Nitin Dhansinghn Ayadban vs The State Of Maharashtra And Ors.

Court
Bombay High Court

CNR No : HCBM010419072010

WP-9739-2010 Judgment.doc
Digitally
signed by
GAURI AMIT
GAEKWAD
Date:
2026.11.21
13:00:03
+0530
GAURI
AMIT
GAEKWAD
Gauri Gaekwad
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO. 9739 OF 2010
NITIN DHANSINGH AYADBAN
Aged 32 years, Occ. Nil,
R/at Sai Baba Colony Balkanji Bari,
Khemani Road, Central Hospital Area,
Ulhasnagar – 421 002
Dist. Thane …PETITIONER
~ versus ~
1) THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA,
Through the Secretary,
Revenue and Forest Department,
Mantralaya, Mumbai.
2) THE SETTLEMENT
COMMISSIONER AND DIRECTOR,
Land Record (Maharashtra State),
New Administrative Building,
Pune.
3) THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR,
Land Records, Konkan Region,
st
D.D. Building, 1 Floor,
Old Custom House, Fort, Mumbai.
4) THE SUPERINTENDENT LAND
RECORD,
Collector Office Compound,
Ratnagiri, Dist. Ratnagiri.
5) TALUKA SUPERVISOR LAND
Page 1 of 9
rd
3 NOVEMBER, 2026.
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 13:20:51

WP-9739-2010 Judgment.doc
RECORDS OFFICE ,
Land Records, Chiplun,
Near Tahasildar Office,
Dist. Ratnagiri. …RESPONDENTS
APPEARANCE
For the Petitioner Mr. Amol Arun Shinde
For the Respondent – State Mr. A.I. Patel, Addl. GP a/w.
Mrs. R.M. Shinde, AGP
CORAM : SUMAN SHYAM &
GAUTAM A. ANKHAD, JJ.
th
RESERVED ON : 27 OCTOBER, 2026.
st
PRONOUNCED ON : 21 NOVEMBER, 2026.
JUDGMENT ( Per Gautam Ankhad, J) :-
1. The Petitioner has filed the present Petition challenging the
th
order dated 15 October 2010 passed by the learned Maharashtra
Administrative Tribunal, Mumbai (“Tribunal”) in Original
Application No.46 of 2010. By the impugned order, the Tribunal
has rejected the Petitioner's claim for reinstatement to the post of
Surveyor Clerk-cum-Typist in the office of Respondent No.4-
Superintendent of Land Records, District Ratnagiri.
Page 2 of 9
rd
3 NOVEMBER, 2026.
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 13:20:51

WP-9739-2010 Judgment.doc
2. Briefly stated, the material facts are as follows:-
(i) Respondent No.3 issued an advertisement dated
th
19 October 2007 inviting applications for various
posts in the Department of Land Records, including
144 applications for the posts of Surveyor Clerk-cum-
Typist. The Petitioner was appointed to the said post
st
and he joined service on 31 January 2009. He was
th
deputed for training in March 2009 and on 12 May
st
2009, he proceeded on medical leave until 31 May
2009.
(ii) In the meantime, the Petitioner had received
th
appointment letter dated 29 April 2009 for the post of
Junior Clerk in the District and Sessions Court, Thane.
th
(iii) On 10 June 2009, the Petitioner tendered his
resignation to Respondent No.3 and deposited an
amount of Rs.4,575/-, equivalent to one month’s salary,
in accordance with the applicable condition of his
appointment.
th
(iv) On 12 June 2009, the Petitioner joined the District
and Sessions Court, Thane and worked there until
Page 3 of 9
rd
3 NOVEMBER, 2026.
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 13:20:51

WP-9739-2010 Judgment.doc
th
6 July 2009, for approximately 25 days.
(v) The Petitioner thereafter sought to return to the
Department of Land Records and therefore, on
th
4 July 2009, he had resigned from the post of Junior
Clerk in the District and Sessions Court, Thane.
th
(vi) On 30 June 2009, the Petitioner, by his letter to
Respondent No.3, sought to withdraw his resignation
and requested Respondent No.3 not to accept the same.
Respondent No.3 called for a report and after
examining the relevant circumstances, by its orders
th th
dated 16 and 18 January 2010, rejected the
Petitioner’s request for withdrawal of resignation.
3. Aggrieved by the decision of Respondent No.3, the Petitioner
approached the Tribunal by filing Original Application No.46 of
2010, seeking reinstatement to the post of Surveyor Clerk-cum-
th
Typist with effect from 10 June 2009, together with consequential
th
service benefits. By the impugned order dated 15 October 2010,
the Tribunal dismissed the said Original Application. Hence this
writ petition.
Page 4 of 9
rd
3 NOVEMBER, 2026.
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 13:20:51

WP-9739-2010 Judgment.doc
4. Mr. Shinde, learned counsel appearing for the Petitioner,
submits that although the Petitioner had tendered his resignation on
th
10 June 2009 to the Respondent No.3, he subsequently sought to
th
withdraw the same on 30 June 2009. According to him, no
communication accepting the resignation had been issued to the
Petitioner before its withdrawal. If at all, the resignation was
th th
accepted only on 16 /18 January 2010 and, therefore, the
departmental authorities were not justified in treating the
th
Petitioner's services as having come to an end with effect from 10
June 2009. Thus, the impugned order deserves to be set aside and
the Petitioner ought to be reinstated to the post of Surveyor Clerk-
th
cum-Typist with effect from 10 June 2009, with all consequential
benefits.
5. On the other hand, Mr. Patel, learned Additional Government
Pleader appearing for the Respondents, opposes the Petition and
th
relies upon the reply affidavits dated 30 September 2024,
th rd
17 April 2025 and 3 December 2025. The learned AGP submits
that the Petitioner’s appointment as a Surveyor Clerk-cum-Typist
was subject to the terms and conditions stipulated in his
st
appointment order dated 21 January 2009. In particular, Condition
Page 5 of 9
rd
3 NOVEMBER, 2026.
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 13:20:51

WP-9739-2010 Judgment.doc
No.13 required the Petitioner to give one month advance notice, in
the event of resignation, or to submit his resignation along with one
month's salary. The Petitioner complied with this requirement by
tendering his resignation and depositing the stipulated amount. It is
further submitted that for re-joining the Petitioner was required to
furnish an affidavit in terms of the Government Resolution dated
nd
2 December 1997, declaring that he had not been employed in any
private establishment or Government service during the intervening
period. The Petitioner admittedly did not furnish the requisite
affidavit. Hence this petition ought to be dismissed.
Reasons:
6. We have considered the rival submissions and perused the
th
record. The Petitioner tendered his resignation on 10 June 2009
and, in accordance with the conditions of his employment,
deposited one month's salary along with his resignation. On the
very next day, he joined the District and Sessions Court, Thane,
where he continued to work for approximately 25 days before
seeking to return to the Department of Land Records. The only
issue is whether, having tendered his resignation and taken up an
Page 6 of 9
rd
3 NOVEMBER, 2026.
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 13:20:51

WP-9739-2010 Judgment.doc
alternative employment, the Petitioner had retained any subsisting
right to return to his previous post.
7. In a matter involving disputed question of fact, the scope of
interference by this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India is limited. This Court would not reappreciate the evidence or
substitute its own findings for those recorded by the Tribunal,
unless the impugned decision suffers from a jurisdictional error,
breach of the principles of Natural Justice, violation of fundamental
rights, or manifest arbitrariness or perversity. In the present case,
we find no such infirmity in the order of the Tribunal, warranting
interference. The Tribunal has duly considered the relevant facts
and assigned cogent reasons for rejecting the Petitioner's claim. We,
therefore, find no good ground to interfere with the impugned order.
8. Having considered the record, we note the submission of the
th
learned AGP that Respondent No.3’s order dated 16 January 2010,
th
which was subsequently corrected by order dated 18 January 2010,
expressly records that the resignation of the Petitioner had been
accepted, is correct. It also records that the Petitioner had not
furnished documents to consider the request for withdrawal of his
Page 7 of 9
rd
3 NOVEMBER, 2026.
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 13:20:51

WP-9739-2010 Judgment.doc
resignation as a result of which his request to withdraw the
resignation was not considered. These are factual matters, which
have not been disputed by the Petitioner.
9. We may also note herein that the Petitioner’s appointment
was governed by the conditions stipulated in the appointment order
st
dated 21 January 2009. Condition No.6 restricted a candidate from
applying for another post outside the Department within one year of
service without prior approval of the competent authority.
Condition No.10 provided for recovery of the expenditure incurred
by the Government on training if the candidate accepted another
employment. Condition No.13 required an employee, seeking to
resign, to submit his resignation along with one month’s salary in
lieu of serving one month notice period. Cumulatively read, the
conditions indicate that there would be consequences for accepting
alternative employment. The Petitioner resigned and as per the
Condition No.13 deposited one month’s salary.
10. As regards reinstatement, the Petitioner resigned from
Respondent No.4 in 2009, and a considerable period has since
elapsed. In all likelihood, the resultant vacancy would have been
Page 8 of 9
rd
3 NOVEMBER, 2026.
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 13:20:51

WP-9739-2010 Judgment.doc
filled up by now. The Petitioner has not produced anything on
record to demonstrate that even today, the posts are available. For
the above reasons, we do not find that the approach of the
Department or the Tribunal is unreasonable or arbitrary calling for
interference in our writ jurisdiction. The Petition is accordingly
dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.
(GAUTAM A. ANKHAD, J.) (SUMAN SHYAM, J.)
Page 9 of 9
rd
3 NOVEMBER, 2026.
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 13:20:51
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)