The Branch Manager vs Sakthivel
- Court
- Madras High Court
CMA(MD) NO. 1467 of 2024
BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT
Reserved On : 10.09.2026 Pronounced On: 20.11.2026
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE MR JUSTICE K.K. RAMAKRISHNAN
CMA(MD) NO. 1467 of 2024
{CNR: HCMD010588602024}
Case QR
The Branch Manager
M/s. Oriental Insurance Company Limited
No.39/40, Saratha Shopping Complex,
Workshop Road,
Simmakkal,
Madurai 625 001. ...Appellant(s)
Vs
1.Sakthivel
2.Ramakrishnan
3.The Branch Manager
M/s. Oriental Insurance Company Limited
No.39/40, Saratha Shopping Complex,
Workshop Road,
Simmakkal,
Madurai 625 001.
4.Vignesh
(Respondent Nos.2 to 4 given up) ...Respondent(s)
1
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:18:56 pm )
CMA(MD) NO. 1467 of 2024
Prayer: This Civil Miscellaneous Appeal has been filed under Section 173 of Motor
Vehicle Act to set aside the order of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal Cum
Special Sub Court, Madurai made in M.C.O.P.No.270 of 2019 dated 11.03.2024 and
allow the appeal with costs.
For Appellant(s) : Mr.C.Jawahar Ravindran
For Respondent(s) : M/s.S.Ayyanar Prem Kumar for R1
: R2 To R4 - Given Up
JUDGEMENT
The fourth respondent in M.C.O.P.No.270 of 2019, on the file of the Motor
Accidents Claims Tribunal, Special Sub Judge dealing with M.C.O.P. cases,
Madurai, has filed the present Civil Miscellaneous Appeal in C.M.A.(MD).No.1467
of 2024, challenging the award dated 11.03.2024 passed in M.C.O.P.No.270 of
2019.
2. Facts of the case:
2.1. The claimant filed the claim petition under Section 166 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, claiming compensation of Rs.2,00,000/-. It is the case of the claimant
that on 02.12.2018, at about 7.30 p.m., he and his friend were standing near the
Kadambamaram Temple. At that time, another friend of the claimant was travelling
along Alanganallur Road with his friend as a pillion rider on a two-wheeler bearing
2
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:18:56 pm )
CMA(MD) NO. 1467 of 2024
Registration No. TN-59-CZ-2358, belonging to one Chinnasamy and made
conversation. At that time, the offending vehicle bearing Registration No.TN-59-
GZ-3354, driven by the first respondent in the claim petition, namely,
Ramakrishnan, in a rash and negligent manner, rammed into the two-wheeler in
which the claimant's friend was travelling. Due to the impact, the claimant sustained
injuries and took treatment in various hospitals at Madurai.
2.2. As a result of the accident, he suffered loss of vision in his left eye. In
respect of the accident, an FIR was registered against the driver of the offending
vehicle. Hence, the claimant filed the claim petition seeking compensation.
2.3. The appellant/Insurance Company disputed its liability, contending that
the accident occurred due to the negligence of the claimant and the rider of the two-
wheeler in which the claimant was travelling. It was also contended that the claim
petition was not maintainable against the appellant. The insurer of the two-wheeler
in which the claimant was travelling also contested the claim, contending that the
accident occurred due to the negligence of the driver of the offending vehicle.
2.4. Before the Tribunal, the claimant examined P.Ws.1 and 2 and marked
Exs.P1 to P8. The Disability Certificate was marked as Ex.C1. On the side of the
respondents, R.W.1 was examined and Exs.R1 and R2 were marked.
3
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:18:56 pm )
CMA(MD) NO. 1467 of 2024
3. Findings of the Tribunal:
3.1. Upon considering the oral and documentary evidence available on record,
the Tribunal fixed 90% negligence on the driver of the offending vehicle and 10%
negligence on the rider of the two-wheeler in which the claimant was travelling.
Thereafter, the Tribunal awarded a sum of Rs.14,93,080/- as compensation.
Sl.No. Heads Amount (in Rs.)
1 Permanent Disability 12,70,080/-
2 Pain and Sufferings 2,00,000/-
3 Nutritions 10,000/-
4 Medical expenses 1,500/-
5 Attendant charges 7,000/-
6 Transportation charges 5,000/-
Total Rs.14,93,080/-
3.2.Challenging the said award, the appellant/Insurance Company has
preferred the present appeal.
4. Submission of the learned counsel appearing for the appellant /
Insurance Company:
4.1. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant/Insurance Company
submitted that the Tribunal, without properly appreciating the evidence available on
record, erroneously fixed 90% negligence on the driver of the insured vehicle. It was
4
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:18:56 pm )
CMA(MD) NO. 1467 of 2024
further submitted that three persons were travelling in the two-wheeler and,
therefore, the Tribunal ought to have fixed a higher percentage of contributory
negligence on the rider of the two-wheeler. The learned counsel further submitted
that the amount awarded under the head of loss of future earning capacity is
excessive and sought reduction of the compensation.
5. Submission of the learned counsel appearing for the
respondent/claimant:
5.1. Per contra, the learned counsel appearing for the claimant submitted that
the Tribunal, after properly appreciating the entire evidence, awarded just and
reasonable compensation by adopting the multiplier method. It was further
submitted that the claimant was working as a painter and, due to the accident, he
suffered substantial impairment of vision in his left eye. Hence, the multiplier
method adopted by the Tribunal is justified. It was also submitted that the Tribunal
rightly fixed 90% negligence on the driver of the offending vehicle and 10%
negligence on the rider of the two-wheeler. Therefore, interference with the award is
not warranted.
6. This Court has considered the rival submissions and perused the materials
available on record.
5
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:18:56 pm )
CMA(MD) NO. 1467 of 2024
7. The points for determination in this appeal are:
(i) Whether the Tribunal was justified in fixing 90% negligence on the driver
of the appellant/Insurance Company's vehicle and 10% negligence on the rider of
the two-wheeler in which the claimant was travelling?
(ii) Whether the compensation awarded by the Tribunal requires interference?
8. Discussion on negligence:
8.1. As regards negligence, this Court has carefully perused the evidence of
P.Ws.1 and 2 and Ex.P1. The Tribunal, upon considering the oral and documentary
evidence, fixed 90% negligence on the driver of the offending vehicle and 10%
negligence on the rider of the two-wheeler in which the claimant was travelling.
8.2. Though the appellant/Insurance Company disputed the manner of the
accident, no contra evidence was adduced to establish that the entire negligence was
attributable to the rider of the two-wheeler. In the absence of any contra evidence,
this Court finds no reason to interfere with the finding of the Tribunal fixing 90%
negligence on the driver of the offending vehicle and 10% negligence on the rider of
the two-wheeler. Accordingly, the said finding is confirmed.
6
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:18:56 pm )
CMA(MD) NO. 1467 of 2024
9. Discussion on quantum:
9.1. As regards the quantum of compensation, it is not in dispute that the
claimant sustained injuries to his face and suffered impairment of vision in his left
eye. However, there is no evidence on record to establish that the claimant suffered
complete loss of vision. Therefore, the permanent disability cannot automatically be
treated as functional disability resulting in complete loss of earning capacity.
9.2. The Hon'ble Supreme Court, in Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar , reported in
(2011) 1 SCC 343 , has held that the Court has to determine whether the disability
has affected the earning capacity of the injured and, if so, to what extent. Thereafter,
the loss of future earning capacity has to be assessed by applying the appropriate
multiplier to the percentage of functional disability.
9.3. In the present case, the claimant has suffered injuries to his face and
impairment of vision. However, there is no evidence to establish complete loss of
vision or complete incapacity to pursue his avocation. Therefore, the Tribunal was
not justified in adopting the multiplier method and awarding a sum of
Rs.12,70,080/- under the head of loss of future earning capacity.
7
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:18:56 pm )
CMA(MD) NO. 1467 of 2024
9.4. Accordingly, the amount of Rs.12,70,080/- awarded by the Tribunal under
the head of loss of future earning capacity is set aside. Considering the nature of the
injuries and the disability suffered by the claimant, this Court assesses the
permanent disability at 30% and awards a sum of Rs.3,00,000/- at the rate of
Rs.10,000/- per percentage of disability. Further, considering the nature of the
injuries and the inconvenience suffered by the claimant, this Court awards
Rs.1,00,000/- towards loss of amenities and Rs.1,00,000/- towards loss of
convenience. A sum of Rs.70,000/- is awarded towards future medical expenses. The
amount awarded towards attendant charges is enhanced from Rs.7,000/- to
Rs.25,000/-.
10. Conclusion:
10.1. For the foregoing reasons, the compensation awarded by the Tribunal to
the claimant is re-determined as follows:-
Re-quantified
Amount awarded
Sl.
Heads
No.
amount by
by the Tribunal
Status
this Court
(in Rs.)
(in Rs.)
1. Permanent disability 12,70,080/- 3,00,000/- Reduced
2. Pain and suffering 2,00,000/- 2,00,000/- Confirmed
3. Extra nourishment 10,000/- 10,000/- Confirmed
4. Medical expenses 1,500/- 1,500/- Confirmed
8
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:18:56 pm )
CMA(MD) NO. 1467 of 2024
Re-quantified
Amount awarded
Sl.
Heads
No.
amount by
by the Tribunal
Status
this Court
(in Rs.)
(in Rs.)
5. Attendant charges 7,000/- 25,000/- Enhanced
6. Transportation 5,000/- 5,000/- Confirmed
Future medical
7. ------- 70,000/- Awarded
expenses
8. Loss of amenities ------- 1,00,000/- Awarded
9. Loss of convenience ------- 1,00,000/- Awarded
Total compensation award
amount Rs.14,93,080/- Rs.8,11,500/- Reduced
Deduction of 10% on
contributory negligence -------- Rs.81,150/- ---------
Total Entitlement of the
claimant Rs.14,93,080/- Rs.7,30,350/- Reduced
11. Result:
11.1.In the result, this CMA(MD)No.1467 of 2024 is partly allowed .
11.2.The award dated 11.03.2024 in M.C.O.P.No.270 of 2019 on the file of
the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal Cum Special Sub Court, Madurai is reduced
from Rs.14,93,080/- to Rs.7,30,350/- , together with interest at the rate of 7.5% per
annum from the date of the claim petition.
9
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:18:56 pm )
CMA(MD) NO. 1467 of 2024
11.3. The appellant/Insurance Company is directed to deposit the reduced
award amount of Rs.7,30,350/- , together with accrued interest at the rate of 7.5%,
after adjusting the amount, if any, already deposited, within a period of eight weeks
from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
11.4.On such deposit, the claimant is permitted to withdraw the same in
accordance with law. If the appellant/Insurance Company has already deposited any
amount in excess of the modified award amount, the Insurance Company is at
liberty to withdraw the excess amount.
There shall be no orders as to cost. Consequently, the connected Civil
Miscellaneous Petition is also closed.
20.11.2026
NCC :Yes/No
Index :Yes/No
Internet :Yes/No
AKM
To
1. Motor Accident Claims Tribunal Cum Special Sub Court,
Madurai.
2. The Section Officer,
VR Section,
Madurai Bench of Madras High Court, Madurai.
10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:18:56 pm )
CMA(MD) NO. 1467 of 2024
K.K.RAMAKRISHNAN.J
AKM
C.M.P.(MD).No.15713 of 2024
in
C.M.A.(MD).No.1467 of 2024
20.11.2026
11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:18:56 pm )