MR. VENKATA RAMANA C vs MRS. RAJALAKSHMI,
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59535-DB
COMAP No. 10 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010012332025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
TH
DATED THIS THE 27 DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D K SINGH
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN
COMMERCIAL APPEAL NO. 10 OF 2025
BETWEEN:
MR. VENKATA RAMANA C
AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS
S/O.LATE SRI.CHENNAMUNIYAPPA
PROPRIETOR,
M/S VENKATA RAMANA ENGINEERS & CONTRACTORS
ARCHITECTS & INTERIOR FITOUTS),
TOUCH & TOUCH BUILDING,
ST
DOOR NO.02, 1 FLOOR, BHAVANI ROAD,
HEBBAGODI, BOMMASANDRA POST, ANEKAL TQ,
ATTIBELE HOBLI, BENGALURU-560 099.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. SUKUMARAN G, ADVOCATE)
AND:
MRS. RAJALAKSHMI,
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS,
PROPRIETOR/PRINCIPAL,
MAITRI ENGLISH SCHOOL,
BEHIND TIN FACTORY, UDAYANAGAR,
A, NARAYANAPURA, K.R.PURAM,
BENGALURU-560 016.
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. RAJESH GOWDA, ADVOCATE)
THIS COMMERCIAL APPEAL UNDER SECTION 13(1A) OF THE
COMMERCIAL COURTS ACT, 2015 PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE
JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 7.11.2024 PASSED BY THE
LEARNED LXXXVII ADDITIONAL CITY CIVIL AND SESSIONS JUDGE,
(EXCLUSIVE DEDICATED COMMERCIAL COURT) BENGALURU, IN
COM.OS NO.1148/2024 AGAINST THE APPELLANT AND ALLOW THE
APPEAL IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
Digitally signed
by B VEENA
KUMARI
Location:
HIGH COURT
OF
KARNATAKA
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59535-DB
COMAP No. 10 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010012332025
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR ORDERS, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D K SINGH
AND
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN)
This Commercial Appeal is directed against the judgment
and decree dated 07.11.2024 passed by the LXXXVII Additional
City Civil and Sessions Judge, Bengaluru (CCH-88)
( ‘Commercial Court’ ) in Com.O.S.No.1148/2024, whereby the
suit filed by the plaintiff came to be dismissed with costs.
2. The parties shall, for the sake of convenience, be
referred to by their respective ranks before the Commercial
Court.
(i) Facts of the Plaintiff:
3. It was the case of the plaintiff that he is the
proprietor of M/s.Venkata Ramana Engineers & Contractors
(Architects & Interior Fitouts) and that the defendant was the
Principal of Maitri English School, A.Narayanapura, K.R.Puram,
Bengaluru. The defendant approached the plaintiff for
construction of a school building in Site No.33/1, Narayanapura,
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59535-DB
COMAP No. 10 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010012332025
Udhayanagar, K.R.Puram, Bangalore ( ‘Suit Schedule
Property’ ). Pursuant thereto, the parties entered into a
construction agreement dated 28.09.2020 ( ‘Construction
Agreement’ ).
4. Pursuant to the Construction Agreement, the
plaintiff commenced construction work and incurred
expenditure towards requisite materials. The defendant, in
turn, made part payments to the plaintiff from time to time,
linked to the progress of construction. The plaintiff claimed to
have completed the entire construction work in March 2021 and
submitted his final bill to the defendant for Rs.45,01,317/-.
5. The plaintiff further claimed that though the
defendant had promised to settle the amount, she consistently
postponed payment. Thereafter, the defendant issued three
cheques in favour of the plaintiff towards repayment. The
defendant thereafter took back the cheques for making certain
corrections and falsely assured him that fresh cheques would
be issued.
6. Owing to non-payment of dues, the plaintiff
instituted the suit seeking inter alia , an injunction restraining
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59535-DB
COMAP No. 10 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010012332025
the defendant from dispossessing him from the suit schedule
property and from inducting any third party for further
construction thereon, apart from recovery of a sum of
Rs.45,01,317/- with interest at the rate of 18% per annum.
(ii) Defence of the Defendant:
7. The defendant filed her written statement and
denied having executed the Construction Agreement. According
to her, the document relied upon by the plaintiff was fraudulent
and contained a forged signature. She contended that the
parties had only entered into an oral arrangement for
construction.
8. The defendant stated that she was the Principal of
Jishnu Educational Society, in whose name the suit schedule
property had been purchased. She intended to demolish the
existing school building and construct a new building
comprising a Western Block and an Eastern Block. One L.N.
Babu introduced the plaintiff to her as a person experienced in
construction. The parties thereafter orally agreed that the
plaintiff would undertake the construction at Rs.1,300/- per
sq.ft. for the ground and first floors and Rs.1,200/- per sq.ft.
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59535-DB
COMAP No. 10 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010012332025
for the second floor. The defendant denied that the
arrangement was subsequently reduced into writing.
9. According to the defendant, construction commenced in
June 2020 and payments were to be made progressively in
accordance with the progress of construction. She stated that
she had paid Rs.20,00,000/- to the plaintiff by RTGS on
20.05.2020 and between 20.05.2020 and 21.11.2020, had
made further payments towards construction, including
payments to the plaintiff and suppliers, totalling Rs.80,00,000 /- .
She denied, however, having issued the three cheques relied
upon by the plaintiff.
10. The defendant contended that the plaintiff stopped
the construction in November 2020 during the COVID-19
pandemic, leaving the Western Block incomplete. No
construction had been undertaken in the Eastern Block. She,
therefore, contended that the plaintiff had not completed the
construction as agreed and was not entitled to recover the
amount claimed in the suit.
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59535-DB
COMAP No. 10 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010012332025
(iii) Issues framed by the Commercial Court:
11. On the basis of the above pleadings, the
Commercial Court framed the following issues:
“ (i) Whether plaintiff proves that he had entered into
building construction agreement dated 28/09/2020 with
the defendant for construction of building?
(ii) Whether the plaintiff further proves that he had
completed building in the March- 2021 and issued final bill
for Rs.45,01,317/-?
(iii) Whether the defendant proves that she had paid
Rs.80,00,000/- to the plaintiff from 20/05/2020 to
21/11/2020?
(iv) Whether the defendant further proves that the
construction agreement dated 28/09/2020 is insufficient
document and same is to be impounded under Section 33
and 34 of Karnataka Stamp Act?
(v) Whether the plaintiff further proves that the defendant
is due sum of Rs.45,01,317/-?
(vi) Whether plaintiff is entitled for suit claimed amount
with the interest at the rate of 18% p.a., from 10/04/2021
till realization of the amount?
(vii) What order or decree? ”
12. To substantiate his case, the plaintiff examined
himself as P.W.1 and examined one L.N.Babu as PW-2 and got
marked Exs.P.1 to P.124. The defendant examined herself as
D.W.1 and got marked Exs.D.1 to D.7.
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59535-DB
COMAP No. 10 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010012332025
(iv) Order of the Commercial Court:
13. The Commercial Court noticed from the evidence of
P.W.1 that, though the Construction Agreement contemplated
construction of two blocks, the Eastern Block had not been
completed. P.W.1 also admitted that he had received
Rs.80,00,000/- from the defendant as on 01.03.2021. The
Commercial Court noticed that this fact had not been disclosed
either in the plaint or in the evidence affidavit and that no
explanation had been offered for such non-disclosure.
14. The Commercial Court then noted that the
Construction Agreement relied upon by the plaintiff was an
unregistered document bearing the names of two attesting
witnesses, namely, L.N.Babu and G.Reddappa. While the
existence of an understanding between the parties regarding
construction of the school building was not in dispute, the
defendant specifically contended that the Construction
Agreement was a concocted document and that she had not
executed it. PW-2/L.N.Babu deposed that he had signed the
Construction Agreement at the school. He admitted that G.
Reddappa was not present when he attested the document,
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59535-DB
COMAP No. 10 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010012332025
though the plaintiff and defendant were present. He also
admitted that the Eastern Block had not been completed.
15. It was also noticed that the defendant had
categorically denied the signature attributed to her on the
Construction Agreement. Having regard to such denial and the
evidence of L.N.Babu regarding the circumstances of
attestation, the Commercial Court found that the plaintiff had
not established due execution of the Construction Agreement.
It further noticed that the plaintiff had not taken steps to have
the disputed signature compared with an admitted signature
through an expert.
16. As regards performance under the Construction
Agreement, the Commercial Court relied upon the admission of
P.W.1 that the Eastern Block had not been completed. It also
noticed that the plaintiff had not produced any document to
establish purchase of the construction materials claimed by
him. The photographs produced by the parties were found to
corroborate the incomplete state of construction. The
Commercial Court accordingly held that the plaintiff had not
completed the construction contemplated under the
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59535-DB
COMAP No. 10 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010012332025
Construction Agreement and had raised invoices and the final
bill without completing his obligations thereunder.
17. The Commercial Court further noticed the plaintiff's
case that three cheques had been issued towards the balance
amount and had subsequently been taken back by the
defendant. It observed that no separate notice had been issued
calling upon the defendant to issue fresh cheques. The non-
disclosure of the receipt of Rs.80,00,000/- in the plaint and
evidence affidavit was also considered significant. The
Commercial Court held that the plaintiff's conduct in
withholding this material fact indicated that he had not
approached the Court with clean hands.
18. The evidence of D.W.1 was also taken into
consideration. While denying execution of the Construction
Agreement and her signature therein, D.W.1 admitted that
there had been an understanding regarding construction of the
school building. She admitted having made payments towards
the construction, including Rs.35,00,000/- through RTGS. She
also admitted having received the plaintiff's notice dated
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59535-DB
COMAP No. 10 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010012332025
10.04.2021 without replying to it and having sent the
WhatsApp messages marked as Ex.P.33.
19. On an overall consideration of the evidence, the
Commercial Court held that the plaintiff had failed to establish
due execution of the Construction Agreement, completion of
the construction contemplated thereunder and his entitlement
to the amount claimed. Accordingly, issue Nos.1, 2, 5 and 6
were answered in the negative. Issue No.3 was answered in the
affirmative on the basis of the plaintiff's admission regarding
receipt of Rs.80,00,000/-. Issue No.4 was also answered in the
affirmative on the ground that the Construction Agreement was
an unregistered and insufficiently stamped document.
Consequently, the suit was dismissed with costs.
20. Aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment and order
dated 07.11.2024 passed by the Commercial Court, the plaintiff
has preferred the present appeal.
(v) Grounds of Appeal:
21. The appellant-plaintiff has challenged the impugned
judgment and decree, inter alia , contending that the findings
recorded by the Commercial Court are arbitrary and suffer from
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59535-DB
COMAP No. 10 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010012332025
non-application of mind. It is contended that the suit schedule
property continues to be used for storing construction materials
valued at more than Rs.25,00,000/-.
22. It is further contended that, though the
construction was only partially completed, the Construction
Agreement contemplated payment based on the work
completed. According to the plaintiff, the total value of the work
under the Construction Agreement was Rs.2,57,54,800/-,
against which the appellant had completed work valued at
Rs.1,28,01,317/- as reflected in Ex.P.30. It is therefore
contended that, even after accounting for the payment of
Rs.83,00,000/- made by the defendant, the plaintiff was
entitled to recover the balance amount due.
23. We have heard Sri Sukumaran G., learned counsel
appearing for the appellant-plaintiff and Sri Rajesh Gowda,
learned counsel appearing for the respondent-defendant. Upon
consideration of the pleadings, the records placed before this
Court and the submissions advanced by learned counsel on
both sides, the following point arises for our consideration:
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59535-DB
COMAP No. 10 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010012332025
Whether the appellant-plaintiff has made out any
ground warranting interference with the judgment
and order dated 07.11.2024 passed by the
Commercial Court in Com.O.S. No.1148/2024?
(vi) Reasons and Conclusion:
24. We have considered the submissions of learned
counsel and examined the records. The principal claim of the
plaintiff is for recovery of Rs.45,01,317/- towards the alleged
balance amount payable for the construction work. The burden
was therefore on the plaintiff to establish the contractual basis
of the claim, the work actually completed and the amount
remaining payable.
25. The plaintiff relies upon the Construction Agreement
and the final bill dated 20.03.2021. The execution of the
Construction Agreement was specifically disputed by the
defendant. The evidence of L.N. Babu, examined as P.W.2, did
not satisfactorily establish its due execution and attestation.
P.W.2 admitted that the other attesting witness, G.Reddappa,
was not present when he signed the document. The defendant
also denied the signature attributed to her. Despite such
specific denial, the plaintiff did not take steps to have the
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59535-DB
COMAP No. 10 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010012332025
disputed signature compared with an admitted signature
through an expert. In these circumstances, the Commercial
Court was justified in holding that the plaintiff had failed to
establish due execution of the Construction Agreement.
26. Even otherwise, the plaintiff's own evidence raises
serious doubts regarding the claim for the amount sought. The
final bill dated 20.03.2021 includes amounts towards works on
the Eastern Block. However, P.W.1 categorically admitted that
the Eastern Block had not been completed. The photographs
produced in evidence also corroborate this position. The
plaintiff, therefore, sought to recover amounts under a final bill
which included work that had admittedly not been completed.
27. The plaintiff contends that the Construction
Agreement contemplated payment according to the work
completed and that the bills and ledger entries establish that
work valued at Rs.1,28,01,317/- had been carried out.
However, the production of bills and ledger entries, by itself,
cannot establish that the corresponding work was actually
executed.
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59535-DB
COMAP No. 10 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010012332025
28. The Apex Court in Chandradhar Goswami v.
1
Gauhati Bank Ltd
. has held that entries in books of account,
even when maintained in the regular course of business, cannot
alone fasten liability upon a person. Such entries must be
supported by further evidence establishing the underlying
transaction. In the present case, particularly in view of the
plaintiff's own admission regarding incomplete construction, it
was incumbent upon him to establish the nature and extent of
the work actually completed and its corresponding value. No
independent material establishing the measurements or
valuation of the work has been placed on record.
29. This assumes significance since the plaintiff seeks
recovery of a specific sum of Rs.45,01,317/-. The mere
assertion that work valued at Rs.1,28,01,317/- was completed,
after accounting for the payments received, cannot establish
the amount allegedly due. The underlying Construction
Agreement itself having not been proved, and the actual work
completed and its value having not been established, the bills
1
1966 SCC OnLine SC 255.
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59535-DB
COMAP No. 10 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010012332025
and ledger entries cannot, by themselves, furnish a basis for
passing a decree for the amount claimed.
30. The Commercial Court also rightly took note of the
plaintiff's conduct in suppressing the factum of receipt of
Rs.80,00,000/- from the defendant as on 01.03.2021. P.W.1
admitted such receipt in his cross-examination. However, this
substantial payment was not disclosed either in the plaint or in
the evidence affidavit. No explanation was offered for such
omission. The suppression of a significant payment, which
directly bore upon the very claim for recovery, cannot be
brushed aside as a mere omission. The Commercial Court was
therefore justified in holding that the plaintiff had not
approached the Court with clean hands.
31. The contention that construction materials worth
more than Rs.25,00,000/- continue to be stored in the suit
schedule property does not advance the plaintiff's case. No
evidence has been placed on record to establish the existence
or value of such materials. In any event, the alleged presence
of construction materials at the site cannot, without proof of
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59535-DB
COMAP No. 10 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010012332025
the work executed and the amount payable, establish the
plaintiff's entitlement to the suit claim.
32. On an overall consideration of the evidence, we find
that the Commercial Court has correctly appreciated the
material on record. Its findings are supported by the plaintiff's
own admissions, the evidence of P.W.2 and the photographs
produced in evidence. The plaintiff has failed to establish the
execution of the Construction Agreement, completion and
valuation of the work claimed, or the amount allegedly
remaining due. We find no perversity or error in the
appreciation of evidence warranting interference in the
impugned judgment and order.
33. The plaintiff has, therefore, failed to make out any
ground warranting interference with the judgment and order
dated 07.11.2024 and therefore, the appeal is liable to be
dismissed. Accordingly, the following;
ORDER
(i) The appeal is dismissed;
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59535-DB
COMAP No. 10 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010012332025
(ii) The judgment and decree dated 07.11.2024 passed
by the LXXXVII Additional City Civil and Sessions Judge,
Bengaluru, in Com.O.S. No.1148/2024, is hereby affirmed.
(iii) Pending I.As., if any, stand disposed of.
No order as to costs.
Sd/-
(D K SINGH)
JUDGE
Sd/-
(H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN)
JUDGE
KNM
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 17