Noornisha vs State Of Tamilnadu Rep By Inspector Of Police, Tirunelveli Town

Court
Madras High Court

CRL RC(MD) No. 1169 of 2026
BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT
DATED: 17-11-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE B.MURUGESAN
CRL RC(MD) No. 1169 of 2026
CNR:{HCMD010938152026}
AND
CRL MP(MD) No. 13956 of 2026
Noornisha ..Petitioner
Vs
1.State Of Tamilnadu Rep By
Inspector Of Police,
Tirunelveli Town Police Station,
Tirunelveli City.
(Crime No. 68 of 2025)
2.Azeezu Nisha
(R2 is impleaded as per order of the court
dt.08.10.2026 in Crl.MP(MD).21978 of 2026 in
Crl.RC(MD).1169 of 2026 by BMJ)
..Respondents
PRAYER: This Petition filed under section 438 and 442 BNSS, to call
for the records relating to the order dated 30.06.2026 passed in
Crl.M.P.No. 4 of 2026 in S.C.No. 527 of 2025 on the file of the Learned
IV Additional District and Sessions Judge, Tirunelveli and set aside.
For Petitioner : Mr.S.R.Muthuvasan
For R1 : Mr.D.Venkatesh,
Additional Public Prosecutor
For R2 : Mr.M.Jegadeesh Pandian
__________
Page  1  of  14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:40:57 pm )

CRL RC(MD) No. 1169 of 2026
ORDER
Heard and admitted.
02. With the consent of both parties, this criminal revision was
taken up for final hearing.
03. Challenging the order dated 30.06.2026 of the IV Additional
District and Sessions Judge, Tirunelveli, hereinafter referred to as ‘the
trial court’, dismissing the discharge petition in Cr MP No.04/2026
filed by the revision petitioner/A4 in SC No 527/2025 (in Cr
No.68/2025 on the file of Tirunelveli Town Police Station), the
revision petitioner/A4 has filed this Criminal Revision Petition under
S.438 BNSS.
04. For the sake of convenience, the parties are referred
hereunder according to their litigative status and ranking in this
criminal revision, 'the revision petitioner' and 'the revision respondent',
unless the context otherwise requires.
05. Prefatory facts are that the investigating police officer, in Cr
No.68/2025 on the file of Tirunelveli Town Police Station, has filed a
police report alleging
(1) that Azeezunisha, the de facto complainant, is the wife of the
deceased, Jahir Hussain Bijili,
(2) that the deceased was a permanent Muthavalli in Tamilnadu
Wakf Board Muthu Jahan Thaika Pallivasal, Tirunelveli Town,
__________
Page  2  of  14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:40:57 pm )

CRL RC(MD) No. 1169 of 2026
(3) that A1 is the husband of the revision petitioner/A4 and there
was a land dispute between the deceased and A1,
(4) that A1 and his wife, A4, claim a land measuring 36 cents in
TS No. 2591 as the property of A4 but the deceased was
claiming it is the property of Wakf Board,
(5) that therefore, the deceased was trying to recover the
property from A1 and A4,
(6) that as and when the deceased tried to put up a shed in the
disputed land, a case in Cr No.02/2025 on the file of Tirunelveli
Town Police Station has been registered against the deceased
and his wife, the de facto complainant, on the complaint of A1,
(7) that even after such complaint, the deceased tried to put up a
shed in the disputed land,
(8) that therefore, A1 and A5 along with the child in conflict
with law, with a view to eliminate the deceased and his wife, the
de facto complainant, entered into a criminal conspiracy on
17.03.2025 at about 5.00 pm at the rented house of A1 and A4,
(9) that in furtherance of such common intention and in
prosecution of such criminal conspiracy, the deceased was
murdered on 18.03.2025 at about 5.00 am while the deceased
was returning from the mosque after worship,
(10) that therefore, a police report has been filed against the
aforesaid accused and accordingly, the case in SC No 527/2025
on the file of the trial court is pending, and
that the revision petitioner/A4 against whom the charges, according to
the revision respondent, are under S.61(2), S.103(1) r/w S.49 BNSS,
has filed a discharge petition in Cr MP No.04/2026 which has been
dismissed by the trial court after enquiry.
__________
Page  3  of  14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:40:57 pm )

CRL RC(MD) No. 1169 of 2026
06. Challenging such dismissal, the revision petitioner/A4 has
filed this criminal revision.
07. Heard both sides, and perused all the materials available.
08. Learned counsel for the revision petitioner/A4 would submit
(1) that the trial court, when there is no prima facie material
against the revision petitioner, has erroneously dismissed the discharge
petition filed by the revision petitioner,
st
(2) that the 1 revision respondent has relied on some CDR
materials to show the post occurrence communication between the
revision petitioner and A1 but such CDR materials fall short of legal
evidence,
st
(3) that the 1 revision respondent has relied on the statements of
interested witness to show the enmity between the deceased and A1,
st
(4) that the 1 revision respondent has relied on the statement of
LW27, the owner of the rented house, to implicate the revision
petitioner under the guise of common intention and criminal
conspiracy,
(5) that the trial court has not properly appreciated the electronic
and forensic materials relied on by the prosecution, and
(6) that therefore, the impugned order of the trial court is
erroneous and perverse, liable to be interfered with.

st
09. Learned counsel appearing for the 1 revision respondent
would submit that there are prima facie materials against the revision
petitioner, that the probative value of CDR materials cannot be decided
__________
Page  4  of  14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:40:57 pm )

CRL RC(MD) No. 1169 of 2026
in the discharge petition, that whether the witnesses speaking about the
motive are interested witnesses is a matter of a full-fledged trial, that
the statement of LW27, the owner of the rented house, would be the
prima facie material against the revision petitioner for criminal
conspiracy and abetment, that the probative value of electronic and
forensic materials cannot be decided in the discharge petition, that
therefore, the impugned order of the trial court does not suffer any sort
of illegality or infirmity warranting the interference of this court and
that therefore, the criminal revision petition deserves for dismissal.
nd
10. Learned counsel appearing for the 2 revision respondent/de
facto complainant would submit that as rightly held by the trial court,
there are sufficient materials to prove the motive for the murder of the
deceased, that the statement of LW27 and the CDR materials would
bring home the offence committed by the revision petitioner, that the
trial court, while deciding a discharge petition, is not required to
conduct a mini trial and that therefore, the criminal revision petition
deserves for dismissal.
11. Point for determination is whether the revision petitioner is
entitled to get an order, allowing this criminal revision, setting aside
the impugned order of the trial court and discharging her from the case
in SC No 527/2025 on the file of the trial court (in Cr No.68/2025 on
the file of Tirunelveli Town Police Station)?
12. At the very outset, this court would like to fumigate its mind
with the decisions settling the scope of discharge in a criminal case.
(1) Sajjan Kumar V CBI ((2010) 9 SCC 368) is a case where
__________
Page  5  of  14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:40:57 pm )

CRL RC(MD) No. 1169 of 2026
the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as under:
‘ 17 ) Exercise of jurisdiction under Sections 227 & 228 of
Cr.P.C.
On consideration of the authorities about the scope of Section
227 and 228 of the Code, the following principles emerge:-
(i) The Judge while considering the question of framing
the charges under Section 227 of the Cr.P.C. has the undoubted
power to sift and weigh the evidence for the limited purpose of
finding out whether or not a prima facie case against the accused
has been made out. The test to determine prima facie case would
depend upon the facts of each case.
ii) Where the materials placed before the Court disclose
grave suspicion against the accused which has not been properly
explained, the Court will be fully justified in framing a charge
and proceeding with the trial.
iii) The Court cannot act merely as a Post Office or a
mouthpiece of the prosecution but has to consider the broad
probabilities of the case, the total effect of the evidence and the
documents produced before the Court, any basic infirmities etc.
However, at this stage, there cannot be a roving enquiry into the
pros and cons of the matter and weigh the evidence as if he was
conducting a trial.
iv) If on the basis of the material on record, the Court
could form an opinion that the accused might have committed
offence, it can frame the charge, though for conviction the
conclusion is required to be proved beyond reasonable doubt that
the accused has committed the offence.
v) At the time of framing of the charges, the probative
__________
Page  6  of  14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:40:57 pm )

CRL RC(MD) No. 1169 of 2026
value of the material on record cannot be gone into but before
framing a charge the Court must apply its judicial mind on the
material placed on record and must be satisfied that the
commission of offence by the accused was possible.
vi) At the stage of Sections 227 and 228, the Court is
required to evaluate the material and documents on record with a
view to find out if the facts emerging therefrom taken at their
face value discloses the existence of all the ingredients
constituting the alleged offence. For this limited purpose, sift the
evidence as it cannot be expected even at that initial stage to
accept all that the prosecution states as gospel truth even if it is
opposed to common sense or the broad probabilities of the case.
vii) If two views are possible and one of them gives rise to
suspicion only, as distinguished from grave suspicion, the trial
Judge will be empowered to discharge the accused and at this
stage, he is not to see whether the trial will end in conviction or
acquittal.’
(2) State of Rajasthan V Ashok Kumar Kashap (2021
LiveLaw SC 210) is a case where the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held
as under:
‘ 9.1 In the case of P.Vijayan (supra), this Court had an occasion
to consider Section 227 of the Cr.P.C. What is required to be
considered at the time of framing of the charge and/or
considering the discharge application has been considered
elaborately in the said decision. It is observed and held that at the
stage of Section 227, the Judge has merely to sift the evidence in
order to find out whether or not there is sufficient ground for
__________
Page  7  of  14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:40:57 pm )

CRL RC(MD) No. 1169 of 2026
proceeding against the accused. It is observed that in other
words, the sufficiency of grounds would take within its fold the
nature of the evidence recorded by the police or the documents
produced before the Court which ex facie disclose that there are
suspicious circumstances against the accused so as to frame a
charge against him. It is further observed that if the Judge comes
to a conclusion that there is sufficient ground to proceed, he will
frame a charge under Section 228 Cr.P.C., if not, he will
discharge the accused. It is further observed that while
exercising its judicial mind to the facts of the case in order to
determine whether a case for trial has been made out by the
prosecution, it is not necessary for the court to enter into the pros
and cons of the matter or into a weighing and balancing of
evidence and probabilities which is really the function of the
court, after the trial starts.
9.2 In the recent decision of this Court in the case of M.R.
Hiremath (supra), one of us (Justice D.Y. Chandrachud)
speaking for the Bench has observed and held in paragraph 25 as
under:
25. The High Court ought to have been cognizant of the
fact that the trial court was dealing with an application for
discharge under the provisions of Section 239 CrPC. The
parameters which govern the exercise of this jurisdiction have
found expression in several decisions of this Court. It is a settled
principle of law that at the stage of considering an application for
discharge the court must proceed on the assumption that the
material which has been brought on the record by the
prosecution is true and evaluate the material in order to
__________
Page  8  of  14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:40:57 pm )

CRL RC(MD) No. 1169 of 2026
determine whether the facts emerging from the material, taken
on its face value, disclose the existence of the ingredients
necessary to constitute the offence. In State of T.N. v. N. Suresh
Rajan [State of T.N. v.N. Suresh Rajan, (2014) 11 SCC 709,
adverting to the earlier decisions on the subject, this Court held:
(SCC pp. 721-22, para 29)
“29. … At this stage, probative value of the materials has
to be gone into and the court is not expected to go deep into the
matter and hold that the materials would not warrant a
conviction. In our opinion, what needs to be considered is
whether there is a ground for presuming that the offence has
been committed and not whether a ground for convicting the
accused has been made out. To put it differently, if the court
thinks that the accused might have committed the offence on the
basis of the materials on record on its probative value, it can
frame the charge; though for conviction, the court has to come to
the conclusion that the accused has committed the offence. The
law does not permit a mini trial at this stage.”
(3) CBI V Aryan Singh ((2023) 18 SCC 399) a case where the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as under:
‘ 4.1 …… As per the cardinal principle of law, at the stage of
discharge and/or quashing of the criminal proceedings, while
exercising the powers under Section 482 Cr.P.C., the Court is
not required to conduct the mini trial. The High Court in the
common impugned judgment and order has observed that the
charges against the accused are not proved. This is not the stage
where the prosecution / investigating agency is/are required to
__________
Page  9  of  14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:40:57 pm )

CRL RC(MD) No. 1169 of 2026
prove the charges. The charges are required to be proved during
the trial on the basis of the evidence led by the prosecution /
investigating agency. Therefore, the High Court has materially
erred in going in detail in the allegations and the material
collected during the course of the investigation against the
accused, at this stage. At the stage of discharge and/or while
exercising the powers under Section 482 Cr.P.C., the Court has a
very limited jurisdiction and is required to consider “whether any
sufficient material is available to proceed further against the
accused for which the accused is required to be tried or not”.
4.2 One another reason pointed by the High Court is that the
initiation of the criminal proceedings / proceedings is malicious.
At this stage, it is required to be noted that the investigation was
handed over to the CBI pursuant to the directions issued by the
High Court. That thereafter, on conclusion of the investigation,
the accused persons have been chargesheeted. Therefore, the
High Court has erred in observing at this stage that the initiation
of the criminal proceedings / proceedings is malicious. Whether
the criminal proceedings was/were malicious or not, is not
required to be considered at this stage. The same is required to
be considered at the conclusion of the trial. In any case, at this
stage, what is required to be considered is a prima facie case and
the material collected during the course of the investigation,
which warranted the accused to be tried.’
13. Keeping in mind the aforesaid legal propositions, let us get
into the discussions.
__________
Page  10  of  14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:40:57 pm )

CRL RC(MD) No. 1169 of 2026
st
14. Charges against the revision petitioner, according to the 1
revision respondent, are under S.61(2) (criminal conspiracy), S.103(1)
(murder) r/w S.49 (abetment) BNSS.
15. Primarily and predominantly, the trial court has considered
the statement recorded under S.180(3) BNSS of LW27, the owner of
the rented house where A1 and A4 are said to have resided, which
would read to the effect that as and when he went to that house for
receiving rent, there were the accused herein, that A4 said loudly ‘so
many men are here, kill him quickly (‘ ePq;fs; ,j;jid
Mk;gisq;f ,Uf;fPq;f mtid rPf;fpuk; bfhy;Yq;fs; vd;W rj;jk; nghl;L
’) and that on seeing him, they stopped talking. That apart,
brhd;dhh;
the trial court has considered some CDR materials for the post
occurrence communication between the revision petitioner and A1. On
due consideration thereof, the trial court has come to the conclusion
that there are prima facie materials against the revision petitioner for
criminal conspiracy and for abetment.
16. As rightly pointed out by the learned counsel appearing for
st
the 1 revision respondent, questions as to whether the reliance given
by the trial court on the statement of LW27 is legally sustainable,
whether CDR materials have probative value, whether the witnesses
speaking about the motive are interested witnesses and whether the
st
electronic and forensic materials relied on by the 1 revision
respondent have probative value are matters of trial.
__________
Page  11  of  14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:40:57 pm )

CRL RC(MD) No. 1169 of 2026
17. In short, the findings of the trial court that there are prima
facie materials to proceed further against the revision petitioner are not
erroneous or perverse as claimed by the revision petitioner.
18. Resultantly, this court holds that the revision petitioner is not
entitled to get an order, allowing this criminal revision, setting aside
the impugned order of the trial court and discharging her from the case
in SC No 527/2025 on the file of the trial court (in Cr No.68/2025 on
the file of Tirunelveli Town Police Station), and this point is answered,
accordingly.
19. Before parting with, this court, as a word of caution, would
like to make it clear that any observation/finding given by this court in
this order shall not influence the decision of the case concerned.
20. In fine, the criminal revision shall stand dismissed,
upholding the order of the trial court in Crl MP No.04/2026.
21. Pending applications, if any, shall stand closed.
17-11-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes/No
GNS
__________
Page  12  of  14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:40:57 pm )

CRL RC(MD) No. 1169 of 2026
To
1.The IV Additional District and Sessions Judge, Tirunelveli
2.The Inspector Of Police,
Tirunelveli Town Police Station
Tirunelveli City
3.The Additional Public Prosecutor
Madurai Bench of Madras High Court
Madurai
__________
Page  13  of  14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:40:57 pm )

CRL RC(MD) No. 1169 of 2026
B.MURUGESAN, J.
GNS
CRL RC(MD) No. 1169 of 2026
17-11-2026
__________
Page  14  of  14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:40:57 pm )