DEV RAJ vs ALOK KUMAR AND ANOTHER
- Court
- High Court of Himachal Pradesh
1 . ( 2026:HHC:41375 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH
SHIMLA
High Court of H.P.
Cr. Revision No.89 of 2024
Reserved on 15.09.2026
Decided on 25.09.2026
Uploaded on : 25.09.2026
Dev Raj …Petitioner
Versus
s
Alok Kumar & Anr. …..Respondents
Coram:
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Chirag Bhanu Singh, Judge.
1
Whether approved for reporting? Yes
For the Petitioner : Mr. Praveen Chandel, Advocate.
For the Respondents : Mr. Ankush Dass Sood, Senior
Advocate with Mr. Ankit Dhiman,
Advocate, for respondent No.1.
Mr. Lokender Kutlehria, Additional
Advocate General, for respondent
No.2/State.
__________________________________________________________
Chirag Bhanu Singh, Judge
The petitioner has preferred the present revision
assailing the order dated 16.10.2023, passed by learned
Judicial Magistrate First Class, Rajgarh, Camp at Sarahan,
District Sirmaur, H.P., (hereinafter referred to as the learned
trial Court), whereby his application filed under Section
156(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure stands dismissed.
1
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes.
::: Downloaded on - 25/09/2026 17:02:28 :::CIS
2 . ( 2026:HHC:41375 )
2. In brief, the genesis leading to the dismissal of the
High Court of H.P.
aforesaid application may be succinctly summarized thus.
The petitioner had preferred the complaint inter-alia alleging
that the accused/respondent though was the son of one Shri
Babu Ram and his date of birth has been recorded as
21.10.1971, but, he in connivance and collusion with the
Panchayat had got himself recorded, as Alok Kumar son of
Shri Swaroop Singh in place of Alok Kumar son of Shri Babu
Ram. The fact that the accused/respondent was the son of
Shri Babu Ram and has also been duly recorded in the
Panchayat, as well as, the school records.
3. It is further averred by the petitioner that a Will
dated 27.01.1999, was executed by Shri Swaroop Singh and
respondent No.1, had been shown, as his nephew. However,
in a Family Settlement Deed No.709/2013, dated
31.08.2013, accused/respondent has been reflected, as son
of Shri Swaroop Singh. The accused-respondent had
thereafter, also obtained agriculturist certificate bearing
No.1102 NT-3758-2013, dated 30.08.2013, intentionally and
deliberately by giving a false declaration that he was son of
Shri Swaroop Singh. The respondent-accused had also
::: Downloaded on - 25/09/2026 17:02:28 :::CIS
3 . ( 2026:HHC:41375 )
procured a false report from the revenue agency for wrongful
High Court of H.P.
gain knowing-fully well that the accused-respondent was the
son of Shri Babu Ram.
4. It is further averred by the petitioner himself that
the Will bearing No.87/16, dated 05.07.2016, registered
before the Sub Registrar, Pachhad, District Sirmaur, H.P., is
stated to be executed by Shri Swaroop Singh who himself had
stated that he was having only one son namely, Alok Kumar
(respondent) and had no more children.
5. The aforesaid Deeds were stated to be wrong,
illegal, void, manipulated, suspicious, fabricated and a result
of fraud having been prepared by the respondent-accused, in
collusion and connivance with the scribe of marginal
witnesses. No adoption of any kind have been taken place
between Shri Swaroop Singh and accused-respondent.
6. It was thus, prayed that since a prima-facie case
has been made out against the accused/respondent, under
Section 465, 467 and 420-B of the IPC, an appropriate legal
action be initiated against respondent/accused.
7. The learned trial Court, after having sought the
affidavit from the petitioner and after having heard and
::: Downloaded on - 25/09/2026 17:02:28 :::CIS
4 . ( 2026:HHC:41375 )
perused the record went on to dismiss the application, hence,
High Court of H.P.
the present revision.
8. Based on the aforesaid allegations, it is the
contention of the petitioner that the learned trial Court
without holding any inquiry has wrongly dismissed the
application. It has failed to appreciate that no document
regarding any valid adoption had been placed on record. It
was urged with vehemence that the learned trial Court has
passed a non-speaking order and failed to appreciate that
civil and criminal proceedings may go on simultaneously.
There was sufficient material on record disclosing a
cognizable offence. The learned trial Court has failed to
appreciate the documents in its right perspective. The
learned Court below without any preliminary inquiry has
come to the conclusion that the settlement deed was valid.
9. Per contra, the learned counsel appearing for the
respondent urged that he had sought a stay against the
petitioner on 18.01.2023. Since the petitioner did not pay
any heed to the stay, he had been constrained to report the
matter to the police on 05.02.2023 and as a counter blast,
the complaint has been filed by the petitioner. While filing
::: Downloaded on - 25/09/2026 17:02:28 :::CIS
5 . ( 2026:HHC:41375 )
the complaint, the petitioner had very cleverly failed to refer
High Court of H.P.
the civil suit and the status quo order passed against him. It
was further urged that the petitioner had failed to mention in
the complaint, preferred under Section 156(3) of the Cr.P.C.,
that he had also even earlier approached the police. There is
no such averment in the complaint. The learned Court below
had after due deliberations and after seeing the record placed
on record by the petitioner himself come to the conclusion
that no cognizable offence was made out, and the learned
trial Court was well within its right, dismissed the complaint
at the threshold.
10. Having heard the rival contentions of learned
counsel for the parties and after gone through the record, the
learned trial Court came to the conclusion that the petitioner
had placed on record enumerable documents. The learned
trial Court after having sought an affidavit from the petitioner
and having heard and perused the record had passed the
impugned order. The mere using of the word heard, “Record
perused” will reflect that the learned trial Court had applied
his mind to the facts alleged in the complaint. If such
statement recorded by the learned trial Court is in order,
::: Downloaded on - 25/09/2026 17:02:28 :::CIS
6 . ( 2026:HHC:41375 )
under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C., there may not be much scope
High Court of H.P.
for the petitioner, as in the instant case, the challenge in the
correctness of such order on the ground that the learned trial
Court had passed it mechanically, without applying his mind
to the facts alleged in the complaint.
11. In this behalf support can be aptly drawn from the
judgment titled as Y.N. Ramachandra Rao versus M/s CCI
Limited (2011) Cr. Law Journal 1073.
12. The perusal of the documents placed on record by
the petitioner himself shows that accused/respondent, has
been shown as son of Shri Swaroop Singh in the Will, dated
05.07.2016, along with agriculture certificate placed on
record. The settlement deed prepared by Shri Swaroop Singh,
himself and placed on record by the petitioner also reflects
Alok Chauhan, as his son. The Nakal Parivar Register placed
on record by the petitioner himself shows that in the
Goshawara, after between 31.12.2010 to 31.12.2015, the
parentage of accused/respondent, Alok Chauhan had been
shown, as Swaroop Singh. The name of Alok Chauhan had
been removed from the Parivar Register of Shri Babu Ram
and reflected in the Parivar Register of Shri Swaroop Singh
::: Downloaded on - 25/09/2026 17:02:28 :::CIS
7 . ( 2026:HHC:41375 )
and thereafter, he came to be consistently reflected in the
High Court of H.P.
Parivar Register of Shri Swaroop Singh. The petitioner
himself had placed these documents on record, which had
been duly considered by the learned trial Court.
13. Seemingly a further corroborated by the
documents placed on record before this Court. After having
considered the documents on record, since the learned trial
Court came to the conclusion that the allegations in the
complaint do not disclose any cognizable offence, the learned
trial Court had dismissed the application. Preferring such a
complaint to the police for investigation would have been an
order without jurisdiction. After having considered the
documents placed on record, if the learned trial Court comes
to the conclusion that no cognizable offence is made out, the
learned trial Court would be well within its right to dismiss
the complaint at the threshold. The said proposition is more
than settled in law.
14. Even otherwise, one another aspect, which
conspicuously comes to the Court is that the petitioner in his
complaint has nowhere spelt out that he had approached the
police, under Sections 154(1) & 154(3) of the Cr.P.C., there is
::: Downloaded on - 25/09/2026 17:02:28 :::CIS
8 . ( 2026:HHC:41375 )
not a whisper in the complaint in this regard. The bare
High Court of H.P.
perusal of Section 154(1), is suggestive of the fact that any
information relating to the commission of a cognizable
offence, in the first instance, has to be given to the Officer
Incharge of the Police Station and in case, a person has
aggrieved by the refusal on the part of the Officer Incharge of
the Police Station to record the FIR, he may approach the
Superintendent of Police concerned. There is nothing on
record to remotely show that the petitioner had approached
the Officer Incharge of the Police Station. A feeble attempt
was made to prove that the petitioner had approached the
Superintendent of Police, but no action had been taken by
him. The said complaint is stated to have been made on
13.06.2023 and the date on the complaint however, preferred
before the learned trial Court was on 12.06.2023.
15. The learned counsel for the respondent has thus,
highly placed reliance of the judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Priyanka Srivastava and another versus
State of Uttar Pradesh and others, reported in (2015) 6
Supreme Court Cases 287, which inter-alia clearly held that
it is incumbent to move an application under Section 154(1)
::: Downloaded on - 25/09/2026 17:02:28 :::CIS
9 . ( 2026:HHC:41375 )
and 154(3) of Cr.P.C., before filing a petition under Section
High Court of H.P.
156(3) of Cr.P.C. and the said aspect was also clearly spelt
out in the application/complaint and necessary documents
to that effect also had to be filed along with the complaint. It
may be apposite to reproduce para-31 of the aforesaid
judgment, which reads thus:-
“31. We have already indicated that there has to be prior
applications under Section 154(1) and 154(3) while filing a
petition under Section 156(3). Both the aspects should be
clearly spelt out in the application and necessary documents
to that effect shall be filed. The warrant for giving a
direction that an the application under Section 156(3) be
supported by an affidavit so that the person making the
application should be conscious and also endeavour to see
that no false affidavit is made. It is because once an affidavit
is found to be false, he will be liable for prosecution in
accordance with law. This will deter him to casually invoke
the authority of the Magistrate under Section 156(3). That
apart, we have already stated that the veracity of the same
can also be verified by the learned Magistrate, regard being
had to the nature of allegations of the case. We are
compelled to say so as a number of cases pertaining to fiscal
sphere, matrimonial dispute/family disputes, commercial
offences, medical negligence cases, corruption cases and the
cases where there is abnormal delay/laches in initiating
criminal prosecution, as are illustrated in Lalita Kumari are
being filed. That apart, the learned Magistrate would also be
aware of the delay in lodging of the FIR.”
13. There is nothing on record to remotely suggest that
anything has been highlighted by the learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner to prove that the learned trial
Court had not applied his mind, before coming to the
conclusion that no cognizable offence was made out against
::: Downloaded on - 25/09/2026 17:02:28 :::CIS
10 . ( 2026:HHC:41375 )
the respondent. In fact, the documents placed on record by
High Court of H.P.
the petitioner itself are suggestive of the fact that not only
Shri Swaroop Singh made a settlement deed showing the
respondent to be his adopted son, but even the Goshwara of
the Parivar Register also goes to show that the name of the
respondent had been removed from the household of Shri
Babu Ram and included in the name of Shri Swaroop Singh.
14. Further during the course of the present
proceedings, the marriage card of the respondent, legal heirs
certificate, the pension papers of Shri Swaroop Singh and the
documents of the Municipal Corporation, clearly spelt out
that Alok Kumar has been shown to be son of Shri Swaroop
Singh.
15. Seeing to the fact that the parties were already
embroiled in civil litigation, as has been discussed herein-
above, it cannot be ruled out that the present criminal
proceedings initiated by the petitioner was initiated as a ploy
to settle scores with the respondent or pressurize him to
settle civil dispute pending between them.
16. Even otherwise, if the allegations made by the
petitioner are taken at its face value, apparently, the
::: Downloaded on - 25/09/2026 17:02:28 :::CIS
11 . ( 2026:HHC:41375 )
provisions of Section 464, are still not attracted. Section 464
High Court of H.P.
defines, as under:-
“Section 464 defining “making a false document” is
extracted below:
“464. Making a false document-A person is said to make a
false document or false electronic record—
First — Who dishonestly or fradulently—
(a) makes, signs, seals or executes a document or part of a
document;
(b) makes or transmits any electronic record or part of any
electronic record;
(c) affixes any electronic signature on any electronic record;
(d) makes any mark denoting the execution of a document or
the authenticity of the electronic signature,
with the intention of causing it to be believed that such
document or part of document, electronic record or
electronic signature was made, signed, sealed, executed,
transmitted or affixed by or by the authority of a person by
whom or by whose authority he knows that it was not made,
signed, sealed, executed or affixed; or
Secondly — Who, without lawful authority, dishonestly or
fraudulently, by cancellation or otherwise, alters a document
or an electronic record in any material part thereof, after it
has been made, executed or affixed with electronic signature
either by himself or by any other person, whether such
person be living or dead at the time of such alteration; or
Thirdly — Who dishonestly or fraudulently causes any
person to sign, seal, execute or alter a document or an
electronic record or to affix his electronic signature on any
electronic record knowing that such person by reason of
unsoundness of mind or intoxication cannot, or that by
reason of deception practised upon him, he does not know
the contents of the document or electronic record or the
nature of the alteration.”
::: Downloaded on - 25/09/2026 17:02:28 :::CIS
12 . ( 2026:HHC:41375 )
17. The perusal of the allegations against the
High Court of H.P.
respondent nowhere shows that he had either himself signed
or executed any of documents to make him fall within the
purview of Section 464 and likewise, the condition precedent
for offences under Sections 467 and 471 of IPC, is forgery.
There is nothing on record to remotely show that the
respondent had forged any of the documents purportedly
placed on record. There is nothing placed on record by the
petitioner that the respondent had made or executed any of
these documents claims to be someone else, or had
authorized someone else to alter or tamper the documents or
at least obtained some documents by practised deception on
some other person. It was not sufficient for the petitioner to
prove that the document had been made or executed
dishonestly or fraudulently to make it fall under the category
of “false documents”. There was something further which was
required to have been proved that it was made with the
intention of causing it to be believed to be true and correct.
The provisions of Sections 467 and 471 of IPC, thus, were not
otherwise, prima-facie attracted. In this behalf a support can
be aptly drawn by judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
::: Downloaded on - 25/09/2026 17:02:28 :::CIS
13 . ( 2026:HHC:41375 )
titled as Mohammed Ibrahim and others versus State of
High Court of H.P.
Bihar and another, reported in (2009) 8 Supreme Court
Cases 751.
18. For all the reasons detailed herein-above, I see no
reasons to differ with the findings recorded by the learned
trial Court. The order dated 06.10.2023 passed by the
learned Judicial Magistrate First Class, Rajgarh, camp at
Sarahan, District Sirmaur, is affirmed. The revision petition
is thus, dismissed, being devoid of any merits.
19. The petition is disposed of accordingly, so also the
pending application(s), if any.
(Chirag Bhanu Singh)
Judge
th
25 September, 2026
(subhash)
::: Downloaded on - 25/09/2026 17:02:28 :::CIS