Sharda Devi and Anr vs State Of Bihar and Anr

Court
Patna High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
CRIMINAL MISCELLANEOUS No.47367 of 2017
CNR No. BRHC010960972017
Arising Out of PS. Case No.-139 Year-2016 Thana- PAHARPUR District- East Champaran
======================================================
1. Sharda Devi W/o Shri Tuntun Sharma resident of village Barwan, P.O. -
Areraj, P.S. Govindganj, District East Champaran.
2. Ranjan Sharma S/o Shri Tuntun Sharma Resident of village- Barwan, P.O.-
Areraj, P.S.- Govindganj, District- East Champaran.
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1. State Of Bihar
2. Madhukar Kumar Singh S/o Shri Shambhu Sharan Singh Resident of
village- Laukahan, P.S.- Paharpur, District- East Champaran
... ... Opposite Party/s
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Petitioner/s : Mr.Shri Prakash Srivastava, Advocate
For the Opposite Party/s : Mr.Smt. Anita Kumari, APP
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANSUL
ORAL JUDGMENT
Date : 06-11-2026
Heard the parties.
2. This application under Section 482 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973 has been preferred for quashing of the
First Information Report registered as Paharpur P.S. Case No. 139
of 2016, corresponding to G.R. No. 3624 of 2016, under Sections
363 and 366 of the Indian Penal Code, and the entire criminal
proceeding arising out of it, presently pending before the learned
Chief Judicial Magistrate, East Champaran at Motihari.
3. The fardbeyan of the informant, opposite party no. 2
Madhukar Kumar Singh, was recorded on 22.07.2016 at 16:30
hours. It states that his marriage with Nisha Devi, daughter of

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.47367 of 2017 dt.06-11-2026
2/8
Munna Thakur of village Khajuria, Police Station Govindganj, was
solemnised on 10.07.2016. It goes on to state that on 20.07.2016,
at about 3.30 a.m., his wife left the house to answer the call of
nature and did not come back; that a search was made through
relatives without success; and that on 22.07.2016, that is two days
later, he learnt that she had been kidnapped by petitioner no. 2,
Ranjan Sharma, at the instance of petitioner no. 1 Sharda Devi,
who is Ranjan Sharma's mother, both of village Barwan, Police
Station Govindganj. The fardbeyan adds that the informant
thereafter spoke to his wife on her mobile number and that she had
taken away certain ornaments and clothes. On this fardbeyan,
Paharpur P.S. Case No. 139 of 2016 was registered under Sections
363 and 366 of the Indian Penal Code.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that
neither petitioner has any connection with the alleged occurrence,
that the allegation of kidnapping rests on nothing beyond the bare
word of the informant, and that the record itself, once it is read as a
whole, shows the entire prosecution to be an afterthought raised by
a man whose own conduct towards his wife was the actual cause
of her leaving the matrimonial home.
5. That submission has to be weighed against the rest of
what is on record, and the matrimonial history between the

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.47367 of 2017 dt.06-11-2026
3/8
informant and Nisha Devi cannot be kept out of that reckoning.
Barely two months after the alleged kidnapping, on 23.09.2016,
Nisha Devi herself instituted Matrimonial Case No. 296 of 2016
under Section 13 of the Hindu Marriage Act before the learned
Principal Judge, Family Court, Motihari, seeking dissolution of her
marriage with the informant. She has stated there that the marriage
was solemnised against her wishes, that the informant was a
widower of about 45 years with two sons aged 13 and 11 years,
and that on the night following the marriage she was pressed to
submit to unnatural sex, a demand that continued and was
accompanied by beating whenever she resisted. She has said in
terms that she left her sasural during the night of 20.07.2016, the
very date the fardbeyan gives for the alleged kidnapping, and took
shelter with a relative because she saw no other way out.
6. On the same date, 23.09.2016, she also filed an
application under Section 14(1) of the Hindu Marriage Act seeking
leave to present the divorce petition before completion of one year
of marriage, describing her case as one of exceptional hardship.
Neither petition has been shown to be false or withdrawn, and
nothing on this record suggests that either proceeding was got up
for the purpose of this quashing application. They were filed for an
independent, civil purpose of their own, well before any occasion

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.47367 of 2017 dt.06-11-2026
4/8
could have arisen to manufacture a defence to the present criminal
case.
7. Nisha Devi also gave a statement under Section 164
of the Code of Criminal Procedure, on 21.10.2016, before the
learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Motihari, in this very
case. She said she was making the statement of her own will,
without fear or pressure. She said Madhukar Singh had filed a case
against a person she did not even know. She said that:-
“ ¼1½ eSa viuk c;ku LosPNk ls fcuk fdlh Hk;] ncko ds ns jgh gwWA
fu”kk nsoh
jktho dqekj
voj U;k;k/kh”k&3
lg
vk0 eq0 U;k0 n.Mk0
eksfrgkjh
¼2½ esjh “kknh e/kqdj dqekj flag ds lkFk gqbZ FkhA e/kqdj iwoZ ls “kknh”kqnk gS
vkSj mlds 2 cPps gSaA gels dkQh cM+k gSA eSa e/kqdj ds ikl ;k lkFk
jguk ugha pkgrh gwWA eq>s og dkQh ekjrk vkSj fiVrk gSA Ckkj&2 xyr
djrk gSA
¼3½ e/kqdj flag ,d vatku O;fDr ij dsl dj fn;k gSA eSa mldks ugha
tkurh gwWA
¼4½ esjk fdlh us vigj.k ugha fd;k gS] eS eqt¶Qjiqj esa viuh lgsfy;ksa ds
lkFk jgdj i<+kbZ dj jgh gwWA
¼5½ eS viuh ethZ ls eqt¶Qjiqj tkuk pkgrh gwWA
fu”kk nsoh
jktho dqekj
voj U;k;k/kh”k&3
lg
vk0 eq0 U;k0 n.Mk0
eksfrgkjh
21-10-2016 ”

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.47367 of 2017 dt.06-11-2026
5/8
She did not merely deny compulsion. She said she did not know
the man named as her abductor.
8. This is not a statement got up for the purposes of this
petition. It was recorded within three months of the alleged
occurrence, by a Magistrate, on oath, while the investigation was
still open, long before anyone could have anticipated that a
quashing petition would be needed at all. Neither the informant
nor the State has, at any stage over the years this case has
remained pending, suggested that the statement is false, extracted
under pressure, or otherwise unreliable. Material of that kind,
sound and not capable of being brushed aside, is exactly what the
Supreme Court had in mind in Rajiv Thapar v. Madan Lal
Kapoor, (2013) 3 SCC 330 , when it held that such material may be
looked into at this stage to see whether it displaces the accusation
altogether.
9. Sections 363 and 366 of the Indian Penal Code punish
the kidnapping of a person from lawful guardianship and the
kidnapping or abduction of a woman with intent that she may be
compelled to marry against her will or forced or seduced to illicit
intercourse. Nisha Devi was, on her own showing and on the
record of the marriage itself, a major of about 21 years, already
married to the informant. She was not a minor being taken from a

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.47367 of 2017 dt.06-11-2026
6/8
guardian within the meaning contemplated by Section 361, and the
fardbeyan does not allege, even in the barest terms, that the
petitioners used force or inducement to compel her into a marriage
or into intercourse with anyone. It states only that she was
kidnapped for the purpose of marriage, without a single particular
of how, by whom she was approached, or what compulsion was
applied. In Mafat Lal v. State of Rajasthan, 2022 SCC OnLine
SC 433 , dealing with a similarly worded allegation, the Supreme
Court held that an accusation of kidnapping for marriage does not
attract Section 366 unless some element of force or compulsion is
shown. Going purely by what the fardbeyan itself says, without
anything the petitioners have placed on record, the ingredients of
neither offence are made out.
10. These two difficulties, one visible on the face of the
complaint and the other arising from material that has since come
on record, fall within the categories recognised in State of
Haryana v. Bhajan Lal, 1992 Supp (1) SCC 335 , where the
Supreme Court held, among other things, that the inherent power
may be used where the allegations, even taken at their face value,
do not make out an offence, or where they are so improbable that
no prudent person could think there was ground to proceed, or
where the proceeding is shown to be actuated by a private grudge

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.47367 of 2017 dt.06-11-2026
7/8
rather than a genuine grievance. Nisha Devi left a marriage
marked, on her own account, by concealment of a prior family and
by cruelty. The fardbeyan naming two strangers as her abductors
was lodged two days later, before she had made any complaint of
her own. It has since been followed by her divorce petition, her
application under Section 14(1), and her statement under Section
164, none of which the informant has cared to contest, though the
matter has in the meantime been listed for admission before more
than one Bench, as the order-sheet itself shows.
11. Learned counsel appearing for opposite party no. 2
has not been able to point to anything on the record that meets
these documents. No counter affidavit has been filed, either by the
informant or by the State, controverting the matrimonial petitions
or the statement under Section 164, even though notice was issued
to opposite party no. 2 as far back as December 2023. That silence
does not by itself entitle the petitioners to an order of quashing,
and this Court has looked at the record on its own merits rather
than treat it as an admission. Having done that, this Court does not
see how a trial could end in anything except the vindication of the
petitioners. Nisha Devi, the person said to have been kidnapped,
has stated on oath that it did not happen and that she does not even
know the man accused of it.

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.47367 of 2017 dt.06-11-2026
8/8
12. There is little to be gained by sending the petitioners
to trial on these facts. It would keep two people under prosecution
for an offence that Nisha Devi's own later statement, given on
oath, rules out, in a case built on a fardbeyan that said nothing of
the informant's earlier marriage or of why his wife actually left
him. This is not a matter for trial. It is a matter for the inherent
power under Section 482 to prevent the process of the Court from
being misused.
13. In view of the above, this application is allowed. The
First Information Report registered as Paharpur P.S. Case No. 139
of 2016, corresponding to G.R. No. 3624 of 2016, under Sections
363 and 366 of the Indian Penal Code, and the entire criminal
proceeding arising from it, including the charge sheet, if any
submitted, and the order of cognizance, if taken, now pending
before the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, East Champaran at
Motihari, stand quashed.
14. There shall be no order as to costs.
(Ansul, J)
amitkr/-
AFR/NAFR NAFR
CAV DATE 25.08.2026
Uploading Date 07.11.2026
Transmission Date 07.11.2026