the petitioner that the entire
sale consideration was transferred to his account after
conduct of survey and after being convinced about the extent
of the property cannot be believed prima facie. So also, the
version of the petitioner that he was not aware or informed
about the manner in which the plots were created also cannot
be believed prima facie. Interestingly, it is the case of the
petitioner that he was not very particular to go through the
documents prepared by the authorities. This version also
cannot be believed even for a moment since he had conveyed
property admittedly for the aforesaid scheme of the
Government.
11. The law regarding a plea of discharge under Section 239 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 is by now trite. Our
Hon'ble High Court in the recent decision reported in Kumari
M. v. State of Kerala [2025 KHC 1109] held that while
considering a plea of discharge under Sec.239 the power of the
court is confined to the examination of the prosecution
records to ascertain whether a prima facie case has been made
out against the accused or whether there exists at least a
strong suspicion regarding the involvement of the accused
who seeks discharge. It is equally trite as held by our Hon'ble
High Court again in the recent decision reported in
Balakrishnan M. v. Central Bureau of Investigation [2025
KHC 997] that at the stage of considering a plea of discharge
the court cannot consider materials by exercising the power of
a trial court and after evidence. It was held that if the
prosecution materials would show a prima facie case or strong
suspicion regarding the involvement of the accused in the case
the plea of discharge should fail. It is further held that a "mere
suspicion" would not suffice the requirements of "strong
suspicion". In State of Kerala v. Biju Alexander [2025 KHC
968] it was held that while considering the plea of discharge
the trial Judge need to merely examine the materials produced
by the prosecution in order to determine whether or not the
Crl. Rev. Pet No.1169/2026 8
grounds are sufficient to proceed against the accused. It was
held that the trial Judge should look into the materials
collected by the investigating agency produced before the
court to see prima facie whether those materials would induce
suspicious circumstances against the accused so as to frame a
charge. Further in the ruling reported in Radhakrishnan Nair
v. CBI Ernakulam [2025 KHC 768] the dictum of the Hon'ble
Apex Court to the effect that at the stage of considering an
application for discharge the court has to proceed on the
assumption that the materials which have been brought out by
the prosecution are true was reiterated. Our Hon'ble High
Court relied on the decision of the Hon'ble Apex Court in
Sandeep G. v. State of Kerala [2024 KHC online 586] wherein
it was held that the primary consideration at the stage of
framing charge is the test of existence of a prima facie case
and that at this stage, the probative value of materials on
record shall not be evaluated. This basic requirement laid
down by the Hon'ble Apex Court was also relied upon in the
aforesaid ruling. Further importantly, the dictum of the
Hon'ble Apex Court that at the stage of framing of charge the
court has to form a presumptive opinion regarding the
existence of factual ingredients constituting the offence
alleged and it is not expected to go deep into the probative
value of the material on record and check whether the material
on record would certainly lead to conviction at the conclusion
of trial was also relied upon by our Hon'ble High Court.
12. Apart from these recent decisions of our Hon'ble High
Court the classic decision of the Hon'ble Apex Court in State
of Madhya Pradesh v. Mohanlal Soni [(2000) 6 SCC 338) is also
pertinent considering the facts and circumstances of the case.
13. Applying the aforesaid well settled principles of law to the
facts of the present case it is evident that the petitioner/2nd
accused has not made out a case for his discharge under
Sec.239 of the Code on the ground that the charges levelled
against the accused/petitioner are "groundless". As mentioned
above there is ample prima facie evidence for a trial against
the petitioner and the veracity of the case of the prosecution
regarding "criminal conspiracy" which is primarily alleged
against the petitioner/2nd accused can only be considered
after a full-fledged trial on evidence. In this context the
statement of witness No. 14 to the effect that the petitioner
Crl. Rev. Pet No.1169/2026 9
and the other accused came together and discussed matters on
the date of survey measurement at the site is very pertinent
and material as prima facie evidence of criminal conspiracy.”
9. The learned counsel for the revision petitioner
zealously argued that, apart from the statement of witness No.14,
no other materials to be found to show involvement of the
petitioner in this case. Further, it is submitted that the statement
of witness No.14 would not show the involvement of the
petitioner in this crime, prima facie. Therefore, the learned
Special Judge went wrong in negating the discharge plea raised
by the revision petitioner. According to the learned counsel for
the revision petitioner, the impugned order is liable to be set
aside.
10. This is a case where the allegation is that the
petitioner had provided only 170.17 cents of land to the
beneficiaries instead of 2 acres of land (200 cents) though the
petitioner had received 77,00,000/- towards the price of 200
cents. That apart, the specific allegation is that the first accused,
being the Implementing Officer, sanctioned and disbursed an
amount of ₹77,00,000/- to the second accused/petitioner towards
the purchase of 200 cents of lands in survey No.780/1-2-3170 of
Crl. Rev. Pet No.1169/2026 10
Kollamula Village at the rate of ₹38,500/- per cent intended to be
distributed among 8 Scheduled Tribe beneficiaries, each entitled
to not less than 25 cents of property. However, in deliberate
violation of the scheme norms and with fraudulent intention, the
second accused who actually possessed only 183.50 cents of land
improperly set apart 13.33 cents of land for a pathway. This
non-distributable extent of land was also dishonestly included in
the total consideration. Consequently, only an extent of 170.17
cents was available for actual distribution and this was
arbitrarily and unequally divided among the beneficiaries. As a
result, one beneficiary received 26.44 cents and the remaining
seven beneficiaries were allotted substantially lesser extents of
18.33 cents, 20.01cents, 20.21 cents, 19.39 cents, 21.13 cents, 24.19
cents and 21.37 cents. Hence the very object of the welfare
scheme was defeated. Further, by adopting this fraudulent
method, an excess amount of ₹11,48,555/- was dishonestly paid
to the second accused with the active assistance of the third
accused who functioned as a broker in the entire transaction.
The statements of witness Nos.14 to 17 would show that the
petitioner actively participated in the measurement of the
Crl. Rev. Pet No.1169/2026 11
property and only conveyed 170.17 cents of property out of 200
cents meant for 8 beneficiaries. Further, he did not possess even
200 cents of property and the property possessed by him was
found only to an extent of 183.50 cents. Be it so, it is a case
wherein the prosecution alleges hatching of conspiracy between
the accused persons by not fully allotting 200 cents of land for
the beneficiaries ie., scheduled caste community members to be
found, prima facie . In such a case, plea of innocence of the
revision petitioner is a matter of evidence. That is to say, when
the prosecution alleges conspiracy between the accused persons,
direct evidence to establish the conspiracy cannot be insisted
upon, and proof of conspiracy, mainly based on circumstantial
evidence, though direct evidence in all cases could not be ruled
out. Here is a case wherein, prima facie , the statements of
witness Nos. 14 to 17 would indicate that there was measurement
of the property to give only 170.17 cents out of 200 cents and
separation of a portion thereof having an extent of 13.33 cents to
provide a pathway, which is not permissible (where actually the
revision petitioner possessed only 183.50 cents). This would show
prima facie involvement of the revision petitioner in the crime or,
Crl. Rev. Pet No.1169/2026 12
at least, a strong suspicion regarding his involvement,
warranting trial. It is well settled law that, even a strong
suspicion regarding the involvement of an accused in a case
would be sufficient to negate the plea of discharge even in the
absence of prima facie materials as such, though a mere
suspicion would not suffice the requirement of strong suspicion.
11. Holding so, the plea of discharge canvassed by the
revision petitioner would not succeed, as found by the learned
Special Judge.
Thus, the revision petition fails and is dismissed
accordingly.
Sd/-
A. BADHARUDEEN
JUDGE
Sbna/