BRUHATH BANGALORE MAHANAGARA PALIKE vs MR. T JAYASHANKARA

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55532
RFA No. 1762 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010483532022




IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

TH
DATED THIS THE 5 DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026


BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HANCHATE SANJEEVKUMAR

REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO.1762 OF 2022 (INJ)


BETWEEN:


BRUHATH BANGALORE MAHANAGARA PALIKE
CORPORATION BUILDINGS, N.R. SQUARE,
BANGALORE-560 002, REP. BY ITS
CHIEF COMMISSIONER
…APPELLANT





(BY SRI. SATYANAND.B.S., ADVOCATE)


AND:

MR. T.JAYASHANKARA S/O. MR. THIMMAIAH
AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
ND
R/AT: NO. 527, 2 MAIN ROAD,
ST ST
BSK 1 STATE, 1 BLOCK,
SRINAGARA, BANGALORE-560 050.
…RESPONDENT




Digitally
signed by N
UMA
Location:
HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA

(BY SRI. VIKRAM.G., ADVOCATE)
THIS RFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 96 R/W ORDER 41 RULE 1
OF CPC AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 30.06.2022
PASSED IN OS No.26289/2019 ON THE FILE OF THE LXXIV
ADDITIONAL CITY CIVIL AND SESSIONS JUDGE, MAYOHALL UNIT,
CITY CIVIL COURT, BENGALURU (CCH 75) DECREEING THE SUIT FOR
PERPETUAL PROHIBITORY INJUNCTION AND ETC.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR ADMISSION, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55532
RFA No. 1762 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010483532022


CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HANCHATE SANJEEVKUMAR

ORAL JUDGMENT
This Regular First Appeal is filed by the defendant-BBMP
calling in question the judgment and decree dated 30.06.2022
in O.S.No.26289/2019 on the file of the learned LXXIV
Additional City Civil and Sessions Judge, Mayohall Unit,
Bengaluru (CCH-75), whereby the suit filed seeking for
perpetual prohibitory injunction was decreed, restraining the
defendant-BBMP from demolishing the structure existing in the
suit property or any portion therein and/or interfering with his
possession and enjoyment of the suit property.

2. Heard Sri. Satyanand.B.S., learned counsel for the
appellant and Sri. Vikram.G., learned counsel for the
respondent.

3. For the sake of convenience, the parties are
referred to, as per their rankings before the Trial Court.

4. The plaintiff and his brothers are stated to be the
owners of the suit schedule property having purchased the
same through registered sale deed dated 24.11.2004 and in all
the records their names were mutated. The plaintiff and his

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55532
RFA No. 1762 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010483532022


brothers are in possession and enjoyment of the suit schedule
property by paying tax to the defendant-BBMP.

5. Further, it is the case of the plaintiff that the
plaintiff and his brothers have put up temporary structure in
the suit property by using iron rods. The Officials of the BBMP
were threatening the plaintiff stating that they would demolish
the structure put up in the suit property. Therefore, the
plaintiff filed the suit after issuing notice dated 06.08.2019 to
the defendant under Section 482(1) of the Karnataka Municipal
Corporations Act, 1976 (for short 'KMC Act'). The defendant
received the said notice on 08.08.2019. When this being the
fact, the officials of the defendant-BBMP visited the suit
property and were in process of demolishing the structure put
up therein by causing interference with the plaintiff’s
possession without following due process of law, therefore, the
plaintiff filed suit for perpetual prohibitory injunction.

6. The defendant resisted the suit by filing the written
statement and contended that the defendant had issued the
notice under Section 308 of KMC Act calling upon the plaintiff to
produce the documents of the suit property and also to remove

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55532
RFA No. 1762 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010483532022


the structure put up therein, stating that the structure was
illegal.

7. Further, it is contended that the said notice was
received by the plaintiff. Therefore, the suit is not
maintainable. Hence, the defendant prays for dismissal of the
suit.

8. Based on the pleadings of the parties, the Trial
Court framed the following issues:

1. Whether the plaintiff proves that, defendant made
vehement threats to cause damage to the suit
property and interfered with his possession and
enjoyment of the said property as alleged in para
No.5 of the plaint?
2. Whether the defendant proves that, the suit is not
maintainable for the reasons stated in para No.4 & 6
of the written statement?
3. Whether the defendant proves that, the suit is bad for
non-joinder of necessary party?
4. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the relief of
injuction as prayed for?
5. What Order or Decree?

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55532
RFA No. 1762 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010483532022



9. The plaintiff was examined as P.W.1 and produced
documentary evidence and got them marked as Exs.P1 to P9.
The defendant has not led any evidence but confronted the
notice marked as Ex.D1 to the plaintiff.

10. The Trial Court after considering the evidence on
record has decreed the suit for permanent injunction
restraining the defendant-BBMP from demolishing the structure
existing in the suit property or any portion therein and/or
interfering with the plaintiff’s possession and enjoyment of the
suit property.

11. The Trial Court assigned the reason that, though
the defendant claimed that the notice at Ex.D1 was issued and
served on the plaintiff under Section 308 of the KMC Act, but
there was no evidence to show that the plaintiff had received
the said notice, as there was no acknowledgment evidencing
service of the said notice on the plaintiff. When there was no
evidence to show that the plaintiff had received the notice
under Section 308 of KMC Act, then there could not be any
initiation of proceedings under the KMC Act. Therefore, for the
aforesaid reasons, the Trial Court decreed the suit. Further,

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55532
RFA No. 1762 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010483532022


the Trial Court assigned the reason that the defendant without
due process of law has forwarded to interfere with the plaintiff’s
property. Hence, the suit was decreed in favour of the plaintiff.

12. Being aggrieved by the judgment and decree
passed by the Trial Court, the appellant/defendant-BBMP has
preferred this appeal by raising various grounds and learned
counsel for the appellant in consonance with the grounds urged
has submitted that the suit itself is not maintainable as it is
impliedly barred under Section 9 of the CPC.

13. Further, it is submitted that the defendant-BBMP
had issued show cause notice under Section 308 of KMC Act.
Therefore, when the defendant had initiated proceedings under
the KMC Act, the suit is not maintainable and it is impliedly
barred under Section 9 of the CPC.

14. Further, the learned counsel by placing reliance on
the order passed by this Court in W.P No.9934/2023 dated
17.08.2026 in the case of Smt.Kavitha Jain and another v.
The Commissioner, BBMP and others submitted that, the
District Judges do not have jurisdiction where the BBMP has
initiated proceedings under Section 248(1) and (2) of the BBMP

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55532
RFA No. 1762 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010483532022


Act, 2020 within the City of Bengaluru. Therefore, it is
submitted that the City Civil Court lacks jurisdiction to entertain
the suit. In this regard, the learned counsel placed reliance on
the Circular issued by this Court dated 11.01.2024 based on
the judgment passed by this Court in the case of Smt.Kavitha
Jain stated supra .

15. Further, it is submitted that the Trial Court has
committed an error in granting decree for permanent
prohibitory injunction without observing that the defendant
may take recourse to due process of law. Therefore, it is
submitted that the decree passed by the Trial Court amounts to
legitimisation of the illegal structure put up on the suit property
by the plaintiff. Therefore, the learned counsel also prays for
modification of the judgment and decree, in case, the appellant
makes out a case for grant of injunction. For the aforesaid
reasons canvassed, learned counsel for the appellant prays to
set aside / modify the judgment and decree passed by the Trial
Court.

16. On the other hand, learned counsel for the
respondent/plaintiff submitted that the Trial Court is correct in

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55532
RFA No. 1762 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010483532022


holding that the defendant-BBMP had not served the notice at
Ex.D1 to the plaintiff. Therefore, the Trial Court appreciated
the evidence on record correctly that without initiating due
process of law has gone to interfere with the possession of the
plaintiff. Hence, the learned counsel justified the judgment and
decree passed by the Trial Court.

17. Further, it is submitted that the order passed by
this Court in the case of Smt.Kavitha Jain stated supra in W.P
No.9934/2023 dated 17.08.2026 was set aside by the
Division Bench of this Court in W.A No.1301/2023 and
connected cases dated 16.09.2025 in the case of Chief
Commissioner & another v. Smt.Smita Vijay . Therefore, it
is submitted that the direction issued by the learned Single
Judge in W.P No.9934/2023 in Smt.Kavitha Jain case was set
aside on both aspects that the Zonal Commissioner alone can
exercise powers under Section 248 of the BBMP Act, 2020 and
the District Judges do not have jurisdiction to entertain the suit.
Therefore, it is submitted that the suit is maintainable. Hence,
the learned counsel prays to dismiss the appeal.

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55532
RFA No. 1762 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010483532022



18. Heard the submissions of learned counsel for both
the parties and also perused the records, the following points
arise for my consideration:

i) Whether under the facts and circumstances
involved in the case, the Trial Court is correct in
holding that the defendant has not issued show
cause notice under Section 308 of KMC Act?

ii) Whether under the facts and circumstances
involved in the case, the Trial Court is justified in
granting decree for permanent injunction without
observing the defendant is at liberty to initiate
action by due process of law?

iii) Whether the judgment and decree passed by the
Trial Court requires to be modified?


19. The plaintiff is the owner and title of the suit
property. This aspect is not denied by the defendant. It is
the case of the defendant that plaintiff has put up structure
illegally in violation of building bye-laws. Therefore, the
defendant initiated proceedings by issuing show cause notice
under Section 308 of KMC Act. But on the other hand, it is the
case of the plaintiff that the defendant without having authority

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55532
RFA No. 1762 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010483532022


and following due process of law interfered with the plaintiff’s
possession of the suit property.

20. While considering these rival contentions, the
burden is on the defendant to prove that the defendant- BBMP
had issued show cause notice under Section 308 of KMC Act.

21. Ex.D1 is the show cause notice dated 04.05.2019
but upon appreciating the evidence on record, the Trial Court
observed that though the said notice was addressed to the
plaintiff but there was no signature of the plaintiff or the other
co-owners on Ex.D1-notice to establish that the plaintiff and
other co-owners had received the said notice. Ex.D1 is the
notice issued by the Assistant Executive Engineer, BBMP,
J.P.Nagar, Sub-Division, Bengaluru. Therefore, the Trial Court
has given a finding that the defendant has not proved the fact
that Ex.D1-notice was served on the plaintiff. Therefore, the
Trial Court held that the action initiated by the defendant is
without due process of law and granted an injunction in favour
of the plaintiff.

22. Upon considering the pleadings and evidence on
record, it is the case of the defendant that plaintiff has violated

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55532
RFA No. 1762 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010483532022


the building bye-laws and has constructed the structure
unauthorisedly. When this being the fact, as alleged by the
defendant, then the defendant-BBMP has power and authority
to initiate proceedings in accordance with law to remove the
structures if it is found to be unauthorized and illegal.
Therefore, Ex.D1-notice does not contain the signature of the
plaintiff to prove the fact that the plaintiff has received the said
notice. Therefore, in these circumstances, the defendant-BBMP
is authorized to initiate necessary action in accordance with law
and without following the due process of law, the defendant
cannot take any action against the plaintiff. In this regard, the
decree granted by the Trial Court in blanket totally restraining
the defendant from demolishing the structure is not correct.
Though the Trial Court was justified in granting the decree for
prohibitory injunction but the same curtails the right of BBMP
to initiate action in accordance with law. Therefore, in this
regard, the judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court is
required to be modified holding that, though the plaintiff is
entitled for decree of permanent injunction restraining the
defendant from demolishing the structure existing in the suit

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55532
RFA No. 1762 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010483532022


property or any portion therein and/or interfering with his
possession and enjoyment of the suit property but the
defendant shall not proceed against the plaintiff without
following due process of law.

23. Therefore, the judgment and decree passed by the
Trial Court is liable to be modified. Accordingly, it is modified
to the effect that decree of permanent injunction granted
against the defendant from demolishing the structure existing
in the suit property or any portion therein and/or interfering
with the plaintiff’s possession but liberty is reserved to the
defendant to initiate action in accordance with law and by
following due process of law. The plaintiff shall pass order and
take action in accordance with law. Till then, the decree for
permanent injunction is continued. Accordingly, I answer point
No.(i) in the affirmative , point No.(ii) in the negative and
point No.(iii) in the partly affirmative .

24. During the course of arguments, a very interesting
discussion is made by the learned counsel appearing for the
appellant and the respondent. Sri.Satyanand B.S., learned
counsel for the appellant submitted that recently the Bruhat

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55532
RFA No. 1762 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010483532022


Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike Act, 2020 is repealed and the
‘Greater Bengaluru Governance Act of 2024 (for short ‘GBG Act,
2025) has been enacted by the legislature of the State of
Karnataka. For this, learned counsel for the respondent
commented upon the very nomenclature made to the Greater
Bengaluru Governance Act of 2024 particularly the use of
English words “Greater and Governance” in naming the
enactment as the ‘Greater Bengaluru Governance Act of 2024.

25. For this, the learned counsel for the appellant has
fairly submitted that the Government might have chosen
appropriate alternative words for the English words ‘Greater
and Governance’ in the nomenclature of the enactment in place
of English words ‘Greater and Goverance’. The learned counsel
submitted that the Kannada language is a rich and prosperous
language and is one of the most ancient languages in the
world. Further, it is submitted that the history of Kannada
language traces back to more than 2500 years old. It is
submitted that the Kannada language was originated before
1000 years of the birth of Christ i.e., 3000 years ago and till

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55532
RFA No. 1762 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010483532022


today, the Kannada language is being celebrated as a glorious
language as it has a rich culture and a great heritage.

26. Both the learned counsel submitted that the
Kannada language is an incredible language and has rich
abundance of words. Therefore, learned counsel suggested
making use of Kannada language for naming the enactment by
replacing the English words ‘Greater and Governance’ and
inserting the words “ (Bruhat) in the place of ‘Greater’
ಹ”
and “ ಆಡ ತ” (Adalitha) in the place of ‘Governance’.

27. Considering the concern shown by the learned
counsel appearing for the appellant and the respondent, the
Court has appreciated the efforts being made by the Bar in
suggesting measures to promote and to celebrate the use of
Kannada language while naming and enacting the legislations.
Therefore, honouring the concern expressed by the learned
advocates appearing for the appellant and respondent, the
Court is of the opinion and completely agrees with the
submissions made by the learned Advocates, that a request is
to be made to the Government by this Court. The Court
expresses its concern regarding the development of Kannada

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55532
RFA No. 1762 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010483532022


language while naming the enactment. Therefore, this Court
requests the Government to consider naming the enactment in
the Kannada language by replacing the words ‘Greater and
Governance’ and in its place suitable Kannada words may be
inserted/replaced. For this, the State Government may
constitute a Committee consisting of many prominent
personalities in literatures. They have devoted their lives to
the promotion and development of the Kannada language and
the Committee may suggest any appropriate word in a Kannada
language so as to put the name in a Kannada language instead
of using the words ‘Greater and Governance’ which is in
English.

28. Therefore, the Chief Secretary of the Government
of Karnataka and the Hon’ble Minister, Department of Kannada
and Culture, Government of Karnataka, are requested to take
necessary steps in this regard in honouring the great feelings of
the Bar. Thus, this Court is completely in consonance with the
concern expressed by the Bar. Therefore, it is requested to
take necessary action in this regard for nomenclating the
enactment, namely, ‘The Greater Bengaluru Governance Act of

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55532
RFA No. 1762 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010483532022


2024, by using the Kannada language by replacing the words
‘Greater and Governance’.

29. With the above said observations, I proceed to pass
the following:
ORDER

i) The Regular First Appeal is allowed in part.

ii) The judgment and decree dated 30.06.2022 passed
in O.S.No.26289/2019 by the learned LXXIV
Additional City Civil and Sessions Judge, Mayohall
Unit, Bengaluru (CCH-75), is modified to the effect
that the defendant-BBMP is restrained from
demolishing the structure existing in the suit
property or any portion therein and/or interfering
with the plaintiff’s possession and enjoyment of the
suit property unless due process of law is taken, the
defendant shall not cause interference of demolishing
the structure put up on the suit schedule property.
The order of injunction is continued till due process
of law is taken by the defendant and

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55532
RFA No. 1762 of 2022


CNR: KAHC010483532022


passing order and taking action in accordance with
law.

iii) Other observation made by the Trial Court shall not
come in the way of taking due process of law by the
defendant-appellant.

iv) The Registrar General is directed to forward a copy
of this order to the Chief Secretary to the
Government of Karnataka and the Hon’ble Minister
for Department of Kannada and Culture, Government
of Karnataka, highlighting the observations made by
this Court at paragraphs No.24 to 28.

Sd/-
(HANCHATE SANJEEVKUMAR)
JUDGE




SMJ, UN
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 44