Usha Rani vs State Of Haryana And Others

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

CWP-3020-2023 (O&M) -1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
(259) CWP-3020-2023 (O&M)
Date of Decision: 12.11.2026
USHA RANI
......Petitioner
Versus
STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS
.....Respondents

CORAM: HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE KIRTI SINGH
Present: Ms. Veena Hooda, Advocate for the petitioner.
Mr. Chirag Wadhwa, DAG, Haryana.

KIRTI SINGH , J. (ORAL)
1. The present writ petition has been filed under Articles 226/227
of the Constitution of India seeking quashing of the award dated 23.12.2022
(Annexure P-2) passed by the learned Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour
Court, Hisar, whereby Reference No.33 of 2018 raised by the petitioner-
workman was answered against her and her claim for reinstatement with
continuity of service and full back wages was declined.
2. Briefly stated, as per the pleaded case of the petitioner, she was
engaged as a Beldar-cum-Mali in Charkhi Dadri Range, and had worked
from 22.10.1994 to 25.12.2017, when her services were terminated.
According to her, she had worked continuously with the respondent-
management, had completed more than 240 days of service in the twelve
months preceding the alleged termination and was discontinued without
notice or retrenchment compensation. She further alleged that persons junior
to her had been retained, in violation of Sections 25-F, 25-G and 25-H of the
Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (hereinafter referred to as 'the Act'). A demand
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.20 12:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
notice under Section 2-A of the Act was served, followed by conciliation

CWP-3020-2023 (O&M) -2-
proceedings, which did not result in a settlement. The dispute was thereafter
referred for adjudication and registered as Reference No. 33 of 2018. The
respondent-management contested the claim, disputing the alleged
engagement of the petitioner and the existence of an employer-employee
relationship. It pleaded that the old departmental records had been weeded
out in accordance with the applicable instructions and that the petitioner had
never been engaged by it as a Beldar-cum-Mali. It was also its stand that
there was no sanctioned post of Beldar-cum-Mali in the department.
3. Upon completion of pleadings and evidence, the learned Labour
Court answered the reference against the petitioner. It examined the
evidence led by her, including the muster roll cards Ex.W1 to Ex.W11. It
also considered the departmental record summoned during the proceedings
and the testimony of Sh. Deepak Kumar, Deputy Ranger, Office of D.F.O.,
Charkhi Dadri, as MW1. Upon appreciation of the material available on
record, the learned Labour Court concluded that the petitioner had failed to
establish that she had worked with the respondent-management for the
requisite period and, accordingly, dismissed her claim petition.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioner contends that the petitioner
had worked continuously as a Beldar-cum-Mali in Charkhi Dadri from
22.10.1994 till 25.12.2017. It is argued that she had completed more than
240 days of service during the twelve months preceding the alleged
termination. Learned counsel further submits that the learned Labour Court
failed to properly appreciate the muster roll cards Ex.W1 to Ex.W11
produced by the petitioner. It is also contended that the management failed
to produce the muster rolls, wage registers, attendance records and other
relevant employment records, despite the same being material for
adjudication of the dispute, and an adverse inference ought to have been
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.20 12:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
drawn against it. Learned counsel additionally relies upon the plea that

CWP-3020-2023 (O&M) -3-
persons junior to the petitioner were retained even after discontinuance of
her services.
Per contra,
5. learned State counsel has opposed the prayer made
by learned counsel for the petitioner and contended that the petitioner was
never engaged by the respondent-department as a Beldar-cum-Mali and,
consequently, no employer-employee relationship was established between
the parties. It is further submitted that the muster roll cards relied upon by
the petitioner neither bear proper identification particulars nor the requisite
authentication of the competent officer. Learned State counsel, therefore,
submits that the learned Labour Court, upon proper appreciation of the
evidence and material available on record, rightly answered the reference
against the petitioner and the impugned award does not call for any
interference by this Court.
6. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
relevant material on record.
7. The principal question which arises for consideration is whether
the petitioner established the foundational facts necessary to claim protection
under Section 25-F of the Act. For attracting the protection of the said
provision, the petitioner was required to establish, in the first instance, the
factum of her employment with the respondent-management and the
requisite qualifying service contemplated under Section 25-B of the Act. The
initial burden of establishing these foundational facts rests upon the
workman. In Range Forest Officer v. S.T. Hadimani, (2002) 3 SCC 25, the
Hon'ble Supreme Court held that a mere statement or affidavit of the
workman, by itself, would not be sufficient to establish completion of 240
days of service. The claim, therefore, has to be examined in the light of the
evidence actually brought on record and not merely on the basis of the
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.20 12:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
period of employment asserted by the workman.

CWP-3020-2023 (O&M) -4-
8. In the present case, the petitioner asserted that she had worked
with the respondent-department from 22.10.1994 to 25.12.2017. The
management, on the other hand, disputed the very factum of her engagement
and the existence of an employer-employee relationship. In support of her
claim, the petitioner relied upon muster roll cards Ex.W1 to Ex.W11. The
learned Labour Court examined these documents and noticed that none of
the muster roll cards bore a muster roll number. Though one of the cards
carried the stamp of the Range Forest Officer, Charkhi Dadri, they did not
bear his signatures, while certain other cards did not even carry the
departmental stamp. In these circumstances, the learned Labour Court found
that the said documents could not safely be relied upon to establish the
petitioner's engagement with the respondent-management or to calculate her
period of service from 22.10.1994 to 25.12.2017. The learned Labour Court
also noticed that the petitioner had alleged having worked under certain
Forest Guards, namely Rampal, Jai Bhagwan, Sri Bhagwan, Molar, B.O.
Rameshwar and few other Forest Guards. However, the muster roll cards
relied upon by her did not substantiate the said assertion, as some of them
bore the signatures of Molar as Forest Guard. Consequently, the same could
not be treated as substantive evidence to establish payment of wages by the
respondent-management or the alleged employment of the petitioner. Thus,
the material relied upon by the petitioner did not establish the necessary
connection between her alleged engagement and the respondent-
management.
9. The aforesaid conclusion of the learned Labour Court also finds
support from the departmental record summoned during the proceedings. As
noticed in the impugned award, the muster rolls and muster roll issue
register for the period from October 2010 to January 2018, along with the
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.20 12:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
attendance register of Beldars at Behria and Pantawas Beat for the period

CWP-3020-2023 (O&M) -5-
from October 1994 to December 2017, were summoned. The available
record, except the attendance register which, as stated by Sh. Kailash Chand,
Range Forest Officer, was not maintained, was produced and inspected by
the learned authorised representative of the petitioner. Significantly, the
petitioner's name was not found reflected in the record so produced. The
learned Labour Court, therefore, considered not only the documents relied
upon by the petitioner but also the departmental record summoned at her
instance. In the face of such material, the finding that the petitioner had
failed to establish her employment with the respondent-management cannot
be said to be based on a selective or incomplete appreciation of the evidence.
10. The contention that the management failed to produce the
muster rolls, wage registers and other employment records also requires
consideration in the context of the evidence as a whole. The initial burden
upon the workman does not absolve the management of its obligation to
produce relevant records when their production is properly sought and the
circumstances warrant it. Equally, an adverse inference does not follow
automatically from non-production of records; its justification has to be
examined having regard to the nature of the records, the explanation for their
non-availability and the other evidence available on record. In the present
case, the management had specifically pleaded that the old muster rolls had
been weeded out in accordance with the departmental instructions, while the
available departmental record summoned during the proceedings was
produced and inspected by the petitioner's representative. The fact that the
attendance register was not maintained was also explained by the concerned
officer. The learned Labour Court considered this material while
adjudicating the dispute. In these circumstances, merely because the
petitioner sought production of further employment records, the absence of
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.20 12:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
which was explained by the management, would not, by itself, justify

CWP-3020-2023 (O&M) -6-
drawing an adverse inference sufficient to establish the petitioner's alleged
employment or the requisite period of service. No material has been pointed
out to demonstrate that the explanation furnished by the management was
disbelieved or that the learned Labour Court ignored any specific record
which could have materially altered its conclusion.
11. The petitioner's further contention regarding violation of
Sections 25-G and 25-H of the Act also does not advance her case. Although
the petitioner alleged that persons junior to her had been retained, the
learned Labour Court specifically noticed that she had neither mentioned the
names of such persons nor furnished particulars regarding any person
subsequently appointed in her place. In the absence of such particulars or
supporting evidence, the allegation regarding retention of juniors or
engagement of fresh persons remained unsubstantiated. Moreover, the
petitioner having failed to establish the foundational factum of her
employment with the respondent-management, the allegations of violation
of the aforesaid provisions cannot independently sustain her claim.
12. The allegation of non-compliance with Section 25-F of the Act
has to be examined in the light of the foundational facts necessary to attract
the said provision. The petitioner was required to establish that she was
employed by the respondent-management and had rendered the qualifying
continuous service contemplated under Section 25-B of the Act. Once the
very factum of employment and the requisite qualifying service remained
unestablished, the alleged failure to issue notice or pay retrenchment
compensation cannot, by itself, confer upon her a right to reinstatement. The
learned Labour Court, therefore, cannot be faulted for declining the relief
claimed by the petitioner in the absence of proof of the essential ingredients
necessary to invoke Section 25-F of the Act.
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.20 12:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
13. It is well settled that while exercising jurisdiction under Articles

CWP-3020-2023 (O&M) -7-
226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, this Court does not sit as a Court of
appeal over the findings recorded by the Labour Court. Interference with an
award is warranted where the findings are perverse, based on no evidence,
contrary to the material on record or vitiated by patent illegality or
jurisdictional error. The jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 cannot be
invoked merely because another view of the evidence may also be possible.
14. In the present case, the learned Labour Court has considered the
oral and documentary evidence, examined the muster roll cards relied upon
by the petitioner, taken into account the summoned departmental record and
recorded reasons for disbelieving the petitioner's claim. No material has
been brought to the notice of this Court to demonstrate that the findings so
recorded suffer from perversity, misreading of evidence or any other
infirmity warranting interference.
15. On an overall consideration of the pleadings, evidence and the
reasoning adopted by the learned Labour Court, this Court finds no ground
to hold that the impugned award suffers from any patent illegality, perversity
or jurisdictional infirmity. The petitioner has failed to demonstrate that the
learned Labour Court committed any error warranting interference in the
exercise of the extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court.
16. Consequently, finding no merit in the present writ petition, the
same is dismissed.
17. Pending civil miscellaneous application(s), if any, also stand
disposed of.
(KIRTI SINGH)
JUDGE
th
November 12 , 2026
Ithlesh
Whether speaking/reasoned : Yes/No
Whether reportable : Yes/No
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.20 12:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment