Bimla And Others vs Suresh Kumar And Others

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

FAO No.2431 of 2003 (O&M) -1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH


FAO No.2431 of 2003 (O&M)

Bimla and others .....Appellants
Vs.
Suresh Kumar and others .....Respondents
1. Judgment reserved on 21.08.2026
2. Judgment pronounced on 19.11.2026
3. Judgment uploaded on 20.11.2026
4. Whether only operative part of the judgment is
pronounced or whether the full judgment is Full
pronounced.
5. The delay, if any of the pronouncement is full Nil
judgment and reason thereof.
CORAM:- HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE YASHVIR SINGH RATHOR
Argued By:-Mr. Rohit Mittal, Advocate for the appellants.
Mr. Kapil Aggarwal, Advocate for respondents
No.1 and 2.
Mr. Abhishek Goyal, Advocate for respondent
No.3.
(Through Video Conferencing).

Yashvir Singh Rathor, J.
1. The present appeal has been instituted by claimants against the Award dated
31.03.2003 passed by Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Narnaul (for short “Tribunal”), vide
which MACT Case No.93 of 2001/02, filed by the claimants on account of death of Bhoop
Singh in a motor vehicle accident due to rash and negligent driving on the part of respondent
RENU
2026.11.20 16:26
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO No.2431 of 2003 (O&M) -2-
No.1 while driving truck No.HRM-3529) (for short ‘the offending vehicle’), owned by
respondent No.2, was dismissed.
2. Case of claimants is that on 08.12.2000, Bhoop Singh (since de-
ceased) was going to his village Lehroda on scooter bearing registration No.HR-
35-8555. At about 6:30 PM, when he reached near Fatni curve, truck bearing
registration No.HRM-3529 came from the side of Rewari which was being driven
rashly and negligently by respondent No.1- Suresh Kumar and at a high speed.
He could not control the truck and hit the scooter from behind as a result of which,
Bhoop Singh fell on the road and died at the spot. It is alleged that accident took
place solely due to rash and negligent driving of offending vehicle by respondent
No.1 which was owned by respondent No.2 and insured with respondent No.3 and
as such, all the respondents are jointly and severally liable to pay compensation to
the claimants. It is alleged that deceased- Bhoop Singh was running a dairy and
used to earn Rs.7,000/- per month.
3. Respondents No.1 and 2 in their written statement have denied the
factum of accident submitting that on 8.12.2000, the truck never came on the road
as it was in the workshop for repairs and the vehicle in question has been falsely
implicated to extract compensation. Remaining contents of the petition regarding
age and income of deceased have also been refuted to be wrong and dismissal of
the petition has been sought.
4. Insurance Company in its written statement has also taken similar
pleas and it is further submitted that the driver was not possessing a valid and ef-
fective driving licence and Insurance Company is not liable to indemnify the in-
sured.
RENU
2026.11.20 16:26
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO No.2431 of 2003 (O&M) -3-
5. From the pleadings of parties, following issues were framed by the
learned Tribunal:-
1. Whether Bhup Singh died in a motor vehicular accident caused
on 8.12.2000 due to rash and negligent driving of truck bear-
ing registration No.HRM-3529 by Suresh Kumar (respondent
No.1) which was owned by Puran Chand (respondent No.2)
and was insured by United Insurance Co. Ltd. (respondent
No.3)?OPP
2. If issue No.1 is proved, whether Smt. Bimla etc. (petitioners)
are entitled to a compensation of Rs.20 lac or any other
amount if so, how much?OPP
3. Whether truck No.HRM-3529 was being driven by a person
who was not holding a valid and effective driving licence at the
time of accident?OPR
4. Whether the said truck was being driven in violation of the
terms and conditions of the Insurance Policy?OPR
5. Relief.”
6. Thereafter, the parties led evidence in support of their case.
7. After hearing learned counsel for the parties and on going through the
material on file, learned Tribunal held under Issue No.1 that accident in question
had not taken place on account of rash and negligent driving on the part of respon-
dent No.1 while driving the offending truck and infact, the said vehicle was not in-
volved in the accident and resultantly, the claim petition was dismissed.
8. Feeling aggrieved, the appeal in hand has been preferred. The mate-
rial on file has been perused and parties have been heard.
9. Learned counsel for appellant contended that award passed by the
Tribunal is based on conjectures and surmises. The pleadings of the parties and
RENU
2026.11.20 16:26
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO No.2431 of 2003 (O&M) -4-
material on file have not been appreciated in the correct perspective while dis-
missing the claim petition. Learned counsel next contended that scooter of the de-
ceased was being followed by scooter being driven by Bir Singh who had wit-
nessed the accident and the claimants have examined PW2 Bir Singh as well as
PW3 Kanwar Singh and they had chased the truck upto a considerable distance
but their own scooter got punctured as a result of which they could not apprehend
respondent No.1. Learned counsel next contended that nothing favourable could
be extracted during the cross-examination of PW2 and PW3 so as to impeach their
testimony. The evidence led by the claimants had gone unrebutted as respondent
No.1 had not stepped into the witness box to controvert their testimony and state
his case on oath and to offer himself for cross-examination and in these circum-
stances, the testimony of PW2 and PW3 should have been relied upon to come to
the conclusion that accident in question had taken place due to rash and negligent
driving on the part of respondent No.1 while driving the offending vehicle and he
prayed that finding on issue No.1 be reversed and adequate compensation be
awarded to the claimants- appellants.
10. On the other hand, learned counsel for respondents argued that the
award in question is well reasoned and justified. The material on file has been ap-
preciated in the correct perspective and no interference in the same is thus called
for.
11. At the very outset, it is pertinent to mention that FIR in the present
case was got registered by one Rajender Singh which has been led in evidence as
Ex.PW5/A and has been proved by PW5 UGC Jagat Ram. He stated that FIR was
RENU
2026.11.20 16:26
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO No.2431 of 2003 (O&M) -5-
recorded against an unknown person and name of the driver and registration num-
ber of the offending vehicle are not mentioned in the FIR. Respondents have ex-
amined RW1 HC Balbir Singh who deposed that untrace report was prepared by
the Police in the afore-said FIR which was forwarded to the Area Magistrate and
the final report is Ex.R3 on which order Ex.R4 was passed by Judicial Magistrate
Ist Class, Narnaul. A perusal of the order Ex.R4 shows that the untrace report has
been accepted by the Ld. Magistrate as the offending vehicle could not be traced
during the investigation.
12. No doubt, the claimants have examined PW2 and PW3 who have de-
posed that they were following the scooter of the deceased and had seen offending
vehicle hitting the scooter of deceased from behind yet they never approached the
police and informed about the registration number of the offending vehicle. PW2
has stated that he had identified the driver i.e. respondent No.1 but still, he did not
disclose his name to the police and remained a mute spectator despite the fact that
he belonged to the village of the deceased. Rather, it shows that he has been sub-
sequently introduced to support the version of claimants being a co-villager. Had
both PW2 and PW3 witnessed the accident, they would have certainly informed
the registration number of the offending truck as well as name of the driver to the
police and would not have remained silent particularly because deceased belonged
to village of PW2 and such a conduct cannot be expected from a normal prudent
man. In these circumstances, learned Tribunal rightly discarded the testimony of
PW2 and PW3 and the evidence led by claimants while coming to the conclusion
that offending vehicle was not involved in the accident. It is well settled that onus
to prove rash and negligent driving on the part of driver of the offending vehicle
RENU
2026.11.20 16:26
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO No.2431 of 2003 (O&M) -6-
and the involvement of the offending vehicle in the accident is upon the claimants.
This fact has to be proved by leading cogent and credible evidence and sympathy
for victims cannot override legal principles. However, in the present case, the
presence of PW2 and PW3 is doubtful at the time of accident and had they wit-
nessed the accident, the registration number of the offending vehicle would cer-
tainly have been disclosed the police and in these circumstances, their testimony
cannot be relied upon rather, it was a hit and run case. Resultantly, it is held that
there is no infirmity in the finding on issue No.1 and the same is accordingly af-
firmed.
13. In view of the above, the present appeal is dismissed.
14. Pending misc. application (s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
(Yashvir Singh Rathor)
Judge
November 19, 2026
renu
Whether Speaking/reasoned Yes/No
Whether Reportable Yes/No
RENU
2026.11.20 16:26
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document