SHAKUNTALA DEVI vs DEFENCE
- Court
- Central Administrative Tribunal
1
OA No. 3814/2023
Item No. 55/C-3
CENTRAL ADMINIST
TRATIVE TRIBUNAL
PRINCIPAL BENC
CH, NEW DELHI
OA No. 3814/20
023
Reserved on 27.10.
Pronounced on 18.11.
.2026
.2026
P
)
Hon’b
Hon’b
le Ms. Harvinder Kau
le Dr. Sumeet Jerath,
ur Oberoi, Member (J)
Member (A)
1. SHAK
SHANK
FAZALP
KUNTALA DEVI W/O LATE
KAR MARG, FIRST FLOOR,
E SH. VIJAI KRISHNA R/O
215,
LI
GALI NO. 4, MANDAWAL
PUR, DELHI-110044.
2. V. AR
D/O LAT
R/O 215
FIRST F
110044.
RCHANA
TE SH. VIJAI KRISHNA
, SHANKAR MARG,
FLOOR, GALI NO. 4, MAND
DAWALI FAZALPUR, DELH
HI-
… App
plicants
(By Adv
vocate: Mr. Gurpreet Singh)
Ver
ISITRY OF DEFENCE,
E OF JS & CAO,
sus
1. MINI
OFFICE
CAO/PE
OFFICE
2. Princ
ENSION CELL, ROOM NO. 3
E COMPLEX, AFRICA AVEN
304, A-BLOCK, DEFENCE
NUE, NEW DELHI-110023.
cipal Controller of
Defen
Praya
3. The C
nce Accounts (Pensions), Dra
agraj, Uttar Pradesh-211014.
aupadi Ghat, Near Sadar Baza
ar,
Chief Manager
o. HDFC Bank
I, Sector 4, Noida 201301.
Oppo
A-III
… Respo
ondents
(By Adv
vocate: Mr. Anil Kumar Mishr
ra, Ms. Neelima Rathore )
ARTI
2026.11.19
17:16:38
+05'30'
ARTI
2
Item No. 55/C-3 OA No. 3814/2023
O R D E R
Hon’ble Ms. Harvinder Kaur Oberoi, Member (J) : -
Learned counsel for the applicants have filed the present Original
Application seeking grant of family pension in respect of Late Shri Vijai
Krishna, Ex-Joint Director, Ministry of Defence. Applicant No. 1, Smt.
Shakuntala Devi, claims to be the wife of the deceased pensioner, whereas
Applicant No. 2 is stated to be their daughter, born on 28.08.1996.
2. Learned counsel for the applicants stated that Late Shri Vijai Krishna
was initially married to Smt. Binu Ratan on 14.02.1990. However, shortly
thereafter, Smt. Binu Ratan left the matrimonial home in the year 1991.
Subsequently, Late Shri Vijai Krishna started residing with Applicant No.
1, Smt. Shakuntala Devi, as husband and wife, and their relationship
continued for several years. Out of the said relationship, Applicant No. 2
was born on 28.08.1996. It was further stated that Applicant No. 1 had
been residing with Late Shri Vijai Krishna since 1995, maintaining the
household, looking after him and bringing up their daughter.
3. Learned counsel further stated that Late Shri Vijai Krishna was serving
as Joint Director in the Ministry of Defence. During his service tenure, he
suffered paralysis and, owing to his deteriorating health condition, opted
for voluntary retirement. It was stated that, while submitting his pension
papers, Late Shri Vijai Krishna himself disclosed the name of Applicant
ARTI
2026.11.19
17:16:38
+05'30'
ARTI
3
Item No. 55/C-3 OA No. 3814/2023
No. 1, Smt. Shakuntala Devi, as his wife. However, on account of certain
discrepancies between the earlier service records and the particulars
furnished in the pension papers, the Respondents sought clarification from
him.
4. It was further stated that Late Shri Vijai Krishna had requested Applicant
No. 1 to initiate the necessary formalities for inclusion of her name and that
of Applicant No. 2 in the family pension records. Accordingly, Applicant
No. 1 stated a representation dated 10.08.2020 to the Respondents. The
Respondents, vide communication dated 06.11.2020, requested the
Applicants to furnish the requisite documents. Pursuant thereto, the
Applicants stated the necessary documents on 12.04.2021. However, no
decision was communicated to them. Subsequently, Late Shri Vijai
Krishna expired on 15.01.2022.
5. Learned counsel stated that, after the demise of Late Shri Vijai Krishna,
Applicant No. 1 again approached the Respondents vide representation
dated 18.01.2023, requesting grant of family pension to Applicant Nos. 1
and 2. However, the Respondents, vide communication dated 15.02.2023,
rejected her claim on the ground that she was not the legally wedded wife
of the deceased pensioner.
6. Learned counsel further stated that Applicant No. 1 was initially
unaware of the first marriage of Late Shri Vijai Krishna with Smt. Binu
ARTI
2026.11.19
17:16:38
+05'30'
ARTI
4
Item No. 55/C-3 OA No. 3814/2023
Ratan and came to know about the same only when Late Shri Vijai Krishna
disclosed the said fact to her. It was contended that Applicant No. 1 had
been residing with Late Shri Vijai Krishna as his wife for several years,
had maintained the household and had discharged her familial
responsibilities towards him and their daughter. Applicant No. 1 was an
unemployed woman and had no independent source of income, whereas
Late Shri Vijai Krishna was the sole earning member of the family.
7. Per contra, learned counsel for the Respondents stated that Late Shri
Vijai Krishna joined the Armed Forces Headquarters as an Assistant on
06.02.1984. On 30.06.1992, he stated nominations in respect of DCRG and
CGEGIS in favour of his wife, Smt. Binu Ratan. Subsequently, on
20.10.1994, he stated nominations in respect of DCRG, GPF and Family
Pension in favour of his sister, Kumari Madhu Tambe, and in respect of
CGEGIS in favour of his sister, Kumari Madhu Tambe, and brother, Shri
Ajai Kumar.
8. It was stated that, after his retirement from Government service with
effect from 01.11.2018, Smt. Shakuntala Devi stated a representation dated
12.11.2018 claiming that she had married Late Shri Vijai Krishna on
05.03.1995 and requesting inclusion of her name as his wife and that of her
daughter, Miss V. Archana, in his family particulars. She had also stated
that she came to know about the earlier marriage of Late Shri Vijai Krishna
with Smt. Binu Ratan after one year of her marriage.
ARTI
2026.11.19
17:16:38
+05'30'
ARTI
5
Item No. 55/C-3 OA No. 3814/2023
9. Learned counsel for the Respondents further stated that, since the name
of Smt. Binu Ratan was recorded as the wife of Late Shri Vijai Krishna in
the service records, the latter was asked to furnish clarification vide letter
dated 15.11.2018. In response thereto, Late Shri Vijai Krishna stated
explanations dated 04.12.2018 and 21.01.2019, stating that he had married
Smt. Binu Ratan and had separated from her shortly thereafter. He further
stated that he had subsequently married Smt. Shakuntala Devi in the year
1995 and that a daughter had been born out of the said relationship.
10. The Respondents contended that Late Shri Vijai Krishna had contracted
the second marriage despite being aware that his first marriage had not
been dissolved by a decree of divorce passed by a competent Court of law.
It was further stated that neither Late Shri Vijai Krishna nor Applicant No.
1 had approached the office during his service tenure for inclusion of the
particulars of the alleged second marriage in the service records. The
officer had also not modified his earlier nominations in favour of Applicant
No. 1 or intimated the department about the alleged second marriage.
According to the Respondents, had the said fact been disclosed during his
service tenure, he would have been liable for disciplinary action.
11. Learned counsel for the Respondents further stated that Late Shri Vijai
Krishna stated his pension papers on 10.01.2019, wherein he mentioned the
name of Smt. Shakuntala Devi as his wife. However, in view of the
discrepancies in the earlier nominations and the particulars furnished in the
ARTI
2026.11.19
17:16:38
+05'30'
ARTI
6
Item No. 55/C-3 OA No. 3814/2023
pension papers, his case was processed under the category of "Two Wives
or Disputed Case", in accordance with the organisational codes prescribed
under Appendix-I of the instructions issued by PCDA(P), Allahabad.
Consequently, the Pension Payment Order was issued without including
the names of any dependants.
12. It was further stated that Smt. Shakuntala Devi, vide her application
dated 10.08.2020, forwarded a copy of the divorce decree dated 15.02.2020
and requested inclusion of her name and that of her daughter in the family
particulars of Late Shri Vijai Krishna. The Respondents, vide letter dated
06.11.2020, asked her to furnish valid proof of marriage, such as a
marriage registration certificate or an affidavit duly attested by an
Executive Magistrate. However, she stated only an affidavit attested by a
Notary Public, which, according to the Respondents, did not constitute the
requisite proof of marriage.
13. Learned counsel for the Respondents placed reliance upon Rule 50(6)
of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 2021, and stated that the term "widow" or
"widower" refers to a spouse legally wedded to the deceased Government
servant or pensioner. Reliance was also placed upon Government of India
Decision No. 13 under Rule 54 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, to
contend that a second wife is not entitled to family pension as a legally
wedded wife where the second marriage was contracted during the
subsistence of the first marriage. Accordingly, since the alleged marriage
ARTI
2026.11.19
17:16:38
+05'30'
ARTI
7
Item No. 55/C-3 OA No. 3814/2023
between Late Shri Vijai Krishna and Applicant No. 1 was solemnised in
1995, whereas the first marriage was dissolved only vide decree dated
15.02.2020, the Respondents rejected the claim of Applicant No. 1 vide
communication dated 15.02.2023.
14. In rejoinder, learned counsel for the applicants stated that the averments
made by the Respondents in their counter affidavit, insofar as they are
contrary to the pleadings and documents placed on record by the
applicants, are incorrect, misconceived and hence denied. Learned counsel
contended that the Respondents have failed to appreciate the peculiar facts
and circumstances of the present case and have rejected the claim of
Applicant No. 1 without considering the long-standing relationship
between her and Late Shri Vijai Krishna.
15. Learned counsel reiterated that Applicant No. 1 had been residing with
Late Shri Vijai Krishna as his wife since 1995 and that the relationship
continued throughout his lifetime. Out of the said relationship, Applicant
No. 2 was born on 28.08.1996. It was stated that Applicant No. 1 had
maintained the household, looked after Late Shri Vijai Krishna and brought
up their daughter. Learned counsel further stated that Applicant No. 1 was
not aware of the earlier marriage of Late Shri Vijai Krishna at the time of
entering into the relationship and came to know about the same only
subsequently, when he himself disclosed the said fact to her. Therefore,
ARTI
2026.11.19
17:16:38
+05'30'
ARTI
8
Item No. 55/C-3 OA No. 3814/2023
Applicant No. 1 ought not to be made to suffer on account of the
concealment of the earlier marriage by Late Shri Vijai Krishna.
16. Learned counsel further stated that the conduct of Late Shri Vijai
Krishna himself lends support to the claim of Applicant No. 1, inasmuch as
he had specifically mentioned her name as his wife in the pension papers
stated to the Respondents. It was contended that such acknowledgment by
the deceased pensioner during his lifetime is a significant circumstance
which could not have been ignored by the Respondents. The mere fact that
Applicant No. 1's name was not reflected in the earlier service records or
nomination forms cannot, by itself, be treated as conclusive against her
claim.
17. Learned counsel further drew attention to the fact that the first marriage
of Late Shri Vijai Krishna was subsequently dissolved by a decree of
divorce dated 15.02.2020 passed by the competent Court at Allahabad. It
was stated that the said decree has neither been challenged nor its validity
disputed by the Respondents. According to learned counsel, the subsequent
dissolution of the first marriage, when considered along with the long-
standing cohabitation between Applicant No. 1 and Late Shri Vijai
Krishna, the birth of their daughter and the acknowledgment made by the
deceased pensioner himself, constitutes a material circumstance which
ought to have been considered while examining the claim for family
pension.
ARTI
2026.11.19
17:16:38
+05'30'
ARTI
9
Item No. 55/C-3 OA No. 3814/2023
18. Learned counsel contended that the Respondents have placed undue
emphasis upon the alleged failure of Late Shri Vijai Krishna to disclose the
second marriage during his service tenure and to modify his earlier
nominations. It was stated that any such lapse on the part of the deceased
employee cannot, by itself, determine the entitlement of Applicant No. 1 to
family pension. The Respondents were required to examine the entire
factual background, including the long-standing cohabitation, the
acknowledgment made by the deceased pensioner in his pension papers
and the subsequent divorce decree, rather than rejecting the claim solely on
the basis of the earlier service records.
19. Learned counsel further stated that the legal presumption arising from
long-standing cohabitation between a man and a woman living together as
husband and wife is required to be considered in the present case. In this
regard, reliance was placed upon Section 114 of the Indian Evidence Act,
1872. It was argued that, having regard to the fact that Applicant No. 1 and
Late Shri Vijai Krishna had lived together for several years, had raised a
daughter together and that the deceased pensioner himself had
acknowledged Applicant No. 1 as his wife, a presumption in favour of the
validity of their marriage ought to be drawn.
20. Learned counsel also stated that the claim of Applicant No. 2 stands on
an independent footing, being the daughter of Late Shri Vijai Krishna, born
on 28.08.1996. It was contended that her entitlement to family pension is
ARTI
2026.11.19
17:16:38
+05'30'
ARTI
10
Item No. 55/C-3 OA No. 3814/2023
required to be examined independently under the applicable pension rules
and cannot be rejected merely because the marital status of Applicant No. 1
is disputed.
21. In support of the aforesaid submissions, the learned counsel for the
applicants have placed reliance upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Smt. Shiramabai W/o Pundalik Bhave & Ors. v. The Captain,
Record Officer for O.I.C. Records, Sena Corps Abhilekh, Gaya, Bihar
State & Anr., Civil Appeal No. 5262 of 2023, decided on 18.08.2023,
reported as 2023 INSC 744. The said judgment deals with the issue of
recognition of a marital relationship and entitlement to pensionary benefits
in circumstances where the marriage was alleged to have been contracted
during the subsistence of an earlier marriage.
22. In the aforesaid judgment, the Hon’ble Supreme Court considered
the effect of long and continuous cohabitation between a man and a woman
as husband and wife and held that such cohabitation gives rise to a
presumption in favour of a valid marriage. The Hon’ble Supreme Court,
while referring to Section 114 of the Evidence Act, observed as under:
“It is no longer res integra that if a man and woman cohabit as husband and
wife for a long duration, one can draw a presumption in their favour that
they were living together as a consequence of a valid marriage.”
23. The Hon’ble Supreme Court further reiterated that a strong
presumption arises in favour of wedlock where the parties have lived
ARTI
2026.11.19
17:16:38
+05'30'
ARTI
11
Item No. 55/C-3 OA No. 3814/2023
together for a long period as husband and wife and that the burden to rebut
such presumption lies heavily upon the party seeking to deprive the
relationship of its legal origin. The relevant observation reads as under:
“A strong presumption arises in favour of wedlock where the partners have
lived together for a long spell as husband and wife. Although the
presumption is rebuttable, a heavy burden lies on him who seeks to deprive
the relationship of legal origin. Law leans in favour of legitimacy and
frowns upon bastardy…..”
24. The Hon’ble Supreme Court, in paragraphs 20 to 22 of the said
judgment, further clarified the nature of the burden required to rebut such
presumption, in the following terms:
“20. It can be discerned from the aforesaid line of decisions that the law infers a
presumption in favour of a marriage when a man and woman have continuously
cohabitated for a long spell. No doubt, the said presumption is rebuttable and can be
rebutted by leading unimpeachable evidence. When there is any circumstance that
weakens such a presumption, courts ought not to ignore the same. The burden lies
heavily on the party who seeks to question the cohabitation and to deprive the
relationship of a legal sanctity.
21. In the instant case, if the period upto the year 1990 was to be excluded as the
marriage between Late Subedar Bhave and Anusuya had got dissolved only on 15th
November, 1990, fact remains that even thereafter, the deceased had continued to
cohabit with the appellant No. 1 for eleven long years, till his demise in the year 2001.
The appellant No.1 was the mother of two children born from the relationship with the
deceased, namely, appellants Nos.2 and 3. Appellants No.2 and 3 have been held
entitled to the estate of the deceased by virtue of the order passed by the High Court on
the Review application moved by them. In the above background, a presumption ought
to have been drawn in favour of the validity of the marriage between the deceased and
the appellant No. 1, more so, when during his life time, the deceased had approached
the respondent authorities for seeking deletion of the name of his previous wife -
Anusuya from his service record and for endorsement of the name of the appellant No.
1 therein, which was duly acted upon by the respondents vide letter dated 05th July,
1999. It is also not in dispute that the ex-wife did not claim any pension from the
respondents on the demise of Subedar Bhave.”
22. In view of the aforesaid discussion, the impugned judgment dated 25th June, 2013,
passed by the High Court of Karnataka Circuit Bench at Dharwad endorsing the order
dated 16th September, 2010, passed by the First Appellate Court cannot be sustained
and are, accordingly, quashed and set aside. The judgment and decree dated 22nd
December, 2007, passed by the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Chikodi is
restored. The appellant No.1 is held entitled to receive the pension payable on the
ARTI
2026.11.19
17:16:38
+05'30'
ARTI
12
Item No. 55/C-3 OA No. 3814/2023
demise of Late Subedar Bhave. As for the appellants No. 2 and 3, they would be
entitled to the said relief till the date they attained the age of 25 years.”
25. Applying the aforesaid principles to the facts of the present case, it is
the specific case of Applicant No. 1 that she had been residing with Late
Shri Vijai Krishna as his wife since the year 1995 and that Applicant No. 2
was born out of the said relationship on 28.08.1996. The applicants have
thus relied upon the long-standing nature of their relationship, the birth of a
child from the said relationship and the fact that Applicant No. 1 allegedly
continued to share a household with the deceased and looked after him
during his lifetime.
26. It is also relevant to notice that, as per the pleadings, Late Shri Vijai
Krishna had himself mentioned Applicant No. 1 as his wife in the pension
papers stated to the respondent authorities. This circumstance, though not
by itself conclusive of the legal status of Applicant No. 1, is a relevant
piece of material which requires consideration along with the other
evidence placed on record. The respondent authorities were, therefore,
required to examine the claim by taking into consideration the entire
factual background and the material furnished by the applicants, rather than
rejecting the claim solely on the basis of the disputed marital status.
27. The respondents have primarily opposed the claim on the ground
that the first marriage of Late Shri Vijai Krishna had not been dissolved
when he allegedly entered into the relationship with Applicant No. 1 in the
year 1995 and that the decree of divorce was passed only on 15.02.2020.
ARTI
2026.11.19
17:16:38
+05'30'
ARTI
13
Item No. 55/C-3 OA No. 3814/2023
The said objection is required to be considered in the light of the law laid
down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Shiramabai (supra), particularly
the principle that long and continuous cohabitation as husband and wife
gives rise to a rebuttable presumption in favour of marriage and that the
burden to rebut such presumption is a heavy one.
28. It is further noticed that the first marriage was dissolved by a decree
dated 15.02.2020 and Late Shri Vijai Krishna expired on 15.01.2022. Thus,
the relationship between Applicant No. 1 and the deceased continued, as
claimed, even after dissolution of the earlier marriage. The factum of the
decree of divorce and the subsequent period of cohabitation are relevant
circumstances which ought to be considered while examining the claim of
Applicant No. 1.
29. In these circumstances, the claim of Applicant No. 1 deserves
consideration in the light of the principles laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Shiramabai (supra). The respondent authorities cannot
disregard the long-standing relationship, the birth of Applicant No. 2 from
the said relationship, the deceased’s own declaration in the pension papers
and the subsequent dissolution of the earlier marriage without examining
their cumulative effect. The issue is, therefore, required to be adjudicated
on the basis of the complete material available on record and the aforesaid
binding principles of law.
ARTI
2026.11.19
17:16:38
+05'30'
ARTI
14
Item No. 55/C-3 OA No. 3814/2023
30. Accordingly, in view of the facts and circumstances of the present
case, the material placed on record, and the law laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Smt. Shiramabai W/o Pundalik Bhave & Ors. v. The
Captain, Record Officer for O.I.C. Records, Sena Corps Abhilekh, Gaya,
Bihar State & Anr., Civil Appeal No. 5262 of 2023, this Tribunal is of the
considered view that the applicants have made out a case for grant of relief.
The long-standing relationship between Applicant No. 1 and Late Shri
Vijai Krishna, the birth of Applicant No. 2 out of the said relationship, the
deceased’s own declaration of Applicant No. 1 as his wife in the pension
papers, and the subsequent dissolution of his earlier marriage by decree
dated 15.02.2020 are relevant circumstances which, when considered
cumulatively, lend support to the applicants’ claim. The respondents have
failed to dislodge the presumption arising from the long-standing
cohabitation by placing unimpeachable evidence on record. The rejection
of the claim vide communication dated 15.02.2023, therefore, cannot be
sustained in law and is accordingly set aside. The respondents are directed
to reconsider and process the claim of Applicant No. 1 for grant of family
pension, treating her as the eligible spouse of the deceased, and release the
admissible family pensionary benefits, along with consequential arrears, in
accordance with the applicable rules, within a period of eight weeks from
the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order. The claim of Applicant
No. 2 shall be examined independently in accordance with the applicable
provisions governing family pension payable to eligible children.
ARTI
2026.11.19
17:16:38
+05'30'
ARTI
15
Item No. 55/C-3 OA No. 3814/2023
31. The Original Application is allowed in the aforesaid terms. There
shall be no order as to costs.
(Dr. Sumeet Jerath) (Harvinder Kaur Oberoi)
Member (A) Member (J)
/arti/
ARTI
2026.11.19
17:16:38
+05'30'
ARTI