ASHLESHA MEHTA vs All India Radio
- Court
- Central Administrative Tribunal
:: 1 :: OA No.4/2023
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
AHMEDABAD BENCH
Original Application No. 4/2023
th
Dated this the 30 day of October, 2026.
Reserved On: 01.10.2026
Pronounced On: 30.10.2026
CORAM:
Hon’ble Shri Jayesh V Bhairavia, Member (J)
Hon’ble Shri Sanjiv Kumar, Member (A)
Smt. Ashlesha Mehta W/o Late Shri Mihir Mehta,
Age: 59 years, Serving as TREX
In the office of the respondents i.e. Director DDK, Ahmedabad
Residing at M/14/159, Vidyanagar Flats,
132 Feet Ring Road, B/h. Himmatlal Park-II,
Ahmedabhad – 380 015.
… Applicants
(By Advocate Mr. M S Trivedi)
V/s.
1. Chief Executive Officer,
O/o. All India Radio, Vigilance Section,
Akashwani Bhavan, Sanand Marg,
New Delhi – 110 001.
2. The Director General,
O/o. DG All India Radio
Akashwani Bhavan, Sansad Marg,
New Delhi – 110 001.
3. The Director
O/o the Director,
Doordarshan Kendra, Thaltej Tekra,
Ahmedabad – 380 054.
… Respondents
(By Advocate Mr. H D Shukla)
P ANUKUMA
:: 2 :: OA No.4/2023
ORDER
Per: Hon’ble Shri Sanjiv Kumar, Member (A)
1. The applicant has filed the present OA, under Section 19 of the
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, seeking the following reliefs:
(A) That the Hon’ble Tribunal be pleased to allow this
petition.
(B)That the Hon’ble Tribunal further be pleased to
hold/declare the action on the part of the respondents
regarding Non payment of legal expenses incurred by the
applicant in defending CBI Court Proceedings, as mentioned
in the communication dtd. 15/10/2019 of the respondents,
claim submitted by the applicant on 21/7/2020 to the
respondents.
(C) That the Hon’ble Tribunal further be pleased to direct the
respondents to settle/pay the claim of the applicant as
mentioned in request/representation dtd. 21/7/2020 in
pursuant to communication dtd. 15/10/2019 of the
respondents
(D) Such other and further relief/s as may be deemed just and
proper in view of the facts and circumstances of the case may
be granted.
2. Brief facts of the case as stated by the applicant are as under: -
2.1 The applicant is a permanent employee of the respondents, serving as
Transmission Executive (TREX) under All India Radio/Prasar
Bharati.
2.2 While the applicant was serving at All India Radio, Ahmedabad,
criminal proceedings were initiated against her by the Central Bureau
of Investigation (CBI) pursuant to a complaint made by the then
Station Director, All India Radio, Ahmedabad. The applicant was
prosecuted in Special CBI Case No. 06/2009 and she was acquitted
by the learned Special Judge, CBI Court, Ahmedabad, vide judgment
dated 04.05.2019.
2.3 The respondents informed vide communication dated 15.10.2019 that
the Travelling Allowance (TA) for attending the CBI proceedings
could be granted to the applicant only if the legal expenses incurred
in defending the proceedings were reimbursed, either in full or in
part, by the Department. Thereafter, the applicant submitted a
P ANUKUMA
:: 3 :: OA No.4/2023
representation dated 21.07.2020 seeking reimbursement of the legal
expenses incurred by her in Special CBI Case No. 06/2009.
2.4 The applicant submits that she has incurred substantial expenditure
towards professional fees and other legal charges for defending the
criminal proceedings. The applicant contends that despite submission
of the requisite claim and supporting documents, the respondents
have neither finalised her claim nor reimbursed the legal expenses as
per Ministry of Home Affairs Office Memorandum dated 08.01.1959
and the provisions of Article 320(3)(d) of the Constitution of India.
2.5 Hence, applicant is seeking appropriate directions upon the
respondents to consider and settle her claim for reimbursement of
legal expenses, along with interest and other consequential reliefs.
3. Submission of learned counsel for the applicant:
3.1 Learned counsel for the applicant submits that the applicant is a
permanent employee of the respondents and her claim for
reimbursement of legal expenses arose out of criminal proceedings
initiated against her pursuant to a complaint made by the then Station
Director, All India Radio, Ahmedabad.
3.2 Learned counsel submits that the applicant was acquitted in Special
CBI Case No. 06/2009 by judgment dated 04.05.2019 and the
respondents, vide communication dated 15.10.2019, had specifically
linked the grant of TA with reimbursement of legal expenses incurred
in defending the CBI proceedings.
3.3 It is contended that the applicant submitted her claim dated
21.07.2020 along with the relevant supporting documents. Despite
the lapse of considerable time, the respondents have failed to take a
final decision on the claim or release any amount towards
reimbursement.
3.4 Learned counsel further submits that the omission of the name of the
applicant’s advocate in the judgment dated 04.05.2019 was
subsequently rectified by the learned Special Judge, CBI Court,
Ahmedabad, vide order dated 04.09.2020. Therefore, the said
P ANUKUMA
:: 4 :: OA No.4/2023
omission cannot be a ground to withhold consideration of the
applicant’s claim.
3.5 Learned counsel argues that the claim is required to be examined in
accordance with the applicable Government instructions, including
the Ministry of Home Affairs Office Memorandum dated 08.01.1959,
and the relevant constitutional provisions concerning consultation
with the UPSC, wherever applicable. The respondents cannot
indefinitely keep the claim pending without taking an appropriate
decision in accordance with law.
3.6 It is further submitted that the continued inaction of the respondents
is arbitrary and has caused financial hardship to the applicant. The
respondents ought to have processed and decided the claim within a
reasonable period, particularly when the relevant representation and
supporting documents had already been submitted.
3.7 In view of the above submissions, learned counsel for the applicant
prays that this Hon’ble Tribunal may be pleased to direct the
respondents to consider and settle the applicant’s claim for
reimbursement of legal expenses submitted on 21.07.2020, in
accordance with the applicable rules and instructions, together with
interest and consequential reliefs as may be deemed just and proper.
4. Submission of learned counsel for the respondents:
4.1 Per contra, respondents have filed their reply and denied the claim of
the applicant.
4.2 Learned counsel for the respondents submitted that the applicant,
who retired as a Transmission Executive from All India Radio,
Ahmedabad, has claimed reimbursement of legal expenses spent on
defending criminal cases filed by the Central Bureau of Investigation.
He contended that the application is not maintainable because the
claim was never submitted through the proper official channels to the
Directorate, meaning no valid cause of action has arisen against the
respondents. Moreover, he pointed out that the financial claim put
forward by the applicant is merely a lump-sum amount without any
P ANUKUMA
:: 5 :: OA No.4/2023
hearing-wise bifurcation, bills, or receipts of payments made to
advocates.
4.3 Learned counsel for the respondents further submitted that the
records clearly show that during her service, the applicant, along with
her late husband who was a Program Executive, secretly created a
private firm in another person’s name called M/s Maanisha Creatives.
Through this unauthorized firm, she secured production contracts for
programs meant for Akashvani from the Tribal Development
Corporation and illegally earned substantial production costs.
Consequently, the learned Special Judge for CBI Court No. 3 at
Ahmedabad, vide judgment dated 22.08.2023 in Special Case No. 31
of 2009, convicted the applicant under Section 168 of the IPC,
Section 420 read with Section 120-B of the IPC, and Section 13(2)
read with Section 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988,
sentencing her to imprisonment. Additionally, departmental
proceedings against her were concluded, and the Ministry of
Information and Broadcasting imposed a penalty of withholding 10%
of her monthly pension for one year.
4.4 Learned counsel for the respondents argued that the rules regarding
the reimbursement of legal expenses for government servants are
governed by the Ministry of Home Affairs Office Memorandum
dated 08.01.1959. Under these guidelines, the government does not
reimburse legal costs for criminal proceedings instituted by the State
unless the case concludes completely in favor of the employee and
the government is satisfied that the employee faced the proceedings
without proper justification. In the present case, the applicant was not
acquitted; rather, she was formally convicted of criminal charges
after a full trial, and her prosecution arose from her own serious
misconduct of engaging in private trade in violation of the Conduct
Rules. Furthermore, he submitted that the applicant’s reliance on
communication dated 15.10.2019 is entirely misplaced, as that
relates to Travelling Allowance for attending court dates and treating
P ANUKUMA
:: 6 :: OA No.4/2023
those days as on duty and has nothing to do with legal cost
reimbursement.
4.5 In conclusion, learned counsel for the respondents submitted that in
view of these established facts, the applicant’s criminal conviction,
and the clear statutory guidelines, the applicant is not entitled to any
reimbursement or financial assistance. Therefore, the OA is
completely devoid of merit and is liable to be dismissed.
5. Applicant has filed the rejoinder and reiterated the submissions made
in the OA.
6. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material
available on record.
7. Having considered the pleadings and the submissions, the following
points arise for determination:
(i) Whether the communication dated 15.10.2019 confers upon the
applicant a right to reimbursement of the legal expenses incurred in
defending Special CBI Case No. 06/2009;
(ii) Whether the proceedings in Special CBI Case No. 06/2009 arose
out of acts done by the applicant in the discharge of her official
duties, so as to bring her claim within the instructions governing
reimbursement of legal expenses;
7.1 The respondents have raised a preliminary objection that the claim
was never submitted through proper official channels to the
Directorate, and so no cause of action has arisen. The communication
dated 15.10.2019 was also issued to the applicant. Thereafter, she
applied directly to the Director General by her representation dated
21.07.2020. There is no proof on record that it was sent through
proper channel, and the respondents have clearly stated that it was
not. The applicant, in her rejoinder, has stated that non-receipt of the
communication/correspondence in the concerned section is not a
valid ground to deny the claim, and that the respondents should have
decided it on their own. We cannot presume that the representation
was received and that the respondents failed to act on it. However,
P ANUKUMA
:: 7 :: OA No.4/2023
without going into this controversy, we proceed to decide the case on
merits.
7.2 Point (i): The claim of the applicant rests essentially on the
communication No. 15/1693/95-S.VII/476 dated 15.10.2019. Relief
(B) seeks a declaration with reference to that communication, and
relief (C) seeks payment “in pursuant to communication dtd.
15/10/2019”. The relevant portion reads as under: -
“(i) TA for appearing CBI Cases- In light of S.R. 153-A, it
is clarified that TA for attending the CBI cases at Ahmedabad
may be granted to Smt. Ashlesha Metha, only if the legal
expenses incurred by her in defending the CBI Court
proceedings have been reimbursed to her, in full or in part by
the Department. Otherwise, TA will not be granted to her.
(ii) Treatment of period spent in attending CBI cases- In
light of S.R. 154, it has already been clarified vide this
Directorate’s letter dated 05.08.2019 and 09.10.2019 (Copies
enclosed) that period spent by Smt. Mehta in attending the CBI
cases may not be treated as on duty. As such, Smt Mehta may
be requested to apply for earned leave or any other kind of
leave due for the periods spent by her in attending the CBI
cases else these periods maybe treated as on unauthorized
absence.”
The communication was issued by the Directorate General, All India
Radio (S-VII Section), to the Head of Office, All India Radio, Bhuj,
with a copy to the applicant, in response to the letter of All India
Radio, Bhuj, dated 19.08.2019 seeking legal and administrative
advice.
7.3 A plain reading of the communication shows that its subject is
Travelling Allowance and the treatment of the period spent in
attending the CBI cases. It does not deal with any claim for legal
expenses. Paragraph 2(i) makes the grant of Travelling Allowance
conditional upon reimbursement of legal expenses; it does not
provide that legal expenses shall be reimbursed. The words “only if”
and “Otherwise, TA will not be granted to her” show that
reimbursement of legal expenses was treated as an uncertain event,
which may or may not happen. The communication neither sanctions
nor approves any claim for legal expenses, nor does it refer to any
amount. To read it as an assurance that the legal expenses would be
P ANUKUMA
:: 8 :: OA No.4/2023
paid would reverse its meaning. Further, by paragraph 2(ii) of the
same communication, the Directorate declined to treat the period
spent by the applicant in attending the CBI cases as duty. Far from
accepting that the proceedings concerned her official duties, the
communication treats her attendance in those proceedings as her own
affair, to be covered by leave.
7.4 Moreover, the communication was not, and could not be, a decision
on reimbursement of legal expenses. It was advice to the Head of
Office, All India Radio, Bhuj, on the processing of the applicant’s
requests for Travelling Allowance and duty treatment. Under
paragraph 5 of the Ministry of Home Affairs Office Memorandum
dated 08.01.1959 (Annexure R-3), the decision on a claim for legal
expenses rests with the administrative Ministry, in consultation with
the Ministries of Finance and Law where necessary, and, under
Article 320(3)(d) of the Constitution, after consultation with the
Union Public Service Commission where that provision applies. A
communication issued on the subject of Travelling Allowance cannot
take the place of that decision or bind the Government to make
payment.
7.5 Even if the communication were read as an assurance, no right could
arise from it contrary to the governing instructions. A communication
of an office cannot enlarge the scope of the OM or create an
entitlement which the OM does not confer, and there can be no
estoppel or legitimate expectation against the terms of the governing
instructions. Government servants are prosecuted in a large number
of cases. Reimbursement of the cost of their defence out of public
funds is an exception, confined by the OM to the cases it covers and
to be decided in the manner it prescribes.
7.6 Point (ii): Both parties rely on the Ministry of Home Affairs Office
Memorandum No. F-45/5/53-Ests.(A) dated 08.01.1959, placed on
record by the respondents as Annexure R-3. The relevant portion
reads as under: -
P ANUKUMA
:: 9 :: OA No.4/2023
“(4) Legal and financial assistance to Government servants
involved in law suits arising out of their official work and
conduct”.
Paragraph 2(a), under the heading “Proceedings initiated by
Government in respect of matters connected with the official
duties or position of the Government servant”.
“Government will not give any assistance to a Government
servant for his defence in any proceedings, civil or criminal
instituted against him by the State in respect of matters arising
out of, or connected with, his official duties or his official
position. Should, however, the proceedings conclude in favour
of the Government servant, Government will entertain his
claim for reimbursement of costs incurred by him for his
defence, and if Government are satisfied from the facts and
circumstance of the case that the Government servant was
subjected to the strain of the proceedings without proper
justification, they will consider whether the whole or any
reasonable proportion of the expenses incurred by the
Government servant for his defence should be reimbursed to
him.”
Paragraph 2(b), under the heading “Proceedings in respect of
matters not connected with official duties or position of the
Government servant”.
“Government will not give any assistance to a Government
servant or reimburse the expenditure incurred by him in the
conduct of proceedings in respect of matters not arising out of or
connected with, his official duties or his official position,
irrespective of whether the proceedings were instituted by a
private party against the Government servant or vice versa.”
Paragraph 4 explains that
“the act must bear such relation to the official duties that the
Government servant could lay a reasonable but not a pretended
or a fanciful claim that he did it in the course of the
performance of his duties.”
Paragraph 5 provides that
“The appropriate authority for taking decision in each case will
be the administrative Ministry of the Government of India
concerned who will consult the Finance and Law Ministries,
where necessary.”
7.7 A bare reading of the OM makes it clear that the act must be
connected with official duty. This condition must be satisfied before
any question of the outcome of the proceedings, the satisfaction of
the Government or the quantum of expenses can arise. If the
proceedings did not arise out of acts done in the discharge of official
duties, the OM does not apply at all, and no reimbursement can be
made under it, whatever the result of the proceedings.
P ANUKUMA
:: 10 :: OA No.4/2023
7.8 In her representation dated 21.07.2020, the applicant herself states
that, on the complaint of the then Station Director, All India Radio,
Ahmedabad, the then Vigilance Officer lodged an FIR against her
before the CBI, Gandhinagar, and that after investigation the CBI
filed two cases against her, namely, Special Case No. 06/2009 and
Special Case No. 31/2009. Both cases thus arose from the same
complaint and the same investigation. The judgment dated
22.08.2023 in Special Case No. 31 of 2009 records that the case arose
from FIR RC-18(A)/2008-GNR dated 31.10.2008, and that charges
were framed under Sections 168, 420 and 120-B of the Indian Penal
Code read with Section 13(2) read with Section 13(1)(d) of the
Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. Section 168 of the Indian Penal
Code deals with a public servant unlawfully engaging in trade. The
case of the respondents is that the applicant, along with her late
husband, carried on a private firm, M/s Maanisha Creatives, in the
name of another person, and through it obtained production contracts
for programmes meant for Akashvani. Allegations of this nature,
namely private trade, cheating and criminal misconduct for pecuniary
advantage, do not relate to acts done in the discharge of official duty.
An act of corruption, that is, the securing of an illegal gain or
advantage for oneself or another by abuse of one’s position, is an act
done on one’s own personal account. The official position of the
Government servant may furnish the occasion or the opportunity for
such an act, but that does not make it a matter arising out of, or
connected with, her official duties or official position within the
meaning of paragraph 2(a) of the OM. Carrying on a private firm in
the name of another person to obtain production contracts, and
obtaining pecuniary advantage by abuse of position, can never be
claimed to be done in the performance of official duties. No part of
the official duties of a Transmission Executive in All India Radio can
include the acts alleged against the applicant. The applicant has
neither pleaded nor shown that the acts for which she was prosecuted
were acts done, or purporting to be done, in the execution of her duty.
P ANUKUMA
:: 11 :: OA No.4/2023
7.9 The acquittal of the applicant by judgment dated 04.05.2019 does not
alter this position. Under the OM, the question is the nature of the
matter in respect of which the proceedings were instituted, not their
outcome. An acquittal means that the prosecution failed to prove the
charge; it does not convert the acts alleged into acts done in the
discharge of official duties. The proceedings in Special CBI Case No.
06/2009 thus fall under paragraph 2(b) of the OM, under which no
reimbursement is admissible. In this view of the matter, the questions
whether the prosecution was without proper justification, and what
part of the expenses, if any, would be reasonable, do not arise. For
the same reason, Article 320(3)(d) of the Constitution, on which the
applicant relies, does not help her. It applies only to the costs of
defending proceedings in respect of acts “done or purporting to be
done in the execution of his duty”.
7.10 Even if the claim were taken to fall under paragraph 2(a) of the OM,
it could be entertained only if the proceedings “conclude in favour of
the Government servant”. The Central Bureau of Investigation has
filed an appeal against the judgment of acquittal dated 04.05.2019
before the Hon’ble High Court of Gujarat, and the appeal is pending.
The acquittal has, therefore, not attained finality. The applicant in her
rejoinder has stated that the judgment dated 22.08.2023 in Special
Case No. 31 of 2009 has no relevancy so far as the issue/grievance
involved in the present petition is concerned. The claim before us
relates only to Special CBI Case No. 06/2009, and we have not
decided it on the merits of the other case. However, both cases arose
from the same complaint, and in the other case the applicant has been
convicted by judgment dated 22.08.2023. With the acquittal under
appeal and a conviction in the connected case, the criminal
proceedings arising from that complaint cannot be said to have
concluded in her favour. It would not be appropriate to hold that she
was subjected to the proceedings without proper justification on the
basis of the acquittal in one case alone.
P ANUKUMA
:: 12 :: OA No.4/2023
7.11 Even otherwise, the claim of Rs. 14,50,000/- is a consolidated sum,
without any hearing-wise or item-wise statement, for two advocates
who, by her own statement, defended her in both cases. The choice of
counsel and the fee agreed were her own. As the claim fails on the
grounds stated above, we need not go into these details.
7.12 The pendency of the representation dated 21.07.2020 does not, by
itself, create a legal right to the amount claimed. Such a right must be
established under the OM. The communication dated 15.10.2019
confers no such right. The proceedings in question did not arise out
of acts done in the discharge of official duties, and the claim falls
outside the OM. Even under paragraph 2(a), the proceedings have not
concluded in her favour.
7.13 In view of the foregoing, we hold that the applicant is not entitled to
reimbursement of the legal expenses incurred in defending Special
CBI Case No. 06/2009. Relief (B) and relief (C) cannot be granted.
8. In view of the above discussion and findings, the OA is devoid of
merit and is accordingly dismissed.
9. There shall be no order as to costs.
10. Pending MA, if any, shall also stand disposed of.
(Sanjiv Kumar) (Jayesh V Bhairavia)
Member (A) Member (J)
//Anu//
P ANUKUMA