Satish Motiani & Ors. vs T Choithram Foundation & Ors.

Court
Delhi High Court

* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
% Reserved on:04.08.2026
Date of decision:20.11.2026
# CNR No. DLHC010346452026
+ FAO(OS) 78/2026, CM APPL. 49914/2026 & CM APPL. 49915/2026
SATISH MOTIANI & ORS. .....Appellants
Through: Mr. Gaurav Khanna, Mr. Gautam
Barnwal, Ms. Sakshi Attri and
Ms. Astha Agarwal, Advs.

versus

T CHOITHRAM FOUNDATION & ORS. .....Respondents
Through: Mr. Abhimanyu Mahajan with
Ms. Amritananda Chakravorty,
Mr. Mihir Samson, Ms. Shreya
Munoth, Ms. Asawari Sodhi,
Ms. Anubha Goel, Ms. Vaishnavi
Prasad, Mr. Khush Aalam Singh and
Mr. Mayank Joshi, Advs.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE VIVEK CHAUDHARY
HON’BLE MS. JUSTICE RENU BHATNAGAR
J U D G M E N T


1. The present appeal arises out of a dispute between members of the
Choithram family concerning the trusteeship and administration of two
charitable trusts, namely, Choithram Charitable Trust (“CCT”) and T.
Choithram Foundation (“TCF”). CCT was constituted by Late Shri
Thakurdas Choithram Pagarani (“the Settlor”) under a trust deed dated
29.12.1970 which is registered in Madhya Pradesh. TCF was constituted by
the same Settlor under a trust deed dated 24.05.1971 which is registered in
New Delhi. Both trusts have their administrative affairs at Indore and over the
years the said trusts are managed by members of the same family.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
Signing Date:20.11.2026
17:18:44

FAO(OS) 78/2026 Page 1 of 10

2. The Settlor passed away on 19.03.1992. Prior thereto, various members
of the family had been appointed as trustees of the two trusts. Differences
thereafter arose between the parties regarding the validity of the aforesaid
appointments. The Respondents questioned the manner in which the
appointments were made in both the trusts and alleged that the appointments
were affected without proper notice to the other trustees and without valid
meetings being convened. They also questioned the documents relied upon in
support of the appointments, including the minutes of the meetings. The
Appellants disputed these allegations and maintained that the appointments
had been validly made and duly recorded.
3. On 17.11.2021, Respondents Nos. 2 to 5 instituted RCS/A/1255 of
2021 before the Court of the XXVI Additional District Judge, Indore,
concerning CCT. CCT was arrayed as Plaintiff No. 1 and the members of the
family were arrayed as the other parties. The suit, inter alia , sought a
declaration that Defendants Nos. 2 to 6 were strangers to CCT and were not
entitled to function as its trustees.
4. Four days thereafter, on 21.11.2021, the same Respondents instituted
CS(OS) No. 609 of 2021 before this Court concerning TCF. TCF was arrayed
as Plaintiff No. 1 and the remaining parties were the same members of the
family. The reliefs sought in the two suits included declarations that
Defendants Nos. 2 to 6 were not trustees, injunctions restraining them from
functioning as trustees, challenging the minutes of the meeting dated
01.02.2019 and rendition of accounts.
5. On 24.11.2021, while considering an application under Order XXXIX
Rules 1 and 2 of CPC in CS(OS) No. 609 of 2021, this Court recorded an
undertaking on behalf of Defendants Nos. 2 to 6 that, till the next date of
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
Signing Date:20.11.2026
17:18:44

FAO(OS) 78/2026 Page 2 of 10

hearing, Defendants Nos. 2 to 6 would not represent themselves as members
of TCF, deal with its properties or hold any meeting of the trust.
6. The defendants / Appellants filed their respective written statements in
CS(OS) No. 609 of 2021 in February and March 2022. Since proceedings
concerning the two trusts were pending before the courts at Delhi and Indore,
the Appellants approached the Supreme Court by way of Transfer Petition
(Civil) No. 1228 of 2022 seeking transfer of the Delhi suit also to Indore. By
order dated 26.07.2023, the Supreme Court, declined to transfer the
proceedings but granted liberty to the Appellants to avail of the remedy under
Section 10 of CPC.
7. Pursuant thereto, on 07.08.2023, the Appellants filed IA No. 14834 of
2023 under Section 10 CPC seeking stay of CS(OS) No. 609 of 2021 during
the pendency of the earlier instituted suit at Indore. The application was
opposed by the Respondents, who filed their reply on 10.09.2023.
8. During the pendency of the said application, the Indore Court, by order
dated 18.11.2024, rejected the plaint in RCS/A/1255 of 2021 on an
application filed under Order VII Rule 11 of CPC. The suit was held to be
barred by limitation and to suffer from non-compliance with Section 26 of the
Madhya Pradesh Public Trusts Act, 1951. The appeal against the said order is
stated to be pending.
9. The application under Section 10 of CPC was heard by the learned
Single Judge and was dismissed by the impugned order dated 12.05.2026,
holding that Section 10 of CPC was not attracted since the two suits related to
two different trusts constituted under separate trust deeds and the subject
matter of the two suits was, therefore, not substantially identical.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
Signing Date:20.11.2026
17:18:44

FAO(OS) 78/2026 Page 3 of 10

10. Aggrieved by the order dated 12.05.2026, the present appeal is
preferred by the Appellants under Section 10 of the Delhi High Court Act,
1966 read with Section 151 CPC.
11. Learned counsel for the Appellants submits that the learned Single
Judge erred in dismissing the application on the ground that the two suits
concern different trusts. He submits that both suits arise out of substantially
the same dispute between the members of the Choithram family regarding the
validity of the appointments and functioning of the trustees. The parties,
allegations, documents, including the disputed appointments and minutes of
meetings as well as the reliefs sought, are substantially common. It was
contended that merely because CCT and TCF were constituted under separate
trust deeds, the subject matter of the two suits cannot be treated as different
for the purposes of Section 10 of CPC, particularly when the issues relating to
the trustees substantially overlap. He further submits that the rejection of the
plaint in the Indore proceedings on 18.11.2024 could not be a ground to
dismiss the application, as the said order is under challenge. The Appellants
accordingly sought stay of the Delhi proceedings to avoid parallel
adjudication.
12. Per contra, learned counsel for the Respondents submits that the
application under Section 10 of CPC was rightly dismissed by the Learned
Single Judge, as the two suits do not involve the same subject matter. It is
contended that CCT and TCF are two distinct trusts, constituted under
separate trust deeds dated 29.12.1970 and 24.05.1971, respectively, and that
the rights, administration and trusteeship of each trust give rise to independent
causes of action. The Respondents further submit that merely because same
persons are trustees in both the trust, it would not attract the bar under Section
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
Signing Date:20.11.2026
17:18:44

FAO(OS) 78/2026 Page 4 of 10

10 of CPC, unless it is shown that the subject matter of both suits is
substantially the same. It is also pointed out that the Indore suit already stood
rejected vide order dated 18.11.2024. The Respondents therefore contend that
there was no ground to stay the proceedings in the Delhi suit.
13. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material placed on record.
14. The question that arises for consideration is whether the proceedings in
CS(OS) No. 609 of 2021 are required to be stayed under Section 10 of CPC
on account of the earlier instituted proceedings before the Court at Indore.

15. Section 10 of CPC operates where the matter in issue in a subsequently
instituted suit is “ directly and substantially in issue ” in a previously instituted
suit between the same parties. The provision is intended to prevent two Courts
of concurrent jurisdiction from trying the same issues at the same time and
arriving at conflicting conclusions. At the same time, the mere fact that some
questions arising in the two suits are common is not enough to attract the
provision.
16. The Supreme Court in National Institute of Mental Health & Neuro
Sciences v. C. Parameshwara, (2005) 2 SCC 256, has explained that the test
for applying Section 10 of CPC is whether a decision in the previously
instituted suit would operate as res judicata in the subsequently instituted suit.
The requirement is of substantial identity of the subject matter and not merely
of some common issues. The Court held that :-
“8. The object underlying Section 10 is to prevent courts of
concurrent jurisdiction from simultaneously trying two parallel
suits in respect of the same matter in issue. The object underlying
Section 10 is to avoid two parallel trials on the same issue by two
courts and to avoid recording of conflicting findings on issues
which are directly and substantially in issue in previously instituted
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
Signing Date:20.11.2026
17:18:44

FAO(OS) 78/2026 Page 5 of 10

suit. The language of Section 10 suggests that it is referable to a
suit instituted in the civil court and it cannot apply to proceedings
of other nature instituted under any other statute. The object of
Section 10 is to prevent courts of concurrent jurisdiction from
simultaneously trying two parallel suits between the same parties
in respect of the same matter in issue. The fundamental test to
attract Section 10 is, whether on final decision being reached in the
previous suit, such decision would operate as res judicata in the
subsequent suit. Section 10 applies only in cases where the whole of
the subject-matter in both the suits is identical. The key words in
Section 10 are “the matter in issue is directly and substantially in
issue” in the previous instituted suit. The words “directly and
substantially in issue” are used in contradistinction to the words
“incidentally or collaterally in issue”. Therefore, Section 10 would
apply only if there is identity of the matter in issue in both the suits,
meaning thereby, that the whole of the subject-matter in both the
proceedings is identical.”
(emphasis supplied)

17. This position was reiterated in Aspi Jal v. Khushroo Rustom
Dadyburjor, (2013) 4 SCC 333 . The Supreme Court held that even where the
parties and some of the issues are common, Section 10 of CPC would not
apply if the causes of action are different. The Court held that the relevant
question is whether, even if the earlier suit were to fail, the plaintiff could still
obtain the relief claimed in the subsequent suit. The Court held that:-
“ 11. In the present case, the parties in all the three suits are one
and the same and the court in which the first two suits have been
instituted is competent to grant the relief claimed in the third suit.
The only question which invites our adjudication is as to whether
“the matter in issue is also directly and substantially in issue in
previously instituted suits”. The key words in Section 10 are “the
matter in issue is directly and substantially in issue in a previously
instituted suit”. The test for applicability of Section 10 of the Code
is whether on a final decision being reached in the previously
instituted suit, such decision would operate as res judicata in the
subsequent suit. To put it differently one may ask, can the plaintiff
get the same relief in the subsequent suit, if the earlier suit has been
dismissed? In our opinion, if the answer is in the affirmative, the
subsequent suit is not fit to be stayed. However, we hasten to add
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
Signing Date:20.11.2026
17:18:44

FAO(OS) 78/2026 Page 6 of 10

then when the matter in controversy is the same, it is immaterial
what further relief is claimed in the subsequent suit.

12. As observed earlier, for application of Section 10 of the Code,
the matter in issue in both the suits have to be directly and
substantially in issue in the previous suit but the question is what
“the matter in issue” exactly means? As in the present case, many
of the matters in issue are common, including the issue as to
whether the plaintiffs are entitled to recovery of possession of the
suit premises, but for application of Section 10 of the Code, the
entire subject-matter of the two suits must be the same. This
provision will not apply where a few of the matters in issue are
common and will apply only when the entire subject-matter in
controversy is same. In other words, the matter in issue is not
equivalent to any of the questions in issue. As stated earlier, the
eviction in the third suit has been sought on the ground of non-user
for six months prior to the institution of that suit. It has also been
sought in the earlier two suits on the same ground of non-user but
for a different period. Though the ground of eviction in the two
suits was similar, the same were based on different causes. The
plaintiffs may or may not be able to establish the ground of
non-user in the earlier two suits, but if they establish the ground of
non-user for a period of six months prior to the institution of the
third suit that may entitle them the decree for eviction. Therefore,
in our opinion, the provisions of Section 10 of the Code is not
attracted in the facts and circumstances of the case.”

18. It is in the light of these principles that the present proceedings must be
examined.
19. There is substantial similarity between the parties in the two
proceedings. The nature of the reliefs sought is also similar, both proceedings
involving challenges to the appointment and status of certain members of the
Choithram family as trustees. There is also some overlap in the documents
relied upon by the parties. These similarities, however, do not by themselves
determine the applicability of Section 10 of CPC.
20. The present suit concerns TCF, constituted under the trust deed dated
24.05.1971 and registered in New Delhi. The earlier suit before the Indore
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
Signing Date:20.11.2026
17:18:44

FAO(OS) 78/2026 Page 7 of 10

Court concerns CCT, constituted under a separate trust deed dated 29.12.1970
and registered in Madhya Pradesh. Thus, the two proceedings concern two
separate trusts and not different claims arising in respect of the same trust.
21. The distinction between the two trusts is also reflected in the manner in
which they are constituted and administered. Their respective trust deeds
contain different provisions governing, inter alia , the constitution and
strength of the Board of Trustees, quorum, meetings, notice and appointment
or removal of trustees. CCT is also governed by the Madhya Pradesh Public
Trusts Act, 1951 and the Rules framed thereunder, which do not govern TCF.
These differences are material while examining the validity of the
appointment and status of a trustee in either trust. Trustees can be appointed in
separate proceedings of each trust.
22. The fact that some of the trustees are common to both trusts does not
change the position. The same is for some of the documents which may be
common to both proceedings. As noted by the learned Single Judge, only 29
documents are common to the two sets of proceedings. More importantly, the
relevance of a document must be considered in the context of the trust to
which the proceedings relate.
23. The reliefs sought in the two suits, though similar in form, are directed
towards the trusteeship of different trusts. In the present suit, the challenge is
to the status of Defendant Nos. 2 to 6 as trustees of TCF, along with a
declaration concerning the valid trustees of that trust. The relief in the Indore
proceedings is with respect to CCT. A determination as to who is validly
appointed as a trustee of CCT would not, by itself, determine the
corresponding question in respect of TCF.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
Signing Date:20.11.2026
17:18:44

FAO(OS) 78/2026 Page 8 of 10

24. This distinction is important because the rights and obligations of the
trustees must be examined with reference to the respective trust deed and the
legal provisions applicable to that trust. The validity of an appointment in
CCT cannot automatically determine the validity of the appointment in TCF.
It follows that a decision in the Indore proceedings would not necessarily
operate as res judicata in the present suit.
25. The submission that the proceedings should nevertheless be stayed
because some findings may overlap also cannot be accepted. Avoiding
conflicting decisions is one of the main purposes of Section 10 of CPC.
However, the statutory requirement that the matter in issue must be directly
and substantially the same cannot be dispensed with merely because there is a
possibility of some overlap in the findings.
26. The subsequent rejection of the plaint in the Indore proceedings on
18.11.2024 does not alter this position. The said proceedings relate to CCT,
whereas the present proceedings relate to TCF. The findings recorded by the
Indore Court on limitation and compliance with Section 26 of the Madhya
Pradesh Public Trusts Act, 1951 therefore do not, by themselves, determine
the rights of the parties in the present suit. The fact that the order dated
18.11.2024 is under challenge also does not make the subject matter of the
two proceedings identical.
27. We are, therefore, unable to accept the contention that the commonality
of the parties, trustees or certain documents is sufficient to invoke Section 10
of CPC. The two proceedings may have a common factual background, but
the trusts involved, the governing instruments, the applicable legal provisions
are distinct.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
Signing Date:20.11.2026
17:18:44

FAO(OS) 78/2026 Page 9 of 10

28. In our view, the learned Single Judge has correctly applied the
principles governing Section 10 of CPC. The entire subject matter of the two
suits is not substantially identical, and a decision in the earlier suit concerning
CCT would not conclude the issues arising in the present suit concerning
TCF.
29. We accordingly find no error in the order dated 12.05.2026 warranting
interference in the present appeal.
30. The appeal is dismissed. The order dated 12.05.2026 passed by the
learned Single Judge in IA No. 14834/2023 in CS(OS) No. 609/2021 is
affirmed. Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of.

VIVEK CHAUDHARY
(JUDGE)



RENU BHATNAGAR
(JUDGE)
NOVEMBER 20, 2026/ ss
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
Signing Date:20.11.2026
17:18:44

FAO(OS) 78/2026 Page 10 of 10