NARAHARI BEHERA vs STATE OF ODISHA
- Court
- Odisha High Court
CRLMP/1464/2024
ODHC010771862024
2026:OHC:302
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
CRLMP No.1464 of 2024
CNR No. ODHC010771862024
AFR
Narahari Behera …. Petitioner
Mr. J. Katikia, Advocate
-Versus -
State of Odisha and others …. Opposite
Parties
Mr. S. Panda, ASC
CORAM:
JUSTICE R.K. PATTANAIK
DATE OF HEARING:11.08.2026
DATE OF JUDGMENT:13.11.2026
1. Instant petition is filed by the petitioner for issuance
of a writ of mandamus directing opposite party No.1 to
handover the investigation in connection with
Dharmasala P.S. Case No.670 of 2024 corresponding
to C.T. Case No.2074 of 2024 pending in the file of
the learned J.M.F.C., Chandikhole, Jajpur to the CID
CB, Odisha, Cuttack for an impartial and fair
investigation on the grounds stated.
2. It is pleaded on record that the petitioner’s minor
son, who is the deceased, was brutally murdered in a
planned way and the investigation has been botched
up on account of political interference and as a result,
the real assailants have gone scot-free, hence, the
demand for a thorough investigation by the CID CB,
Page 1 of 22
Odisha, Cuttack thereby handing over the case to
opposite party No.5 for the aforesaid purpose.
3. A copy of the FIR leading to the registration of
th
Dharmasala P.S. Case No. 670 dated 4 September,
2024 under Section 137(2) of BNS is at Annexure-1.
4. From the record, it is made to understand that on
th
5 September, 2024 at about 6.00 A.M. in the
morning, the petitioner, namely, the informant
received information about a dead body lying near his
shop and on reaching there found it of the deceased
son with multiple cut injuries on his body. On an
intimation given to opposite party No.4, the case was
converted to one under Sections 103(2) and 238(a)
BNS. It has been further alleged that the deceased was
having love affair with the sister, namely, Halima
Khatun of the accused juvenile, whose house is situated
near the spot. According to the investigation, the
accused juvenile, namely, Md. Sarfaraj Alam, who
happens to be the brother of said Halima Khatun was
interrogated and during such interrogation, he
confessed to have committed the crime. As per the
confessional statement, the said accused found his sister
above named in a compromising position with the
deceased, who was chased by him and was assaulted
by means of a ‘Katuri’. According to the confession of
the said accused, he gave four to five blows on the
person of the deceased while chasing him and finally,
Page 2 of 22
when the latter fell down near the canal, returned from
there and concealed the said weapon and disclosed
about the incident to the accused mother, namely,
Jahanara Bibi, who advised him not to reveal the
incident to anyone and instead washed the clothes of
the accused son and also disturbed the spot of
occurrence with an intention to conceal the evidence
and to screen the offender. Basing upon such
confession, the accused son and mother were arrested.
th
Upon closure of investigation, the chargesheet dated 8
December, 2024 was filed under the alleged offences
keeping the further investigation open in terms of
Section 193(8) BNSS.
5. The petitioner alleged that the investigation has
never gone beyond the confession of the accused CCL.
It is claimed that the entire investigation has been
confined to the confession only. It is further alleged
that the petitioner has reliably learnt that besides the
accused persons chargesheeted, others of their family
including the sister with whom the deceased had love
affair were involved in the crime and it was executed in
a planned manner and that involvement of hired killers
cannot be ruled out. The accused family is alleged to be
strong supporter of the local MLA and according to the
petitioner, the police did not go deep into the matter
to find out the involvement of other culprits and it was
avoided on the premise that there may be outbreak of
communal riot. The petitioner claims that time and
Page 3 of 22
again, he requested opposite party No.4 to have a fair
investigation but all his attempts were in vain and
hence, approached opposite party No.3 with a
representation and also the local MLA but there has
been no any support received and it strengthened the
suspicion regarding the involvement of others in the
crime. The copies of the representation addressed to
opposite party No.3 and the local MLA are at
Annexures-2 and 3 respectively. Further referring to the
P.M. Report at Annexure-4 and the nature of injuries
received by the deceased, it is claimed that accused
CCL, who is 15 year old, alleged to be responsible for
causing death of the deceased, is highly improbable. In
other words, the involvement of the accused juvenile
in the death of the deceased is difficult to believe
having regard to the nature and extent of injuries
revealed in the P.M. Report, as is pleaded. The
petitioner claims that in all probability, the
investigation has been derailed and therefore, to
unearth the involvement of any others and the exact
cause of murder of the deceased, who is the only child
of the petitioner, the same is required to be handed
over to the CID CB, Odisha. It is suspected that the
deceased son was cunningly taken to the house of the
accused juvenile and was confined there and was
assaulted by means of a sword and subsequently, his
body was shifted to the spot, where it was finally
found and hence, it is quite impossible on the part of
Page 4 of 22
the juvenile to execute the same by himself and
therefore, having regard to the circumstances under
which the crime was committed with recovery of
incriminating evidence in the spot house, it is absolutely
essential that the investigation should be conducted by
the CID CB, Odisha in the interest of justice.
6. Heard Mr. Katikia, learned counsel for the petitioner
and Mr. Panda, learned ASC for the State.
7. Mr. Katikia, learned counsel for the petitioner
would submit that the deceased was 17 years old and
in the night of occurrence, he was found missing after
leaving his house at around 6.00 P.M. and did not
return till 9.00 P.M. and despite a frantic search by the
petitioner, could not be traced out till 2.00 AM. and
on the next day morning, the deceased phone was
found to be switched off. Referring to the FIR, it is
submitted that two to three days prior to the death of
the deceased, he was found arguing with someone
over phone and on being asked, it was revealed by him
about having a quarrel with a friend, namely, Srinibas
Khatua @ Nandi and hence the suspicion that he was
kidnapped after such quarrel. According to Mr. Katikia,
th
learned counsel, after the FIR was lodged on 4
September, 2024, no such investigation was carried
out, as to what had happened over which the deceased
th
had quarrel with his friend. On 5 September, 2024 at
6.00 A.M. the dead body of the deceased was floating
Page 5 of 22
in a nearby water body and referring to the same and
circumstances leading to incident, it is reiterated by Mr.
Katikia, learned counsel that investigation never
proceeded beyond the confession of the juvenile
accused. It is claimed that the investigation failed to
adopt the necessary procedures to reach at the truth. It
is further claimed that the juvenile accused alleged to
have given the blows on the face of the deceased while
he was chased. The submission is that such blows were
expected to land on the backside of the deceased but
the injuries as per the P.M. Report were on the head
and its front side and by no stretch of imagination, one
can believe that the blows on the face could be
possible, while he was being chased. It is submitted that
rd
the deceased was killed in the night of 3 September,
2024 and in course of search of the house of the
accused blood drops were found along with other
incriminating substance collected and seized by the
th
police of 5 September, 2024, hence, there was need
for a detailed investigation to find out as to how the
deceased was assaulted and had it really been at the
spot where it is claimed by the juvenile accused or
inside the house of the accused persons. Mr. Katikia,
learned counsel submits that the house of the accused
was searched and there inside, blood drops were found
from the first floor of Room No.1 along with one
‘RAKHI’ from the roof top of the house and two pieces
of yellow colour plastic ropes and even though the said
Page 6 of 22
articles have been seized by the police, no further
investigation was conducted as to whether, the alleged
assault to the deceased was inside the spot house after
confinement. The role of the friend of the deceased,
who had dropped him near the house of the accused
was not enquired into and despite presence of other
suspicious circumstances, the investigation was confined
to the confession at the juvenile accused. Further, the
claim is that the body of the deceased was found in a
‘Nala’ in floating position and the death by drowning
has been ruled out in view of the forensic report, rather
the P.M. Report revealed that there was antemortem
injuries and in view of the injuries, it was a homicidal
death and with such an argument advanced, Mr.
Katikia, learned counsel refers to Chapter-20 of Modi's
Medical Jurisprudence and Toxicology. The submission
is that the deceased was killed and his body was
thrown into the water body and hence, no a case of
drowning, inasmuch as, diatom could not be detected.
Furthermore, the contention is that no investigation has
been carried out with the interrogation of other family
members and neither all of them have been questioned
nor CDR analysis was made to obtain the call details of
the suspected persons, instead, on account of
confessional statement of the juvenile accused, the
investigation was completed alleging him to be the
author of the crime and the mother accused as an
abettor. Under the above circumstances, Mr. Katikia,
Page 7 of 22
learned counsel pleads for a fresh investigation into the
alleged incident with a primary object to ascertain the
involvement of anyone else in the killing of the victim.
8. Mr. Panda, learned ASC, on the other hand, would
submit that the detailed investigation has been
conducted and there is nothing to suspect the
involvement of the juvenile accused, who without
anyone’s influence, described the alleged incident and
on the basis of such disclosure made, he was taken to
custody and chargesheeted along with the accused
mother, who allegedly played a role of abettor. The
further submission is that the said accused, who after
being informed by the juvenile son, committed certain
overt acts to make the evidence disappear and hence,
has been implicated and there has been no any
evidence revealed about the involvement of his other
family members. The incriminating materials collected
at the crime scene have been subjected to forensic
examination and upon receiving the C.E. & Diatom
Test Reports, the chargesheet was filed keeping the
investigation open under Section 193 BNSS. According
to Mr. Panda, learned ASC, it is a case of pure and
simple assault by the juvenile accused finding his sister
in the company of the deceased in a compromising
position and no other evidence was available to
suggest involvement of his other family members and
hence, no need for any investigation to be handed
over to the CID CB, Odisha. It is further submitted that
Page 8 of 22
the confessional statement of the juvenile accused
leading to the discovery of the weapon of offence
connects to the alleged incident and probablizes the
assault with the nature of injuries sustained by the
deceased and as such, in absence of any suspicious
circumstances, it is not a case of investigation by the
CID CD, Odisha, as is pleaded.
9. Perused the CE Report and the findings therein and
the result of examination reveals that the exhibits with
human blood stain could not determine its group due
to degradation of the samples sent. The Serology
Report and the opinion of DNA profiling have been
enclosed therewith for reference. Similarly, the blood
stains could not be detected in some of the exhibits
after forensic test. The diatom could not be noticed as
well. From the said reports, it is suggested that the
death of the deceased is not on account of drowning
but a homicidal one for having suffered the injuries
described in the P.M. Report. The question is whether
such death of the deceased was primarily at the behest
of the juvenile accused or in connivance with other
family members being involved besides his mother?
The petitioner suspects the involvement of the family
of the accused and also outsiders alleging that the crime
has been committed in a planned manner and the body
of the deceased was disposed of much later and that
the circumstances leading to the recovery of the body
of the deceased further suggests that the death was not
Page 9 of 22
after any such assault by the juvenile accused but a
killing having taken place inside their house and
thereafter, secretly disposing it of and thrown into the
‘Nala’. No one found the dead body for nearly two
days, hence, the suspicion is that the deceased was
killed inside the spot house and his body was
surreptitiously removed from there and thrown into
the water body, otherwise, it could have been noticed
in the next day morning itself and therefore, the
demand for investigation by the CID CB, Odisha.
10. Mr. Katikia, learned counsel relied on the following
decisions, such as, Hasanbhai Valibhai Qureshi Vrs.
State of Gujarat and others (2004) 5 SCC 347 and
Dharam Pal Vrs. State of Haryana and others (2016) 4
SCC 160 to contend that in order to instill faith in the
victim’s family, investigation by any other agency is
essential. It is contended that the power of a
Constitutional Court to direct de novo or further
investigation or reinvestigation by some other agency
other than the local police may be directed in a given
to ensure fair and just investigation.
11. In Hasanbhai Valibhai Qureshi (supra), the Apex
Court concluded that further investigation may be
considered and not to be denied merely for the fact
that it may delay the trial and in a case, where such
investigation is necessary and the police can conduct
such investigation even though a Court has taken
Page 10 of 22
cognizance of the offences alleged. It has also been
concluded therein that when fresh facts (absence in
earlier investigation) come to light, the police is
required to inform the Court and seek permission to
make further investigation. In Dharam Pal (supra), the
Apex Court held and observed that commencement of
trial and examination of some witnesses cannot be an
absolute impediment for exercising Constitutional
power as such jurisdiction is meant to ensure fair
investigation and when it is necessary, further
investigation or de novo or reinvestigation may be
directed by some other Investigating Agency. In the
case (supra), the Apex Court referred to one of its
earlier decisions in State of West Bengal Vrs Committee
for Protection of Democratic Rights, West Bengal and
others (2010) 3SCC 571, wherein, the contention was
that a detailed chargesheet had been filed and
thereafter a supplementary chargesheet to bring whom
the guilt of the accused and for the direction given for
further investigation held and concluded in accordance
with Section 173(8) Cr.P.C and thus, no need for any
investigation by such other agency, it was opined that
regard being had to the nature of crime and the
persons involved the investigation could not be said to
be satisfactory thereby repealing such contention
advanced with the chargesheets being filed further
observing that such investigation by the CBI is necessary
Page 11 of 22
in the circumstances in order to instill confidence in the
minds of the victim and also public at large.
12. If certain circumstances unerringly suggest that
investigation is not accomplished satisfactorily, further
investigation or a reinvestigation may be directed by a
Constitutional Court. As earlier discussed, referring to
the case laws cited (supra), investigation may be
handed over to any other agency when certain facts
revealed incomplete investigation or completion of
investigation without taking judicial notice of some
facts which could have thrown light regarding
involvement of some others in the commission of the
crime, or that in a case where, it is highly improbable
to believe and accept the fact that the alleged incident
is an outcome of involvement of the accused only and
none else when it is read in juxtaposition to the
material evidence collected during investigation.
13. The body of the deceased was found floating in a
‘Nala’. The said fact is not in dispute. It is revealed
from the Inquest Report that the deceased was found
inside the water body. The P.M. Report reveals
external injuries ante mortem in nature to have been
received by the deceased possibly by a sharp cutting
weapon. The time since death is between 36 to 48
hours of autopsy. The medical opinion has been
collected by the IO and it is suggested therein that the
death is an account of fatal injuries received by the
Page 12 of 22
victim probably caused by the weapon of offence. The
juvenile accused made the confession during
investigation. Such confession is not admissible in view
of Section 25 of the Indian Evidence Act. But the
statement of the said accused is admissible only to the
extent as to the leading to discovery of the weapon of
offence. The record reveals that the weapon i.e.
‘Katuri’ was recovered at the instance of the juvenile
accused. Such revelation has been made by the police
after interrogation of the said accused. The seizure
th
memo dated 11 September, 2024 suggests that the
weapon of offence was discovered with the help of the
accused juvenile, namely, Raja @ Md. Sarfaraj Alam.
The statements of the witnesses to the recovery have
been recorded during investigation. The juvenile
accused claimed that he found the deceased in a
compromising position with his sister and hence,
chased and while he was running to escape, assaulted
him. The seizure of blood stains from the spot house is
th
also revealed. The seizure memo dated 5 September,
2024 suggests that blood stains were collected from the
floor of Room No.1 of the house of Md. Iqbal Alam,
namely, father of the juvenile. Along with that, the said
seizure memo further reveals a ‘Rakhi’ collected from
the roof of the cattle shed of the house and blood
stained yellow colour plastic rope from the spot itself.
The plea of the petitioner is that the said articles even
Page 13 of 22
though seized after being collected from the spot have
not been subjected to forensic examination.
14. As it is made to understand, the case at hand is
predominantly rested on the confession of the juvenile
accused and disclosure made by him to the accused
mother. As per the statement of the sister of the
juvenile accused examined during investigation, the
deceased was dropped near their house by one of his
friends but not disclosing such other facts about her
meeting him, which is quite obvious. The juvenile
accused is about 15 years old by then and he said to
have chased the deceased and assaulted It is claimed by
the accused’s sister that both of them spent time
together for about 10 minutes and thereafter, the
deceased left and did not reply to her message and
later found him dead near the ‘Nala’. But as it appears,
the investigation is entirely dependent on the disclosure
made by the juvenile accused. Under what
circumstances, the blood drops were found inside the
spot house have not been described at the end of the
investigation. No evidence is on record to suggest that
the investigation to have been conducted with the
thorough scrutiny of the CDR details. Admittedly, the
body was found after two nights and it was with the
injuries on the person of the deceased. How and under
what circumstances, the body of the deceased was
found in a ‘Nala’ in a floating condition is something
which needed a satisfactory explanation. According to
Page 14 of 22
the juvenile accused, he chased and assaulted the
deceased couple of times and he stumbled upon the
ridge and fell near the ‘Nala’. If such is the disclosure
made, which is again not admissible as evidence being
a confession, recovery of the dead body in a floating
position found in a ‘Nala’ owes an explanation. The
suspicion of the petitioner is that the juvenile accused
could not have orchestrated the crime single handedly
in disposing of the body of the deceased into the
‘Nala’. Furthermore, the death is not on account of any
drowning as suggested from the Diatom Test Report.
The investigation ought to have thrown light with the
collection of evidence particularly with regard to the
recovery of the dead body from the Nala as it could
not have been disposed of by the juvenile accused
himself. If the assault was outside the house, was it that
the blood stains were found after the juvenile accused
returned home with the weapon of offence. The
investigation ought to have been in a direction to find
out and ascertain as to whether such evidence like
blood stains inside the house of the accused had really
to do anything with the involvement of others
including other family members of the accused persons.
Under the above circumstances, a question would arise
whether investigation should have been more extensive
instead of concluding it primarily relying on the
disclosure made by the juvenile accused. Having regard
to the submissions of learned counsel for the respective
Page 15 of 22
parties and the principles delineated by the Apex Court
in the decisions (supra), it has to be considered whether
the investigation is adequate and needs no further
inquiry or handing over of the same to the CID CB.
15. The Constitutional courts can order a fresh or
further investigation by an independent agency, if
major contradictions, such as, physical evidence
indicating the crime might have taken place inside a
house while the prosecution claims it to have happened
outside and the same is not clarified, etc. or in a given
circumstance, to prevent miscarriage of justice. Under
Section 173(8) of the CrPC, now Section 193(9) of the
BNSS), a Magistrate can order further investigation by
the same police, if new facts emerge. Such is not the
case herein as nothing is brought to the notice of this
Court about any such development having taken place,
in the meantime. The Courts’ exercise the power for
reinvestigation or further investigation sparingly and
only when the initial investigation appears tainted,
biased or fundamentally flawed or based on evidence,
which is inadmissible.
16. Under Indian Evidence law, a confession made to a
police officer is completely inadmissible. Even if
recorded before a Magistrate, a confession standalone
is considered a weak piece of evidence and requires
independent corroboration from physical or
circumstantial facts. Furthermore, the exact place of
Page 16 of 22
occurrence is a foundational fact in any criminal
prosecution. If physical or forensic evidence could
potentially prove the crime happened inside a house,
while the prosecution's chargesheet claims it outside, it
creates a fatal inconsistency. According to the settled
position of law, further investigation or its transfer to
an independent agency can be directed even after the
chargesheet is filed provided there appears a glaring
contradiction or inconsistency between the physical
evidence and the prosecution's narrative.
17. When the sole basis of a chargesheet is a confession
and the prosecution's claim scene of crime (outside)
directly contradicts physical evidence (inside a house),
the investigation is legally considered perfunctory. In
such a situation, under Section 173(8) CrPC read with
Section 193(9) of the BNSS, a Magistrate can direct
further investigation by the same police agency before
trial commences, but cannot order a re-investigation or
transfer the probe to a different agency like the CBI or
CID. If evidence is confined to suit a confession while
ignoring forensic or physical evidence, a direction may
be had for re-investigation or further investigation since
failure in ensuring a fair investigation is in gross
violation of Article 21 of the Constitution of India. As
earlier discussed, a confession made to a police officer
is completely inadmissible and even a judicial
confession under Section 183 BNSS cannot sustain a
Page 17 of 22
conviction, if it is contradicted by medical or physical
evidence on the place of occurrence.
18. The Apex Court have laid down principles on post-
chargesheet transfers and defective investigation. In
Vinay Tyagi Vrs. Irshad Ali and others (2013) 5 SCC
762, there is a clarification on the distinction between
further investigation and re-investigation. In Dharam
Pal (supra), it is held that the Constitutional courts can
transfer investigation to an independent agency like the
CBI even after the chargesheet has been filed and trial
has commenced, if doing so appears necessary to
ensure a fair trial and uphold public confidence. In
Pooja Pal Vrs. Union of India and others (2016) 3 SCC
135, the Apex Court ruled that filing a chargesheet does
not curtail the extra-ordinary jurisdiction of a High
Court or the Supreme Court to hand over the probe to
another agency, if the initial police investigation was
biased, incomplete, or designed to shield the real truth.
In Hasanbhai Valibhai Qureshi (supra), it has been
emphasized that the prime consideration for ordering
further investigation is to arrive at the truth and to do
substantial justice and procedural technicalities or
delays cannot bar a probe into crucial overlooked
evidence. In Babubhai Vrs. State of Gujarat and others
(2010) 12 SCC 254, it is held that a tainted and biased
investigation vitiates the entire trial process, and where
the investigating agency manipulates the facts or scene
of occurrence, the Court must step in to order a fair
Page 18 of 22
probe. In Bharati Tamang Vrs. Union of India and
others (2013) 15 SCC 578, it has been ruled that if
deficiency in investigation or prosecution is visible, or if
the police try to shield the real culprits by fabricating
the scene or story, the Constitutional courts must
intervene and order further investigation or transfer it
to an independent agency, even after the chargesheet is
filed to ensure a fair trial. In fact, in Pooja Pal (supra),
the Apex Court held that a fair investigation is a
fundamental right under Article 21 of the Constitution.
Even after a chargesheet is submitted, if the
investigation suffers from glaring loopholes or ignores
vital physical evidence, the investigation may be
entrusted to an independent agency to instill public
confidence.
19. In fact, in Puja Pal case, the Apex Court held and
observed in the following words, such as, the
precedential ordainment against absolute prohibition
for assignment of investigation to any impartial agency
like the CBI, submission of the chargesheet by the
normal investigating agency in law notwithstanding,
albeit in an exceptional fact situation warranting such
initiative, in order to secure a fair, honest and complete
investigation and to consolidate the confidence of the
victims and the public in general in the justice
administering mechanism is unquestionably absolute
and hallowed by time. Such a measure however can by
no means be a matter of course or routine but has to
Page 19 of 22
be essentially adopted in order to live up to and
effectuate the salutary objective of guaranteeing an
independent and upright mechanism of justice
dispensation without fear or favour by treating all
alike; in the decisions cited on behalf of the CBI as well,
this Court in K. Saravanan Karuppasamy and another
Vrs. State of Tamil Nadu and others 2014 10 SCC 406
and Sudipta Lenka Vrs. State of Odisha and others 2014
11 SCC 527 supra (italicized for reference) recounted
the above propositions underpinning the primacy of
credibility and confidence in investigations and a need
for complete justice and enforcement of fundamental
rights judged on the touchstone of high public interest
and the paramountcy of the rule of law; the judicially
propounded propositions on the aspects of essentiality
and justifiability for assignment of further investigation
or reinvestigation to an independent investigating
agency like the CBI, whether or not the probe into a
criminal offence by the local/state police is pending or
completed, irrespective of the pendency of the
resultant trial have concretized over the years,
applicability whereof however is contingent on the
factual setting involved and the desideratum for
vigilant, sensitized and evenhanded justice to the
parties; the exhaustive references of the citations
seemingly repetitive though, assuredly attest the
conceptual consisting in the expositions and
enunciations on the issue highlighting the cause of
Page 20 of 22
justice as the ultimate determinant for the course to be
adopted.
20. In the present case, this Court finds that the entire
case revolves around the confessional disclosure of the
juvenile, who claimed to have committed the crime.
Law does not allow a confession as admissible but the
discovery made as a result is considered a piece of
evidence subject to its scrutiny during trial. The
circumstances, such as, incriminating evidence found
inside the house of the accused persons but absence of
any clear and definite conclusion about its presence and
probative value; recovery of the body of the deceased
nearby floating in a water body having not been
noticed immediately after his disappearance; contrast
claim of the juvenile not able to connect as to how the
deceased was found in a floating condition, which is
possible in ordinary circumstances only if the body is
disposed of or shifted from the crime scene; absence of
any evidence to clarify as to how the incriminating
articles were found inside the house when the crime
said to be committed outside etc. Whether, it was
possible for a juvenile to execute the assault or anyone
else’s involvement in the death of the deceased,
considering the circumstances under which the dead
body was found and recovered, needs a clarification,
which is conspicuously absent. Excessive dependence
on a confession would be fatal to a prosecution during
trial, hence, always safe to have additional evidence in
Page 21 of 22
place. Whether, the materials on record really clears
the cloud of suspicion only with the involvement of the
juvenile accused? All the doubts illustrated hereinabove
deservedly needs a reply, hence, considering the
materials on record, this Court is inclined and in favour
of a thorough probe and further investigation by the
CID CB to elicit the truth on the death of the deceased
and at the same time, to ensure ruling out involvement
of anyone else in the commission of the crime.
21. Accordingly, it is ordered.
22. In the result, the CRLMP stands disposed of with a
direction for further investigation in connection with
Dharmasala P.S. Case No.670 of 2024 corresponding
to C.T. Case No.2074 of 2024 pending in the file of
the learned J.M.F.C., Chandikhole, Jajpur by the CID
CB, Odisha. It is further directed that the chargesheet
and connected materials collected during investigation
by the local police shall forthwith be handed over to
opposite party No.5 for further investigation, which
shall be concluded within a reasonable time may be
upon filing of additional/supplementary chargesheet.
(R.K. Pattanaik)
Judge
Balaram
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BALARAM BEHERA
Designation: Personal Assistant
Reason: Authentication
Location: OHC, CUTTACK
Date: 17-Nov-2026 18:00:35
Page 22 of 22