Omkara Assets Reconstruction Private Limited vs Sahjunimpex Trading Pvt Ltd

Court
Bombay High Court

pmk 33-APP(L)-6326-2026.doc
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
APPEAL (L) NO.6326 OF 2026
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION (L) NO.6779 OF 2026
Omkara Assets Reconstruction Pvt Ltd ]
a Company incorporated under the ]
Companies Act, 1956 and registered ]
with Reeserve Bank of India as an ]
Asset Reconstruction Company under ]
Section 3 of the SARFAESI Act, 2002 ]
and having its Corporate Office at ]
th
Kohinoor Square, 47 Floor, N C Kelkar ]
Marg, RG Gadkari Chowk, Dadar ]
(West), Mumbai 400 028 ] … Appellant
V/s.
Sahjun Impex Trading Pvt Ltd ]
A company incorporate under the ]
Companies Act, 1956 and having its ]
registered address at 330, Nana Peth, ]
Laxmi Road, Pune – 411 002 ] … Orig. Applicant
In the matter between:
KSL & industries Ltd. ]
A company incorporated under the ]
Companies Act, 1956, having its ]
corporate office at Kamat Industrial ]
Estate, Veer Savarkar Marg, ]
Prabhadevi, Mumbai – 400 025 ] … Petitioner

Digitally
signed by
PRIYANKA
MADHAVRAO
KALE
Date:
2026.08.20
15:47:37
+0530
PRIYANKA
MADHAVRAO
KALE
V/s.
Patheja Forging & Auto Parts ]
Manufacturing Ltd (In Liquidation) ]
1/6

pmk 33-APP(L)-6326-2026.doc
through the Official Liquidator ]
Having its registered office at E-20, ]
MIDC Industrial Area, Bhoisar, ]
Pune – 411 026. ] … Respondent

Mr. Prakash Shinde a/w Ms. Niyati Merchant, Ms. Rajlaxmi Pawar i/by MDP
Legal for the Appellant.
Mr. Zubin Behramkamdin, senior counsel a/w Ms. Sakshi Kashyap i/by
Ms. Kaizeen Mistry for the Respondent.

CORAM : A. S. GADKARI AND
KAMAL KHATA, JJ.
nd
RESERVED ON : 22 July, 2026
th
PRONOUNCED ON : 20 August, 2026.
Judgment (Per : Kamal Khata, J.):-
1) By the present Appeal, the Appellant seeks to set aside the Order
rd
dated 3 February, 2026, passed by the learned Single Judge in the
Company Application filed by the Applicant seeking transfer of the
captioned Company Petition to the Hon’ble National Company Law Tribunal
under the provisions of Section 434(1)(c) of the Companies Act, 2013. By
the impugned Order, the learned Single Judge has allowed the transfer of
the captioned Company Petition to N.C.L.T.
2) Mr. Shinde, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the Appellant
submits that, the Appellant intervened in the Application, objecting to the
transfer of the Petition to N.C.L.T. mainly on the ground that the steps taken
by the official liquidator in the company liquidation were irreversible. He
2/6

pmk 33-APP(L)-6326-2026.doc
contends that the learned Judge erroneously applied the test of ‘corporate
death’ to the present case.
3) He further submits that, the learned Single Judge failed to
consider that, the company had been in winding up since 2008, with its net
worth having eroded as early as 1997. The Board for Industrial and
Financial Reconstruction (B.I.F.R.) affirmed the direction to wind up under
Section 20 of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985,
finding that the company was no longer a going concern and lacked
functional manufacturing units or operational assets. The impugned Order
proceeded on a mere theoretical possibility of revival, contrary to the
material on record, which establishes that the company had crossed the
point of no return. He contends that any revival is illusory and speculative.
4) Mr. Shinde submitted that, irreversible steps had been taken,
including the sale of core industrial and factory assets at Aurangabad
(Walunj) and Chakan / Bhosari / Pimpri, Pune through the D.R.T.
proceedings, whereby the base assets have been extinguished. These sales
were confirmed by statutory authorities, and there is no possibility of
reversal. He further submits that the learned Judge misread and misapplied
the Supreme Court decisions in A. Navinchandra Steels Private Limited vs.
SREI Equipment Finance Limited and Others, reported in 2021 4 SCC 435,
and Action Ispat and Power Pvt Ltd vs. Shyam Metalics and Energy Limited
reported in 2021 2 SCC 641 particularly paragraph 25 thereof. The learned
3/6

pmk 33-APP(L)-6326-2026.doc
single Judge also failed to undertake a fact-intensive enquiry mandated in
A. Navinchandra Steels Pvt Ltd (supra), resulting in unsettlement of the
concluded proceedings.
5) He further submits that the conduct of the Applicant was also
overlooked. In particular, the Applicant had suppressed the ongoing and
concluded D.R.T. proceedings, and material subsequent developments were
not placed on record. The Applicant failed to disclose the sale of critical
assets, which would have rendered the entire C.I.R.P. proceedings
meaningless. He contends that impugned Order disregarded the statutory
rights of the secured creditors. He reiterates that, with core assets having
been sold, there remains no possibility of the company's revival or transfer
to N.C.L.T.
6) Per contra , Mr. Behramkamdin, senior counsel appearing on
behalf of the Respondent, submits that there is no justification for refusing
to revive the company, particularly as the Applicant now represents more
than 50 percent of the total financial debt owed by the company and stands
as an erstwhile financial creditors entitled to seek revival. He submits that
the Application was filed in accordance with law under Section 434 (1)(c)
of the Companies Act and that the learned Single Judge correctly
appreciated both the law and the facts, warranting dismissal of the Appeal.
7) We have heard the learned counsel for the Appellant as well as
the Respondent and have carefully examined the impugned Order and the
4/6

pmk 33-APP(L)-6326-2026.doc
entire record.
8) We find merit in the submissions of Mr. Behramkamdin,
representing the erstwhile financial creditors now holding more than 50
percent of the company’s financial debt. A financial creditor is entitled in
law to seek a transfer of proceedings to N.C.L.T. for the revival of the
company. We find no justifiable reason to reject such an Application by an
erstwhile financial creditor, particularly where the Applicant seeks to do the
same in a time bound manner and within the rehabilitative framework
provided under the I.B.C.
9) The Supreme Court in Action Ispat and Power Private Limited vs.
Shyam Metalics and Energy Limited (supra), held that the power of the
company Court to transfer winding up proceedings to the N.C.L.T. under
Section 434(1)(c) of the Companies Act must be exercised by examining
whether winding up has reached an irreversible stage. Mere admission of a
winding-up Petition and appointment of a provisional liquidator, or even
the liquidator taking possession of the assets, does not by itself constitute
an irreversible position.
10) In our view, the Appellant’s case is not that no assets exists to
enable company’s revival. It is for the investors to decide whether revival
would be beneficial to their interest. Consequently, if there exists a
possibility to revive the company under the IBC framework, the sale of
assets by the secured creditors standing outside the winding-up proceedings
5/6

pmk 33-APP(L)-6326-2026.doc
does not by itself constitute an irreversible step warranting refusal of
transfer. We are fortified by the decision of the Supreme Court in A. Navin
Chandra Steels Pvt. Ltd. (supra).
11) The record shows that the company possesses assets located at
Thane, Bangalore and Pune, currently in the custody of the receiver
appointed by the Debt Recovery Tribunal (the D.R.T.). There are also
certain plots at Aurangabad and Pune that were sold outside the winding
up proceedings; certain other assets located at Pune and Gujarat remain in
the custody of the official liquidator. The record indicates that the Official
Liquidator took only limited steps, which cannot be characterized as
irreversible or amounting to corporate death. We find the impugned Order
to be well-reasoned, having considered all material facts and applicable law,
and see no justifiable reason to set it aside.
12) The Appeal accordingly is dismissed with no order as to costs.
13) In view of disposal of Appeal, Interim Application does not survive
and is accordingly disposed off.
(KAMAL KHATA, J.) (A.S. GADKARI, J.)
6/6