TVS MOTOR COMPANY LIMITED vs THE DEPUTY CONTROLLER OF PATENTS AND DESIGNS
- Court
- Madras High Court
CMA(PT) No.61 of 2024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
RESERVED ON
PRONOUNCED ON
28.07.2026
12.11.2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE K.KUMARESH BABU
CMA(PT) No. 61 of 2024 &
CMP.No.25526 of 2024
TVS Motor Company Limited,
“Jayalakshmi Estate:
No.29, (Old No.8), Haddows Road,
Chennai – 600 006. ..Appellant(s)
Vs
The Deputy Controller of Patents and Designs
Patent Office, I.P.Building, GST.Road, Guindy,
Chennai 32.
..Respondent(s)
PRAYER:- Civil Miscellaneous Appeal filed under Section 117A of the
Patents Act, 1970 against the order of the Deputy Controller of Patents and
th
Designs to set aside the impugned order dated 19 July 2024 in respect of the
Indian Patent Application No.201841004638 and allow Patent Application
No.201841004638.
For Petitioner(s): Mr.Damodar Vaidya
for Mrs.Deepika Murali
For Respondent(s): Mr.A.R.Sakthivel SPCGSC
JUDGMENT
The present Civil Miscellaneous Appeal has been filed seeking to set aside the
__________
Page1 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )
CMA(PT) No.61 of 2024
impugned order dated 19.07.2024 passed by the respondent in respect to the
Application No.201841004638 and allow the patent Application
No.201841004638.
2. The facts giving rise to the present appeal is that the Appellant engaged
in the business of manufacturing various two-wheeled and three-wheeled
vehicles, had filed an application for the grant of the patent on 07.02.2018. The
invention forming the subject matter of the aforesaid patent application was
titled “A Vehicle”, comprising a set of Claims 1 to 11. Pursuant to the request
for examination filed by the Appellant on 22.04.2021, the respondent had issued
the First Information Report (hereinafter referred to as ‘FER’) dated
24.02.2022. Wherein the respondent had raised substantive objections under the
Sections 2(1)(j), 2(1)(ja), 3(f), 3(k), 10(4), nd10(4)(c) of the Patent’s Act
(hereinafter referred to as ‘Act’). The Appellant in turn filed its detailed
response dated 24.02.2022 to the FER, wherein the appellant had explained the
inventive concept and had responded to all objections raised by the respondent.
Subsequently, upon receipt of the response to the FER, the Respondent issued a
Hearing Notice dated 17.05.2024, wherein the respondent had dropped the
objections under the sections 2(1)(j) and 10(4) of the Act and all the formal
objections. However the hearing notice retained the substantial objections under
the section 2(1)(ja), 3(f) and 3(k) of the Act in view of the earlier cited prior arts
D1 and D2. Thereafter, a hearing was conducted on 20.06.2024, during which
__________
Page2 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )
CMA(PT) No.61 of 2024
the Appellant advanced its arguments and subsequently filed written
submissions dated 28.06.2024 , providing further explanations and clarifications,
without amending the claims. Thereafter, the Respondent passed the impugned
order dated 19.07.2024, refusing to grant the patent sought under the
Appellant’s patent application on the grounds of non-compliance with Sections
2(1)(ja) and 3(f) of the Act, namely, absence of inventive step and the mere
arrangement or rearrangement of known devices, each functioning
independently in a known manner, which falls within the scope of non-
patentable subject matter. Aggrieved by the impugned order dated 19.07.2024
issued by the respondent the appellant had preferred the present Appeal.
3. Heard Mr.Damodar Vaidya learned counsel appearing for Mrs.Deepika
Murali learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant and
Mr.A.R.Sakthivel learned Senior Panel Central Government counsel appearing
on behalf of the respondent.
4. Mr.Damodar Vaidya learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
appellant would submit that the invention forming the subject matter of the
Appellant’s patent application comprises Claims 1 to 11 and pertains to a
vehicle with a biometric recognition system mounted on the fuel tank assembly
for facilitating the user authentication, where the said biometric recognition
system is based on fingerprint or voice or retina recognition.It is submitted that
__________
Page3 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )
CMA(PT) No.61 of 2024
the said bio-metric system is strategically positioned within the close proximity
to the rider’s body, specifically behind the handlebar and ahead of the front
portion of the rider’s seat, duly taking into consideration of the ergonomic
requirements of the rider reducing fatigue and physical strain. He further
submits that the wires are routed in such a way that they are reliable and cost-
effective and safe.Therefore the learned counsel submits that Claim 1
incorporates the inventive feature of the present invention, which teaches
mounting of the biometric user recognition system on the top surface of the
fuel-tank assembly, thereby providing convenient access to the rider, facilitating
ease of wiring, enhancing the durability of the wiring and rendering the system
theft-proof.
3. He submits that respondent erred in concluding that the placement of
the biometric authentication system on top of the fuel tank for the ergonomic
benefits is advantageous but the same cannot be held as the technical
advancement over the existing prior arts, thereby treating the same as a non-
technical feature that does not contribute to the inventive step. He submits that
based on the Manual of patent and Procedure (2019) (hereinafter referred to as
MPPP) as far as an analysis for an inventive step is considered, the invention as
a whole has to be taken into account. He nevertheless submits that in the present
invention the respondent failed to recognize that the inventive step does not
merely involve the placement of the bio-metric authentication system on the
__________
Page4 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )
CMA(PT) No.61 of 2024
fuel tank assembly but its integration with the other devices on the vehicle,
including the routing of the complex wiring harness being simplified, made
reliable and tamperproof as the additional technical advancements. In that
regard the learned counsel places reliance upon the judgement of this court
made in the case of Rhodia Operations Vs Assistant Controller of Patents and
Designs reported as 2024:MHC:6024 . Wherein this court had analysed section
2(1)(ja) of the Act and had laid down that the Assessment of Inventive Step of
the invention involves two step process, namely, identifying the features that
involves the technical advancement as compared to the existing knowledge or
economic significance or both and the determination of whether aforesaid
technical advancement or economic significance is not obvious to a person
skilled in the art (hereinafter referred to as ‘PSITA’). The aforesaid judgement
had also formulated five steps for assessing the inventive step or obviousness
and a similar five step analysis has been formulated by the Hon’ble Delhi High
Court in the case of F.Hoffman La Roche Vs. Cipla reported as 2015 SCC
Online Del 13619 .
5. The learned counsel submits that the respondent had erred in refusing
the appellant’s application on the grounds of lack of inventive step under the
section 2(1)(ja) of the Act and concluded that the present invention is obvious to
the PSITA. It is submitted that as far as the present invention is considered the
inventive concept is to mount the bio-metric user recognition system on a
__________
Page5 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )
CMA(PT) No.61 of 2024
vehicle in such a way that it provides ergonomical advantages to the user,to
simplify the wiring harness and enhance wiring durability. The learned counsel
contends that the ergonomic benefits offered by the present invention
constitutes a technical advancement, thereby contributing to the inventive step.
To support his contention in that regard, the learned counsel had placed reliance
upon the Hon’ble Delhi High Court judgement made in the case of Ferid Allani
Vs Assistant Controller of Patents and Design reported in 2019 SCC Online
Del 11867 , wherein the improved User Interface is recognised as a technical
advancement. Therefore respondent had wrongly held that the ergonomic
advantages offered by the present invention does not constitute a technical
advancement and the present invention lacks the inventive step.
6. It is further submitted that the Respondent erred in concluding that it
would be obvious for a PSITA to relocate and adapt the biometric user
recognition systems mounted on the fuel-tank assembly especially with the aid
of the prior art documents D1 and D2. The learned counsel contends that this
court in its judgment Rhodia Operations (supra) had clearly laid down the
requirements for a person to be recognised as a PSITA, is to possess above-
average skill in the relevant art, the requisite vocational or educational
qualifications to practise the art, familiarity with the tools and techniques
necessary for the same and knowledge of the existing prior art. The learned
counsel denies the above ground of the respondent as according to him, as the
__________
Page6 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )
CMA(PT) No.61 of 2024
prior art D1 and D2 teaches away from exposing the biometric user recognition
device to dust and water. Hence for the PSITA having knowledge of prior-art
documents D1 and D2, mounting the biometric user recognition system on the
fuel-tank assembly, where it would be exposed to harsh environmental
conditions such as dirt and water, would not have been obvious..
7. The learned counsel further submits that the prior arts D1 and D2 does
not teach the inventive step of the present invention. It is submitted that prior-art
document D1 discloses the placement of a fingerprint identification device on
the handlebar or the rear cover of the front handle. However, D1 does not
disclose the placement of the said device on the fuel-tank assembly located
between the seat and the handlebar, as in the present invention. On the contrary,
D1 relates to a scooter-type two-wheeler, wherein the fuel tank is ordinarily
located below the seat. D1 teaches that the fingerprint detection device is
covered with a transparent cover to protect it from dirt and water. However it
neither teaches the simplification of the complex wiring harness nor addresses
the problem of facilitating convenient access to the fingerprint identification
device. Similarly, prior-art document D2 discloses the placement of a
fingerprint identification device on a glove box located below the seat and
teaches that the said device must be protected from exposure to dirt and water.
However, D2 neither discloses the placement of the device on the fuel-tank
assembly nor addresses the technical problems of facilitating convenient access
__________
Page7 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )
CMA(PT) No.61 of 2024
to the fingerprint identification device and simplifying the wiring harness.
8. The learned counsel vehemently contends that the respondent erred by
refusing the grant of the patent under the grounds of section 3(f) to the
appellants by arriving at the conclusion that the present invention is merely an
arrangement or rearrangement of the known devices. It is submitted that
according to the MPPP where an invention involving a combination of known
devices or integers produces a new result, an improved result, or achieves the
intended result more expeditiously or economically, or where the known
integers are arranged side by side and interact with one another to produce a
new result, such an invention would not fall within the ambit of Section 3(f) of
the Act.According to the learned counsel, the present invention satisfies the
principles set out in the MPPP Guidelines, as the biometric user recognition
system mounted on the fuel-tank assembly interacts with the associated wiring
harness, thereby combining known devices in a distinct arrangement to produce
an enhanced result in the form of enhanced ergonomic benefits to the user.
Therefore it is contended that the respondent failed in both understanding the
present invention and in applying the legal propositions to test the applicability
of the section 3(f) of the Act. It is further contended that the respondent had also
failed to consider the invention as a whole as the determination of the inventive
step does not merely involve in identifying new features but rather about how
these features interoperate with the known features to provide the technical
__________
Page8 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )
CMA(PT) No.61 of 2024
advancement.
9. The learned counsel submits that, although the term “inventive step” is
defined under the Act to encompass both non-obviousness and technical
advancement and the Act provides grounds for refusing a patent where the
present invention lacks novelty, there is no substantive provision empowering
the Controller of Patents to refuse a patent solely on the ground of lack of non-
obviousness, except where objection with regard to the lack of non-obviousness
is raised through a pre-grant opposition filed by way of representation under
Section 25(1) of the Act. Therefore, in view of forgoing submissions the learned
counsel prays this court to set aside the impugned order and allow the present
Civil Miscellaneous Appeal.
10. Per Contra, opposing the abovesaid arguments Mr.A.R.Sakthivel
learned Senior Panel Central Government counsel appearing on behalf of the
respondent would submit that appellant had failed to note that the respondent in
its reasoning had referred to the authentication based control of operating the
saddle type vehicle by means of the fingerprint (biometric) user recognition
system along with its entire wiring and networks present, as a whole and treated
the same as common general knowledge. It is contended that the prior Arts D1
and D2 explicitly discloses a fingerprint (biometric) user identification system
along with its wiring circuits and authentication and control functions for
__________
Page9 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )
CMA(PT) No.61 of 2024
securely operating the vehicle. It is further submitted that the prior arts D1 and
D2 also discloses the said biometric authentication system along with its circuit
and networks in its entirety in different places, namely, D1 discloses the
positioning of the said biometric system on the handle bar and D2 discloses the
placement of the biometric system in the glove box beneath the motorcycle seat.
Hence the learned counsel submits that the positioning of the biometric
authentication system along with its associated control wiring as the whole is
well known common general knowledge. Consequently the relocation or
repositioning of the said biometric authentication system does not constitute a
technical advancement.
11. He further submits that the relocation of the biometric authentication
system on the fuel tank assembly does not result in any new or improved
technical outcome; rather it provides the same result and benefit of securely
operating the vehicle. It is submitted that in general most of the notifications
and the controls are displayed on the dashboard which is positioned in the front
of the vehicle to ensure optimal ergonomic visibility and accessibility for the
rider. Hence he submits that a mere relocation of the biometric authentication
system from dashboard to the top of the fuel tank assembly cannot be
considered as an improved user interface amounting to technical advancement
and it does not constitute a valid inventive step. The learned senior panel
counsel further submits that the relocation of the biometric authentication
__________
Page10 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )
CMA(PT) No.61 of 2024
system asserted by the appellant coincides with that of the position of the fuel
tank cap and consequently, the repositioning of the said biometric system would
result in manufacturing complications. It is submitted that the principles of
Design for Manufacturing and Assembly (DFMA) do not support such
alterations as the same necessitate additional wiring networks to ensure
communications between the vehicle control modules, the dashboard
notification control system and the biometric authentication system, thereby
increasing the manufacturing cost of the vehicle and further complicating the
wiring harness.
12. The learned senior panel counsel further submits that the respondent
at no point of time held that mounting of the biometric authentication system on
top of the fuel tank assembly is infeasible. Instead the respondent merely stated
that the relocating and repositioning of the biometric user recognition system
along with its associated network and wiring to a different location is a well-
known common general knowledge, as the prior Arts D1 and D2 discloses the
same biometric authentication system along with its wiring at various locations
as stated supra. Therefore positioning of the bio-metric user recognition system
at a different location from that of the D1 and D2, as disclosed in the present
invention would be an obvious modification for a PSITA which does not
constitute a technical advancement, consequently does not establish the
inventive step in the present invention. He further submits that whether or not
__________
Page11 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )
CMA(PT) No.61 of 2024
the protective layer needs to be added to shield the bio-metric authentication
system from the rain and dirt would have to considered only after the routine
experimentation and mere workshop improvements.
13. He further submits that the respondent had properly analysed and
identified the correct PSITA who general are the professionals involved in the
automobile manufacturing encompassing a broad category including the
mechanical engineers with 6 to 8 years of experience, packaging engineers with
knowledge of element interfaces, design engineers familiar with DFMA
guidelines, etc. Therefore the appellant’s contention that the respondent erred in
identifying the PSITA is not true. He further submits that the dependent claims
2 to 11 of the present application solely depends upon the independent claim 1
of the application. It is submitted that, since independent Claim 1 does not
introduce any significant features capable of establishing non-obviousness and
is considered obvious to PSITA, dependent Claims 2 to 11 are likewise obvious
by virtue of their dependency on Claim 1 and the absence of distinguishable
features.
14. The leaned senior panel counsel further submits that the present
invention neither introduces an unique combination of known elements nor does
it provide any advantageous, new results. On contrary the present invention
merely relocates or a repositions the well known biometric authentication
system along with its associated control wiring networks from the front-portion
__________
Page12 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )
CMA(PT) No.61 of 2024
of the handle bar or glove box of the vehicle as disclosed in the prior art D1 and
D2 respectively to top of the fuel tank assembly. Even as from the technical
advancement point of view the present invention does not produce any new or
advantageous result but contrarily increases the manufacturing costs and the
complexity of the wiring harness remains unresolved as the biometric
authentication system still has to interact with the control and notification
modules located in the front portion of the vehicle. Therefore, the learned
Senior Panel Counsel submits that the present invention neither demonstrates
any technical advancement nor proves to be economically advantageous.
Rather, it merely involves the relocation and repositioning of a known device,
namely, the biometric user recognition system. Such a modification could be
readily implemented by a PSITA using common general knowledge and the
prior art documents D1 and D2. Furthermore, the issues of increased
manufacturing costs and wiring problems remain unresolved. Hence, the
learned senior panel counsel submits that the present invention fails to satisfy
the requirement of inventive step under Section 2(1)(ja) of the Act and that the
mere rearrangement of known devices, without producing any new or improved
result, falls within the ambit of Section 3(f) of the Act. In view of the foregoing,
the learned counsel submits that the impugned order does not warrant
interference from this Court and, accordingly, prays that the present Civil
Miscellaneous Appeal to be dismissed.
__________
Page13 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )
CMA(PT) No.61 of 2024
15. I have considered the submissions made by the learned counsels
appearing on either side and perused the materials placed on record.
16. An order of refusal to register a patent submitted by the appellant on
the grounds that the invention is a conceived prior art which does not involve
any inventive step and that a person skill in the art would find it obvious to
adopt to the invention. The primordial contention of the appellant was that the
respondent had erred in holding that the placement of a bio-metric system of the
fuel tank assembly is not a technical feature involving any technical
advancement. It is admitted to by the appellant that similar features are
available and placement of the same was claimed to be in a disadvantageous
position and the placement of the same made by the appellant would be more
advantageous. Technical advantageous can be considered, but such technical
advantageous on a notable prior art cannot make a method to be a new
invention. Teaching D1 & D2 cited documents are also identical to the claimed
invention except for the placement of the bio-metric user recognition system
and therefore, they cannot be held to be an irrelevant document. Just a
placement of the bio-metric identification device on a different surface of the
vehicle cannot do away with the prior cited documents to hold that the claim
made by the appellant is a new invention. In that regard, this Court also holds
that the findings and reasonings given that the invention is obvious to person
skilled art.
__________
Page14 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )
CMA(PT) No.61 of 2024
17. For the aforesaid reasons, this Court is of the view that the further
grounds that had been raised by the appellant and contested by the respondents
need not be answered.
18. Therefore this Court finds no merits in the appeal and accordingly,
Civil Miscellaneous Appeal stands dismissed. Consequently connected
Miscellaneous Petition is closed. However, there shall be no order as to costs.
12.11.2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes/No
Pbn
To
The Deputy Controller of Patents and Designs
Patent Office, I.P.Building,
GST.Road, Guindy, Chennai 32.
__________
Page15 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )
CMA(PT) No.61 of 2024
K.KUMARESH BABU, J.
Pbn
A Pre-delivery order made in
CMA(PT) No. 61 of 2024
12.11.2026
__________
Page16 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )