Sri Samir Sarkar @ Arup vs The State of Tripura
- Court
- Tripura High Court
TRHC010002682025 2026:THC:1526-DB
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Crl. A(J) 12/2025
Sri Samir Sarkar @ Arup , son of Ganesh Sarkar, resident of
Bangamura, P.S. Chailengta, District- Dhalai, Tripura.
----Appellant
Versus
The State of Tripura , notice to be served through the Ld. Public
Prosecutor, High Court of Tripura, Agartala, West Tripura.
----Respondent
For the Appellant(s) : Mr. PS Roy, Advocate
For the Respondent(s) : Mr. Raju Datta, PP
Date of hearing & delivery
of Judgment & Order : 10.11.2026
Whether fit for reporting : No
BEFORE
HON’BLE JUSTICE DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
JUDGMENT & ORDER(ORAL)
( Dr.T.Amarnath Goud, J)
Heard Mr. PS Roy, learned Legal Aid Counsel appearing
for the appellant. Also heard Mr. Raju Datta, learned Public
Prosecutor, appearing for the respondent-State of Tripura .
2. The appellant, by means of filing the present appeal
has challenged the judgment and order of conviction and sentence
dated 22.05.2024 passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Dhalai
Judicial District, Ambassa, in connection with case No. S.T.(Type
1) 34 of 2022, whereby the appellant has been convicted under
Section 302/323 of the IPC and was sentenced to suffer rigorous
imprisonment for life with default stipulation for commission of
offence punishable under Section 302 IPC and, further sentenced
to suffer rigorous imprisonment for six months with default
stipulation for commission of offence punishable under Section 323
IPC .
Page 2 of 11
3. Facts leading to the present appeal are that, on
19.09.2022 at around 1.30 p.m. the appellant attacked and
assaulted his grand-mother with a lathi and also tried to attack
and assault upon his mother and wife but the wife and mother of
the appellant somehow managed to take shelter in the dwelling
hut of one Pradip Roy and bolted the door from inside but the
appellant tried to break open the door and attack and assault upon
them and on hearing their hue and cry, while the parents of the
complainant tried to restrain the appellant from breaking the door
of the dwelling hut of Pradip Roy suddenly the appellant attacked
and assaulted them indiscriminately with a wooden stick resulting
which the parents of the complainant suffered grievous bleeding
injuries on their head and subsequently they were taken to
hospital. It is further case of the prosecution that thereafter the
complainant went to the house of the appellant and found that the
grandmother of the appellant was lying on the verandah with
severe bleeding injuries and local people removed her to
Chailengta hospital but the attending doctors declared her as
brought dead.
4. A specific case was registered against the accused-
appellant before the Chailengta police station. In course of
investigation, the Investigating Officer visited the place of
occurrence, recorded the statement of the available witnesses,
arranged for post mortem of the deceased, seized the weapon of
offence i.e. two numbers of lathi from the place of occurrence
under seizure list and arrested the appellant-accused. After
Page 3 of 11
completion of investigation, charge sheet was submitted against
the accused appellant under Section 302/323 IPC. After receipt of
the papers, learned SDJM, Longtharai Valley, Dhalai, took
cognizance of the offence against the accused-appellant and
thereby committed the case to the court of learned Sessions
Judge, Dhalai, Ambassa. Learned Sessions Judge, after supplying
the prosecution papers, framed charge against the accused-
appellant to which he pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
Accordingly, trial commenced. During trial, prosecution examined
13 witnesses and exhibited some documents. Subsequently,
examination of the prosecution witnesses was closed and the
accused appellant was examined under Section 313 Cr.P.C.
wherein he denied all the incriminating materials brought against
him and also declined to adduce any defence witness. Having
heard learned counsels appearing for the parties, and after
considering the oral and documentary evidence, the learned trial
Court passed the impugned judgment of conviction and order of
sentence. Being aggrieved, the appellant has filed the present
appeal challenging the impugned judgment and order of conviction
and sentence .
5. Mr. PS Roy, learned Legal Aid Counsel appearing for the
appellant has submitted that the conviction passed by the learned
trial court is not based on cogent evidence. Learned counsel has
also submitted that there is no eye witness to the alleged incident
and hence the deposition of the witnesses is not trustworthy.
Learned counsel has further submitted that the entire case is
Page 4 of 11
based on circumstantial evidence, but the prosecution has
miserably failed to prove the circumstance. Learned counsel for
the appellant has also submitted that there are many
discrepancies in the deposition of the witnesses and also the
medical documents/reports do not support the prosecution story.
He has further submitted that the medical papers reveal that the
injuries sustained by the victim are simple in nature. Learned
counsel has also submitted that no finger print report on the
alleged weapon of offence has been produced in trial by the
prosecution. Thus, learned counsel has urged this court for clear
acquittal of the appellant.
6 . Mr. Raju Datta, learned PP defending the judgment of
conviction and order of sentence has submitted that the case is
well-proved as the depositions of PWs 2,3,4,7,9 and 10 are
trustworthy out of whom PWs 7, 9 and 10 have stated how the
offence was committed. Mr. Saha, has further submitted that the
medical report has established the fact that the deceased was
killed due to deadly hit by a lathi. In fine, learned PP has urged
this court that the finding of the learned trial Court requires no
interference.
7. Taking the aforesaid submissions into consideration,
this Court would proceed to decide the appeal at hand to examine
whether there is any manifest error or illegality and whether any
miscarriage of justice on account of misreading or ignoring
material evidence has occurred in the present case. This invariably
would require a proper examination of the facts in the context of
Page 5 of 11
the case, for which we must revisit the facts of the case and
evidences adduced.
8. PW-2 is the informant who deposed that the mother
and wife of the appellant out of fear of being assaulted by the
appellant took shelter in the house of one Pradip Roy where the
appellant tried to break open the door and attack them. He also
deposed that while his parents (PWs 3 and 4) tried to restrain the
appellant, the appellant had assaulted them with wooden stick
indiscriminately. PW-2 also deposed that when he went to the
house of the appellant, he found the grand-mother of the
appellant lying on the ground of their verandah and was pulled
with blood and when she was taken to hospital, she was declared
brought dead. PW-2 also deposed that the mother of the appellant
stated to him that the appellant had assaulted his grand-mother
by a wooden stick. PW-2 has also identified the weapon of
offences in the dock marked as Exhibit MO-I and MO-II and also
could have identified the accused. Nothing material has been
elucidated from cross-examination of this witness.
PW-3 and 4, i.e. father and mother of the informant deposed
before the court the manner when, how and where they were
being assaulted by the appellant. They also identified the weapon
of offence and the appellant in the dock. Nothing material has
been elucidated from their cross-examination.
PW-5 has been turned hostile and nothing material has been
elucidated from his deposition. PW-6 is hearsay witness.
Page 6 of 11
PW-7 is the wife of Pradip Roy in whose house the wife and
mother of the appellant took shelter to save themselves from
being assaulted by the appellant. She deposed in similar tune to
that of PW-2 regarding the incident happened in the house of
Pradip Roy. She has further deposed that the appellant had
assaulted her and her nephew. Nothing material has been
elucidated from cross-examination of this witness.
PW-9, also deposed in similar version to that of PW-7. He has
further deposed that he could hear that the grand-mother of the
appellant had also died in their house. Nothing material has been
elucidated from cross-examination of this witness.
PW-10, deposed that he was the grandmother of the
appellant was taken out from their house to the hospital. He also
deposed that on the issue of sale proceed regarding selling of 2
nos. of goats in local market there was an altercation between the
appellant and his wife. He further deposed regarding the incident
of assault by the appellant in the house of PWs 3 and 4.
PW-11 is the Medical Officer who conducted autopsy over the
dead body of the victim and opined that the injuries sustained by
the victim were grievous and caused by hard and blunt objects. He
also opined that the cause of death was multiple fracture over the
head, face and nose and severe bleeding.
PW-12, mother of the appellant was declared hostile. PW-13
is the Investigating Officer who after completion of investigation
submitted charge sheet.
Page 7 of 11
PWs - 2, 3, 4, 7, 9 and 10 are not the eye witnesses to the
incident, but they have collectively deposed that the appellant has
assaulted his grand-mother by a lathi. The medical evidence as
adduced by PW-11 also supports the version of the PWs - 2, 3, 4, 7,
9 and 10. PWs 4, 7, 10 have further stated that there was an
altercation between the appellant and his wife on the issue of sale
proceed of two goats.
During the course of investigation, the IO has arranged for
recording the statements of PWs 3, 4 and 9 before the Magistrate
under Section 164(5) Cr.P.C. and their statements were marked as
Exhibit P/5, P/6/1 and P/10/1.
Thus, from the entire deposition of the prosecution
witnesses, as stated above, it is evident that the testimony of the
witnesses is corroborative in nature. The witnesses also identified
the accused in the dock. Further, the appellant in his examination
under Section 313 Cr.P.C. also declined to adduce any evidence on
his behalf.
Now, if we go through the medical evidence, it is found that
PW-11, Medical Officer, has conducted PM examination over the
dead body of the deceased. As per his examination a lacerated
wound measuring 7cm x 4cm x 2cm was found over right forearm
4 cm. below elbow and also bruise over left side of face 2cm x 1
cm. and forehead depressed and nose was disfigured and closed
fracture of frontal bone and also haematoma present on frontal
lobes of brain. As per his opinion, the cause of death was head
injury caused by hard and blunt object.
Page 8 of 11
Further, from the Surathal/Inquest report, it is revealed that
skin around the eyes are black and blood are seen which appears
to be injury marks and in the uppers side of right elbow, there is
an abrasion mark and also injury marks were seen on the face
which appears to be caused by a stick.
If the post mortem examination report, surathal/inquest
report and the deposition of PWs 2, 3, 4, 7, 9 and 10are read
unanimously, it would conclusively be seen that the 2, 3, 4, 7, 9
and 10 deposed that the appellant had assaulted the victim i.e. his
grandmother by a wooden stick wherein the PM examination
report and the inquest report also speak that the cause of death
was due to hitting by a hard and blunt object.
Thus, the evidence of PWs 2, 3, 4, 7, 9 and 10, who are not
the eye-witnesses to the alleged incident, but are trustworthy,
consistent and reliable.
9. Upon scrutiny of the depositions of the material
witnesses as well as the exhibits produced by the prosecution,
predominantly, it is evident that on the alleged date, time and
place, the deceased died due to the injuries caused due to hit on
her head, face and nose inflicted by her grand-son i.e. the
appellant herein, by a wooden stick which has been clearly
demonstrated in their deposition that the accused was having a
wooden stick in his hand as is revealed from the statement of PWs
3, 4 and 9 before the Magistrate under Section 164(5) Cr.P.C.
Further, from the line of the evidence of the prosecution witness it
is revealed that the appellant had a hot altercation with his wife on
Page 9 of 11
the issue of sale proceed towards two goats and after commission
of the alleged crime he chased his mother and wife to assault, but
they took shelter in the house of PWs 2 and 3, who were
subsequently assaulted by the appellant and were treated in
hospital. Thus, it can be presumed that there was no sudden
provocation or in a heat of moment he had committed the alleged
offence rather the same was predetermined . Undisputedly, the
case of the prosecution is based on circumstantial evidence and
there is no eyewitness to the commission of the offence. None of
the witnesses were present at the place of occurrence at the time
of the commission of the offence but, later on PWs 2, 3, 4, 7, 9
and 10 discovered that the victim i.e. grandmother of the
appellant was lying on the verandah of her house bleeding
profusely. Two sticks that were seized under proper seizure list
under Exhibit-4 also were identified by the witnesses in the dock
by which the deceased was being assaulted. The weapon of crime
i.e., wooden sticks (Ex P/4) were set to have been recovered from
the place of occurrence. However, no forensic report was brought
on record. Merely for the reason that the doctor opined that the
injuries on the deceased may have been caused by a similar
weapon would not discard that the recovered wooden sticks/lathis
were the weapon of crime. That apart, PWs 2, 3, 4, 7, 9 and 10, in
their examination referred the said wooden sticks/lathis as the
weapon of offence. Further non-submission of forensic report
regarding the the weapon used in the commission of the offence is
not sine qua non to convict the accused. Similarly, assuming that
Page 10 of 11
the recovery of the weapon used is not established or proved also
cannot be a ground to acquit the accused when the testimonies of
the witnesses are trustworthy and reliable. As observed
hereinabove, PWs 2, 3, 4, 7, 9 and 10 have fully supported the
case of the prosecution and if the medical evidences are taken into
consideration, the said witnesses are found to be trustworthy
and/or reliable. As observed hereinabove, there is no reason to
doubt the credibility and/or reliability of prosecution witnesses, as
deposed. Therefore, it will be safe to convict the accused on the
sole reliance of deposition of the witnesses.
10. Though learned counsel for the appellant pointed out
certain inconsistencies/contradictions in the evidence let in by the
prosecution, they being minor in nature, cannot be considered as
remissness in the investigation enabling the appellant’s acquittal
when the presence and act of the appellant was well proved
through the prosecution witnesses, more particularly, PWs 2, 3, 4,
7, 9 and 10, and also through the medical papers. It is settled
proposition of law that even if there are some omissions,
contradictions and discrepancies, the entire evidence cannot be
discarded. Thus, it can be held that there is nothing which could
shatter the veracity of the prosecution witnesses or falsify the
claim of the prosecution. All the prosecution witnesses have
materially supported the prosecution case and, the testimonies of
the prosecution witnesses do not suffer from any material infirmity
or contradiction and are consistent and corroborative. The
evidence of the prosecution witnesses is natural and trustworthy
Page 11 of 11
and corroborated by medical evidence. The prosecution witnesses
have been able to build up a continuous link. Therefore, it is
established beyond reasonable doubt that the accused-appellant
committed the murder of his grand-mother.
11. In fine, taking into consideration all these
circumstances cumulatively, we find that the trial Court was
justified in arriving at the conclusion that it was the accused-
appellant who committed the crime-in-question. On re-
appreciation of the entire oral and documentary evidences, we find
that the conclusion arrived at by the learned trial Court is neither
illegal nor perverse. Hence, we find no reason to disturb with the
judgment and order of conviction and sentence dated 22.05.2024
passed by the learned trial Court in S.T.(Type 1) 34 of 2022.
Hence, the appeal stands dismissed . Consequently,
the finding of conviction and sentence as returned by the learned
trial Court is confirmed.
BISWAJIT PALIT,J DR.T. AMARNATH GOUD,J
Digitally signed by SAIKAT
KAR
Date: 2026.11.17 16:23:51
+05'30'
SAIKAT KAR