G.MOSES SHARAK vs STATE REP.BY
- Court
- Madras High Court
CRL A No. 291 of 2023
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
RESERVED ON : 28.10.2026
PRONOUNCED ON : 19.11.2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE A.D.JAGADISH CHANDIRA
AND
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE B.KARTHIKEYAN
CRL A No. 291 of 2023
CNR: {HCMA010484692023}
G.Moses Sharak
S/o. Gnanaprakasam,
No.3/5, Rex Street,
Chindadripet, Chennai - 600 002.
..Appellant(s)
Vs
State Rep.By
The Inspector of Police, F-1, Chindatripet Police
Station, Chennai - 600 002.
Cr.No.260/2018.
..Respondent(s)
Prayer: Criminal Appeal filed under Section 374 (2) of Crl.P.C., to set aside the
Judgment dated 24.02.2023 in SC.No.179 of 2019 passed by the learned
Sessions Judge, Mahalir Neethimandram, Allikulam, Chennai accordingly
convicted and sentenced the Appellant /Accused for offences u/s.294(b), 302,
506(ii) of IPC.
For Appellant : Mr. D.Percival Pericles
For Respondent(s): Mr.C.R.Malarvannan
Additional Public Prosecutor
__________
Page1 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 03:21:11 pm )
CRL A No. 291 of 2023
JUDGMENT
B. KARTHIKEYAN, J.
T his Criminal Appeal has been filed seeking to set aside the judgment
dated 24.02.2023 passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Mahalir
Neethimandram, Allikulam, Chennai, in S.C. No.179 of 2019.
2. The appellant, who was the sole accused before the trial Court in
S.C. No.179 of 2019, was convicted and sentenced by the learned Sessions
Judge, Mahalir Neethimandram, Allikulam, Chennai, on 24.02.2023, as follows:
Provision under
Accused Sentence
which convicted
Sole Accused Section 294(b)
Simple Imprisonment for three months and
to pay a fine of Rs.1000/-, in default to
undergo simple imprisonment for 15 days.
IPC
Section 302 IPC Rigorous Imprisonment for life and fine of
Rs.10,000/-, in default to undergo simple
imprisonment for six months.
Section 506(ii)
IPC
Rigorous imprisonment for seven years and
to pay a find of Rs.5,000/-, in default to
undergo simple imprisonment for three
months
The aforesaid sentences were ordered to run concurrently.
Out of the total fine amount of Rs.16,000/-, a sum of Rs.5,000/- each was
ordered to be paid as compensation to PW1, the husband of the deceased, and
PW2 and PW3, the son and daughter of the deceased, respectively. The
__________
Page2 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 03:21:11 pm )
CRL A No. 291 of 2023
judgment of conviction and sentence is under challenge in the present Criminal
Appeal.
3. The Inspector of Police, F-1, Chindadripet Police Station had filed a
final report in Cr.No.260 of 2018 before the learned Metropolitan Magistrate,
accusing the accused of offences under Sections 294(b), 302 and 506(ii) IPC
and the same was taken on file as PRC.No.58 of 2019, which was committed to
the learned Principal District and Sessions Court, Chennai, who took the case on
file in S.C.No.179 of 2019 and made over the case to Mahalir Neethimandram,
Allikulam, Chennai.
4. The case of the prosecution, in brief, is as follows:
The deceased Karpagam is the wife of PW1, Kaliyaperumal. PW2,
Gowtham, and PW3, Gayathri, are their children. Originally, the family of the
deceased and PW1 resided as tenants in a portion of a house owned by the
accused and his relatives at No.3/5, Rex Street, Chintadripet, Chennai. The
accused and his wife frequently quarrelled with each other, during which the
deceased Karpagam used to intervene and pacify them. Ultimately, the wife of
the accused deserted him. The accused suspected that the deceased Karpagam
was responsible for his wife's decision to leave him and consequently developed
animosity towards her. As a result, PW1 Kaliyaperumal and his family
__________
Page3 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 03:21:11 pm )
CRL A No. 291 of 2023
members vacated the premises and shifted their residence to an adjacent street,
namely, Bazaar Street, Chintadripet, Chennai. However, as they continued the
friendship with neighbours residing at Rex Street, they used to visit them on
Sundays.
5. On 09.09.2018, between 7.00 p.m. and 8.00 p.m., PW1 Kaliyaperumal,
along with his wife, the deceased Karpagam, and their children, namely, PW2
Gowtham and PW3 Gayathri, went to Rex Street. The deceased was chatting
with her friends near the lane leading towards the house of the accused. PW1
and their children were also conversing with their friends and were standing at
some distance from the deceased.
6. While the deceased Karpagam was talking to PW5 Kamala and her
daughter PW6 Sheela, who were also residing near the house where the
deceased had earlier lived as a tenant, the accused came out of his house
carrying a hammer and struck the deceased on the back of her head. As a result,
she sustained injuries and fell down. Immediately, PW1, PW2 and PW3,
namely, the husband and children of the deceased, rushed towards the accused.
However, the accused threatened them, stating that if they approached him, they
would also meet with the same fate, and thereafter fled from the scene. It is also
__________
Page4 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 03:21:11 pm )
CRL A No. 291 of 2023
the case of the prosecution that, while assaulting the deceased, the accused
abused her in filthy language, thereby causing insult and annoyance.
7. PW1 Kaliyaperumal, along with his children, took the injured
Karpagam to Government Rajiv Gandhi General Hospital, Chennai, where she
was admitted. PW11 Dr. Dineshkumar, who was on duty as the Casualty
Medical Officer on 09.09.2018 at 8.45 p.m., examined the injured Karpagam.
At that time, she was semi-conscious and was reported to have suffered
vomiting, loss of consciousness and headache. Her blood pressure was also
found to be high. However, no external injuries were noticed. PW11
administered first aid and referred the patient for further treatment as an
inpatient. Intimation was also sent to the police from the hospital.
8. On 09.09.2018, at about 9.00 p.m., PW12 Mareeswaran, the then Sub-
Inspector of Police, F-1, Chindadripet Police Station received the said
intimation from Government Rajiv Gandhi General Hospital and proceeded to
the hospital. He found the injured Karpagam undergoing treatment in Ward
No.201. Since she was unconscious, he recorded the complaint statement given
by her husband, PW1 Kaliyaperumal, at the hospital. Thereafter, he returned to
the police station and at 10.15 p.m. registered a case in Crime No.260 of 2018
for the offences under Sections 341, 294(b), 324, 307 and 506(ii) IPC.
__________
Page5 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 03:21:11 pm )
CRL A No. 291 of 2023
9. PW13 Murugesan, Inspector of Police, F1 Chintadripet Police Station,
took up the case for investigation. He visited the place of occurrence at 10.40
p.m. and prepared an observation mahazar and a rough sketch in the presence of
witnesses PW7 Prabhu and one Akash. He also examined the other witnesses,
including those who were projected as eyewitnesses to the occurrence. On the
next day, i.e., 10.09.2018, at 12.30 p.m., the Investigating Officer attempted to
arrest the accused at the junction of Anna Salai and West Cooum Road,
Chintadripet. However, the accused attempted to escape, fell into a rubbish heap
and sustained injuries, including a fracture in his right hand. At 12.45 p.m., the
accused was arrested and brought to the police station. Thereafter, he was sent
to Government Rajiv Gandhi General Hospital for medical treatment for the
injuries sustained by him.
10. Subsequently, at 3.30 p.m., during interrogation, the accused gave a
voluntary confession statement. The same was recorded in the presence of
Saravanan and PW8 Veera. Pursuant to his disclosure statement, wherein the
accused offered to identify and produce the weapon used in the commission of
the offence, the accused was taken to Rex Street, Chintadripet. He identified
and produced a hammer from a gutter near a church. The same was seized under
the seizure mahazar marked as Ex.P11 in the presence of the same witnesses.
__________
Page6 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 03:21:11 pm )
CRL A No. 291 of 2023
11. On 11.09.2018, at 12.15 a.m., the Investigating Officer, PW13,
received information that Karpagam, who had been undergoing treatment at the
hospital, had succumbed to her injuries on 10.09.2018 at 9.45 p.m., despite
treatment. Based on the said information, PW13 altered the offences to Section
302 IPC. On 11.09.2018 itself, between 9.45 a.m. and 10.45 a.m., he
conducted an inquest over the body of the deceased Karpagam in the presence
of panchayatdars and prepared an inquest report, which was marked as Ex.P14.
12. PW9 Dr. Narendra received a requisition for conducting the post-
mortem examination from the Investigation Officer through PW10 Heymindar
and conducted the post-mortem on 11.09.2018 at 11.40 a.m. He issued the post-
mortem certificate, which was marked as Ex.P5, opining that the deceased had
died due to the effects of head injuries. The viscera collected from the body of
the deceased was sent to the Forensic Science Laboratory for analysis.
However, the viscera report was not received. The Investigating Officer
thereafter examined and recorded the statements of the medical officer, Dr.
Narendra, who conducted the post-mortem examination, PW10 Heymindar, the
Police Head Constable, and PW12 Mareeswaran, the Sub-Inspector of Police.
He also recorded the statements of other witnesses completed the investigation
and filed the final report.
__________
Page7 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 03:21:11 pm )
CRL A No. 291 of 2023
13. Based on the above materials, the trial Court framed charges under
Section 294(b), 301 and 506(ii) IPC against the accused for the offences
referred to above. The accused denied the charges, resulting in the trial.
To substantiate its case, the prosecution examined PW1 to PW13 and marked
Ex.P1 to Ex.P33. The iron hammer with a wooden handle was marked as MO1.
14. The husband of the deceased, PW1, their children, PW2 and PW3,
and the neighbours, PW4, PW5 and PW6, were cited as eyewitnesses to the
occurrence. However, before the trial Court, PW4 did not support the case of
the prosecution and turned hostile. PW1, PW2, PW3 and PW6 deposed that the
accused assaulted the deceased on the back of her head. On the other hand, PW5
deposed that the accused assaulted the deceased on the right side of her head by
gesturing towards the right side of her head.
15. Though PW8 Veera identified his signature in the confession and
seizure mahazars, he did not fully support the case of the prosecution. However,
when he was cross-examined by the prosecution after being treated as hostile,
he admitted that he had witnessed the recording of the confession statement and
the seizure of the hammer, had signed as a witness and also identified the
hammer.
__________
Page8 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 03:21:11 pm )
CRL A No. 291 of 2023
16. The evidence of PW9 Dr. Narendra, who conducted the post-mortem
examination, was to the effect that the deceased died due to the effects of head
injuries.
17. PW12 Mareeswaran, Sub-Inspector of Police, spoke about the receipt
of the complaint from PW1 and the registration of the FIR in Crime No.260 of
2018 for the offences under Sections 341, 294(b), 324, 307 and 506(ii) IPC.
PW13 Murugesan, the Investigating Officer, spoke about receiving the copy of
the FIR and the investigation conducted by him, besides the arrest of the
accused and the recovery of MO1 hammer pursuant to the confession and
disclosure statement given by the accused. He also spoke about the alteration of
the FIR and the filing of the final report against the accused for the offences
under Sections 341, 509, 302 and 506(ii) IPC.
18. When the incriminating circumstances appearing against the accused
were put to him under Section 313 Cr.P.C., he denied the same as false. He
further stated that his mother and maternal uncle had filed a case in respect of
their property in the year 2014. He also claimed that his relatives and the tenants
had filed a false case against him with the intention of grabbing the property and
that they had threatened him with filing false cases. On behalf of the defence,
the accused examined himself as DW1. However, no documentary evidence
__________
Page9 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 03:21:11 pm )
CRL A No. 291 of 2023
was produced on his behalf. In his evidence as DW1, he spoke about the alleged
dispute between him and his other family members, besides his arrest and
remand.
19. Having considered the above materials, the trial Court found the
accused guilty of the offences under Sections 294(b), 302 and 506(ii) IPC and
sentenced him as stated above. The said conviction and sentence are under
challenge in the present Criminal Appeal.
20. Heard the learned counsel appearing for the appellant and the learned
Additional Public Prosecutor appearing for the respondent/State and perused the
records.
21. As pointed out above, PW1 to PW6 were cited as eyewitnesses, out of
whom PW4 turned hostile. Insofar as PW1, PW2, PW3 and PW6 are
concerned, they have deposed that, on 09.09.2018 at about 7.45 p.m., the
accused came out of his house holding a hammer and struck the deceased
Karpagam on the back of her head. On the other hand, PW5 claimed that the
accused assaulted the deceased on the right side of her head. Whereas, the
medical evidence, in the form of the accident report (Ex.P7), post-mortem
certificate, Ex.P5, and the evidence of the doctor who conducted the post-
__________
Page10 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 03:21:11 pm )
CRL A No. 291 of 2023
mortem examination, PW9, indicate that the head injury was on the left side of
the head. This would be pointed out by the learned counsel appearing for the
appellant to dispute the veracity of the prosecution claim that they are eye
witnesses.
22. Apart from the above, the learned counsel for the appellant would
point out that PW5 and PW6, who were projected as eyewitnesses, have
disputed the presence of PW1, PW2, PW3 and PW4 at the scene of occurrence
at the relevant time. In this regard, it is pointed out that PW5 categorically
stated during her cross-examination that, at the time of the incident, the husband
of Karpagam, namely, PW1, was not present. She further stated that the son and
daughter of Karpagam were also not present, as they had gone to the church.
PW6 also made a similar statement.
23. Thus, it is the contention of the learned counsel for the appellant that,
in view of the evidence of PW5 and PW6, who were projected as independent
eyewitnesses by the prosecution, the presence of PW1, PW2 and PW3 at the
scene of occurrence is completely ruled out.
24. This apart, it is pointed out that, though the case of the prosecution is
that the accused was arrested on 10.09.2018 at 12.30 p.m. near the junction of
__________
Page11 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 03:21:11 pm )
CRL A No. 291 of 2023
Anna Salai and West Cooum Road and that, at 3.30 p.m., he gave a disclosure
statement in the presence of PW8 Veera and one Saravanan, pursuant to which
the hammer allegedly used for committing the offence was recovered from the
place where it had been concealed, PW5 and PW6 have deposed that, on the
very next day of the occurrence, namely, 10.09.2018, the police visited the
place of occurrence and recovered the hammer from a gutter at the instance of
the accused. According to the learned counsel for the appellant, this evidence
renders the prosecution claim regarding the arrest of the accused and the manner
in which MO1 was recovered as completely false.
25. The learned counsel for the appellant would also contend that the
failure of the prosecution to examine the doctors who treated the injured
Karpagam during the intervening period, from the time of her admission in the
hospital until her death on 10.09.2018 at 9.45 pm, is fatal to the prosecution
case. According to him, unless the details of the treatment administered to the
deceased are brought on record, it cannot be conclusively stated that she died on
account of the injuries allegedly inflicted by the accused.
26. Per contra, the learned Additional Public Prosecutor appearing for the
respondent would vehemently contend that PW1, PW2 and PW3 have clearly
described the manner in which the deceased was assaulted by the accused.
__________
Page12 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 03:21:11 pm )
CRL A No. 291 of 2023
Further, the medical evidence, particularly the post-mortem report, clearly
establishes that the deceased died due to the head injuries sustained by her.
27. Insofar as the discrepancy regarding the location of the injury on the
deceased is concerned, the learned Additional Public Prosecutor would submit
that the objections raised by the learned counsel for the appellant are
unsustainable. It would be pointed out that the incident occurred suddenly and
the witnesses would have been in a state of panic. It is not possible for an
ordinary person witnessing such an incident to remember with clinical precision
the exact portion of the head on which the accused assaulted the deceased.
28. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor would further submit that
all the witnesses, namely, PW1, PW2, PW3, PW5 and PW6, have categorically
stated that they saw the accused assaulting the deceased with a hammer on her
head. According to him, the said evidence is sufficient to sustain the conviction
recorded by the trial Court.
29. Considering that before looking at the culpability of the accused, it
has to be established first that the death of the victim is a culpable homicide
amounting to murder, we proceed to look into the objections of the appellant as
to the cause of death. In this regard, the post-mortem certificate, Ex.P5, and
__________
Page13 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 03:21:11 pm )
CRL A No. 291 of 2023
the evidence of PW9 indicate the presence of the following ante-mortem
injuries:
“1. Dark red contusion measuring 1 x 1 x 0.5 cm on
the back of the middle third of the left arm.
2. Sutured surgical incised wound measuring 20 cm
on the left fronto-temporo-parietal region of the scalp. On
removal of the sutures, the wound measured 20 x 0.5 cm,
extending up to the scalp, with regular and gaping
margins. On reflection of the scalp, dark red bruising
measuring 17 x 16 cm, extending up to the scalp, was
found on the left fronto-temporo-parietal region. Bony
deficiency measuring 4 x 4 cm was noticed on the left
temporal bone, with a radiating fissure fracture measuring
5 cm on the left temporo-occipital bone. Diffuse dark red
bruising was noticed on the left temporalis muscle. On
removal of the calvarium, the dura mater was found intact.
A thick film of dark red subdural and subarachnoid
haemorrhage was noticed on the surfaces of the right and
left cerebral and cerebellar hemispheres. The brain was
soft and oedematous. Lacerations measuring 2 x 1 x 1 cm
and 1 x 1 x 1 cm were noticed on the left and right
temporal lobes, respectively. Another laceration measuring
1 x 1 x 1 cm was noticed on the inferior surface of the right
frontal lobe. On cut section, the findings were normal. A
fracture measuring 6 cm was noticed on the floor of the left
side of the middle cranial fossa.”
30. PW9, the doctor who conducted the post-mortem examination, has
vouched for the contents of the post-mortem certificate and deposed that the
deceased would have died on account of the injuries sustained by her on the
head.
__________
Page14 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 03:21:11 pm )
CRL A No. 291 of 2023
31. A perusal of the post-mortem certificate and the evidence of PW9
reveals the presence of several internal injuries, including bony deficiency
measuring 4 x 4 cm on the left temporal bone, with a radiating fissure fracture
measuring 5 cm on the left temporo-occipital bone, and a fracture measuring 6
cm on the floor of the left side of the middle cranial fossa. These injuries, along
with the other injuries to the head mentioned in the post-mortem certificate and
spoken to by PW9, clearly indicate that they could have been caused by an
assault with a hammer.
32. Even though, the learned counsel would point out to the non
examination of the doctor who treated the deceased from the time she was
admitted in the hospital till her death and the non production of chemical
analysis report of viscera issued by the forensic department and the final
opinion of the PW9 after taking note of the findings therein, we are of the view
that these contentions have not been raised by the defence before the trial Court
either during the cross examination of PW9, doctor who conducted post-mortem
report or the PW13 investigation officer. Therefore, it is too late in the day to
question the cause of death particularly in the light of the categorical assertion
of PW9 both before the Court as well as in Ex. P5 post-mortem report that the
deceased would appear to have died due to effects of head injuries. Even when
__________
Page15 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 03:21:11 pm )
CRL A No. 291 of 2023
PW13, the Investigation Officer was cross examined by the defence, the
evidence of the doctor that the deceased would have died on account of the
injuries sustained by her on the head has not been disputed. It was only been
suggested that the deceased would have fallen down due to which such injuries,
which caused her death would have occurred.
33. Next in question is the presence of PW1, PW2, PW3, PW5 and PW6
in the scene of occurrence. In this regard, it is pointed out that PW1, PW2,
PW3 and PW6 have claimed that the deceased was struck on the back of her
head, whereas PW5 has stated that she was struck on the right side of her head.
However, as rightly pointed out by the learned Additional Public Prosecutor,
when an incident of this nature occurs suddenly, the witnesses around would
have been in a state of panic. Therefore, it is highly improbable for an ordinary
person to remember with exact precision the particular portion of the head on
which the accused struck the deceased with the hammer.
34. Moreover, one aspect that remains consistent in the evidences of
PW1, PW2, PW3, PW5 and PW6 is that, on 09.09.2018, at about 08.00pm, the
accused assaulted the deceased on her head with a hammer, which corresponds
to the ante mortem injuries identified on the body of the deceased by PW9 in
the post-mortem report, which in turn, correspond to injuries that could have
__________
Page16 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 03:21:11 pm )
CRL A No. 291 of 2023
been caused by an assault with a hammer. Therefore, merely because the eye
witnesses had not precisely stated the portion of head of the deceased in which
the accused struck with the hammer, their evidence, cannot be discarded.
35. The other contention raised by the learned counsel for the appellant is
that PW5 and PW6 have deposed that the relatives of Karpagam, more
particularly her husband and children, were not present at the scene of
occurrence at the relevant time. In this regard, it is noticed that PW5 and PW6
have, in fact, stated during her chief examination that the deceased was present
along with her relatives. It was only when a suggestion was put to them on
behalf of the accused during cross examination to the effect that the husband
and children of Karpagam were not present at the scene of occurrence that they
had admitted the same. This would not necessarily mean that what they stated
during their chief examination is false. It would only mean that the witnesses
are making inconsistent statements, which would only lead to an enquiry as to
whether these witnesses are trustworthy and whether they can be relied upon.
Certainly, on the aspects in which they made inconsistent statements, it would
not be safe to fall back upon their evidence. However, it is settled principle
now that “ falsus in uno, falsus in omnibus ” has no application to the Courts in
India and it is the duty of the Court to remove the chaff from the grain in its
pursuit for truth. Reliance in this regard is placed on the decision of Supreme
__________
Page17 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 03:21:11 pm )
CRL A No. 291 of 2023
Court in T.G.Krishnamurthy vs. State of Karnataka , reported in 2023 LiveLaw
(SC) 671 and Mahendran vs. State of Tamil Nadu reported in AIR 2019 SC
1719 .
36. We are of the view that the evidence of PW5 and PW6 are otherwise
consistent and trustworthy. They are individuals who reside near the scene of
occurrence is not in dispute. Similarly, they are acquainted with both accused
and the deceased is also not disputed. No reason has been suggested for them to
adduce false evidence against the accused. Looking at the evidence of PW5 and
PW6 in totality, their account of assault on the deceased appear believable. The
only discrepancy pointed out by the defence with regard to the evidence of PW5
is that she had spoken about the deceased having sustained injuries on the right
side of her head but there cannot be a reason to disbelieve her totally.
37. Insofar as the question of motive is concerned, the learned counsel for
the appellant would contend that the alleged motive is a very weak motive and
is highly unbelievable, pointing out that several days had elapsed after the wife
of the accused left him and that there was no reason for the accused to have
become agitated and committed such an offence after the lapse of considerable
time. However, in a case where there is believable evidence in the form of
eyewitness testimony, motive loses its significance and would not be relevant.
__________
Page18 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 03:21:11 pm )
CRL A No. 291 of 2023
Reliance in this regard is placed on the decision on Supreme Court in Madan
vs. State of Uttar Pradesh , reported in (2023) SCC OnLine SC 1473 relying on
its earlier decision in Darbara Singh vs.State of Punjab , reported in AIR 2013
SC 840 . Therefore, in the case on hand, where the eye witness accounts of PW1
to PW3, PW5 and PW6 are trustworthy, motive pales into insignificance.
38. Similarly, a discrepancy is noticed with regard to the alleged
recovery of the hammer from a gutter near the scene of occurrence. While the
consistent case of the prosecution is that MO1 was recovered on 10.09.2018
pursuant to the disclosure statement made by the accused after his arrest, the
evidence of PW5 and PW6 indicates that the police had visited the scene of
occurrence on the following day and recovered the hammer from a gutter at the
instance of the accused.
39. However, this discrepancy deserves to be brushed away as one of
those instances where investigating officers, in their anxiety to present a
foolproof case, have gone to any extent in the course of investigation, as merely
for the fault of the investigation officer, truth cannot be allowed to suffer. It is
well settled that even if the weapon allegedly used by the accused in assaulting
the deceased is not recovered or its recovery is found to be doubtful, the same
would not, by itself, vitiate the prosecution case based on ocular evidence
__________
Page19 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 03:21:11 pm )
CRL A No. 291 of 2023
corroborated by medical evidence. Reliance in this regard is placed on the
decision of Supreme Court in Om Pal and others Vs. State of U.P (Now state
of Uttarakhand) , reported in 2025 INSC 1262 , relying upon its earlier decision
in Nankaunoo vs. State of U.P. reported in 2016 (3) SCC 317 .
40. The ocular evidence of PW1, PW2, PW3, PW5 and PW6 is that the
accused assaulted the deceased on her head with a hammer. Further, the injuries
mentioned in the post-mortem report, which ultimately led to her death,
correspond to the nature of the assault spoken to by the eyewitnesses. Therefore,
the discrepancy in the prosecution case regarding the recovery of the hammer
would not, by itself, vitiate the prosecution case.
41. The facts do not permit us to invoke any of the exceptions to Section
300 of IPC nor was it canvassed on behalf of the appellant. In such
circumstances, we are of the view that there are no grounds to interfere with the
findings of the trial Court insofar as the offence under Section 302 IPC is
concerned, and consequently, the conviction of the accused for the offence
punishable under Section 302 IPC deserves to be confirmed.
42. However, insofar as the offence under Section 294(b) IPC is
concerned, it is settled law that mere utterance of swear words, profanity or
__________
Page20 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 03:21:11 pm )
CRL A No. 291 of 2023
using vulgar expletives is not sufficient to make out an offence. The
prosecution must establish that the alleged words were lascivious, appeals to
prurient interest, tends deprave or corrupt impressionable minds and causes
annoyance in a public place. Reliance in this regard is placed on the decision of
Supreme Court in Mani @ Subramaniyan vs. State of Tamil Nadu , reported in
2025 INSC 719 . In the present case, there is no material to establish the said
essential ingredients of the said offence.
43. Moreover, PW1 has stated that, when the accused assaulted his wife,
he abused her by uttering the following words:
“ vd; kidtpia vjphp mof;Fk; nghJ mrp ’ ';fkhf nfhj;jh cd;dhy; jhd; vd;
FLk;gk; bfl;Lg;ngha; t[pl;L vd;W Twp moj;jhh;/ ”
On the other hand, PW2 claims that the accused abused his mother by
calling her “ njtpoah . ”
However, PW2 has not stated that the accused used the same words spoken to
by PW1. PW3, PW5 and PW6 have not stated anything about the specific words
allegedly uttered by the accused during the assault.
44. In such circumstances, the evidence of PW1 and PW2, with regard to
the alleged offence under Section 294(b) IPC, is insufficient to establish the
__________
Page21 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 03:21:11 pm )
CRL A No. 291 of 2023
commission of the said offence. Therefore, the conviction of the accused under
Section 294(b) IPC cannot be sustained and deserves to be set aside.
45. Insofar as the offence under Section 506(ii) IPC is concerned, the
evidence of PW1 is silent regarding any specific threat allegedly made by the
accused. It is only PW2 who has claimed that, when he and PW1 approached
the accused, the accused threatened them with similar consequences. More
over, in the decision in Mani @ Subramaniyan vs. State of Tamil Nadu,
reported in 2025 INSC 719 referred above, the Supreme Court has pointed out
that for conviction under an offence of Criminal intimidation, it must be shown
that there was an act of such threat. In the present case, even assuming that the
evidence of PW2 in this regard is sufficient, there is no proof that such threat
was intended to cause alarm to the complainant and other eyewitnesses to do or
to omit to do any act.
46. Considering the same, we are of the view that conviction under
Section 506(ii) IPC cannot be sustained. Accordingly, the conviction and
sentence imposed on the accused for the offence under Section 506(ii) IPC also
deserve to be set aside.
__________
Page22 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 03:21:11 pm )
CRL A No. 291 of 2023
47. In the result, the Criminal Appeal is partly allowed. The conviction
and sentence imposed on the appellant/accused for the offence under Section
302 IPC are confirmed. However, the conviction and sentence imposed for the
offences under Sections 294(b) and 506(ii) IPC are set aside.
(A.D.J.C.,J.) (B.K.,J.)
19 -11-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes/No
av
To
1. The learned Sessions Judge,
Mahalir Neethimandram, Allikulam, Chennai.
2.The Inspector of Police,
F-1, Chindatripet Police Station,
Chennai - 600 002.
3.The Superintendent of Prison
Central Prison, Chennai.
4.The Public Prosecutor,
Madras High Court, Chennai.
__________
Page23 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 03:21:11 pm )
CRL A No. 291 of 2023
A.D.JAGADISH CHANDIRA, J.
AND
B.KARTHIKEYAN, J.
av
Pre-delivery Judgment made in
CRL A No. 291 of 2023
19-11-2026
__________
Page24 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 03:21:11 pm )