DR SONAL ASTHANA vs STATE OF KARNATAKA
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
CRL.P No. 35 of 2022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
ST
DATED THIS THE 21 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.P.SANDESH
CRIMINAL PETITION NO.35 OF 2022
BETWEEN:
1. DR. SONAL ASTHANA
S/O.MAHENDRA ASTHANA
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS
R/AT NO.116B
SOBHA MALACHITE APARTMENT
JAKKUR PLANTATION ROAD
BENGALURU-560 064.
2. DR. KAISAR RAJA
S/O DR. J.H. RAJA
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS
R/AT NO.103, PRESTIGE OASIS
RAJANUKUNTE
DODDABALLAURA ROAD
BENGALURU-560 064.
3. DR. RAJIV LOCHAN
S/O JAYADEVA H
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS
R/AT C-13, SOBHA ATHEA AND AZALEA
EASHWAR TEMPLE ROAD
HAROAHALLI, YELAHANKA
DODDABALLAPURA ROAD
BENGALURU-560 064.
4. MARLENE VENKAT D/O JOSEPH
AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS
R/AT NO.31/1, HARRIS ROAD
BENSON TOWN, BENGALURU-560 046.
…PETITIONERS
Digitally signed
by DEVIKA M
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
(BY SRI. S. BALAKRISHNAN, ADVOCATE)
- 2 -
CRL.P No. 35 of 2022
AND:
1. STATE OF KARNATAKA
BY KENGERI POLICE STATION
REPRESENTED BY SPP
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
BENGALURU-560 001.
2. DR. VIJAY VEMURI
CEO, BGS HOSPITAL
UTTARAHALLI MAIN ROAD
KENGERI, BENGALURU-560 060.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. MOHAMMED AYUB ALI, ADDL. SPP FOR R1;
SRI. S.V. SOGARAO &
SMT. RADHA PYARI, ADVOCATES FOR R2)
THIS CRIMINAL PETITION IS FILED UNDER SECTION 482
OF CR.P.C PRAYING TO QUASH ALL THE PROCEEDINGS IN
C.C.NO.26322/2018 BEFORE THE LEARNED I ADDITIONAL
CHIEF METROPOLITAN MAGISTRATE COURT AT BENGALURU
FOR THE OFFENCES PUNISHABLE UNDER SECTIONS 43-A AND
66 OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY ACT AND SECTION 408 OF
IPC.
THIS PETITION HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED
FOR ORDERS ON 11.11.2026, THIS DAY, THE COURT
PRONOUNCED THE FOLLOWING:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.P.SANDESH
CAV ORDER
Heard learned counsel for the petitioners, learned
Additional SPP for respondent No.1 and learned counsel for
respondent No.2.
2. This petition is filed praying this Court to quash
initiation of proceedings against the petitioners, who have been
- 3 -
CRL.P No. 35 of 2022
arraigned as accused Nos.1 to 4 in C.C.No.26322/2018 for the
offences punishable under Sections 43A and 66 of Information
Technology Act (‘IT Act’ for short) and Section 408 of IPC.
3. The factual matrix of case of the complainant i.e.,
respondent No.2 is that he had lodged a complaint with the
police i.e., respondent No.1 and based on the complaint, Crime
No.335/2015 was registered. The police have investigated the
matter and during the investigation, seized 320 GB hard disc
and filed the charge sheet and the Magistrate took cognizance
for the offence under Section 408 of IPC and Sections 43A and
66 of IT Act. The main accusation made in the complaint is that
these petitioners involved in data stealing and data deleting
from the hospital computer which seriously and adversely
impacted the integrity of the patients data and reputation of
the hospital. With that accusation, the FIR was registered and
investigation was conducted.
4. The main contention of learned counsel appearing
for the petitioners is that these petitioners have been falsely
implicated with a vengeance and no material to attract Section
408 of IPC and counsel also brought to notice of this Court
Section 408 of IPC, wherein it says that a clerk or servant or
- 4 -
CRL.P No. 35 of 2022
employed as a clerk or servant, and being in any manner
entrusted in such capacity with property, or with any dominion
over property, commits criminal breach of trust in respect of
that property, it attracts Section 408 of IPC. The counsel would
vehemently contend that the ingredients of offence under
Section 408 of IPC will not attract against the petitioners. But,
the petitioners are not clerks or servants and they are only
retainers and no material to invoke Section 408 of IPC. The
counsel also vehemently contend that, in order to attract
Section 66 of IT Act also there are no ingredients that
Investigation Officer has recovered CD by drawing the mahazar
dated 04.12.2015 and the same was subjected to PF
No.149/2018. The content of the CD is not retrieved and placed
on record connecting the same to the petitioners visa viz.,
neither a certificate mandated under Section 65B of the
Evidence Act nor it was subjected to expert opinion as per
Section 45A of the Evidence Act in compliance of Section 79A of
the IT Act. Hence, the provisions under Section 66 of IT cannot
be invoked. All patients' information in the hospital is
maintained in the Hospital Information System (HIS) which is a
password protected system, no export or deletion of data is
possible and absolutely, there is no material that these
- 5 -
CRL.P No. 35 of 2022
petitioners have stolen any data from the BGS Global Hospital
computer. The facts and circumstances of the case also does
not indicate that there was any intentional act. But, the
management was not liking the petitioners leaving the hospital
when an attempt was made to leave the hospital and when
they were firm to leave the hospital, they were
unceremoniously terminated from the service leveling serious
fabricated and false allegations, which are per se not only
defamatory, but also a coercion. It is contended that even
hospital is liable to pay sum of Rs.70,00,000/- to the
petitioners which is legal dues and the same also not paid and
only with an intention to prevent the payment, false allegations
are made. The counsel also vehemently contend that there was
no fraudulent or dishonesty is found and on the face value, it is
very clear that they were not operating the computers and with
an oblique motive, filed the complaint. The device hard disc
was seized, but nothing is found.
5. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for
respondent No.2 would vehemently contend that hospital had
engaging the services of these petitioners for Liver
Transplantation and the fact that they were appointed as
Retainers is not in dispute. But, they are maintaining the
- 6 -
CRL.P No. 35 of 2022
records and they were operating and maintaining the
information in the hospital. But, IT Department of the Hospital
alerted that the data was stolen. Hence, COO filed the
complaint and cognizance was taken. The consultant also come
within the scope of Section 408 of IPC that they were having
the data and the same was entrusted with them and once it is
entrusted to them, it attracts Section 408 of IPC read with
Section 66 of IT Act. The information is sensitive containing
personal data of the patients, who visit the hospital and hence,
within the meaning of Sections 24 and 25 of IPC also attracts
and there cannot be any interference under Section 482 of
Cr.P.C. and the data stealing amounts to serious economic
offence. Hence, police rightly investigated the matter and filed
the charge sheet and cognizance was taken.
6. Learned High Court Government Pleader appearing
for the respondent No.1 also would contend that the fact that
they are working as Retainers under the contract is not in
dispute and they cannot harp upon as clerk or servant. But,
when there is a contractual employment between the hospital
and the petitioners, they can be tried and it requires trial.
- 7 -
CRL.P No. 35 of 2022
7. In reply to this argument, the counsel appearing for
the petitioners would vehemently contend that no statement is
recorded regarding stolen data. In the absence of any such
statement, it cannot be proved and it will not attract Section
408 of IPC and with an oblique motive, case is registered and
salary is also not paid.
8. In reply to this argument of leaned counsel
appearing for the petitioners, learned counsel appearing for
respondent No.2 would submit that when they were retained as
Retainers and it is a matter of contractual appointment and
need not necessarily a clerk or servant and the definition of
Section 408 of IPC is very clear.
9. Having heard learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners, learned counsel for respondent No.2 and learned
High Court Government Pleader for the respondent No.1 and
the grounds which have been urged, the points that would arise
for consideration of this Court are:
(1) Whether the Trial Court committed an error in
taking cognizance based on the charge sheet and
whether it is a case for invoking Section 482 of
Cr.P.C.?
(2) What order?
- 8 -
CRL.P No. 35 of 2022
Point No.(1):
10. The main contention of learned counsel appearing
for the petitioners is that they are the Retainers and not
servants or clerks as mentioned in Section 408 of IPC. Having
perused Section 408 of IPC also, it is very clear that though the
word commences with whoever being a clerk or servant or
employed as a clerk or servant, and being in any manner
entrusted in such capacity with property, or with any dominion
over property, commits criminal breach of trust in respect of
that property, shall be punished. But, in the case on hand, it is
not in dispute that petitioners are Retainers and are also
working as Doctors and they were part of Liver Transplantation
and data was stored in the computer system maintained in the
hospital and they were having dominion over the property and
if such person indulge in such act, it amounts to criminal
breach and the fact that they were also Retainers and condition
of retainership is not to provide similar services to any other
hospitals is not in dispute. Hence, the first contention that it
will not attract Section 408 of IPC cannot be accepted.
11. The other contention that CD is recovered, but the
same is not supported by Section 65B of Evidence Act cannot
be accepted and at the time of initiation of proceedings, it is
- 9 -
CRL.P No. 35 of 2022
not necessary that it should contain the Certificate under
Section 65B of Evidence Act and the same can be even
produced at the time of trial and only for the admissibility of
the said material, Certificate is required which is held in the
judgment of the Apex Court in M.R. Hiremath vs. State by
Karnataka Lokayukta Police Station’s case, wherein the
Apex Court as categorically held that certificate can be
produced at the time of the evidence and the second argument
also cannot be accepted.
12. The High Court of Judicature at Madras in
O.A.No.3/2023 and A.No.17/2023 in C.S.No.1/2023 dated
07.06.2023, has observed in paragraph No.7 that the case of
the plaintiff is that based upon the vulnerability report, it is
clear that the defendants have accessed the system and had
taken out various details of its customers which is completely
illegal and therefore, they have initiated the present suit. In
paragraph No.9 it is observed that various provisions of the
Information Technology Act, particularly Section 2(a)(i), (j) and
z(e), Section 43 and Section 66 of the Act prohibits any person
to access or secure access to a computer, computer system or
computer network without the permission of the owner or any
other person who is incharge of them. If such access is being
- 10 -
CRL.P No. 35 of 2022
made, then such person would be liable for penalty under
Section 43 and for a punishment of imprisonment with fine as
per Section 66. In paragraph No.22 it is observed that this is
an act prima facie not only attracts penalty under Section 43
but it is also an offence punishable with imprisonment under
Section 66 of the Act. Therefore, I am prima facie of the view
that the act of the respondents in accessing and downloading
the date of the applicant is illegal as being contrary to the Act.
13. The other contention that all patients information
will be in the Hospital Information System (HIS) which is a
password protected system and the fact that these petitioners
have stored the data and they were having access in respect of
the computer is not in dispute and the same is not a ground to
exercise the power under Section 482 of Cr.P.C. But, specific
allegation is that data was stolen and deleted and when specific
accusation is made, it is a matter of trial and the Court cannot
consider the said defence at the time of considering the petition
under Section 482 of Cr.P.C.
14. The other contention that with an oblique motive,
the complaint is filed is also to be considered at the time of trial
whether they were having any oblique motive and malafide
- 11 -
CRL.P No. 35 of 2022
reasons and the fact hard disc was seized is not in dispute and
whether the same was subjected to expert opinion or not and
these grounds can be urged at the time of trial and whether the
data was stolen or deleted from the computer system and
whether these petitioners were having control over the same is
also a defence could be raised at the time of trial. When the
material available before the Court prima facie discloses
committing of an offence and also there was contractual
employment and they were working as Retainers is not in
dispute. Hence, the said also contention cannot be accepted.
15. No doubt, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners relies upon judgment of the Apex Court in
WOLFGANG PROCK-SCHAUER vs. STATE OF
MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHER reported in 2024 SCC
ONLINE BOM 3482 and brought to notice of this Court
discussion made in paragraph Nos.6 and 7 invoking Section 43
of Information Technology Act as well as ingredients of Section
66 of Information Technology Act and without the permission of
the owner or any other person in-charge of the computer or the
computer system network, fraudulently or dishonestly as
required under Section 66 of the Act, of 2000 whether it is with
dishonesty or fraudulent act also to be considered under
- 12 -
CRL.P No. 35 of 2022
Sections 24 and 25 of the IPC and the same is a matter of trial
and this Court cannot consider the same at this stage. Hence, I
do not find any ground to entertain the petition. Accordingly, I
answer Point No.(1) as ‘negative’.
Point No.(2):
16. In view of the discussion made above, I pass the
following:
ORDER
The criminal petition is dismissed.
Sd/-
(H.P.SANDESH)
JUDGE
ST