Ms Rajkumar Theatres Pvt Ltd, Represented by its D vs Wide Angle Creations and 6 others
- Court
- Madras High Court
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
Order reserved on : 27-10-2026
Order pronounced on : 13-11-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE P.B. BALAJI
OA No. 1114 of 2026
IN
C.S(COMM DIV) NO. 280 OF 2026
Ms Rajkumar Theatres Pvt Ltd, Represented by its
Director Mr.Rajkumar Sethupathy
27, 4th Main Road, Raja Annamalaipuram,
Chennai 600 028.
..Applicant(s)
Vs
1. Wide Angle Creations and 6 others
Representedby its Partner Shoba George 62,
Casa Major Road
Egmore, Chennai- 600 008.
2. Aashirvad Cinema
Represented by its Proprietor
M.J.Antony,
59/1047 Valakuzhi
Krishna Swamy Road,
Off Chittoor Road,
Ernakulam 682 035.
3. Mr.Jeethu Joseph
Valiyakandathi,
Murholoapuram PO
Elanji, Ernakulam 586 665.
4. Digital 18 Media Private Limited
(Carrying on business in the trade name of Star
Studio 18)
31st floor, Tower -4,
One Unity Center,
Senapati Bapat Marg, Prabhadevi,
Mumbai, Maharashtra 400 013.
__________
Page1 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
5. Panarama Studios
22nd Floor, Lotus Signature,
Veera Desai Road,
Near Country club,
Andheri West, Mumbai 400 053.
6. Ajay Devgn
5/6, Sheetal Apartments,
Ground Floor, Opposite Chandan Cinema,
Juhu, Mumbai 400 049.
7. Jyoti Deshpande
Zion Biz World,
Subhash Road A
Vile Parle (East),
Mumbai 400 057.
..Respondent(s)
Grant a temporary injunction restraining the Respondents 2 to 7
and all persons claiming under or through them from containing to exhibit,
exploit or distribute the Hindi Movie Dhrishyam 3 The Conclusion starrying
Ajay Devgn, Tabu, etc., and directed by Abhishek Pathak anywhere in the
world, in any format whatsoever, inlcuding such exhibition and exploitation on
OTT platforms or in or through any social media pending disposal of the suit.
For Applicant(s): Mr.K.Ravi
Senior Counsel
for Mr.R.Murugan
for M/s.Rugan & Arya
For Respondent(s): Mr.P.S.Raman
Senior Counsel
for Mr.Rahul Balaji for R4
Mr.Sathish Parasaran
Senior Counsel
__________
Page2 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
for Mrs.Akshaya Ramadurai for RR2 & 3
Mr.K.Manoj Menon for R5
Ms.Sowjanya Shyam
for Mr.Sharath Chandran for R1
RR6 & 7 - dismissed as not pressed against RR6 &
7
ORDER
The above Original Application has been taken out by the Plaintiff,
seeking a temporary injunction restraining defendants 1 to 7, and all persons
claiming under or through them from continuing to exhibit, exploit or distribute
the Hindi movie “Dhrishyam 3: The Conclusion”, starring Ajay Devgn, Tabu,
etc and directed by Abhishek Pathak, anywhere in the world, in any format
whatsoever, pending the disposal of the suit.
2. The above application has been contested by the respondents namely,
nd
2 respondent, who is the producer of the original Malayalam film “Dhrishyam
rd
3”; the 3 respondent who is the director of the original Malayalam film
th
“Dhrishyam 3”; the 4 respondent who is an assignee from the plaintiff and the
st
1 defendant claiming though Viacom 18, whose business and production and
th th
distribution rights stood assigned in favour of the 4 respondent; the 5
respondent, who claims an independent and unencumbered title and right over
__________
Page3 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
the subject film, the Hindi remake of the Malayalam version of the film
“Dhrishyam 3”.
st
3. The 1 respondent, despite having entered appearance through
counsel, has neither chose to file any counter, much less make any oral
submissions.
4. I have heard Mr. K. Ravi, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
applicant/plaintiff; Mr. Satish Parasaran, learned Senior Counsel appearing for
the Respondents/defendants 2 and 3, Mr. P.S. Raman, learned Senior Counsel
th
appearing for the 4 respondent/defendant; and Mr. Manoj Menon, learned
th
counsel for the 5 respondent/defendant.
5.The application as well as the suit has been given up against the
respondents/defendants 6 and 7.
6. The submissions of Mr. K. Ravi, learned S enior C ounsel appearing for
the applicant/plaintiff are as follows:
Mr. Ravi, learned Senior Counsel, at the outset, would take me through 4
agreements, namely-
a) An agreement dated 22.12.2013, in and by which the 1st
respondent/defendant was granted rights to remake/dub/adapt the
__________
Page4 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
st
Malayalam film “Dhrishyam” (the 1 version) and also its sequels,
in Hindi, as well as other north Indian languages. The said
agreement was entered into between respondents 2 and 3 (producer
th
and director of the original Malayalam film) with the 4
respondent;
nd
b) The 2 agreement relied on is an agreement dated 12.06.2014,
which confines to the Hindi rights of the entered into between the
st
1 respondent and the plaintiff, relating to the original Malayalam
st
version “Dhrishyam”, in and by which the 1 respondent assigned
its rights to prequel, sequel or remake the original Malayalam
version of “Dhrishyam” in Hindi alone by coproduction, co-
ownership and co-exploitation between the parties mutually;
rd st
c) The 3 agreement dated 11.09.2024, was entered into by the 1
respondent, plaintiff and Viacom 18 Media Pvt. Ltd. (now known
as Star Studio 18), whose rights subsequently were assigned in
th
favour of the 4 respondent. This agreement was entered into for
st
the purposes of the 1 respondent assigning its remake rights in the
original film “Dhrishyam” in Hindi language;
th
d) And finally, the 4 agreement dated 22.11.2025, entered into
nd rd
between the 2 and 3 respondent, who are the producer and the
th
director of the original Malayalam film “Dhrishyam”, and the 5
respondent in and by which the producer and director have
__________
Page5 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
assigned the production of an adaptation of the script of the
original film in Hindi called “Dhrishyam 3: The Conclusion”
7. Referring to these agreements, Mr. K. Ravi, learned Senior Counsel
st
would submit that the 1 respondent had been granted exclusive rights to not
only remake, but also to dub and adopt the movie in all North Indian languages,
st
including Hindi and therefore, the said valid rights assigned in favour of the 1
respondent had been sub-assigned to the applicant/plaintiff, for valuable sale
consideration. He would also take me though the relevant clauses under the
above referred agreements, where the rights have been acquired by the
applicant/plaintiff for consideration and present and future exploitation rights
have been granted to the applicant/plaintiff.
8. In short, the submissions of learned senior counsel, Mr. K. Ravi,
learned Senior Counsel, is that once admittedly the assignee whose assignment
agreement is admitted by the respondents 2 to 5 was granted rights to remake,
dub and adapt the original Malayalam film “Dhrishyam” and its sequels in
st
Hindi, leave alone other North Indian languages under the 1 agreement, the
respondents 2 and 3 could not have validly assigned the said rights for a sequel
to be made in Hindi titled “Dhrishyam 3: The Conclusion”.
9. As regards the submissions of learned Senior Counsel Mr. P.S. Raman
__________
Page6 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
and Mr. Satish Parasaran, learned Senior Counsel and Mr. Manoj Menon,
learned counsel, with regard to “Dhrishyam 3: The Conclusion” being a totally
independent film and a new adaptation of the Malayalam movie “Dhrishyam” in
Hindi. Mr. K. Ravi, learned Senior Counsel, would submit that the said
contention is clearly mischievous. In this regard, he takes me through the
consistent and continuous projection of the film only as “Dhrishyam 3” in all
promotional materials leading up to filing of the Section 9 application by the
applicant/plaintiff, invoking the arbitration clause in the agreement entered into
st
by the applicant/plaintiff with the 1 respondent. He would also rely on the new
tactics adopted by the respondents, after the filing of the Section 9 application
before this Court, by dropping “3” from the title. To substantiate his
contentions, Mr. Ravi, learned Senior Counsel has taken me through the various
promotional materials and also the opening credits of the film and finally the
censor certificate dated 28.09.2026, which is 4 days after the service of the
application of Section 9 on the respondents 2 and 3.
10. Mr. Ravi, learned Senior Counsel, would further state that the
respondents 4 and 5 cannot claim to have validly purchased the adaptation
rights of the Malayalam film “Dhrishyam” for a whopping Rs. 15,00,00,000/-,
that too within 6 months after the commencement of the production of the
offending film. In this regard, it is the submission that the agreement is only a
collusive action to defeat and deprive the valuable rights of the
__________
Page7 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
applicant/plaintiff and he would also take me through the lack of proof to even
establish the factum of the said huge payments having been vide on the said
agreement. He would place heavy reliance on the opening credits in the film
which clearly indicates and evidences the fact that it is based on the Malayalam
film story only. Therefore, he contends that when such right had already been
assigned in favour of the applicant/ plaintiff, which factum is not even disputed,
the producer and director had no subsisting right or interest to have assigned the
rights in favour of respondents 4 and 5.
th
11. Submissions of Mr. P.S. Raman, learned S enior C ounsel for the 4
respondent, are summarised as follows:
th
At the outset, Mr. P.S. Raman, learned Senior Counsel for the 4
respondent, contends that the applicant/plaintiff has not approached the Court
with clean hands and having failed in his attempt to obtain an interim order,
after contest, in application filed under Section 9 of the Arbitration and
st
Conciliation Act, not only against the 1 respondent, but also against the
contesting respondents herein, the applicant/plaintiff is estopped from seeking
the very same relief, as it would clearly amount to res judicata . He would
further state that O.A. (CD) No. 1050 of 2026 was filed against the very same
respondents herein claiming a right to remake the Malayalam version of
“Dhrishyam 3” in Hindi. He would further state that, even the documents that
were relied on by the applicant/plaintiff were the very same 4 documents which
__________
Page8 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
are being relied upon in the present Original Application as well.
12. Taking me through the relief sought for in the Section 9 application,
th
and the present application, Mr. P.S. Raman, learned Senior Counsel for the 4
respondent, would state that the applicant having sought for an interim relief of
worldwide restraint on exploiting the Malayalam version of “Dhrishyam 3” in
Hindi, not only in theatres but also media, specifically including OTT platforms,
and said application having been dismissed after due enquiry and the said order
having become final, with the applicant/plaintiff not preferring an appeal
against the same, the very same reliefs cannot be maintained in the present
Original Application.
14. Apart from the said preliminary objection with regard to res judicata ,
estoppel and conduct of the applicant/plaintiff, even on merits, the submission
th
of Mr. P.S. Raman, learned Senior Counsel for the 4 respondent, is that the
applicant/plaintiff has no subsisting right in the original Malayalam version of
the movie “Dhrishyam 3” to even seek any infringement in the 1st place, leave
alone an interim injunction as prayed for. In this regard, he relies on Section 51
and 55 of the Copyright Act, 1957. He would further refer to the admitted facts
that thought the Hindi sequel right had been assigned by the plaintiff to Viacom
rd
18 Media Pvt. Ltd. under the 3 agreement dated 11.09.2014, styled as remake
rights agreement, under which the plaintiff has expressly consulted that he
would not set up any adverse title to the assigned rights, the applicant cannot
__________
Page9 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
fall back on the assignment agreement dated 22.12.2013 to prevent the
respondents 4 and 5, who have in fact already released the film “Dhrishyam 3:
The Conclusion” in theatres on 02.10.2026 from further exploiting the said
theatrical right in the OTT platforms.
15. The further submissions of Mr. P.S. Raman, learned Senior Counsel
th
for the 4 respondent, that rights to exploit the film in the OTT platform is
nothing but a natural corollary and consequence to the release of the film in
theatres and when the respondent 4 has parted with huge consideration for
acquiring such rights, no prima facie had been made by the applicant for grant
of an interim order. In this regard, he reiterates his submission with regard to the
restrain and sought for by the applicant in the Section 9 application, which
included a release of the film in OTT platforms as well. It is his further
submission that despite the Hindi film “Dhrishyam 3: The Conclusion”, hitting
the theatres as early as on 02.10.2026, not a single argument has been advanced
that the movie, as contended by the respondents 2 and 3, or that matter
respondents 4 and 5, is not an entirely different adaptation of the Malayalam
version of the “Dhrishyam 3”. If really the applicant/plaintiff is aggrieved by
the alleged infringement of his right to remake the Malayalam movie
“Dhrishyam 3” in Hindi, even assuming for a moment he had vested rights, then
according to Mr. P.S. Raman, learned Senior Counsel, the first argument that
would have been placed before this Court was that the movie “Dhrishyam 3:
The Conclusion” released on 02.10.2026 in Hindi was only based on the
__________
Page10 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
original Malayalam version “Dhrishyam 1” and “Dhrishyam 2”, and not a new
adaptation all together, as contended by the applicant/plaintiff.
16. Submissions of Mr. Satish Parasaran, learned S enior C ounsel
appearing for the Respondents/defendants 2 and 3, are summarised as follows:
According to Mr. Satish Parasaran, learned Senior Counsel appearing for
the Respondents/defendants 2 and 3, namely the producer and the director of the
original Malayalam film Dhrishyam, the present suit is a clear abuse and the
interim relief sought for after dismissal of Section 9 application for the very
same prayer, is a further abuse and has to be dismissed with exemplary costs on
this limited ground itself. He would further state that having parted with a mere
Rs. 25,00,000/-, for assignment of adaptation, remake and dubbing of the
original Malayalam film Dhrishyam in all North Indian languages including
Hindi, way back in the year 2013, the applicant/ plaintiff has already made huge
profit of not less than Rs.100,00,00,000/-, since the original version was a big
hit, pan India, and also internationally, in now attempting kite flying by trying
to falsely claim non-existent rights in respect of the Malayalam version of
Dhrishyam 3. He would, in any event, state that Dhrishyam 3: The Conclusion,
which is the subject film complained of, is a totally new film and has nothing to
do with the original Malayalam versions Dhrishyam 1, 2 and 3, and it cannot be
titled as a sequel to the Dhrishyam 2, Malayalam version. He would further
__________
Page11 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
state that in any event, the applicant/ plaintiff was assigned the rights only in
st
respect of the 1 Malayalam film “Drishyam” and he cannot claim any rights
over Dhrishyam 2 or 3, for that matter.
17. Meeting the arguments of Mr. K. Ravi, learned Senior Counsel, Mr.
Satish Parasaran, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondents
/defendants 2 and 3, would state that merely because in the promotional
materials, the name of the movie was projected as Dhrishyam 3, what ultimately
counts is the censorship certificate which clearly indicated the fact that it is not
a sequel of Dhrishyam 2 or the remake of Dhrishyam 3 Malayalam movie, but a
new adaptation of the movie in Hindi and is titled “Dhrishyam: The
Conclusion”. It is therefore clearly indicating of the fact that there was a
complete departure from the movie series, by drawing to a close or rather
putting an end to the movie, or rather its sequels. He would further state that it is
not for the applicant/plaintiff to question the mode of payment of the
consideration, when the receipt of the consideration was not denied by the
respondent 2 and 3, especially when it was the respondent 2 and 3 who had
absolute rights title and interest being the original producer and director of the
Malayalam version of the movie Dhrishyam. He would further state that it was
st
the applicant and the 1 respondent who are colluding and having assigned non-
st
existent rights, the 1 respondent has conveniently stayed away from
committing to any stand before this Court, and despite having engaged a
__________
Page12 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
Counsel, no arguments were also advanced in this application, which only goes
st
to show that the 1 respondent, is avoiding to take any stand in writing or by
making oral submissions through since it will expose the lack of any valid rights
st
subsisting with the 1 respondent, leave alone the same being unlawfully
assigned in favour of the applicant/plaintiff.
th
18. Mr. P.S. Raman, learned Senior Counsel for the 4 respondent, would
rely on Vishnu Traders v. State of Haryana and Ors. 1995 Supp (1) Supreme
Court Cases 461 ; Sanjit Singh Salwan and Ors v. Sardar Inderjit Singh Salwan
and Ors. (2026) 4 Supreme Court Cases 476;and, K.V. Rajendran vs Sudha
Kongra reported in 2026 SCC Online Mad 27.
19. Submissions of Mr. Manoj Menon, learned counsel appearing for the
th
5 respondent are as follows:
th
Mr. Manoj Menon, learned counsel appearing for the 5 respondent,
would firstly contend that Dhrishyam: The Conclusion in Hindi is an entirely
different version of the Malayalam movie Dhrishyam 3, and is not any sequel.
Relying on Section 13(3) and 13(4) of the Copyright Act, he would state that
the applicant/plaintiff is not the creator, but only an assignee and he cannot
claim any better rights than what is available with the original creator. In this
st
regard, he would take me through the agreement between the plaintiff and the 1
respondent, more specifically, Clause 5 and contended that the agreement itself
was a commercial transaction for sharing of profits, not relating to the
__________
Page13 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
assignment of copyrights, which continued to vest with the original author. He
would also invite my attention to the reliefs sought for in the plaint and in the
Original Application, and would contend that the relief in the OA cannot travel
beyond the scope of the relief sought for in the plaint, and on this limited
ground itself, the applicant is disentitled to seek any interim relief.
20. In so far as res judicata , Mr. Manoj Menon, learned counsel
th
appearing for the 5 respondent, adopts the arguments of learned Senior
Counsels, Mr. P.S. Raman and Mr. Sathish Parasaran.
21. In so far as his submission, Mr. Manoj Menon relied on the decision
of this Court in K.V. Rajendran vs Sudha Kongra reported in 2026 SCC Online
Mad 27 .
22. In reply, Mr. K. Ravi, learned Senior Counsel, would contend that the
Section 9 application was filed just prior to few days before the film
“Dhrishyam: The Conclusion” in Hindi, was about to be released in theatres and
st
since there was a valid arbitration agreement between the applicant and the 1
st
respondent, the applicant being in dark as to whether the 1 respondent was the
mischief maker, was compelled to implead the respondents 2 to 5 as well, along
with respondents 6 and 7, in the Section 9 application. However, once the
st
applicant came to know that 1 respondent had not assigned any rights, but it
was only respondents 2 and 3, subsequent to the dismissal of the application
__________
Page14 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
under Section 9, the present suit was filed. As the movie had already been
released, the interim prayer sought for was restricted to the release of the movie
in OTT platforms. He would further state that there has been complete and fair
disclosure of all these, in the plaint as well as the affidavit filed, and therefore
the applicant is not guilty of suppression of material facts, as contended by the
counsel of the respondents.
23. As regards res judicata , the learned Senior Counsel contends that the
case with which the applicant approached the Section 9 Court was under
entirely different circumstances all together and the cause of action for the suit
being distinct in nature, there can be no estoppel or res judicata put against the
applicant/plaintiff.
24. As regards the order in the Section 9 application becoming final, Mr.
st
K. Ravi, learned Senior Counsel, would submit that since the 1 respondent’s
stand made it clear that he had no real dispute with the applicant/plaintiff, there
was no scope for any arbitration, and only under such circumstances, the
applicant/plaintiff did not prefer any appeal and instead filed the instant suit. In
support of his submissions, Mr. K. Ravi, learned Senior Counsel would rely on
the following authorities:
1.Novenco Building & Industry A/S v. Xero Energy Engg. Solutions (P)
Ltd., (2026) 4 SCC 815;
2.Arjun Singh v. Mohindra Kumar and Ors., 1963 SCC OnLine;
__________
Page15 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
3.Firm Ashok Traders and Anr v. Gurumukh Das Saluja and Ors. (2004)
3 Supreme Court Cases 155;
4.M/s. Shvedh v. M/s. Sharaddha Entertainment in CMA Nos. 3656, 3657
& 3659 of 2019 dated 31.01.2020 ;
5.Vijaya Vijayrao Khadke and Anr v. State of Maharashtra and Ors.
2022 SCC OnLine Bo 1141;
6.Erach Boman Khavar v. Tukaram Shridhar Bhat and Anr. (2013) 15
Supreme Court Cases 655;
7.Sanjit Singh Salwan and Ors v. Sardar Inderjit Singh Salwan and Ors.
(2026) 4 Supreme Court Cases 476;
8.K.K. Modi v. K.N. Modi and Ors. (1998) 3 Supreme Court Cases 573;
and
9. V. Ramathal v. B. Bagyalakshmi and Anr. in CRP No. 1025 of 2025,
dated 27.06.2025.
25. I have carefully considered the submissions of learned Senior
Counsels Mr. K. Ravi, Mr. P.S. Raman and Mr. Satish Parasaran and the
th
counsel for the 5 respondent Mr. Manoj Menon. I have gone through the
various documents and decisions that have been relied on by either sides.
26. Admitted facts are as hereunder:
nd
The movie titled as “Dhrishyam” was produced by the 2 respondent and
__________
Page16 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
rd
directed by the 3 respondent and released in Malayalam in the year 2013. The
st
movie was a big run-away hit, which resulted in the 1 respondent approaching
the producer and the director seeking rights to adapt, dub, and remake the
original Malayalam version of “Dhrishyam”.
st
27. For consideration, the 1 respondent entered into a purchase
agreement on 22.12.2013, with respondents 2 and 3. Under the said agreement,
respondents 2 and 3 granted exclusive and irrevocable rights to remake, dub and
adapt, in Hindi and all North Indian languages including Bengali, Marathi,
st
Gujarati, Bhojpuri, and Punjabi. The rights granted in favour of the 1
respondent under the said agreement were to remake the Malayalam version of
Dhrishyam in all the above languages, especially Hindi, including its sequels,
prequels, and remakes, across all media platforms whether known already or
devised hereinafter. The producer and director however reserved their
st
proprietary rights, save what was granted to the 1 respondent/defendant.
28. Pursuant to the purchase of the rights, the 1st respondent entered into
an agreement with the applicant/plaintiff on 12.06.2014. In the preamble to said
agreement, it has been explicitly understood that the applicant and the 1st
respondent proposed to jointly develop the project in the Hindi language in
respect of adaptation and remake of the Malayalam film “Dhrishyam” that was
__________
Page17 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
released in December 2013. In fact, the agreement dated 22.12.2013 has been
referred to in the agreement dated 12.06.2026, between the applicant and the 1st
respondent as well.
29. From the preamble, it is clear that the agreement was an outcome of
st
an understanding between the applicant and the 1 respondent for joint
development based on the funds provided by the applicant/ plaintiff, by way of
st
a loan to the 1 respondent, to co-produce and co-own the Hindi language rights
of the original film “Dhrishyam”. Curiously, the said agreement between the
st
applicant and the 1 respondent has incorporated an explicit covenant that the
nd rd
agreement between the original rights holder, namely the 2 and 3
st
respondents, and the 1 respondent dated 22.12.2013 shall form part and parcel
st
of the agreement between the applicant and the 1 respondent as well as any
rd
other agreements with investors, co-producers, and 3 parties.
30. The recitals of this agreement dated 12.06.2014 further indicate that
the 1st respondent was liable to repay the loan amount to the applicant/plaintiff
st
upon execution of the agreement and that the applicant and the 1 respondent
would become equal and joint owners of the Hindi language (remake version of
the original film Dhrishyam). It is further seen that under the heading essential
elements, the source material is only the original film titled “Dhrishyam” and
st
the applicant and the 1 respondent had agreed to share on a 50-50 basis the net
__________
Page18 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
profits made from the film, i.e., a remake/dubbing/adaptation of the Malayalam
version of “Dhrishyam” in Hindi. I am able further see that the right to make a
prequel, sequel, or remake of the film “Dhrishyam” in Malayalam in the Hindi
st
language was jointly and equally vested with both the applicant and the 1
respondent. It is only based on this agreement that the applicant/plaintiff claims
a right to injunct respondents 2 and 3, the original copyright holders being
producer and director, and their assignees respondents 4 and 5, from exploiting
the movie “Dhrishyam: The Conclusion” in Hindi.
31. Apart from the above two agreements, there are two further
st
agreements, namely an agreement entered into by the 1 respondent with the
th
applicant as well as the predecessor in the interest of the 4 respondent. This
agreement is dated 11.09.2024 and is styled as a Remake Rights Agreement.
th
Under the said agreement, the 4 respondent's predecessor in interest and right,
st
requested the applicant and the 1 respondent, as assignors, to jointly assign
their right to remake the original Malayalam film Dhrishyam in Hindi, in all
social media, formats, and platforms of exploitation, including production,
distribution, making prequels and/or sequels in Hindi, based on the new story
th
developed by the predecessor in interest of the 4 respondent on its own, and
also adapt, mobisodes, webisode’s, dramatize, novelize, televise, and make
spin-off series based on the remake rights jointly assigned in respect of Hindi
language alone. In the very same agreement, the predecessor in interest of the
__________
Page19 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
th st
4 respondent has agreed to give due credit to the applicant and the 1
respondent in the new film remade in Hindi, by showing them as co-producers,
in the opening credits of the new film, apart from giving credits to the writer of
the original maker of the film Dhrishyam, by making a specific mention that it
rd
is based on an original story written by the 3 respondent, Jeethu Joseph.
32. Thereafter yet another agreement was entered into between the
original author and director, respondents two and three, and Panorama Studios,
assigning the right to produce the adaptation of the script of the original film in
th
Hindi under the title Dhrishyam 3. The 5 respondent was assigned a right not
only to produce, but also remake and co-produce Dhrishyam 3 in Hindi
language. Under the said agreement, it is clear that the new film, namely
Dhrishyam 3 would be an independent work of the assignee, and consequently,
all rights, including intellectual property rights, exploitation rights, and negative
th
rights would consequently vest, absolutely and exclusively, with the 5
respondent. Clause 2.9 of the said agreement assumes a lot of significance.
While keeping in mind that the last of the four agreements, namely the one
dated 22.11.25, entered into between the producers and directors on one part
th
and the 5 respondent as the other part, not only referred to all the earlier
agreements, various rights assigned by respondents two and three in favour of
th
the 5 respondent, etc. Clause 2.9 also recorded the specific understanding
__________
Page20 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
th
between the parties that, in terms of the adaptation rights granted to the 5
th
respondent, the 5 respondent has developed a slightly different storyline from
the script of the original film produced by the assignors and that to the extent of
th
modifications carried out by the assignee, namely the 5 respondent to the
storyline of the original film, the assignor could not have any right to use such
modified elements of the storyline which were created by the assignee, namely
th
the 5 respondent. This agreement is no doubt for a consideration of
₹ 15,00,00,000/- Crores and it records the factum of payment of Rs.
7,50,00,000/- to the producer and director respectively.
33. Though Mr. K. Ravi, learned Senior Counsel has vehemently argued
that there is no proof of payment of such huge amounts and therefore the
agreement itself is a collusive agreement, I do not see such a plea being
available to be taken by the applicant/plaintiff who is not a party to the said
agreement. It is for the respondents 2 and 3 to complain that they have not
th
received the consideration as promised by the 5 respondent. Therefore, I do not
see this argument taking the applicant/plaintiff anywhere, especially in the light
of the reliefs sought for in the present application.
34. On a conjoint reading of all the four agreements, it is significantly
clear and evident that the rights that were given to the applicant/plaintiff by the
st
1st respondent was not the entirety of the rights vested with the 1 respondent
__________
Page21 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
st
under 1 respondent's agreement with the producer and director of the original
st
Malayalam version of Dhrishyam (1 version). The right to remake the original
Malayalam version of Dhrishyam in Hindi alone was assigned by the 1st
respondent to the plaintiff. As rightly contended by the learned counsel for the
respondents, the agreement entered into between the applicant and the 1st
respondent was not relating to any assignment of copyrights, but more a
commercial exploitation of the Malayalam version of Dhrishyam in Hindi. The
applicant/plaintiff has not prima facie been able to satisfy me as to how they had
a subsisting right to prevent the original copyright owners from assigning the
adaptation rights in favour of the respondents 4 and 5.
35. Yet another significant and relevant contention argued by Mr. P.S.
Raman, learned Senior Counsel, was that despite the movie Dhrishyam: The
Conclusion, in Hindi being released on 02.10.2026, there is not a whisper in the
pleadings, or any introduction of new pleadings to contend that the movie which
is being screened in theaters worldwide under the title Dhrishyam: The
Conclusion is only a sequel of Dhrishyam 2 and the claim of the respondents
that it is a totally new adaptation is false all together. I find force in the said
submissions. It is the case of the applicant/plaintiff that the rights vested with
them to make a sequel of Dhrishyam 2 in Hindi have been infringed by the
respondents. If so, when the movie had already been released on October 2nd,
2026, at least on the date of advancing arguments, if not in the pleadings, the
__________
Page22 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
applicant/plaintiff would have sprung up like a jack in the box and asserted that
the applicant's rights have been explicitly violated and infringed by the
respondents by referring to Dhrishyam: The Conclusion or at least parts thereof.
36. Though Mr. K. Ravi, learned Senior Counsel, had invited my
attention to the promotional materials as well as the use of name Dhrishyam 3
up to the filing of the Section 9 application, and thereafter, mischief's attempt
has been made to modify the name to Dhrishyam: The Conclusion, and that,
mischievously, the word '3' has been dropped. The Censor Certificate that has
been relied upon by the applicant/plaintiff themselves evidences the fact that the
certification is for the film Dhrishyam: The Conclusion. By using the said title,
the producers and director, namely respondents 2 and 3, have given out a clear
indication that a full stop is been given to the Dhrishyam series, by titling it as
The Conclusion.
37. The agreement dated 22.11.2026, the last of the four agreements,
clearly refers to the earlier three agreements and acknowledges the rights of the
respective parties under the said three earlier agreements. As the original
copyright holders, the respondents 2 and 3 were certainly entitled to assign
st
rights retained by them and not granted to the 1 respondent under whom the
applicant/plaintiff claims. Further, in the light of there being not a single
allegation raised that Dhrishyam: The Conclusion in Hindi is nothing but a of
dubbing or remake of Dhrishyam 3 in Malayalam, and in the light of the express
__________
Page23 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
covenants and stand of the respondents, that the impugned movie is a creation
th
of the 5 respondent, by carrying out adaptations/modifications to the original
nd rd
story produced by the 2 respondent and directed by the 3 respondent, the
applicant/plaintiff certainly has no prima facie case to seek an injunction to
restrain the lawful owners from dealing with their rights, especially when the
st
applicant has miserably failed to establish a subsisting right in itself, in the 1
place.
38. Reliance has also been placed on a No Objection Certificate issued by
st nd
the 1 respondent as well as the applicant, to the producer, 2 respondent on
st
20.01.2021, in and by which the applicant and the 1 respondent have given
their consent for assignment of Hindi remake rights of the Malayalam film
rd nd
Dhrishyam 2, in favour of a 3 party of the choice of the 2 respondent. I do not
see any serious impact because of this NOC, for the simple reason that
admittedly the Hindi remake rights of the Malayalam film Dhrishyam 2, which
was a sequel of the original Malayalam film Dhrishyam, had been assigned to
st
the 1 respondent, who had in-turn assigned it to applicant/plaintiff and
nd st
therefore the 2 respondent approached the applicant and the 1 respondent, had
no objection for remake of Malayalam film Dhrishyam 2 in Hindi, admittedly
Dhrishyam 2 being a sequel of the original Malayalam film Dhrishyam, such
st
right was then subsisting with the applicant and the 1 respondent. Therefore,
nd
the mere fact that the 2 respondent approached the applicant and the 1st
respondent for consent to assign the remake the rights to remake the Malayalam
__________
Page24 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
rd nd
film Dhrishyam 2 in Hindi language to any 3 party of the 2 respondent’s
choice does not in any way affect or alter the rights of the parties in so far as the
impugned movie Dhrishyam: The Conclusion is concerned.
39. Yet another aspect which had been argued at length is with regard to
the effect of the dismissal of the Section 9 application filed by the
applicant/plaintiff before this Court. There is no doubt that the very same prayer
was sought for in the Section 9 application, against the very same respondents
and also relying upon the very same documents. This court after hearing the
parties, clearly found that the applicant/plaintiff had not made out a case for
grant of interim injunction and proceeded to dismiss the application on merits.
Though Mr. K. Ravi learned Senior Counsel, contended that the order passed in
the Section 9 application is not on merits, on going through the order, I am
unable to countenance the arguments advanced by Mr. K. Ravi, learned Senior
Counsel. This court, in the Section 9 application, was only testing the
entitlement of the applicant/plaintiff to an interim injunction as prayed for by
applying the principles for grant of a temporary injunction and Order XXXIX
Rules 1 and 2 of Code of Civil Procedure (CPC).
40. The forum alone was different since it was by way of a Section 9
application in intended/proposed arbitration proceedings. As already referred
herein above, parties to the Section 9 application as well as in present original
__________
Page25 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
application are one and the same, the cause of action is the same, and equally
the documents that have been relied on by the applicant/plaintiff for seeking an
interim injunction in these proceedings were also the very same documents that
were projected before the Section 9 Court. Though Mr. K. Ravi, learned Senior
Counsel, projected an interesting argument that the arbitration agreement was
st
only between the applicant and the 1 respondent and the application could not
pursue further despite the application being dismissed, because of the fact that
st
the applicant/plaintiff came to be aware of the stand of the 1
st
respondent/defendant and having realized that the 1 respondent/defendant was
not the mischief maker, the applicant/plaintiff had no other option to stop
further proceedings under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, I am unable to
see any merit in this line of argument as well.
41. If really the applicant/plaintiff was apprehending any mischief to be
st
committed by the 1 respondent with whom alone the applicant had a valid
arbitration agreement, there was no necessity for the applicant to have
impleaded respondents 2 to 7, who were admittedly not parties to the arbitration
agreement. However, having voluntarily impleaded respondents two to seven,
and relying on very same four agreements dated 22.12.2013, 12.06.2014,
11.09.2024 and 22.11.2025, and having pressed for an interim injunction
against respondents 2 to 7 as well, in the Section 9 application and this court
finding that the applicant/plaintiff was not entitled to the equitable relief of
__________
Page26 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
interim injunction, if the applicant was aggrieved by this order, the applicant
ought to have taken up the matter on appeal before the Division Bench of this
Court. On the contrary, the applicant/plaintiff abandoned the arbitration
proceedings and instead chose to institute the present suit.
42. Though in a sense, I am in agreement with the arguments of Mr. K.
Ravi, learned Senior Counsel that when the 1st respondent made it clear that
there was no dispute to be arbitrated in the 1st place, there was no real purpose
for the applicant to pursue the arbitration proceedings. Consequently, the
applicant was certainly not obligated to challenge the order. However, when the
applicant had invited an order voluntarily by impleading respondents 2 to 7 in
the presence of strong objections taken by respondents 2 to 7, the
applicant/plaintiff should have at least got the liberty of this Court or challenged
the order in the Section 9 application, dismissing the interim injunction
application and obtained liberty at least before the Division Bench and
thereafter pursued the present litigation. By now it is well settled that res
judicata would apply to even interlocutory orders in a pending suit.
43. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Vishnu Traders case (referred in
supra), held that even in the case interlocutory orders, though the principle of
binding precedents would not apply, yet the need for consistency of approach
and uniformity in the exercise of judicial discretion respecting similar causes
__________
Page27 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
and the desirability to eliminate occasions for grievances of discriminatory
treatment requires that all similar matters should receive similar treatment
except where factual differences would require a different treatment, which
alone could assure of consistency, uniformity, predictability, and certainty of
judicial approach.
44. In K.K. Modi’s case (referred in supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court
found that the appellant had resorted to two parallel proceedings, one under the
Arbitration Act and another by way of a Suit, and that despite the Order of
injunction obtained by appellants being vacated in the arbitration proceedings,
they had obtained an injunction in the suit, which was vacated by the High
Court finding that the issues in the two proceedings were identical and the suit
was substantially to set aside the award. However, on merits, the Supreme Court
did not agree with the view of the High Court only with regard to the finding
that the relief in the suit was substantially the same. In fact, the very same
decision has also been relied on by Mr. Satish Parasaran, learned Senior
Counsel, as well since the Hon’ble Supreme Court upheld the view of the High
Court that the injunction application filed in the suit, after the injunction being
vacated in the arbitration proceedings amounted to an abuse of process of court,
as it was a case of re-litigating the same issue in a different forum, through
different proceedings. Even applying ratio laid down in K.K. Modi's case as
well in so far as limiting its applicability to the present Original Application for
__________
Page28 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
interim injunction, I am able to only apply it in favour of the respondents and
not the applicant. Here also, the relief sought for in the suit, is one which could
not have been prayed for in the arbitration proceedings, even assuming the
applicant/plaintiff had chosen to go ahead with the arbitration route. However,
at the same time for the purposes of entitling the applicant/plaintiff to an interim
injunction, this decision in fact stares at the face of the applicant/plaintiff. I have
already discussed as to how in both the Section 9 application as well as in the
present original application, the parties are the same, the relief sought for is the
same, and the documents relied on are also the same. Having been unsuccessful
in the Section 9 application and this Court rendering a categorical finding that
the applicant/plaintiff has not made out a case for grant of interim injunction
and the said order having attained finality as well, the very same relief cannot
be sought for by way of in the present suit, by way of an interlocutory
application.
th
45. Though Mr. Manoj Menon, learned counsel for the 5 respondent,
contended that the prayer for interim injunction is beyond the scope of the relief
sought for in the suit, I am unable to see any merit in the said contention. In the
suit, the applicant/plaintiff has, apart from the declaratory relief that he is the
absolute owner of 50% share in the copyright to remake Malayalam film
Dhrishyam 3 in Hindi, has also sought for a permanent injunction to restrain
defendants 2 to 7 and all persons claiming through or under them from
__________
Page29 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
continuing to exhibit, exploit, or distribute the Hindi movie Dhrishyam 3: The
Conclusion and also from exhibiting the said film on OTT platforms or in any
manner in or through social media. The interim injunction that has been sought
for is again to restrain respondents 2 to 7 and all persons claiming through or
under them from continuing to exhibit, exploit, or distribute the Hindi movie
Dhrishyam 3: The Conclusion, anywhere in the world, in any format
whatsoever, including exhibition and exploitation on OTT platforms or to any
social media. Today, we are concerned only with the release of the movie in the
OTT platforms and substantially I find the relief has been claimed in the plaint
as well. Therefore, merely because the interim prayer has been worded as
“anywhere in the world, in any format whatsoever…”, I do not see it as an
interim relief exceeding the scope of the suit reliefs.
46. In light of the above, 1stly, the applicant/plaintiff is not entitled to an
interim injunction as prayed for, for two reasons: namely, having suffered a
dismissal in the Section 9 application, where the very same relief has been
sought for, against the very same respondents as well, and the said order dated
01.10.2026 having become final, the applicant/plaintiff cannot and is not
entitled to an interim injunction, merely because the applicant/plaintiff has
chosen to abandon the arbitration route and has instead filed the present suit
wherein the very same interim relief has been renewed. Though there may be
change in circumstances, as held in Vishnu Traders case as well as in K.K. Modi
__________
Page30 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
case (referred in supra), the interlocutory orders also have to be respected,
unless exceptional facts and circumstances are made out as to any change in
factual position, entitling the applicant/plaintiff to interim relief in the 2nd
action despite having suffered an adverse order in an earlier action.
47. Coming to the decisions that have been relied on by Mr. K. Ravi,
learned senior counsel, in Arjun Singh case (referred in supra), the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held that interlocutory orders are of various kinds and they are
designed to preserve status quo, pending litigation and to ensure that parties are
not prejudiced by normal delay which the proceedings before the court usually
take. In such context, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that interlocutory orders
do not decide in any manner the merits of the controversy in issue in the suit
and do not put an end, to it even in part, and that such orders are certainly
capable of being altered or varied by subsequent applications for the same
relief, though normally only on proof of new facts or new situation which
subsequently emerge. I have no quarrel with regard to the ratio laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in this case. However, I do not see how the applicant
can derive any advantage from the ratio laid down in this case for the simple
reason that the factual matrix in which the ratio was laid down was entirely
different, and the Hon’ble Supreme Court only made it clear that the effect of an
Interlocutory Order would not affect the merits of the suit, since it is designed
only for limited purposes of preserving a status quo or through interest of the
__________
Page31 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
parties pending the suit. However, this argument cannot be put across
successfully, and contend that the Section 9 Court has not decided the matter on
merits, as contended by Mr. K. Ravi, learned Senior Counsel. The test is to see
whether the relief sought for in the Section 9 application has been decided on
merits or not, and if so, then there is a clear, explicit res judicata for operating
against the applicant/plaintiff to press for the very same relief before this court.
Hence this decision is not relevant to the facts of the present case.
48. In Firm Ashok Traders case (referred in supra), the Hon’ble Supreme
Court, testing the scope of an application under Section 9 for interim relief
under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, took note of the power of the
tribunal under Section 17 of the Act to pass orders in the nature of interim
measures. The Hon’ble Supreme Court found that the powers conferred under
Section 17 and Section 9 to some extent overlap, but the appellants can only
approach the Court and not the Arbitral Tribunal. This decision again does not
ensure in favour of the applicant/plaintiff.
49. In the Shwedh's case (referred in supra), this Court held that even
though a Section 9 application had been dismissed and said Order had become
final, it would not preclude the party from filing an application under Section 17
seeking interim protection, holding that Section 17 would become redundant
__________
Page32 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
and would amount to rejection of a statutory relief under which a party is
entitled to go before the arbitrator. However, with great respect, I am not able to
follow the ratio laid down in this case for the simple reason that the court did
not discuss the principles of res judicata and the effect of the dismissal of the
Section 9 application in a subsequent suit where the relief sought for is identical
and against the same parties.
50. In Vijaya Vijayrao's case (referred in supra), the Hon’ble Supreme
Court held that res judicata operates at successive stages in the same litigation,
but the basic foundation of res judicata rests on delineation of merits and it has
at least an expression of an opinion for rejection of an application. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court further held that for applying the principle of res judicata , there
has to be an expression of opinion on the merits and the question or issue
involved must have been decided on merits at an earlier stage of the same
litigation. Here again, I do not see how this ratio can be pressed into service to
the aid of the applicant/plaintiff. For example, an issue of improper payment of
Court Fee has been raised by way of an interlocutory application and an Order
comes to be passed by the Court rendering a finding on the merit and holding
that proper Court Fee has been paid, then it would certainly amount to res
judicata and the defendant cannot re-agitate the issue very same issue in the
subsequent stages of the suit. However, in the case of this nature, where an
injunction petition is dismissed, applying the settled principles laid down by the
__________
Page33 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
Hon’ble Supreme Court, at best, the order in the interim injunction application
cannot be put against the unsuccessful plaintiff when the main suit is tried.
However, it does not dilute in any manner the effect of the dismissal of the
injunction application on merits.
51. In Erach Boman case (referred in supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court
held that, in order to attract the doctrine of res judicata , there must be a
conscious adjudication of an issue and an expression of an opinion on the
merits. The Hon’ble Supreme Court also held that res judicata is applicable
between two stages of the same litigation, provided the question or issue
involved must have been decided at an earlier stage of the same litigation. This
decision again does not, in my considered opinion, come to the rescue of the
applicant/plaintiff. I have already found that the dismissal of the Section 9
application was on only on merits and therefore, it would clearly operate as an
express res judicata for renewing the very same interim relief in a different
forum, namely the present civil suit. Of course, it cannot be stretched to such an
extent that because the interim relief has been declined, the applicant/plaintiff is
consequently not entitled to relief in the main suit, where a permanent
injunction of similar or identical nature has been prayed for.
52. As regards, to reliance placed on the ratio laid down in K.V.
Rajendran's case (referred in supra) by this Court, and relied on by Mr. Manoj
Menon, learned counsel, I am in entire agreement with the ratio laid down by
__________
Page34 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
this Court with regard to the consequences of granting an interim injunction and
its far-reaching effect, applying the elements of prima facie case, balance of
convenience and irreparable hardship. This court held that a movie is a big
budget film, and even if it is prima facie found that there is a Copyright
infringement and would result in huge financial losses as production of the
movie involves multiple stakeholders, all of whom would be adversely affected
by an interim injunction. In short, this court held that even if a prima facie case
is made out, applying the remaining 2 principles namely, balance of
convenience and irreparable loss and hardship, the same would outweigh the
prima facie case factor, to deny an interim injunction in case of the applicant.
53. Lastly, with regard to Sanjit Singh's case (referred in supra), the
Hon’ble Supreme Court held that having resorted to resolution of disputes by
Arbitration, the party concerned in the said case was estopped from setting up
its invalidity and the issue revolved more around estoppel by conduct in election
rather than estoppel in law. This decision would apply for limited purposes of
the applicant's conduct in including respondents 2 to 7 also, as respondents in
Section 9 Application and having allowed the Order in the Section 9 application
to become final. Therefore, in this sense, certainly the conduct of the applicant
in electing to proceed against respondents 2 to 7 in arbitration proceedings and
inviting an adverse order would certainly act as an estoppel for seeking the very
same relief by way of the present Original Application.
__________
Page35 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
54. For all the above reasons, for not only attempting to re-agitate a lost
cause, but also on merits as well, the applicant/plaintiff has not made out a case
for exercise of equity, by granting an interim injunction as prayed for.
55.In fine, this Original Application is dismissed. No costs.
13-11-2026
2/3
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes/No
ATA
__________
Page36 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )
2026:MHC:4563
OA No. 1114 of 2026
P.B.BALAJI, J.
ATA
OA No. 1114 of 2026
IN
C.S(COMM DIV) NO. 280 OF 2026
13-11-2026
2/3
__________
Page37 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:12 pm )